Piran’s Night Attack
58 published couplets preserved verbatim;12 substantive notes.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 58 published couplets preserved verbatim;12 substantive notes. |
| Moscow IV | Printed83–87:1155–1213,59 running couplets;actual printed self-reproach addition, Giv/Gudarz exception and son-for-father alternate distinguished from main text. |
| Mohl II | Printed331–333:1183–1241,59 running couplets (PDF337–339). Opening corrected from previous checkpoint’s predicted1184. Earlier emergence;daylight ordering;medical deprivation before Tus/Gudarz. |
| Ganjoor | Forood sh19:1–59,59 digital running couplets. sh19:60–63 belong to B12.20 and are excluded. Direct self-reproach and Siavash armor absent locally. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh III | Printed73–76:746–806,61 running couplets (PDF89–92). Earlier emergence, direct self-reproach, extra daylight Gudarz inspection;actual movement alternate74 n13. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6A silent march and the destruction of herds
Moscow IV83:1155–1160; Mohl II331:1183–1188; Ganjoor sh19:1–6; Khaleghi III73:746–751 and n16.
All four select thirty thousand swordsmen, depart after half the night and retain seven farsangs between the forces. English preserves both numbers but adds naked blades and substitutes karnay for buq among the silenced instruments. The first victims are the herds and their attendants. English calls the herds abandoned, although the subsequent killing of herdsmen shows that loose grazing does not mean complete absence of custody. The taking of many animals and killing of others becomes a claim that many more were killed, introducing a ratio the sources do not supply. The shared declaration of unparalleled bad fortune supports the scale of loss without verifying that ratio. Iranian fortune turns as the shepherds die.
7–11Readiness within the drunken camp
Moscow IV83:1161–1165; Mohl II331:1189–1193; Ganjoor sh19:7–11; Khaleghi III73:752–756.
The approaching black dust becomes a storm-cloud in English, enlarging a shared image of the advance. All four then set the intoxicated camp against Giv awake in his tent and Gudarz alert. English strengthens wakefulness into sobriety and turns some seated, loose-belted men into reclining men without weapons in their hands. The distinction matters because the later English self-reproach specifically invokes wine fumes. The Persian statements of wakefulness do not authorize inventing an intermediate drinking episode to reconcile that sequence. Cries and axe blows startle Giv in every presentation, and a caparisoned horse stands ready outside. English preserves that practical readiness, which enables his immediate movement through a camp otherwise caught unprepared.
12–15Unverified armor and the smoke of self-reproach
Moscow IV83:1165–1167, n19 and unnumbered printed addition after1166; Mohl II331:1193–1197; Ganjoor sh19:11–13; Khaleghi III73:756–757 and n24, III74:758–760.
No checked local witness establishes the donning of a jowshan owned by Siavash. Mohl and Khaleghi do insert Giv’s emergence from the tent before his self-reproach, and Moscow prints emergence alternatives, but those passages do not verify the armor or its owner. That English detail remains unsupported locally. The leopard-like anger at himself is shared by all four, while English adds an inward flame. The subsequent direct reproach is running text in Mohl and Khaleghi and actually printed in Moscow’s addition, with a Ganjoor gap. Its smoke comes from battle in the checked wording. English makes it wine fumes and contrasts drinking with combat. Positive support for the speech therefore does not establish its English causal explanation.
16–20Giv rallies the leaders
Moscow IV84:1168–1172; Mohl II331:1198–1202; Ganjoor sh19:14–18; Khaleghi III74:761–765.
All four bring Giv through darkness to the commander’s tent, but the summons develops differently. Moscow and Ganjoor raise battlefield dust after the command to rise; Mohl and Khaleghi instead ask whether Iran’s warriors are asleep. English follows the dust reading and repeats the imperative, making the alarm more urgent. Giv then goes to his father carrying the ox-headed gorz. English raises it high and explicitly locates his father in a tent. The smoke-like movement around the army and rousing of alert men are shared, although English again substitutes sober for alert. Bijan’s rebuke contrasts warfare with wine. English preserves the garden image of Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi, while Mohl uses the wine cup.
21–25Encirclement, arrows and dawn
Moscow IV84:1175–1179,1182; Mohl II331:1203–1205, II332:1206–1207,1210–1211; Ganjoor sh19:21–25,28; Khaleghi III74:766–770,774.
