Tus Sees Siavash in a Dream
39 numbered couplets,78 exact published line spans.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 39 numbered couplets,78 exact published line spans. |
| Moscow | IV160–162:692–731,40 running units; actually printed local alternatives separately labeled. |
| Mohl | III36–38:788–827,40 running units,PDF42–44. |
| Ganjoor | Kamus sh11:1–40,40 poem-body units; anomalous segmentation in6 identified. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | III149–151:696–735,40 running units,PDF165–167; actually printed local alternatives separately labeled. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5Siavash returns in a dream
Moscow IV160:692 running text | IV160:693 running text | IV160:694 running text | IV160:695 running text | IV160:696 running text; Mohl III36:788 running text | III36:789 running text | III36:790 running text | III36:791 running text | III36:792 running text; Ganjoor sh11:1 running poem body | sh11:2 running poem body | sh11:3 running poem body | sh11:4 running poem body | sh11:5 running poem body; Khaleghi III149:696 running text | III149:697 running text | III149:698 running text | III149:699 running text | III149:700 running text
Moscow printed p.160 · Mohl printed p.36 · Khaleghi printed p.149 · Ganjoor sh11 poem body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all open with Tus’s grief, the drumbeat and sleep, then the shining candle rising from water. English turns the candle into a living flame and adds the depth and darkness through which its radiance moves. The ivory throne, crown, smile and gentle speech remain recognizable, with the sunlike turning of Siavash’s face redistributed between the fourth and fifth couplets. This is explicitly Tus’s dream, so the scene may be read as consolation without treating it as an independently narrated visit to the dead. The command to keep the Iranians in place begins a promise whose victory clause continues into English6. That redistribution must not generate an additional Persian unit.
6–10The garden and the promised relief
Moscow IV160:696,697 running text | IV160:697,698 running text | IV160:698 running text | IV160:699,700 running text | IV160:700,701 running text; Mohl III36:792,793 running text | III36:793,794 running text | III36:794 running text | III36:795,796 running text | III36:796,797 running text; Ganjoor sh11:5,6 running poem body | sh11:6,7 running poem body | sh11:7 running poem body | sh11:8,9 running poem body | sh11:9,10 running poem body; Khaleghi III149:700,701 running text | III149:701,702 running text | III149:702 running text | III149:703,704 running text | III149:704,705 running text
Moscow printed p.160 · Mohl printed p.36 · Khaleghi printed p.149 · Ganjoor sh11 poem body
The printed editions identify Gudarz’s kin in the consolation. Ganjoor’s displayed segmentation, بگو در زیان, is anomalous beside their گودرزیان and should not become a rival interpretation about speaking of loss. English makes the reference explicit. The fresh garden and drinking beneath flowers offer the bereaved a consoling image of continued company; an afterlife interpretation belongs to the dream’s meaning, not to a separately proved doctrine. English changes present drinking to future drinking and expands the question about its duration into a second question about remaining beneath the blooms. When Tus wakes, he himself announces Rostam’s imminent arrival. All four presentations preserve that change of speaker and setting; the English should not be cited as Siavash explicitly naming Rostam in his dream speech.
11–15The armies face one another
Moscow IV160:702 running text | IV160:703 running text | IV160:704 running text | IV160:705 running text | IV160:706 running text; Mohl III36:798 running text | III36:799 running text | III36:800 running text | III37:801 running text | III37:802 running text; Ganjoor sh11:11 running poem body | sh11:12 running poem body | sh11:13 running poem body | sh11:14 running poem body | sh11:15 running poem body; Khaleghi III149:706 running text | III149:707 running text | III149:708 running text | III149:709 running text | III149:710 running text
Moscow printed p.160 · Mohl printed p.36 · Mohl printed p.37 · Khaleghi printed p.149 · Ganjoor sh11 poem body
All four sources give the horn call, the movement of the mountain army, the girding of Iranian warriors and the raised Kavian banner. English makes this movement more expansive through every height and the mountain pouring forth fighters. Those phrases add scale to an attested mobilization. Dust blackening the sun and the voices and arrow rain dazzling its eye preserve the Persian’s cosmic disturbance, including the contrast between obscured light and overwhelming battle noise. The final couplet limits what has happened: the armies face one another, but no champion advances. English met therefore need not imply that a general close combat has already begun. The distinction prepares Houman’s impatience and Piran’s argument for withholding another attack.
