Afrasiab Sends Aid to Piran
54 numbered couplets,108 published line spans.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 54 numbered couplets,108 published line spans. |
| Moscow | IV162–165:732–787,56 running units; actual local variants and placement notices separately identified. |
| Mohl | III38–40:828–879,52 running units,PDF44–46. Earlier catalogue; local gaps for dispatch, renewed-command blessing and no-need-to-come clause. |
| Ganjoor | Kamus sh11:41–96,56 poem-body units. Catalogue later, broadly following Moscow sequence. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | III151–154:736–787,52 running units,PDF167–170. Actual apparatus dispatch, second Khan introduction, renewed-command blessing and pause-before-battle verse separately labeled. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5A vast army and a displaced strength comparison
Moscow IV162:732,733 running text | IV162:733 running text | IV162:733,734 running text | IV162:737 running text; IV162 n12 placement after737 | IV162:736 running text; IV162 n12 placement after737; Mohl III38:828,829 running text | III38:829 running text | III38:829,831 running text | III38:832 running text | III38:833 running text; Ganjoor sh11:41,42 running poem body | sh11:42 running poem body | sh11:42,43 running poem body | sh11:46 running poem body | sh11:45 running poem body; Khaleghi III151:736,737 running text | III151:737 running text | III151:737,738 running text | III151:740 running text | III151:741 running text
Moscow printed p.162 · Mohl printed p.38 · Khaleghi printed p.151 · Ganjoor inspected passage
The dawn tears a musk-colored garment as the sun emerges from Cancer; English keeps that celestial image while combining it with the messenger’s arrival. The armies’ dust turning the Sea of Chin into desert is a boast of overwhelming numbers, not a geographical report. The placement of the strength comparison matters. Moscow and Ganjoor put the hundred lions and subdued elephant immediately after the Khan’s introduction, before naming the chief from Mawarannahr. Mohl and Khaleghi place it after that Transoxian chief, as English does. Moscow’s actual apparatus records the alternate position. English therefore has positive support for assigning the prowess to the chief subsequently identified as Kamus. The shared arrival material across English1–3 is counted once.
6–10Kamus, the dispatch and the Khan
Moscow IV162:738 running text | IV162:739 running text | IV162:740 running text | IV163:741 running text | IV162:735; IV163:751 running text; Mohl III38:834 running text | III38:835 running text | III38:836 running text | III38:836–837 checked local gap: geographical range followed by Manshur; no separate dispatch verse | III38:830 running text; Ganjoor sh11:47 running poem body | sh11:48 running poem body | sh11:49 running poem body | sh11:50 running poem body | sh11:44,60 running poem body; Khaleghi III151:742 running text | III151:743 running text | III151:744 running text | III151:744–III152:745 running junction inspected; dispatch not in main text; III151 n15 actually printed dispatch after744; not running text | III151:739 running text; III151 n16 actually printed second Khan introduction
Moscow printed p.162 · Moscow printed p.163 · Mohl printed p.38 · Khaleghi printed p.151 · Khaleghi printed p.152 · Ganjoor inspected passage
Cypress stature and a moonlike face survive clearly, but crowns and thrones as playthings changes the Persian relation: crown and throne take pride in the conqueror. None of the checked clauses verifies playthings. The message then ranges from Sipanjab to Rum. Moscow and Ganjoor explicitly print the dispatch against Tus and Khosrow; Mohl passes from the geographical range to Manshur, while Khaleghi actually prints the dispatch in its apparatus. English changes the royal first person to Afrasiab’s name within the messenger’s speech. The Khan’s sky-crown and earth-throne formula runs early in Mohl and Khaleghi, but later in Moscow and Ganjoor. Its relocation is supported; the two introductions must not be collapsed without recording their different positions.
