The March to Kasa Rud
56 published couplets preserved verbatim;11 substantive notes.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 56 published couplets preserved verbatim;11 substantive notes. |
| Moscow IV | Printed68–71:933–985,53 running couplets; actual printed68 n6 supplies the opening transition. |
| Mohl II | Printed321–323:955–1008,54 running couplets, including the opening transition. All individually accounted for. |
| Ganjoor | Forood sh16:1–53,53 digital running couplets. Opening transition absent at the checked sh15/sh16 boundary; Mohl supplies that Persian display row. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh III | Printed60–62:524–575,52 running couplets. Opening transition actually printed60 n1; final blessing actually printed62 n23; weapon and challenge alternates recorded separately. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6Departure from Forood and the devastated marches
Moscow IV68 n6 and933–936; Mohl II321:955–959; Ganjoor sh16:1–4 and preceding boundary; Khaleghi III60 n1 and524–527.
The opening departure is not an unsupported bridge. Mohl prints it in running text, while Moscow and Khaleghi actually print it in their local apparatus; Ganjoor begins at the halt in Charam. English supplies martial mood and the dead youth’s bravery, then expands the three-day halt with lingering dust. The fourth-day signal and ebony landscape are common to all four presentations. Their darkness accompanies military movement rather than a separately identified weather change. The destruction of encountered Turanian soldiers is explicit, though English changes bodies cast on the road into bodies flung from combat. Retaining warp and woof preserves the striking image of a frontier whose fabric has been destroyed.
7–11The covered ground and an enemy reconnaissance
Moscow IV68:936–940; Mohl II321:959–963; Ganjoor sh16:4–8; Khaleghi III60:527–531.
The river arrival and establishment of camp are shared, but English spreads them into a fuller scene of banks, multitude and equipment. In the Persian presentations, tents make the ground disappear. English follows that visual totality with a second denial of open space, giving the encampment greater physical weight. The news reaching Turan is then cast as direct speech, where the sources report its substance. Palashan enters as a young champion with an alert heart. Shrewd is a plausible interpretation of that attentiveness, while fierceness adds an appraisal. His inspection of the army and counting of commanders’ standards remain specific reconnaissance actions in all four texts, rather than a generalized search for combat.
12–17The lookout, Giv’s weapon and his two alternatives
Moscow IV68:941–946; Mohl II321:964–969; Ganjoor sh16:9–14; Khaleghi III60:532–537 and n23.
The hill is within the camp but apart from its mass, allowing Giv and Bijan to converse away from the crowded army. English resolves that separation as an open mound with an empty side; the source wording need not establish an entirely deserted flank. Giv’s response contains a genuine weapon difference. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor give him a sword, while Khaleghi prints a club and records sword in its apparatus. English follows the sword-bearing tradition and draws his recognition of Palashan into the same couplet. His proposal is to sever the opponent’s head or bring him bound. Cut him down softens the first option’s anatomical specificity while keeping the contrast between killing and capture.
18–22Royal obligation meets a father’s fear
Moscow IV69:947–951; Mohl II321:970–973, II322:974; Ganjoor sh16:15–19; Khaleghi III60:538–540, III61:541–542.
Bijan invokes the royal robe and the duty to gird himself for this encounter in all four presentations. English turns the conditional reference to the gift into a direct statement and stresses his entitlement to undertake the task. Giv answers through fear of Palashan’s strength and of the grief defeat would bring him. The prayer to Yazdan makes that paternal concern devotional, but no separate prayer appears in the checked Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor or Khaleghi passage and local apparatus. It is an English expansion. The lion and meadow comparison remains supported, including the restriction of its prey to fighting men; Khaleghi varies the formulation by making the plain the lion’s meadow.
23–26Reputation, inherited armor and the mounted departure
Moscow IV69:952–955; Mohl II322:975–978; Ganjoor sh16:20–23; Khaleghi III61:543–546 and apparatus.
The fear of shame before the ruler gives Bijan a public answer to his father’s private anxiety. English extends that appeal into protection of fame, then specifies Siavash’s requested equipment as jowshan. The following armor verse supports that contextual narrowing, although the request itself uses the broader equipment term. All four have Bijan fasten the armor, but none of the checked local wording individually supplies rings, scales and clasps. Those are English material elaborations and cannot establish a particular armor construction. The departure with spear is shared. Moscow and Ganjoor call the horse swift, while Mohl and Khaleghi use a color description; English follows the supported speed reading and adds brightness.
27–31The interrupted meal and the challenge of names
Moscow IV69:956–961; Mohl II322:979–984; Ganjoor sh16:24–29; Khaleghi III61:547–552.
