Gudarz Hears of Rostam’s Coming
82 numbered couplets,164 exact published line spans.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 82 numbered couplets,164 exact published line spans. |
| Moscow | IV168–173:833–909,77 running units. Actual additions: moon IV172 n21; desire/fame and abandoned raid IV172 n31 continued173. Checked local gaps for Mohl943 contrast and final overnight remembrance. |
| Mohl | III42–45:926–1007,82 running units; PDF48–51. Earlier lookout lament; additional activity/sleep943; moon997; desire1003; abandoned raid1004; overnight remembrance1007. |
| Ganjoor | Kamus sh11:142–210 plus sh12:1–8,77 poem-body units. Local gaps for Mohl943,997,1003,1004,1007 at stated junctions. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | III157–161:834–911,78 running units; PDF173–177. Moon904 main. Local gaps for Mohl943,1003,1004,1007; actual alternatives separated from main. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5The lookout’s lament and the darkened sky
Moscow IV168:833 running text | IV168:835 running text; IV168 n17 actual alternate placement after835 | IV168:834 running text; IV168 n17 actual alternate placement after835 | IV168:836 running text | IV168:837 running text; Mohl III42:926 running text | III42:927 running text | III42:928 running text | III42:929 running text | III42:930 running text; Ganjoor sh11:142 running poem body | sh11:144 running poem body | sh11:143 running poem body | sh11:145 running poem body | sh11:146 running poem body; Khaleghi III157:834 running text | III157:836 running text | III157:835 running text | III157:837 running text | III157:838 running text
Moscow printed p.168 · Mohl printed p.42 · Khaleghi printed p.157 · Ganjoor sh11:142 · Ganjoor sh11:144 · Ganjoor sh11:143 · Ganjoor sh11:145 · Ganjoor sh11:146
Gudarz’s ascent opens a scene governed by distant sight and incomplete knowledge. The order of the next two units differs: Mohl places the lookout’s lament before the declining sun, as English does; Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi place the sun first. Moscow actually records the alternate position. English also makes the following landscape part of the lookout’s quoted report, a clearer speech boundary than the Persian sequence itself supplies. The dust turning the western world into lapis night and the sun violet is common to the four presentations. English retains the scale and darkness but omits the westward direction and violet sun. Its golden splendor and haze develop the atmosphere without constituting separate source readings.
6–10Earth as refuge from bereavement
Moscow IV168:838 running text; IV168 n25 actual hiding alternative | IV168:839 running text | IV168:840 running text | IV168:841 running text | IV169:842 running text; Mohl III42:931 running text | III42:932 running text | III42:933 running text | III42:934 running text | III42:935 running text; Ganjoor sh11:147 running poem body | sh11:148 running poem body | sh11:149 running poem body | sh11:150 running poem body | sh11:151 running poem body; Khaleghi III157:839 running text; III157 n18 actual hiding alternative | III157:840 running text | III157:841 running text | III157:842 running text | III157:843 running text
Moscow printed p.168 · Moscow printed p.169 · Mohl printed p.42 · Khaleghi printed p.157 · Ganjoor sh11:147 · Ganjoor sh11:148 · Ganjoor sh11:149 · Ganjoor sh11:150 · Ganjoor sh11:151
Gudarz’s response draws death close before recounting his family’s losses. Moscow and Khaleghi principally make dark earth his only companion, whereas Mohl’s hiding formulation supports English’s retreat from grief; actual apparatus alternatives preserve that wording. English assigns the arrow’s pain specifically to the heart where the sources leave the wounded comparison less localized. War consuming his life elaborates the allotted vengeance and battle, while poison replacing an antidote faithfully keeps the bitterness of what should have healed. All four presentations then call his sons and grandsons an army renowned across countries. English reduces that numerical hyperbole to many and adds their graves in anticipation of the next death statement. Burial itself is not independently established by this catalogue.
