Iran and Turan Set Their Battle Lines
B13.27,95 couplets;190 exact published line spans.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | B13.27,95 couplets;190 exact published line spans. |
| Moscow | IV188–194:1164–1258 (PDF188–194);95 running units plus inspected apparatus. |
| Mohl | III57–60:1278–1372 (PDF63–66);95 running units. |
| Ganjoor | Kamus sh14:104–198;95 running units, end of section. |
| Khaleghi | III176–182:1172–1266 (PDF192–198);95 running units;1267 next-scene boundary checked. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5Dawn turns into reconnaissance
Moscow IV188:1164 running text | IV188:1165 running text | IV189:1166 running text | IV189:1167 running text | IV189:1168 running text; Mohl III57:1278 running text | III57:1279 running text | III57:1280 running text | III57:1281 running text | III57:1282 running text; Ganjoor sh14:104 running poem body | sh14:105 running poem body | sh14:106 running poem body | sh14:107 running poem body | sh14:108 running poem body; Khaleghi III176:1172 running text | III176:1173 running text | III176:1174 running text | III176:1175 running text | III176:1176 running text
Moscow printed p.188 · Moscow printed p.189 · Mohl printed p.57 · Khaleghi printed p.176 · Ganjoor sh14:104 · Ganjoor sh14:105 · Ganjoor sh14:106 · Ganjoor sh14:107 · Ganjoor sh14:108
All four presentations open with an aggressive dawn: day seizes night’s tresses, emerges from a pitch-colored covering and bites the moon’s lip until it bleeds. English preserves the startling bodily violence, though robes replace the tentlike covering and dread adds an emotional quality. The drums then sound from two camps, not an indefinite multitude. Houman’s movement to the army’s front leads to an inquiry about the aid Iran has received. English anticipates that question as private thought and adds secrecy through hide. The tents are visible evidence of reinforcement; camp-walls and standards enlarge that evidence beyond the objects named in the immediate source question.
6–10Reading the new encampment
Moscow IV189:1169 running text | IV189:1170 running text; IV189:1170 armor main wording differs from fortune branch | IV189:1171 running text | IV189:1172 running text | IV189:1173 running text; Mohl III57:1283 running text | III57:1284 running text | III57:1285 running text | III57:1286 running text | III57:1287 running text; Ganjoor sh14:109 running poem body | sh14:110 running poem body | sh14:111 running poem body | sh14:112 running poem body | sh14:113 running poem body; Khaleghi III177:1177 running text | III177:1178 running text | III177:1179 running text | III177:1180 running text | III177:1181 running text
Moscow printed p.189 · Mohl printed p.57 · Khaleghi printed p.177 · Ganjoor sh14:109 · Ganjoor sh14:110 · Ganjoor sh14:111 · Ganjoor sh14:112 · Ganjoor sh14:113
The turquoise silk pavilion is surrounded by further curtains or pavilion structures in Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. English turns those surrounding textile structures into attendants, changing the evidence of an enlarged camp into a human retinue. Houman’s next observation has stronger variant support: Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi connect the standard and spear with altered fortune, whereas Moscow’s main wording concerns armor. English follows the fortune branch and makes Houman’s reflection explicit. The second pavilion is black in the checked texts, a color omitted in English, while its moonlike banner remains. Fariborz’s nearby elephants, drums and tents establish another recognizable contingent before Houman reports his anxiety to Piran.
11–15Noise, banners and recognizable troops
Moscow IV189:1174 running text | IV189:1175 running text | IV189:1176 running text | IV189:1177 running text | IV189:1178 running text; Mohl III57:1288 running text | III57:1289 running text | III57:1290 running text | III57:1291 running text | III57:1292 running text; Ganjoor sh14:114 running poem body | sh14:115 running poem body | sh14:116 running poem body | sh14:117 running poem body | sh14:118 running poem body; Khaleghi III177:1182 running text | III177:1183 running text | III177:1184 running text | III177:1185 running text | III177:1186 running text
Moscow printed p.189 · Mohl printed p.57 · Khaleghi printed p.177 · Ganjoor sh14:114 · Ganjoor sh14:115 · Ganjoor sh14:116 · Ganjoor sh14:117 · Ganjoor sh14:118
Houman compares the previous night’s Iranian clamor with earlier nights, then explains that he went out alone at dawn to inspect the army. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi account for this sequence of audible evidence followed by visual confirmation. English’s noise striking the sky heightens the first sign, and rode supplies a mount to the lone reconnaissance. The report identifies many reinforcements and then describes a green silk pavilion with a dragonlike standard at its foot. English introduces a shield beside that standard, which the inspected verse does not name. Zabul shield-bearers and Kabul daggers support the recognition of Rostam’s men; rings makes their surrounding position more geometrically ordered.
