News of Tus Reaches Afrasiab
35 published couplets preserved verbatim;7 substantive notes.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 35 published couplets preserved verbatim;7 substantive notes. |
| Moscow IV | Printed80–82:1124–1154,31 running couplets. Royal review actually printed in81 n29, continued on82; silence actually printed82 n13. Both distinguished from local running gaps. |
| Mohl II | Printed329–330:1149–1182,34 running couplets (PDF335–336). Royal review and camp silence in running text. Loss-of-fortress unit locally absent. Geography also has a checked local running gap1176–1177. |
| Ganjoor | Forood sh18:72–102,31 running digital couplets. Royal review and silence have checked local gaps. Two source-only units retained. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh III | Printed71–73:712–745,34 running couplets (PDF87–89). Royal review in running text; allocation couplet actually printed72 n1. Camp silence has a checked local gap; no full equivalent certified in local apparatus. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5A defeat reported through grief
Moscow IV80:1124–1128; Mohl II329:1149–1153; Ganjoor sh18:72–76; Khaleghi III71:712–716.
Tazhav’s tears introduce a report of military and territorial loss in all four presentations. English preserves that distress and supplies Afrasiab’s national title for orientation. The arrival of Tus includes elephants and the koust, but the plain is an English specification of location. Palashan and the leading men are brought to earth; English makes the outcome explicitly fatal and funerary through slain and grave. Burning the territory and disrupting the horse herds then becomes scorched fields, lost herds and universal ruin. That broadens the report while removing the herds’ equine specificity. Afrasiab’s trouble and search for a remedy are common to all four. English at once tightens the transition from receiving bad news to seeking a response.
6–10Royal blame and the narrowing world
Moscow IV81:1129–1133; Mohl II329:1154–1157; Ganjoor sh18:77–81; Khaleghi III71:717–721.
English grants Piran wisdom and trusted status before Afrasiab rebukes his delay. All four give the name and patronymic, but those approving descriptions are not expressed at this address. The command to gather troops is shared, followed by accusations involving sloth, age and weakened capacity; Mohl explicitly supplies ignorance. English gathers those charges and adds dying fortune. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi also declare the loss of fortress, horses and men, a separate unit absent from Mohl’s local sequence and not separately translated here. Captive relatives and injured warriors follow in all four. English bleeding specifies the injury. Finally, the world narrowing for a vigilant man becomes closed roads on hostile ground, turning figurative constraint into a concrete logistical predicament.
11–15Mobilization and the strength of the wings
Moscow IV81:1134–1138; Mohl II329:1158–1161, II330:1162; Ganjoor sh18:82–86; Khaleghi III71:722, III72:723–725 and n1.
All four take Piran from the court into recruitment, equipment, payment and movement. English turns the recruiting regions into forts and locates payment in a store, specifying institutions not named in the verses. The assignment of warriors’ places is running text in Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor; Khaleghi omits that unit locally but prints it completely in the apparatus. English therefore has positive support for allocation. On the right, Moscow and Mohl give horsemen able to contend with elephants, whereas Ganjoor and Khaleghi substitute lions. English selects the primary animal but converts fighting capacity into physical size, a consequential change in the comparison. Nastihan’s left-wing lion becoming a lamb in his grasp is common to all four and preserved closely.
16–19Sound, color and the crowded route
Moscow IV81:1139–1142; Mohl II330:1163–1166; Ganjoor sh18:87–90; Khaleghi III72:726–729.
The army becomes visible and audible through instruments, colors, banners and densely crowded animals. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor specify Indian bells, while Khaleghi’s running verse gives the striking of bells without that provenance. English retains the primary detail and adds thunder and cosmic wonder, enlarging the audience for the noise. The shared red, yellow and violet remain exact, though setting the air alight converts color into illumination. All four number the warriors at one hundred thousand; English preserves that assertion without requiring a modern numerical estimate. Horses, elephants, camels and troops then block the way from sea to sea. This narrator’s image of military abundance differs from Afrasiab’s earlier constricted world, which English had also rendered as impassable roads.