11–16A personal lament turns back toward watching
Moscow IV169:843 running text | IV169:844 running text | IV169:845 running text | IV169:846 running text | IV169:847 running text | IV169:848 running text; Mohl III42:936 running text | III42:937 running text | III42:938 running text | III42:939 running text | III42:940 running text | III42:941 running text; Ganjoor sh11:152 running poem body | sh11:153 running poem body | sh11:154 running poem body | sh11:155 running poem body | sh11:156 running poem body | sh11:157 running poem body; Khaleghi III157:844 running text | III157:845 running text | III157:846 running text | III157:847 running text | III158:848 running text | III158:849 running text
Moscow printed p.169 · Mohl printed p.42 · Khaleghi printed p.157 · Khaleghi printed p.158 · Ganjoor sh11:152 · Ganjoor sh11:153 · Ganjoor sh11:154 · Ganjoor sh11:155 · Ganjoor sh11:156 · Ganjoor sh11:157
The deaths are explicitly associated with vengeance for Siavash in Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. English for Siavash preserves the cause broadly while reducing the revenge language. The wakeful fortune that turns away and the darkened bright day maintain the lament’s reversal of earlier confidence. The wish that heaven had not turned over Gudarz becomes a wish that it had not turned above the earth, widening a personal negation into a cosmic one. He nevertheless resumes inquiry rather than remaining absorbed in grief. English anticipates the command to look again and asks about movement where the corresponding source clause describes both armies resting from battle. The banner inquiry and left-to-right search remain clear, with an added appeal to answer his grief.
17–20Stillness on both sides and Mohl’s added contrast
Moscow IV169:849 running text | IV169:849–850 checked local gap between no-stir report and grief | IV169:850 running text; IV169 n14 actual child alternative | IV169:851 running text; Mohl III42:942; III43:943 running text | III43:943 running text | III43:944 running text | III43:945 running text; Ganjoor sh11:158 running poem body | sh11:158–159 checked local gap | sh11:159 running poem body | sh11:160 running poem body; Khaleghi III158:850 running text | III158:850–851 checked local gap between no-stir report and grief | III158:851 running text | III158:852 running text
Moscow printed p.169 · Mohl printed p.42 · Mohl printed p.43 · Khaleghi printed p.158 · Ganjoor sh11:158 · Ganjoor checked gap neighbor · Ganjoor sh11:159 · Ganjoor sh11:160
The first watchman’s answer in Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi reports no movement on either side. Mohl then adds a distinct running verse contrasting haste over there with apparent sleep here. English uses that additional contrast to describe Turanian activity and Iranian stillness across two couplets. The second verse has checked local gaps in the Moscow and Khaleghi main sequences and in Ganjoor, so the asymmetry must not be attributed indiscriminately to all four. Weary and in pain further interpret the sleepers. Gudarz’s tears follow, with Khaleghi explicitly linking grief to his child and Moscow recording that alternative. English suppresses the yellow tears and invents gathered peers, then expands the brick pillow into both bed and headrest.
21–25The intended farewell is interrupted
Moscow IV169:852 running text | IV169:852,853 running text | IV169:853,854 running text | IV169:855 running text | IV169:856,857 running text; Mohl III43:946 running text | III43:946,947 running text | III43:947,948 running text | III43:949 running text | III43:950,951 running text; Ganjoor sh11:161 running poem body | sh11:161, sh11:162 running poem body | sh11:162, sh11:163 running poem body | sh11:164 running poem body | sh11:165, sh11:166 running poem body; Khaleghi III158:853 running text | III158:853,854 running text | III158:854,855 running text | III158:856 running text | III158:857,858 running text
Moscow printed p.169 · Mohl printed p.43 · Khaleghi printed p.158 · Ganjoor sh11:161 · Ganjoor sh11:162 · Ganjoor sh11:164 · Ganjoor sh11:165
Gudarz wants to fill his eyes and arms with his surviving kinsmen, naming Giv and Shidush before Bijan and Rohham. All four presentations retain the embraces, martial companions and farewell kisses. English redistributes those names across its couplets and gives the warriors fiery nobility rather than preserving the self-willed or independent quality of the epithet. The most marked embellishment is lashes that bleed: the checked farewell clause promises much weeping, without explicitly making those tears blood. The saddling of the prancing samand interrupts the farewell with the watchman’s cry. Bay is an interpretive color choice rather than a precise reproduction of that horse term. English announces Iranian aid during the invitation to rejoice, anticipating the following report of dust from Iran’s road.