11–15The catalogue enters the first message
Moscow IV163:752 running text | IV163:753 running text; IV163 n20 actual Kashani alternative | IV163:754 running text | IV163:742 running text | IV163:743 running text; Mohl III38:837 running text | III38:838 running text | III38:839 running text | III38:841 running text | III38:842 running text; Ganjoor sh11:61 running poem body | sh11:62 running poem body | sh11:63 running poem body | sh11:51 running poem body | sh11:52 running poem body; Khaleghi III152:745 running text; III152 n1 actual Manshur spelling alternative | III152:746 running text; III152 n4 actual brave alternative | III152:747 running text | III152:749 running text | III152:750 running text
Moscow printed p.163 · Mohl printed p.38 · Khaleghi printed p.152 · Ganjoor inspected passage
Manshur and Kamus appear before Piran’s address in Mohl and Khaleghi. Moscow and Ganjoor place this catalogue in the later heralds’ speech, though Moscow’s placement apparatus records the earlier ordering. English follows the earlier arrangement. Kashani is running text in Mohl and Khaleghi and an actual Moscow variant against brave; from Kashan interprets that epithet without establishing a modern geographical identification. English all prospers in his hand changes remarkable deeds into universal success. The anger bringing wind and snow is retained, but the balancing verse in which contentment brings spring, flowers and streams is absent from the English and preserved as source-only S1. Piran’s ensuing invitation to rejoice substitutes chiefs and warriors for the source’s young and old.
16–20Joy becomes a promise of devastation
Moscow IV163:744 running text | IV163:745 running text | IV163:746 running text | IV163:747 running text; Mohl III38:843 running text | III38:844 running text | III38:845 running text | III38:846 running text; Ganjoor sh11:53 running poem body | sh11:54 running poem body | sh11:55 running poem body | sh11:56 running poem body; Khaleghi III152:751 running text | III152:752 running text | III152:753 running text | III152:754 running text
Moscow printed p.163 · Mohl printed p.38 · Khaleghi printed p.152 · Ganjoor inspected passage
The washing away of sorrow and the destruction of Iran’s land and growth occupy one Persian couplet in all four presentations. English gives them separate couplets, expanding consolation before sharpening the threat into ruined fields and harvests. Its claim that the king’s toil is ended explicitly assigns release from battle, vengeance and mustering to Afrasiab. The Persian leaves the subject less fully named within Piran’s boast. The following universal claim is that only Afrasiab’s desired outcome will be seen on land and water in Iran and Turan; English instead emphasizes expanding might. These remain Piran’s anticipations, not completed conquests certified by the narrator. Repeated heralds then bring another wave of reassurance, which English explains as news from approaching powers.
21–25Greetings and the names of the allies
Moscow IV163:748 running text | IV163:749 running text | IV163:750 running text | IV163:756 running text; IV163 n24 Biward and n25 Kati actually printed alternatives | IV163:757 running text; Mohl III38:847 running text | III38:848 running text | III39:849 running text | III39:850 running text | III39:851 running text; Ganjoor sh11:57 running poem body | sh11:58 running poem body | sh11:59 running poem body | sh11:65 running poem body | sh11:66 running poem body; Khaleghi III152:755 running text | III152:756 running text | III152:757 running text | III152:758 running text | III152:759 running text
Moscow printed p.163 · Mohl printed p.38 · Mohl printed p.39 · Khaleghi printed p.152 · Ganjoor inspected passage
The wish that Piran live happily becomes joy shared by every heart and voice, extending a personal blessing to the whole company. All four presentations then mention Kashmir, the Shahd, standards, troops, elephants and litters; English stops at the river where the Persian reaches beyond it. The catalogue contains genuine name variants. Moscow and Ganjoor print Piroz Kani, whereas Mohl and Khaleghi print the form supporting Biward Kati. Moscow’s actual apparatus separately supplies Biward and Kati, so the English choice has printed support. In battle old replaces the more exalted battle-sky epithet. Garcha and Shangul follow, with English adding the vanguard and fighting clan. Name correspondences do not by themselves establish modern locations for every people or place.
