Khosrow Dispatches Tus to Turan
32 published English couplets unchanged; seven substantive notes.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 32 published English couplets unchanged; seven substantive notes. |
| Moscow IV | Printed120–122:77–111,35 running units. Opening77–78 overlaps the relocated comparison in B13.3. |
| Mohl III | Printed7–8:91–121,31 running units; PDF13–14. Shorter post-pay ceremony and reversed Bahram-warning order. |
| Ganjoor | Kamus sh2:61–81 plus sh3:1–14,35 running units. sh3:15 captured as boundary only. sh2:61–62 overlaps B13.3 comparison. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh III | Printed110–112:88–118,31 running units; PDF126–128. Actual local additions distinguished from unprinted relocation notices. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5The old feud and a newly personalized shame
Moscow IV120:77–78,121:79–81; Mohl III7:91–95; Ganjoor sh2:61–65; Khaleghi III110:88–92.
The dawn and royal audience are shared, though Moscow and Ganjoor's opening pair also supplied the comparison for the differently positioned dawn in B13.3. They must not be counted twice as unique source verses. Khosrow then invokes the enduring trace of vengeance and the ancient conflict of Salm and Tur. English makes the history more explicit by adding Manuchehr's avenging spears, but neither that name nor those weapons occurs in the checked passage or its relevant local apparatus. This is historical enlargement rather than a verified local variant. The following first-person shame effectively personalizes the source's unprecedented disgrace of Iran's king while preserving the contrast between royal humiliation and the warriors' blood.
6–9Blood, mourning nature, and collective reproach
Moscow IV121:82–85; Mohl III7:96–99; Ganjoor sh2:66–69; Khaleghi III111:93–96 and n1.
English retains the concentrated horror of the bloodied landscape and the scattered limbs. The Gudarzian identification follows Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor; Khaleghi's main text broadens the group to Iranians, while printing related Gudarzian wording among variants. The girdle image requires more care: making the mountain's core the wearer resolves an ambiguity, especially where Khaleghi describes the Iranians actively binding their waists. The mourning birds and fish are shared, but the mountain-and-sea setting follows Moscow and Ganjoor rather than Mohl and Khaleghi's stream-and-sea wording. The final rebuke then accuses the living of choosing pleasure over vengeance. English preserves that moral pressure without turning the preceding dismemberment into a fresh battlefield event.
10–16Public submission and the celestial exception
Moscow IV121:86–91 and n29; Mohl III7–8:100–106; Ganjoor sh2:70–75 and75–76 gap; Khaleghi III111:97–103.
The assembled heroes answer through bodily submission, named attendance and a promise to give their lives. English keeps the collective voice and the major names despite changing their order. Its patronymic reading of Zangeh Shavaran should remain an interpretation of the naming formula, not fresh genealogical evidence established by this verse alone. The concluding promise against future fault belongs to Mohl and Khaleghi's running text and is actually printed in Moscow's apparatus; Ganjoor lacks it locally. English renders its exception through a positive condition: celestial favor must remain bright. That preserves the rhetorical dependence on sun and moon, but translates cosmic darkening into fortune's condition rather than reproducing the original formulation literally.
17–22Giv’s authority and the lesson drawn from Bahram
Moscow IV121–122:92–97; Mohl III8:107–112; Ganjoor sh2:76–81; Khaleghi III111:104–109.
The honors bestowed on Giv lead to a concrete restriction on Tus: the commander cannot take elephants and drums to war without Giv's judgment. English's veto formulation makes that safeguard clear and follows the sources' negative command. The ensuing warning is less uniform. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor prohibit making a small affair dangerous through rashness; Khaleghi's main text asks retrospectively about a terrible deed. Mohl also places the darkened-world verse before the warning. English follows the instructional arrangement and retains the blessing of Bahram's soul, adding fire to its luminosity. Evil counsel narrows the wider bad-speech wording: the passage does not independently identify an adviser whose counsel caused the tragedy.
23–25Pay, counsel, and an unverified fame maxim
Moscow IV122:98–103; Mohl III8:113–114; Ganjoor sh3:1–6; Khaleghi III112:110–111 and n2.
The material preparations are securely attested: money is distributed, paymasters summoned, and the commander addressed. Mohl and Khaleghi make that speech gracious, whereas English emphasizes firmness and clarity. The next English couplet's maxim about brief life and lasting fame has no verified counterpart in the inspected local texts or apparatus. Moscow and Ganjoor instead record consultation extending until evening, followed by another dawn and audience; Mohl and Khaleghi proceed directly to choosing an auspicious day. Khaleghi's printed consultation addition does not supply the missing maxim. The fame statement should therefore remain explicitly unverified. The following astrological selection is supported across all four, although the banner's presentation occupies different positions in their ceremonial sequences.
26–29The commander, the banner, and the army’s sound
Moscow IV122:102–108; Mohl III8:115–118; Ganjoor sh3:5–11; Khaleghi III112:112–115 and n5.
The departure is a public ceremony rather than a battle. All four preserve the Kaviani standard, royal blessing and the overwhelming sound of the moving force. English's hoof-driven boiling has particularly direct support in Mohl, while Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi emphasize the horses' noise. The commander's approach is not identical across witnesses: Moscow and Ganjoor explicitly bring Tus before the king after the army and have him kiss the ground. Mohl and Khaleghi instead give the waiting king with drums and elephants, without that separate approach verse. English combines the emergence and equipment under Tus and omits the kiss. Calling the gavdam a karnay explains the instrument rather than adding a second source instrument.
