Fariborz Asks for Farangis’s Hand
74 numbered couplets; all148 published lines matched against fresh retrieval.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 74 numbered couplets; all148 published lines matched against fresh retrieval. |
| Moscow | IV315–318 Appendix II1–69 (69 appendix units), plus IV159–160 main688–691 (4 running units). IV316 n8 actually prints justice/love addition. Distinct evidence classes. |
| Mohl | III33–36:714–787,74 continuous Persian running units,PDF39–42. Local gaps and order differences independently recorded. |
| Ganjoor | Kamus sh10:62–65,4 running units. Checked junction61–62 contains no marriage episode; no comments or summaries counted as verse. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | III148:692–695,4 running units,PDF164. Checked junction691–692 and local n18–19 contain no marriage episode. Contents checked without claiming exhaustive absence. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5A private request placed in heroic hands
Moscow IV315:1 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV315:2 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV316:3,4 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text); Mohl III33:714 running text | III33:715 running text | III33:716,717 running text; Ganjoor Checked local gap sh10:61–62; Gorgin counsel followed directly by dawn; no marriage episode; Khaleghi III148:691–692 checked local gap for marriage episode; n18–19 inspected, no marriage verses printed
Moscow printed p.315 · Moscow printed p.316 · Mohl printed p.33 · Khaleghi printed p.148 · Ganjoor sh10:61–62 checked episode gap
The marriage episode is positively printed in Mohl’s continuous Persian text and in Moscow’s Appendix II. The appendix itself has been read; Moscow’s earlier pointer is not the evidence for these individual clauses. Ganjoor and Khaleghi pass from Gorgin’s counsel directly to dawn at the checked junction, without this conversation. English adds Fariborz’s approach and intent heart before the opening address, then preserves the secret wish and Rostam’s position as the army’s refuge. Rakhsh, khaftan and gopal keep the request within the hero’s martial identity. The raised helmets and divine blessing rearrange neighboring source clauses, while yielding proud warriors and the turning sky enlarge the praise. Fariborz’s dependence on the intermediary is established before the intended bride is named.
6–10Brotherhood becomes an argument for marriage
Moscow IV316:5 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV316:6 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV316:7 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV316:8 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV316:9 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text); Mohl III33:718 running text | III33:719 running text | III33:720 running text | III33:721 running text | III33:722 running text; Ganjoor Checked local gap sh10:61–62; Gorgin counsel followed directly by dawn; no marriage episode; Khaleghi III148:691–692 checked local gap for marriage episode; n18–19 inspected, no marriage verses printed
Moscow printed p.316 · Mohl printed p.33 · Khaleghi printed p.148 · Ganjoor sh10:61–62 checked episode gap
Moscow’s appendix and Mohl support Fariborz’s assertion that he and Siavash share brotherhood and origin. English standing ever side by side adds companionship to that genealogical claim. The suitability of marrying the widow remains Fariborz’s argument, not the analyst’s endorsement of a general rule about marriage. His appeal asks Rostam to speak to the king and metaphorically crown him through success. English makes the woman’s place beside him explicit. The preceding praise changes more substantially: the source calls Rostam worthy of throne, crown and signet, whereas English makes him the support through which those royal objects and Iran’s renown stand firm. Ganjoor and Khaleghi’s checked local episode gaps do not contradict this fuller printed conversation, but they cannot supply independent agreement with its wording.
