Tazhav Slays Bahram
59 published English couplets unchanged;12 substantive notes;one source-only row. Title anticipates the fatal outcome;this passage ends with disabling injury and remorse.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 59 published English couplets unchanged;12 substantive notes;one source-only row. Title anticipates the fatal outcome;this passage ends with disabling injury and remorse. |
| Moscow IV | Printed105–108:1494–1550,57 running couplets. Relevant actual printed variants and additions individually distinguished. |
| Mohl II | Printed345–348:1535–1594,60 running couplets(PDF351–354). Fuller arrival/darkness,hunger/duration,and Gudarz destination. |
| Ganjoor | Forood sh23:59–115,57 running digital couplets. Continuation of the same digital section used for B12.23;not sh24. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh III | Printed92–96:1087–1142,56 running couplets(PDF108–112). Hunger/destination run in text;Afrasiab constraint,horse offer,and Tazhav approach actually printed in apparatus. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5A name revealed through enemy testimony
Moscow IV105:1494–1498; Mohl II345:1535–1539; Ganjoor sh23:59–63; Khaleghi III92:1087–III93:1091.
The defeated riders first describe an extraordinary opponent and only then identify him. English preserves that progression, allowing Bahram’s reputation to emerge from enemy testimony rather than from an independent narrator’s praise. Naming Piran immediately clarifies the destination without altering the exchange. The question about rank, however, enlarges a request for identity into a request for standing among the famous. The source image that Bahram illuminates the army becomes the more abstract idea of glory filling its ranks. This retains his collective importance but reduces the visible brightness. Day and night is also an English amplification of tirelessness here, not an additional chronological statement supplied by these five source couplets.
6–9Capture, recruitment, and unrecognized danger
Moscow IV105:1499–1502; Mohl II345:1540–II346:1543; Ganjoor sh23:64–67; Khaleghi III93:1092–1095.
Piran’s immediate objective remains capture alive, an important distinction from Tazhav’s later threat of destruction. English retains that objective and follows the three sources that promise rest for the age; Khaleghi limits the relief to the two armies. The instruction to recruit fighters is less exact. Its description of distinguished, combative men becomes a second description of Bahram’s fame and fiery heart, although seasoned partly preserves the quality of the recruits. The English also replaces Ruyin’s absence of ominous suspicion with eagerness to prove himself. That makes his motivation more active but obscures the narrative warning implicit in his failure to anticipate danger. The omitted assertion that Bahram cannot escape belongs to Piran’s assessment.
10–12Shield, bow, and the disputed mound
Moscow IV105:1503–IV106:1505; Mohl II346:1544–1547; Ganjoor sh23:68–70; Khaleghi III93:1096–1098. Lexical control:Dehkhoda,charkh,bow sense;URL in source record.
All four print the same essential shield arrangement, but the English supplies a mound and takes charkh as the heavens. The bow sense is independently documented in the lexicon and fits the surrounding arrows and defensive equipment more closely; that is an interpretive judgment, not a newly discovered edition variant. No checked wording explicitly names the mound. The added height subsequently shapes shooting below and falling from that mound. Casualty identification also varies: Moscow and Ganjoor wound Ruyin himself, Mohl has him observe wounds among the men, and Khaleghi includes him with individual fighters. English follows the named casualty branch. Mohl’s extra arrival verse darkens sun and moon before the arrow-rain;that separate causal step has no distinct English counterpart.
13–18From military defeat to personal appeal
Moscow IV106:1506–1511,n13; Mohl II346:1548–1553; Ganjoor sh23:71–76; Khaleghi III93:1099–1104.
The failed attack changes Piran’s method from sending troops to approaching in person. English preserves the wounded men’s darkened spirits and the nahang comparison, but hurried replaces the sources’ weak return. The leaf simile follows Moscow, Ganjoor, and Khaleghi rather than Mohl’s branch; storm winds add a cause for the trembling. Piran’s recollection of Siavash then becomes especially consequential. All four running texts retain martial language, whereas English remembers reserve and judgment. Moscow’s printed apparatus actually supplies the wise, wakeful, silent alternative, so that choice has evidence without being the common running reading. The distinction matters because the English prepares a prudent appeal through an explicitly prudent remembered character.
19–24Hospitality, family, and the terms of safety
Moscow IV106:1512–1517,n17; Mohl II346:1554–1559; Ganjoor sh23:77–82; Khaleghi III93:1105–III94:1110.
