Tus and Houman Meet in Combat
95 published couplets preserved verbatim.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 95 published couplets preserved verbatim. |
| Moscow IV | Printed127–133:184–280,97 running units; local printed apparatus inspected. |
| Mohl III | Printed12–15:196–289,94 running units; PDF18–21. Printed16 checked as following boundary. |
| Ganjoor | Kamus sh4:1–97,97 running units;98 is following boundary. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh III | Printed117–123:192–285,94 running units; PDF133–139. Actual additions in120 n7,121 n1 and122 n11 distinguished from running text. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5An armored mountain and two different trees
Moscow IV127:184–188; Mohl III12:196–200; Ganjoor sh4:1–5; Khaleghi III117:192–196.
The entrance gives Houman monumental weight before anyone begins to argue. All four checked texts move from the eagle-like horse to an iron barrier and armored Alborz, then to the spear and Tus’s arrival. The English preserves that progression while adding brightness, height and instrumental placement. Its tree accusation needs a different account. Mohl explicitly connects the Viseh line with an ill-fated tree and bad fruit, so the English is not simply inventing a genealogy absent from Ganjoor. Moscow and Ganjoor instead question growth from vengeance’s garden; Khaleghi names Viseh but keeps the interrogative growth image. The affirmative English tree and fruit therefore follow a particular printed branch. Recording all four as identical would conceal the evidence that actually supports the translation.
6–10The oath and the missing victory boast
Moscow IV127:189–193, IV128:194; Mohl III12:201–206; Ganjoor sh4:6–11; Khaleghi III117:197–202.
Before the mounted challenge, every checked running text has Tus recall his blow against Arzhang. There is no separate English counterpart between the tree accusation and the revenge question; the register retains that source-only verse. The omission removes a specific provocation but not the oath’s underlying confidence, since the preceding subchapter has already narrated Arzhang’s death. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi then agree on Khosrow’s life, the discarded armor, mace and Roman helmet, and the mountain leopard attack. The English’s specialized equipment words are consequently substantive, not decorative additions. Its threat remains a conditional display of Tus’s courage, answered by Houman’s warning against arrogant speech. The added mortal risk in the question makes an implicit consequence explicit without introducing a new combat event.
11–16A commander’s exposed life
Moscow IV128:195–199; Mohl III12:207–211; Ganjoor sh4:12–16; Khaleghi III117:203, III118:204–207.
Houman turns one man’s death into a lesson about the danger of generalizing from an unlucky encounter. All four sources preserve that argumentative reversal: Arzhang’s defeat does not measure Houman, and Iran ought to have other fighters. The English distributes the shame, hot blood, commander and ineffective hands over several couplets before extending the naming of Gudarz. This is redistribution rather than evidence of extra Persian verses. Khaleghi’s tied hands differs from the ineffective-hand language in Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor; the English’s weakness belongs with the latter, while slowness is its own intensification. The grander description of Gudarz enlarges an epithet but does not establish another historical feat. Most importantly, the attack on Tus’s leadership remains Houman’s adversarial speech, not the narrator’s verdict.
17–22The banner and the aspirant to honor
Moscow IV128:200–204; Mohl III12:212–216; Ganjoor sh4:17–21; Khaleghi III118:208–212.
The distinction between commanding and fighting gives this speech more than the usual exchange of boasts. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all tell Tus to remain associated with the Kavian standard and send someone seeking the rewards of distinction. The English keeps the banner’s strategic importance but makes its proposed substitute a tested chief already marked by investiture. That wording slightly changes the emphasis of a source sequence organized around what a warrior seeks: robe of honor, signet and crown. The three English couplets on selecting and sending him expand two Persian units, so their references deliberately overlap. Proving Iran’s strength before everyone is an explanatory conclusion, not a further edition-specific line. Houman’s recommendation can be tactically sensible and rhetorically self-serving at the same time.
23–28The army’s need and the Sam chain
Moscow IV128:205–206,209–211; Mohl III12:217–218, III13:221–223; Ganjoor sh4:22–23,26–28; Khaleghi III118:213–214,217–219.
Houman imagines the army’s disaster if Tus dies, then flatters the ancestry of the very man he has criticized. All four sources provide those elements, although the English expands the survivors’ misery and darkens their surroundings. The explicit question about needing an army has direct support in Mohl and Khaleghi; Moscow and Ganjoor instead use the neighboring space to deny Tus a peer in the army. That distinction defends the English question without manufacturing unanimity. The Rostam, Zal and Sam sequence requires more caution. The English conjunction makes Sam another independent exception alongside Rostam. The checked Persian naming chain is compressed and genealogical; it does not explicitly enumerate two separate exempt warriors. This should remain a flagged reading question, not be normalized silently in the displayed English.
