Fariborz Asks Piran for a Truce
34 published English couplets preserved verbatim;7 substantive notes.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 34 published English couplets preserved verbatim;7 substantive notes. |
| Moscow IV | Printed91–93:1280–1313,34 running couplets. Additional speaking/listening and month requests actually printed91 nn7,20;first-person threat alternative93n4;wealth-giving in running text. |
| Mohl II | Printed336–337:1307–1342,36 running couplets (PDF342–343). Includes two source-only instructions;weapons and recruitment close the passage. |
| Ganjoor | Forood sh21:1–34,34 running digital couplets. Wealth-giving follows respite;two Mohl instructions absent from bounded local sequence. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh III | Printed80–82:870–904,35 running couplets (PDF96–98). Speaking/listening instruction in running text;month request81n5 and giving alternative82n22 actually printed. First-person blood threat in running text. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5Command becomes a diplomatic commission
Moscow IV91:1280–1284 and n7; Mohl II336:1307–1312; Ganjoor sh21:1–5; Khaleghi III80:870–875.
All four identify Fariborz through royal descent and military standing before he commissions Rohham. English makes the headgear a helmet and gives it an immediate fighting purpose, bringing military readiness into the opening even though the ensuing action is negotiation. It then turns the instruction about name and inherited quality into direct speech. Mohl and Khaleghi include a further direction to speak and listen to Piran, also actually printed in Moscow’s apparatus but absent from its running sequence and Ganjoor. English compresses that fuller exchange into the mission itself. Calling the message peaceful defines its diplomatic purpose without exhausting its warning. The cosmic love and pain follows Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi; Mohl instead pairs war with affection. That difference gives the English opening a broader emotional frame than Mohl’s explicitly martial contrast.
6–8A respite proposed through accusation
Moscow IV91:1285–1287 and n20; Mohl II336:1313–1316; Ganjoor sh21:6–8 and boundary8–9; Khaleghi III81:876–878 and n5.
All four put the condemnation of night attack into Fariborz’s message. English man of worth clarifies its moral pressure, while refusing to shun daylight turns the source’s negative prohibition into a positive image of courage. This is partisan speech after defeat, not an impartial statement of every warrior’s practice. The mutual choice between respite and battle remains intact, although English peace sounds more settled than a temporary pause. Mohl then explicitly asks for a month to restore the wounded; related requests are actually printed in Moscow and Khaleghi apparatus, while Ganjoor proceeds directly to departure. English omits that request here. Its later month belongs to Piran’s reply and must not be counted as preserving Fariborz’s complete original demand.
9–14The envoy crosses the line
Moscow IV92:1288–1293; Mohl II336:1317–1322; Ganjoor sh21:9–14; Khaleghi III81:879–884.
All four carry Rohham from his commander to an outpost, require his identification and send news forward to Piran. English identifies the outpost as Turanian and the requested place as homeland, making the military geography explicit. Its letter has Moscow and Mohl support alongside Ganjoor, although Khaleghi’s departure line names only the message. Rohham’s self-description preserves skill and vigilance, and firm as stone makes the source adjective of solidity into a clear simile. The reporting rider comes like dust in the sources; English gives him a streaming dust-cloud instead, converting comparison into a visible trace of speed. The report then preserves Gudarz’s connection with Rohham by stating sonship directly, keeping recognition central to safe passage.
15–20Courtesy does not erase the dispute
Moscow IV92:1294–1300; Mohl II336:1323–1324, II337:1325–1329; Ganjoor sh21:15–21; Khaleghi III81:885–891.
All four juxtapose Piran’s welcoming order with Rohham’s fear of concealed ill intention. English guarded heart softens that fear into diplomatic uncertainty, and asked his quest makes the hospitable inquiry specifically about the mission. Neither formulation establishes that treachery is actually planned. A more consequential shift comes in Piran’s opening answer: the common phrase says the war or matter cannot be reckoned small. English instead denies wisdom in its making, converting a claim about gravity into a judgment about prudence. Its next line brings the accusation of Iranian initiative forward from the following couplet. The ensuing wolf image and criticism of Tus remain recognizable, but their redistribution should not conceal the altered opening emphasis.
21–24Recompense and an offer through the envoy
Moscow IV92:1300–1303; Mohl II337:1329–1332; Ganjoor sh21:21–24; Khaleghi III81:891–892, III82:893–894.
All four charge Tus with indiscriminate killing and carrying things or people away, then call the reverse a recompense. English identifies the carried-off objects as captives and transforms killing without fear into killing without remorse. Both choices sharpen the accusation but are more specific than the local wording. Its vengeance clause has Moscow and Ganjoor support; Mohl and Khaleghi instead describe the earlier advance as sudden or unexpected. That difference matters because English makes revenge the motive driving the army. The direct address to your side also replaces third-person reporting. Piran’s subsequent invitation is addressed to Fariborz through Rohham: the conditional recognition of command does not promote the envoy or confuse the two men’s identities.
25–29A month with a demand to withdraw
Moscow IV92:1304–1306, IV93:1307–1308 and n4; Mohl II337:1333–1337; Ganjoor sh21:25–29; Khaleghi III82:895–899 and nn14,17–18.
All four offer a month without an attacking horseman and connect the respite with departure toward the Iranians’ own country. English makes the nonattack an observance of peace and personifies time as fulfilling a vow. Its demand to learn one’s worth preserves Piran’s humiliation of his opponents. The final threat combines different source possibilities: Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor tell the opponents to enter battle and request no further time, whereas Khaleghi has Piran threaten battle and streams of blood. Moscow’s printed alternative also supports a first-person threat of direct war. English therefore has evidence for its change of speaker’s agency, but forevermore strengthens the refusal beyond the temporal phrase after this. No single running version supplies the entire English combination.
