The Prelude
18 couplets; Mohl order and fuller four-couplet announcement; pain/toil/grief reading; Pahlevan and Iran added in final application.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 18 couplets; Mohl order and fuller four-couplet announcement; pain/toil/grief reading; Pahlevan and Iran added in final application. |
| Moscow IV | IV pp.8–9: 13 ethical running verses, then narrator vv.14–15; narrator also printed in p.8 n.1; beneficent deeds in p.8 n.6. Full introductory Mohl vv.2–4 absent in checked opening and appendices. |
| Mohl II | II pp.280–281 (PDF286–287), reset vv.1–18; complete continuous reference for all English couplets. |
| Ganjoor | Kay Khosrow sh1 vv.1–15: 13 ethical verses followed by narrator transition; lacks Mohl 2–4 and 7 in this opening. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh III | III pp.3–4 (PDF19–20): 13 ethical running verses; narrator below v.13 in p.4 n.6; beneficent deeds below v.2 in p.3 n.6. Greed/pain/grief differs from Mohl. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–4A promise placed before the ethical prelude
Mohl II280:1–4; Moscow IV8 n.1 and IV9:14–15; Khaleghi III4 n.6 after v.13; Ganjoor sh1.14–15. English 2–4: checked local gaps documented in register; Moscow appendices I–VII also inspected.
The English follows Mohl in putting the narrator’s announcement before the image of the cypress. Moscow and Ganjoor instead place the narrator after the discussion of the virtues, while Khaleghi records the corresponding transition below the main text. The introductory promise therefore has different structural force in these presentations. English gives the coming kingship and campaign their own advance announcement, then makes the poet’s survival a condition of completing another tale. Those three fuller introductory verses are printed in Mohl but are not present in the checked opening loci of the other editions. The English adds a sense of completed business at the outset, and expands continued life and freshness of face into strength and renewal of spirit. These are intelligible poetic developments, but should remain distinct from the wording actually attested.
Return to passage5–7The tree, the observer, and the beneficiary
Mohl II280:5–7; Moscow IV8:1–2, n.6; Khaleghi III3:1–2, n.6; Ganjoor sh1.1–2, checked gap before v.3.
The cypress rises above the palace in all four presentations, preserving a visible image of exceptional growth. The English makes the familial implication explicit by naming a parent tree. Its next line then introduces wise and fortunate spectators. The Persian construction also permits the tree to see the offspring as perceptive and fortunate, maintaining the family image rather than introducing an audience. This interpretive shift matters because the passage moves toward the qualities required in the future ruler. The following statement of worldly benefit is continuous in Mohl, printed as an addition in both critical apparatuses, and absent at this point in Ganjoor. English makes Fortune the active supporter of the beneficiary’s heart. That syntax is particularly close to the printed apparatus formulation, whereas Mohl’s intervening preposition allows a different grammatical emphasis.
Return to passage8–10Three connected qualities, not interchangeable virtues
Mohl II280:8–10; Moscow IV8:3–5 and n.12; Khaleghi III3:3–5; Ganjoor sh1.3–5.
The English first invites a shared examination and then names the three qualities in an order that differs from the Persian list. Its later definitions let readers distinguish lineage, accomplishment, and native worth, so the reordered catalogue does not destroy the argument. Nevertheless, brave deeds initially gives accomplishment a more martial sense than the broader ability subsequently acquired through learning. The statement that the qualities are connected is securely shared by the four texts. The additional suggestion that they have one degree is less exact: connection does not itself establish equality. The next couplet importantly prevents high birth from being treated as sufficient. English preserves that qualification and its dependence of accomplishment on native worth. Its reference to many high-born people agrees with the reading in Moscow, Ganjoor, and Khaleghi rather than Mohl’s scanned wording with an indefinite person.
Return to passage11–14Divine endowment, paternal descent, and learning
Mohl II280:11–14; Moscow IV8:6–7 and IV9:8–9; Khaleghi III3:6–9, especially n.16; Ganjoor sh1.6–9.
The definitions make the distinction among the three qualities much sharper than the preceding catalogue. English preserves paternal descent as lineage and learning through effort as accomplishment. Its account of native worth retains the connection with divine farr and the refusal to reach toward evil or listen to it. However, making native worth clear emphasizes manifestation, whereas the Persian directly connects its existence or source with divine farr. The English description of stainless stock also strengthens the language of purity around descent. In the final image, Moscow, Mohl, and Ganjoor retain the beauty of the Creator’s robe. Khaleghi’s main text instead has wording associated with wearing the robe, with the beauty reading printed in the apparatus. English follows the beauty reading; that agreement should not be attributed to all four running texts.
Return to passage15–17Wisdom relieves suffering but cannot defeat death
Mohl II280:15–16, II281:17; Moscow IV9:10–12 and nn.9–12; Khaleghi III4:10–12, nn.1–4; Ganjoor sh1.10–12.