Bread and salt give Piran’s offer a remembered personal basis before he proposes oath and kinship. English preserves this sequence and makes the later increase in standing concrete as rank and honor. It should not be used to determine a particular marriage arrangement, since the checked offer leaves the mechanism unstated. The threatened grief differs among editions: Moscow and Ganjoor name the loving mother, while Mohl and Khaleghi name lineage and country, also printed as a Moscow variant. English follows the wider collective loss. Its pledge satisfying both hearts makes the offer more reciprocal than the source promise of a way pleasing to Bahram. The closing warning returns from these inducements to the unequal military situation.
25–28Three unfed days and a named destination
Moscow IV106:1518–1519,n24,n28; Mohl II346:1560–1563; Ganjoor sh23:83–84; Khaleghi III94:1111–1114.
The fuller answer is directly supported by Mohl and Khaleghi: Bahram reports three unfed days and continuous combat, asks for a horse, and names Gudarz as his destination. Moscow prints the hunger and destination additions in separate apparatus entries, although neither belongs to its local running sequence. Ganjoor has the shorter address and horse request. The English therefore follows a defensible fuller tradition rather than inventing the whole speech. No drink is more specific than the unfed lips of the printed wording, and the declaration that his duty will be complete is additional interpretation. These three days concern Bahram himself and do not validate the different duration assigned to the wounded kinsman in the preceding subchapter.
29–34The riders’ shame and the speaker’s agency
Moscow IV106:1520–IV107:1525,n4; Mohl II346:1564–II347:1569; Ganjoor sh23:85–90; Khaleghi III94:1115–1120.
Piran grounds his refusal in the dishonor his riders would bear after losing noble companions. English retains that social argument while making him personally responsible for letting Bahram go. It redistributes ancestry, diadems, and casualties across two couplets and attaches blood and dust directly to the fallen bodies. A printed Moscow variant contains blood-soaked ground, but it does not by itself verify that changed grammatical attachment. The final question also moves from a singular person with boiling blood and brain to the anger of the whole band. This is a coherent explanation of collective pressure, yet it should remain identified as interpretation. Keeping my truth similarly adds a personal fidelity motive before the source’s explicit political constraints arrive.
35–38Afrasiab’s constraint and Piran’s divided response
Moscow IV107:1526–1529,n8,n12; Mohl II347:1570–1573; Ganjoor sh23:91–94; Khaleghi III94:1120–1122,n24,n29.
The fear of Afrasiab and the conditional horse offer belong to Moscow, Mohl, and Ganjoor’s running texts. Khaleghi omits them locally but prints both complete couplets in the apparatus, providing actual wording rather than a mere addition notice. English preserves the constraint and adopts the affection reading for Piran’s departure, found in Mohl and Khaleghi and a Moscow variant; Moscow and Ganjoor’s running text instead has rancor. Prudence is the English interpretation of his deliberation. Tazhav’s introduction then presents a separate comparison problem. The main texts vary between a lion opponent and other characterizations. Khaleghi records an elephant-related alternative, but that does not automatically verify the English’s stronger formulation about what no elephant could bear.
39–44Failed persuasion and the threat of crushing
Moscow IV107:1530–1535; Mohl II347:1574–1579; Ganjoor sh23:95–100; Khaleghi III94:1123–III95:1127,n3.
Piran’s report repeats the personal quality of his counsel and Bahram’s determination to reach Iran. English preserves that refusal but interprets Tazhav’s reply as a criticism of ineffective gentleness. The Persian phrase about love of life can instead challenge Piran’s own willingness to face danger; its pronouns and rhetorical target should not be flattened into a verified paraphrase. The threatened crushing of Bahram’s head is shared, while foul brain adds contempt and anatomical specificity. Khaleghi’s running narrative moves directly from the threat to seeing the spear-bearing hero. Its printed apparatus supplies the intervening approach to the battlefield. English’s transitional movement thus has support in all four source accounts, with the evidence classes explicitly different.
45–49A taunt and a materially different weapon list
Moscow IV107:1536–IV108:1540; Mohl II347:1580–1584; Ganjoor sh23:101–105; Khaleghi III95:1128–1132.
The confrontation begins with the spear-bearing Bahram and an elephant-like roar from Tazhav. English makes the acting speaker explicit and follows the one pedestrian against many riders taunt of Moscow, Ganjoor, and Khaleghi; Mohl instead denies any escape from this army. The accusation of severing heads is closer to Mohl’s explicit cutting language than the other presentations’ formulation of delivering heads to death. The command to attack provides a clear instance where Khaleghi supports an English choice against the other three running texts. Its weapon list includes the dagger, while Moscow, Mohl, and Ganjoor have a mace alongside arrows and javelins. Retaining khanjar is therefore an attested selection, not an unsupported substitution.
