Giv Finds Kay Khosrow
77 published couplets, preserved verbatim from the established published-page capture; checked against that capture on 10 November 2026.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 77 published couplets, preserved verbatim from the established published-page capture; checked against that capture on 10 November 2026. |
| Moscow III | Printed pp. 204–208, vv. 3112–3173; individual apparatus verses and checked running-text gaps distinguished. |
| Mohl II | Printed pp. 243–246, vv. 621–696; Persian running text in the linked facsimile. |
| Ganjoor | Siavash §18.42–103; Persian displayed from the poem body, not the automated paraphrase. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh II | Printed pp. 421–425, Giv’s Journey vv. 39–101 and apparatus. PDF pages are printed pages +16. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5Seven years in the wilderness
Moscow III p. 204 vv. 3112–3115; Mohl II p. 243 vv. 621–624; Ganjoor §18.42–45; Khaleghi II pp. 421–422 Journey vv. 39–42.
The opening retains the comparison with a person deprived of sense, so the search begins with exhaustion rather than unbroken heroic confidence. All four presentations specify seven years and the abrasion caused by weapons and straps. The English makes this bodily cost immediately legible through the girdle that galls him. Its third couplet preserves the striking continuity between food and clothing: the hunted animal supplies both. The Persian also mentions the horse eating grass, a detail not separately retained. Two English couplets unfold the final Persian verse about mountains, wilderness, hardship and separation from company. The claim that nothing remains to gain intensifies despair beyond that verse’s statement of isolation.
Return to passage6–13A return preserved outside Moscow’s running text
Moscow III p. 205 continuation of p. 204 n. 20 to v. 3115, eight added verses; Mohl II pp. 243–244 vv. 625–632; Ganjoor gap between §18.45–46; Khaleghi II p. 422 n. 1 to Journey v. 42, eight added verses.
The English interrupts Giv’s wandering to explain how Khosrow comes back to his mother. This is not an unsupported narrative insertion: Mohl prints the eight Persian verses continuously, while both critical editions preserve them below the text. Ganjoor proceeds directly to the grove. The return consequently belongs to a fuller attested sequence, although its editorial status differs among the witnesses. The English makes Afrasiab’s control especially explicit by turning the instruction to close the roads into a command that nobody pass. Its peaceful years go further than the Persian’s less determinate passage of time. The evidence establishes the return and surveillance, but does not establish an exact duration of peaceful residence.
Return to passage14–19A welcoming landscape and a doubtful dream
Moscow III p. 205 vv. 3116–3121; Mohl II p. 244 vv. 633–638; Ganjoor §18.46–51; Khaleghi II p. 422 Journey vv. 43–48.
The agreement across the four presentations makes the contrast between the flourishing landscape and the exhausted visitor particularly secure. The English carries that opposition through a bright world and a forlorn heart, then renders the green ground and plentiful water as an invitation to rest. Its description of Giv as pale adds a visible symptom to the Persian’s emotional description. The subsequent question about a Div preserves the possibility of a deceptive dream without converting that fear into the narrator’s explanation. Naming Gudarz clarifies the Persian reference to the champion who dreamed. The extra phrase about dressing the dream in apparent rightness interprets the deception rather than translating a separate image.
Return to passage20–24The walnut on the dome
Moscow III p. 205 vv. 3122–3126; Mohl II p. 244 vv. 639–643; Ganjoor §18.52–56; Khaleghi II pp. 422–423 Journey vv. 49–53.
The English preserves the unusually concrete image of a walnut on a dome, but changes its grammar. In the Persian, fortune casts a walnut onto the dome; the translation makes fortune itself resemble the walnut. Its additional explanation about finding no settled home makes the image accessible while narrowing its possible implications to instability. The bowed back remains a direct bodily measure of wasted effort. The suspicion that Khosrow never existed, followed by the wish for release through poison, is also shared by all four presentations. These lines belong to Giv’s distressed speech. They prepare the reversal at the spring and should not be softened into merely ordinary impatience with the journey.
Return to passage25–28Wine, flowers and visible farr
Moscow III p. 206 vv. 3127–3130; Mohl II p. 244 vv. 644–647; Ganjoor §18.57–60; Khaleghi II p. 423 Journey vv. 54–57.