26–30Dust becomes a sign of rescue
Moscow IV169:857 running text | IV169:858 running text | IV169:859 running text | IV170:860 running text | IV170:861 running text; Mohl III43:951 running text | III43:952 running text | III43:953 running text | III43:954 running text | III43:955 running text; Ganjoor sh11:166 running poem body | sh11:167 running poem body | sh11:168 running poem body | sh11:169 running poem body | sh11:170 running poem body; Khaleghi III158:858 running text | III158:859 running text | III158:860 running text | III158:861 running text | III158:862 running text
Moscow printed p.169 · Moscow printed p.170 · Mohl printed p.43 · Khaleghi printed p.158 · Ganjoor sh11:166 · Ganjoor sh11:167 · Ganjoor sh11:168 · Ganjoor sh11:169 · Ganjoor sh11:170
Dark dust now reverses its emotional significance: the same obscuring atmosphere that suggested catastrophe announces an approaching friendly force. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi preserve the Iranian road, numerous moon-bright standards and the successive wolf, moon and dragon images. English shifts the lapis-colored day to blackness and multiplies the moon comparison across the banners. The final emblem needs particular care. The Persian describes a dragon-image standard and a golden lion at its head or top; English’s dragon with a lion’s head can instead suggest a composite animal. The checked wording does not require that anatomy. The ensuing blessing against the evil eye fits the watchman’s role as bearer of hopeful sight, without proving that the banners have already reached the camp.
31–36Rewards and a disputed instruction
Moscow IV170:862 running text | IV170:863 running text; IV170 n9 actual every-kind alternative | IV170:864 running text | IV170:865 running text | IV170:866 running text | IV170:867 running text; Mohl III43:956 running text | III43:957 running text | III43:958 running text | III43:959 running text | III43:960 running text | III43:961 running text; Ganjoor sh11:171 running poem body | sh11:172 running poem body | sh11:173 running poem body | sh11:174 running poem body | sh11:175 running poem body | sh11:176 running poem body; Khaleghi III158:863 running text | III158:864 running text | III158:865 running text | III158:866 running text | III159:867 running text | III159:868 running text; III159 n6 actual tidings alternative against main remedy
Moscow printed p.170 · Mohl printed p.43 · Khaleghi printed p.158 · Khaleghi printed p.159 · Ganjoor sh11:171 · Ganjoor sh11:172 · Ganjoor sh11:173 · Ganjoor sh11:174 · Ganjoor sh11:175 · Ganjoor sh11:176
Gudarz’s reward remains conditional on the report proving true. The four presentations promise valuable property sufficient to remove need, followed by public elevation at the king’s court. English elaborates that promise into a royal prize and a throne scene with standing nobles. The departure command differs in phrasing: Moscow has windlike movement from the post, while Mohl and Khaleghi say that Gudarz sends the lookout from it. The following instruction is to recount observations and seek tidings from everyone in Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor; Khaleghi prints remedy, with tidings actually recorded as an alternative. English instead orders the sending of any available rider. That dispatch is not verified by the inspected clauses and changes who is supposed to obtain or carry information.
37–42The lookout insists on remaining at his post
Moscow IV170:868 running text | IV170:869,870 running text | IV170:870 running text | IV170:871 running text | IV170:872 running text | IV170:873 running text; Mohl III43:962 running text | III43:963,964 running text | III43:964 running text | III43:965 running text | III43:966 running text | III43:967 running text; Ganjoor sh11:177 running poem body | sh11:178, sh11:179 running poem body | sh11:179 running poem body | sh11:180 running poem body | sh11:181 running poem body | sh11:182 running poem body; Khaleghi III159:869 running text | III159:870,871 running text | III159:871 running text | III159:872 running text | III159:873 running text | III159:874 running text
Moscow printed p.170 · Mohl printed p.43 · Khaleghi printed p.159 · Ganjoor sh11:177 · Ganjoor sh11:178 · Ganjoor sh11:179 · Ganjoor sh11:180 · Ganjoor sh11:181 · Ganjoor sh11:182
The lookout refuses to leave while watching remains useful. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi state that departure for the Iranian army is not permissible, then identify darkness as the point when his eyes can no longer serve the task. English supplies the chiefs’ hopes as the reason for staying. Its dark sealing the eye is figurative, and should not be read as an injury or permanent blindness. The Simorgh comparison belongs to his planned delivery of the news after dark; English spreads that movement and its anticipated encouragement across two couplets. Gudarz then asks the practical arrival question. Tomorrow early, rendered as dawn and sunlight, is shared across the four presentations. No precise clock hour is supplied.