26–30The catalogue closes and Piran revives
Moscow IV163:757 running text | IV163:758 running text | IV164:759 running text | IV164:760 running text | IV164:762 running text; Mohl III39:851 running text | III39:852 running text | III39:853 running text | III39:854 running text | III39:855 running text; Ganjoor sh11:66 running poem body | sh11:67 running poem body | sh11:68 running poem body | sh11:69 running poem body | sh11:71 running poem body; Khaleghi III152:759 running text | III152:760 running text | III153:761 running text | III153:762 running text | III153:763 running text
Moscow printed p.163 · Moscow printed p.164 · Mohl printed p.39 · Khaleghi printed p.152 · Khaleghi printed p.153 · Ganjoor inspected passage
The air filled with standards and earth filled with steel belongs to the same Persian unit as Garcha and Shangul, expanded into a separate English couplet. Fartus and Gahar retain their martial epithets, though yielding foes specifies the warrior-burning image. The next catalogue line is less secure in English: the printed and digital presentations have variant name forms and a second named figure alongside Shamiran’s counterpart. English suppresses that second member, assigns the poisoned arms to Shamiran alone and adds first of the age without a corresponding checked phrase. The rejuvenating news is shared. Moscow and Ganjoor then give a renewed-command blessing, actually printed in Khaleghi’s apparatus but locally absent in Mohl. Source-only S2 preserves it before Piran’s figurative return to life.
31–35Courtesy toward independent rulers
Moscow IV164:763,764 running text | IV164:764,766 running text | IV164:766,767 running text | IV164:767,768 running text | IV164:768,769 running text; Mohl III39:856,857 running text | III39:857,858 running text | III39:858,859 running text | III39:859,860 running text | III39:860,861 running text; Ganjoor sh11:72,73 running poem body | sh11:73,75 running poem body | sh11:75,76 running poem body | sh11:76,77 running poem body | sh11:77,78 running poem body; Khaleghi III153:764,765 running text | III153:765,767 running text | III153:767,768 running text | III153:768,769 running text | III153:769,770 running text
Moscow printed p.164 · Mohl printed p.39 · Khaleghi printed p.153 · Ganjoor inspected passage
Piran decides to greet allies who have travelled far and prepared for battle. English adds weary feet and combines their concern with their equality to Afrasiab. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi also explicitly say that these crown-holders have no need to come; Mohl has a checked local gap at that clause. Its absence from English loses an emphasis on the voluntary character of their aid, retained in source-only S3. Treasure, throne and status explain why Piran treats them with ceremony. His inquiry concerns numbers, identities, commanders and champions, while army weight interprets the practical assessment. Bowing renders a greeting or blessing, and as is his due supplies a norm. The ground-kiss and seeing Kamus are redistributed across English34–35.
36–40From ceremonial greeting to threatened captivity
Moscow IV164:769,770 running text; IV164 n13 actual Gahar/Fartus alternative | IV164:771 running text | IV164:772 running text | IV164:773 running text | IV164:773,774 running text; Mohl III39:861,862 running text | III39:863 running text | III39:864 running text | III39:865 running text | III39:865,866 running text; Ganjoor sh11:78,79 running poem body | sh11:80 running poem body | sh11:81 running poem body | sh11:82 running poem body | sh11:82,83 running poem body; Khaleghi III153:770,771 running text | III153:772 running text | III153:773 running text | III153:774 running text | III153:774,775 running text
Moscow printed p.164 · Mohl printed p.39 · Khaleghi printed p.153 · Ganjoor inspected passage
The proposed pairing of Shangul with Tus follows Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. Mohl instead names Gahar and Fartus at this point, also actually recorded in Moscow’s apparatus. English thus chooses an attested encounter, but drops Piran’s explicit return before girding for action. Breath and grace interprets the threat to raise smoke and breath from the Iranians. The darkened day and binding of chiefs’ feet and necks are shared, with if any still remain adding a survival condition. Sending captives to Afrasiab then broadens from those chiefs to the surviving armed band in English. The next source clause concerns whoever is captured from the army; footmen specifies a troop category absent from the checked wording. The refusal of rest remains explicit.