Moscow and Ganjoor place Gudarz’s looking around within the encirclement verse; Mohl and Khaleghi focus that verse on surrounding forces and battle noise. English follows the latter emphasis and saves Gudarz’s inspection for daylight. All four make the cloud rain arrows and oppose soft pillows below the sleepers to weapons above. English preserves that violent reversal of comfort into vulnerability. Dawn then emerges from the lion’s sign and Giv sees Iranian dead and reversed fortune. English supplies an iron knell and concentrates slaughter into this view. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi also retain a separate blood-soaked battlefield unit, absent from Mohl’s local sequence; its blood image has no distinct English rendering here.
26–31Different sequences within the collapse
Moscow IV84:1174–1175,1180–1182 and n29, IV85:1183,1187; Mohl II332:1208–1213; Ganjoor sh19:20–21,26–29,33; Khaleghi III74:771–774, III75:775–777.
Mohl and Khaleghi place Gudarz’s inspection, the growing enemy and the ants-and-locusts comparison after dawn. Moscow and Ganjoor position the corresponding small-force comparison and inspection earlier. English follows the daylight sequence, avoiding any need to manufacture an additional movement between these views. Its exception for Giv, Gudarz and distressed companions has actual Moscow apparatus support, although the local running texts simply deny available warriors. Torn standards, overturned drums and ebony faces mark the collapse across all four; English softens inversion into the koust lying low. Fatherless sons and sonless fathers become vanished relatives. The turning heaven then appears before flight in Mohl and Khaleghi, as in English, rather than after the riverward movement.
32–37Retreat strips the army of its fabric
Moscow IV85:1184–1189; Mohl II332:1214–1218; Ganjoor sh19:30–35; Khaleghi III75:778–782.
All four combine helpless retreat with abandoned tents, drums and baggage, wounded wings and movement toward Kasa Rud. English redistributes these materials into successive views of flight, equipment loss and staggering bodies. In doing so it turns the wounded right and left formations into men moving on either side, keeping injury but loosening the military structure. The warp-and-woof image survives particularly well: English names the lost fabric as order, making the metaphor immediately legible. Turanian riders follow Tus in hatred and mockery. English makes the mockery audible as curses and jeers. The shared rain of gorz blows falls as from a cloud onto armor; English generalizes the source to heaven and adds an iron knell.
38–42The mountain refuge and the returning army
Moscow IV85:1190–1195; Mohl II332:1219–1224; Ganjoor sh19:36–41; Khaleghi III75:783–788.
The sources deny any firm stand and turn the mountains into a refuge. English joins that movement to exhausted horses and men, adding wounds to the horses and describing the climb as struggle. All four then return an army exhausted by fighting and distance; Khaleghi explicitly places its return at the foot of the mountain. English identifies it as the Turanian pursuers and makes returning mean abandoning the chase. This is a contextual resolution of the army’s identity, not an explicit national label in every corresponding verse. The commander’s relief from Turkish fighting supports the cessation of immediate pressure. The narrative then laments Iranian losses and wounded or bound survivors; English compresses that lament and adds barely successful flight.
43–45Loss, neglect and the direction of mourning
Moscow IV85:1196–1197, IV86:1198 and n1; Mohl II332:1225–1227; Ganjoor sh19:42–44; Khaleghi III75:789–791.
The inventory of absence moves from royal and military possessions to habitable land, capable men and care for the wounded. English retains the primary catalogue, including the crown that Khaleghi’s running list does not separately name. The apparently total loss belongs to the lament’s rhetoric alongside surviving leaders, rather than furnishing a literal independent census. The next relationship differs: every checked running text has fathers weeping for sons, while English has sons mourning fathers. Moscow actually prints the reversed relationship in its apparatus, so the English choice has positive textual support. That support must remain identified as an alternate, not universal agreement. The wounded burning in pain then returns the scene from kinship grief to bodily suffering.
46–49Hidden conduct and reordered reflection
Moscow IV86:1199–1202; Mohl II332:1228–1230, II333:1231; Ganjoor sh19:45–48; Khaleghi III76:792–795.
All four move from the ruined army to the world’s concealed conduct, its veiled play, human greed and the passage from wind to dust. English gives concealment a visible face and hidden heart, replacing the source’s more general division between outward appearance and secret action with an anatomical contrast. It also makes the bondage of greed a consumption of human years. The ordering follows Mohl and Khaleghi, which put greed before wind and dust; Moscow and Ganjoor reverse those two units. English shifts the personal address toward collective humanity and names fate as the unknown agent. The uncertainty of what will happen survives, even though its grammar and explanatory language become more explicit.