11–15Permission, divine approval and a printed addition
Moscow IV316:10 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV316:11 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV316:12 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text); IV316 n5 actually printed good-for-king alternative | IV316 Appendix II12–13 checked local gap for royal reply; n5–8 inspected | IV316 n8 actually printed justice/love addition after Appendix II13; Mohl III33:723 running text | III33:724 running text | III33:725 running text | III33:726,727 running text | III34:729 running text; Ganjoor Checked local gap sh10:61–62; Gorgin counsel followed directly by dawn; no marriage episode; Khaleghi III148:691–692 checked local gap for marriage episode; n18–19 inspected, no marriage verses printed
Moscow printed p.316 · Mohl printed p.33 · Mohl printed p.34 · Khaleghi printed p.148 · Ganjoor sh10:61–62 checked episode gap
Rostam’s petition is supported by Mohl’s running text and Moscow’s appendix, but their formulations diverge. Moscow makes the king raise the petitioner’s head beyond sky and moon; Mohl gives the first-person raising. More consequentially, Mohl explicitly names the creator in the approval clause, while Moscow’s appendix speaks of what is good to the discerning and records another wording about the king. English God approves thus has specific Mohl support; just men is an elaboration. Khosrow’s invitation to speak also runs in Mohl but has a checked gap in the appendix. The following justice-and-love praise, by contrast, is actually printed in Moscow’s appendix apparatus as well as Mohl’s text. Ganjoor and Khaleghi provide no marriage dialogue at their inspected junctions.
16–20A royal match linked to the campaign
Moscow IV316 n8 actually printed justice/love addition after Appendix II13 | IV316:14 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV316:15 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV316:16 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV316:17 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text); Mohl III34:729 running text | III34:730 running text | III34:731 running text | III34:732 running text | III34:733 running text; Ganjoor Checked local gap sh10:61–62; Gorgin counsel followed directly by dawn; no marriage episode; Khaleghi III148:691–692 checked local gap for marriage episode; n18–19 inspected, no marriage verses printed
Moscow printed p.316 · Mohl printed p.34 · Khaleghi printed p.148 · Ganjoor sh10:61–62 checked episode gap
The heaven with two open faces belongs to the same source verse as the preceding distribution of justice and affection. English unfolds that single unit into two couplets, adding balance and loving mercy without requiring another Persian verse. Mohl prints the verse continuously; Moscow prints it in the apparatus to Appendix II. The praise of Fariborz as unmatched among princes then runs in both presentations, although English makes valor more explicit and partly shifts counsel toward prowess. His request to occupy his brother’s place links marriage with vengeance. The source describes his girding for vengeance and becoming a support to Iran; English sword and Turan’s dark flood supply a martial image beyond those clauses. Ganjoor and Khaleghi remain checked local gaps for this episode.
21–25Guardianship, assent and the authority of advice
Moscow IV316:18,19 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV316:19 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV316:22 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV316:23 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV316:24 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text); Mohl III34:734,735 running text | III34:735 running text | III34:738 running text | III34:739 running text | III34:740 running text; Ganjoor Checked local gap sh10:61–62; Gorgin counsel followed directly by dawn; no marriage episode; Khaleghi III148:691–692 checked local gap for marriage episode; n18–19 inspected, no marriage verses printed
Moscow printed p.316 · Mohl printed p.34 · Khaleghi printed p.148 · Ganjoor sh10:61–62 checked episode gap
Rostam’s argument identifies Afrasiab’s daughter as the appropriate guardian of palace and treasure while Fariborz campaigns. Moscow’s appendix and Mohl frame her as the only suitable candidate; English makes the lineage explicit but softens that exclusion. Its shared care follows Moscow’s ranj more closely than Mohl’s rokh, or face. The sun-and-moon union is preserved, with one royal house adding a dynastic interpretation. Two following source units explicitly explain the hoped-for good and Khosrow’s sense of increased greatness. They remain separately recorded because English moves to assent and strengthening counsel instead of preserving that narration. The warning about fortune trampling anyone who rejects Rostam’s advice is then retained closely. Ganjoor and Khaleghi have no corresponding marriage passage at the checked junction, so assent is not presented as four-way running-text agreement.
