Piran’s Message to the Army of Iran
25 published English couplets, preserved verbatim.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 25 published English couplets, preserved verbatim. |
| Moscow IV | Printed123–124:112–135,24 running couplets;123 n15 actually prints the fuller reply. |
| Mohl III | Printed8–9:122–146,25 running couplets;PDF14–15. Fuller reply in running text. |
| Ganjoor | Kamus sh3:15–38,24 running couplets;39 captured as following boundary only. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh III | Printed112–114:119–142,24 running couplets;PDF128–130. Main reply shorter;141 punctuated as a question. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5A reluctant response to an open challenge
Moscow IV123:112–116; Mohl III8–9:122–126; Ganjoor sh3:15–19; Khaleghi III112:119–123.
The challenge establishes readiness at the river rather than describing an attack already begun. The English retains the raised neck, the swift dispatch and Piran’s reconnaissance purpose, so its martial confidence belongs to Tus’s message. Piran’s response is less uniform across editions: three explicitly mark reluctance, whereas Mohl describes the loading as sudden or unexpected. The English follows the former reading when it makes departure unwilling; that distinction should not disappear into a claim of fourfold agreement. Its selected chiefs and riders preserve the commander’s deliberate choice of company. The final inquiry keeps the identities of Tus’s companions but makes the source’s separate interest in their number less explicit, slightly narrowing the reconnaissance.
6–10Diplomacy across the river
Moscow IV123:117–121; Mohl III9:127–131; Ganjoor sh3:20–24; Khaleghi III112–113:124–128.
All four accounts establish opposing banks before the smooth-speaking envoy carries Piran’s appeal. The English’s change of viewpoint places Tus across the stream from Piran; it need not imply that Tus crosses during this passage. Describing the greeting as kind adds a conciliatory tone to the source’s ordinary salutation, while the envoy’s verbal skill already makes diplomacy purposeful. Piran invokes his own treatment of Farangis and the king; naming Khosrow resolves the royal title without changing its referent. These benefits remain claims within Piran’s message. The English’s added emotional assurances strengthen his self-presentation, and its boiling grief preserves the source’s fire imagery rather than converting remembered suffering into a new physical ordeal.
11–14The fuller conditional reply
Moscow IV123:122–124 and actually printed n15; Mohl III9:132–135; Ganjoor sh3:25–27; Khaleghi III113:129–131 and n14.
The remedy becoming poison turns former kindness into grievance. The English substitutes nush-daru for the printed tiryak, retaining the medicinal contrast without reproducing its noun. Tus’s sorrow is common to all four, though the editions differently emphasize conflict, demeanor or speech. More significantly, the envoy instruction and conditional ending of contention run in Mohl and are actually printed in Moscow’s apparatus. The shorter Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi main replies instead point to visible signs of affection; that alternative receives its own register row. Khaleghi’s different printed addition does not verify the conditional exchange. The English therefore has fuller support, but its vocative may redirect Piran’s bright-souled epithet toward the messenger who is being addressed.
15–19Reward offered with the army
Moscow IV123–124:125–129; Mohl III9:136–140; Ganjoor sh3:28–32; Khaleghi III113:132–136.
The invitation combines safety with reward for past kindness, but its military condition requires an explicit flag. All four checked texts tell Piran to approach Iran’s Shah with the army. The English requires an unarmed approach instead, changing the proposed incorporation of a force into a personal submission. No inspected local variant supplies the missing negation, so this cannot be defended as an attested edition choice. The promised office, crown and sympathetic remembrance otherwise remain recognizable. English renown amplifies the reward, while its account of shared pain develops the king’s compassion. Associating Gudarz, Giv and the other chiefs with the offer supports collective endorsement; their choice of a wiser course is interpretive characterization.
20–23A reported answer and a conditional following
Moscow IV124:130–133; Mohl III9:141–144; Ganjoor sh3:33–36; Khaleghi III113:137–140.
The return journey keeps the exchange mediated: the envoy reports what he heard rather than introducing direct contact between the commanders. All four name Tus and Gudarz as sources of the answer, and the English correctly attaches the luminous-soul epithet to Gudarz here. Its assurance of faithful reporting adds a narrator’s certification beyond the basic report. Piran’s response then enlarges remembrance into lifelong praise; the source’s day-and-night expression marks repeated remembrance without explicitly promising celebration throughout his remaining life. His accompanying kin are also qualified by their willingness to heed counsel. The English retains that restriction in its second line, although winning their hearts makes their acceptance sound more prospective and persuasive.
24–25A promise emptied by the narrator
Moscow IV124:134–135; Mohl III9:145–146; Ganjoor sh3:37–38; Khaleghi III114:141–142 and n1.