43–48Two armies receive different good news
Moscow IV170:874 running text | IV170:875 running text | IV171:876 running text | IV171:877 running text | IV171:878 running text | IV171:879 running text; Mohl III44:968 running text | III44:969 running text | III44:970 running text | III44:971 running text | III44:972 running text | III44:973 running text; Ganjoor sh11:183 running poem body | sh11:184 running poem body | sh11:185 running poem body | sh11:186 running poem body | sh11:187 running poem body | sh11:188 running poem body; Khaleghi III159:875 running text | III159:876 running text | III159:877 running text; III159 n19 actual tidings alternative | III159:878 running text | III159:879 running text | III159:880 running text
Moscow printed p.170 · Moscow printed p.171 · Mohl printed p.44 · Khaleghi printed p.159 · Ganjoor sh11:183 · Ganjoor sh11:184 · Ganjoor sh11:185 · Ganjoor sh11:186 · Ganjoor sh11:187 · Ganjoor sh11:188
Gudarz’s joy is likened to life returning to a lifeless body in all four presentations. The narrative then turns to Piran’s approaching army and a messenger whose report delights Houman. That report concerns the Turanian allies and must not be confused with the Iranian rescue that the lookout has identified. English joyful news leaves the content implicit, so preserving the change of viewpoint is essential. Khaleghi’s messenger wording differs from the tidings wording in Moscow and Mohl, but its apparatus actually records the alternative. Houman’s wakeful fortune mirrors the language of Gudarz’s lost fortune, producing dramatic contrast. The triumphant Turanian shout and Iranian yellow faces with lapis lips are retained; fresh troops and waiting foes add military specificity.
49–54Those below still expect disaster
Moscow IV171:880 running text | IV171:881,882 running text | IV171:882,883 running text | IV171:883 running text | IV171:884,885 running text | IV171:885,886 running text; Mohl III44:974 running text | III44:975,976 running text | III44:976,977 running text | III44:977 running text | III44:978,979 running text | III44:979,980 running text; Ganjoor sh11:189 running poem body | sh11:190, sh11:191 running poem body | sh11:191, sh11:192 running poem body | sh11:192 running poem body | sh11:193, sh11:194 running poem body | sh11:194, sh11:195 running poem body; Khaleghi III159:881 running text | III159:882,883 running text | III159:883,884 running text | III159:884 running text | III159:885; III160:886 running text | III160:886,887 running text
Moscow printed p.171 · Mohl printed p.44 · Khaleghi printed p.159 · Khaleghi printed p.160 · Ganjoor sh11:189 · Ganjoor sh11:190 · Ganjoor sh11:191 · Ganjoor sh11:192 · Ganjoor sh11:193 · Ganjoor sh11:194
The Iranian groups scattered around the mountain do not yet share Gudarz’s new confidence. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi keep their consultation and self-lament before the complaint that Iran will not remember them. English turns the gathering into last counsel against the army’s fall and distributes its lament across additional couplets. Lion mouths serve as the warriors’ shrouds in the Persian image; living tomb and grave interpret that bodily threat, while crimson wave intensifies the earth filled with blood. Tus then sends Bijan to discover what is hidden. English names the commander and spreads the questions of identity, number, character and route across its instructions. The commanders’ ignorance remains narratively consequential rather than an inconsistency to be silently corrected.
55–60Bijan’s survey confirms the scale of the threat
Moscow IV171:886 running text; IV171 n16 actual elephant alternative | IV171:887 running text | IV171:888 running text | IV171:889 running text | IV171:890 running text | IV171:891 running text; Mohl III44:980 running text | III44:981 running text | III44:982 running text | III44:983 running text | III44:984 running text | III44:985 running text; Ganjoor sh11:195 running poem body | sh11:196 running poem body | sh11:197 running poem body | sh11:198 running poem body | sh11:199 running poem body | sh11:200 running poem body; Khaleghi III160:887 running text | III160:888 running text | III160:889 running text | III160:890 running text | III160:891 running text | III160:892 running text
Moscow printed p.171 · Mohl printed p.44 · Khaleghi printed p.160 · Ganjoor sh11:195 · Ganjoor sh11:196 · Ganjoor sh11:197 · Ganjoor sh11:198 · Ganjoor sh11:199 · Ganjoor sh11:200
The approaching army’s equipment includes enclosures and royal furnishings, but the list varies. Moscow and Khaleghi name throne and seat; Mohl includes elephants, also recorded as a Moscow alternative. English gives camps, enclosures, thrones and train, broadening the inventory. Bijan climbs apart from the company in all four presentations; barren stone supplies terrain detail. His panoramic view of standards, horsemen and elephants becomes an army extending as far as sight, and his distressed return becomes care that denies rest. These are coherent expansions of scale and feeling, rather than additional Persian units. The indigo earth and dust-dimmed sun remain recognizable. Thought and tongue enlarge the source’s assertion that the standards and spearheads cannot be measured.