50–53Casualties and the transfer of bereavement
Moscow IV86:1203–1208; Mohl II333:1232–1236; Ganjoor sh19:49–54; Khaleghi III76:796–801.
All four report two portions killed and the remaining men returning wounded. English resolves the fraction as two-thirds and turns wounded return into crawling misery. Its immediate placement of absent physicians follows Mohl; the other three position that unit later. English retains bloody tears but omits the accompanying lack of food. The commander’s madness and estrangement from reason are shared. More consequentially, the next source unit explicitly describes Gudarz deprived of son, grandson and homeland before experienced men approach him. English attaches those losses to the arriving veterans instead, shifting the grammatical bearer of bereavement. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi also retain a separate criticism of troops desiring feasting instead of war; Mohl locally omits it, as does English.
54–58Observation replaces failed command
Moscow IV86:1209–1210, IV87:1211–1213; Mohl II333:1237–1241; Ganjoor sh19:55–59; Khaleghi III76:802–806.
The surviving leadership responds with observation and communication in all four presentations. A mountain watcher faces the gathered force, scouts range outward seeking a remedy, and a distinguished Iranian prepares to carry news. English identifies the watched mass as enemy troops and makes the messenger’s ride explicit before his report is specified. The cure metaphor survives even as pain becomes disaster’s tide. The message concerns what the army’s leader has done and the Iranians’ bad day. English names ill fortune as a cause, then closes with vengeance yielding neither gain nor rest. That conclusion interprets the campaign’s wider purpose; the checked closing verses do not separately name vengeance or lack of rest. The distinction preserves evidence without rewriting the English.
Source record
Facsimiles Moscow83–87, Mohl331–333 and Khaleghi73–76 read;Mohl330 rechecked solely to establish the opening boundary. Relevant local apparatus inspected for armor, self-reproach, emergence, surviving heroes and reversed mourning. Moscow83 n19 and unnumbered self-reproach addition,84 n29,86 n1 and Khaleghi73 n24/74 n13 actually printed evidence distinguished from running text. No unprinted addition notice counted as verification. No appendix evidence invoked or volume-wide appendix search claimed. Unused apparatus is not exhaustively transcribed or certified.
English12 Siavash-owned jowshan remains unsupported in checked local evidence. English14 turns battle smoke into wine fumes;English9/19 sober goes beyond awake/alert. English53 transfers Gudarz’s expressly stated losses to the approaching veterans. English58 adds explicit vengeance and lack of gain/rest. English45 son-for-father has actual Moscow apparatus support against all four running texts. Mohl boundary correction: B12.19 begins1183, not1184. B12.18’s stored Mohl geography mapping and subsequent locators need correction: no separate geographical unit occurs after1176;1177 report,1178 silence,1179 drinking,1180 lookout,1181 chiefs,1182 advantage. Prior package retained unchanged;this issue is flagged for the next authorized compilation.
Selected printed excerpts normalize spacing only. Persian display rows reproduce the captured Ganjoor poem body except English14, which displays labelled Mohl1196, and English12, which has no verified local Persian counterpart and no reconstructed text. English26 uses a relocated Ganjoor parallel. Source-only rows display Ganjoor and record the individual edition differences. No composite Persian is reconstructed. Edition-specific readings and gaps remain explicit in the register.