The departure formula is not identical across the editions. Mohl specifies kin and baggage, while the other three name land, home and possessions; Khaleghi additionally presents the first hemistich with interrogative punctuation. The English makes an affirmative crossing with wealth and gear, simplifying these differences and leaving landed attachment unexpressed. Its preference for an honored head over crown and throne preserves the shared comparison, though honor is less explicitly reputational than the Persian epithet. The following narrator statement decisively exposes Piran’s insincerity in all four texts. English makes intended nonperformance explicit and turns the search for better days into tactical opportunity. This disclosure belongs outside Piran’s speech: the chapter records a delaying promise, not a completed defection.
Source record
Moscow IV123–124 and Mohl III8–9 inspected first; Ganjoor sh3 and Khaleghi III112–114 compared afterward. Relevant local printed apparatus inspected. Moscow123 n15 actually prints both fuller reply couplets. Khaleghi113 n14 prints different reply material; it does not verify the Mohl conditional unit. No appendix evidence invoked or exhaustive appendix search claimed. No unprinted addition notice counted as verification. Selected Persian readings normalize spacing and are excerpts, not full diplomatic transcriptions.
Principal flag: English16 without an armed band reverses with the army in all four checked texts; no local negative variant verified. English13 may shift bright-souled from Piran to the envoy. English24 combines an affirmative departure with wealth/gear; Mohl specifies kin/baggage, the other three land/home/possessions, and Khaleghi marks a question. English3 reluctance follows Moscow/Ganjoor/Khaleghi, not Mohl sudden loading. English22 lifetime praise expands day-and-night remembrance. Prior flags retained.
Selected printed excerpts normalize spacing only. Persian display follows Ganjoor sh3 except English13–14, explicitly labelled Mohl134–135. One source-only row preserves the different main-text reply in Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. No composite Persian is reconstructed; every edition-specific reading and checked gap retains its own locator.
Selected printed readings
Mohl III8:124 running unexpected loading
که بر بست ناگاه بر پیل رخت
Mohl III9:134 running envoy instruction
که رو پیش پیران روشن روان
Mohl III9:135 running conditional reconciliation
مرا با تو گفتار آمد به بن
Moscow IV123 n15 actually printed envoy instruction
که رو پیش پیران روشن روان
Moscow IV123 n15 actually printed conditional reconciliation
مرا با تو گفتار آمد به بن
Moscow IV123:124 running reply
فراوان نشاندست بر چهر تو
Khaleghi III113:131 running reply
فراوان نشانست بر چهر تو
Mohl III9:137 running approach with army
مکافات یابی به نیکی ز شاه
Khaleghi III113:133 running approach with army
مکافات یابی به نیکی ز شاه
Mohl III9:145 running kin and baggage
سر نامور بهتر از تاج و تخت
Khaleghi III114:141 running land and possessions, interrogative punctuation
سر نامور بهتر از تاج و تخت!
Khaleghi III113 n14 actually printed alternative reply, excerpt
چنان چون بود درخور شهریار
B13.5 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow IV | Mohl III |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV123:112 running text | III8:122 running text |
| 2 | IV123:113 running text | III8:123 running text |
| 3 | IV123:114 running text | III8:124 running text |
| 4 | IV123:115 running text | III8:125 running text |
| 5 | IV123:116 running text | III9:126 running text |
| 6 | IV123:117 running text | III9:127 running text |
| 7 | IV123:118 running text | III9:128 running text |
| 8 | IV123:119 running text | III9:129 running text |
| 9 | IV123:120 running text | III9:130 running text |
| 10 | IV123:121 running text | III9:131 running text |
| 11 | IV123:122 running text | III9:132 running text |
| 12 | IV123:123 running text | III9:133 running text |
| 13 | IV123:123–125 checked main-text sequence; IV123 n15 actually printed envoy-instruction addition | III9:134 running text |
| 14 | IV123:123–125 checked main-text sequence; IV123 n15 actually printed conditional-reconciliation addition | III9:135 running text |
| 15 | IV123:125 running text | III9:136 running text |
| 16 | IV123:126 running text | III9:137 running text |
| 17 | IV123:127 running text | III9:138 running text |
| 18 | IV123:128 running text | III9:139 running text |
| 19 | IV124:129 running text | III9:140 running text |
| 20 | IV124:130 running text | III9:141 running text |
| 21 | IV124:131 running text | III9:142 running text |
| 22 | IV124:132 running text | III9:143 running text |
| 23 | IV124:133 running text | III9:144 running text |
| 24 | IV124:134 running text | III9:145 running text |
| 25 | IV124:135 running text | III9:146 running text |
New Naqqali