61–66Fear becomes a proposal for action
Moscow IV171:892 running text | IV171:893 running text | IV172:894 running text | IV172:895,896 running text | IV172:896,897 running text | IV172:897,898 running text; Mohl III44:986 running text | III44:987 running text | III44:988 running text | III44:989,990 running text | III44:990,991 running text | III44:991,992 running text; Ganjoor sh11:201 running poem body | sh11:202 running poem body | sh11:203 running poem body | sh11:204, sh11:205 running poem body | sh11:205, sh11:206 running poem body | sh11:206, sh11:207 running poem body; Khaleghi III160:893 running text | III160:894 running text | III160:895 running text | III160:896,897 running text | III160:897,898 running text | III160:898,899 running text
Moscow printed p.171 · Moscow printed p.172 · Mohl printed p.44 · Khaleghi printed p.160 · Ganjoor sh11:201 · Ganjoor sh11:202 · Ganjoor sh11:203 · Ganjoor sh11:204 · Ganjoor sh11:205 · Ganjoor sh11:206
The uncountable army and deafening drum bring Tus from grief to consultation. All four presentations make the drum deafen the ear, whereas English transfers its force to valley, crag and steep. Tus’s wet face and gathering of the chiefs preserve the visible and collective response. His recollection of many ups and downs is elaborated into triumph, flight and overthrow, a specific catalogue absent from the corresponding wording. The claim that he has never faced such terror leads to the assertion that only one course remains despite scant forces and equipment. English adds the judgment that action serves best and the refusal ever to yield. These strengthen resolve while the Persian keeps the proposal tied to the immediate shortage and emergency.
67–72A night attack, succession and the moon
Moscow IV172:898 running text; IV172 n11 actual blood-river alternative | IV172:899 running text; IV172 n13 actual continuing-command alternative | IV172:900 running text; IV172 n15 actual negation alternatives | IV172:901 running text | IV172:902 running text | IV172 n21 actually printed moon verse after902; not running text; Mohl III44:992 running text | III45:993 running text | III45:994 running text | III45:995 running text | III45:996 running text | III45:997 running text; Ganjoor sh11:207 running poem body | sh11:208 running poem body | sh11:209 running poem body | sh11:210 running poem body | sh12:1 running poem body | sh12:1–2 checked local gap; Khaleghi III160:899 running text | III160:900 running text | III160:901 running text | III160:902 running text | III161:903 running text | III161:904 running text
Moscow printed p.172 · Mohl printed p.44 · Mohl printed p.45 · Khaleghi printed p.160 · Khaleghi printed p.161 · Ganjoor sh11:207 · Ganjoor sh11:208 · Ganjoor sh11:209 · Ganjoor sh11:210 · Ganjoor sh12:1 · Ganjoor checked gap neighbor
The raid would turn the earth into a Jihun of enemy blood, explicit in Mohl and Khaleghi and supported by an actual Moscow variant. The following death clause differs more sharply. Moscow and Ganjoor say the dead would incur no blame from the king; Mohl and Khaleghi preserve continuing command while kingship endures, also printed in Moscow’s apparatus. English’s replacement chief follows that latter branch. Its claim that Tus’s fame has grown goes beyond the next disputed burial clause, whose negation varies across the editions. The moon verse is main text in Mohl and Khaleghi, actually printed apparatus in Moscow, and locally absent from Ganjoor. English retains Pisces but turns the black hair’s torn plait into a robe.
73–78Relief stops the projected assault
Moscow IV172:903 running text | IV172:904 running text | IV172:905 running text | IV172:906 running text | IV172:907 running text | IV172 n31 continued IV173 actually printed desire/fame-sun verse after907; not running text; Mohl III45:998 running text | III45:999 running text | III45:1000 running text | III45:1001 running text | III45:1002 running text | III45:1003 running text; Ganjoor sh12:2 running poem body | sh12:3 running poem body | sh12:4 running poem body | sh12:5 running poem body | sh12:6 running poem body | sh12:6–7 checked local gap; Khaleghi III161:905 running text | III161:906 running text | III161:907 running text | III161:908 running text | III161:909 running text | III161:909–910 checked local gap after Piltan assurance
Moscow printed p.172 · Moscow printed p.173 · Mohl printed p.45 · Khaleghi printed p.161 · Ganjoor sh12:2 · Ganjoor sh12:3 · Ganjoor sh12:4 · Ganjoor sh12:5 · Ganjoor sh12:6 · Ganjoor checked gap neighbor
The lookout finally reaches Tus with a face compared to sandarac and announces an army from Iran’s king. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi preserve the report and the distinction between occasions for haste and delay. English’s today is supplied, while its naming of Rostam identifies the Piltan already expected in the scene. Removing fear expands the promised assistance. The next desire-and-fame verse has narrower distribution: it runs in Mohl and is actually printed in Moscow’s apparatus continuation, but the inspected Khaleghi and Ganjoor sequences pass directly to the response to the lookout. English thus follows an attested fuller branch. Its rising Iranian fame should be distinguished from the earlier, less directly supported claim that Tus’s individual fame has already grown.
