Khosrow Learns of His Army’s Plight
61 numbered couplets,122 exact published line spans.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 61 numbered couplets,122 exact published line spans. |
| Moscow | IV156–159:627–687,61 running units; actual reaction in156 n8 and local alternatives separately classified. |
| Mohl | III30–33:653–713,61 running units,PDF36–39. Reaction658 runs; world-treasure clause has local gap701–702. |
| Ganjoor | Kamus sh10:1–61,61 poem-body units; reaction local gap5–6 and source-only49 explicit. Following62–65 outside chapter. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | III145–148:631–691,61 running units,PDF161–164; actual apparatus alternatives separately classified. Following692–695 outside chapter. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5News becomes a collective lament
Moscow IV156:627,628,631 running text | IV156:628 running text | IV156:629 running text | IV156:630 running text | IV156:631 running text; Mohl III30:653,654; III31:657 running text | III30:654 running text | III31:655 running text | III31:656 running text | III31:657 running text; Ganjoor sh10:1,2,5 running poem body | sh10:2 running poem body | sh10:3 running poem body | sh10:4 running poem body | sh10:5 running poem body; Khaleghi III145:631,632,635 running text | III145:632 running text | III145:633 running text | III145:634 running text; III145 n10 actual pillow/blood alternative against main autumn rosebush | III145:635 running text
Moscow printed p.156 · Mohl printed p.30 · Mohl printed p.31 · Khaleghi printed p.145 · Ganjoor sh10 poem body
The news combines Piran’s victory, Tus’s retreat and the loss of Iranian commanders. English recasts the narrative report as a quoted message and anticipates Tus’s fallen star in its first couplet, then repeats the image at the close. That repetition should not create an extra Persian unit. The emptied house of Gudarz carries both family bereavement and the loss of military leadership. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor give blood beside the pillows; Khaleghi’s main text instead says the rosebush does not grow in autumn, while its actual apparatus prints a pillow-and-blood alternative. English therefore has positive support for its darker image. Iran’s darkened heart and beds of pain intensify the shared lament without establishing additional events beyond the reported deaths.
6–10The king’s reaction and the summons
Moscow IV156 n8 actually printed reaction verse after631; not running text | IV156:632 running text | IV156:633 running text | IV156:634 running text | IV157:635 running text; Mohl III31:658 running text | III31:659 running text | III31:660 running text | III31:661 running text | III31:662 running text; Ganjoor Checked local gap sh10:5–6; no reaction verse | sh10:6 running poem body | sh10:7 running poem body | sh10:8 running poem body | sh10:9 running poem body; Khaleghi III145:635–636 checked local gap; n10–11 inspected, no reaction verse | III145:636 running text | III145:637 running text | III145:638 running text | III145:639 running text
Moscow printed p.156 · Moscow printed p.157 · Mohl printed p.31 · Khaleghi printed p.145 · Ganjoor sh10 poem body
Khosrow’s overturned heart is not merely an inferred emotional bridge: Mohl prints the reaction in its running text, and Moscow actually prints the verse in its local apparatus. Ganjoor and Khaleghi have checked local gaps between the report and the summons. The English grief burning fiercely elaborates that attested reaction, while the assembly, experienced sages and renowned mobads are common to the ensuing sequence. Khosrow’s fear then begins a statement about the decline of long-standing fortune. English overrun converts that apprehension into a stronger military description; it is not independently established by the source clause. The king’s speech should retain its anxious perspective rather than becoming the commentator’s factual verdict on Iran’s complete occupation.