The meal makes Palashan’s confidence visible without requiring an explicit statement of complacency. All four presentations give him a hunted deer, roasting meat, a bow at his arm and a grazing horse. English adds curling smoke, later useful beside Bijan’s taunt, and makes the bow a possession rather than preserving its exact bodily position. The horse detects the approaching mount and gives the alert; English keeps that animal agency while placing the sound close to its rider. Palashan prepares for combat and boasts of felling lions and binding Divs before demanding a name. His opponent’s star will weep. English specifies defeat as the cause of that weeping, resolving the ominous image into a direct threat.
32–36Genealogy, the carrion wolf and a variant challenge
Moscow IV69:962–965; Mohl II322:985–988; Ganjoor sh16:30–33; Khaleghi III61:553–556, nn24,28.
Bijan answers with name, lineage and a promise of demonstrated skill. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor call him an elephant in battle; Khaleghi has a warrior in running text and actually prints elephant as an alternate. English follows the former reading and resolves the accompanying bodily epithet as bronze-bodied, without this local comparison independently certifying its exact material sense. Expanding the promised demonstration into a separate couplet gives the lineage room to resonate. The carrion wolf and its smoke, ashes and blood reverse Palashan’s hunting dignity into scavenging. The demand to bring warriors to the plain follows the three fuller presentations. Khaleghi instead calls for bringing one’s own life or self, while its apparatus prints army.
37–42The weapon sequence and the exhausted combatants
Moscow IV70:966–971; Mohl II322:989–994; Ganjoor sh16:34–39; Khaleghi III61:557, n31, III62:558–562.
Palashan answers through action, and the sources vary the imposing comparison applied to his mount: elephant-bodied, battle elephant or warlike Div. English makes the referent plainly a charger and keeps the windlike speed supported by Moscow and Ganjoor, while adding the released rein. Thereafter all four move from spears to swords and finally heavy clubs. English combines broken spearheads and fragmented blades before giving the trembling riders a separate couplet. Sand scattered with steel and quailing armor amplify the destruction beyond the stated weapon fragments and branchlike trembling. The drenched horses and distressed warriors remain shared. Reeling mounts and breast-to-breast rage supply further physical intensity without changing the sequence of weapons.
43–46The decisive blow and the trophies
Moscow IV70:972–976; Mohl II322:995–998, II323:999; Ganjoor sh16:40–44; Khaleghi III62:563–567.
The decisive action is unusually direct in all four presentations: Bijan cries out, strikes Palashan’s middle and shatters his back. English keeps the target and anatomical result while changing the club’s shoulder placement into a high-raised weapon and thunderous cry. Naming the armor around the spine carries equipment already present in the scene into the blow itself. The fallen body is explicitly a corpse in English before the next action completes the beheading. Dismounting and removal of the head are shared; the English distributes them across adjacent couplets and lets pride characterize the victor. Equipment and horse accompany the return, while the head reappears explicitly when the trophies reach Giv.
47–50The battle wind seen from the father’s lookout
Moscow IV70:977–980; Mohl II323:1000–1003; Ganjoor sh16:45–48; Khaleghi III62:568–571.
The narrative returns to the waiting father, whose distress depends on not yet knowing how the battle has turned. All four preserve the battle-wind image and his agitation at the lookout. English makes the backward shift explicit with meanwhile, identifies the distress as fear, and specifies pacing as well as groaning. Pacing is not a distinct action expressed by the Persian agitation words. The question of when Bijan’s dust will appear becomes an arrival completed by until. Head, armor and horse then answer the uncertainty through visible proof. English adds the release of care before Giv’s blessing; the source wish for the son’s victory is retained and widened to victory everywhere.
51–56Public praise and the blessing outside Khaleghi’s running text
Moscow IV70:981, IV71:982–985; Mohl II323:1004–1008; Ganjoor sh16:49–53; Khaleghi III62:572–575 and actually printed n23.
The joyful movement to the commander’s pavilion converts the private reunion into public recognition. English names both travelers and Tus, adding speed and an arrangement of trophies where the sources simply present them. The commander’s spirit seems about to scatter with joy; English makes it leap beyond the body, preserving the hyperbole through a clearer physical image. Army’s support, chief of renowned men and royal diadem are shared praise, distributed across the English close. The final wish for glad, elevated living and separation from evil is running text in Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor but actually printed apparatus in Khaleghi. English expands its protection into fortune and heart; that expansion does not change the blessing’s positive attestation.
Source record
Moscow printed68–71 and Khaleghi printed60–62 inspected with their local apparatus. Actual printed transition at Moscow68 n6 and Khaleghi60 n1; actual final blessing at Khaleghi62 n23. Relevant Khaleghi alternates include60 n23 sword,61 n24 elephant,61 n28 army and61 n31 mount comparisons. Ganjoor’s opening gap checked against sh15:85/sh16:1. The prayer, armor construction and pacing are classified against bounded local passages, not inferred from source availability. No appendix evidence invoked or volume-wide appendix search claimed; no unprinted addition notice used as verification.