16–20Piran tests the frightening inference
Moscow IV189:1179 running text | IV189:1180 running text | IV189:1181 running text | IV189:1182 running text | IV189:1183 running text; Mohl III57:1293 running text | III57:1294 running text | III57:1295 running text | III57:1296 running text | III57:1297 running text; Ganjoor sh14:119 running poem body | sh14:120 running poem body | sh14:121 running poem body | sh14:122 running poem body | sh14:123 running poem body; Khaleghi III177:1187 running text | III177:1188 running text | III177:1189 running text | III177:1190 running text | III177:1191 running text
Moscow printed p.189 · Mohl printed p.57 · Khaleghi printed p.177 · Ganjoor sh14:119 · Ganjoor sh14:120 · Ganjoor sh14:121 · Ganjoor sh14:122 · Ganjoor sh14:123
Houman presents Rostam’s arrival as a conjecture, and Piran responds conditionally: if Rostam enters the contest, the great allies and Turanian champions will not survive. All four presentations retain that relation between uncertain identification and devastating expectation. English’s doom is clear intensifies the prediction but keeps its conditional basis. Piran then goes to inspect the situation himself. Moscow and Ganjoor direct attention toward the commander, while Mohl emphasizes the army’s imposing mass and Khaleghi the whole force. English’s battalions follows the latter emphasis, although grow suggests an increase happening before his eyes. His hurried return to Kamus, Manshur and Fartus preserves the practical consequence of the reconnaissance.
21–25The report meets Kamus’s rebuke
Moscow IV190:1184 running text | IV190:1185 running text | IV190:1186 running text | IV190:1187 running text; IV190 n6 actual vengeance-seeking alternative | IV190:1188 running text; Mohl III57:1298 running text | III57:1299 running text | III57:1300 running text | III58:1301 running text | III58:1302 running text; Ganjoor sh14:124 running poem body | sh14:125 running poem body | sh14:126 running poem body | sh14:127 running poem body | sh14:128 running poem body; Khaleghi III177:1192 running text | III177:1193 running text | III177:1194 running text | III177:1195 running text | III178:1196 running text
Moscow printed p.190 · Mohl printed p.57 · Mohl printed p.58 · Khaleghi printed p.177 · Khaleghi printed p.178 · Ganjoor sh14:124 · Ganjoor sh14:125 · Ganjoor sh14:126 · Ganjoor sh14:127 · Ganjoor sh14:128
Piran’s report repeats the dawn inspection and the arrival of numerous helpers, then identifies Rostam as the elephantine warrior previously described to the assembled chiefs. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi preserve both the conjecture and the appeal to earlier knowledge. English adds a bright Iranian sign and makes the reinforcement more explicitly immediate. Its vengeance-seeking Rostam has support in an actual Moscow alternative, although the main sequence in the other presentations emphasizes coming to help after leaving the Shah’s court. Being sent by the Shah is an inference from that departure. Kamus answers by locating the problem in Piran’s thoughts, converting a military assessment into an accusation of fearful imagination.
26–30A boast and a changed reaction
Moscow IV190:1189 running text | IV190:1190 running text | IV190:1191 running text | IV190:1192 running text | IV190:1193 running text; Mohl III58:1303 running text | III58:1304 running text | III58:1305 running text | III58:1306 running text | III58:1307 running text; Ganjoor sh14:129 running poem body | sh14:130 running poem body | sh14:131 running poem body | sh14:132 running poem body | sh14:133 running poem body; Khaleghi III178:1197 running text | III178:1198 running text | III178:1199 running text | III178:1200 running text | III178:1201 running text
Moscow printed p.190 · Mohl printed p.58 · Khaleghi printed p.178 · Ganjoor sh14:129 · Ganjoor sh14:130 · Ganjoor sh14:131 · Ganjoor sh14:132 · Ganjoor sh14:133
Kamus’s instruction to reckon that Kay Khosrow has come can be understood as a concessive challenge: even that prospect should not cause distress. English’s Know this sounds more like confirmed news of the king’s arrival, which the passage does not independently establish. His dismissal of Rostam and Zabulistan then leads to a striking boast. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor make a nahang roar in the Sea of Chin at the sight of Kamus’s flag; Khaleghi places the creature in blood-filled water, with variants recorded below. English replaces this nonhuman reaction with Rostam’s mourning heart. That changes both agent and image. The following commands to form ranks and avoid delay remain shared.
31–35Borrowed confidence and a renewed audience
Moscow IV190:1194 running text | IV190:1195 running text | IV190 n16 actual printed courage-water addition | IV190:1196 running text | IV190:1197 running text; Mohl III58:1308 running text | III58:1309 running text | III58:1310 running text | III58:1311 running text | III58:1312 running text; Ganjoor sh14:134 running poem body | sh14:135 running poem body | sh14:135–136 checked local running gap for courage-water addition | sh14:136 running poem body | sh14:137 running poem body; Khaleghi III178:1202 running text | III178:1203 running text | III178:1204 running text | III178:1205 running text | III178:1206 running text
Moscow printed p.190 · Mohl printed p.58 · Khaleghi printed p.178 · Ganjoor sh14:134 · Ganjoor sh14:135 · Ganjoor sh14:136 · Ganjoor sh14:137
The threatened sea of blood restores Piran’s courage in all four presentations, though English’s drowning plain makes the simile more actively destructive. His additional departure with a sound purpose and a soul washed in courage’s water is continuous in Mohl and Khaleghi and actually printed in Moscow’s apparatus. Ganjoor moves directly from relief about Rostam to distributing equipment, so its local gap cannot be treated as evidence against the fuller passage. English’s clear current develops the water metaphor without changing its emotional purpose. Piran arms the soldiers while remembering Kamus’s words, then approaches the Khan and kisses the earth. His confidence is visibly borrowed from the boast he has just heard.