26–30The king approaches his mother
Moscow IV317:25 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text); IV317 n1–4 actual local variants | IV317:26 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV317:27 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV317:28 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV317:29 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text); Mohl III34:741 running text | III34:742 running text | III34:743 running text | III34:744 running text | III34:745 running text; Ganjoor Checked local gap sh10:61–62; Gorgin counsel followed directly by dawn; no marriage episode; Khaleghi III148:691–692 checked local gap for marriage episode; n18–19 inspected, no marriage verses printed
Moscow printed p.317 · Mohl printed p.34 · Khaleghi printed p.148 · Ganjoor sh10:61–62 checked episode gap
Khosrow’s reluctance to speak and his conditional willingness if his mother listens are attested in Mohl and Moscow’s appendix, with different wording in the initial reservation. English resolves the difficult formulation as the impropriety of his urging the match. Consent to hear must remain distinct from consent to marry: the scene has not yet reached her answer. Rostam and Khosrow then approach her together, and the king addresses her as the memorial of his father and his refuge in good and ill. Moscow explicitly says she is his Shah; Mohl compares her support to a kanarang and Shah. English wisdom above royal pride develops that hierarchy. Ganjoor and Khaleghi’s local gaps leave this family encounter supported by the two fuller presentations only.
31–35Military loss enters the marriage proposal
Moscow IV317:30 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV317:31,32 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV317:33 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV317:34 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV317:35,36 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text); Mohl III34:746 running text | III34:747 running text; III34:747–748 checked local gap for mourning-women verse | III34:748 running text | III34:749 running text | III34:750,751 running text; Ganjoor Checked local gap sh10:61–62; Gorgin counsel followed directly by dawn; no marriage episode; Khaleghi III148:691–692 checked local gap for marriage episode; n18–19 inspected, no marriage verses printed
Moscow printed p.317 · Mohl printed p.34 · Khaleghi printed p.148 · Ganjoor sh10:61–62 checked episode gap
The army’s suffering and the loss of Iranian nobles prepare Khosrow’s request in both Mohl and Moscow’s appendix. The women’s house-by-house mourning has more specific evidence: Moscow prints it as Appendix II32, while Mohl has a checked local gap between the losses and the promised force. English empty homes interprets the household lament. The next couplet sends an army guided by Rostam, but the English promise to turn shame to grief when war is won has no corresponding clause in either inspected primary passage or its local apparatus. That wording remains unverified rather than being justified by the campaign’s general purpose. Fariborz’s command and Rostam’s mediation then lead into the request for her hand. Ganjoor and Khaleghi omit this conversation at their checked junctions.
36–40Memory interrupts the proposal
Moscow IV317:36 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV317:37 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV317:38,39 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV317:39 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV317:40 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text); Mohl III34:751 running text | III34:752 running text | III35:753,754 running text | III35:754 running text | III35:755 running text; Ganjoor Checked local gap sh10:61–62; Gorgin counsel followed directly by dawn; no marriage episode; Khaleghi III148:691–692 checked local gap for marriage episode; n18–19 inspected, no marriage verses printed
Moscow printed p.317 · Mohl printed p.34 · Mohl printed p.35 · Khaleghi printed p.148 · Ganjoor sh10:61–62 checked episode gap
The blessing for goodness and greatness closes Khosrow’s request in Moscow’s appendix and Mohl; English adds fortune and enduring praise. His mother’s remembrance of former days then interrupts the political argument with private distress. Both printed presentations give hidden agitation and tears before she distinguishes her lack of anger toward Rostam from the unsuitability of the time. English if I were free makes the pressure of his request more explicit than the corresponding otherwise formulation. Her question about who but heaven could resist him is rhetorically extreme, revealing the weight of his authority within this conversation. It should not become a claim that her own feelings are absent. Ganjoor and Khaleghi have no corresponding dialogue in the checked local sequence.
