Kay Khosrow Recalls Tus
65 published English couplets preserved verbatim;13 substantive notes.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 65 published English couplets preserved verbatim;13 substantive notes. |
| Moscow IV | Printed87–91:1214–1279,66 running couplets. Divine patience, mountain prediction and both punitive couplets retained in running text. |
| Mohl II | Printed333–336:1242–1306,65 running couplets (PDF339–342). Victory paired with defeat;creation follows. Nails/fetters catalogue has a checked local gap1302–1303. |
| Ganjoor | Forood sh19:60–63 plus sh20:1–62,66 running digital couplets. Both section boundaries explicitly retained. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh III | Printed76–80:807–869,63 running couplets (PDF92–96). Mountain prediction and two punitive couplets absent from running text but actually printed78 n15 and80 n14;patience alternative actually printed77 n14. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–4The defeat renews a brother’s grief
Moscow IV87:1214–1217; Mohl II333:1242–1245; Ganjoor sh19:60–63; Khaleghi III76:807–808, III77:809–810.
All four carry the courier’s news to the Shah, darken the reported fortunes and add grief for the army to grief for the brother. English names Khosrow and makes the second grief specifically a vision of bodies on the plain, narrowing the army’s wider calamity to its dead. Newly slain adds temporal emphasis to the remembered brother. The shared night-long cursing of Tus ends at cockcrow, giving anger duration before the administrative response begins. English directs that wrath toward Tus’s fame, preparing the later public humiliation without a separate source statement about reputation at this point. The sequence preserves the movement from private bereavement through accusation toward an order changing command.
5–9A personal grief enters the royal letter
Moscow IV87:1218–1222; Mohl II333:1246–1250; Ganjoor sh20:1–5; Khaleghi III77:811–815.
The summoned scribe and the king’s overflowing heart establish the letter’s production in all four presentations. English keeps royal authorship and emotional authority without requiring that Khosrow physically perform every written stroke himself. Its wrath in every note intensifies the shared combination of tears, grief and anger. The audience includes Fariborz and the army’s principal men; specifying Kavus as his father clarifies the dynastic relation. Formal praise then interrupts personal anger according to established practice. English ancient adds historical depth to that formula. The invocation connects divine rule with goodness and bestowed standing, but English makes the recipients’ station something they have won, introducing earned merit more explicitly than the corresponding source wording.
10–15Divine gifts and different readings of victory
Moscow IV87:1223–1225, IV88:1226–1228; Mohl II333:1251–1252, II334:1253–1256; Ganjoor sh20:6–11; Khaleghi III77:816–821 and n14.
English combines two distinct editorial choices. Its victory and patience follows Moscow and Ganjoor, while Mohl and Khaleghi’s running text pairs victory with defeat. Khaleghi also actually prints the patience alternative. Yet English places that verse before creation, following Mohl and Khaleghi’s order. The creation catalogue preserves world, place, time and the ant-to-elephant contrast, though elephant in prime changes greatness into a life-stage quality. English then distinguishes granted wisdom, soul and strength from regalia belonging to God, where the source continues a catalogue of divine gifts. Bonds become the circle of sovereignty. The conclusion retains the range from sun to dark earth but turns the Moscow/Ganjoor speaker’s seeing justice into a direct assertion.
16–21The failed mission and renewed mourning
Moscow IV88:1229–1234; Mohl II334:1257–1262; Ganjoor sh20:12–17; Khaleghi III77:822–824, III78:825–827.
All four retain the Kaviani standard and forty golden-shod men before the king recalls sending Tus with the force. English anticipates the explicit first-person sending in its opening formulation. The brother becoming the mission’s first casualty explains why an expedition for vengeance produces renewed grief instead. English makes the death occur in the fray and develops the vengeance motive later. The curse against another such commander belongs to Khosrow’s voice, not the commentator’s independent judgment. Forood remains the support of the warriors, although English replaces his youth with personal absence and bravery. The recollection of paternal grief becomes burning for revenge, followed by uncertainty over friend and enemy. English whom to believe adds distrust to failed recognition.
22–26The forbidden road and the omitted prediction
Moscow IV88:1235–1239; Mohl II334:1263–1267; Ganjoor sh20:18–22; Khaleghi III78:828–831 and n15.