36–40Courtesy makes a claim on assistance
Moscow IV190:1198 running text; IV190 n20 actual wisdom/thought alternative | IV190:1199 running text | IV190:1200 running text | IV190:1201 running text | IV191:1202 running text; Mohl III58:1313 running text | III58:1314 running text | III58:1315 running text | III58:1316 running text | III58:1317 running text; Ganjoor sh14:138 running poem body | sh14:139 running poem body | sh14:140 running poem body | sh14:141 running poem body | sh14:142 running poem body; Khaleghi III178:1207 running text | III178:1208 running text | III178:1209 running text | III178:1210 running text | III178:1211 running text
Moscow printed p.190 · Moscow printed p.191 · Mohl printed p.58 · Khaleghi printed p.178 · Ganjoor sh14:138 · Ganjoor sh14:139 · Ganjoor sh14:140 · Ganjoor sh14:141 · Ganjoor sh14:142
The greeting to the Khan differs materially. Mohl and Khaleghi nourish wisdom through thought, with a corresponding alternative actually printed in Moscow; Moscow’s main text and Ganjoor instead nourish the soul through sight. English follows the wisdom branch and extends it into guidance for royal deeds. The difficult journey and the exchange of feasting for hardship then give Piran’s request a courteous foundation in all four presentations. The sea crossing honors Afrasiab, while English adds sharing the war with Piran personally. The army’s straightened back is retained as a bodily image of strengthened confidence. Bells, daray and karnay preserve the ceremonial sound that accompanies the appeal to inherited worth.
41–45Who speaks the mace oath
Moscow IV191:1203 running text | IV191:1203 running text; IV191:1204 running text | IV191:1204 running text; IV191:1205 running text | IV191:1206 running text | IV191:1207 running text; Mohl III58:1318 running text | III58:1318 running text; III58:1319 running text | III58:1319 running text; III58:1320 running text | III58:1321 running text | III58:1322 running text; Ganjoor sh14:143 running poem body | sh14:143 running poem body; sh14:144 running poem body | sh14:144 running poem body; sh14:145 running poem body | sh14:146 running poem body | sh14:147 running poem body; Khaleghi III178:1212 running text | III178:1212 running text; III178:1213 running text | III178:1213 running text; III178:1214 running text | III178:1215 running text | III179:1216 running text
Moscow printed p.191 · Mohl printed p.58 · Khaleghi printed p.178 · Khaleghi printed p.179 · Ganjoor sh14:143 · Ganjoor sh14:144 · Ganjoor sh14:145 · Ganjoor sh14:146 · Ganjoor sh14:147
Piran offers to fight while the Khan remains with elephants and drums in the center, guarding the rear of Piran’s army. English’s guarded core adds a protective purpose to the position, and my rear makes the request more personal. The cap raised toward the clouds is a request for increased honor, followed by Piran’s report that Kamus has appointed him to lead. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi continue with Kamus’s oaths and raised mace within that report. English’s Then Kamus raised presents the gesture as fresh narration, altering the speech level and apparent timing. The vow to use only the mace even under falling stones remains recognizably supported.
46–50The Khan’s moving spectacle
Moscow IV191:1208 running text; IV191 n10 actual dust-feet alternative | IV191:1209 running text | IV191:1210 running text | IV191:1211 running text | IV191:1212 running text; Mohl III58:1323 running text | III58:1324 running text | III58:1325 running text | III59:1327 running text | III59:1328 running text; Ganjoor sh14:148 running poem body | sh14:149 running poem body | sh14:150 running poem body | sh14:151 running poem body | sh14:152 running poem body; Khaleghi III179:1217 running text | III179:1218 running text | III179:1219 running text; III179 n6 actual mahd alternative | III179:1220 running text | III179:1221 running text
Moscow printed p.191 · Mohl printed p.58 · Mohl printed p.59 · Khaleghi printed p.179 · Ganjoor sh14:148 · Ganjoor sh14:149 · Ganjoor sh14:150 · Ganjoor sh14:151 · Ganjoor sh14:152
The karnay’s effect varies: Moscow and Ganjoor make a mountain seem to move, while Mohl and Khaleghi give feet to the body of dust. An actual Moscow alternative also records the latter image, directly supporting English’s dust with feet. The drum passage is less exactly retained: the source’s falling or obscured sun disappears from English’s generalized shaking and rising war. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor bind a mahd to the elephant; Khaleghi’s main word differs but its apparatus actually records mahd. English makes the indigo world a result of the animal’s tread. The dark-cloud sky follows Mohl and Khaleghi, while hearts rising to mouths specifies a destination absent from the shared displaced-heart image.