11–15Rostam as the support of kingship
Moscow IV157:636 running text | IV157:637 running text | IV157:638 running text | IV157:639 running text | IV157:640 running text; Mohl III31:663 running text | III31:664 running text | III31:665 running text | III31:666 running text | III31:667 running text; Ganjoor sh10:10 running poem body | sh10:11 running poem body | sh10:12 running poem body | sh10:13 running poem body | sh10:14 running poem body; Khaleghi III145:640 running text | III145:641 running text | III145:642 running text | III145:643 running text | III145:644 running text
Moscow printed p.157 · Mohl printed p.31 · Khaleghi printed p.145 · Ganjoor sh10 poem body
All four presentations turn fear of declining fortune into praise of the man expected to reverse it. The English former days shifts the description of Rostam as fosterer of crown and throne toward past service, although the Persian predicate also describes his continuing function. Heaven’s heart on his sword-point and sky, earth and time beneath him are deliberate cosmic hyperbole. They express Khosrow’s dependence, not a literal hierarchy of supernatural powers. The White Div’s heart and brain give that praise a remembered deed, while the age’s hope rests on Rostam’s affection. English preserves the loving-mother comparison for Time but adds guidance. Its earth round Rakhsh loses the more particular Persian image of earth serving the dust of Rakhsh.
16–20Cosmic praise meets the defeated commanders
Moscow IV157:641 running text | IV157:642 running text | IV157:643 running text | IV157:644 running text | IV157:645 running text; Mohl III31:668 running text | III31:669 running text | III31:670 running text | III31:671 running text | III31:672 running text; Ganjoor sh10:15 running poem body | sh10:16 running poem body | sh10:17 running poem body | sh10:18 running poem body | sh10:19 running poem body; Khaleghi III146:645 running text | III146:646 running text | III146:647 running text | III146:648 running text | III146:649 running text
Moscow printed p.157 · Mohl printed p.31 · Khaleghi printed p.146 · Ganjoor sh10 poem body
The scorching sun and weeping Nahid survive in English as the sun and Venus, retaining the opposition between sword and mace. The arrow-point that makes a lion weary of battle also remains recognizable, though feathers and fire enrich the image beyond the checked wording. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi support the central boast that no enemy looked toward Iran after Rostam assumed manly headgear. It belongs to Khosrow’s praise and should not be read as an exhaustive historical assertion. The named commanders then return the speech to present defeat. Khaleghi calls their opponents Afrasiab’s warriors where the other presentations name Turks; the English ranks accommodates both without forcing an ethnic designation.
21–25Wounded survivors and the appeal for rescue
Moscow IV157:646 running text | IV157:647 running text | IV157:648 running text | IV157:649 running text | IV157:650 running text; Mohl III31:673 running text | III31:674 running text | III31:675 running text | III31:676 running text | III31:677 running text; Ganjoor sh10:20 running poem body | sh10:21 running poem body | sh10:22 running poem body | sh10:23 running poem body | sh10:24 running poem body; Khaleghi III146:650 running text | III146:651 running text | III146:652 running text | III146:653 running text | III146:654 running text
Moscow printed p.157 · Mohl printed p.31 · Khaleghi printed p.146 · Ganjoor sh10 poem body
Earth as the bed of Gudarz’s dead moves the king’s speech from cosmic praise back to bodily loss. The four texts then locate the survivors at Hamavan and describe their wounded or weary condition. English broken spirits makes that condition chiefly psychological, a plausible emotional interpretation that should not conceal the physical sense available in the Persian. Their heavenward appeal invokes the creator of place and time, asking that Piltan arrive through divine strength and the king’s command. The English this land preserves a deictic expression without settling the shift between the king’s speech and the imagined survivors’ prayer. The dark-night letter and liver blood are explicitly attested; bitter grief explains the bodily idiom rather than adding another message.
26–30Three days of silence and an unlimited offer
Moscow IV157:651 running text | IV157:652 running text | IV157:653 running text | IV158:654 running text | IV158:655 running text; Mohl III31:678 running text | III31:679 running text | III32:680 running text | III32:681 running text | III32:682 running text; Ganjoor sh10:25 running poem body | sh10:26 running poem body | sh10:27 running poem body | sh10:28 running poem body | sh10:29 running poem body; Khaleghi III146:655 running text | III146:656 running text | III146:657 running text | III146:658 running text | III146:659 running text
Moscow printed p.157 · Moscow printed p.158 · Mohl printed p.31 · Mohl printed p.32 · Khaleghi printed p.146 · Ganjoor sh10 poem body
The three days are printed in all four presentations, so this interval is direct textual evidence rather than a chronology reconstructed from earlier fighting. Khosrow says he spoke only before the divine helper, then describes the situation passing beyond measure. English makes grief itself exceed mortal bounds and emphasizes surrounding fear; the change internalizes a statement about the crisis. Blessings for Rostam’s soul, body, green head and joyful heart follow, extending protection to Zal. Old and by choice specify the English wording beyond the blessing’s essentials. Horses, arms, treasure and troops are all present in the offer. As your right turns the king’s willingness to supply them into a statement of entitlement, strengthening his dependence on Rostam.