Wisdom supplies the fourth requirement and the capacity to distinguish good from evil in every checked text. English preserves that practical role, although its formulation makes wisdom arise when the first three meet rather than directly telling their possessor that wisdom is still needed. The resulting release is not described identically in the editions. Mohl has pain, toil, and grief; Moscow and Ganjoor substitute greed for pain; Khaleghi retains greed and pain but not toil in its main line. English follows Mohl’s combination. It consequently loses the explicit release from acquisitiveness present in the other three readings. The exception for death then places a firm limit on this ideal condition. English preserves that limit while replacing Mohl’s darkness and the other editions’ comparative worsening with the severity of a bane.
Return to passage18The world-seeker becomes an Iranian Pahlevan
Mohl II281:18; Moscow IV9:13; Khaleghi III4:13; Ganjoor sh1.13. Boundary transition: Moscow IV9:14–15 / Ganjoor sh1.14–15 / Khaleghi III4 n.6.
The closing couplet applies the discussion to a world-seeking figure supported by fortune from above. In its position at the opening of Kay Khosrow’s reign, the description naturally points toward the king whose rule follows. English preserves the favorable fortune but introduces both a named heroic rank and an Iranian nationality that are not stated in this Persian couplet. These additions may make the figure sound like a champion serving the king rather than the prospective ruler himself. The preceding explicit reference to the four qualities also becomes a more general expression of grace. The English thus retains praise while making the argumentative conclusion less precise. This is a question of referent and logical connection, not evidence that the Persian editions name a different historical person here.
Return to passageSource-only verses
| Evidence and placement | Persian |
|---|---|
Return to beginning of the royal narrative; no separate English B11.1 counterpart. IV9:15 running · No separate counterpart in II280:1–18; opening announcement already precedes prelude · Ganjoor: No separate Ganjoor reading recorded · III4 n.6 second addition block, second verse | کنون بازگردم به آغاز کار که چون بود کردار آن شهریار |
Additional lineage condition. Kept separate from running v.5, not conflated with English 10. IV8 n.12, printed addition after v.4; apparatus also gives فر و داد variant · No separate counterpart in checked II280:9–10 · Ganjoor: No separate Ganjoor reading recorded · No identical extra couplet in checked III3:4–5 apparatus | هنر کی بود تا نباشد نژاد نژاده بسی دیده بی فر و زاد |
Royal obligation to do good; source-only apparatus material. No corresponding second addition in IV8 n.6 · No corresponding verse between II280:7–8 · Ganjoor: No separate Ganjoor reading recorded · III3 n.6, second printed added verse after v.2 | کرا پادشاهی بود در گهر بباید که نیکی کند تاجور |
Source record and limits
Moscow IV printed/PDF pp.315–322, Appendices I–VII visually checked: Kamus, Khaqan, Akvan episodes; no corresponding opening announcement.
Running text, printed apparatus, appendix evidence, checked local gaps and unverified readings remain distinct. No unprinted addition notice establishes a positive reading.
B11.1 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow IV | Mohl II |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV p.8 n.1 (printed opening addition); p.9 v.14 (relocated running text) | II p.280, v.1 (running text) |
| 2 | Checked gap: IV pp.8–9, opening running vv.1–15 and their apparatus; appendices I–VII, pp.315–322, checked and concern later episodes | II p.280, v.2 (running text) |
| 3 | Checked gap: IV pp.8–9, opening running vv.1–15 and their apparatus; appendices I–VII, pp.315–322, checked and concern later episodes | II p.280, v.3 (running text) |
| 4 | Checked gap: IV pp.8–9, opening running vv.1–15 and their apparatus; appendices I–VII, pp.315–322, checked and concern later episodes | II p.280, v.4 (running text) |
| 5 | IV p.8, v.1 (running text) | II p.280, v.5 (running text) |
| 6 | IV p.8, v.2 (running text) | II p.280, v.6 (running text) |
| 7 | IV p.8 n.6 to v.2, printed added verse | II p.280, v.7 (running text) |
| 8 | IV p.8, v.3 (running text) | II p.280, v.8 (running text) |
| 9 | IV p.8, v.4 (running text) | II p.280, v.9 (running text) |
| 10 | IV p.8, v.5 (running text) | II p.280, v.10 (running text) |
| 11 | IV p.8, v.6 (running text) | II p.280, v.11 (running text) |
| 12 | IV p.8, v.7 (running text) | II p.280, v.12 (running text) |
| 13 | IV p.9, v.8 (running text) | II p.280, v.13 (running text) |
| 14 | IV p.9, v.9 (running text) | II p.280, v.14 (running text) |
| 15 | IV p.9, v.10 (running text) | II p.280, v.15 (running text) |
| 16 | IV p.9, v.11 (running text) | II p.280, v.16 (running text) |
| 17 | IV p.9, v.12 (running text) | II p.281, v.17 (running text) |
| 18 | IV p.9, v.13 (running text) | II p.281, v.18 (running text) |
New Naqqali