Tus Battles Forood
50 published couplets verbatim;10 substantive notes;3 source-only rows.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 50 published couplets verbatim;10 substantive notes;3 source-only rows. |
| Moscow IV | Printed52–55:685–732,48 running couplets;701 bracketed. Relevant printed apparatus checked, including praise addition at54 n20. |
| Mohl II | Printed310–312:696–746,51 running couplets individually accounted for;720,723,741 source-only,736 acclamation aligns English40. |
| Ganjoor | Forood sh9:17–21,sh10:1–16,sh11:1–27:48 couplets;sh11:22 source-only. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh III | Printed44–47:283–330,48 running couplets;305,308,325 source-only. Royal grief and retreat in actually printed45 nn27–28; acclamation47 n15. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5Grief becomes an armed advance
Moscow IV52:685–689; Mohl II310:696–700; Ganjoor sh9:17–21; Khaleghi III44–45:283–287.
All four sources move from the army’s cry and the removal of helmets to Tus’s grief, hurried arming and immense mounted presence. English preserves this progression and the mountain borne by an elephant, so the approaching commander already seems to match the terrain. It also supplies emotional explanations: the warriors are grieving, the trembling combines rage and sorrow, and Tus mounts in warlike pride. These additions make visible gestures into more explicit psychological narration. The source places smoke in his head; English makes it obscure his sight, suggesting impaired perception. Similarly, the turn toward Forood becomes a turn toward the mountain height. The resulting scene retains the direction of attack while strengthening the landscape and its connection to anger.
Return to passage6–9A warning to close the gate
Moscow IV52:690–693; Mohl II310:701–704; Ganjoor sh10:1–4; Khaleghi III45:288–291.
Tokhvar’s mountain approaching a mountain continues the preceding simile in all four witnesses. English maintains that link and gives it explicit upward motion. The experienced nahang remains a metaphor for Tus, while the statement that Forood cannot withstand him becomes a direct warning that a challenge will end in defeat. The proposed refuge is more specific in Persian: the speakers should close the fortress gate firmly and see what fate brings. English directs Forood to withdraw and remain, losing the shared gate-closing action but retaining the uncertain future. The final reminder identifies both dead relatives. Its prohibition concerns feasting now; English nevermore extends the warning beyond this immediate crisis and lends it the sound of a permanent sentence.
Return to passage10–13Encouragement replaced by a threat to the foes
Moscow IV52–53:694–697; Mohl II310:705–708; Ganjoor sh10:5–8; Khaleghi III45:292–295.
Forood’s sharp response asks what difference the opponent’s identity makes when battle comes, ranging from Tus to formidable animals. English turns that comparison into a possible array arriving with Tus. More consequentially, the source then insists that a man should be given heart in battle rather than having his fire damped. English omits that demand for encouragement and assigns the flower-casting action to the foes. The printed word for the material placed on the fire is unvocalized; these pages alone do not certify the flower reading rather than mud. All four preserve the encouragement clause, making the shift in agency independently visible. Tokhvar’s response about kings respecting speech remains, but English praises both adviser and kings as wise where the source does not make both judgments.
Return to passage14–19Numbers, royal grief and the retreat order
Moscow IV53:698–703,701 bracketed; Mohl II310:709–714; Ganjoor sh10:9–14; Khaleghi III45:296–299,nn27–28.
The solitary rider, even imagined as iron and capable of uprooting rock, faces thirty thousand Iranians in all four presentations. English redistributes the solitary premise after the feat and adds a second feat of splitting a hill. The threatened destruction of fortress, stone and earth remains, although plain changes the mountain setting. The warning about harm to Tus bringing distress to Khosrow has a different status across editions: Moscow brackets it in running text, Mohl and Ganjoor print it normally, and Khaleghi prints the actual addition in a footnote. Khaleghi likewise places the retreat instruction in printed apparatus. English retains both warnings, intensifies royal distress into heartbreak, and compresses the irreparable damage to Siavash’s vengeance with the command not to shoot.
Return to passage20–21The narrator judges the delayed advice
Moscow IV53:704–705; Mohl II310–311:715–716; Ganjoor sh10:15–16; Khaleghi III46:300–301.
All four witnesses interrupt the exchange to condemn the adviser for failing to say earlier what needed to be said. This is a judgment about timing: the preceding speech has now supplied the warning, but too late. English concealed captures the active withholding, whereas never was revealed risks making the omission absolute despite the speech just heard. The next couplet gives the result through a bitter accounting image, with war as gain and life as loss for the person advised. English makes war itself gain profit, transferring the grammatical emphasis from the victim’s disastrous balance to war’s personified success. Precious explicitly values the lost life. The incompetent adviser remains the cause in both presentations, preserving the narrator’s interruption of heroic action with criticism of counsel.
Return to passage22–24The watching women and the cost of retreat
Moscow IV53:706–708 and nn20–23; Mohl II311:717–720; Ganjoor sh11:1–3; Khaleghi III46:302–305 and nn4–14.