20–24Afrasiab inspects and blesses the army
Moscow IV81:1142–IV82:1143 local running gap, IV81 n29 actually printed addition continued on IV82; Mohl II330:1167–1171; Ganjoor sh18:90–91 local gap; Khaleghi III72:730–734.
Mohl and Khaleghi retain the royal inspection and blessing in running text. Moscow passes directly from the crowded route to the marching groups, but its printed addition supplies the departure, individual count, joy and blessing; its continuation also repeats the army total. Ganjoor has the same local running gap without this added passage. English consequently has positive primary support and should not be classified as inventing the scene. It makes Piran’s haste to depart an onward march and turns counting distinguished fighters into assessing strength. Praising Piran’s wisdom narrows a general commendation to a particular quality. The wish for victorious departure and happy return remains intact. The subsequent terrain swallowed by marching groups is shared by all four.
25–29Concealment and the mountain attack
Moscow IV82:1144–1149; Mohl II330:1172–1176 (geography gap1176–1177); Ganjoor sh18:92–97; Khaleghi III72:735–739, III73:740.
All four direct the host away from the ordinary route to a shorter way, conceal its approach and imagine bringing the dense army suddenly upon the enemy like a mountain. English preserves the tactical sequence, but divides general enemy awareness into hearing the approach and learning the ranks. Piran’s first-person intention becomes a collective strike, with design making the planning explicit. The intelligence agents are common to all four; English specifies their object as the Iranian forces. Swift movement toward Gorugard becomes steady progress into a place already marked by war and blood. The following geographical couplet names Sarakhs, Tus and Bavard in Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. Mohl passes directly from advance to the agents’ report, so its previously claimed geographical wording is withdrawn. English omits that unit, which remains separately registered rather than silently standardized.
30–35Intelligence becomes an opportunity
Moscow IV82:1150–1154 and n13; Mohl II330:1177–1182; Ganjoor sh18:98–102; Khaleghi III73:741–745.
All four deliver the agents’ reports privately and describe drinking, full cups and neglected vigilance. English stages private delivery as whispered words in Piran’s ear. Tus sitting still and the unsounded koust are explicit in Mohl and actually printed in Moscow’s apparatus, but absent from the checked Ganjoor and Khaleghi running sequences. English therefore has support for silence, while lack of will supplies an unspoken cause. The report that no mounted lookout was seen becomes the categorical assertion that none keeps watch, strengthening the scouts’ evidentiary reach. Piran summons the chiefs and recognizes an unprecedented advantage in all four. English assigns that opportunity to fortune. His confidence remains a character’s assessment before the attack, not evidence that success is assured.
Source record
Moscow80–82, Mohl329–330 and Khaleghi71–73 facsimiles read. Moscow81 n29 followed across the page break to its actual printed continuation on82;82 n13 first silence couplet and Khaleghi72 n1 complete allocation couplet inspected directly. These are printed apparatus/addition evidence, not notices of unprinted material. Local running gaps bounded by neighboring verse numbers. No appendix evidence invoked; no volume-wide appendix search claimed. Other apparatus variants not needed for this analysis are not exhaustively transcribed or certified.
English14 changes prowess against elephants into size;22 specifies wisdom as the object of praise;31 lack of will is an added explanation;33 strengthens no lookout seen into no lookout keeping watch. English10 turns figurative constriction into closed roads;29 adds war and blood at Gorugard. The geographical source-only verse must not be harmonized across editions. Royal review and silence have positive Mohl and actual printed Moscow support despite Ganjoor gaps. All inherited flags retained.
Selected printed excerpts normalize spacing only. Persian display rows reproduce the captured Ganjoor poem body except English20–23 and31, which display explicitly labelled Mohl running verses. Source-only rows display Ganjoor and record the individual edition differences. No composite Persian is reconstructed. Edition-specific readings and gaps remain explicit in the register.
