The Vow of Vengeance against Afrasiab
63 couplets preserved verbatim; combines attested readings, redistributes speech, and relocates old-Kavus plea. Significant choices assessed at20,26,41,46,53 and60.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 63 couplets preserved verbatim; combines attested readings, redistributes speech, and relocates old-Kavus plea. Significant choices assessed at20,26,41,46,53 and60. |
| Moscow IV | IV13–16:78–139, all62 running verses covered. Lofty spirit; singular writing; old-Kavus plea; death reading. Relevant printed grief and exhortation additions distinguished. |
| Mohl II | II284–286=PDF290–292:85–147, all63 running verses accounted for including source-only101. Humility, plural writing, fuller grief verses; old-Kavus plea absent in checked prayer. |
| Ganjoor | Kay Khosrow sh2:20–81, all62 verses covered. Accessible Persian reference, not a substitute for primary checks. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh III | III7–10=PDF23–26:72–133, all62 running verses covered. Alternate oath list, no rest before prayer, war rather than death; apparatus alternatives individually labelled. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5Council and tears at a ruby dawn
Moscow IV13:78–81; Mohl II284:85–88; Ganjoor sh2:20–23; Khaleghi III7:72–75.
The Persian opens with a rupture in dawn and ruby color spreading over dark earth. English preserves the gemlike brilliance but makes Sol spread light and turns the earthward image into the reign of daylight. Mohl’s solar wording is closer to that named agency than the day of the other three texts. All four then place the two fortunate kings with Rostam and Dastan. English makes the four-person council explicit and adds a collective description of political strength. It redistributes Kavus’s account and his turn to Afrasiab across the next couplets without changing the speaker. The blood of the eyes washing the cheeks becomes tears apparently mixed with blood. That qualification reduces the literal force of the shared Persian grief image while retaining its emotional severity.
Return to passage6–11A devastated realm makes the demand for justice
Moscow IV13:82–87; Mohl II284:89–94; Ganjoor sh2:24–29; Khaleghi III8:76–81 and nn9–12.
All four sources move from Siavash’s fate to dead champions, suffering women and children, and Iranian cities ruined by Afrasiab. English distributes those consequences across more lines, adding the land robbed of breath and describing ruined cities as emptied. These images intensify devastation without creating a different agent. The transition to the grandson’s gifts is also common: stature, knowledge, physical strength, divine favor, and fortunate standing justify the demand for an oath. English gathers the gifts into one couplet and joins superiority over kings to justice in the next. Its positive formulation of justice as a guide replaces the Persian prohibition on even a slight deviation. Mohl’s Kayanian farr and the other presentations’ differing descriptions of completeness or excellence should not be collapsed into identical wording, although the royal qualification remains shared.
Return to passage12–16Kinship, persuasion, and an oath’s foundation
Moscow IV13:88–90, IV14:91–92 and n1; Mohl II284:95–99; Ganjoor sh2:30–34; Khaleghi III8:82–86, especially n20.
The oath explicitly excludes maternal kinship as a reason for turning toward Afrasiab in every source. English therefore preserves a substantive conflict between family connection and the demanded vengeance. It also retains resistance to wealth and changing fortune, adding reins as an image of self-command. The lists of tempting royal objects differ: Moscow and Ganjoor most closely support the crown, throne, and signet, whereas Mohl includes weapons and Khaleghi’s main line begins with treasure. Khaleghi prints the crown and signet alternative, so the English should not be treated as unsupported. The final English couplet changes the explanation of the oath’s foundation and its counsel to reason and soul into a binding bond. This makes obligation more prominent and the Persian invitation to understand the oath’s rationale less explicit.
Return to passage17–20Exclusive weapons and the disputed humility
Moscow IV14:93–95 and nn6–12; Mohl II284:100–103; Ganjoor sh2:35–37; Khaleghi III8:87–89 and nn21–27.