The change from wandering to recognition is staged through visible objects before anyone speaks. The Persian combines a shining spring, a cypresslike youth, a cup full of wine and a fragrant, colorful arrangement on his head. The English redistributes these details across its couplets and calls the flowers a wreath. That is a plausible visualization, although the checked words specify a bunch or cluster rather than its precise construction. All four presentations then identify divine farr and the banner of wisdom. Royal right gives the first expression a more constitutional emphasis than the Persian’s divine qualification. The banner remains an image of perceptible intelligence, not a separate physical standard beside the youth.
Return to passage29–31Siavash or Manuchehr?
Moscow III p. 206 vv. 3131–3133 and nn. 9–10; Mohl II p. 244 vv. 648–650; Ganjoor §18.61–63; Khaleghi II p. 423 Journey vv. 58–60 and nn. 9–12.
Here the witnesses do not give a single uniform comparison. Moscow and Ganjoor name Manuchehr on an ivory throne; Mohl names Siavash. Khaleghi’s running text describes an enthroned figure with a collar without naming either king, and its apparatus records the competing names. The English therefore follows an attested reading when it makes the son resemble his father restored to life. That choice brings bereavement and familial recognition to the foreground, whereas Manuchehr evokes a more distant royal model. The translation also generalizes the crown’s material rather than retaining Moscow’s turquoise or the alternative jewel wording. The following face and hair imagery supports Giv’s conviction before genealogical proof arrives.
Return to passage32–37Recognition before conversation
Moscow III p. 206 vv. 3134–3138; Mohl II p. 245 vv. 651–655; Ganjoor §18.64–68; Khaleghi II p. 423 Journey vv. 61–65.
The English expands five Persian verses into six couplets, dividing the loosening knot and the discovered treasure into separate moments. That expansion makes the emotional release slower and more explicit. The mention of seven years recalls the earlier duration, but is not repeated at this exact Persian locus. Similarly, sacrifice and an earned prize interpret the relation between toil and discovery. All four presentations then move inside Khosrow’s thoughts: he recognizes Giv and anticipates being taken to Iran as king. The English preserves that reciprocal recognition while adding the language of a foretold rescuer. The prophecy is supplied later in the dialogue, so the added anticipation is narratively intelligible rather than an independent new event.
Return to passage38–46Who speaks first, and how much is said?
Moscow III p. 206 vv. 3138–3142, n. 19, and p. 207 v. 3143; Mohl II p. 245 vv. 656–665; Ganjoor §18.68–73; Khaleghi II pp. 423–424 Journey vv. 65–70 and p. 423 n. 32.
Mohl gives the fuller greeting, questions about Iran’s leaders and Giv’s astonished praise that the English substantially follows. Khaleghi records the expanded exchange in its apparatus. Moscow and Ganjoor instead give a shorter conversation, including Khosrow’s explicit identification of Giv after Giv identifies the prince. Moscow’s alternate greeting in the apparatus is not evidence for every verse of the longer exchange. The register therefore labels the checked gap separately. The English also adds yearning hearts to Giv’s respectful address and omits a separate rendering of the shorter sequence’s identification reply. Its continuous conversation is coherent, but that coherence should not disguise the different ordering and extent of the witnesses.
Return to passage47–53The mother transmits the father’s prediction
Moscow III p. 207 vv. 3144–3150; Mohl II p. 245 vv. 666–672; Ganjoor §18.74–80; Khaleghi II p. 424 Journey vv. 71–77.
The four presentations agree that Khosrow’s knowledge reaches him through his mother, who remembers his father’s final counsel. The English makes this chain of transmission unusually clear and preserves the key that opens bonds. Its language of cleansing the world and righting every wrong, however, broadens the political restoration and personal vengeance in the Persian. The last Persian verse explicitly links the future ruler’s action to avenging the speaker and his family. By making vengeance both just and strong, the English supplies an ethical evaluation in place of that more immediate possessive emphasis. The result presents the prince as a universal restorer while slightly reducing the father’s personal claim upon his future action.
Return to passage54–58From visible majesty to inherited proof
Moscow III p. 207 vv. 3151–3155; Mohl II pp. 245–246 vv. 673–677; Ganjoor §18.81–85; Khaleghi II p. 424 Journey vv. 78–82.
Giv does not accept impressive appearance alone as conclusive proof. Across all four presentations he asks to see the inherited dark mark associated with Siavash and the line of Kay Qobad. The English preserves this movement from perceived farr to bodily evidence. Its rose design gives a more patterned visual form to the Persian comparison with a dark speck in a flower garden. That phrasing may suggest a particular shape for the birthmark which the checked comparison does not require. Calling it a birthmark usefully explains its inherited function, while the explicit request to bare the arm retains the practical action by which recognition becomes confirmation rather than intuition.