16–20Houman’s impatience and Piran’s memory
Moscow IV160:707 running text | IV161:708 running text; IV161 n2 actual body/horse alternative | IV161:709 running text | IV161:710 running text | IV161:711 running text; IV161 n8 actual hungry alternative; Mohl III37:803 running text | III37:804 running text | III37:805 running text | III37:806 running text | III37:807 running text; Ganjoor sh11:16 running poem body | sh11:17 running poem body | sh11:18 running poem body | sh11:19 running poem body | sh11:20 running poem body; Khaleghi III149:711 running text | III149:712 running text | III149:713 running text | III150:714 running text | III150:715 running text
Moscow printed p.160 · Moscow printed p.161 · Mohl printed p.37 · Khaleghi printed p.149 · Khaleghi printed p.150 · Ganjoor sh11 poem body
Houman presses for battle, and Piran refuses rashness. English both man and beast has support in Moscow’s printed body-and-horse alternative and Khaleghi’s main wording, although Ganjoor names the horses. More consequentially, the corresponding clauses describe three men with a small force leaving the battlefield: late in Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi, suddenly in Mohl. English attacked before our ranks could make a stand changes that action and adds a failure to form ranks. Earlier fighting explains the recollection but does not verify this replacement clause. The hungry lions are better grounded: Mohl and Khaleghi print hungry, and Moscow records it in the apparatus against its warlike lions, also found in Ganjoor. English cold elaborates the mountain image rather than translating an explicit temperature.
21–25Piran chooses starvation over battle
Moscow IV161:712 running text | IV161:713 running text; IV161 n15 actual dust alternative | IV161:714 running text; IV161 n16 actual roasted alternative | IV161:715 running text | IV161:716 running text; Mohl III37:808 running text | III37:809 running text | III37:810 running text | III37:811 running text | III37:812 running text; Ganjoor sh11:21 running poem body | sh11:22 running poem body | sh11:23 running poem body | sh11:24 running poem body | sh11:25 running poem body; Khaleghi III150:716 running text | III150:717 running text; III150 n8 actual dust alternative | III150:718 running text; III150 n11 actual lifeless alternative | III150:719 running text | III150:720 running text; III150 n14 actual haste alternative
Moscow printed p.161 · Mohl printed p.37 · Khaleghi printed p.150 · Ganjoor sh11 poem body
Piran’s collective we found becomes English I found, and mud is added to the lowered heads. The barren mountain and horses smelling thorns as musk explain the strategy of deprivation. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi print thorns here; Mohl prints dust, also recorded in the apparatus of Moscow and Khaleghi. English burn likewise has positive support: Mohl and Khaleghi print the roasting image, while Moscow records it against writhing. Khaleghi’s main ending is weeping, with lifeless actually printed as an alternative. The closing tactical maxim also branches. Moscow and Ganjoor warn that haste makes capture difficult; Mohl and Khaleghi prefer a short delay, with the haste wording in Khaleghi’s apparatus. English follows the former argument without needing harmonization.
26–30Ten riders and the economy of siege
Moscow IV161:717 running text; IV161 n24 actual ten alternative | IV161:718 running text | IV161:719 running text; IV161 n26 actual thorn alternative | IV161:720 running text | IV161:721 running text; IV161 n31 actual sleep alternative; Mohl III37:813 running text | III37:814 running text | III37:815 running text | III37:816 running text | III37:817 running text; Ganjoor sh11:26 running poem body | sh11:27 running poem body | sh11:28 running poem body | sh11:29 running poem body | sh11:30 running poem body; Khaleghi III150:721 running text; III150 n15 actual hundred alternative | III150:722 running text | III150:723 running text | III150:724 running text | III150:725 running text; III150 n20 actual table alternative
Moscow printed p.161 · Mohl printed p.37 · Khaleghi printed p.150 · Ganjoor sh11 poem body
Ten riders is a verified reading, not a numerical slip: Khaleghi prints ten, and Moscow actually records ten beneath a main text of one hundred. Mohl and Ganjoor also print one hundred, while Khaleghi records that alternative. Swift, tonight and the enemy’s slight strength are English elaborations. Zanhar retains the plea for protection or quarter once food and water fail. Thorn and flint in the following couplet combines a printed Moscow thorn variant with the shared flint image; the four main texts have dust. English cannot remain softens their explicit death. Return to tents and scouts before the army are secure, but night and facing the height specify more. Rest follows Mohl and Khaleghi’s sleep, also in Moscow’s apparatus, against table and eating in Moscow and Ganjoor.
