The Mustering of the Pahlevans
30 couplets verbatim. Reorders registration and banner lines; combines two Mohl closing verses. Names and counts draw on different attested readings.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 30 couplets verbatim. Reorders registration and banner lines; combines two Mohl closing verses. Names and counts draw on different attested readings. |
| Moscow IV | IV17–18:140–169 all30 running verses covered, plus identified printed apparatus. Main:80/78/63/100/85/33/70/105; Shiruy, Royin, Taurus. |
| Mohl II | II286–287=PDF292–293:148–178 all31 running verses covered. Tavaba75, Rivniz, Barzin70, Guraza120, Aries; closing praise in running text. |
| Ganjoor | Kay Khosrow sh3:1–30 all30 verses covered. Reference Persian body only. Luade85, Royin, Shiruy70, Guraza105, Taurus. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh III | III11–12=PDF27–28:134–163 all30 running verses covered. Navaye85;70 recruited from city; Guraza105; Taurus main, Aries printed alternative. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5From the solar season to the royal register
Moscow IV17:140–145, n10; Mohl II286:148–152; Ganjoor sh3:1–6; Khaleghi III11:134–138, n12.
All four begin with the sun appearing in Virgo and then turn to administration. English names the sun as Sol, retains the two-week suspension of audience, and makes the new register’s purpose inclusive. It also changes the chain of instruction. Moscow, Ganjoor, and Khaleghi make the mobad instruct the paymasters to give the names of lesser and greater people; Mohl prints dastur with the paymasters’ designation. English instead presents Khosrow addressing those terms and commanding writing. Its administrative action is intelligible but should not be described as identical wording or agency across the witnesses. Appropriate inscription of the heroes’ names precedes Kavus’s kin in Mohl and Khaleghi, as in English. Moscow and Ganjoor reverse those two verses, with the transposition explicitly reported beneath Moscow. Solemnity and ceremonial rite are English additions.
Return to passage6–11Royal kin and the banner’s changing attachment
Moscow IV17:144–149,152, nn12,17; Mohl II286:153–154, II287:155–158; Ganjoor sh3:5,7–10,13; Khaleghi III11:139–143,146, nn13,18.
The four running texts agree on one hundred ten Kavus kinsmen and eighty Nozari men. Both Moscow and Khaleghi nevertheless print seventy as an alternative for the second contingent, so agreement of the selected texts does not erase the numerical variation. English adds grace, bravery, and the splendid design of the maces. It makes the drum proclaim Zarasp’s name where the Persian attributes possession of weapons and drum. More consequentially, English places the raised standard immediately after Tus’s son, assigning him its action. That sequence agrees with Mohl and with a placement reported in Moscow’s apparatus. Moscow, Ganjoor, and Khaleghi place the verse after Gudarz’s descendants instead. The royal imagery also differs: Mohl has throne and fortune where the others have crown and throne. English’s sequence and fortune thus have specific support rather than unanimous attestation.
Return to passage12–15Counsel, descendants, and territorial expansion
Moscow IV17:150–154, n18; Mohl II287:159–162; Ganjoor sh3:11–15; Khaleghi III11:144–148, n16.
Gudarz’s counsel sustains the army in all four running texts. English’s land broadens that benefit from a military body to the realm; the printed giti alternatives in Moscow and Khaleghi supply a textual route toward that wider scope. The seventy-eight sons and grandsons, sixty-three Gazhdaham descendants, and hundred Milad horsemen are shared. Mohl, however, reverses the mountain and plain descriptions associated with Gudarz’s descendants: its riders belong to the mountain and its heroes to the plain. English follows the other three texts’ arrangement. Gostaham’s renown and Gorgin riding before the company add emphasis or staging beyond the short source designations. Moscow also actually prints an additional twenty-five descendants of Giv in its apparatus. That separate cohort is recorded as source-only evidence, not silently incorporated into Gudarz’s total or treated as part of every witness.
Return to passage16–19Names and numbers must be collated separately
Moscow IV17:155–156 and n23, IV18:157–158; Mohl II287:163–166; Ganjoor sh3:16–19; Khaleghi III11:149–150 and nn22–23, III12:151–152.