Return to passage59–62The embrace and the return to public affairs
Moscow III p. 207 vv. 3156–3158; Mohl II p. 246 vv. 678–680; Ganjoor §18.86–88; Khaleghi II p. 424 Journey vv. 83–85.
The tears and reverence follow the sight of the mark in all four presentations. The English turns those tears into a declaration of certainty, making their narrative function explicit. The next Persian verse places the king of the land after the embracing verb, naturally allowing the king to be read as the person who embraces Giv; the English expressly makes Giv clasp the Shah. The commentary should retain that grammatical issue rather than claim an unambiguous agreement in agency. The added flame of joy also anticipates a later fire image. Finally, one Persian verse asking about Iran, its throne and leading champions becomes two English couplets, expanding the transition from private recognition to public responsibility.
Return to passage63–69A joy greater than sovereignty
Moscow III pp. 207–208 vv. 3159–3164 and p. 208 n. 3 to v. 3163; Mohl II p. 246 vv. 681–687; Ganjoor §18.89–94; Khaleghi II pp. 424–425 Journey vv. 86–92.
Giv measures his joy against paradise, sovereignty over the seven regions and the royal crown. The English retains the extravagant scale while spreading the comparative conclusion over two couplets. Its wording about a foreign land makes the contrast with Iran more explicit than the place name alone. The imagined meeting with Siavash in English couplet sixty-eight is printed in Mohl and Khaleghi and preserved in Moscow’s apparatus; Ganjoor passes directly from uncertainty about Giv’s survival to thanksgiving. It is therefore an attested additional verse, not a newly invented recollection. Keeping that recollection strengthens the emotional link between finding the son and the irrecoverable loss of the father.
Return to passage70–74Personal endurance and Iran’s decline
Moscow III p. 208 vv. 3165–3170; Mohl II p. 246 vv. 688–693; Ganjoor §18.95–100; Khaleghi II p. 425 Journey vv. 93–98.
The departure from the grove opens a retrospective account rather than ending the discovery scene abruptly. All four presentations connect the seven years of hardship, Gudarz’s dream, Giv’s food and clothing, Kavus’s diminished farr and Iran’s devastation. The English compresses the general introduction to the account and its list of experiences into a single couplet. It preserves color and fragrance as signs of the country’s lost vitality, but adds wealth and earlier prosperity. Its account of Kavus also leaves the cause of grief less specific: the Persian explicitly names the pain of losing his son. The broader wording makes decline readily comprehensible while loosening the direct connection to Siavash’s death.
Return to passage75–77Compassion, fatherhood and secrecy
Moscow III p. 208 vv. 3171–3173; Mohl II p. 246 vv. 694–696; Ganjoor §18.101–103; Khaleghi II p. 425 Journey vv. 99–101.
The closing image joins inward burning to a face kindled like fire. The English keeps both the burning heart and reddened cheeks, but supplies a fierce and bold spirit where the Persian foregrounds the pain that produces the response. That addition can make compassion sound closer to martial resolve. The promise of rest then leads into the request that Giv act as a father, followed by secrecy and attention to what time will bring. The English moves the fatherhood request into its preceding couplet and narrows the silence to what happened today. All four presentations support the broader sequence, but their injunction to tell nobody is less explicitly limited to that day’s meeting.
Return to passageSource-only verse
Ganjoor §18.71 · Moscow III p. 206 v. 3141; Khaleghi II p. 424 Journey v. 68. Khosrow explicitly identifies Giv as Gudarz’s son. No separate English couplet or Mohl verse at this placement; the longer Mohl greeting already names Giv.
Source record and limits
Moscow and Mohl scans were checked first, followed by Ganjoor and Khaleghi. All 76 Mohl verses and all 62 Ganjoor verses in the declared ranges are accounted for. The five English greeting couplets 38–42 have checked Moscow running-text gaps, not verified full Moscow apparatus equivalents. The Machin return and the Siavash recollection have individual Moscow apparatus support. No appendix evidence is cited. Exact support for the English’s peaceful years, the precise construction of the floral wreath, and the expanded universal justice wording remains unverified; these are discussed as interpretation or elaboration, not quoted Persian readings. The embrace’s grammatical agency is flagged as an interpretive issue. A collation pass denotes complete accounting, not identical wording.