31–35Tus resolves to break the encirclement
Moscow IV161:722 running text; IV161 n32 actual ebony alternative | IV161:723 running text | IV161:724; IV162:725 running text | IV162:725 running text | IV162:726,727 running text; Mohl III37:818 running text | III37:819 running text | III37:820,821 running text | III37:821 running text | III37:822,823 running text; Ganjoor sh11:31 running poem body | sh11:32 running poem body | sh11:33,34 running poem body | sh11:34 running poem body | sh11:35,36 running poem body; Khaleghi III150:726 running text | III150:727 running text | III150:728,729 running text | III150:729 running text | III151:730,731 running text
Moscow printed p.161 · Moscow printed p.162 · Mohl printed p.37 · Khaleghi printed p.150 · Khaleghi printed p.151 · Ganjoor sh11 poem body
Tus’s ebony face has positive apparatus support: Moscow actually prints the ebony wording beside its main sandarus comparison. Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi also have sandarus in their running texts. English should therefore retain its darker image with the evidence class made clear. The blood-filled heart, dark fortune, encirclement and thorn fodder then lead to the scarcity of human food. English distributes that scarcity across two couplets and adds the daybreak marker, but the source units must be counted only once. Sword and mace become the only remedy. Dawn mobilization is explicit; the mountain skirt becomes the broader height. The source hopes that good fortune will grant victory, whereas English stand and fight states resolve more clearly than promised success.
36–39Famed death and the limits of choice
Moscow IV162:728 running text | IV162:729 running text | IV162:730 running text | IV162:731 running text; Mohl III37:824 running text | III37:825 running text | III38:826 running text | III38:827 running text; Ganjoor sh11:37 running poem body | sh11:38 running poem body | sh11:39 running poem body | sh11:40 running poem body; Khaleghi III151:732 running text | III151:733 running text | III151:734 running text | III151:735 running text
Moscow printed p.162 · Mohl printed p.37 · Mohl printed p.38 · Khaleghi printed p.151 · Ganjoor sh11 poem body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi retain the same closing argument: if the heavenly Judge ends their allotted time by the sword, no increase or decrease can be made in the Creator’s portion. English turns this into no mortal hand staying the decree and makes vain measuring of breath an anxious count before battle. Scorning fear anticipates the next couplet’s opposition between honorable death and life under fear and harm. Tus’s personal I prefer becomes a general proposition about the brave, broadening the ethical claim while preserving its direction. The commanders agree to the fortunate leader’s plan. Their assent completes this English chapter; the following dawn and arrival of news about reinforcements belong to the next narrative unit.
Source record and limits
Comparison:12 November2026 UTC. Published B13.17 English supplies39 numbered couplets, preserved verbatim from78 line spans. Moscow and Mohl were independently read first; Ganjoor poem body and Khaleghi running text and actual local apparatus followed.
- Moscow: IV692–731. Actual IV161 apparatus: n2 body/horse; n8 hungry; n15 dust; n16 roasted; n24 ten riders; n26 thorn; n31 sleep; n32 ebony. These readings are not all the main text. printed 160 / PDF 160, printed 161 / PDF 161, printed 162 / PDF 162.
- Mohl: III788–827. Hungry807, dust809, roasted810, brief delay812, hundred riders813, dust/flint815, sleep817, sandarus818 run in the text. printed 36 / PDF 42, printed 37 / PDF 43, printed 38 / PDF 44.
- Khaleghi: III696–735. Hungry715, thorns717, roasted/weeping718, brief delay720, ten721, dust/flint723, sleep725, sandarus726 run in the text. Actual III150 apparatus n8 dust, n11 lifeless, n14 haste, n15 hundred, n20 table separately inspected. printed 149 / PDF 165, printed 150 / PDF 166, printed 151 / PDF 167.
- Ganjoor: Kamus sh11:1–40. Poem body only. Displayed segmentation at6 differs from the Gudarziyan of the printed editions. Following dawn41 marks the next narrative unit.