Selected printed readings
Mohl II331:1196 running self-reproach
که مغزم ز پیکار شد پر ز دود
Moscow IV83 unnumbered actual printed self-reproach addition after1166
که مغزم ز پیکار شد پر ز دود
Khaleghi III74:759 running self-reproach
که مغزم ز پیکار شد پر ز دود
Moscow IV84 n29 actual printed exception to loss of warriors
که بودند با رنج در کارزار
Moscow IV86 n1 actually printed alternate first hemistich
Mohl II331:1191 running vigilance
سپهدار گودرز هشیار بود
Khaleghi III73:757 running emergence before self-reproach
به ره بر ندیدند یک کس سوار
Moscow IV83:1165 running horse and caparison
یکی اسپ برگستوانور بپای
Khaleghi III74 n13 actually printed forward-movement alternate
بره بر شتابید چندی سوار
Khaleghi III74:771 running Gudarz inspection after dawn
ز دشمن بیفزود هر زمان سپاه
Moscow IV86:1206 running Gudarz bereavement
نه پور و نبیره نه بوم و نه بر
B12.19 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow IV | Mohl II |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV83:1155 running text | II331:1183 running text |
| 2 | IV83:1156 running text | II331:1184 running text |
| 3 | IV83:1157 running text | II331:1185 running text |
| 4 | IV83:1158 running text | II331:1186 running text |
| 5 | IV83:1159 running text | II331:1187 running text |
| 6 | IV83:1160 running text | II331:1188 running text |
| 7 | IV83:1161 running text | II331:1189 running text |
| 8 | IV83:1162 running text | II331:1190 running text |
| 9 | IV83:1163 running text | II331:1191 running text |
| 10 | IV83:1164 running text | II331:1192 running text |
| 11 | IV83:1165 running text | II331:1193 running text |
| 12 | IV83:1165–1166 checked local gap for Siavash armor; relevant apparatus inspected, no positive reading verified | II331:1193–1195 checked local gap for Siavash armor;1194 narrates emergence, not donning that armor |
| 13 | IV83:1166 running text | II331:1195 running text |
| 14 | IV83:1166–1167 checked running gap; IV83 unnumbered actual printed self-reproach addition after1166 | II331:1196 running text |
| 15 | IV83:1167 running text | II331:1197 running text |
| 16 | IV84:1168 running text | II331:1198 running text |
| 17 | IV84:1169 running text | II331:1199 running text |
| 18 | IV84:1170 running text | II331:1200 running text |
| 19 | IV84:1171 running text | II331:1201 running text |
| 20 | IV84:1172 running text | II331:1202 running text |
| 21 | IV84:1175 running text | II331:1203 running text |
| 22 | IV84:1176 running text | II331:1204 running text |
| 23 | IV84:1177 running text | II331:1205 running text |
| 24 | IV84:1178 running text | II332:1206 running text |
| 25 | IV84:1179; IV84:1182 running text | II332:1207 running text; II332:1210–1211 checked gap for separate blood-soaked battlefield unit |
| 26 | IV84:1175 running text; IV84:1179–1180 checked gap for separate post-dawn repetition; earlier parallel relocated | II332:1208 running text |
| 27 | IV84:1174 running text | II332:1209 running text |
| 28 | IV84:1181 running text; IV84 n29 actual printed Giv/Gudarz exception after1182 | II332:1210 running text |
| 29 | IV84:1180 running text | II332:1211 running text |
| 30 | IV85:1183 running text | II332:1212 running text |
| 31 | IV85:1187 running text | II332:1213 running text |
| 32 | IV85:1184 running text | II332:1214 running text |
| 33 | IV85:1184; IV85:1185 running text | II332:1214; II332:1215 running text |
| 34 | IV85:1185 running text | II332:1215 running text |
| 35 | IV85:1186 running text | II332:1216 running text |
| 36 | IV85:1188 running text | II332:1217 running text |
| 37 | IV85:1189 running text | II332:1218 running text |
| 38 | IV85:1190; IV85:1191 running text | II332:1219; II332:1220 running text |
| 39 | IV85:1191 running text | II332:1220 running text |
| 40 | IV85:1192 running text | II332:1221 running text |
| 41 | IV85:1193 running text | II332:1222 running text |
| 42 | IV85:1194; IV85:1195 running text | II332:1223; II332:1224 running text |
| 43 | IV85:1196 running text | II332:1225 running text |
| 44 | IV85:1197 running text | II332:1226 running text |
| 45 | IV86:1198 running text; IV86 n1 actual printed son-for-father alternate | II332:1227 running text |
| 46 | IV86:1199 running text | II332:1228 running text |
| 47 | IV86:1200 running text | II332:1229 running text |
| 48 | IV86:1202 running text | II332:1230 running text |
| 49 | IV86:1201 running text | II333:1231 running text |
| 50 | IV86:1203 running text | II333:1232 running text |
| 51 | IV86:1207 running text | II333:1233 running text |
| 52 | IV86:1204 running text | II333:1234 running text |
| 53 | IV86:1206; IV86:1208 running text | II333:1235; II333:1236 running text |
| 54 | IV86:1209 running text | II333:1237 running text |
| 55 | IV86:1210 running text | II333:1238 running text |
| 56 | IV87:1211 running text | II333:1239 running text |
| 57 | IV87:1212; IV87:1213 running text | II333:1240; II333:1241 running text |
| 58 | IV87:1213 running text | II333:1241 running text |
New Naqqali