News of Tus Reaches Forood
53 published couplets preserved verbatim;11 substantive notes;3 source-only rows.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 53 published couplets preserved verbatim;11 substantive notes;3 source-only rows. |
| Moscow IV | Printed37–40:451–495,45 running couplets, including relocated494–495; individually checked printed apparatus distinguished. |
| Mohl II | Printed299–301:455–507,53 running couplets. Selected467 first half-line only; remainder uncertified and unused. |
| Ganjoor | Forood sh4:1–45,45 couplets. Remaining46–51 outside B12.3 scope. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh III | Printed31–34:59–107,49 running couplets, with actually printed apparatus31n6,33n25 and34n2 distinguished. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5News, darkness, and the identity of the speaker
Moscow IV37:451–452,n5; Mohl II299:455–459; Ganjoor sh4:1–2 and transition2–3; Khaleghi III31:59–61,n6.
The darkened sun and the world resembling a sea of nil are common to the four witnesses. English makes the initial report direct speech, specifies dust and selects a Nile comparison. The ensuing identification of the arriving force requires separate statements about content and speaker. Mohl explicitly names Tokhvar before the report of the brother’s army. Moscow actually prints the brother-army and Kalat-destination material in its apparatus, without that named introduction; Khaleghi divides corresponding material between running text and printed apparatus. Ganjoor passes directly to the inexperienced youth’s reaction. English therefore follows a verified fuller sequence, but Tokhvar’s explicit role is supported specifically by Mohl. Dark banners veiling the sky elaborate the source’s uncertainty about where battle will occur.
Return to passage6–11Securing the herds and moving the fortress actions
Moscow IV37:453–456,n6/n14 and IV40:494–495; Mohl II299–300:460–465; Ganjoor sh4:3–6,44–45; Khaleghi III31:62–67.
Forood’s inexperience, pain and darkened spirit precede the protective gathering of livestock in all four presentations. English preserves that vulnerability and gives it the intensified image of an abyss. The fortress actions, however, occupy different positions. Mohl and Khaleghi place the descent and viewing before the herds are gathered and the return and mounting immediately afterward. Moscow and Ganjoor put those actions later, following the watchman’s report; Moscow also prints the earlier placements below the text. English follows the earlier sequence. It omits shutting the gate and adds preparation for counsel. Sepid Kooh and Anboh become two named destinations, while the language of confinement becomes herds spread within bounds. Those choices should not be mistaken for independently verified modern geography.
Return to passage12–17Jarireh’s view and Forood’s appeal
Moscow IV37:457–460, IV40:490 and37n14; Mohl II300:466–471; Ganjoor sh4:7–10,40; Khaleghi III31–32:68–72.
The drums from Charam and the ebony-dark world occur earlier in Mohl and Khaleghi than in Moscow and Ganjoor, and English follows the earlier placement. Mohl then describes a woman seeing dust from the fortress. A separate corresponding viewing verse was not found at the checked Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi transitions. English identifies the woman as Jarireh and makes the Charam dust-cloud her object of sight. The secure evidence used here is the first half-line of Mohl’s viewing verse; its remainder is not certified or quoted. Jarireh’s continuing grief for Siavash is independently shared by all four. Forood’s ensuing appeal preserves the troops, elephants, drums and Tus’s leadership, while specifying a swift attack as the danger to forestall.
Return to passage18–24Kinship, marriage, and the changed second half-line
Moscow IV38:461–474 and local variants; Mohl II300:472–477,484,486; Ganjoor sh4:11–13,20,22–24; Khaleghi III32:73–77,85,87.
Jarireh’s wish that such a day should never be needed becomes a general blessing for fortunate days beneath Heaven. The shared father and Khosrow’s recognition of Forood remain clear. English then follows Mohl in inserting separate praise of Siavash before the marriage recollection; Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi place the corresponding praise later. The marriage couplet contains a substantive departure. All four say Piran first gave Jarireh to Siavash, who otherwise did not seek a wife among the Turks. English replaces that latter statement with a heart that never clashed with rivals. This removes the specific marriage distinction and introduces a claim about temperament or rivalry. The ensuing nobility on both maternal and paternal sides, and the Kayan lineage and appearance, remain substantially preserved.