79–82Abandoning the raid and awaiting the Pahlevan
Moscow IV172 n31 continued IV173 actually printed abandonment-of-raid verse after907; not running text | IV173:908 running text | IV173:909 running text | IV173:909–910 checked local gap between scouts and sunrise; Mohl III45:1004 running text | III45:1005 running text | III45:1006 running text | III45:1007 running text; Ganjoor sh12:6–7 checked local gap | sh12:7 running poem body | sh12:8 running poem body | sh12:8–9 checked local gap; Khaleghi III161:909–910 checked local gap after Piltan assurance | III161:910 running text; III161 n14 actual tidings alternative against gifts | III161:911 running text | III161:911–912 checked local gap between scouts and sunrise
Moscow printed p.172 · Moscow printed p.173 · Mohl printed p.45 · Khaleghi printed p.161 · Ganjoor checked gap neighbor · Ganjoor sh12:7 · Ganjoor sh12:8 · Ganjoor checked gap neighbor
Mohl explicitly says the army abandons the night raid and becomes glad, and Moscow actually prints that verse in its apparatus. Khaleghi and Ganjoor have checked local gaps at this point. The next shared unit describes the lookout’s effect, although Khaleghi’s main text has gifts where Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor have exchanged tidings; Khaleghi actually records the tidings alternative. English follows the communication branch. Scouts and the mountain bell then close the shared sequence. Mohl alone supplies the inspected running verse about spending the night recalling the world-Pahlevan in joy. Moscow, Khaleghi and Ganjoor pass from scouts to sunrise at the checked junction. English’s final overnight remembrance is therefore supported without converting those local gaps into claims about every possible appendix.
Source record and limits
Comparison:12 November2026. Published B13.21 English supplies82 couplets,164 line spans retained verbatim. Moscow and Mohl independently inspected first; Ganjoor and Khaleghi followed. Existing PDFs supplied PNG facsimiles; scans excluded from delivery.
- Moscow: IV833–909,77 running units. Actual168 n17 order alternative;168 n25 hiding;169 n14 child;170 n9 every-kind;171 n16 elephants;172 n11 blood, n13 continuing command, n15 burial negation. Moon verse is actually printed172 n21; desire/fame and abandoned raid are actually printed172 n31 continued173. The849–850 and909–910 main junctions have checked gaps for Mohl943 and1007. Arabic-translation notices and unprinted omission reports do not verify additional Persian verses. printed 168 / PDF 168, printed 169 / PDF 169, printed 170 / PDF 170, printed 171 / PDF 171, printed 172 / PDF 172, printed 173 / PDF 173.
- Mohl: III926–1007,82 running units. Lament927 precedes sunset928. Main942 no stir on either side is followed by943 contrasting haste and apparent sleep. Main961 seeks tidings,993 preserves command while kingship endures,997 prints moon,1003 desire/fame,1004 abandoned raid and1007 overnight remembrance. No actual apparatus reading asserted on these pages. printed 42 / PDF 48, printed 43 / PDF 49, printed 44 / PDF 50, printed 45 / PDF 51.
- Khaleghi: III834–911,78 running units. Main850 both-side stillness;851 grief for child;868 remedy, actual159 n6 tidings alternative. Messenger877 has actual159 n19 tidings alternative. Main900 continuing command;904 moon;910 gifts, actual161 n14 tidings. Checked gaps850–851,909–910 and911–912 for contrast, two fuller reassurance verses and final remembrance. Actual157 n18 hiding alternative inspected. printed 157 / PDF 173, printed 158 / PDF 174, printed 159 / PDF 175, printed 160 / PDF 176, printed 161 / PDF 177.