41–46Praise and the argument for a partner
Moscow IV317:41,42,43,44 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV317:44,45 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV317:45 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV317:46 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV317:47 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text); Mohl III35:756,757,758,759 running text | III35:759,760 running text | III35:760 running text | III35:761 running text | III35:762 running text; Ganjoor Checked local gap sh10:61–62; Gorgin counsel followed directly by dawn; no marriage episode; Khaleghi III148:691–692 checked local gap for marriage episode; n18–19 inspected, no marriage verses printed
Moscow printed p.317 · Mohl printed p.35 · Khaleghi printed p.148 · Ganjoor sh10:61–62 checked episode gap
Rostam responds with several honorific verses in Moscow’s appendix and Mohl, compressed in English into the lady’s preeminence and spotless worth. The fuller praise includes crown and ivory throne; Mohl also addresses the lady of Chin where the appendix has pride of the assembly. Those particulars are not separately retained. His subsequent claim that a woman cannot endure without a husband belongs to his persuasion, not to the commentator’s description of all women. English rest alone and fitting partner soften its categorical wording, while age pairing and Kayan descent preserve the proposed match’s social argument. The mutual attraction of men and women remains, but no divided part adds emotional exclusivity. Ganjoor and Khaleghi offer no parallel marriage speech at the checked junction.
47–51Repeated royal praise and the extent of rule
Moscow IV316:14,15 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text); partial relocated facts only; IV317 Appendix II47–IV318 Appendix II48 and local apparatus have no separate intervening praise verse | IV316:6,14,15 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text); partial relocated facts only; IV317 Appendix II47–IV318 Appendix II48 and local apparatus have no separate intervening praise verse | IV316:6 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text); partial relocated facts only; IV317 Appendix II47–IV318 Appendix II48 and local apparatus have no separate intervening praise verse | IV318:48 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text); Mohl III34:730,731 running text; partial relocated facts only; III35:762–763 checked local gap for separate intervening praise verse | III33:719; III34:730,731 running text; partial relocated facts only; III35:762–763 checked local gap for separate intervening praise verse | III33:719 running text; partial relocated facts only; III35:762–763 checked local gap for separate intervening praise verse | III35:763 running text; Ganjoor Checked local gap sh10:61–62; Gorgin counsel followed directly by dawn; no marriage episode; Khaleghi III148:691–692 checked local gap for marriage episode; n18–19 inspected, no marriage verses printed
Moscow printed p.316 · Moscow printed p.317 · Moscow printed p.318 · Mohl printed p.34 · Mohl printed p.35 · Mohl printed p.33 · Khaleghi printed p.148 · Ganjoor sh10:61–62 checked episode gap
The additional praise of Fariborz is only partly supported at this position. His Kavus descent, distinction among princes and brotherhood with Siavash appear earlier in Moscow’s appendix and Mohl, and those locators are retained as relocated support. Neither inspected post-maxim junction contains separate verses asserting his victorious crown fitness or a throne illuminated by his name. Earlier related facts do not verify the added claims or their placement in Rostam’s speech. The territorial statement is present: two shares of Iran obey Fariborz, including inhabited and ruined territory. English greater part interprets the division, while desert plain turns desolation into geography and many realms enlarges its scope. Ganjoor and Khaleghi’s local gaps cannot settle the unverified praise.
52–55A question framed by royal approval
Moscow IV318:49 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV318:50 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV318:51 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text); Mohl III35:764 running text | III35:765 running text | III35:766 running text; Ganjoor Checked local gap sh10:61–62; Gorgin counsel followed directly by dawn; no marriage episode; Khaleghi III148:691–692 checked local gap for marriage episode; n18–19 inspected, no marriage verses printed
Moscow printed p.318 · Mohl printed p.35 · Khaleghi printed p.148 · Ganjoor sh10:61–62 checked episode gap
Moscow’s appendix and Mohl both introduce the king’s permission, counsel and command before asking whether Fariborz is pleasing and suitable. English preserves this sanctioned framework, though it does not repeat the sun-and-moon pairing at this point. The suitability question is then expanded into two English couplets. Heart moved emphasizes personal feeling; crown, lineage and guide draw on the surrounding argument rather than an additional source verse. The final instruction asks her to heed Rostam and the king. English by which the great should live turns that particular imperative into a wider maxim. This sequence matters because the offered choice is surrounded by authoritative advice. Ganjoor and Khaleghi have no corresponding question-and-command passage at their independently checked local gaps.
