The Retreat to Mount Hamavan
31 published couplets unchanged; seven substantive notes.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 31 published couplets unchanged; seven substantive notes. |
| Moscow IV | Printed141–143:415–447,33 running units. Actual local apparatus at142 n26 supports the earlier Turanian battle. |
| Mohl III | Printed21–22:422–455,34 running units; PDF27–28. Fuller lament runs at440–442. |
| Ganjoor | Kamus sh6:72–103 and sh7:1,33 running units. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh III | Printed131–133:420–450,31 running units; PDF147–149. Actual additions at132 n19 and133 n11 distinguished from running text. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5Nightfall and Piran’s confidence
Moscow IV141:415–418, IV142:419; Mohl III21:422–426; Ganjoor sh6:72–76; Khaleghi III131:420–424.
Moscow printed p.141 · Moscow printed p.142 · Mohl printed p.21 · Khaleghi printed p.131 · Ganjoor sh6:72
The retreat begins with grief for relatives and shame in Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. Bowed heads makes shame visible, while comrades broadens the kinship reference. Laid below can suggest men lying dead, but should not be read as completed burial: Tus orders burial later. The moon’s victorious kingship and turquoise throne survive strongly in English, followed by a yellow jewel sea washing the lapis sky. Topaz gives that color image an accessible English form without requiring a mineralogical identification. Piran’s confidence concerns the enemy’s few survivors; Khaleghi names the enemy explicitly where the other readings use a pronoun. For us to fear adds a psychological gloss. More consequentially, like mine makes his threat of grief to the Shah a comparison with his own bereavement. None of the four inspected readings or relevant local apparatus establishes that personal comparison here. The threat itself remains firmly supported.
6–10Celebration beside a field of bodies
Moscow IV142:420–424; Mohl III21:427–431; Ganjoor sh6:77–81; Khaleghi III131:425–426, III132:427–429.
Moscow printed p.142 · Mohl printed p.21 · Khaleghi printed p.131 · Khaleghi printed p.132 · Ganjoor sh6:77
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all oppose a rejoicing army’s music to fathers mourning sons. English preserves the chang and rabab and the sleeplessness they cause, but redistributes the pavilion setting and the following music across two couplets. Its next transition likewise brings the field’s dead, wounded and blood into the fathers’ lament before returning to the same field in the next couplet. These overlaps are intelligible narrative compression, not extra source verses. None was claimed is more difficult: the checked texts say that noble blood washes the ground, not that no body was claimed. The later recovery of wounded men and command to bury the dead do not retrospectively supply that universal assertion. The severed hands and feet then obstruct even a single step in all four accounts. English retains this concrete consequence of slaughter particularly well, allowing the physical scene to carry the horror.
11–15Care, captivity and the sound of grief
Moscow IV142:425–429; Mohl III21:432–436; Ganjoor sh6:82–86; Khaleghi III132:430–434 and n12.
Moscow printed p.142 · Mohl printed p.21 · Khaleghi printed p.132 · Ganjoor sh6:82
The wounded are lifted throughout the night, while the outsider is left in contempt in all four sources. Within the opposed armies, English foe is a reasonable resolution of that outsider; without relief emphasizes the withheld care while softening the contempt. Fire, binding and stitching are all present, so seared defensibly renders the treatment without inventing a second episode. The wounded, dead and bound members of Gudarz’s family are also common to Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi, although went away adds movement to the captive condition. The sound surrounding his cry varies. Moscow and Ganjoor name horses’ noise; Mohl names their hoofs; Khaleghi’s running text has their cry, while its apparatus actually prints the horses reading. English horses thundered by therefore has specific primary support in Mohl’s physical image. The chiefs’ torn garments and Gudarz’s dust-covered head then restore a shared sequence of mourning gestures.
16–19A lifetime in the khaftan
Moscow IV142:430–433 and inspected local apparatus; Mohl III21:437, III22:438–440; Ganjoor sh6:87–90; Khaleghi III132:435–438 and n19 unit2.
Moscow printed p.142 · Mohl printed p.21 · Mohl printed p.22 · Khaleghi printed p.132 · Ganjoor sh6:87
Gudarz’s old age makes survival unbearable because he sees his sons dead. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi agree on this reversal of the expected order of generations. English white and silver hair makes his age visible, while despair belongs to the grieving voice rather than establishing what the slain themselves felt. The khaftan never loosened since birth expresses an entire life spent in service; the English preserves the source’s deliberate hyperbole. The following sons-and-grandsons couplet needs a different evidentiary account. It runs in Mohl as a statement that his descendants were his companions in battle. Moscow and Ganjoor have a checked local gap for that distinct verse. Khaleghi’s running text also lacks it, but the actual four-verse addition printed in its apparatus includes related riders-and-kin wording as its second unit. That is supporting apparatus evidence, with different phrasing, not a Khaleghi running verse or an inferred appendix reading.
