Giv Captures Piran
37 published couplets preserved verbatim from the retained page capture, compared with the live chapter on 10 November 2026.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 37 published couplets preserved verbatim from the retained page capture, compared with the live chapter on 10 November 2026. |
| Moscow III | Printed pp. 219–221, vv. 3346–3376 and individually identified apparatus verses. |
| Mohl II | Printed pp. 256–258, vv. 920–956, Persian running text. |
| Ganjoor | Siavash §19.47–77, poem body. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh II | Printed pp. 438–440, Journey278–307 and apparatus; the retreat is apparatus-only in this edition. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5Anger crosses the river; patience waits
Moscow III pp. 219–220 vv. 3346–3350. Mohl II p. 256 vv. 920–924. Ganjoor §19.47–51. Khaleghi II p. 438 Journey278–282.
Piran’s tears accompany anger rather than replace it with sorrow, and the English keeps that emotional combination visible. The ship comparison then presents the river crossing as forceful and continuous, while Giv’s refusal to hurry establishes deliberate tactical control. Praising the One makes the recipient of Piran’s praise explicitly divine; the Persian describes the praised giver through beneficence, so the English clarifies the religious reading rather than naming a new participant. The final couplet supplies inward battle excitement that the corresponding Persian does not state. Its seemed to flee, however, makes the stratagem immediately legible: the surrounding action confirms that Giv is drawing his opponent away from support. The narrative contrast is therefore between impulsive pursuit and controlled delay, not between courage and actual abandonment of the fight.
Return to passage6–10A relocated approach and a changed weapon movement
Moscow III p. 220 vv. 3351–3353, nn. 4–5. Mohl II p. 256 vv. 925–929. Ganjoor §19.52–54. Khaleghi II pp. 438–439 Journey283–285, p. 438 n. 16 and p. 439 n. 3.
The English brings Piran close before describing separation from the river and army, following Mohl’s order. Moscow and Ganjoor place the darkening-world verse after the lasso preparation; Khaleghi places it before that preparation but after the separation. These differences affect the timing of the trap. Raised his battle-gorz is more substantial: the Persian puts the mace into or at the saddle, making way for the subsequent maneuver, rather than explicitly raising it. The additional charge and Piran’s flight have individual apparatus support in Moscow and Khaleghi and run continuously in Mohl. The English’s gorz in hand elaborates the charge rather than resolving the earlier weapon movement. Its secret lasso preparation follows a variant attested in the apparatus; the exact combat mechanics should not be harmonized silently.
Return to passage11–16The captive’s direction and the borrowed standard
Moscow III p. 220 vv. 3354–3359, n. 7 to 3356. Mohl II p. 257 vv. 930–935. Ganjoor §19.55–60. Khaleghi II p. 439 Journey286–291.
The lasso catches Piran’s head and removes him from the saddle, preserving the capture’s decisive physical sequence. What follows differs geographically among the texts: Moscow and Ganjoor take him toward the riverbank, whereas Mohl, Khaleghi and Moscow’s apparatus support taking him away from it. The English therefore has a verified basis for its direction, despite disagreement with the two shorter running texts. It then keeps the binding, transfer of arms, remounting and seizure of Piran’s standard in order. His arms can be momentarily ambiguous in English, but the Persian possessive connects the equipment with the captured opponent. Fooled by their own eyes interprets the troops’ response to their commander’s banner. Their approach is explicit; their mistaken identification is an inference from Giv’s possession of the standard.
Return to passage17–22Battle music and the changing ship simile
Moscow III pp. 220–221 vv. 3360–3365, p. 220 nn. 13, 15 and 17. Mohl II p. 257 vv. 936–941. Ganjoor §19.61–66. Khaleghi II p. 439 Journey292–297 and nn. 15, 19, 26–27.
