Zal Going as an Envoy before Manuchehr
Sahm turns a lifetime of service into a plea for restraint. The dragon episode establishes both his achievement and the bodily cost from which age has not released him.
The chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | Eighty-three couplets make Sahm’s service, age and paternal promise into an extended petition, retaining the full dragon story. |
| Moscow | Pp 201–207 retain the letter; long stretches of the dragon account at pp 203–204 are bracketed. |
| Mohl | Pp 155–159 supply the full service narrative and the fuller close, including the place notice retained in English. |
| Ganjoor | Sh15.52–131 has 80 couplets, with a night-to-morning transition condensed at the English departure. |
| Khaleghi | The letter and service story are consulted within pp 231–237, where apparatus and continuous main text remain distinct. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor is the reference except where a row names a printed source. Select a number to open the relevant note. G identifiers distinguish digital sections across chapter boundaries.
Narrative and poetic form
The English’s length is narratively justified: martial service establishes the speaker’s claim, damage establishes its cost, and the son establishes what is now at stake. The geographical seam and explicit witnessing remain local qualifications, not reasons to dismiss the whole petition.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–10Royal praise defines the standard being invoked
The letter praises the Creator, royal valor and generosity, then the ruler who brings wolf and sheep to one watering place.
The pastoral image sets an ethical standard for the Shah who has just ordered a lineage destroyed. The English preserves the traditional pairing of battle-poison and feast-moon without reducing either to modern literal description.
11–16Aging service gives the plea standing
Sahm says he has reached sixty, recalls his riding and campaigns and the proud heads he has lowered.
The English’s “some sixty” suits the letter’s life-stage rhetoric. It should not be forced into a precise chronology by reconciling every age and reign-length elsewhere in the epic. White hair now signifies ordinary age, in pointed contrast with the son’s birth feature.
17–29The Kashaf dragon empties a whole habitat
The beast drives off birds, beasts and humans, burns a vulture and draws water-creature and eagle into danger. Sahm arms and advances after receiving farewells.
The English preserves the scale through absence as well as size: the inhabited world becomes empty. Nahang is rendered here as water-beast, a useful way to retain the dangerous aquatic creature without forcing a single modern species onto the whole poem.
30–40A monster described before it is wounded
Hair, black-tree tongue, blood-pool eyes, smoke, poison and roar precede three arrows into the mouth. Ganjoor 86 explicitly likens the poisoned earth to the sea of Chin.
English “Chin’s dark flow” condenses that particular geographical simile; it is not a reference to pitch manufacture invented by the commentary. The three distinct arrows prepare the decisive blow rather than contradicting the epithet One Blow.
41–49One Blow names the finishing stroke
Sahm closes with the ox-head mace, shatters the skull, fills the river with blood and gall and gains the name One Blow.
The English correctly retains the prior arrows. The epithet records the decisive mace-stroke in the story’s explanation, not a mathematical assertion that he used only one weapon or made one movement.
50–58Victory has lasting physical costs
Armor falls away, poison injures the survivor and the land remains sterile except for scorched thorns. The service history then resumes.
The English gives the dragon-slayer a damaged body rather than effortless invulnerability. This aftermath matters to the later request: the king’s servant is old and used up, not merely boasting to secure an indulgence.
59–68Succession and a promise enter the letterKnown promise made an explicit witnessed promise
Age bends the champion; he passes the turn to Zal and recalls the wish and paternal pledge. Ganjoor says the Shah has heard the promise. English 67’s “before your sight” makes witnessing more explicit than that wording.
The English’s ceremonial idiom intensifies public accountability, but a known promise and an eyewitness promise are not identical evidence. The central political point survives: Sahm is explaining an obligation already familiar to the sovereign.
69–80Pity becomes a sovereign argument
The son’s torn body imagery and choice of death over Kabul’s ruin are followed by his fosterage, love, innocence and the appeal to kingly judgment. Mohl pp 158–159 adds the sole-son and closing blessing material.
The English lets Sahm use the very fosterage he had mocked as a reason for compassion. The closing deference is diplomatic: he asks the Shah to act according to his own best office rather than claiming to instruct him from above.
81–83A departure with a fuller-tradition seamCompressed interval; transmitted place seam
Ganjoor gives a sleepless night and the morning departure. English compresses that interval. Its final Kabul/garden notice has fuller support in Mohl p 158, although Zal has just been speaking at his father’s camp.
The commentary leaves the narrative seam visible. A printed place-name supports the English reading without proving that the preceding itinerary is geographically seamless. No otherwise unreported journey is invented to remove the tension.
New Naqqali