Return to passage25–28Vengeance, the Roman coat, and animal lament
Moscow IV38:464–468, IV40:488; Mohl II300:478–482; Ganjoor sh4:14–18,38; Khaleghi III32:78–83.
The four witnesses link fraternal vengeance with the cleansing of Siavash’s soul and describe Forood’s obligation as especially fitting when the brother’s target is his own grandfather. English does not separately render that cleansing and alchemical comparison; both source couplets remain in the register. Instead it emphasizes taking the foremost place in the fight, naming Turan as the target and contrasting the new king with the new avenger. The Roman khaftan is retained, while boiling emotion becomes revenge flaming within the spirit. The lament of leopard and nahang also survives, though English pluralizes the creatures and makes pain explicit. The different orders of the vengeance instructions do not alter their common purpose: Jarireh urges participation in the brother’s campaign rather than resistance to it.
Return to passage29–33Peerlessness, public grief, and visible lineage
Moscow IV38–39:469–475; Mohl II300–301:483–487; Ganjoor sh4:19–25; Khaleghi III32:84–88.
The four texts extend mourning into the natural world and praise Siavash through a catalogue of martial, genealogical and royal qualities. English makes the birds’ and fishes’ curse more directly affirmative and repeats the claim of peerlessness across several couplets. Its crowned monarch is more specifically royal than the Persian comparison with a famous mounted warrior. The virtues are broadly retained, with weight or dignity condensed into the selected English qualities. Two further assertions are interpretive additions: all Iran’s grief and a face that visibly proclaims lineage. The source moves from being the son of such a chief to girding oneself for vengeance and fulfilling inherited worth. English turns that inheritance into visible evidence before returning to the imperative to avenge the father.
Return to passage34–37Identifying the chiefs and offering hospitality
Moscow IV39n1 to475 and IV40:485–487; Mohl II301:488–492; Ganjoor sh4:35–37 and transition25–26; Khaleghi III32–33:89–93.
The preliminary question about the commander and foremost chiefs is present in Mohl and Khaleghi and actually printed in Moscow’s apparatus, but not at the corresponding Ganjoor transition. English uses it to introduce a practical programme of recognition and honor. Wine, robes and a feast are shared, although their position is later in Moscow and Ganjoor. Mohl and Khaleghi also list weapons and military equipment as gifts; Moscow prints that catalogue below the text. English omits its specificity and substitutes treasure alongside robes. The statement that the brother is sufficient treasure becomes Khosrow as strength and pride, shifting material metaphor toward emotional support. The instruction not to leave vengeance to strangers is an explicit interpretation of compressed wording, linked to the common call for Forood to lead.
Return to passage38–43Unknown names and two recognizable allies
Moscow IV39:476–481,n7 and IV40:484; Mohl II301:493–498; Ganjoor sh4:26–28,31,34; Khaleghi III33:94–99.
Forood’s problem is practical and relational: whom should he address, who will support him, and why has no greeting or message arrived? English repeatedly names trust, turning the absence of personal acquaintance into an explicit test of reliability. Mohl and Khaleghi introduce two mounted warriors before naming Bahram and Zangeh; Moscow actually prints a comparable two-rider answer in its apparatus, while Ganjoor proceeds to their names without that separate introduction. English follows the fuller form. Calling Zangeh Shavaran’s son supplies a kinship interpretation rather than translating a separate word for son at this locus. The absence of secrets between the heroes and mother and son becomes friendship, a reasonable relational inference that nevertheless states more directly what the Persian leaves compressed.
Return to passage44–47The father’s companions and the size of the party
Moscow IV39–40:479,482–483 and39n8; Mohl II301:499–501; Ganjoor sh4:29,32–33; Khaleghi III33:100–102.