20–22The fuller lament and Bahram’s loss
Moscow IV142:433–434, n26 unit2; IV143:435–436; Mohl III22:441–445; Ganjoor sh6:90–93; Khaleghi III132:438–440, n19 unit3.
Moscow printed p.142 · Moscow printed p.143 · Mohl printed p.22 · Khaleghi printed p.132 · Ganjoor sh6:90
English draws on a fuller lament than the running sequences of Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi alone would suggest. Mohl explicitly recalls the first Turanian battle and the loss of Gudarz’s seed; Moscow actually prints that verse in its apparatus. The general sight of slain sons in the other running texts is not equivalent verification of this earlier-battle claim. English omits first, so that Turanian fray can sound like the present disaster rather than a retrospective reference. Bahram’s proud-lion description follows Moscow and Ganjoor and is also printed in Khaleghi’s apparatus. Mohl instead couples his separation with a slain-in-battle formulation. These readings explain why the English cannot be judged against one edition’s sequence alone. Mohl also relocates the repeated sight-of-sons verse after Bahram; it has no separate English couplet. Tus’s response then compresses two source couplets, retaining bloody lashes, the sandarac face and the cry while reducing the explicit report reaching him.
23–27Tus’s counterfactual and the burial order
Moscow IV143:437–442; Mohl III22:446–451; Ganjoor sh6:94–99; Khaleghi III133:441–446.
Moscow printed p.143 · Mohl printed p.22 · Khaleghi printed p.133 · Ganjoor sh6:94
Tus’s wish that Nohzar had never planted his root makes his lament a rejection of his own birth. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi sustain the botanical image and then connect it to suffering, the slain and the heat of battle. English stock and shoot develops the image naturally; battle’s throe retains the suffering but does not separately preserve the heat. The wounded heart and surviving life are deliberately opposed. Pierced should therefore remain figurative, not be treated as a newly reported bodily injury. His speech then turns from grief to action: burial, reunion of heads with bodies, and removal of baggage and army toward Hamavan. English combines one burial verse with the next first hemistich, carrying the destination-bearing second hemistich into its movement couplet. The register marks that shared source verse. Strong and guarded characterizes the height; the checked wording here establishes the destination rather than an already installed garrison.
28–31Two messages and an uncertain rescue
Moscow IV143:443–447; Mohl III22:452–455; Ganjoor sh6:100–103 and sh7:1; Khaleghi III133:447–450 and n11.
Moscow printed p.143 · Mohl printed p.22 · Khaleghi printed p.133 · Ganjoor sh6:100 · Ganjoor sh7:1
The proposed hiyun and the earlier rider are distinct communications in Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. English preserves that distinction. Its imperative dispatch replaces a proposal to send, singular in Mohl and plural in the other three, while enraged interprets the Shah’s kindled heart. The fear-content of the earlier message is supplied from the situation rather than separately quoted by the sources. More substantially, all four introduce Rostam’s possible dispatch with magar, expressing hope or possibility. He will turns that expectation into assurance; speed and command of the van are also added. Moscow and Ganjoor immediately sharpen the uncertainty with an otherwise-no-survivor warning. Mohl has a checked local gap for that verse, while Khaleghi actually prints it in the apparatus. Its absence from the English reinforces the more confident tone. The final mounting, loading and remembrance of the dead is shared, although Ganjoor begins its next section at that point.
Source record and limits
B13.11 only. Moscow and Mohl individually checked first from rendered PDF facsimiles, then Ganjoor and Khaleghi-Motlagh. Every English couplet has a separate primary-source account; every declared running unit is represented, including two source-only rows. Coverage includes checked gaps and does not certify every English detail.
Printed-page citations below open the corresponding PDF page. Moscow printed and PDF page numbers coincide here; Mohl PDF pages are printed pages plus six; Khaleghi-Motlagh PDF pages are printed pages plus sixteen. Ganjoor links identify the individual poem couplet. The complete label beside each link distinguishes running text, actually printed apparatus and checked local gaps; a link does not establish agreement with every English detail.
| Edition | Inspected running range and page links |
|---|---|
| Moscow | Volume IV:415–447; 33 running units · printed p.141 · printed p.142 · printed p.143 |
| Mohl | Volume III:422–455; 34 running units · printed p.21 · printed p.22 |
| Khaleghi | Volume III:420–450; 31 running units · printed p.131 · printed p.132 · printed p.133 |
| Ganjoor | Kamus sh6:72–103; sh7:1; 33 running units. |
Printed apparatus and checked gaps
- English 19: IV142:432–434 checked local running gap; no matching kin-companion verse in inspected local apparatus; III22:440 running text; sh6:89–91 checked local gap for the specific verse; III132:437–439 checked local running gap; III132 n19 (attached after438) actually printed addition unit2: related kin-and-riders wording, not identical. Mohl440 directly supports sons and grandsons as battlefield companions. Moscow and Ganjoor have a checked local gap; Khaleghi132 n19 unit2 actually prints a related kin-and-riders verse, outside the running text and with different wording.