B10.17 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow III | Mohl II |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | p. 204 · v. 3112 (running text) | p. 243 · v. 621 (running text) |
| 2 | p. 204 · v. 3113 (running text) | p. 243 · v. 622 (running text) |
| 3 | p. 204 · v. 3114 (running text) | p. 243 · v. 623 (running text) |
| 4 | p. 204 · v. 3115 (running text) | p. 243 · v. 624 (running text) |
| 5 | p. 204 · v. 3115 (running text) | p. 243 · v. 624 (running text) |
| 6 | p. 205 · Continuation of p. 204 n. 20 to v. 3115; added verse(s) 1 (apparatus) | p. 243 · v. 625 (running text) |
| 7 | p. 205 · Continuation of p. 204 n. 20 to v. 3115; added verse(s) 2 (apparatus) | p. 244 · v. 626 (running text) |
| 8 | p. 205 · Continuation of p. 204 n. 20 to v. 3115; added verse(s) 3,4 (apparatus) | p. 244 · v. 627 (running text) · p. 244 · v. 628 (running text) |
| 9 | p. 205 · Continuation of p. 204 n. 20 to v. 3115; added verse(s) 4 (apparatus) | p. 244 · v. 628 (running text) |
| 10 | p. 205 · Continuation of p. 204 n. 20 to v. 3115; added verse(s) 5 (apparatus) | p. 244 · v. 629 (running text) |
| 11 | p. 205 · Continuation of p. 204 n. 20 to v. 3115; added verse(s) 6 (apparatus) | p. 244 · v. 630 (running text) |
| 12 | p. 205 · Continuation of p. 204 n. 20 to v. 3115; added verse(s) 7 (apparatus) | p. 244 · v. 631 (running text) |
| 13 | p. 205 · Continuation of p. 204 n. 20 to v. 3115; added verse(s) 8 (apparatus) | p. 244 · v. 632 (running text) |
| 14 | p. 205 · v. 3116 (running text) | p. 244 · v. 633 (running text) |
| 15 | p. 205 · v. 3117 (running text) | p. 244 · v. 634 (running text) |
| 16 | p. 205 · v. 3118 (running text) | p. 244 · v. 635 (running text) |
| 17 | p. 205 · v. 3119 (running text) | p. 244 · v. 636 (running text) |
| 18 | p. 205 · v. 3120 (running text) | p. 244 · v. 637 (running text) |
| 19 | p. 205 · v. 3121 (running text) | p. 244 · v. 638 (running text) |
| 20 | p. 205 · v. 3122 (running text) | p. 244 · v. 639 (running text) |
| 21 | p. 205 · v. 3123 (running text) | p. 244 · v. 640 (running text) |
| 22 | p. 205 · v. 3124 (running text) | p. 244 · v. 641 (running text) |
| 23 | p. 205 · v. 3125 (running text) | p. 244 · v. 642 (running text) |
| 24 | p. 205 · v. 3126 (running text) | p. 244 · v. 643 (running text) |
| 25 | p. 206 · v. 3127 (running text) | p. 244 · v. 644 (running text) |
| 26 | p. 206 · v. 3128 (running text) | p. 244 · v. 645 (running text) |
| 27 | p. 206 · v. 3129 (running text) | p. 244 · v. 646 (running text) |
| 28 | p. 206 · v. 3130 (running text) | p. 244 · v. 647 (running text) |
| 29 | p. 206 · v. 3131 (running text) | p. 244 · v. 648 (running text) |
| 30 | p. 206 · v. 3132 (running text) | p. 244 · v. 649 (running text) |
| 31 | p. 206 · v. 3133 (running text) | p. 244 · v. 650 (running text) |
| 32 | p. 206 · v. 3134 (running text) | p. 245 · v. 651 (running text) |
| 33 | p. 206 · v. 3135 (running text) | p. 245 · v. 652 (running text) |
| 34 | p. 206 · v. 3135 (running text) | p. 245 · v. 652 (running text) |
| 35 | p. 206 · v. 3136 (running text) | p. 245 · v. 653 (running text) |
| 36 | p. 206 · v. 3137 (running text) | p. 245 · v. 654 (running text) |
| 37 | p. 206 · v. 3138 (running text) | p. 245 · v. 655 (running text) |
| 38 | p. 206 · Checked gap between vv. 3138–3139 for the expanded greeting; n. 19 gives only an alternate greeting verse | p. 245 · v. 656 (running text) |