56–60Silence and the irreplaceable Siavash
Moscow IV318:52 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV318:53 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV318:53,54 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV318:55 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text); Mohl III35:767 running text | III35:768 running text | III35:768,769 running text | III35:770 running text; Ganjoor Checked local gap sh10:61–62; Gorgin counsel followed directly by dawn; no marriage episode; Khaleghi III148:691–692 checked local gap for marriage episode; n18–19 inspected, no marriage verses printed
Moscow printed p.318 · Mohl printed p.35 · Khaleghi printed p.148 · Ganjoor sh10:61–62 checked episode gap
Her long silence, grief, repeated cold sighs and shame before her son are explicit in Moscow’s appendix and Mohl. English adds the raised face but preserves the difficulty of answering. The ensuing source statement says that no man in Iran is like Siavash and none fits his place. English repeats that irreplaceability across two couplets, but introduces affirmative praise of Fariborz’s royal name into her speech. Earlier praise by other speakers does not independently verify this new affirmation. The source also gives an explicit lament for Siavash’s killing and a question about responding when Rostam requests her for Fariborz; both are preserved in source-only rows. Ganjoor and Khaleghi’s checked local gaps provide no alternative version of her answer.
61–64Submission and a changed subject
Moscow IV318:58 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV318:59 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV318:60 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV318:61 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text); Mohl III35:773 running text | III35:774 running text | III35:775 running text | III35:776 running text; Ganjoor Checked local gap sh10:61–62; Gorgin counsel followed directly by dawn; no marriage episode; Khaleghi III148:691–692 checked local gap for marriage episode; n18–19 inspected, no marriage verses printed
Moscow printed p.318 · Mohl printed p.35 · Khaleghi printed p.148 · Ganjoor sh10:61–62 checked episode gap
The image of Rostam’s words tying her tongue and her readiness to obey the king are secure in Moscow’s appendix and Mohl. English honor gives a positive moral expression to that submission, while the surrounding silence and grief complicate any simple account of willing enthusiasm. A substantive change follows: both Persian presentations say the king’s mother softened or assented and her face shone like a spring rose. English transfers the response and rose-face to Khosrow. The next Persian verse narrates Rostam girding himself for the task without delay; English makes this Khosrow’s direct command instead. Urgency is supported, but the changed subject and new speech are not verified alternatives. Ganjoor and Khaleghi retain local gaps for the entire exchange.
65–69The contract and the three-day interval
Moscow IV318:61,62,63 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV318:63,64 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV318:65 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV318:65,66 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV318:66,67 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text); Mohl III35:776,777; III36:778 running text | III35:777; III36:778 running text; III35:777–III36:778 no separate named-pact verse corresponding to Moscow Appendix II64 | III36:779 running text | III36:779,780 running text | III36:780,781 running text; Ganjoor Checked local gap sh10:61–62; Gorgin counsel followed directly by dawn; no marriage episode; Khaleghi III148:691–692 checked local gap for marriage episode; n18–19 inspected, no marriage verses printed
Moscow printed p.318 · Mohl printed p.35 · Mohl printed p.36 · Khaleghi printed p.148 · Ganjoor sh10:61–62 checked episode gap
Rostam’s persistence, the calling of a mobad and a written agreement according to their custom are positively attested. Moscow’s appendix places his persistence before the mobad, whereas Mohl reverses those units. Moscow also separately names Fariborz and Farangis in the firm pact; Mohl has the contract and sun-and-moon pairing without that additional named verse. English reading of the contract exceeds the explicit writing. The following damad statement supports new marital affinity, but the clause involving release or freedom from Khosrow and Rostam is not an explicit favored-by formula. English resolves it as patronage and combines it with the attested rise in rank. Robe, new crown, three days and fourth-day preparation are secure; Ganjoor and Khaleghi lack these marriage particulars locally.