English’s Tavaba agrees with Mohl’s name and with a printed Khaleghi alternative. It does not agree with Mohl’s number: Mohl gives seventy-five, whereas English gives eighty-five, as do Moscow, Ganjoor, and Khaleghi in their running texts. Those three name the lineage differently, and Khaleghi also prints a seventy alternative. The translation therefore combines individually attested features rather than following one uniform roster. Borteh’s protection becomes a battle-shield in English, making an abstract supporting role concrete. The thirty-three descendants of Pashang are common to all four, but their commander differs. Mohl names Rivniz; Moscow, Ganjoor, and Khaleghi name Royin. English follows Mohl and postpones that name to the next couplet. Tus’s son-in-law and the position before the drum remain shared, while riding and the description sworn and free supply additional characterization.
Return to passage20–22Barzin’s kin and Guraza’s disputed strength
Moscow IV18:159–161 and nn9,11,13; Mohl II287:167–169; Ganjoor sh3:20–22; Khaleghi III12:153–155 and nn6–10.
The seventy men belong to Barzin in Mohl, to Shiruy in Moscow and Ganjoor, and are recruited from the city in Khaleghi’s running line. English’s genealogical statement thus has direct Mohl support, but cannot be attributed indiscriminately to all sources. Its lions also accord with Mohl’s leonine description more closely than the warriors of the other accounts. Farhad’s steel-anvil image is shared; English makes the anvil an active force that can stagger an enemy, enlarging a compact characterization of steadfast combat strength. Guraza’s contingent then numbers one hundred five in English, Moscow, Ganjoor, and Khaleghi. Mohl instead prints one hundred twenty, a number also explicitly recorded beneath Moscow. Shining armor is an English visual addition. These local count differences are preserved without manufacturing a grand army total from a passage that soon declares its numbers uncountable.
Return to passage23–28An innumerable host receives a dated command
Moscow IV18:162–167; Mohl II287:170–175; Ganjoor sh3:23–28; Khaleghi III12:156–161.
All four move from named contingents to a host beyond the mobad’s counting, yet also state that the names enter the royal register for future need. English keeps that productive tension between epic abundance and administrative enumeration. It transfers the stature and farr of the many nobles into the preceding couplet and adds a hall as the setting. Mohl’s corresponding phrase uses beauty or adornment with farr rather than the stature reading found in the other three. The movement out of the city toward open country is shared; English’s downward direction and explicit leading of the army provide additional staging. The new month’s beginning and the trumpet and Indian daray then mark mobilization in every witness. English retains the turn toward Turan and the abandonment of celebration. Neither the Virgo opening nor this monthly command by itself fixes an exact civil date.
Return to passage29–30The closing blessing and the zodiac’s first sign
Moscow IV18:168–169, nn27,30; Mohl II287:176–178; Ganjoor sh3:29–30; Khaleghi III12:162–163, nn24,26.
The shared act is prostration accompanied by blessings. English supplies courtiers standing in a ring, a more specific social and spatial arrangement than the source lines state. Its final couplet combines two Mohl verses: praise in which crown and girdle brighten through the king, followed by service extending from Aries to Pisces. The praise verse is not merely reported as an unidentified addition elsewhere: it is actually printed in Moscow’s apparatus and in Khaleghi’s. Ganjoor’s checked transition has no separate counterpart. The zodiac also matters. Moscow, Ganjoor, and Khaleghi’s running texts begin with Taurus, while Mohl begins with Aries; Khaleghi explicitly prints the Aries word as an alternative. English therefore has support for its complete zodiacal span. It retains the speakers’ service but drops the separate assertion that kingship belongs to the addressee.
Return to passageSource-only verses
| Evidence and placement | Persian |
|---|---|
Moscow IV17 n20, actually printed addition IV17 n20, printed25 Giv descendants after152 in VI; apparatus, not main text · Checked II287:158–161 transition; no separate25 Giv cohort · Ganjoor: Checked sh3:11–14 transition; no separate25 Giv cohort · Checked III11:144–147 and nn15–19; no separate25 Giv cohort printed here Source-only cohort; not part of English roster, not added to Gudarz78 or to an invented grand total. | هم از تخمه گیو چون بیست و پنج که بودند زیبای دیهیم و گنج |
Source record and limits
Inherited B11.1 inspection: Moscow IV315–322 Appendices I–VII concern later Kamus/Khaqan/Akvan episodes. No appendix evidence establishes a B11.5 reading. No unprinted addition notice counted as verification.