The witnesses agree that sword and mace are to be the only mediators. English retains that exclusion but adds the language of deciding right, making violence a form of adjudication. Its next instruction to remain humble is textually consequential. Mohl explicitly lowers disposition against high stature; Moscow, Ganjoor, and Khaleghi instead raise spirit along with stature. The checked Moscow and Khaleghi apparatus do not supply Mohl’s lowering word. English thus follows a real alternative whose ethical effect reverses the other running texts at this point. The preceding invocations also vary: Mohl adds Faridun, Siavash’s blood, and the king’s life, while Khaleghi prints a different astral addition. Neither extension is separately rendered. English’s seal interprets the Persian term within the royal list rather than preserving its possible ambiguity.
Return to passage21–25Turning to fire and speaking the vow
Moscow IV14:96–99 and nn14–17; Mohl II284:104–107; Ganjoor sh2:38–41; Khaleghi III8:90–92 and nn31–32, III9:93.
All four texts turn the young king’s face and soul toward fire before the vow. English preserves the action but adds holy fear, converting a described orientation into an explicitly felt religious response. White day and lapis night remain recognizable, with the English face and pall extending the imagery. One Persian verse of royal and celestial objects then occupies two English couplets; the added language of witnessing and binding anticipates the formal witnesses who follow. Khaleghi’s main list differs materially, including sword and treasure where the other running texts have moon and throne. Its apparatus prints relevant alternatives, which must remain distinct from its chosen text. The final refusal of affection and dream-vision is shared. Naming Afrasiab replaces pronouns and makes the vow independently intelligible in English.
Return to passage26–30A written oath becomes an entrusted object
Moscow IV14:100–104 and nn18–28; Mohl II285:108–112; Ganjoor sh2:42–46; Khaleghi III9:94–98 and nn2–12.
The written record, Pahlavi designation, witnesses, and transfer to Rostam make the oath materially enforceable in all four accounts. English’s plural scribal agency agrees with Mohl and Khaleghi, while Moscow and Ganjoor use a singular verb. Its musk-water is directly supported by Moscow and Ganjoor; Mohl names musk and Khaleghi prints a different compound. The English consequently combines attested features rather than reproducing one witness without variation. Sealing has support in Mohl’s formulation and a printed Moscow alternative, whereas a separate act of signing is not narrated. Calling Rostam the document’s shield interprets the protection implied by entrustment. The following week of music and wine is common to all four. English retains its duration and setting while enriching the description of Kavus’s hall.
Return to passage31–35Washing, prostration, and remembered rescue
Moscow IV14:105–107, IV15:108–109; Mohl II285:113–117; Ganjoor sh2:47–51; Khaleghi III9:99–103, especially n13.
The eighth-day washing and search for prayer are shared, but the intervening rest is not: Khaleghi says he did not rest, while Moscow, Mohl, and Ganjoor say he rested. English omits that disputed clause. Its face laid toward the earth follows the face reading of Moscow and Ganjoor, also printed beneath Khaleghi; Mohl and Khaleghi’s main line use affection instead. The English makes physical prostration more explicit than the immediate face phrase alone, although a later verse describes the face against the ground. The night-long crying remains intact. The prayer then joins universal divine attributes to a personal history of rescue without an army. English retains the dragon’s maw and adds helplessness, stressing vulnerability without needing to identify a literal animal outside the poem’s figurative narrative.
Return to passage36–41Public devastation and a personal plea
Moscow IV15:110–115, especially n4; Mohl II285:118–123; Ganjoor sh2:52–57; Khaleghi III9:104–109, especially nn17–25.
English compresses the lack of restraint or shame and the curse associated with ruined and thriving places. Its cursed ground makes the land’s condition explicit, while dropping the separate restraint term. For the murder and fire imagery, Mohl has two fuller verses, with fire and grief before the bloodshed; Moscow prints expanded variants beneath its combined verse. English places murder first and adds a flood to the grieving hearts, then develops fire-rain separately. The characterization through corrupt gohar, descent, and sorcery remains recognizably attested, but race generalizes a charge directed at this individual. The plea for help and mercy toward old Kavus is running text in Moscow, Ganjoor, and Khaleghi, but absent from the checked Mohl prayer. English retains it and places it after the characterization, changing the prayer’s closing emphasis.