Evidence distinctions and retained qualifications
Each English row links an independent account for each presentation. All40 running units per source are covered, with shared references deduplicated. There are no source-only units or checked local gaps within this chapter’s declared sequence. Coverage is accounting, not support for every English detail. No appendix evidence is used; no exhaustive appendix or whole-edition absence claim is made. Unprinted addition notices and source availability are never verification.
English19 replaces the corresponding departure clause with attacked before our ranks could make a stand. That action/timing remains unverified in these clauses and inspected local apparatus. Prior battle context does not establish a missing variant. English18 narrows the caution toward speech, English21 changes we to I, English23 combines roasted with death, English28 softens death, English35 reduces victory to fighting, and English38 generalizes Tus’s personal preference. The register preserves smaller additions of time, location, intensity and purpose. Supported choices include hungry lions, ten riders, thorn, sleep and ebony, each with its own main-text or actually printed apparatus status.
Selected inspected readings
- Moscow IV161:711 main lions: چو شیران جنگی
- Mohl III37:807 / Khaleghi III150:715 main lions: چو شیران نهار
- Moscow IV161:717 main riders: صد سوار
- Moscow IV161 n24 actual alternative / Khaleghi III150:721 main: ده سوار
- Khaleghi III150 n15 actual alternative: صد
- Moscow IV161 n26 actual alternative to dust: خار
- Moscow IV161 n32 actual alternative to sandarus: رخ شده آبنوس
- Khaleghi III150:725 main rest: بخواب و به خوردن
- Khaleghi III150:718 main condition: بمان تا بر آن سنگ بریان شوند / چو بیچاره گردند گریان شوند
Persian excerpts normalize spacing and typography; they are not diplomatic transcriptions.
B13.17 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV160:692 running text | III36:788 running text |
| 2 | IV160:693 running text | III36:789 running text |
| 3 | IV160:694 running text | III36:790 running text |
| 4 | IV160:695 running text | III36:791 running text |
| 5 | IV160:696 running text | III36:792 running text |
| 6 | IV160:696,697 running text | III36:792,793 running text |
| 7 | IV160:697,698 running text | III36:793,794 running text |
| 8 | IV160:698 running text | III36:794 running text |
| 9 | IV160:699,700 running text | III36:795,796 running text |
| 10 | IV160:700,701 running text | III36:796,797 running text |
| 11 | IV160:702 running text | III36:798 running text |
| 12 | IV160:703 running text | III36:799 running text |
| 13 | IV160:704 running text | III36:800 running text |
| 14 | IV160:705 running text | III37:801 running text |
| 15 | IV160:706 running text | III37:802 running text |
| 16 | IV160:707 running text | III37:803 running text |
| 17 | IV161:708 running text; IV161 n2 actual body/horse alternative | III37:804 running text |
| 18 | IV161:709 running text | III37:805 running text |
| 19 | IV161:710 running text | III37:806 running text |
| 20 | IV161:711 running text; IV161 n8 actual hungry alternative | III37:807 running text |
| 21 | IV161:712 running text | III37:808 running text |
| 22 | IV161:713 running text; IV161 n15 actual dust alternative | III37:809 running text |
| 23 | IV161:714 running text; IV161 n16 actual roasted alternative | III37:810 running text |
| 24 | IV161:715 running text | III37:811 running text |
| 25 | IV161:716 running text | III37:812 running text |
| 26 | IV161:717 running text; IV161 n24 actual ten alternative | III37:813 running text |
| 27 | IV161:718 running text | III37:814 running text |
| 28 | IV161:719 running text; IV161 n26 actual thorn alternative | III37:815 running text |
| 29 | IV161:720 running text | III37:816 running text |
| 30 | IV161:721 running text; IV161 n31 actual sleep alternative | III37:817 running text |
| 31 | IV161:722 running text; IV161 n32 actual ebony alternative | III37:818 running text |
| 32 | IV161:723 running text | III37:819 running text |
| 33 | IV161:724; IV162:725 running text | III37:820,821 running text |
| 34 | IV162:725 running text | III37:821 running text |
| 35 | IV162:726,727 running text | III37:822,823 running text |
| 36 | IV162:728 running text | III37:824 running text |
| 37 | IV162:729 running text | III37:825 running text |
| 38 | IV162:730 running text | III38:826 running text |
| 39 | IV162:731 running text | III38:827 running text |
New Naqqali