Kay Khosrow Surveys His Kingdom
20 couplets unchanged; Mohl supplies fuller roster and battlefield simile; restoration expanded across four English couplets.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 20 couplets unchanged; Mohl supplies fuller roster and battlefield simile; restoration expanded across four English couplets. |
| Moscow IV | IV12–13:59–77; main drum/helmets and hunting animals; printed ney replacement in12n10 and armor alternatives in12n15. Fuller roster and game/battlefield couplet absent in checked local sequence. |
| Mohl II | II283=PDF289:64–84, 21 continuous verses. Labelled Persian reference; arrival roster compressed and restoration redistributed in English. |
| Ganjoor | Kay Khosrow sh2:1–19, all accounted for. Main drum/helmets and hunting animals; separate Giv/Gudarz accompaniment recorded source-only. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh III | III6–7=PDF22–23:53–71; main drum/helmets but armored procession. Printed name and equipment variants kept distinct from fuller Mohl passages. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–4A martial dawn and the expanded company
Moscow IV12:59–62, nn8–11; Mohl II283:64–69; Ganjoor sh2:1–4; Khaleghi III6:53–55, nn26–28 and III7:56.
The drawn solar blade makes the dawn martial in all four texts. English specifies a scimitar and names the sun as Sol, adding cultural coloring without changing the action. The ensuing ney is not an error against the other editions’ drum: Mohl prints the wind instrument and the nobles’ turn toward the king, and Moscow reproduces that whole alternative in its apparatus. English follows that version rather than the drum and helmets of the other running texts. Mohl also supplies the fuller five-name roster compressed into English’s fourth couplet. The corresponding Moscow, Ganjoor, and Khaleghi passages give collective arrival without those two additional roster verses. Printed Rohham variants support that name only. They cannot verify Bijan, Ashkash, Fariborz, and Zangeh as a complete additional roster.
Return to passage5–7Hunting animals, armor, and a battlefield
Moscow IV12:63–66, nn12–15; Mohl II283:70–73; Ganjoor sh2:5–8; Khaleghi III7:57–60, nn2–6.
The sources agree that Rostam accompanies the royal hunt, but English adds his position at the head of the heroes. Moscow and Ganjoor’s main procession carries hunting animals; Mohl and Khaleghi instead specify equipment, with armor alternatives actually printed beneath Moscow’s text. English’s armor and weapons therefore follow an attested reading. Its upward crowding makes the obscuring of sun and moon more physically explicit. The following battlefield simile is continuously printed in Mohl, while the other three checked passages move directly into the royal circuit without that separate verse. English preserves both fallen game and the comparison with slain combatants. This moment brings the hunt close to martial slaughter before the narrative turns to repair and generosity. Its absence from the shorter sequence changes that transition, not merely the length of the account.
Return to passage8–11Inspection and treasury-funded restoration
Moscow IV12:66–68; Mohl II283:73–75; Ganjoor sh2:8–10; Khaleghi III7:60–62, nn6–7.
All four sources distinguish thriving territory from places ruined by injustice, and all make treasury expenditure the means of restoration. English preserves this causal structure: destruction has a political cause, and repair requires material resources. Its description of the king as aware makes inspection explicit where the Persian describes passage through the landscape. The English then spreads three Persian verses across four couplets, anticipating restoration before naming the dirhams and giving unwearied justice a separate concluding couplet. Deserted towns filled with life narrows the broader Persian land and habitation vocabulary while making the benefits concrete. The final easing of distress supplies an emotional result not stated in that half-line. It remains consistent with the restorative action, but should be distinguished from the directly attested claim that generosity does not weary the king.
Return to passage12–16Portable kingship, wealth, and the sanctuary
Moscow IV12:69–71, nn18–21; IV13:72–73, nn1–4; Mohl II283:76–80; Ganjoor sh2:11–15; Khaleghi III7:63–67, nn8–18.