The number is a genuine edition difference: Moscow and Ganjoor give seventy attendants, while Mohl and Khaleghi give eighty. English follows the latter. It combines the number with the moon-faced description, omits the prosperous fortress, and adds fear. The watching women are compared with Chinese silk in Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi; Mohl’s separate rooftop description uses stars. English retains neither comparison and adds continual eager watching and talk filling the fortress. The checked lines do not independently supply that conversation. Forood’s distress at retreating before them becomes an explicit inability to flee without staining his name. That renders the social pressure directly, but changes unease into prohibition. Mohl and Khaleghi then add a distinct rein-and-arrow preparation that English does not separately narrate.
Return to passage25–30Spare Tus, shoot the horse
Moscow IV53–54:709–713 and IV54 n1; Mohl II311:721–726; Ganjoor sh11:4–8; Khaleghi III46:306–311.
Tokhvar’s conditional advice distinguishes harming Tus from felling his horse in all four sources. English makes the distinction explicitly lethal, directing Forood to preserve Tus’s life, and adds first, which can suggest sequence rather than an alternative target. A single Persian couplet about his allotted time and one arrow becomes two English couplets, expanding the possibility of survival into repeated statements about fate not yet calling him. Mohl and Khaleghi also include a warning about difficult fighting on foot; Moscow prints corresponding additions in apparatus, while Ganjoor has no separate unit at that location. Mohl and Khaleghi emphasize the certainty of the following group’s arrival. Finally, all four mention Tus’s tense brows and Forood’s inability to withstand him. English instead describes an army’s rising tide and archers. No archer reading is verified here.
Return to passage31–36The dismounted commander and the taunt
Moscow IV54:714–719; Mohl II311:727–732; Ganjoor sh11:9–14; Khaleghi III46–47:312–317.
Forood hears the advice, strings and draws his bow, and shoots the horse in all four witnesses. English supplies deadly strength and makes the fitting horseman’s shot one that nobody could bear. Its poplar renders khadang, but this collation does not independently certify the botanical equivalence. The horse’s death and Tus’s return on foot, dusty and bewildered with shield at his neck, remain closely aligned. English interprets the wind in Tus’s head as wrath binding his senses. Forood’s taunts follow him in the sources; English pursued can suggest a physical chase beyond that relation. The challenge to his ability to stride into battle becomes a question about leading armies, sharpening the humiliation of a commander defeated by a single rider.
Return to passage37–42Mockery above and relief below
Moscow IV54–55:720–723 and IV54 n20; Mohl II311:733–737; Ganjoor sh11:15–18; Khaleghi III47:318–321 and n15.
The women laugh at an old man tumbling before a youth through fear of an arrow. English keeps the age imbalance through stripling but omits the explicit old man and arrow cause, adding a general exclamation of disgrace. It locates the taunts on high walls rather than retaining the source’s Charam wording; Mohl differs at that word. The grieving warriors then meet Tus. English’s separate acclamation has support in Mohl’s running text and actually printed additions in Moscow and Khaleghi, although Ganjoor moves directly from their approach to relief at his safe return. Calling this prayer interprets praise rather than establishing a distinct ritual. English further supplies level ground and continued leadership, expanding the shared assurance that tears are unnecessary because he is alive.
Return to passage43–50Giv separates loyalty from acquiescence
Moscow IV55:724–732; Mohl II311–312:738–746; Ganjoor sh11:19–27; Khaleghi III47:322–330.
Giv’s distress at the commander’s return on foot opens an argument shared by all four witnesses: royal status does not excuse contempt for an army. English generalizes the earrings into gems and gold and makes the chiefs’ altered faces explicitly pale with shame. A separate refusal to agree with whatever Forood says has no distinct English counterpart and is retained in the source-only register. The criticism of Tus’s rashness remains, balanced against the wider suffering caused by Forood. Loyalty to Siavash and refusal to forget the wrong are expanded into two English couplets. The named dead are then compressed into one. Finally, English turns descent from Jam into claimed blood and adds a shameful flame to the source’s charge that ignorance opened the war.