The recalled prohibition names Charam, Kalat and Sepid Kooh in all four sources. English keeps that geographical specificity, adding stone to the mountain landscape and interpreting Forood’s presence with troops as guarding the land. The danger is practical: he cannot identify the approaching force as Iranian or Chinese. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor then predict mountain fighting and the deaths of many chiefs. Khaleghi passes directly to lament in its running text, but actually prints the complete prediction in the apparatus. English therefore has clear primary support despite the shorter running sequence. Descending specifies how battle comes from the mountain; destined night renders the chiefs’ arriving death. The wind image then preserves the charge that Tus destroyed a royal-born warrior.
27–31Sarcasm becomes an order of recall
Moscow IV88:1240–1241, IV89:1242–1244; Mohl II334:1268–1272; Ganjoor sh20:23–27; Khaleghi III78:832–836.
All four imagine how unfortunate Kavus would have been with Tus commanding earlier. The accusation then becomes pointedly domestic: sleep comes during battle, while absence of wine brings agitation. English turns agitation into rising, a bodily consequence more definite than the source states. The following praise of all arts is undermined by the curse on a dark soul; English it seems helpfully signals the sarcasm rather than inventing a new judgment. The letter next demands immediate attention, setting aside food, repose and sleep while Tus is recalled. English redistributes those instructions across two couplets and explicitly opposes the king’s command to private judgment. Their urgency governs execution of the order, rather than an indefinite prohibition on bodily needs.
32–37Authority, counsel and recovery
Moscow IV89:1245–1250; Mohl II334:1273–1277, II335:1278; Ganjoor sh20:28–33; Khaleghi III78:837–841, III79:842.
The replacement command is defined through office and conduct in all four presentations. Fariborz receives the golden shoes and Kaviani standard, while Gudarz is appointed counselor in every affair. English retains that distinction between authority and advice. The prohibition on rushing into battle accompanies abstention from wine and sleep, which English explains through bright judgment and clouded sight. Waiting until the wounded recover then becomes remaining encamped, with zeal added to restored bodily strength. Giv receives the forward role with farr, stature and leopard claws, preserving the combination of royal charisma and animal prowess. Gathering military equipment completes the instructions. English stores specifies supplies, while the prohibition on feasting closes the direct corrective response to Tus’s failures.
38–43The order travels back to the commanders
Moscow IV89:1251–1256; Mohl II335:1279–1284; Ganjoor sh20:34–39; Khaleghi III79:843–848.
The seal authenticates the letter before the messenger is ordered to travel continuously and change horses at each stage. English preserves the practical means of urgency, adding weariness as the reason for replacement mounts. Its plural sealing agent makes the action more collective than the source’s unstated or singular subject. The messenger’s rapid arrival then demonstrates performance of that instruction rather than introducing another event. All four bring the letter to Fariborz, who summons Tus and the heroes and speaks about what has happened. English sharp and clear characterizes the delivery. The named assembly includes Giv, Gudarz and the region’s riders and warriors. Sword and shield supplies equipment that the source’s list of persons does not separately enumerate.
44–49New fruit and transferred regalia
Moscow IV89:1257, IV90:1258–1263; Mohl II335:1285–1291; Ganjoor sh20:40–46; Khaleghi III79:849–855.
The letter’s reading produces a shared image of renewal: a new tree bears fruit for the world. English makes the world itself become the tree, changing the metaphor’s grammar while preserving renewed possibility. The leaders’ blessing of Khosrow is followed by a concrete transfer of standard, drums, elephants and golden shoes. English combines the inventory with delivery to Fariborz, then joins the worthy-to-worthy pairing to the wish for perpetual Nowruz. These remain ceremonial words within the transfer, not evidence of Tus’s inward acceptance. His subsequent taking away of the Nozhari group becomes an assembly of the entire clan in English. The sources then agree on a prompt return from the battlefield to the Shah.
50–55Public disgrace repeats the original warning
Moscow IV90:1264–1269; Mohl II335:1292–1297; Ganjoor sh20:47–52; Khaleghi III79:856–859, III80:860–861.
All four begin the encounter with Tus kissing the ground and Khosrow refusing to look. English substitutes a bow for the specific gesture and makes the refusal an active turning of the gaze. The abuse that follows is public: the gathering witnesses the commander’s humiliation. English dread supplies a possible effect on listeners, while extinguished fame intensifies the wish that Tus’s name diminish among the powerful. The questions about divine fear and shame before warriors retain the ethical challenge, although the watchful eye is an English image. The Charam warning is then repeated face to face. Beginning the king’s vengeance and diminishing Siavash’s lineage forms the accusation’s central reversal; English adds disgrace to that stated loss.