51–55Splendor overwhelms sight
Moscow IV191:1213 running text | IV191:1214 running text | IV191:1215 running text | IV191:1216 running text | IV191:1217 running text; Mohl III59:1329 running text | III59:1326 running text | III59:1330 running text | III59:1331 running text | III59:1332 running text; Ganjoor sh14:153 running poem body | sh14:154 running poem body | sh14:155 running poem body | sh14:156 running poem body | sh14:157 running poem body; Khaleghi III179:1222 running text | III179:1223 running text | III179:1224 running text | III179:1225 running text | III179:1226 running text
Moscow printed p.191 · Mohl printed p.59 · Khaleghi printed p.179 · Ganjoor sh14:153 · Ganjoor sh14:154 · Ganjoor sh14:155 · Ganjoor sh14:156 · Ganjoor sh14:157
Turquoise thrones on elephants and overwhelming radiance connect the display with failing vision. Moscow, Khaleghi and Ganjoor compare the shining spectacle with the Nile, whereas Mohl emphasizes the illuminated plain over several miles. English’s sapphire sea preserves color and scale but replaces the named river; above the flags introduces flags where the Persian describes shining. Mohl also places the loss of sight before the Khan’s approach, while the other presentations place it after the throne display. English makes the thrones themselves steal the light, supplying a specific cause. Heaven’s dusty eye and mouth, its pitch-covered face and the moon losing its way then extend disorientation beyond the human spectators.
56–60Answering one formation with another
Moscow IV191:1218 running text | IV192:1219 running text | IV192:1227 running text; IV192:1227 relocated after aid request | IV192:1220 running text | IV192:1221 running text; Mohl III59:1333 running text | III59:1334 running text | III59:1335 running text | III59:1336 running text | III59:1337 running text; Ganjoor sh14:158 running poem body | sh14:159 running poem body | sh14:167 running poem body | sh14:160 running poem body | sh14:161 running poem body; Khaleghi III179:1227 running text | III179:1228 running text | III179:1229 running text | III179:1230 running text | III179:1231 running text
Moscow printed p.191 · Moscow printed p.192 · Mohl printed p.59 · Khaleghi printed p.179 · Ganjoor sh14:158 · Ganjoor sh14:159 · Ganjoor sh14:167 · Ganjoor sh14:160 · Ganjoor sh14:161
Piran takes the left with Houman and Kulbad, while Rostam responds to the Khan’s formation by preparing his own center. English omits Houman’s relationship to Piran and adds a movement toward the front. The order to Tus and the rooster-eye formation come before Rostam’s speech in Mohl and Khaleghi but after his request for help in Moscow and Ganjoor. English therefore follows a verified alternate order. Its colors interpret the striking simile rather than translate an explicit color list. Rostam then asks whom heaven will favor and whose appointed time will end. English’s repeated elevation imagery softens the sharp juxtaposition of favor with imminent death, though it retains the question of fate.
61–65Rakhsh’s exhaustion and a bounded omission
Moscow IV192:1222 running text; IV192 n7 actual three-stages alternative | IV192:1223 running text | IV192:1224 running text | IV192:1225 running text | IV192:1228 running text; Mohl III59:1338 running text | III59:1339 running text | III59:1340 running text | III59:1341 running text | III59:1342 running text; Ganjoor sh14:162 running poem body | sh14:163 running poem body | sh14:164 running poem body | sh14:165 running poem body | sh14:168 running poem body; Khaleghi III179:1232 running text; III179 n16 actual two-stages alternative | III180:1233 running text | III180:1234 running text | III180:1235 running text | III180:1236 running text
Moscow printed p.192 · Mohl printed p.59 · Khaleghi printed p.179 · Khaleghi printed p.180 · Ganjoor sh14:162 · Ganjoor sh14:163 · Ganjoor sh14:164 · Ganjoor sh14:165 · Ganjoor sh14:168 · Moscow1226 source-only protection · Mohl1341–1342 checked gap · Khaleghi180 n5 actual addition · Ganjoor166 source-only protection
Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor say Rakhsh made two stages into one; Khaleghi says three, and Moscow’s actual apparatus records three as well. English’s number is thus directly supported, although the added morning is not specified. The battered hoof and exhaustion explain why Rostam cannot demand further effort in a duel. His request is for help today and success against the enemy; English makes that success a payment of vengeance. Moscow and Ganjoor then add confidence that heaven, moon and sun protect Iran. Khaleghi actually prints this verse in its apparatus, while the checked Mohl running passage lacks it. It has no separate English counterpart and remains a source-only entry rather than being silently absorbed into the earlier questions about fate.
66–70The Iranian wings and the mountain view
Moscow IV192:1229 running text | IV192:1230 running text | IV192:1231 running text; IV192 n19 actual dust/wind alternative | IV192:1232 running text | IV192:1233 running text; Mohl III59:1343 running text | III59:1344 running text | III59:1345 running text | III59:1346 running text | III59:1347 running text; Ganjoor sh14:169 running poem body | sh14:170 running poem body | sh14:171 running poem body | sh14:172 running poem body | sh14:173 running poem body; Khaleghi III180:1237 running text | III180:1238 running text | III180:1239 running text | III180:1240 running text | III180:1241 running text
Moscow printed p.192 · Mohl printed p.59 · Khaleghi printed p.180 · Ganjoor sh14:169 · Ganjoor sh14:170 · Ganjoor sh14:171 · Ganjoor sh14:172 · Ganjoor sh14:173
Gudarz commands the right and sends baggage onto the rocky mountain, while Fariborz takes the left. All four sources preserve this contrast with the opposing baggage on the plain. The world becoming a reedbed is retained, with English explicitly supplying whirling standards as the visible cause. Tus occupies the center, but the surrounding image varies: Moscow and Ganjoor fill the earth with karnay sound, whereas Mohl and Khaleghi give dust below and wind above. Actual Moscow apparatus also records that branch. English follows its dust but adds the sun. The army becomes invisible even to its own warriors, and Rostam climbs for a broader view of the opposing force.