Return to passageSource-only verses
| Evidence and placement | Persian |
|---|---|
Mohl720 / Khaleghi305: rein and arrow IV53 n23 after708 actually printed related couplet; absent as separate running verse · II311:720 main · Ganjoor: No separate couplet between sh11:3–4 (bounded gap) · III46:305 main Selected first hemistich of Khaleghi305; second differs from Mohl720. Khaleghi puts shaft in hand and bow, Mohl has shaft held in the bow. English omits this distinct preparation before renewed advice. | عنان برگرایید و بفشارد ران |
Mohl723 / Khaleghi308: dismounted army IV54 n1 after710 actually printed addition variants; absent as separate running verse · II311:723 main · Ganjoor: No separate couplet between sh11:5–6 (bounded gap) · III46:308 main Selected first hemistich of Khaleghi308; Mohl speaks of kings, Khaleghi of Iran. Both warn about difficult fighting on foot; no separate English counterpart. | کز ایران پیاده نسازند جنگ |
Ganjoor Forood sh11:22: refusing agreement IV55:727 main · II312:741 main · Ganjoor: forood/sh11:22 · III47:325 main All four reject agreement with whatever story/argument he offers; no distinct English couplet. English48 retains refusal to forget the wrong from the later shared Siavash verse, not this entire unit. | نباید که باشیم همداستان به هر گونهای کو زند داستان |
Source record and limits
No appendix evidence used. Running text and relevant apparatus read directly at Moscow IV52–55, Mohl II310–312, Khaleghi III44–47. No unprinted addition notice verifies a reading. Local gaps are bounded by the named adjacent passages, not edition-wide absence claims.
Unvocalized گل does not independently certify English flowers; the encouragement/agency change is documented separately. No archer reading verified for English30: all four print brows. Poplar/khadang botanical equivalence remains uncertified.
Running text, printed apparatus, appendix evidence, checked local gaps and unverified readings remain distinct. No unprinted addition notice establishes a positive reading.
Selected printed readings
| Evidence and placement | Persian |
|---|---|
| Moscow IV53:701, bracketed running couplet | وگر طوس را زین گزندی رسد به خسرو ز دردش نژندی رسد |
| Khaleghi III45 n27 after298, printed addition, first hemistich | و گر طوس را زین گزندی رسد |
| Khaleghi III45 n28 after299, printed addition, first hemistich | بگردان عنان و مینداز تیر |
| Khaleghi III46:302, second hemistich (eighty) | به دژ بر پرستنده هشتاد بود |
| Mohl II311:736, running acclamation | گرفتند یک یک برو آفرین که ای نامور پهلوان زمین |
| Khaleghi III46:311, second hemistich (brows) | ندیدی بروهای پرتاب اوی |
B12.9 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow IV | Mohl II |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV52:685 main | II310:696 main |
| 2 | IV52:686 main | II310:697 main |
| 3 | IV52:687 main | II310:698 main |
| 4 | IV52:688 main | II310:699 main |
| 5 | IV52:689 main | II310:700 main |
| 6 | IV52:690 main | II310:701 main |
| 7 | IV52:691 main | II310:702 main |
| 8 | IV52:692 main | II310:703 main |
| 9 | IV52:693 main | II310:704 main |
| 10 | IV52:694 main | II310:705 main |
| 11 | IV52:695 main | II310:706 main |
| 12 | IV52:695 main; IV53:696 main | II310:706 main; II310:707 main |
| 13 | IV53:697 main | II310:708 main |
| 14 | IV53:698 main | II310:709 main |
| 15 | IV53:698 main; IV53:699 main | II310:709 main; II310:710 main |
| 16 | IV53:699 main | II310:710 main |
| 17 | IV53:700 main | II310:711 main |
| 18 | IV53:701 bracketed running text | II310:712 main |
| 19 | IV53:702 main; IV53:703 main | II310:713 main; II310:714 main |
| 20 | IV53:704 main | II310:715 main |
| 21 | IV53:705 main | II311:716 main |
| 22 | IV53:706 main; IV53:707 main | II311:717 main; II311:718 main |
| 23 | IV53:707 main | II311:718 main |
| 24 | IV53:708 main | II311:719 main |
| 25 | IV53:709 main | II311:721 main |
| 26 | IV54:710 main | II311:722 main |
| 27 | IV54:711 main | II311:724 main |
| 28 | IV54:711 main | II311:724 main |
| 29 | IV54:712 main | II311:725 main |
| 30 | IV54:713 main | II311:726 main |
| 31 | IV54:714 main | II311:727 main |
| 32 | IV54:715 main | II311:728 main |
| 33 | IV54:716 main | II311:729 main |
| 34 | IV54:717 main | II311:730 main |
| 35 | IV54:718 main | II311:731 main |
| 36 | IV54:719 main | II311:732 main |
| 37 | IV54:720 main | II311:733 main |
| 38 | IV54:721 main | II311:734 main |
| 39 | IV54:722 main | II311:735 main |
| 40 | IV54 n20 after722, actually printed acclamation variants; absent as separate running verse | II311:736 main |
| 41 | IV55:723 main | II311:737 main |
| 42 | IV55:723 main | II311:737 main |
| 43 | IV55:724 main | II311:738 main |
| 44 | IV55:725 main | II311:739 main |
| 45 | IV55:726 main | II311:740 main |
| 46 | IV55:728 main | II312:742 main |
| 47 | IV55:729 main | II312:743 main |
| 48 | IV55:729 main | II312:743 main |
| 49 | IV55:730 main; IV55:731 main | II312:744 main; II312:745 main |
| 50 | IV55:732 main | II312:746 main |
New Naqqali