29–33Who feels the pain?
Moscow IV128:207–208, IV129:212–214; Mohl III13:219–220,224–226; Ganjoor sh4:24–25,29–31; Khaleghi III118:215–216,220–222.
The English moves the heart-and-tongue counsel after the praise and dispatch request. That relocation is intelligible as a concluding flourish, but the next couplet changes more than sequence. In Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi, Houman claims sorrow or heart-pain for brave men who face him. It may be an intimidating, self-regarding profession of pity, yet Houman remains the experiencer of that feeling. The English makes his opponents learn the pain of steel instead. Neither the common running wording nor the inspected local apparatus verifies this transfer of agency. Tus’s reply then restores the shared sequence by exposing Houman’s own double role as commander and combatant. Keeping the emotional reversal explicit allows the commentary to distinguish a forceful English characterization from an edition-supported equivalent.
34–38Invitation, kinship and the guilty
Moscow IV129:214–220 and n2; Mohl III13:227–232; Ganjoor sh4:31–37; Khaleghi III119:223–229.
The invitation to come before the Shah is present in Mohl and Khaleghi running text, and a royal-arrival replacement passage is actually printed in Moscow’s apparatus. Ganjoor’s local sequence has no equivalent separate invitation. Thus the English need not be defended by merely asserting that another edition contains additions: its evidence is visible and locatable. Piran’s name identifies the commander through context; the invitation itself does not name him. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi also include a distinct kinship-and-cavalry appeal that lacks a separate English counterpart and is absent in Mohl’s checked interval. The following English warning compresses two source verses about liability to death and guilt before the king. Those local joins explain its pacing without treating every English couplet as a mechanically matching Persian unit.
39–44Protection of Piran and service to a king
Moscow IV129:220–225; Mohl III13:232–237; Ganjoor sh4:37–42; Khaleghi III119:229–234.
The protected status of Piran is shared by all four accounts. Khosrow’s remembered injunction joins his fosterer’s past care, worldly experience and friendship to a prohibition on unjust harm. Foster-father is therefore a meaningful English interpretation of the nurturing relationship, not a claim of biological paternity. The translation spreads the qualifications and ethical restraint over several couplets; its unsheathed blade makes the injunction visible without narrating a new action. Houman’s response also agrees across Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi: a king’s command leaves his servants little choice, and Piran did not seek the war. The English’s loyal breath colors that compelled service more positively. Piran’s unwillingness remains a claim made by Houman within the dialogue, rather than independently established interior knowledge.
45–50Giv breaks the parley
Moscow IV129:226–229, IV130:230–231; Mohl III13:238–243; Ganjoor sh4:43–48; Khaleghi III119:235–240.
Giv’s interruption changes the scene from political argument to immediate confrontation. All four sources give the sandarac comparison for his face, then his movement from the army with an angry heart. The English interprets the facial change as shame and renders the substance through flame. Neither emotion nor combustion is expressly supplied by that first comparison, even though the following anger explains the violence of his entrance. His demand that the sword replace speech is common to Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. The translation gathers foam, prolonged talk and refusal of an accord across its rebuke, adding a categorical judgment that every word is wrong. This gives Giv a sharper voice while leaving the actual attack for the later combat sequence; interruption alone is not a sword stroke.
51–55Ladan and the sword’s charter
Moscow IV130:232–235 and n4; Mohl III14:244–247; Ganjoor sh4:49–52; Khaleghi III120:241–244.
Mohl and Khaleghi print the place-name لاون, and Moscow prints related named-field variants in its local apparatus beside a general battlefield reference. Ganjoor retains the general reference. These sources support a named battlefield, but they do not verify the exact English form Ladan. That spelling remains flagged; similarity of narrative position is insufficient to certify orthographic identity. The sword’s charter then turns violence against Keshvad’s descendants into a grim written entitlement. The English’s inability to evade that charter interprets its force, without requiring a literal document on the battlefield. A single source couplet joins Ahriman-faced fortune and household mourning; the translation expands those halves into two. Shadow and drinking grief strengthen the image but are not further source units. The register therefore repeats the common locator instead of inventing an extra Persian verse.
56–59Two deaths, unequal consequences
Moscow IV130:236–240; Mohl III14:248–251; Ganjoor sh4:53–57; Khaleghi III120:245–247 and n7.