- English 20: IV142:432–434 checked running gap; IV142 n26 unit2 actually printed addition after433; III22:441 running text; sh6:89–91 checked local gap for the specific verse; III132:437–439 checked local running gap for first-Turan-battle verse; inspected n19 does not print it. Mohl441 supports the first Turanian battle and loss of the speaker’s seed. Moscow142 n26 unit2 actually prints the corresponding verse after433. Ganjoor and Khaleghi running texts have a checked local gap for this specific earlier-battle claim; the inspected Khaleghi132 n19 addition is not that verse. English omits first and adds explicit sons/grandsons from the preceding family context.
- English 21: IV142:434 running text; III22:442 running text; sh6:91 running poem body; III132:438–439 checked running gap; III132 n19 unit3 actually printed Bahram/lion verse and killed variant. Moscow and Ganjoor run the Bahram/proud-lion verse. Mohl442 runs Bahram’s separation with a slain-in-battle alternative, not the lion wording. Khaleghi132 n19 unit3 actually prints the lion verse and gives the killed alternative parenthetically; no Bahram verse in main438–439. No more shall see is an English finality gloss.
- S2: IV143:446 running text; III22:454–455 checked local running gap; sh6:103 running poem body; III133:449–450 checked running gap; III133 n11 actually printed addition. Conditional warning that otherwise no brave champion survives has no separate English counterpart. Khaleghi133 n11 actually prints the complete verse; Mohl454–455 is a checked local running gap. This warning qualifies the hope in English30.
No appendix evidence used or claimed; no exhaustive whole-volume appendix search. No unprinted addition notice treated as verification. Selected Persian readings normalize spacing and are not a complete diplomatic transcription.
The current chapter’s qualifications, including English5’s personal comparison, English9’s unclaimed bodies and English30’s increased certainty, remain in the individual register and notes.
Selected printed readings
نبیره و پسر بود یاران من
Moscow IV142 n26 unit2 printed apparatus; Mohl441 has زتوران in first hemistich
نماند ایچ از تخم من روز کین
Moscow IV142:434; Ganjoor sh6:91; Khaleghi III132 n19 unit3 printed apparatus
چنان نامور شیر خودکام پور
Mohl III22:442 running text — different second hemistich
[Second hemistich: slain-in-battle alternative; see facsimile, not diplomatically transcribed.]
Khaleghi III132 n19 unit2 printed apparatus — selected second hemistich
[Related riders/kinsmen couplet actually printed; not diplomatically transcribed.]
Moscow IV143:446; Ganjoor sh6:103; Khaleghi III133 n11 printed apparatus
نماند به آوردگه بر چو شیر
B13.11 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow IV | Mohl III |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV141:415 running text | III21:422 running text |
| 2 | IV141:416 running text | III21:423 running text |
| 3 | IV141:417 running text | III21:424 running text |
| 4 | IV141:418 running text | III21:425 running text |
| 5 | IV142:419 running text | III21:426 running text |
| 6 | IV142:420 running text | III21:427 running text |
| 7 | IV142:421 running text | III21:428 running text |
| 8 | IV142:422 running text | III21:429 running text |
| 9 | IV142:423 running text | III21:430 running text |
| 10 | IV142:424 running text | III21:431 running text |
| 11 | IV142:425 running text | III21:432 running text |
| 12 | IV142:426 running text | III21:433 running text |
| 13 | IV142:427 running text | III21:434 running text |
| 14 | IV142:428 running text | III21:435 running text |
| 15 | IV142:429 running text | III21:436 running text |
| 16 | IV142:430 running text | III21:437 running text |
| 17 | IV142:431 running text | III22:438 running text |
| 18 | IV142:432 running text | III22:439 running text |
| 19 | IV142:432–434 checked local running gap; no matching kin-companion verse in inspected local apparatus | III22:440 running text |
| 20 | IV142:432–434 checked running gap; IV142 n26 unit2 actually printed addition after433 | III22:441 running text |
| 21 | IV142:434 running text | III22:442 running text |
| 22 | IV143:435; IV143:436 running text | III22:444; III22:445 running text |
| 23 | IV143:437 running text | III22:446 running text |
| 24 | IV143:438 running text | III22:447 running text |
| 25 | IV143:439 running text | III22:448 running text |
| 26 | IV143:440; IV143:441 running text; 441 first hemistich belongs to English26, second to English27 | III22:449; III22:450 running text; 450 first hemistich belongs to English26, second to English27 |
| 27 | IV143:441; IV143:442 running text; 441 first hemistich belongs to English26, second to English27 | III22:450; III22:451 running text; 450 first hemistich belongs to English26, second to English27 |
| 28 | IV143:443 running text | III22:452 running text |
| 29 | IV143:444 running text | III22:453 running text |
| 30 | IV143:445 running text | III22:454 running text |
| 31 | IV143:447 running text | III22:455 running text |
New Naqqali