41–45Killing, burning and the three divisions
Moscow IV164:774,775 running text | IV164:775 running text | IV165:776 running text | IV165:777 running text | IV165:778 running text; IV165 n6/n8 actual reversed place-name alternatives; Mohl III39:866,867 running text | III39:867 running text | III39:868 running text | III39:869 running text | III39:870 running text; Ganjoor sh11:83,84 running poem body | sh11:84 running poem body | sh11:85 running poem body | sh11:86 running poem body | sh11:87 running poem body; Khaleghi III153:775,776 running text | III153:776 running text | III154:777 running text | III154:778 running text | III154:779 running text; III154 n8/n11 actual reversed place-name alternatives
Moscow printed p.164 · Moscow printed p.165 · Mohl printed p.39 · Khaleghi printed p.153 · Khaleghi printed p.154 · Ganjoor inspected passage
The sources threaten beheading, burning and scattering the victims’ dust. English flesh and ashes makes the bodily sequence explicit, while Behead changes Piran’s first-person promise into an imperative. Another plan supplies the transition from forgetting the devastated territory to dividing the army. All four presentations give three divisions and Balkh, but the second division’s geography varies. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi send it toward Kabul and bring Zabul’s dust there; Mohl reverses Kabul and Zabul. The actual apparatus in Moscow and Khaleghi prints those alternate place names. English follows the Moscow branch, with ashes intensifying dust. The threat belongs to Piran’s projected campaign, so these movements and atrocities should not be reported as events already accomplished.
46–50A universal threat and a temporary restraint
Moscow IV165:779 running text | IV165:780 running text | IV165:781 running text | IV165:781,782 running text | IV165:783 running text; Mohl III39:871 running text | III39:872 running text | III39:873 running text | III39:873; III40:874 running text | III40:875 running text; Ganjoor sh11:88 running poem body | sh11:89 running poem body | sh11:90 running poem body | sh11:90,91 running poem body | sh11:92 running poem body; Khaleghi III154:780 running text | III154:781 running text | III154:782 running text | III154:782 running text; III154 n17 actual hand/foot alternative and actually printed pause-before-battle verse after782 | III154:783 running text
Moscow printed p.165 · Mohl printed p.39 · Mohl printed p.40 · Khaleghi printed p.154 · Ganjoor inspected passage
The third division goes toward Iran with Turanian warriors. English specifies where Iran’s lines are laid, then retains the refusal to spare women, children, old or young. Its contrast between settled and open lands, with wild winds, elaborates the compact land-and-country formula. The curse against hands and feet runs in Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor; Khaleghi instead wishes no wise person to remain in Iran and actually records the limb wording as a variant. The instruction to avoid battle while Piran prepares is running text in the first three presentations and an actually printed addition in Khaleghi’s apparatus. English waiting for my command interprets that interval. Piran’s bursting skin expresses vengeance; unrest softens the motive, and his explicit departure is compressed away.
51–54Houman’s watch retains a different emotion
Moscow IV165:784,785 running text; IV165 n19 actual thought alternative, negative retained | IV165:785 running text | IV165:786 running text | IV165:787 running text; Mohl III40:876,877 running text | III40:877 running text | III40:878 running text | III40:879 running text; Ganjoor sh11:93,94 running poem body | sh11:94 running poem body | sh11:95 running poem body | sh11:96 running poem body; Khaleghi III154:784,785 running text; III154 n19 actual thought alternative, negative retained | III154:785 running text | III154:786 running text | III154:787 running text
Moscow printed p.165 · Mohl printed p.40 · Khaleghi printed p.154 · Ganjoor inspected passage
The closing watch is secure: all four running texts give two days, eyes fixed on Hamavan, prevention of escape at night and a landscape soon crowded with troops and standards. English guarding every passage day and night expands the practical instruction. The emotional opening differs materially. Houman tells his men not to clear vengeance from their hearts, whereas English says Cast care away. That replaces retained hostility with dismissed anxiety. Moscow and Khaleghi actually record a thought or concern variant, but its negative syntax still does not verify the affirmative English command. The discrepancy remains flagged without changing the published line. Mountain rock in Mohl and Khaleghi contrasts with the narrow place of Moscow and Ganjoor; English preserves confinement without choosing the rock wording.