Houman claims that his death would leave Turanian force and leadership intact, whereas Tus’s death would strand Iran’s army. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor print the latter warning in running text; Khaleghi’s running sequence omits it, but the complete couplet is actually printed in the apparatus. That is positive evidence of a reading outside the main text, not evidence that Khaleghi places it in the speech’s running sequence. Mohl also explicitly promises vengeance by Piran and Afrasiab, supporting the English formulation more closely than the blood-as-river wording of the other main accounts. A further statement that the world will not be ruined through Houman is source-only in the register. His closing reference to Giv’s brother preserves personal grief as a weapon in the argument, without naming the brother here.
60–66Honorable death and dust-darkened day
Moscow IV130:241–246, IV131:247–248; Mohl III14:252–259; Ganjoor sh4:58–65; Khaleghi III120:248–255.
Tus recalls Houman to the actual opponent, and Houman answers by preferring a warrior’s death at an accomplished hand. All four checked sources sustain that progression from dispute to fatalistic courage. The English condenses the death argument, preserving honar as the quality of the worthy combatant rather than reducing it to simple physical strength. When the maces finally rise, it redistributes the charge and darkening earth over successive couplets. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi describe dust and a hidden sun; this darkness is initially a battlefield effect. It must be distinguished from the real evening that later stops the fight. Treating every mention of night as elapsed astronomical time would make the narrative contradictory in a way the source imagery does not require.
67–71Bent maces and omitted comparisons
Moscow IV131:249–255; Mohl III14:260–265; Ganjoor sh4:66–72; Khaleghi III120:256, III121:257–261 and n1.
The English places the maces bent like Chachi bows before the cloudward steel noise. All four main texts support those images, but they also give the heads a separate blacksmith’s-anvil comparison with no direct English counterpart. Moscow and Ganjoor add blood like foam and a plain filled with sword sound; Mohl has a checked local gap, and Khaleghi actually prints this addition in its apparatus. These are different kinds of omission and must remain separate in the register. The English’s rings of steel and sand in the sparks are additional material details, not substitutes that verify the missing source comparisons. Shahd is retained as printed without a conjectural geographical identification. The broken swords then provide a common transition from striking weapons to bodily struggle.
72–77Thirst, belts and two different remounts
Moscow IV131:256–261 and n15; Mohl III14:266–268, III15:269–271; Ganjoor sh4:73–78; Khaleghi III121:262–267.
The English’s thirst is supported by Mohl’s waterless mouth and an actually printed Moscow variant, although Moscow and Ganjoor main text emphasize dust and Khaleghi gives dust with water. The note should defend that specific branch without pretending all four main accounts describe thirst. The physical sequence is otherwise shared: the warriors strain through their stirrups, Houman’s belt breaks, and he mounts a fresh horse before Tus turns to archery. This is the first remount. Later, an arrow brings down the horse and Turanian companions supply another; collapsing the two would erase the episode’s changing tactical conditions. The English preserves both. Its wheeling motion develops shooting left and right, whereas the arrowheads and eagle feathers screening the sun closely retain the source’s material image.
78–82Night as simile and the second rescue
Moscow IV131:262, IV132:263–267; Mohl III15:272–277; Ganjoor sh4:79–84; Khaleghi III121:268–269, III122:270–273.
The comparison to two watches of night makes the arrow-filled world seem dark and diamond-strewn. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all provide that image, but none of these checked units fixes the moment as noon. The English’s opening temporal clause is consequently an added specification, distinct from the supported contrast of darkness and shining points. Houman then loses his horse, raises his shield and is seen on foot. The English combines the shield and dismounted interval, then gives the Turanians their active role in bringing another mount. It omits the new horse’s tree simile and the Tuzi saddle designation while preserving the essential rescue. This is a second remount after the earlier broken-belt episode, not a duplicate record of the same assistance.
83–87A renewed attack and a disputed blessing
Moscow IV132:268–273 and n20–25; Mohl III15:277–282; Ganjoor sh4:85–90; Khaleghi III122:273–278, n11, n15–16.
Moscow and Ganjoor print the intended renewed attack as night falls. Mohl’s checked sequence passes directly from remounting to the gathering warriors; Khaleghi omits that unit from its main text but actually prints it in the apparatus. The English therefore retains an evidenced action, while wrath supplies a motive. The blessing requires a separate distinction. Mohl places an evil-eye address before withdrawal; Khaleghi also places the address there, with proud men in the main wording and evil ones in a printed variant. Moscow and Ganjoor place their chiefs’ anger formulation after arrival at Piran. The English follows the earlier placement and evil-eye branch, but its private thought attribution is not established by these second-person addresses. Reading support does not automatically verify who silently thinks or publicly speaks.
88–93The returning warrior’s claim
Moscow IV132:272–276, IV133:277–278; Mohl III15:282–287; Ganjoor sh4:89–95; Khaleghi III122:278–283.