31–35Serious purpose and a lifetime of service
Moscow IV158:656 running text | IV158:657 running text | IV158:658 running text | IV158:659 running text | IV158:660 running text; Mohl III32:683 running text | III32:684 running text | III32:685 running text | III32:686 running text | III32:687 running text; Ganjoor sh10:30 running poem body | sh10:31 running poem body | sh10:32 running poem body | sh10:33 running poem body | sh10:34 running poem body; Khaleghi III146:660 running text | III146:661 running text | III146:662 running text | III146:663 running text | III146:664 running text
Moscow printed p.158 · Mohl printed p.32 · Khaleghi printed p.146 · Ganjoor sh10 poem body
The charge to proceed with joy and sound judgment ends with a warning not to take this work lightly. English not done in part makes completeness the issue instead; the practical force is related, but the formulations are not identical. Rostam’s reply preserves the blessing of crown and ring and the king’s farr, stature, counsel and justice across all four presentations. His reference to Qobad establishes the long duration of service rather than beginning a new episode about that king. Kingship’s door is an added English metaphor. The claim never to have rested for a day becomes never to have spent a day apart from fighting, a stronger assertion of continuous combat within an already emphatic account of duty.
36–40The catalogue of hardships and the servant’s answer
Moscow IV158:661 running text; IV158 n9 actual elephant alternative | IV158:662 running text | IV158:663 running text | IV158:664 running text | IV158:665 running text; Mohl III32:688 running text | III32:689 running text | III32:690 running text | III32:691 running text | III32:692 running text; Ganjoor sh10:35 running poem body | sh10:36 running poem body | sh10:37 running poem body | sh10:38 running poem body | sh10:39 running poem body; Khaleghi III147:665 running text; III147 n1 actual Div alternative | III147:666 running text; III147 n3 actual battle alternative | III147:667 running text | III147:668 running text | III147:669 running text; III147 n9 king variants
Moscow printed p.158 · Mohl printed p.32 · Khaleghi printed p.147 · Ganjoor sh10 poem body
The catalogue contains a genuine textual choice: Moscow and Ganjoor print Div and lion, while Mohl and Khaleghi print elephant and lion. The alternate readings are actually printed in the apparatus of Moscow and Khaleghi. English Div is therefore supported, not an error to repair from the shorter comparison alone. Khaleghi also names the great men of Turan and Mazandaran where the battle wording appears in its apparatus and the other presentations. Darkness, heavy maces, thirst and long journeys preserve the catalogue’s cumulative exhaustion. The English king of earth agrees particularly with Khaleghi’s world-king wording, rather than the new-ordinance king of Moscow and Ganjoor. Service retains the humble relation without reproducing the literal slave formula.
41–45A pledge, mourning and royal tears
Moscow IV158:666 running text | IV158:667 running text | IV158:668 running text | IV158:669 running text | IV158:670 running text; Mohl III32:694 running text | III32:693 running text | III32:695 running text | III32:696 running text | III32:697 running text; Ganjoor sh10:40 running poem body | sh10:41 running poem body | sh10:42 running poem body | sh10:43 running poem body | sh10:44 running poem body; Khaleghi III147:671 running text; III147 n13 actual warding-evil alternative | III147:670 running text | III147:672 running text | III147:673 running text | III147:674 running text; III147 n19 actual bow alternative
Moscow printed p.158 · Mohl printed p.32 · Khaleghi printed p.147 · Ganjoor sh10 poem body
English places the armed pledge before the wish that Khosrow be free of grief, following Moscow and Ganjoor. Mohl and Khaleghi reverse those two units. Khaleghi’s pledge emphasizes vengeance for the Iranians, with turning evil away actually recorded as an alternative; English chooses the latter branch. The enemies’ yellow faces become retreat on every side, making a desired emotional defeat into imagined movement. Rostam nevertheless declares his own mourning for Gudarz’s kin, and the king answers with two streams of tears. English mace and bow follows Moscow and Ganjoor: Mohl’s closing phrase names the Kayan throne, while Khaleghi has a heavy mace and records the bow alternative. The life or world clause also varies; lost glow softens the king’s refusal to desire it without Rostam.