The blessing on Forood’s name and Siavash’s soul accompanies an assurance of the two heroes’ closeness to the father. All four retain the distinction between their kanarang status and his kingship. English gives that relationship the visible action of riding beside the Shah, which the cited couplet does not separately describe. The instruction involving Tokhvar has a numerical difference. Mohl and Khaleghi limit the party with wording about no more than three, and Moscow records corresponding wording in its apparatus beside a simpler main-text instruction to go with him. English specifies Tokhvar as the only aide, selecting a two-person party within, but narrower than, that limit. It then expands the warning not to slight the counsel into two parallel admonitions.
Return to passage48–50Tokhvar’s knowledge and the lion-woman’s counsel
Moscow IV39:480,n9 and IV40:489; Mohl II301:502–504; Ganjoor sh4:30,39; Khaleghi III33:103–104,n25.
Tokhvar’s knowledge of Iran’s great and small, expressed through the shepherd-and-flock comparison, is explicit in Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor. Khaleghi places that couplet in its printed apparatus, while retaining a related identification of warriors in the main text. English distributes the knowledge across two couplets and explains the metaphor through chiefs and their followers. This makes the identification function plain without requiring a literal pastoral scene. Forood’s response retains the striking address lion-woman, but changes the effect attributed to her advice. In the Persian, the counsel makes the family and assembly shine. English says the counsel itself shines with truth before his eyes. The public consequence for lineage becomes the speaker’s personal recognition of its wisdom.
Return to passage51–53The watchman and the disputed endpoint
Moscow IV40:491–493; Mohl II301:505–507; Ganjoor sh4:41–43; Khaleghi III33–34:105–107,n2.
The watchman’s report is shared: the terrain is full of troops and the sun seems imprisoned. English’s grim tidings and repeated darkening strengthen the connection with the opening alarm. The final extent of the army requires attention to the printed wording rather than a single harmonized place name. Moscow and Ganjoor give Gang; Mohl’s phrase includes dar-ab with Gang, while Khaleghi’s main line has different wording involving the length of stone and records Gang and Jang forms among the variants. English chooses Jang and presents it as a distant desert endpoint. The collation supports its relation to a printed variant, but does not establish a modern geographical identification. Elephants and fighting men remain common to all four presentations.
Return to passageSource-only verses
| Evidence and placement | Persian |
|---|---|
Ganjoor Forood sh4:14: source-only vengeance rationale IV38:464 main · II300:478 main · Ganjoor: forood/sh4:14 · III32:78 main Brother’s vengeance cleanses Siavash’s soul. | برادرت گر کینه جوید همی روان سیاوش بشوید همی |
Ganjoor Forood sh4:15: source-only vengeance rationale IV38:465 main · II300:481 main · Ganjoor: forood/sh4:15 · III32:80 main Vengeance against the grandfather makes Forood’s obligation especially fitting and precious/alchemical; not separately rendered in English. | گر او کینه جوید همی از نیا ترا کینه زیباتر و کیمیا |
Mohl II301:490 main (display reference) IV39n1 to475: actually printed equipment-gift addition · II301:490 main · Ganjoor: sh4:35–36 no equipment catalogue · III33:91 main Swords, helmets, horse armor, khaftans and Indian daggers specify gifts; English supplies robes and treasure but omits this equipment catalogue. | ز شمشیر و از ترگ و برگستوان ز خفتان و از خنجر هندوان |
Source record and limits
No appendix reading is used. Inherited Moscow IV315–322 appendix inspection concerns later episodes; no positive evidence for this chapter is claimed from it. No unprinted addition notice counts as verification.
Mohl II300:467: only the first half-line about a woman seeing dust from the fortress is quoted and used; the second half-line remains uncertified. Selected excerpts are not complete diplomatic transcriptions. Checked local gaps do not establish absence from all manuscripts or appendices. Place-name and species identifications are not independently certified. All earlier flags remain;
Running text, printed apparatus, appendix evidence, checked local gaps and unverified readings remain distinct. No unprinted addition notice establishes a positive reading.