50–54Exhausted weapons and the direction of wounding
Moscow IV108:1541–1545,n12; Mohl II347:1585–1589; Ganjoor sh23:106–110; Khaleghi III95:1133–1137.
The fighting develops through a precise depletion sequence: arrows run out, the spear breaks, and mace and sword remain. English preserves that progression and the repeated conversion of landscape and sky into blood imagery. Its cloud-directed splashing follows Moscow, Ganjoor, and Khaleghi, whereas Mohl makes the dripping a cloud comparison. The next couplet changes more than imagery. Moscow and Ganjoor describe his arrows wounding many warriors; Mohl explicitly wounds the hero’s body, and Moscow’s apparatus prints that bodily-wounding alternative. Khaleghi’s wording without the possessive allows the wounded-hero interpretation. English therefore has support for Bahram suffering wounds, but the separate injuries to limbs, breast, and head remain unverified elaborations of that general bodily damage.
55–59A disabling blow followed by shame
Moscow IV108:1546–1550; Mohl II347:1590–II348:1594; Ganjoor sh23:111–115; Khaleghi III95:1138–III96:1142,n5.
Exhaustion and the rearward approach make the final blow a culmination of unequal combat. English preserves the shoulder strike, face-first fall, severed fighting limb, and loss of the ability to resist. From the mound repeats an earlier interpretation, however; falling from above does not identify that terrain by itself. The Persian limb term can encompass arm as well as hand, particularly after a shoulder-level strike. The closing emotion belongs to the attacker: painful shame interrupts the victory. English follows the three texts that make his face flare, while Khaleghi’s main text names the heart and prints the face variant below. Despite the published title’s anticipation, this passage narrates disabling injury and remorse, not a completed death.
Source record
Facsimile running text and relevant local apparatus visually inspected:Moscow105–108,Mohl345–348,Khaleghi92–96. Actually printed additions recorded at precise note locators;unprinted notices never used as proof of wording. No appendix evidence invoked or exhaustive volume-wide appendix search claimed. Selected excerpts only,with spacing normalized;not a complete diplomatic transcript. Supplemental lexical control:Dehkhoda charkh entry distinguishes sky and bow senses;the bow interpretation here is analytical inference,not a separate witness.
English10mound/heavens,11below and56mound remain interpretive concerns;martial charkh reading is favored but terrain is not verified. English38exact elephant comparison remains provisional despite an actual elephant-related Khaleghi variant. English42love-of-life pronouns,34collective agency,and54specified wound locations remain flagged. Mohl/Khaleghi fuller hunger and Gudarz destination are supported;do not confuse Bahram’s three days with B12.23wounded man duration. All inherited flags retained.
Selected printed excerpts normalize spacing only. Persian display rows reproduce the captured Ganjoor poem body at sh23:59–115; the English28 parallel is explicitly substituted from Mohl1563,and the Mohl source-only row and selected printed excerpts retain their own edition labels. Each row retains its precise section reference. No composite Persian is reconstructed. Edition-specific readings and gaps remain explicit in the register.
Selected printed readings
Moscow IV105:1503 running shield and charkh
نهاده سپر بر سر و چرخ زیر
Mohl II346:1544 source-only running arrival and darkness
بشد روشنایی ز خورشید و ماه
Moscow IV106 n13 actually printed reserved-character alternative
Mohl II346:1556 second hemistich running collective grief
Moscow IV106 n17 actually printed collective grief alternative
Mohl II346:1561 running hunger and continuous combat
همی رزم سازم به روز و شبان
Moscow IV106 n24 actually printed hunger and combat addition
همی رزم سازم به روز و شبان
Khaleghi III94:1112 running hunger and combat
همی رزم سازم به روز و شبان
Mohl II346:1563 running Gudarz destination
بر پیر گودرز کشوادگان
Khaleghi III94:1114 running Gudarz destination
بنزدیک گودرز کشوادگان
Moscow IV106 n28 actually printed Gudarz addition
بر پیر گودرز کشوادگان
Khaleghi III94 n24 actually printed Afrasiab constraint and horse offer
که گردد سرش زین سخن پرشتاب
ترا بارگی دادمی ای جوان
بدان تات بردی بر پهلوان
Moscow IV107:1528 second hemistich running rancor
Moscow IV107 n8 actually printed affection variant
Mohl II347:1572 second hemistich running affection
Khaleghi III94:1121 second hemistich running affection
Khaleghi III95:1132 second hemistich running dagger list
Mohl II347:1589 second hemistich running wounded hero
Moscow IV108 n12 actually printed wounded-hero alternative
Khaleghi III96 n5 actually printed face variant
Lexical control: Dehkhoda, charkh: sky and bow senses. The contextual preference for bow is an analytical inference.