71–75A catalog whose order matters
Moscow IV192:1234 running text | IV192:1235 running text; IV192 n23–25 actual catalog alternatives | IV192:1236 running text; IV192 n24–25 actual catalog alternatives | IV193:1237 running text | IV193:1238 running text; Mohl III59:1348 running text | III59:1349 running text | III59:1350 running text | III60:1351 running text | III60:1352 running text; Ganjoor sh14:174 running poem body | sh14:175 running poem body | sh14:176 running poem body | sh14:177 running poem body | sh14:178 running poem body; Khaleghi III180:1242 running text | III180:1243 running text | III180:1244 running text | III180:1245 running text | III180:1246 running text
Moscow printed p.192 · Moscow printed p.193 · Mohl printed p.59 · Mohl printed p.60 · Khaleghi printed p.180 · Ganjoor sh14:174 · Ganjoor sh14:175 · Ganjoor sh14:176 · Ganjoor sh14:177 · Ganjoor sh14:178
The enormous army makes the Sea of Rum resemble a small wax bead in all four presentations. English’s lump loses the bead’s crafted shape while preserving the disproportion. The following peoples and places vary substantially in order and wording. Khaleghi’s main text includes Chini and Gahani forms alongside the other contingents, while Moscow and Mohl distribute names differently and include a red, yellow and black description; actual Moscow variants record alternative lists. English largely follows the fuller named grouping and omits that color grouping. Its Indus strand expands Sind rather than establishing another independently verified contingent. Foreign languages, unusual standards, provisions, ivory thrones and ornaments then retain the spectacle’s deliberate variety without requiring modern geographical identifications.
76–80Wonder, hesitation and continued courage
Moscow IV193:1239 running text | IV193:1240 running text | IV193:1241 running text | IV193:1242 running text | IV193:1243 running text; Mohl III60:1353 running text | III60:1354 running text | III60:1355 running text | III60:1356 running text | III60:1357 running text; Ganjoor sh14:179 running poem body | sh14:180 running poem body | sh14:181 running poem body | sh14:182 running poem body | sh14:183 running poem body; Khaleghi III180:1247 running text | III181:1248 running text | III181:1249 running text | III181:1250 running text | III181:1251 running text
Moscow printed p.193 · Mohl printed p.60 · Khaleghi printed p.180 · Khaleghi printed p.181 · Ganjoor sh14:179 · Ganjoor sh14:180 · Ganjoor sh14:181 · Ganjoor sh14:182 · Ganjoor sh14:183
The host turns the world into Paradise and makes ordinary beauty seem ugly by comparison in all four presentations. English’s beauty losing light moderates that sharper reversal. Rostam’s astonishment then leads to thought of turning or returning. This can suggest considering withdrawal, but the wording’s relation to his subsequent descent and reflection should remain interpretively qualified. English resolves it instead into pondering heaven’s purpose, anticipating the following question about the aged sky’s game. The later statement that he descends without losing heart remains important evidence against treating uncertainty as simple cowardice. His declaration that he has never stayed a full year in one place establishes the extensive experience behind his amazement.
81–85From observation to the fighting line
Moscow IV193:1244 running text | IV193:1245 running text | IV193:1245 running text; IV193:1246 running text | IV193:1246 running text | IV193:1247 running text; IV193:1248 running text; Mohl III60:1358 running text | III60:1359 running text | III60:1359 running text; III60:1360 running text | III60:1360 running text | III60:1361 running text; III60:1362 running text; Ganjoor sh14:184 running poem body | sh14:185 running poem body | sh14:185 running poem body; sh14:186 running poem body | sh14:186 running poem body | sh14:187 running poem body; sh14:188 running poem body; Khaleghi III181:1252 running text | III181:1253 running text | III181:1253 running text; III181:1254 running text | III181:1254 running text | III181:1255 running text; III181:1256 running text
Moscow printed p.193 · Mohl printed p.60 · Khaleghi printed p.181 · Ganjoor sh14:184 · Ganjoor sh14:185 · Ganjoor sh14:186 · Ganjoor sh14:187 · Ganjoor sh14:188
Rostam’s experience of many armies confirms that this host is exceptional in all four presentations. The order to raise the drums leads to Tus entering battle and descending from the mountain toward the plain. English distributes that compact sequence across several couplets, repeating the descent without requiring another Persian verse. The spear is already being drawn through blood in vengeance; English instead prepares it to kill hundreds, replacing enacted violence with a prospective and quantified threat. The army then passes for half a day and extends its line across two farsangs. Till noon fixes a time of day more narrowly than the duration alone permits. Dust supplies the transition from measured distance to obscured vision.