Return to passage42–46From private prayer to the public report
Moscow IV15:116–120 and n13; Mohl II285:124–128; Ganjoor sh2:58–62; Khaleghi III9:110–114 and nn26–29.
The return from earthly prostration to the throne is shared, although English adds slow rising and relief of the soul. Its khanjar follows Moscow, Ganjoor, and Khaleghi against Mohl’s sword designation. The report of the royal circuit then reaches a difficult sentence. Moscow, Ganjoor, and Khaleghi coordinate joy, wealth, and flourishing land after the assertion that the king saw no such person. That wording does not straightforwardly assert a prosperous realm without happiness. Mohl introduces a conditional particle before the prosperity clause, permitting a concessive connection more favorable to the English. Even so, English makes both wealth and prosperity explicit concessions and turns an individual-centered observation into a statement about the place. This is a substantial interpretive choice, not unqualified agreement among all four witnesses.
Return to passage47–52Personal grief becomes collective commitment
Moscow IV15:121–125, IV16:126; Mohl II285:129–132, II286:133–134; Ganjoor sh2:63–68; Khaleghi III10:115–120.
All four texts move from universal injury through the speaker’s wounded heart to his grandfather’s sighs and the suffering of Iranian men and women. English retains that widening and narrowing of scale. Its claim that no heart suffers more makes the Persian priority of the speaker explicitly superlative. The cold breath from the grandfather’s heart becomes winds, enlarging the physical expression of grief. Describing the suffering as caused by Afrasiab’s reign can imply direct rule where the Persian attributes damage to him as an agent. The request for wholehearted friendship then becomes a demand to stand together and declare purpose. Finally, the girding of the king for vengeance and removal of evil from Iranians becomes cleansing the land. The political objective is preserved while the beneficiaries shift from people toward territory.
Return to passage53–56Consent, bloodguilt, and the promised afterlife
Moscow IV16:127–132 and nn6–14; Mohl II286:135–140; Ganjoor sh2:69–74; Khaleghi III10:121–126 and nn10–20.
Moscow, Ganjoor, and Khaleghi condition the campaign on the company’s willingness to fight; Mohl uses a collective first-person commitment. English follows the conditional appeal and the leopard comparison but replaces the next claim of success or removal of grief with personal refusal to yield. It preserves the heroes’ leveling of mountains, then condenses the assignment of bloodguilt into Afrasiab’s stain. That retains responsibility less explicitly and loses the image of guilt attached to its bearer. Paradise for fallen soldiers is common to all four, with English adding contrast to mortal existence. The demand for an answer and the argument that the enemy acted wrongly first are also retained. The final urgency strengthens the prohibition on sitting inactive. Printed additional exhortations in Moscow and Khaleghi are recorded separately rather than silently incorporated.
Return to passage57–63The chiefs answer with service and mortality
Moscow IV16:133–139 and nn15–23; Mohl II286:141–147; Ganjoor sh2:75–81; Khaleghi III10:127–133, especially n23.
The chiefs rise in pain, offer themselves and their fortunes, and affirm service despite freeborn status in all four accounts. English makes their unanimity explicit and specifies the throne as the object of service. Its statement that everyone is born to die agrees with Moscow, Mohl, and Ganjoor. Khaleghi’s main text instead says they are born for war, while its apparatus explicitly records the death reading. The English therefore preserves a mortality-based argument where Khaleghi’s chosen wording gives the answer a more directly martial rationale. The king’s face then flowers like redbud as youthful fortune meets a youthful ruler. English redistributes that image and the blessing across three couplets, adding awakened joy and a wish for champions everywhere before restating the earth’s flourishing through them.