Selected printed readings
| Evidence and placement | Persian |
|---|---|
| Mohl II299:457 selected reading | تخوار بدو گفت کای نو جوان تو گر می ندانی همی من بدان |
| Mohl II299:458 selected reading | سپاه برادرت از ایران زمین همی سوی توران گراید بکین |
| Mohl II299:459 selected reading | براه کلاتست آهنگشان ندانم کجا اوفتد جنگشان |
| Mohl II300:467 selected reading (first half-line only; remainder not certified or used) | زنی از دژ اندر چو گرد بدید |
| Mohl II300:475 selected reading | بگیتی شهی چون سیاوش نبود |
| Mohl II301:488 selected reading | بلشکر نگه کن که سالار کیست وز آن مهتران نامبردار کیست |
| Mohl II301:496 selected reading | جریره چنین گفت با گرد پور که چون گرد لشکر ببینی ز دور |
| Mohl II301:490 main (display reference) | ز شمشیر و از ترگ و برگستوان ز خفتان و از خنجر هندوان |
B12.3 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow IV | Mohl II |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV37:451 main | II299:455 main |
| 2 | IV37:452 main | II299:456 main |
| 3 | IV37n5: printed brother-army addition; Tokhvar not named | II299:457 main |
| 4 | IV37n5: actually printed brother-army addition | II299:458 main |
| 5 | IV37n5: actually printed Kalat/destination addition | II299:459 main |
| 6 | IV37:453 main | II299:460 main |
| 7 | IV40:494 main | II299:461 main |
| 8 | IV37:454 main | II300:462 main |
| 9 | IV37:455 main | II300:463 main |
| 10 | IV37:456 main | II300:464 main |
| 11 | IV40:495 main | II300:465 main |
| 12 | IV40:490 main | II300:466 main |
| 13 | IV37:456–457 and local apparatus checked gap for separate woman-viewing verse | II300:467 main |
| 14 | IV37:457 main | II300:468 main |
| 15 | IV37:458 main | II300:469 main |
| 16 | IV37:459 main | II300:470 main |
| 17 | IV37:460 main | II300:471 main |
| 18 | IV38:461 main | II300:472 main |
| 19 | IV38:462 main | II300:473 main |
| 20 | IV38:463 main | II300:474 main |
| 21 | IV38:470 main, later praise; no separate earlier praise verse | II300:475 main |
| 22 | IV38:472 main | II300:476 main |
| 23 | IV38:473 main | II300:477 main |
| 24 | IV38:474 main | II300:486 main |
| 25 | IV40:488 main | II300:479 main |
| 26 | IV38:466 main | II300:480 main |
| 27 | IV38:467 main | II300:479 main |
| 28 | IV38:468 main | II300:482 main |
| 29 | IV38:469 main; IV38:470 main | II300:483 main; II300:484 main |
| 30 | IV38:470 main; IV38:471 main | II300:484 main; II300:485 main |
| 31 | IV38:471 main | II300:485 main |
| 32 | IV38:474 main | II300:486 main |
| 33 | IV39:475 main | II301:487 main |
| 34 | IV39n1 to475: actually printed inquiry | II301:488 main |
| 35 | IV40:485 main | II301:489 main |
| 36 | IV40:485 main; IV40:486 main | II301:489 main; II301:491 main |
| 37 | IV40:486 main; IV40:487 main | II301:491 main; II301:492 main |
| 38 | IV39:476 main | II301:493 main |
| 39 | IV39:477 main; IV39:478 main | II301:494 main; II301:495 main |
| 40 | IV39:478 main | II301:495 main |
| 41 | IV39n7 to478: actually printed two-rider answer | II301:496 main |
| 42 | IV39:481 main | II301:497 main |
| 43 | IV40:484 main | II301:498 main |
| 44 | IV39:482 main | II301:499 main |
| 45 | IV40:483 main | II301:500 main |
| 46 | IV39:479 main | II301:501 main |
| 47 | IV39:479 main | II301:501 main |
| 48 | IV39:480 main | II301:503 main; II301:502 main |
| 49 | IV39:480 main | II301:503 main; II301:502 main |
| 50 | IV40:489 main | II301:504 main |
| 51 | IV40:491 main | II301:505 main |
| 52 | IV40:492 main | II301:506 main |
| 53 | IV40:493 main | II301:507 main |
New Naqqali