86–90The battle disturbs the sky
Moscow IV193:1248 running text | IV193:1249 running text | IV193:1250 running text | IV193:1251 running text | IV193:1252 running text; Mohl III60:1362 running text | III60:1363 running text | III60:1364 running text | III60:1365 running text | III60:1366 running text; Ganjoor sh14:188 running poem body | sh14:189 running poem body | sh14:190 running poem body | sh14:191 running poem body | sh14:192 running poem body; Khaleghi III181:1256 running text | III181:1257 running text | III181:1258 running text | III181:1259 running text | III181:1260 running text
Moscow printed p.193 · Mohl printed p.60 · Khaleghi printed p.181 · Ganjoor sh14:188 · Ganjoor sh14:189 · Ganjoor sh14:190 · Ganjoor sh14:191 · Ganjoor sh14:192
Dust removes the distinction between sunlight and night before arrows and their points darken the air and leave the sun bewildered. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi preserve this accumulating loss of ordinary perception. English brings spears into the first atmospheric transition and retains pikan in the next, redistributing the weapon imagery. The noise of riders and horses passes Bahram and Keyvan; Mars and Saturn identify those planets while red adds a visual characteristic. Axe blows and the riders’ agitation make hard rock sprout wings, an impossibility the English keeps vividly. Ruby-colored swords and forearms then bring the cosmic turbulence back to blood on bodies, with the earth’s groaning carried into the following couplet.
91–95Shrouds, omitted images and Kamus’s command
Moscow IV193:1252 running text; IV193:1253 running text | IV193:1253 running text | IV194:1256 running text | IV194:1257 running text; IV194 n4 actual lofty-battleplace alternative | IV194:1258 running text; IV194 n5 actual soul alternatives; Mohl III60:1366 running text; III60:1367 running text | III60:1367 running text | III60:1370 running text | III60:1371 running text | III60:1372 running text; Ganjoor sh14:192 running poem body; sh14:193 running poem body | sh14:193 running poem body | sh14:196 running poem body | sh14:197 running poem body | sh14:198 running poem body; Khaleghi III181:1260 running text; III181:1261 running text | III181:1261 running text | III181:1264 running text | III181:1265 running text; III181 n25 actual constrain/bind alternative | III182:1266 running text
Moscow printed p.193 · Moscow printed p.194 · Mohl printed p.60 · Khaleghi printed p.181 · Khaleghi printed p.182 · Ganjoor sh14:192 · Ganjoor sh14:193 · Ganjoor sh14:196 · Ganjoor sh14:197 · Ganjoor sh14:198 · Moscow1254–1255 source-only · Mohl1368–1369 source-only · Khaleghi1262–1263 source-only · Ganjoor194–195 source-only
The earth groans beneath hooves, cowardly hearts flee their bodies and brave men cut shrouds from their khaftan. English adds jowshan and iron clouds but preserves readiness for death. All four sources then include departing lions or an eagle image and the sun’s lost color above boiling earth; these two running verses lack separate English counterparts and remain source-only entries. Kamus’s command follows. His readiness to traverse heaven and demand for weapons are shared, but the destination differs: Moscow and Ganjoor constrict and bind the Iranians, while Mohl and Khaleghi summon weapons to the lofty battlefield. Actual apparatus records these branches. English follows the capture wording and the heart reading of the final martial maxim.
Source record and limits
Inspected 12 November 2026. B13.27 only. Moscow and Mohl individually inspected first via PNG facsimiles, then Ganjoor and Khaleghi. All 95 English couplets individually accounted for. Declared running units: Moscow 95, Mohl 95, Ganjoor 95, Khaleghi 95. Shared references deduplicated. Three source-only entries retained: S1 celestial protection; S2 lions/eagle; S3 sun and boiling earth.
Edition scope and inspected pages
- Published English B13.27: fresh HTML,190 exact line spans.
- Moscow: IV188–194:1164–1258 (PDF188–194);95 running units plus inspected apparatus. printed 188 / PDF 188, printed 189 / PDF 189, printed 190 / PDF 190, printed 191 / PDF 191, printed 192 / PDF 192, printed 193 / PDF 193, printed 194 / PDF 194.
- Mohl: III57–60:1278–1372 (PDF63–66);95 running units. printed 57 / PDF 63, printed 58 / PDF 64, printed 59 / PDF 65, printed 60 / PDF 66.
- Khaleghi: III176–182:1172–1266 (PDF192–198);95 running units;1267 next-scene boundary checked. printed 176 / PDF 192, printed 177 / PDF 193, printed 178 / PDF 194, printed 179 / PDF 195, printed 180 / PDF 196, printed 181 / PDF 197, printed 182 / PDF 198.
- Ganjoor sh14:104–198; section ends at 198.
Evidence distinctions and retained findings
Actual Moscow IV190 n16 courage-water addition supports English33 (continuous Mohl1310/Khaleghi1204; Ganjoor135–136 checked gap). Actual Khaleghi III180 n5 celestial-protection addition corresponds to Moscow1226/Ganjoor166 source-only S1; Mohl1341–1342 checked running gap, actual Mohl apparatus support unverified. Actual Moscow192 n7 three stages;191 n10 dust-feet;190 n20 wisdom/thought;194 n4 battle-place alternative; Khaleghi181 n25 constrain/bind alternative. Moscow/Ganjoor and Mohl/Khaleghi differ in order of Tus’s drum/formation; Mohl relocates loss-of-vision verse before Khan’s approach. All declared running units accounted, including S2/S3. No appendix evidence used or exhaustive appendix search claimed. Source availability and unprinted notices never count as verification.