Return to passageSource-only verses
| Evidence and placement | Persian |
|---|---|
Mohl II284:v101 Checked local gap: IV14:93–94 and apparatus · II284:v101 running · Ganjoor: Checked local gap: sh2:35–36 · Checked local gap: III8:87–88 and apparatus; astral addition is different Faridun, Siavash’s blood and the king’s life invoked; not separately rendered. Excerpt deliberately omits the epithet after Faridun; its exact transcription is not certified. | به یاد فریدون … و راد به خون سیاوش به جان تو شاه |
Khaleghi III8 n21 No counterpart in checked IV14:93 apparatus · No equivalent astral list in II284:100–102 · Ganjoor: No counterpart in sh2:35–36 · III8 n21, printed added verse after87 Astral oath extension, distinct from Mohl’s Faridun/Siavash invocation. | به کیوان و زاوش و بهرام و هور به ناهید و تیر و مه و فر و زور |
Moscow IV16 n7, addition1 IV16 n7, printed addition1 after128 · No counterpart in II286:136–137 checked transition · Ganjoor: No counterpart in sh2:70–71 · III10 n11, first printed addition after122 Exhortation to leave Iranian feasting for battle in Turan. | به ایران مدارید دل را به بزم به توران سپارید جان را به رزم |
Moscow IV16 n7, addition2 IV16 n7, printed addition2 after128 · No counterpart in II286:136–137 checked transition · Ganjoor: No counterpart in sh2:70–71 · III10 n11, second printed addition after122 Join hearts through divine strength; source-only exhortation. | ببندید دلها یک اندر دگر به نیروی یزدان پیروزگر |
Source record and limits
Inherited B11.1 inspection: Moscow IV315–322 Appendices I–VII concern later Kamus/Khaqan/Akvan episodes. Present comparison uses running text and actually printed apparatus; no unprinted addition notice counted.
Mohl II284:101 is an excerpt: the epithet after Faridun is omitted, remains uncertified, and is not used in the argument.
Running text, printed apparatus, appendix evidence, checked local gaps and unverified readings remain distinct. No unprinted addition notice establishes a positive reading.
Selected printed readings
| Evidence and placement | Persian |
|---|---|
| Mohl II284:103 | میانجی نخواهی بجز تیغ و گرز منش پست داری ز والای برز |
| Mohl II285:120 | بدین مرز با او ز آتش برشت همی خاک غم بر دلیران ببیخت |
| Mohl II285:121 | به بیداد خون سیاوش بخاک همی ریخت او جان ما کرد چاک |
| Mohl II285:128 | ندیدم کسی را که دلشاد بود توانگر بد ار بومش آباد بود |
| Khaleghi III10:130 | ز مادر همه جنگ را زادهایم همه بندهایم ار چه آزادهایم |
| Khaleghi III8:92 | به خورشید و شمشیر و گنج و کلاه به مهر و به تخت و به دیهیم و گاه |
B11.4 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow IV | Mohl II |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV 13:v.78 running | II 284:v.85 running |
| 2 | IV 13:v.79 running | II 284:v.86 running |
| 3 | IV 13:v.80 running | II 284:v.87 running |
| 4 | IV 13:v.80 running; IV 13:v.81 running | II 284:v.87 running; II 284:v.88 running |
| 5 | IV 13:v.81 running | II 284:v.88 running |
| 6 | IV 13:v.82 running | II 284:v.89 running |
| 7 | IV 13:v.82 running; IV 13:v.83 running | II 284:v.89 running; II 284:v.90 running |
| 8 | IV 13:v.83 running; IV 13:v.84 running | II 284:v.90 running; II 284:v.91 running |
| 9 | IV 13:v.84 running | II 284:v.91 running |
| 10 | IV 13:v.85 running; IV 13:v.86 running | II 284:v.92 running; II 284:v.93 running |