B12.24 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow IV | Mohl II |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV105:1494 running text | II345:1535 running text |
| 2 | IV105:1495 running text | II345:1536 running text |
| 3 | IV105:1496 running text | II345:1537 running text |
| 4 | IV105:1497 running text | II345:1538 running text |
| 5 | IV105:1498 running text | II345:1539 running text |
| 6 | IV105:1499 running text | II345:1540 running text |
| 7 | IV105:1500 running text | II346:1541 running text |
| 8 | IV105:1501 running text | II346:1542 running text |
| 9 | IV105:1502 running text | II346:1543 running text |
| 10 | IV105:1503 running text | II346:1545 running text |
| 11 | IV105:1504 running text | II346:1546 running text |
| 12 | IV106:1505 running text | II346:1547 running text |
| 13 | IV106:1506 running text | II346:1548 running text |
| 14 | IV106:1507 running text | II346:1549 running text |
| 15 | IV106:1508 running text | II346:1550 running text |
| 16 | IV106:1509 running text | II346:1551 running text |
| 17 | IV106:1510 running text | II346:1552 running text |
| 18 | IV106:1511 running text; IV106 n13 actually printed wise/wakeful/silent alternative | II346:1553 running text |
| 19 | IV106:1512 running text | II346:1554 running text |
| 20 | IV106:1513 running text | II346:1555 running text |
| 21 | IV106:1514 running text; IV106 n17 actual collective-grief variant | II346:1556 running text |
| 22 | IV106:1515 running text | II346:1557 running text |
| 23 | IV106:1516 running text | II346:1558 running text |
| 24 | IV106:1517 running text | II346:1559 running text |
| 25 | IV106:1518 running text; IV106:1518–1519 checked running gap for hunger/duration; IV106 n24 actually printed addition | II346:1560; II346:1561 running text |
| 26 | IV106:1519 running text; IV106:1518–1519 checked running gap for hunger/duration; IV106 n24 actually printed addition | II346:1562; II346:1561 running text |
| 27 | IV106:1519 running text | II346:1562 running text |
| 28 | IV106:1519–1520 checked running gap; IV106 n28 actually printed Gudarz addition | II346:1563 running text |
| 29 | IV106:1520 running text | II346:1564 running text |
| 30 | IV106:1521 running text | II346:1565 running text |
| 31 | IV106:1522 running text | II347:1566 running text |
| 32 | IV107:1523; IV107:1524 running text | II347:1567; II347:1568 running text |
| 33 | IV107:1523; IV107:1524 running text; IV107 n4 actual blood-soaked-ground variant,not exact English predication | II347:1567; II347:1568 running text |
| 34 | IV107:1525 running text | II347:1569 running text |
| 35 | IV107:1526 running text | II347:1570 running text |
| 36 | IV107:1527 running text | II347:1571 running text |
| 37 | IV107:1528 running text; IV107 n8 actual affection variant | II347:1572 running text |
| 38 | IV107:1529; IV107:1530 running text | II347:1573; II347:1574 running text |
| 39 | IV107:1530 running text | II347:1574 running text |
| 40 | IV107:1531 running text | II347:1575 running text |
| 41 | IV107:1532 running text | II347:1576 running text |
| 42 | IV107:1533 running text | II347:1577 running text |
| 43 | IV107:1534 running text | II347:1578 running text |
| 44 | IV107:1535 running text | II347:1579 running text |
| 45 | IV107:1536 running text | II347:1580 running text |
| 46 | IV107:1537 running text | II347:1581 running text |
| 47 | IV107:1538 running text | II347:1582 running text |
| 48 | IV108:1539 running text | II347:1583 running text |
| 49 | IV108:1540 running text | II347:1584 running text |
| 50 | IV108:1541 running text | II347:1585 running text |
| 51 | IV108:1542 running text | II347:1586 running text |
| 52 | IV108:1543 running text | II347:1587 running text |
| 53 | IV108:1544 running text | II347:1588 running text |
| 54 | IV108:1545 running text; IV108 n12 actual wounded-hero alternative | II347:1589 running text |
| 55 | IV108:1546 running text | II347:1590 running text |
| 56 | IV108:1547 running text | II348:1591 running text |
| 57 | IV108:1548 running text | II348:1592 running text |
| 58 | IV108:1549 running text | II348:1593 running text |
| 59 | IV108:1550 running text | II348:1594 running text |
New Naqqali