English unchanged. Retained flags:6 attendants for surrounding curtains/pavilions;14 added shield;26 categorical royal-arrival wording for possible concessive supposition;28 Rostam’s mourning heart for nahang/sea reaction;44 reported oath made fresh narration;51 added flags and changed river image;60 repeated elevation for death/favor contrast;73 Indus expansion;77 possible withdrawal/return sense suppressed, interpretively qualified;84 intended hundredfold kills for bloodied spear;85 noon for half-day duration. Source-only S1–S3 retained. English61 three stages is verified in Khaleghi and actual Moscow apparatus, not an unsupported reading. Every inherited flag preserved.
Selected inspected readings
- Khaleghi III177:1178 fortune branch (Mohl1284 has a related reading): همان گردش اختر بد به پیش
- Moscow IV190:1191 / Mohl III58:1305 nahang in Sea of Chin: به دریای چین بر خروشد نهنگ
- Khaleghi III178:1199 blood-sea branch: به دریا درون خون خروشد نهنگ
- Mohl III58:1310 / Khaleghi III178:1204 / actual Moscow IV190 n16 courage-water addition: روان را به آب دلیری بشست
- Mohl III58:1323 / Khaleghi III179:1217 dust-feet; actual Moscow IV191 n10: تو گفتی که دارد تن خاک پای
- Khaleghi III179:1232 / actual Moscow IV192 n7 three stages: سه منزل همی کرد رخشم یکی
- Moscow IV192:1222 / Mohl III59:1338 / Ganjoor sh14:162 two stages: دو منزل همی کرد رخشم یکی
- Moscow IV192:1226 / actual Khaleghi III180 n5 protection; source-only: که گردان سپهر جهان یار ماست / مه و مهر گردون نگهدار ماست
- Moscow IV194:1257 / Ganjoor sh14:197 constrain/bind branch: به ایرانیان تنگ و بند آورید
- Mohl III60:1371 / Khaleghi III181:1265 battlefield branch: بدین رزمگاه بلند آورید
Source-only passages and alternate order
S1: Moscow1226 and Ganjoor166 affirm celestial protection; Khaleghi180 n5 actually prints the addition. Mohl1341–1342 supplies the bounded running gap. S2/S3: Moscow1254–1255, Mohl1368–1369, Khaleghi1262–1263 and Ganjoor194–195 have no separate English counterparts. Related earlier imagery does not certify relocation.
English58 follows Mohl1335/Khaleghi1229 placement before the fortune speech; Moscow1227/Ganjoor167 place the order after the aid request. English52 follows Moscow1214/Khaleghi1223/Ganjoor154 after the thrones; Mohl1326 places the loss of vision before the Khan’s approach. These are verified local reorderings.
The three stages of English61 match Khaleghi1232 and Moscow n7; the two-stage main texts remain separately recorded. The catalog is tracked at Moscow1235–1236 and n23–25, Mohl1349–1350, Khaleghi1243–1244 and Ganjoor175–176. Authorial Roman spellings are preserved; modern geographical equivalences are not certified here.
Persian quotations normalize spacing, not diplomatic transcription. All inherited flags, including B10.26/B10.30/B10.31/B10.32, retained. Structural checks do not certify browser or actual site converter execution.
B13.27 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV188:1164 running text | III57:1278 running text |
| 2 | IV188:1165 running text | III57:1279 running text |
| 3 | IV189:1166 running text | III57:1280 running text |
| 4 | IV189:1167 running text | III57:1281 running text |
| 5 | IV189:1168 running text | III57:1282 running text |
| 6 | IV189:1169 running text | III57:1283 running text |
| 7 | IV189:1170 running text; IV189:1170 armor main wording differs from fortune branch | III57:1284 running text |
| 8 | IV189:1171 running text | III57:1285 running text |
| 9 | IV189:1172 running text | III57:1286 running text |
| 10 | IV189:1173 running text | III57:1287 running text |
| 11 | IV189:1174 running text | III57:1288 running text |
| 12 | IV189:1175 running text | III57:1289 running text |
| 13 | IV189:1176 running text | III57:1290 running text |
| 14 | IV189:1177 running text | III57:1291 running text |
| 15 | IV189:1178 running text | III57:1292 running text |
| 16 | IV189:1179 running text | III57:1293 running text |
| 17 | IV189:1180 running text | III57:1294 running text |
| 18 | IV189:1181 running text | III57:1295 running text |
| 19 | IV189:1182 running text | III57:1296 running text |
| 20 | IV189:1183 running text | III57:1297 running text |
| 21 | IV190:1184 running text | III57:1298 running text |
| 22 | IV190:1185 running text | III57:1299 running text |
| 23 | IV190:1186 running text | III57:1300 running text |
| 24 | IV190:1187 running text; IV190 n6 actual vengeance-seeking alternative | III58:1301 running text |
| 25 | IV190:1188 running text | III58:1302 running text |
| 26 | IV190:1189 running text | III58:1303 running text |
| 27 | IV190:1190 running text | III58:1304 running text |