30–34Honor for Rohham and preparations for war
Moscow IV93:1309–1313 and nn11,15; Mohl II337:1338–1342; Ganjoor sh21:30–34; Khaleghi III82:900–904 and nn21–24.
All four honor Rohham with a robe suited to his standing and return him to Fariborz with a letter. English realizes preparation of the robe as the act of clothing him, then names the reply rather than its written medium. The lion’s reaching claws preserve the commander’s renewed activity during respite. The next English distribution of riches is well supported by Moscow and Ganjoor, which open money-bags and turn to giving. Mohl and Khaleghi instead foreground spears, bows and lassos; Khaleghi actually prints the giving alternative in its apparatus. Their final summons for men is also distinct from Moscow and Ganjoor’s broader preparation. English follows that latter emphasis and strengthens partial provision into equipment for every need.
Source record
Moscow91–93, Mohl336–337 and Khaleghi80–82 facsimiles read directly, including relevant local apparatus. Moscow91 nn7,20 and93 n4;Khaleghi81 n5 and82 n22 are actually printed evidence, not unprinted addition notices. No appendix evidence invoked or volume-wide appendix search claimed. Other local apparatus is not exhaustively transcribed or certified.
English19 changes a statement that the war cannot be reckoned small into absence of wisdom. English21 captives and absence of remorse specify carried-off objects and fearlessness. English23 follows Moscow/Ganjoor vengeance versus Mohl/Khaleghi suddenness. English29 combines a supported first-person threat with another running conclusion;forevermore is stronger. English33 wealth supported by Moscow/Ganjoor and actual Khaleghi alternative;Mohl/Khaleghi running weapons distinguished. Recruitment in Mohl/Khaleghi omitted at34. Earlier flags retained, including B12.18 Mohl correction and B12.19 armor issue.
Selected printed excerpts normalize spacing only. Persian display rows reproduce the captured Ganjoor poem body at sh21:1–34; source-only rows explicitly quote Mohl. Each row retains its precise section reference. No composite Persian is reconstructed. Edition-specific readings and gaps remain explicit in the register.
Selected printed readings
Mohl II336:1309 source-only running instruction
فراوان بگوید وزو بشنود
Khaleghi III80:872 source-only running instruction
بگوید فراوان و هم بشنود
Mohl II336:1316 source-only running month request
که تا خستگان باز یابند هنگ
Moscow IV91 n20 actually printed month request
که تا جنگیان را بود رای جنگ
Khaleghi III81 n5 actually printed month request
که تا خستگان بازیابند هنگ
Mohl II336:1311 second hemistich running text
Moscow IV92:1298 second hemistich running text
Mohl II337:1327 second hemistich running text
Khaleghi III81:889 second hemistich running text
Mohl II337:1331 second hemistich running text
Khaleghi III82:893 second hemistich running text
Khaleghi III82:899 running threat
برآرم از خون لشکر دو جوی
Moscow IV93 n4 actually printed first-person threat alternative
Moscow IV93:1312 running largesse
نهاده همه رای دادن گرفت
Mohl II337:1341 running weapons
ز هر سو سنان و کمان و کمند
Khaleghi III82:903 running weapons
ز هر سو سنان و کمان و کمند
Khaleghi III82 n22 actually printed giving alternative
Mohl II337:1342 running recruitment
ز هر جای مردان همی خواستند
Khaleghi III82:904 running recruitment
ز هر جای مردم همیخواستند
B12.21 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow IV | Mohl II |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV91:1280 running text | II336:1307 running text |
| 2 | IV91:1281 running text | II336:1308 running text |
| 3 | IV91:1282 running text | II336:1310 running text |
| 4 | IV91:1283 running text | II336:1311 running text |
| 5 | IV91:1284 running text | II336:1312 running text |
| 6 | IV91:1285 running text | II336:1313 running text |
| 7 | IV91:1286 running text | II336:1314 running text |
| 8 | IV91:1287 running text | II336:1315 running text |
| 9 | IV92:1288 running text | II336:1317 running text |
| 10 | IV92:1289 running text | II336:1318 running text |
| 11 | IV92:1290 running text | II336:1319 running text |
| 12 | IV92:1291 running text | II336:1320 running text |
| 13 | IV92:1292 running text | II336:1321 running text |
| 14 | IV92:1293 running text | II336:1322 running text |
| 15 | IV92:1294 running text | II336:1323 running text |
| 16 | IV92:1295 running text | II336:1324 running text |
| 17 | IV92:1296 running text | II337:1325 running text |
| 18 | IV92:1297 running text | II337:1326 running text |
| 19 | IV92:1298; IV92:1299 running text | II337:1327; II337:1328 running text |
| 20 | IV92:1299; IV92:1300 running text | II337:1328; II337:1329 running text |
| 21 | IV92:1300; IV92:1301 running text | II337:1329; II337:1330 running text |
| 22 | IV92:1301 running text | II337:1330 running text |
| 23 | IV92:1302 running text | II337:1331 running text |
| 24 | IV92:1303 running text | II337:1332 running text |
| 25 | IV92:1304 running text | II337:1333 running text |
| 26 | IV92:1305 running text | II337:1334 running text |
| 27 | IV92:1306 running text | II337:1335 running text |
| 28 | IV93:1307 running text | II337:1336 running text |
| 29 | IV93:1308 running text | II337:1337 running text |
| 30 | IV93:1309 running text | II337:1338 running text |
| 31 | IV93:1310 running text | II337:1339 running text |
| 32 | IV93:1311 running text | II337:1340 running text |
| 33 | IV93:1312 running text | II337:1341 running text |
| 34 | IV93:1313 running text | II337:1342 running text |
New Naqqali