The instruments announce collective battle before Giv enters the river and scatters the army. Bronze-toned ney follows Moscow and Ganjoor’s metal descriptor, while Mohl and Khaleghi print a different adjective in that position; the apparatus records the metal reading. The second ship comparison has a separate textual choice: Moscow and Ganjoor propel it by wind, whereas Mohl’s wave-driven image supports the English waves. Khaleghi prints another variant and records alternatives. The English maintains the contrast between light reins and firm stirrups but turns the chiefs’ bewilderment into an accomplished rout. It also replaces the explicit spear or variant weapon catalogue with generalized driving force. The heaps of fallen bodies remain mountainous, while attributing the exhaustion specifically to Giv’s gorz is a local elaboration of Mohl’s wording.
Return to passage23–29Routing the army and presenting the prisoner
Moscow III p. 221 vv. 3366–3370 and n. 10. Mohl II p. 257 vv. 942–948. Ganjoor §19.67–71. Khaleghi II pp. 439–440 Journey298–301, p. 439 n. 31 and p. 440 n. 4.
The lion among a flock transforms the army’s mass into vulnerability, and the English sustains that reversal without adding another opponent. The retreat verse runs in Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor but is apparatus material in Khaleghi, so its presence must not be confused with agreement in editorial placement. Fresh and strong interprets the extraordinary return across the river: the Persian says it is as though Giv had not even seen an army in a dream. The subsequent intention is explicitly to cut off Piran’s head, reduced in English to striking him dead. His yellow face and presentation before Khosrow have individual apparatus support as well as Mohl running-text support. Far from the stream in couplet 27 reiterates earlier geography rather than translating that particular Persian verse.
Return to passage30–34Accusation, address, and the first appeal
Moscow III p. 221 vv. 3371–3375. Mohl II p. 257 vv. 949–953. Ganjoor §19.72–76. Khaleghi II p. 440 Journey302–306.
Giv presents the captive through the dragon’s-mouth image, then connects his fate with Siavash’s death. The English shifts into direct second-person accusation in couplet 31. The Persian instead refers to Piran in the third person, continuing an address to Khosrow, so the English alters the immediate addressee while keeping the charge intelligible. Becoming wind preserves the compact image of a life extinguished; it should not be expanded into a literal transformation. Piran’s answering praise redirects attention to the prince’s wisdom and his own record of care. The English distributes the grief-and-struggle verse across couplets 33 and 34, naming Afrasiab where the Persian says the king. That identification clarifies the context, while the added danger emphasizes the personal cost of his intervention.
Return to passage35–37Counterfactual rescue and the plea for royal protection
Moscow III p. 221 n. 15 to 3375 and running3376. Mohl II pp. 257–258 vv. 954–956. Ganjoor §19.76–77; two added pleas absent. Khaleghi II p. 440 n. 11 to Journey306 and running307.
Piran argues that his presence could have prevented Siavash’s destruction, then invokes his rescue of mother and son. These are a captive’s claims for mercy, not independent confirmation that he could have changed the past. Mohl prints both pleas continuously. Moscow’s apparatus supplies the counterfactual and the rescue-from-the-Div wording, while Khaleghi records the counterfactual and a different adjacent statement about Farangis being hidden or protected; the precise Div-rescue verse was not found in that checked note. Ganjoor proceeds directly to the final appeal. The English softens the counterfactual to might be living, whereas the Persian asserts that Siavash would not have perished. Retaining farr alongside fortune preserves the prince’s specifically royal power to deliver Piran from the dragon now embodied by Giv.
Return to passageSource record and limits
Moscow and Mohl scans were checked first, followed by Ganjoor and Khaleghi. Running text, individual apparatus verses and checked gaps are distinguished; no appendix evidence is cited. Six English entries have individual Moscow apparatus support. Khaleghi’s second addition to Journey306 is a partial parallel about Farangis, not the exact Div-rescue line printed by Mohl and recorded in Moscow. The English’s raised mace differs from the checked saddle movement, and the inferred deception at the standard is distinguished from explicit source wording. Exact combat mechanics and the historical truth of Piran’s counterfactual remain interpretive questions.