| 39 | p. 206 · Checked gap between vv. 3138–3139 for the expanded greeting; n. 19 gives only an alternate greeting verse | p. 245 · v. 657 (running text) · p. 245 · v. 658 (running text) |
| 40 | p. 206 · Checked gap between vv. 3138–3139 for the expanded greeting; n. 19 gives only an alternate greeting verse | p. 245 · v. 658 (running text) · p. 245 · v. 659 (running text) |
| 41 | p. 206 · Checked gap between vv. 3138–3139 for the expanded greeting; n. 19 gives only an alternate greeting verse | p. 245 · v. 660 (running text) |
| 42 | p. 206 · Checked gap between vv. 3138–3139 for the expanded greeting; n. 19 gives only an alternate greeting verse | p. 245 · v. 661 (running text) |
| 43 | p. 206 · v. 3139 (running text) | p. 245 · v. 662 (running text) |
| 44 | p. 206 · v. 3140 (running text) | p. 245 · v. 663 (running text) |
| 45 | p. 206 · v. 3142 (running text) | p. 245 · v. 664 (running text) |
| 46 | p. 207 · v. 3143 (running text) | p. 245 · v. 665 (running text) |
| 47 | p. 207 · v. 3144 (running text) | p. 245 · v. 666 (running text) |
| 48 | p. 207 · v. 3145 (running text) | p. 245 · v. 667 (running text) |
| 49 | p. 207 · v. 3146 (running text) | p. 245 · v. 668 (running text) |
| 50 | p. 207 · v. 3147 (running text) | p. 245 · v. 669 (running text) |
| 51 | p. 207 · v. 3148 (running text) | p. 245 · v. 670 (running text) |
| 52 | p. 207 · v. 3149 (running text) | p. 245 · v. 671 (running text) |
| 53 | p. 207 · v. 3150 (running text) | p. 245 · v. 672 (running text) |
| 54 | p. 207 · v. 3151 (running text) | p. 245 · v. 673 (running text) |
| 55 | p. 207 · v. 3152 (running text) | p. 245 · v. 674 (running text) |
| 56 | p. 207 · v. 3153 (running text) | p. 245 · v. 675 (running text) |
| 57 | p. 207 · v. 3154 (running text) | p. 246 · v. 676 (running text) |
| 58 | p. 207 · v. 3155 (running text) | p. 246 · v. 677 (running text) |
| 59 | p. 207 · v. 3156 (running text) | p. 246 · v. 678 (running text) |
| 60 | p. 207 · v. 3157 (running text) | p. 246 · v. 679 (running text) |
| 61 | p. 207 · v. 3158 (running text) | p. 246 · v. 680 (running text) |
| 62 | p. 207 · v. 3158 (running text) | p. 246 · v. 680 (running text) |
| 63 | p. 207 · v. 3159 (running text) · p. 207 · v. 3160 (running text) | p. 246 · v. 681 (running text) · p. 246 · v. 682 (running text) |
| 64 | p. 207 · v. 3161 (running text) | p. 246 · v. 683 (running text) |
| 65 | p. 207 · v. 3162 (running text) | p. 246 · v. 684 (running text) |
| 66 | p. 207 · v. 3162 (running text) | p. 246 · v. 684 (running text) |
| 67 | p. 208 · v. 3163 (running text) | p. 246 · v. 685 (running text) |
| 68 | p. 208 · n. 3 to v. 3163; Siavash recollection (apparatus) | p. 246 · v. 686 (running text) |
| 69 | p. 208 · v. 3164 (running text) | p. 246 · v. 687 (running text) |
| 70 | p. 208 · v. 3165 (running text) | p. 246 · v. 688 (running text) |
| 71 | p. 208 · v. 3166 (running text) | p. 246 · v. 689 (running text) |
| 72 | p. 208 · v. 3167 (running text) · p. 208 · v. 3168 (running text) | p. 246 · v. 690 (running text) · p. 246 · v. 691 (running text) |
| 73 | p. 208 · v. 3169 (running text) | p. 246 · v. 692 (running text) |
| 74 | p. 208 · v. 3170 (running text) | p. 246 · v. 693 (running text) |
| 75 | p. 208 · v. 3171 (running text) | p. 246 · v. 694 (running text) |
| 76 | p. 208 · v. 3172 (running text) · p. 208 · v. 3173 (running text) | p. 246 · v. 695 (running text) · p. 246 · v. 696 (running text) |
| 77 | p. 208 · v. 3173 (running text) | p. 246 · v. 696 (running text) |
New Naqqali