70–74The fuller episode rejoins the march
Moscow IV318:68,69 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV318:69 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | IV159:688,689 running text | IV160:690 running text | IV160:691 running text; Mohl III36:782,783 running text | III36:783 running text | III36:784,785 running text | III36:786 running text | III36:787 running text; Ganjoor Checked local gap sh10:61–62; Gorgin counsel followed directly by dawn; no marriage episode | sh10:62,63 running poem body | sh10:64 running poem body | sh10:65 running poem body; Khaleghi III148:691–692 checked local gap for marriage episode; n18–19 inspected, no marriage verses printed | III148:692,693 running text | III148:694 running text | III148:695 running text
Moscow printed p.318 · Moscow printed p.159 · Moscow printed p.160 · Mohl printed p.36 · Khaleghi printed p.148 · Ganjoor sh10 poem body
Rostam’s movement to the plain and Fariborz’s star-like advance close Moscow’s Appendix II and the marriage passage in Mohl. Ganjoor and Khaleghi have checked gaps for those additional departure verses, then join the common sequence at sunrise. The final four Persian units appear in all four presentations: sun, horn, army movement, Khosrow’s two-farsang accompaniment and Rostam’s doubled stages. English compresses the dawn image and horn, dropping the idol with a loving heart and adding absence of fear. It also omits Khosrow’s anxious mind while supplying his return and Rostam’s renewed hurry. The doubled stages are retained precisely, but little rest by day or night becomes an absolute refusal to rest or stay. The boundaries between appendix and main text remain explicit.
Source record and limits
Comparison:12 November2026 UTC. Published B13.16 English supplies74 numbered couplets. All148 lines matched a fresh retrieval and remain verbatim. Moscow and Mohl were read individually before Ganjoor and Khaleghi.
- Moscow: Appendix II1–69 actually inspected on315–318; main688–691 on159–160. The appendix pointer159 n21 locates the passage but is not its verification. Printed316 n8 independently supplies justice/love verse. Appendix32 supplies mourning women;64 supplies named pact. Appendix60 names mother as rose-faced subject. printed 159 / PDF 159, printed 160 / PDF 160, printed 315 / PDF 315, printed 316 / PDF 316, printed 317 / PDF 317, printed 318 / PDF 318.
- Mohl: Running714–787. Creator clause725; royal invitation726–727; justice/love729. Mourning-women verse absent at747–748. Mother is subject775. Mobad777 precedes persistence778; no separate named-pact verse between them. printed 33 / PDF 39, printed 34 / PDF 40, printed 35 / PDF 41, printed 36 / PDF 42.
- Khaleghi: Main692–695 only in this English chapter. Checked691–692 and n18–19 contain no marriage dialogue; Gorgin’s counsel goes directly to dawn. No marriage apparatus text is certified by inference. printed 148 / PDF 164.
- Ganjoor: checked junction sh10:61–62 and sh10:62–65 common march. The poem body goes directly from Gorgin to dawn, with no marriage episode. Other web summaries or reader comments are not treated as source verse.
Evidence classes and coverage
Moscow supplies69 appendix units and4 main units; Mohl74 running units; Ganjoor4 and Khaleghi4 running units. Each declared unit is accounted for, and overlaps between English rows count once. Moscow’s printed justice/love addition is apparatus within the appendix, separately labeled. Five source-only rows preserve the king-benefiting introduction, hoped-for good, royal self-assessment, explicit lament for Siavash’s killing, and Farangis’s question about Rostam’s request. No Persian was reconstructed from English.
Every English row links its own Moscow and Mohl account, including checked gaps and partial relocations. Ganjoor and Khaleghi rows link the actual checked episode junction, not invented verse equivalents. This coverage does not certify universal support for English wording. In particular, English33 shame-to-grief clause;47–48 further royal praise;59 affirmative praise in Farangis’s answer;63 changed subject from mother to Khosrow;64 new royal command remain flagged. English49 repeats earlier brotherhood and lineage rather than a separately printed post-maxim verse.