56–58Forood’s strength sharpens the accusation
Moscow IV90:1270–1272; Mohl II335:1298–1300; Ganjoor sh20:53–55; Khaleghi III80:862–864.
All four praise Forood’s exceptional standing before accusing Tus of killing him. English narrows the wider claim that no one was like him to unmatched martial might, fitting the immediate argument. The following army comparison is especially personal: the source measures the slain warrior against an army like Tus or his force. English keeps the scale of the required army but drops the explicit comparison to the addressee, reducing the sting of Khosrow’s humiliation. This remains a royal accusation rather than an independent enumeration of fighters needed to defeat Forood. The next charge contrasts the battlefield with recreation and feasting. English adds drinking and song and describes encampment on the plain, specifying the general revelry in the sources.
59–61Punishment in running text and printed additions
Moscow IV90:1273–1274, IV91:1275; Mohl II335:1301–1302, II336:1303 boundary; Ganjoor sh20:56–58; Khaleghi III80:865–866 and n14.
The city exclusion and assignment to bonds and a bimaristan are common to all four. English madman’s ward selects a contextual institutional meaning within the rebuke, without establishing an exact modern institution. The next denial of a place among freeborn nobles has Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor running support and is actually printed in Khaleghi’s apparatus. English good and true moralizes social standing, while never made its home turns deficient judgment into a lifelong condition. The nails, bonds and fetters catalogue is running text in Moscow and Ganjoor, locally absent from Mohl, and also actually printed in Khaleghi’s addition. English therefore has positive support for the punishment despite unequal running coverage. Wine-cup adds a vessel to wine.
62–65Lineage spares life but does not restore office
Moscow IV91:1276–1279; Mohl II336:1303–1306; Ganjoor sh20:59–62; Khaleghi III80:866–869.
All four identify Manuchehr’s lineage and a white beard as grounds for hope of survival. English generalizes the beard into age and strengthens hope into the assertion that these alone preserve Tus’s life. The alternative is decapitation; English stages it explicitly before the gathering and at his present position. Imprisonment then replaces execution, with bad nature made its guardian. English from this hour emphasizes the sentence’s onset while omitting the source’s explicit permanence. Finally, the king drives Tus away and orders binding, uprooting his joy through the bonds. English directly makes him bind Tus in a cell, specifying both agent and location. The preserved root image closes the loss of freedom without implying restored military authority.
Source record
Moscow87–91, Mohl333–336 and Khaleghi76–80 facsimiles checked, including local apparatus. Khaleghi77 n14 patience alternative,78 n15 complete mountain-fight prediction and80 n14 two punitive couplets read as actually printed evidence. Mohl1302–1303 local gap checked directly. No unprinted addition notice counted as verification. No appendix evidence invoked or volume-wide appendix search claimed. Unused apparatus is not exhaustively transcribed or certified.
English10 uses Moscow/Ganjoor patience while following Mohl/Khaleghi ordering;do not claim all4running agreement. English44 changes new tree bearing fruit for world into world becoming tree. English57 omits direct army comparison to Tus. English60 moralizes freeborn nobles and makes deficient judgment lifelong. English62 strengthens hope of life to assured survival;64 omits explicit forever;65 directly binds rather than ordering bonds. All inherited flags retained, including B12.18 Mohl locator/geography correction for next authorized compilation and B12.19 unsupported Siavash armor.
Selected printed excerpts normalize spacing only. Persian display rows reproduce the captured Ganjoor poem body across sh19:60–63 and sh20:1–62. Each row retains its precise section reference. No composite Persian is reconstructed. Edition-specific readings and gaps remain explicit in the register.