Source record and limits
Comparison:12 November2026. Published B13.18 English supplies54 couplets,108 line spans. Exact spans captured from the retrieved public HTML; current web presentation independently read. Moscow and Mohl were individually inspected first, then Ganjoor poem body and Khaleghi main text and actual local apparatus.
- Moscow: IV732–787,56 units. Placement notices IV162 n12 and IV163 n1/n22 distinguish alternate order from new verse. Actual Kashani163 n20, Biward/Kati163 n24/n25, Gahar/Fartus164 n13, place-name alternatives165 n6/n8 and thought165 n19 inspected. printed 162 / PDF 162, printed 163 / PDF 163, printed 164 / PDF 164, printed 165 / PDF 165.
- Mohl: III828–879,52 units. Strength833 follows Transoxian chief832; Manshur837/Kamus838 and spring840 occur before Piran’s address841. Dispatch gap836–837; renewed-command gap854–855; no-need-to-come gap857–858. Pairing861 differs, second invasion route870 reverses Kabul/Zabul. printed 38 / PDF 44, printed 39 / PDF 45, printed 40 / PDF 46.
- Khaleghi: III736–787,52 units. Actual dispatch in151 n15; second Khan introduction151 n16; renewed-command153 n4; pause-before-battle154 n17. Main body retains no-need-to-come766. Hand/foot alternative154 n17 differs from main wise-person curse782. Place-name alternatives154 n8/n11 and thought154 n19 inspected. printed 151 / PDF 167, printed 152 / PDF 168, printed 153 / PDF 169, printed 154 / PDF 170.
- Ganjoor: Kamus sh11:41–96 poem body; freshly retrieved passage matched saved transcription. No prose summaries or reader comments used as verse. Following arrival97 excluded.
Evidence distinctions and limits
Each English row has four separately linked source accounts. Shared references are deduplicated; both Khan introductions remain visible in Moscow/Ganjoor. All declared running units are accounted for. The three source-only rows preserve spring and flowers, renewed command, and allies’ lack of need to come. Mohl’s checked local gaps are bounded findings. Khaleghi’s actually printed additions are not described as running text. No appendix evidence or exhaustive appendix search is claimed. Unprinted addition notices and source availability never establish verification.
Retained flags: English6 makes proud regalia playthings; English28 adds first of the age and suppresses a second catalogue member; English40 specifies footmen without corresponding textual designation; English51 dismisses care where four main texts retain vengeance. The thought variant retains negative syntax and does not verify that reversal. Names remain source-specific; neither exact modern locations nor all English romanizations are independently certified. Further shifts include speaker changes, compressed and redistributed source units, victory boasts treated as projected rather than actual events, omitted spring balance and voluntary-aid clause, added ash/body specificity, and narrowed or enlarged scope. See every register row and its linked note.
All inherited flags remain verbatim in CHECKPOINT.txt, including B10.26/B10.30/B10.31/B10.32.
Selected inspected readings
- Mohl III38:833 / Khaleghi III151:741 strength after Transoxian chief: تنش زور دارد به صد نره شیر
- Khaleghi III151 n15 actually printed dispatch: فرستادم اینک سوی کارزار / برآرند از طوس و خسرو دمار
- Mohl III38:838 / Khaleghi III152:746 main epithet: کشانی چو کاموس شمشیرزن
- Moscow IV163 n24/n25 actual name alternatives: بیورد / کاتی
- Khaleghi III152:758 main name: چو بیورد کاتی سپهر نبرد
- Khaleghi III153 n4 actual renewed-command blessing: ز لشکر توی پهلو و پیشرو / همیشه بزی شاد و فرمانت نو
- Moscow IV164:769 main pairing: برابر کنم شنگل و طوس را
- Moscow IV164 n13 actual pairing alternative: گهار گهانی و فرطوس را
- Khaleghi III154 n17 actual pause-before-battle verse: کنون تا کنم کارها را بسیچ / شما جنگ ایشان مجویید هیچ
- Mohl III40:876 main retained vengeance: که دلها ز کینه نباید سترد
Persian typography is normalized, not a full diplomatic transcription.