B10.24 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow III | Mohl II |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | p. 219 · v. 3346 (running text) | p. 256 · v. 920 (running text) |
| 2 | p. 219 · v. 3347 (running text) | p. 256 · v. 921 (running text) |
| 3 | p. 219 · v. 3348 (running text) | p. 256 · v. 922 (running text) |
| 4 | p. 219 · v. 3349 (running text) | p. 256 · v. 923 (running text) |
| 5 | p. 220 · v. 3350 (running text) | p. 256 · v. 924 (running text) |
| 6 | p. 220 · v. 3353 (running text) | p. 256 · v. 925 (running text) |
| 7 | p. 220 · v. 3351 (running text) | p. 256 · v. 926 (running text) |
| 8 | p. 220 · n. 4 to v. 3351, added verse 1 (apparatus) | p. 256 · v. 927 (running text) |
| 9 | p. 220 · n. 4 to v. 3351, added verse 2 (apparatus) | p. 256 · v. 928 (running text) |
| 10 | p. 220 · v. 3352 (running text) · p. 220 · n. 5 to v. 3352, first split verse (apparatus: secret preparation) | p. 256 · v. 929 (running text) |
| 11 | p. 220 · v. 3354 (running text) | p. 257 · v. 930 (running text) |
| 12 | p. 220 · v. 3355 (running text) | p. 257 · v. 931 (running text) |
| 13 | p. 220 · v. 3356 (running text) | p. 257 · v. 932 (running text) |
| 14 | p. 220 · v. 3357 (running text) | p. 257 · v. 933 (running text) |
| 15 | p. 220 · v. 3358 (running text) | p. 257 · v. 934 (running text) |
| 16 | p. 220 · v. 3359 (running text) | p. 257 · v. 935 (running text) |
| 17 | p. 220 · v. 3360 (running text) | p. 257 · v. 936 (running text) |
| 18 | p. 220 · v. 3361 (running text) | p. 257 · v. 937 (running text) |
| 19 | p. 220 · v. 3362 (running text) | p. 257 · v. 938 (running text) |
| 20 | p. 220 · v. 3363 (running text) | p. 257 · v. 939 (running text) |
| 21 | p. 220 · v. 3364 (running text) | p. 257 · v. 940 (running text) |
| 22 | p. 221 · v. 3365 (running text) | p. 257 · v. 941 (running text) |
| 23 | p. 221 · v. 3366 (running text) | p. 257 · v. 942 (running text) |
| 24 | p. 221 · v. 3367 (running text) | p. 257 · v. 943 (running text) |
| 25 | p. 221 · v. 3368 (running text) | p. 257 · v. 944 (running text) |
| 26 | p. 221 · v. 3369 (running text) | p. 257 · v. 945 (running text) |
| 27 | p. 221 · v. 3370 (running text) | p. 257 · v. 946 (running text) |
| 28 | p. 221 · n. 10 to v. 3370, added verse 1 (apparatus) | p. 257 · v. 947 (running text) |
| 29 | p. 221 · n. 10 to v. 3370, added verse 2 (apparatus) | p. 257 · v. 948 (running text) |
| 30 | p. 221 · v. 3371 (running text) | p. 257 · v. 949 (running text) |
| 31 | p. 221 · v. 3372 (running text) | p. 257 · v. 950 (running text) |
| 32 | p. 221 · v. 3373 (running text) | p. 257 · v. 951 (running text) |
| 33 | p. 221 · v. 3374 (running text) · p. 221 · v. 3375 (running text) | p. 257 · v. 952 (running text) · p. 257 · v. 953 (running text) |
| 34 | p. 221 · v. 3375 (running text) | p. 257 · v. 953 (running text) |
| 35 | p. 221 · n. 15 to v. 3375, first added verse (apparatus) | p. 257 · v. 954 (running text) |
| 36 | p. 221 · n. 15 to v. 3375, final T addition (apparatus: rescue from the Div) | p. 258 · v. 955 (running text) |
| 37 | p. 221 · v. 3376 (running text) | p. 258 · v. 956 (running text) |
New Naqqali