Selected printed readings
Moscow IV87:1224 first hemistich running text
Mohl II333:1251 first hemistich running text
Khaleghi III77:816 first hemistich running text
Khaleghi III77 n14 actual printed patience alternative
به نیک و به بد زو رسد کام و زیب
Khaleghi III78 n15 actually printed mountain-fight couplet
فراوان سران را سرآرد زمان
Moscow IV90:1271 running army comparison
چو تو لشکری خواستی روز کار
Moscow IV91:1275 running punishment catalogue
نه اندر خور تاج و دیهیم و مل
Khaleghi III80 n14 actual printed judgment addition
کجا مر ترا رای هشیار نیست
Khaleghi III80 n14 actual printed punishment addition, first hemistich
Moscow IV91:1276 running lineage and age
ترا داد بر زندگانی امید
Khaleghi III80:868 running imprisonment
همان گوهر بد نگهبان تست
B12.20 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow IV | Mohl II |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV87:1214 running text | II333:1242 running text |
| 2 | IV87:1215 running text | II333:1243 running text |
| 3 | IV87:1216 running text | II333:1244 running text |
| 4 | IV87:1217 running text | II333:1245 running text |
| 5 | IV87:1218 running text | II333:1246 running text |
| 6 | IV87:1219 running text | II333:1247 running text |
| 7 | IV87:1220 running text | II333:1248 running text |
| 8 | IV87:1221 running text | II333:1249 running text |
| 9 | IV87:1222 running text | II333:1250 running text |
| 10 | IV87:1224 running text | II333:1251 running text |
| 11 | IV87:1223 running text | II333:1252 running text |
| 12 | IV87:1225 running text | II334:1253 running text |
| 13 | IV88:1226 running text | II334:1254 running text |
| 14 | IV88:1227 running text | II334:1255 running text |
| 15 | IV88:1228 running text | II334:1256 running text |
| 16 | IV88:1229 running text | II334:1257 running text |
| 17 | IV88:1230 running text | II334:1258 running text |
| 18 | IV88:1231 running text | II334:1259 running text |
| 19 | IV88:1232 running text | II334:1260 running text |
| 20 | IV88:1233 running text | II334:1261 running text |
| 21 | IV88:1234 running text | II334:1262 running text |
| 22 | IV88:1235 running text | II334:1263 running text |
| 23 | IV88:1236 running text | II334:1264 running text |
| 24 | IV88:1237 running text | II334:1265 running text |
| 25 | IV88:1238 running text | II334:1266 running text |
| 26 | IV88:1239 running text | II334:1267 running text |
| 27 | IV88:1240 running text | II334:1268 running text |
| 28 | IV88:1241 running text | II334:1269 running text |
| 29 | IV89:1242 running text | II334:1270 running text |
| 30 | IV89:1243; IV89:1244 running text | II334:1271; II334:1272 running text |
| 31 | IV89:1244 running text | II334:1272 running text |
| 32 | IV89:1245 running text | II334:1273 running text |
| 33 | IV89:1246 running text | II334:1274 running text |
| 34 | IV89:1247 running text | II334:1275 running text |
| 35 | IV89:1248 running text | II334:1276 running text |
| 36 | IV89:1249 running text | II334:1277 running text |
| 37 | IV89:1250 running text | II335:1278 running text |
| 38 | IV89:1251 running text | II335:1279 running text |
| 39 | IV89:1252 running text | II335:1280 running text |
| 40 | IV89:1253 running text | II335:1281 running text |
| 41 | IV89:1254 running text | II335:1282 running text |
| 42 | IV89:1255 running text | II335:1283 running text |
| 43 | IV89:1256 running text | II335:1284 running text |
| 44 | IV89:1257 running text | II335:1285 running text |
| 45 | IV90:1258 running text | II335:1286 running text |
| 46 | IV90:1259; IV90:1260 running text | II335:1287; II335:1288 running text |
| 47 | IV90:1260; IV90:1261 running text | II335:1288; II335:1289 running text |
| 48 | IV90:1262 running text | II335:1290 running text |
| 49 | IV90:1263 running text | II335:1291 running text |
| 50 | IV90:1264 running text | II335:1292 running text |
| 51 | IV90:1265 running text | II335:1293 running text |
| 52 | IV90:1266 running text | II335:1294 running text |
| 53 | IV90:1267 running text | II335:1295 running text |
| 54 | IV90:1268 running text | II335:1296 running text |
| 55 | IV90:1269 running text | II335:1297 running text |
| 56 | IV90:1270 running text | II335:1298 running text |
| 57 | IV90:1271 running text | II335:1299 running text |
| 58 | IV90:1272 running text | II335:1300 running text |
| 59 | IV90:1273 running text | II335:1301 running text |
| 60 | IV90:1274 running text | II335:1302 running text |
| 61 | IV91:1275 running text | II335:1302–II336:1303 checked local running gap for punishment catalogue |
| 62 | IV91:1276 running text | II336:1303 running text |
| 63 | IV91:1277 running text | II336:1304 running text |
| 64 | IV91:1278 running text | II336:1305 running text |
| 65 | IV91:1279 running text | II336:1306 running text |
New Naqqali