- Ganjoor: sh11:142–210 and sh12:1–8 poem bodies. Checked junctions: sh11:158–159 lacks Mohl943; sh12:1–2 lacks moon; sh12:6–7 lacks desire/fame and abandonment; sh12:8–9 lacks overnight remembrance. Following sunrise9 excluded from chapter scope.
Evidence distinctions and limits
Each English row retains four separately linked accounts. The five rows with no Ganjoor running counterpart use explicitly labeled Mohl Persian text, not reconstructed verse. Shared source units are counted once. All declared running units are covered; there are no source-only running rows. Main text, actual apparatus additions and bounded local gaps remain distinct. No appendix evidence or exhaustive appendix search is claimed. Source availability, unprinted addition notices and Arabic-translation omissions never establish verse verification.
Source-dependent findings: the activity/sleep contrast is main Mohl943, absent at inspected Moscow/Khaleghi/Ganjoor junctions; the extra moon verse is main Mohl997/Khaleghi904 and actual Moscow apparatus; desire/fame and abandoned raid are main Mohl1003–1004 and actual Moscow apparatus; final overnight remembrance is main Mohl1007 with checked gaps elsewhere. The successor clause follows Mohl993/Khaleghi900 and an actual Moscow alternative against main Moscow/Ganjoor no-blame wording. These differences support English choices without pretending that all editions print the same sequence.
Retained qualifications: English13 widens heaven’s motion from over Gudarz to over earth;23 makes abundant tears bleeding lashes;29 may fuse a golden lion atop a dragon standard into hybrid anatomy;36 sends a rider where sources seek tidings or remedy;37 supplies the chiefs’ hopes as reason for duty;69 adds increased fame beyond disputed burial wording;72 makes black hair a dark robe. Other individual accounts preserve shifted speech boundaries, explicit grave and battlefield claims, changing colors, expanded despair and hope, moved names, inferred personnel and messenger referents, terrain detail, the drum’s changed recipient and added resolve. Published English unchanged.
Selected inspected readings
- Mohl III43:943 additional running verse: از آن سو به تاب و شتاب اندرند / وز این سو تو گویی به خواب اندرند
- Moscow IV169:849 / Khaleghi III158:850 both-side stillness: نه بینم همی جنبش و گفتوگوی
- Mohl III43:961 seek tidings: سبک باش و از هر کسی مژده جوی
- Khaleghi III159:868 main remedy: سبک باش و از هر کسی چاره جوی
- Mohl III45:993 continuing command: سپهبد بود تا بود شهریار
- Moscow IV172:899 main no blame: نکوهش نیابیم از شهریار
- Mohl III45:997 main moon verse / Moscow IV172 n21 actual addition: سر از برج ماهی برآورد ماه / بدرید تا ناف شعر سیاه
- Mohl III45:1003 / Moscow IV172 n31 continued IV173 actual addition: ز ترکان برآید همه کام ما / برآید به خورشید بر نام ما
- Mohl III45:1004 / Moscow IV172 n31 continued IV173 actual addition: ز کار شبیخون نکردند یاد / سپاه و سپهبد همه گشت شاد
- Mohl III45:1007 running overnight remembrance: همه شب به یاد جهان پهلوان / همه شاد گشته و روشن روان
Selected Persian spacing normalized, not diplomatic. All inherited flags remain verbatim in CHECKPOINT.txt, including B10.26/B10.30/B10.31/B10.32.