46–50Blessing becomes material preparation
Moscow IV158:671 running text | IV158:672; IV159:673 running text | IV159:674 running text | IV159:676 running text; Mohl III32:698 running text | III32:699,700 running text | III32:701 running text | III32:702 running text; Ganjoor sh10:45 running poem body | sh10:46,47 running poem body | sh10:48 running poem body | sh10:50 running poem body; Khaleghi III147:675 running text | III147:676,677 running text | III147:678 running text | III148:680 running text
Moscow printed p.158 · Moscow printed p.159 · Mohl printed p.32 · Khaleghi printed p.147 · Khaleghi printed p.148 · Ganjoor sh10 poem body
The binding of heaven and crowned heads continues the hyperbolic blessing, though English chain substitutes for the lasso and reign explicitly interprets the promised dominion. All four then give the treasure inventory, the treasurer’s key and the silver sacks. English moves the opening before the inventory and distributes two Persian units across two couplets; these overlapping references must be counted once. Crowns by the score supplies a quantity, while gathered sacks softens the explicit opening of their mouths. A further verse makes the world a treasury and Rostam’s sword its keeper. It runs in Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi but has a checked local gap in Mohl and no separate English counterpart. The source-only row preserves it before the Zabul and Kabul command.
51–55The disputed number and Fariborz’s commission
Moscow IV159:677 running text | IV159:678 running text; IV159 n7 actual hundred-thousand alternative | IV159:679 running text | IV159:680 running text | IV159:681 running text; Mohl III32:703 running text | III32:704 running text | III33:705 running text | III33:706 running text | III33:707 running text; Ganjoor sh10:51 running poem body | sh10:52 running poem body | sh10:53 running poem body | sh10:54 running poem body | sh10:55 running poem body; Khaleghi III148:681 running text | III148:682 running text; III148 n4 actual thirty-thousand alternative | III148:683 running text | III148:684 running text | III148:685 running text
Moscow printed p.159 · Mohl printed p.32 · Mohl printed p.33 · Khaleghi printed p.148 · Ganjoor sh10 poem body
Speed is the governing demand, but the size of the selected force differs. Moscow and Ganjoor print thirty thousand; Mohl and Khaleghi print one hundred thousand. Moscow’s apparatus actually records the hundred-thousand alternative, and Khaleghi’s actually records thirty thousand. English follows a positively attested branch, and neither number should silently replace the other. Fariborz is assigned the vanguard and vengeance, with until revenge is won adding an endpoint. Rostam’s ground-kiss and pairing with rein and stirrup express readiness. The unusual English cohorts where I am led is preserved verbatim, but those words are not verified by the corresponding clause in any of the four checked presentations. The denial of rest remains secure, while war passing its test extends it.
56–61Urgency without rash battle
Moscow IV159:682 running text | IV159:683 running text | IV159:684 running text | IV159:685 running text | IV159:686 running text | IV159:687 running text; Mohl III33:708 running text | III33:709 running text | III33:710 running text | III33:711 running text | III33:712 running text | III33:713 running text; Ganjoor sh10:56 running poem body | sh10:57 running poem body | sh10:58 running poem body | sh10:59 running poem body | sh10:60 running poem body | sh10:61 running poem body; Khaleghi III148:686 running text | III148:687 running text | III148:688 running text | III148:689 running text; III148 n16 actual alternate wording | III148:690 running text | III148:691 running text
Moscow printed p.159 · Mohl printed p.33 · Khaleghi printed p.148 · Ganjoor sh10 poem body
The sources begin payment, then move Rostam to the plain to prepare battle. English paid strengthens the inception into completion and locates payment on the plain, compressing the sequence. Dawn departure, the vanguard and the command not to sleep before reaching Tus are shared across all four. Urgent marching does not authorize a rash attack: Fariborz must tell Tus to avoid haste in battle and seek stratagem and time without slackness. Khaleghi’s main wording and printed alternative preserve the distinction. English hold the foe at bay expresses a tactical purpose but drops the explicit prohibition on slowness. Rostam promises wind-speed, and Gorgin is the experienced adviser. At your side specifies placement, while good and ill in the source are matters of counsel rather than necessarily episodes in Gorgin’s biography.