| 28 | IV190:1191 running text | III58:1305 running text |
| 29 | IV190:1192 running text | III58:1306 running text |
| 30 | IV190:1193 running text | III58:1307 running text |
| 31 | IV190:1194 running text | III58:1308 running text |
| 32 | IV190:1195 running text | III58:1309 running text |
| 33 | IV190 n16 actual printed courage-water addition | III58:1310 running text |
| 34 | IV190:1196 running text | III58:1311 running text |
| 35 | IV190:1197 running text | III58:1312 running text |
| 36 | IV190:1198 running text; IV190 n20 actual wisdom/thought alternative | III58:1313 running text |
| 37 | IV190:1199 running text | III58:1314 running text |
| 38 | IV190:1200 running text | III58:1315 running text |
| 39 | IV190:1201 running text | III58:1316 running text |
| 40 | IV191:1202 running text | III58:1317 running text |
| 41 | IV191:1203 running text | III58:1318 running text |
| 42 | IV191:1203 running text; IV191:1204 running text | III58:1318 running text; III58:1319 running text |
| 43 | IV191:1204 running text; IV191:1205 running text | III58:1319 running text; III58:1320 running text |
| 44 | IV191:1206 running text | III58:1321 running text |
| 45 | IV191:1207 running text | III58:1322 running text |
| 46 | IV191:1208 running text; IV191 n10 actual dust-feet alternative | III58:1323 running text |
| 47 | IV191:1209 running text | III58:1324 running text |
| 48 | IV191:1210 running text | III58:1325 running text |
| 49 | IV191:1211 running text | III59:1327 running text |
| 50 | IV191:1212 running text | III59:1328 running text |
| 51 | IV191:1213 running text | III59:1329 running text |
| 52 | IV191:1214 running text | III59:1326 running text |
| 53 | IV191:1215 running text | III59:1330 running text |
| 54 | IV191:1216 running text | III59:1331 running text |
| 55 | IV191:1217 running text | III59:1332 running text |
| 56 | IV191:1218 running text | III59:1333 running text |
| 57 | IV192:1219 running text | III59:1334 running text |
| 58 | IV192:1227 running text; IV192:1227 relocated after aid request | III59:1335 running text |
| 59 | IV192:1220 running text | III59:1336 running text |
| 60 | IV192:1221 running text | III59:1337 running text |
| 61 | IV192:1222 running text; IV192 n7 actual three-stages alternative | III59:1338 running text |
| 62 | IV192:1223 running text | III59:1339 running text |
| 63 | IV192:1224 running text | III59:1340 running text |
| 64 | IV192:1225 running text | III59:1341 running text |
| 65 | IV192:1228 running text | III59:1342 running text |
| 66 | IV192:1229 running text | III59:1343 running text |
| 67 | IV192:1230 running text | III59:1344 running text |
| 68 | IV192:1231 running text; IV192 n19 actual dust/wind alternative | III59:1345 running text |
| 69 | IV192:1232 running text | III59:1346 running text |
| 70 | IV192:1233 running text | III59:1347 running text |
| 71 | IV192:1234 running text | III59:1348 running text |
| 72 | IV192:1235 running text; IV192 n23–25 actual catalog alternatives | III59:1349 running text |
| 73 | IV192:1236 running text; IV192 n24–25 actual catalog alternatives | III59:1350 running text |
| 74 | IV193:1237 running text | III60:1351 running text |
| 75 | IV193:1238 running text | III60:1352 running text |
| 76 | IV193:1239 running text | III60:1353 running text |
| 77 | IV193:1240 running text | III60:1354 running text |
| 78 | IV193:1241 running text | III60:1355 running text |
| 79 | IV193:1242 running text | III60:1356 running text |
| 80 | IV193:1243 running text | III60:1357 running text |
| 81 | IV193:1244 running text | III60:1358 running text |
| 82 | IV193:1245 running text | III60:1359 running text |
| 83 | IV193:1245 running text; IV193:1246 running text | III60:1359 running text; III60:1360 running text |
| 84 | IV193:1246 running text | III60:1360 running text |
| 85 | IV193:1247 running text; IV193:1248 running text | III60:1361 running text; III60:1362 running text |
| 86 | IV193:1248 running text | III60:1362 running text |
| 87 | IV193:1249 running text | III60:1363 running text |
| 88 | IV193:1250 running text | III60:1364 running text |
| 89 | IV193:1251 running text | III60:1365 running text |
| 90 | IV193:1252 running text | III60:1366 running text |
| 91 | IV193:1252 running text; IV193:1253 running text | III60:1366 running text; III60:1367 running text |
| 92 | IV193:1253 running text | III60:1367 running text |
| 93 | IV194:1256 running text | III60:1370 running text |
| 94 | IV194:1257 running text; IV194 n4 actual lofty-battleplace alternative | III60:1371 running text |
| 95 | IV194:1258 running text; IV194 n5 actual soul alternatives | III60:1372 running text |
New Naqqali