The throne established in each city makes royal presence mobile in all four texts. English adds the public announcement of justice in place of the Persian comparison with a fortunate man or king. Mohl next explicitly requests purses from the treasury, whereas the other three main texts associate purses with wine. English follows Mohl’s financial emphasis and converts adorning the world with dinars into scattering them. Wine returns in the next English couplet with throne and crown, preserving the larger balance of pleasure and royal display. The journey then reaches the named region and sanctuary. English’s alternating drinking and riding agrees especially with Moscow and Ganjoor; Mohl and Khaleghi use repeated ongoing actions. Calling the destination the fire’s abode follows the sanctuary sense, while avoiding a claim that Mohl’s differently spelled noun is identical to the other readings.
Return to passage17–20Prayer, reunion, and wine-induced sleep
Moscow IV13:74–77, nn5–8; Mohl II283:81–84; Ganjoor sh2:16–19; Khaleghi III7:68–71, nn19–24.
The fire temple is the place of prayer, while the World-Creator is the object of praise in all four sources. English preserves that distinction and follows Mohl’s prayer-before-praise order rather than the reversed hemistich order of the other three. The subsequent Persian movement is toward Kavus; English anticipates arrival by displaying his court and adds its brightness and the king’s age. Shared uninterrupted happiness then becomes the release of every care, giving the reunion a more explicitly therapeutic effect. At the close, the Persian locates the cup’s effect in the head and follows it with haste toward sleep and repose. English names wine directly, relocates its effect to the breast, and makes the hour of rest arrive. The basic sequence survives, but the bodily image and the agency of the final movement change.
Return to passageSource-only verses
| Evidence and placement | Persian |
|---|---|
Ganjoor sh2:6 IV12:v64 running · Checked local gap between II283:70–71; no separate Giv/Gudarz accompaniment verse · Ganjoor: sh2:6 · III7:v58 running; n3 records relocation in a witness Freeborn chiefs including Giv and Gudarz accompany the hunt. English chosen men is general; these two names are not repeated at this point. | ز لشکر برفتند آزادگان چو گیو و چو گودرز کشوادگان |
Source record and limits
Inherited B11.1 appendix inspection: Moscow IV315–322, Appendices I–VII concern later Kamus/Khaqan/Akvan episodes. No opening supplement; no unprinted addition notice used as verification.
Running text, printed apparatus, appendix evidence, checked local gaps and unverified readings remain distinct. No unprinted addition notice establishes a positive reading.
B11.3 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow IV | Mohl II |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV 12:v.59 running | II283 (PDF289):vv.64 running |
| 2 | IV 12:v.60 running; IV12 n10 prints full ney/arrival replacement | II283 (PDF289):vv.65 running |
| 3 | IV 12:v.61 running | II283 (PDF289):vv.66 running |
| 4 | IV 12:v.62 running; IV12 vv61–63/apparatus checked: fuller Mohl67–68 roster absent; n11 has Rohham name variant only | II283 (PDF289):vv.67,68,69 running |
| 5 | IV 12:v.63 running | II283 (PDF289):vv.70 running |
| 6 | IV 12:v.65 running; IV12 n15 prints armor alternatives | II283 (PDF289):vv.71 running |
| 7 | Checked local gap: IV12 vv65–66 and their printed apparatus; no battlefield-of-game couplet | II283 (PDF289):vv.72 running |
| 8 | IV 12:v.66 running | II283 (PDF289):vv.73 running |
| 9 | IV 12:v.67 running; IV 12:v.68 running | II283 (PDF289):vv.74,75 running |
| 10 | IV 12:v.68 running | II283 (PDF289):vv.75 running |
| 11 | IV 12:v.68 running | II283 (PDF289):vv.75 running |
| 12 | IV 12:v.69 running | II283 (PDF289):vv.76 running |
| 13 | IV 12:v.70 running; IV12 n19 supplies همی variant only, not Mohl’s treasury wording | II283 (PDF289):vv.77 running |
| 14 | IV 12:v.71 running | II283 (PDF289):vv.78 running |
| 15 | IV 13:v.72 running | II283 (PDF289):vv.79 running |
| 16 | IV 13:v.73 running | II283 (PDF289):vv.80 running |
| 17 | IV 13:v.74 running | II283 (PDF289):vv.81 running |
| 18 | IV 13:v.75 running | II283 (PDF289):vv.82 running |
| 19 | IV 13:v.76 running | II283 (PDF289):vv.83 running |
| 20 | IV 13:v.77 running | II283 (PDF289):vv.84 running |
New Naqqali