| 11 | IV 13:v.86 running; IV 13:v.87 running | II 284:v.93 running; II 284:v.94 running |
| 12 | IV 13:v.88 running | II 284:v.95 running |
| 13 | IV 13:v.89 running | II 284:v.96 running |
| 14 | IV 13:v.90 running | II 284:v.97 running |
| 15 | IV 14:v.91 running | II 284:v.98 running |
| 16 | IV 14:v.92 running | II 284:v.99 running |
| 17 | IV 14:v.93 running | II 284:v.100 running |
| 18 | IV 14:v.94 running | II 284:v.102 running |
| 19 | IV 14:v.95 running | II 284:v.103 running |
| 20 | IV 14:v.95 running; IV14 n11 prints تیز alternative, not Mohl پست | II 284:v.103 running |
| 21 | IV 14:v.96 running | II 284:v.104 running |
| 22 | IV 14:v.97 running | II 284:v.105 running |
| 23 | IV 14:v.98 running | II 284:v.106 running |
| 24 | IV 14:v.98 running | II 284:v.106 running |
| 25 | IV 14:v.99 running | II 284:v.107 running |
| 26 | IV 14:v.100 running | II 285:v.108 running |
| 27 | IV 14:v.101 running | II 285:v.109 running |
| 28 | IV 14:v.102 running; IV14 n25 prints مهر alternative | II 285:v.110 running |
| 29 | IV 14:v.103 running | II 285:v.111 running |
| 30 | IV 14:v.104 running | II 285:v.112 running |
| 31 | IV 14:v.105 running | II 285:v.113 running |
| 32 | IV 14:v.106 running | II 285:v.114 running |
| 33 | IV 14:v.107 running | II 285:v.115 running |
| 34 | IV 15:v.108 running | II 285:v.116 running |
| 35 | IV 15:v.109 running | II 285:v.117 running |
| 36 | IV 15:v.110 running; IV 15:v.111 running | II 285:v.118 running; II 285:v.119 running |
| 37 | IV 15:v.112 running; IV15 n4 prints expanded grief/fire variants | II 285:v.121 running |
| 38 | IV 15:v.112 running; IV15 n4 prints expanded grief/fire variants | II 285:v.120 running |
| 39 | IV 15:v.113 running | II 285:v.122 running |
| 40 | IV 15:v.115 running | II 285:v.123 running |
| 41 | IV 15:v.114 running | Checked local gap: II285:122–124, no vengeance/old-Kavus plea |
| 42 | IV 15:v.116 running | II 285:v.124 running |
| 43 | IV 15:v.117 running | II 285:v.125 running |
| 44 | IV 15:v.118 running | II 285:v.126 running |
| 45 | IV 15:v.119 running | II 285:v.127 running |
| 46 | IV 15:v.120 running | II 285:v.128 running |
| 47 | IV 15:v.121 running | II 285:v.129 running |
| 48 | IV 15:v.122 running | II 285:v.130 running |
| 49 | IV 15:v.123 running | II 285:v.131 running |
| 50 | IV 15:v.124 running | II 285:v.132 running |
| 51 | IV 15:v.125 running | II 286:v.133 running |
| 52 | IV 16:v.126 running | II 286:v.134 running |
| 53 | IV 16:v.127 running; IV 16:v.128 running | II 286:v.135 running; II 286:v.136 running |
| 54 | IV 16:v.128 running; IV 16:v.129 running | II 286:v.136 running; II 286:v.137 running |
| 55 | IV 16:v.130 running | II 286:v.138 running |
| 56 | IV 16:v.131 running; IV 16:v.132 running | II 286:v.139 running; II 286:v.140 running |
| 57 | IV 16:v.133 running | II 286:v.141 running |
| 58 | IV 16:v.134 running | II 286:v.142 running |
| 59 | IV 16:v.135 running | II 286:v.143 running |
| 60 | IV 16:v.136 running | II 286:v.144 running |
| 61 | IV 16:v.137 running; IV 16:v.138 running | II 286:v.145 running; II 286:v.146 running |
| 62 | IV 16:v.138 running; IV 16:v.139 running | II 286:v.146 running; II 286:v.147 running |
| 63 | IV 16:v.139 running | II 286:v.147 running |
New Naqqali