Source record and limits
Comparison:12 November2026 UTC. Published B13.15 English supplies61 numbered couplets, preserved verbatim from122 line spans. Moscow and Mohl were individually read first; Ganjoor poem body and Khaleghi main text and actual local apparatus followed. Existing PDFs supplied PNG facsimiles.
- Moscow: IV627–687. Reaction actually printed156 n8; force678 thirty thousand, with hundred alternative159 n7. Catalogue661 Div, alternate elephant158 n9. Source-only675 retained. printed 156 / PDF 156, printed 157 / PDF 157, printed 158 / PDF 158, printed 159 / PDF 159.
- Mohl: III653–713. Reaction658 running. Force704 hundred thousand. Catalogue688 elephant. Reorders mourning693 before pledge694. Local gap701–702 for world-treasure verse. printed 30 / PDF 36, printed 31 / PDF 37, printed 32 / PDF 38, printed 33 / PDF 39.
- Khaleghi: III631–691. Autumn rosebush634, pillow/blood alternative145 n10. Catalogue665 elephant, Div alternative147 n1. Force682 hundred thousand, thirty alternative148 n4. Pledge671 vengeance, warding-evil alternative147 n13. Reaction635–636 checked local gap. printed 145 / PDF 161, printed 146 / PDF 162, printed 147 / PDF 163, printed 148 / PDF 164.
- Ganjoor: Kamus sh10:1–61. Poem body only; no summary or reader comment used as verse evidence. Reaction gap5–6; source-only49; thirty thousand52. Following dawn62 is the boundary, not part of this English chapter.
Evidence distinctions and retained qualifications
Each English row has an independent linked account for each edition. Coverage includes checked gaps and does not imply support for every English detail. The reaction in English6 runs in Mohl and is printed in Moscow’s apparatus, with separate Ganjoor and Khaleghi local gaps. The world-treasure verse runs in Moscow/Ganjoor/Khaleghi but has a Mohl gap and no separate English counterpart. Shared source units in English1/2/5 and47/48 are counted once.
English54 cohorts where I am led remains unverified in the checked corresponding clauses. Retained qualifications include overrun versus apprehended decline; past fostering; loss of Rakhsh’s dust; feathered arrows and fire; psychological broken spirits; granted right; completeness versus seriousness; no rest versus continuous fighting; Div/elephant; reversed pledge order; retreat versus yellow faces; life/world and weapons/throne variants; chain versus lasso; redistributed treasury sequence; thirty/hundred thousand; added endpoints; payment completion/location; holding at bay and omitted no-slowness; Gorgin’s supplied placement. These are assessed without changing the English.
Moscow159 n21 is a pointer to Appendix II, not an inspected marriage passage. No appendix evidence is used; the following marriage material in Mohl falls outside this chapter. No exhaustive appendix search or whole-edition absence is claimed. Unprinted addition notices and source availability never establish verification.
Selected inspected readings
- Moscow IV156 n8 actually printed reaction: چو بشنید کیخسرو نامور / دلش گشت یکباره زیر و زبر
- Khaleghi III145:634 main autumn image: به پایز گلبن نبالد همی
- Khaleghi III145 n10 actual blood alternative: بالینشان خون
- Moscow IV158:661 main catalogue: بیابان و تاریکی و دیو و شیر
- Khaleghi III147:665 main catalogue: بیابان و تاریکی و پیل و شیر
- Khaleghi III147:671 main pledge: شوم با سپاهی کمر بر میان / ببندم برین کین ایرانیان
- Moscow IV159:678 main force: ز گردان شمشیرزن سی هزار
- Mohl III32:704 main force: ز گردان شمشیرزن صد هزار
- Khaleghi III148:682 main force: ز گردان شمشیرزن صد هزار
- Khaleghi III148 n4 actual force alternative: سی هزار
- Moscow IV159:675 source-only unit: جهان گنج و گنجور شمشیر تست / سر سروران جهان زیر تست
Persian excerpts normalize typography and spacing; they are not full diplomatic transcriptions. Structural validation does not claim execution of the live site converter.