B13.18 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV162:732,733 running text | III38:828,829 running text |
| 2 | IV162:733 running text | III38:829 running text |
| 3 | IV162:733,734 running text | III38:829,831 running text |
| 4 | IV162:737 running text; IV162 n12 placement after737 | III38:832 running text |
| 5 | IV162:736 running text; IV162 n12 placement after737 | III38:833 running text |
| 6 | IV162:738 running text | III38:834 running text |
| 7 | IV162:739 running text | III38:835 running text |
| 8 | IV162:740 running text | III38:836 running text |
| 9 | IV163:741 running text | III38:836–837 checked local gap: geographical range followed by Manshur; no separate dispatch verse |
| 10 | IV162:735; IV163:751 running text | III38:830 running text |
| 11 | IV163:752 running text | III38:837 running text |
| 12 | IV163:753 running text; IV163 n20 actual Kashani alternative | III38:838 running text |
| 13 | IV163:754 running text | III38:839 running text |
| 14 | IV163:742 running text | III38:841 running text |
| 15 | IV163:743 running text | III38:842 running text |
| 16 | IV163:744 running text | III38:843 running text |
| 17 | IV163:744 running text | III38:843 running text |
| 18 | IV163:745 running text | III38:844 running text |
| 19 | IV163:746 running text | III38:845 running text |
| 20 | IV163:747 running text | III38:846 running text |
| 21 | IV163:748 running text | III38:847 running text |
| 22 | IV163:749 running text | III38:848 running text |
| 23 | IV163:750 running text | III39:849 running text |
| 24 | IV163:756 running text; IV163 n24 Biward and n25 Kati actually printed alternatives | III39:850 running text |
| 25 | IV163:757 running text | III39:851 running text |
| 26 | IV163:757 running text | III39:851 running text |
| 27 | IV163:758 running text | III39:852 running text |
| 28 | IV164:759 running text | III39:853 running text |
| 29 | IV164:760 running text | III39:854 running text |
| 30 | IV164:762 running text | III39:855 running text |
| 31 | IV164:763,764 running text | III39:856,857 running text |
| 32 | IV164:764,766 running text | III39:857,858 running text |
| 33 | IV164:766,767 running text | III39:858,859 running text |
| 34 | IV164:767,768 running text | III39:859,860 running text |
| 35 | IV164:768,769 running text | III39:860,861 running text |
| 36 | IV164:769,770 running text; IV164 n13 actual Gahar/Fartus alternative | III39:861,862 running text |
| 37 | IV164:771 running text | III39:863 running text |
| 38 | IV164:772 running text | III39:864 running text |
| 39 | IV164:773 running text | III39:865 running text |
| 40 | IV164:773,774 running text | III39:865,866 running text |
| 41 | IV164:774,775 running text | III39:866,867 running text |
| 42 | IV164:775 running text | III39:867 running text |
| 43 | IV165:776 running text | III39:868 running text |
| 44 | IV165:777 running text | III39:869 running text |
| 45 | IV165:778 running text; IV165 n6/n8 actual reversed place-name alternatives | III39:870 running text |
| 46 | IV165:779 running text | III39:871 running text |
| 47 | IV165:780 running text | III39:872 running text |
| 48 | IV165:781 running text | III39:873 running text |
| 49 | IV165:781,782 running text | III39:873; III40:874 running text |
| 50 | IV165:783 running text | III40:875 running text |
| 51 | IV165:784,785 running text; IV165 n19 actual thought alternative, negative retained | III40:876,877 running text |
| 52 | IV165:785 running text | III40:877 running text |
| 53 | IV165:786 running text | III40:878 running text |
| 54 | IV165:787 running text | III40:879 running text |
New Naqqali