Other qualifications include added approach and victorious imagery; sustaining regalia versus worthiness; companionship beyond lineage; Mohl creator versus Moscow discerning/king approval; king’s reply absent in Moscow; women’s mourning present in Moscow but absent locally in Mohl; village/house specificity; grief and pressure; compressed honorifics; Rostam’s gender claims as persuasion; two shares versus greater part; ruined versus desert; suitability expanded to guide; raised face; favored-by interpretation of release wording; contract read beyond written; three-day preparation; omitted royal anxiety and added return; little rest made absolute.
Appendix limits
Moscow’s Appendix II was read on its actual pages. Khaleghi’s printed148 main text and local apparatus were independently checked, with contents for the Kamus episode also inspected. No separate marriage entry was found in the checked contents; this does not claim an exhaustive whole-volume or external-supplement search. Source availability, headings and unprinted addition notices never establish individual verification.
Selected inspected readings
- Moscow IV315 Appendix II heading and placement: به زن خواستن فریبرز فرنگیس مادر کیخسرو
- Moscow IV316 Appendix II12: main appendix wording: که آن هست نیکو بر هوشیار
- Mohl III33:725: creator clause: که آن هست نیکو بر کردگار
- Moscow IV316 n8: actually printed additional verse: رسیده به هر کس ز تو داد و مهر / چو گردون به هر کس گشاده دو چهر
- Moscow IV317 Appendix II32: household mourning excerpt: به ایران ز شیون به هر خانهای
- Moscow IV318 Appendix II48: territorial claim: از ایران دو بهره به فرمان اوست / چه آباد و ویران همه زان اوست
- Moscow IV318 Appendix II60: mother as subject: بران رام شد مادر شهریار / برافروخت رخ چون گل اندر بهار
- Mohl III35:775: mother as subject (excerpt): بران رام شد مادر شهریار
- Moscow IV318 Appendix II63: contract: بخواندند موبد بدان کار پیش / ببستند خطی به آیین خویش
- Moscow IV318 Appendix II64: named pact: فریبرز را با فرنگیس یار / بکردند و بستند عهد استوار
- Khaleghi III148:691–692: main-text junction: چو گرگین میلاد کارآزمای / چو خورشید تابنده بنمود چهر
Persian excerpts normalize spacing and typography; selected half-lines are labeled as excerpts rather than full diplomatic transcripts. Passing structural validation is not execution of the site converter.
B13.16 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV315:1 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III33:714 running text |
| 2 | IV315:1 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III33:714 running text |
| 3 | IV315:2 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III33:715 running text |
| 4 | IV316:3,4 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III33:716,717 running text |
| 5 | IV316:3,4 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III33:716,717 running text |
| 6 | IV316:5 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III33:718 running text |
| 7 | IV316:6 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III33:719 running text |
| 8 | IV316:7 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III33:720 running text |
| 9 | IV316:8 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III33:721 running text |
| 10 | IV316:9 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III33:722 running text |
| 11 | IV316:10 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III33:723 running text |
| 12 | IV316:11 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III33:724 running text |
| 13 | IV316:12 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text); IV316 n5 actually printed good-for-king alternative | III33:725 running text |
| 14 | IV316 Appendix II12–13 checked local gap for royal reply; n5–8 inspected | III33:726,727 running text |
| 15 | IV316 n8 actually printed justice/love addition after Appendix II13 | III34:729 running text |
| 16 | IV316 n8 actually printed justice/love addition after Appendix II13 | III34:729 running text |
| 17 | IV316:14 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III34:730 running text |
| 18 | IV316:15 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III34:731 running text |
| 19 | IV316:16 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III34:732 running text |
| 20 | IV316:17 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III34:733 running text |
| 21 | IV316:18,19 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III34:734,735 running text |
| 22 | IV316:19 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III34:735 running text |
| 23 | IV316:22 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III34:738 running text |
| 24 | IV316:23 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III34:739 running text |
| 25 | IV316:24 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III34:740 running text |
| 26 | IV317:25 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text); IV317 n1–4 actual local variants | III34:741 running text |
| 27 | IV317:26 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III34:742 running text |
| 28 | IV317:27 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III34:743 running text |