Selected Persian excerpts normalize spacing; not a diplomatic transcription of entire pages. Moscow IV18 n22 includes a partially dotted first added verse; its missing wording is not reconstructed or certified. All four main texts and the relevant printed apparatus checked; no global manuscript absence claims.
Running text, printed apparatus, appendix evidence, checked local gaps and unverified readings remain distinct. No unprinted addition notice establishes a positive reading.
Selected printed readings
| Evidence and placement | Persian |
|---|---|
| Mohl II286:151 | بفرمود دستور روزی دهان که گویند نام کهان و مهان |
| Mohl II287:158 | فرازنده اختر کاویان فروزنده تخت و بخت کیان |
| Mohl II287:163 | ز تخم توابه چو هفتاد و پنج سواران رزم و نگهبان گنج |
| Mohl II287:165 | چو سی و سه جنگی ز تخم پشنگ که ریونیز بدی سازشان روز جنگ |
| Mohl II287:167 | ز خویشان برزین چو هفتاد مرد که بودند شیران روز نبرد |
| Mohl II287:169 | ز تخم گرازه صد و بیست گرد نگهبان ایشان مر او را شمرد |
| Mohl II287:177–178 | بگفتند کای شاه با زور و فر فروزنده شد از تو تاج و کمر همه بندگانیم و شاهی تراست ز برج بره تا به ماهی تراست |
| Moscow IV18:169 running | که ما بندگانیم و شاهی تراست در گاو تا برج ماهی تراست |
| Moscow IV18 n27 printed praise | بگفتند کای شاه با زیب و فر فروزنده شد از تو تاج و کمر |
| Khaleghi III12:153 running | گزین از بر شهر هفتاد مرد که بودند گردنکشان نبرد |
| Khaleghi III12 n24 printed praise | بگفتند کای شاه با زیب و فر فروزنده شد از تو تاج و کمر |
| Khaleghi III12 n26 printed word alternative | بره |
B11.5 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow IV | Mohl II |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV 17:v.140 running | II 286:v.148 running |
| 2 | IV 17:v.141 running | II 286:v.149 running |
| 3 | IV 17:v.142 running | II 286:v.150 running |
| 4 | IV 17:v.143 running | II 286:v.151 running |
| 5 | IV 17:v.145 running; IV17 n10, printed transposition report | II 286:v.152 running |
| 6 | IV 17:v.144 running | II 286:v.153 running |
| 7 | IV 17:v.146 running | II 286:v.154 running |
| 8 | IV 17:v.147 running; IV17 n12, printed70 alternative | II 287:v.155 running |
| 9 | IV 17:v.148 running | II 287:v.156 running |
| 10 | IV 17:v.149 running | II 287:v.157 running |
| 11 | IV 17:v.152 running; IV17 n17, printed placement report152 after149 | II 287:v.158 running |
| 12 | IV 17:v.150 running; IV17 n18, printed گیتی | II 287:v.159 running |
| 13 | IV 17:v.151 running | II 287:v.160 running |
| 14 | IV 17:v.153 running | II 287:v.161 running |
| 15 | IV 17:v.154 running | II 287:v.162 running |
| 16 | IV 17:v.155 running; IV17 n23, printed name variants | II 287:v.163 running |
| 17 | IV 17:v.156 running | II 287:v.164 running |
| 18 | IV 18:v.157 running | II 287:v.165 running |
| 19 | IV18:vv.157,158 running | II287:vv.165,166 running |
| 20 | IV 18:v.159 running; IV18 n9, printed alternate recruitment verse | II 287:v.167 running |
| 21 | IV 18:v.160 running | II 287:v.168 running |
| 22 | IV 18:v.161 running; IV18 n13, printed120 alternative | II 287:v.169 running |
| 23 | IV18:vv.162,163 running | II287:vv.170,171 running |
| 24 | IV 18:v.163 running | II 287:v.171 running |
| 25 | IV 18:v.164 running | II 287:v.172 running |
| 26 | IV 18:v.165 running | II 287:v.173 running |
| 27 | IV 18:v.166 running | II 287:v.174 running |
| 28 | IV 18:v.167 running | II 287:v.175 running |
| 29 | IV 18:v.168 running | II 287:v.176 running |
| 30 | IV 18:v.169 running; IV18 n27, actually printed praise verse; n30 zodiac alternatives | II 287:v.177 running; II 287:v.178 running |
New Naqqali