B13.15 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV156:627,628,631 running text | III30:653,654; III31:657 running text |
| 2 | IV156:628 running text | III30:654 running text |
| 3 | IV156:629 running text | III31:655 running text |
| 4 | IV156:630 running text | III31:656 running text |
| 5 | IV156:631 running text | III31:657 running text |
| 6 | IV156 n8 actually printed reaction verse after631; not running text | III31:658 running text |
| 7 | IV156:632 running text | III31:659 running text |
| 8 | IV156:633 running text | III31:660 running text |
| 9 | IV156:634 running text | III31:661 running text |
| 10 | IV157:635 running text | III31:662 running text |
| 11 | IV157:636 running text | III31:663 running text |
| 12 | IV157:637 running text | III31:664 running text |
| 13 | IV157:638 running text | III31:665 running text |
| 14 | IV157:639 running text | III31:666 running text |
| 15 | IV157:640 running text | III31:667 running text |
| 16 | IV157:641 running text | III31:668 running text |
| 17 | IV157:642 running text | III31:669 running text |
| 18 | IV157:643 running text | III31:670 running text |
| 19 | IV157:644 running text | III31:671 running text |
| 20 | IV157:645 running text | III31:672 running text |
| 21 | IV157:646 running text | III31:673 running text |
| 22 | IV157:647 running text | III31:674 running text |
| 23 | IV157:648 running text | III31:675 running text |
| 24 | IV157:649 running text | III31:676 running text |
| 25 | IV157:650 running text | III31:677 running text |
| 26 | IV157:651 running text | III31:678 running text |
| 27 | IV157:652 running text | III31:679 running text |
| 28 | IV157:653 running text | III32:680 running text |
| 29 | IV158:654 running text | III32:681 running text |
| 30 | IV158:655 running text | III32:682 running text |
| 31 | IV158:656 running text | III32:683 running text |
| 32 | IV158:657 running text | III32:684 running text |
| 33 | IV158:658 running text | III32:685 running text |
| 34 | IV158:659 running text | III32:686 running text |
| 35 | IV158:660 running text | III32:687 running text |
| 36 | IV158:661 running text; IV158 n9 actual elephant alternative | III32:688 running text |
| 37 | IV158:662 running text | III32:689 running text |
| 38 | IV158:663 running text | III32:690 running text |
| 39 | IV158:664 running text | III32:691 running text |
| 40 | IV158:665 running text | III32:692 running text |
| 41 | IV158:666 running text | III32:694 running text |
| 42 | IV158:667 running text | III32:693 running text |
| 43 | IV158:668 running text | III32:695 running text |
| 44 | IV158:669 running text | III32:696 running text |
| 45 | IV158:670 running text | III32:697 running text |
| 46 | IV158:671 running text | III32:698 running text |
| 47 | IV158:672; IV159:673 running text | III32:699,700 running text |
| 48 | IV158:672; IV159:673 running text | III32:699,700 running text |
| 49 | IV159:674 running text | III32:701 running text |
| 50 | IV159:676 running text | III32:702 running text |
| 51 | IV159:677 running text | III32:703 running text |
| 52 | IV159:678 running text; IV159 n7 actual hundred-thousand alternative | III32:704 running text |
| 53 | IV159:679 running text | III33:705 running text |
| 54 | IV159:680 running text | III33:706 running text |
| 55 | IV159:681 running text | III33:707 running text |
| 56 | IV159:682 running text | III33:708 running text |
| 57 | IV159:683 running text | III33:709 running text |
| 58 | IV159:684 running text | III33:710 running text |
| 59 | IV159:685 running text | III33:711 running text |
| 60 | IV159:686 running text | III33:712 running text |
| 61 | IV159:687 running text | III33:713 running text |
New Naqqali