English20 adds a prayer to Yazdan; English25 specifies rings, scales and clasps beyond the checked fastening verse; English48 makes agitation into pacing. English32’s bronze-bodied rendering is retained without independent material reconstruction. These are analytical qualifications, not proposed changes. Selected printed excerpts normalize spacing only, not a full diplomatic edition. All inherited provisional flags remain unchanged.
Selected printed excerpts normalize spacing only. English1 uses the explicitly labeled Mohl transition. All other Persian display rows reproduce the captured Ganjoor poem body; no composite Persian is reconstructed.
Selected printed readings
Mohl II321:955 running text
بپردخت و آمد از آن دژ فرود
Moscow IV68 n6 actual printed transition before933
بپردخت و آمد از آن کوه فرود
Khaleghi III60 n1 actual printed transition before524
بپرداخت و آمد از آن کوه فرود
Khaleghi III60:535 second hemistich running text
Khaleghi III60 n23 printed alternate
Moscow IV69:954 running text
همی بست بیژن زره را گره
Khaleghi III61:553 second hemistich running text
Khaleghi III61 n24 printed alternate
Khaleghi III61:556 second hemistich running text
Khaleghi III61 n28 printed alternate
Khaleghi III62 n23 actual printed blessing after575
ز تو دور بادا بد بدکنش
B12.14 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow IV | Mohl II |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV68 n6 actually printed transition before933 | II321:955 running text |
| 2 | IV68:933 running text | II321:956 running text |
| 3 | IV68:933; IV68:934 running text | II321:956; II321:957 running text |
| 4 | IV68:934 running text | II321:957 running text |
| 5 | IV68:935 running text | II321:958 running text |
| 6 | IV68:936 running text | II321:959 running text |
| 7 | IV68:936; IV68:937 running text | II321:959; II321:960 running text |
| 8 | IV68:937 running text | II321:960 running text |
| 9 | IV68:938 running text | II321:961 running text |
| 10 | IV68:939 running text | II321:962 running text |
| 11 | IV68:940 running text | II321:963 running text |
| 12 | IV68:941 running text | II321:964 running text |
| 13 | IV68:942 running text | II321:965 running text |
| 14 | IV68:943 running text | II321:966 running text |
| 15 | IV68:944; IV68:945 running text | II321:967; II321:968 running text |
| 16 | IV68:945 running text | II321:968 running text |
| 17 | IV68:946 running text | II321:969 running text |
| 18 | IV69:947 running text | II321:970 running text |
| 19 | IV69:948 running text | II321:971 running text |
| 20 | IV69:949 running text | II321:972 running text |
| 21 | IV69:950 running text | II321:973 running text |
| 22 | IV69:951 running text | II322:974 running text |
| 23 | IV69:952 running text | II322:975 running text |
| 24 | IV69:953 running text | II322:976 running text |
| 25 | IV69:954 running text | II322:977 running text |
| 26 | IV69:955 running text | II322:978 running text |
| 27 | IV69:956 running text | II322:979 running text |
| 28 | IV69:957 running text | II322:980 running text |
| 29 | IV69:958 running text | II322:981 running text |
| 30 | IV69:959; IV69:960 running text | II322:982; II322:983 running text |
| 31 | IV69:960; IV69:961 running text | II322:983; II322:984 running text |
| 32 | IV69:962 running text | II322:985 running text |
| 33 | IV69:963 running text | II322:986 running text |
| 34 | IV69:963 running text | II322:986 running text |
| 35 | IV69:964; IV69:965 running text | II322:987; II322:988 running text |
| 36 | IV69:965 running text | II322:988 running text |
| 37 | IV70:966 running text | II322:989 running text |
| 38 | IV70:967 running text | II322:990 running text |
| 39 | IV70:968; IV70:969 running text | II322:991; II322:992 running text |
| 40 | IV70:969 running text | II322:992 running text |
| 41 | IV70:970 running text | II322:993 running text |
| 42 | IV70:971 running text | II322:994 running text |
| 43 | IV70:972 running text | II322:995 running text |
| 44 | IV70:973 running text | II322:996 running text |
| 45 | IV70:974; IV70:975 running text | II322:997; II322:998 running text |
| 46 | IV70:975; IV70:976 running text | II322:998; II323:999 running text |
| 47 | IV70:977 running text | II323:1000 running text |
| 48 | IV70:978 running text | II323:1001 running text |
| 49 | IV70:979; IV70:980 running text | II323:1002; II323:1003 running text |
| 50 | IV70:980 running text | II323:1003 running text |
| 51 | IV70:981 running text | II323:1004 running text |
| 52 | IV71:982 running text | II323:1005 running text |
| 53 | IV71:983 running text | II323:1006 running text |
| 54 | IV71:984 running text | II323:1007 running text |
| 55 | IV71:984; IV71:985 running text | II323:1007; II323:1008 running text |
| 56 | IV71:985 running text | II323:1008 running text |
New Naqqali