Selected printed readings
Moscow IV81:1137 second hemistich running text
Mohl II329:1161 second hemistich running text
Khaleghi III72:724 second hemistich running text
Khaleghi III72 n1 actual printed allocation couplet
همی نامزد کرد جای گوان
Moscow IV81 n29 actual printed addition, continuing on IV82
از ایوان بدشت آمد افراسیاب
سپه را یکایک همه برشمرد
که چندست از ایشان سرافراز گرد
Moscow IV82 continuation of IV81 n29, actually printed count and blessing
همه شیرمردان آهن گذار
چنان شادمان گشت و روشن روان
کجا آفرین خواند بر پهلوان
که پیروز رفتی و شاد آمدی
مبیناد چشم تو هرگز بدی
Mohl II330:1167 running text
از ایوان بدشت آمد افراسیاب
Mohl II330:1168 running text
که چندست جنگی سرافراز گرد
Mohl II330:1169 running text
کجا آفرین خواند بر پهلوان
Mohl II330:1170 running text
مبیناد چشم تو هرگز بدی
Mohl II330:1178 running text
ز لشکر نبرخاست آوای کوس
Moscow IV82 n13 first actual printed addition couplet
ز لشکر نه برخاست آوای کوس
Khaleghi III72:726 second hemistich running text
Khaleghi III73:740 running text
ز باورد برخاست آوای کوس
B12.18 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow IV | Mohl II |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV80:1124 running text | II329:1149 running text |
| 2 | IV80:1125 running text | II329:1150 running text |
| 3 | IV80:1126 running text | II329:1151 running text |
| 4 | IV80:1127 running text | II329:1152 running text |
| 5 | IV80:1128 running text | II329:1153 running text |
| 6 | IV81:1129 running text | II329:1154 running text |
| 7 | IV81:1129 running text | II329:1154 running text |
| 8 | IV81:1130 running text | II329:1155 running text |
| 9 | IV81:1132 running text | II329:1156 running text |
| 10 | IV81:1133 running text | II329:1157 running text |
| 11 | IV81:1134; IV81:1135 running text | II329:1158; II329:1159 running text |
| 12 | IV81:1135 running text | II329:1159 running text |
| 13 | IV81:1136 running text | II329:1160 running text |
| 14 | IV81:1137 running text | II329:1161 running text |
| 15 | IV81:1138 running text | II330:1162 running text |
| 16 | IV81:1139 running text | II330:1163 running text |
| 17 | IV81:1140 running text | II330:1164 running text |
| 18 | IV81:1141 running text | II330:1165 running text |
| 19 | IV81:1142 running text | II330:1166 running text |
| 20 | IV81:1142–IV82:1143 checked local running gap; IV81 n29 actual printed addition continued on IV82 | II330:1167 running text |
| 21 | IV81:1142–IV82:1143 checked local running gap; IV81 n29 actual printed addition continued on IV82 | II330:1168 running text |
| 22 | IV81:1142–IV82:1143 checked local running gap; IV81 n29 actual printed addition continued on IV82 | II330:1169 running text |
| 23 | IV81:1142–IV82:1143 checked local running gap; IV81 n29 actual printed addition continued on IV82 | II330:1170 running text |
| 24 | IV82:1143 running text | II330:1171 running text |
| 25 | IV82:1144 running text | II330:1172 running text |
| 26 | IV82:1145 running text | II330:1173 running text |
| 27 | IV82:1146 running text | II330:1174 running text |
| 28 | IV82:1147 running text | II330:1175 running text |
| 29 | IV82:1148 running text | II330:1176 running text |
| 30 | IV82:1150 running text | II330:1176–1177 checked local running gap for geography verse |
| 31 | IV82:1150–1151 checked local running gap; IV82 n13 actual printed silence couplet | II330:1178 running text |
| 32 | IV82:1151 running text | II330:1178 running text |
| 33 | IV82:1152 running text | II330:1180 running text |
| 34 | IV82:1153 running text | II330:1181 running text |
| 35 | IV82:1154 running text | II330:1182 running text |
New Naqqali