30–32Violet armor and the uncertain traveler
Moscow IV122:104,109–111; Mohl III8:115,119–121; Ganjoor sh3:7,12–14; Khaleghi III112:112,116–118.
The violet world, submerged sun and sleeping heavens are shared parade images, and English preserves their accumulating visual obscuration. Its last couplet combines two separated moments: the king waiting while the commander passes, and a turquoise litter placed on an elephant before movement to the river Shahd. The former belongs earlier in all four ceremonial accounts; the latter does not explicitly name its traveler. English's possessive may consequently attach the elephant and journey to the Shah because he is the nearest named subject. That identification is not independently secured by the final Persian couplet and should remain qualified. The movement and litter themselves are attested; blue is a generalized rendering of their turquoise description.
Source record
Moscow120–122, Mohl III7–8 and Khaleghi III110–112 visually inspected with relevant local apparatus. Positive additions include Moscow121 n29, Khaleghi112 n2 and n5; Khaleghi111 n1 prints Gudarzian variants. Khaleghi112 n2 also contains relocation references without reprinting the relevant whole verses; those notices are not treated as verification. No appendix evidence invoked or exhaustive appendix search claimed. Selected Persian excerpts normalize spacing and are not full diplomatic transcripts.
English4 Manuchehr is not named locally;6 mountain-core girdling resolves an ambiguous image;12 patronymic interpretation not independently established here;21 fire adds to luminous soul;22 counsel narrows bad speech;24 brief-life/lasting-fame maxim unverified;26 Tus’s equipment/arrival combines differing ceremonial accounts;32 relocates the waiting-Shah clause and leaves a potentially misleading royal-traveler antecedent. All inherited flags remain, including B13.2.37–38 and B13.3 chronology/agency.
Selected printed excerpts normalize spacing only. Persian display follows the labelled Ganjoor sh2/sh3 references, except English16, explicitly labelled Mohl106. English24 has no Persian display because no counterpart was verified. Four source-only rows retain additional ceremony and consultation units. No composite Persian is reconstructed; every edition-specific reading and checked gap retains its own locator.
Selected printed readings
Mohl III8:106 running promise against fault
مگر تیره گردد رخ هور و ماه
Moscow IV121 n29 actually printed promise excerpt
مگر تیره گردد رخ هور و ماه
Khaleghi III111:103 running promise
مگر تیره گردد رخ هور و ماه
Mohl III8:112 running warning and blessing
که روشن روان باد بهرام گرد
Khaleghi III111:108 running retrospective question
که روشن روان باد بهرام گرد
Moscow IV122:99 source-only consultation until evening
چنین تا رخ روز شد در نهان
Khaleghi III112 n2 actually printed consultation excerpt
Khaleghi III112 n5 actually printed army comparison
گذشتند بر پیش بیدار شاه
Mohl III8:115 king in the field
چنان تا سپهبد بر او برگذشت
Moscow IV122:106 Tus bows after the army
بیامد بر شه زمین داد بوس
Mohl III8:121 elephant litter and river
همی رفت زین گونه تا رود شهد
B13.4 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow IV | Mohl III |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV120:77 running text | III7:91 running text |
| 2 | IV120:78 running text | III7:92 running text |
| 3 | IV121:79 running text | III7:93 running text |
| 4 | IV121:80 running text | III7:94 running text |
| 5 | IV121:81 running text | III7:95 running text |
| 6 | IV121:82 running text | III7:96 running text |
| 7 | IV121:83 running text | III7:97 running text |
| 8 | IV121:84 running text | III7:98 running text |
| 9 | IV121:85 running text | III7:99 running text |
| 10 | IV121:86 running text | III7:100 running text |
| 11 | IV121:87 running text | III7:101 running text |
| 12 | IV121:88 running text | III7:102 running text |
| 13 | IV121:89 running text | III8:103 running text |
| 14 | IV121:90 running text | III8:104 running text |
| 15 | IV121:91 running text | III8:105 running text |
| 16 | IV121:91–92 checked running gap; IV121 n29 actually printed promise addition | III8:106 running text |
| 17 | IV121:92 running text | III8:107 running text |
| 18 | IV121:93 running text | III8:108 running text |
| 19 | IV121:94 running text | III8:109 running text |
| 20 | IV122:95 running text | III8:110 running text |
| 21 | IV122:96 running text | III8:112 running text |
| 22 | IV122:97 running text | III8:111 running text |
| 23 | IV122:98 running text | III8:113 running text |
| 24 | IV122:98–103 checked local passage; no brief-life/lasting-fame maxim verified in running text or inspected local apparatus | III8:113–114 checked local gap for brief-life/lasting-fame maxim |
| 25 | IV122:103 running text | III8:114 running text |
| 26 | IV122:104; IV122:106 running text | III8:115 running text |
| 27 | IV122:102 running text | III8:116 running text |
| 28 | IV122:107 running text | III8:117 running text |
| 29 | IV122:108 running text | III8:118 running text |
| 30 | IV122:109 running text | III8:119 running text |
| 31 | IV122:110 running text | III8:120 running text |
| 32 | IV122:104; IV122:111 running text | III8:115; III8:121 running text |
New Naqqali