| 29 | IV317:28 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III34:744 running text |
| 30 | IV317:29 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III34:745 running text |
| 31 | IV317:30 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III34:746 running text |
| 32 | IV317:31,32 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III34:747 running text; III34:747–748 checked local gap for mourning-women verse |
| 33 | IV317:33 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III34:748 running text |
| 34 | IV317:34 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III34:749 running text |
| 35 | IV317:35,36 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III34:750,751 running text |
| 36 | IV317:36 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III34:751 running text |
| 37 | IV317:37 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III34:752 running text |
| 38 | IV317:38,39 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III35:753,754 running text |
| 39 | IV317:39 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III35:754 running text |
| 40 | IV317:40 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III35:755 running text |
| 41 | IV317:41,42,43,44 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III35:756,757,758,759 running text |
| 42 | IV317:44,45 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III35:759,760 running text |
| 43 | IV317:45 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III35:760 running text |
| 44 | IV317:46 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III35:761 running text |
| 45 | IV317:46 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III35:761 running text |
| 46 | IV317:47 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III35:762 running text |
| 47 | IV316:14,15 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text); partial relocated facts only; IV317 Appendix II47–IV318 Appendix II48 and local apparatus have no separate intervening praise verse | III34:730,731 running text; partial relocated facts only; III35:762–763 checked local gap for separate intervening praise verse |
| 48 | IV316:6,14,15 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text); partial relocated facts only; IV317 Appendix II47–IV318 Appendix II48 and local apparatus have no separate intervening praise verse | III33:719; III34:730,731 running text; partial relocated facts only; III35:762–763 checked local gap for separate intervening praise verse |
| 49 | IV316:6 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text); partial relocated facts only; IV317 Appendix II47–IV318 Appendix II48 and local apparatus have no separate intervening praise verse | III33:719 running text; partial relocated facts only; III35:762–763 checked local gap for separate intervening praise verse |
| 50 | IV318:48 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III35:763 running text |
| 51 | IV318:48 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III35:763 running text |
| 52 | IV318:49 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III35:764 running text |
| 53 | IV318:50 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III35:765 running text |
| 54 | IV318:50 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III35:765 running text |
| 55 | IV318:51 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III35:766 running text |
| 56 | IV318:52 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III35:767 running text |
| 57 | IV318:53 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III35:768 running text |
| 58 | IV318:53,54 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III35:768,769 running text |
| 59 | IV318:55 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III35:770 running text |
| 60 | IV318:55 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III35:770 running text |
| 61 | IV318:58 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III35:773 running text |
| 62 | IV318:59 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III35:774 running text |
| 63 | IV318:60 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III35:775 running text |
| 64 | IV318:61 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III35:776 running text |
| 65 | IV318:61,62,63 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III35:776,777; III36:778 running text |
| 66 | IV318:63,64 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III35:777; III36:778 running text; III35:777–III36:778 no separate named-pact verse corresponding to Moscow Appendix II64 |
| 67 | IV318:65 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III36:779 running text |
| 68 | IV318:65,66 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III36:779,780 running text |
| 69 | IV318:66,67 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III36:780,781 running text |
| 70 | IV318:68,69 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III36:782,783 running text |
| 71 | IV318:69 actually inspected Appendix II verse(s) (not main text) | III36:783 running text |
| 72 | IV159:688,689 running text | III36:784,785 running text |
| 73 | IV160:690 running text | III36:786 running text |
| 74 | IV160:691 running text | III36:787 running text |
New Naqqali