B13.21 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV168:833 running text | III42:926 running text |
| 2 | IV168:835 running text; IV168 n17 actual alternate placement after835 | III42:927 running text |
| 3 | IV168:834 running text; IV168 n17 actual alternate placement after835 | III42:928 running text |
| 4 | IV168:836 running text | III42:929 running text |
| 5 | IV168:837 running text | III42:930 running text |
| 6 | IV168:838 running text; IV168 n25 actual hiding alternative | III42:931 running text |
| 7 | IV168:839 running text | III42:932 running text |
| 8 | IV168:840 running text | III42:933 running text |
| 9 | IV168:841 running text | III42:934 running text |
| 10 | IV169:842 running text | III42:935 running text |
| 11 | IV169:843 running text | III42:936 running text |
| 12 | IV169:844 running text | III42:937 running text |
| 13 | IV169:845 running text | III42:938 running text |
| 14 | IV169:846 running text | III42:939 running text |
| 15 | IV169:847 running text | III42:940 running text |
| 16 | IV169:848 running text | III42:941 running text |
| 17 | IV169:849 running text | III42:942; III43:943 running text |
| 18 | IV169:849–850 checked local gap between no-stir report and grief | III43:943 running text |
| 19 | IV169:850 running text; IV169 n14 actual child alternative | III43:944 running text |
| 20 | IV169:851 running text | III43:945 running text |
| 21 | IV169:852 running text | III43:946 running text |
| 22 | IV169:852,853 running text | III43:946,947 running text |
| 23 | IV169:853,854 running text | III43:947,948 running text |
| 24 | IV169:855 running text | III43:949 running text |
| 25 | IV169:856,857 running text | III43:950,951 running text |
| 26 | IV169:857 running text | III43:951 running text |
| 27 | IV169:858 running text | III43:952 running text |
| 28 | IV169:859 running text | III43:953 running text |
| 29 | IV170:860 running text | III43:954 running text |
| 30 | IV170:861 running text | III43:955 running text |
| 31 | IV170:862 running text | III43:956 running text |
| 32 | IV170:863 running text; IV170 n9 actual every-kind alternative | III43:957 running text |
| 33 | IV170:864 running text | III43:958 running text |
| 34 | IV170:865 running text | III43:959 running text |
| 35 | IV170:866 running text | III43:960 running text |
| 36 | IV170:867 running text | III43:961 running text |
| 37 | IV170:868 running text | III43:962 running text |
| 38 | IV170:869,870 running text | III43:963,964 running text |
| 39 | IV170:870 running text | III43:964 running text |
| 40 | IV170:871 running text | III43:965 running text |
| 41 | IV170:872 running text | III43:966 running text |
| 42 | IV170:873 running text | III43:967 running text |
| 43 | IV170:874 running text | III44:968 running text |
| 44 | IV170:875 running text | III44:969 running text |
| 45 | IV171:876 running text | III44:970 running text |
| 46 | IV171:877 running text | III44:971 running text |
| 47 | IV171:878 running text | III44:972 running text |
| 48 | IV171:879 running text | III44:973 running text |
| 49 | IV171:880 running text | III44:974 running text |
| 50 | IV171:881,882 running text | III44:975,976 running text |
| 51 | IV171:882,883 running text | III44:976,977 running text |
| 52 | IV171:883 running text | III44:977 running text |
| 53 | IV171:884,885 running text | III44:978,979 running text |
| 54 | IV171:885,886 running text | III44:979,980 running text |
| 55 | IV171:886 running text; IV171 n16 actual elephant alternative | III44:980 running text |
| 56 | IV171:887 running text | III44:981 running text |
| 57 | IV171:888 running text | III44:982 running text |
| 58 | IV171:889 running text | III44:983 running text |
| 59 | IV171:890 running text | III44:984 running text |
| 60 | IV171:891 running text | III44:985 running text |
| 61 | IV171:892 running text | III44:986 running text |
| 62 | IV171:893 running text | III44:987 running text |
| 63 | IV172:894 running text | III44:988 running text |
| 64 | IV172:895,896 running text | III44:989,990 running text |
| 65 | IV172:896,897 running text | III44:990,991 running text |
| 66 | IV172:897,898 running text | III44:991,992 running text |
| 67 | IV172:898 running text; IV172 n11 actual blood-river alternative | III44:992 running text |
| 68 | IV172:899 running text; IV172 n13 actual continuing-command alternative | III45:993 running text |
| 69 | IV172:900 running text; IV172 n15 actual negation alternatives | III45:994 running text |
| 70 | IV172:901 running text | III45:995 running text |
| 71 | IV172:902 running text | III45:996 running text |
| 72 | IV172 n21 actually printed moon verse after902; not running text | III45:997 running text |
| 73 | IV172:903 running text | III45:998 running text |
| 74 | IV172:904 running text | III45:999 running text |
| 75 | IV172:905 running text | III45:1000 running text |
| 76 | IV172:906 running text | III45:1001 running text |
| 77 | IV172:907 running text | III45:1002 running text |
| 78 | IV172 n31 continued IV173 actually printed desire/fame-sun verse after907; not running text | III45:1003 running text |
| 79 | IV172 n31 continued IV173 actually printed abandonment-of-raid verse after907; not running text | III45:1004 running text |
| 80 | IV173:908 running text | III45:1005 running text |
| 81 | IV173:909 running text | III45:1006 running text |
| 82 | IV173:909–910 checked local gap between scouts and sunrise | III45:1007 running text |
New Naqqali