The returning Houman meets a force anxious about the duel. All four sources give the question about Tus, the distressed hearts and the appeal to divine knowledge; the English spells out fear for him without changing the concern’s object. His reply assigns the coming day and the world-illuminating akhtar to his own side. The English’s standard selects a martial sense from the star-or-banner vocabulary, while the promise that it will be won makes possession into future acquisition. The local wording alone cannot establish a specific intended capture of the Iranian standard. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi then separate the army’s joy from Houman’s personal fortune or reputation. The English’s enduring fame emphasizes the latter. These remain boasts after survival, not narrative certification of tomorrow’s victory.
94–95The lion has printed support
Moscow IV133:279–280 and n6; Mohl III15:288–289; Ganjoor sh4:96–97; Khaleghi III122:284, III123:285.
Tus’s shouting until cockcrow ends the episode in unresolved rivalry. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi say a raging elephant would be his proper opponent; Mohl prints a raging lion, and Moscow’s apparatus actually records lion as a variant. The English lion is therefore directly supported and should not be corrected merely to conform to the displayed Ganjoor text. Its closing declaration about a lesser foe elaborates the comparative insult. All four still attribute the judgment to Tus, whose prolonged shouting does not undo Houman’s survival or prove that the duel has decided the larger battle. The animal variation changes the boast’s imagery, not the combat outcome. Keeping the narrator separate from each warrior’s self-estimate is particularly important after a chapter built around rival interpretations of courage and command.
Source record
Moscow IV127–133 and Mohl III12–15 inspected first, with Mohl16 following boundary; Ganjoor Kamus sh4:1–97 and Khaleghi III117–123 compared afterward. Local printed apparatus inspected for the identified differences. Actual printed additions and replacement readings are cited individually. No appendix evidence invoked and no exhaustive appendix search claimed. Unprinted addition notices are not verification. Selected excerpts normalize spacing and do not claim complete diplomatic transcription.
Provisional English issues:51 Ladan differs from printed لاون and remains unverified;30 reverses the experiencer of sorrow;26 separates Sam from a compressed genealogical chain;45 supplies shame and flame;78 adds noon;86 supplies private thought where source address does not establish it. The narrower chronicle claims and smaller expansions are recorded verse by verse. Supported variants include5 Viseh tree in Mohl,28 army question in Mohl/Khaleghi,34 royal invitation in Mohl/Khaleghi and printed Moscow replacement,51 named-field branch (not exact Ladan spelling),57 explicit vengeance in Mohl,58 Khaleghi printed addition,72 thirst,83 renewed attack in printed Khaleghi addition,86 evil-eye branch and95 lion. No English revised. Prior provisional flags preserved.
Selected printed excerpts normalize spacing only. Persian display follows Ganjoor sh4 except English34, explicitly labelled Khaleghi III119:223 running text. Edition-specific variants and rearrangements retain their individual locators in the comparison register. No composite Persian is reconstructed; every edition-specific reading and checked gap retains its own locator.
Selected printed readings
Mohl III13:220 running experiencer of pain
که آیند پیشم به روز نبرد
Khaleghi III119:223 running royal invitation
خرامان بیایی بنزدیک شاه
Mohl III14:249 running vengeance
Khaleghi III120 n7 actually printed army-return warning
Khaleghi III121 n1 actually printed blood/foam addition
Mohl III14:266 running waterless-mouth excerpt
Khaleghi III121:262 running dust-and-water excerpt
Khaleghi III122 n11 actually printed renewed attack
شب آمد جهان گشت چون آبنوس
Mohl III15:280 running evil-eye blessing
وزین رزم فرجام تو سور باد
Khaleghi III122:276 running proud-men eyes
وزین رزم فرجام تو سور باد
Khaleghi III122 n15 actually printed evil-ones variant excerpt
Moscow IV133 n6 actually printed lion variant excerpt
Mohl III15:289 running lion ending
که شیر ژیان هم نبرد منست
Khaleghi III123:285 running elephant ending
که پیل ژیان همنبرد منست
Khaleghi III120:242 running named-field excerpt (not Ladan)
Mohl III14:245 running named-field excerpt (not Ladan)
B13.8 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow IV | Mohl III |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV127:184 running text | III12:196 running text |
| 2 | IV127:185 running text | III12:197 running text |
| 3 | IV127:186 running text | III12:198 running text |
| 4 | IV127:187 running text | III12:199 running text |
| 5 | IV127:188 running text | III12:200 running text |
| 6 | IV127:190 running text | III12:202 running text |
| 7 | IV127:191 running text | III12:203 running text |
| 8 | IV127:192 running text | III12:204 running text |
| 9 | IV127:193 running text | III12:205 running text |
| 10 | IV128:194 running text | III12:206 running text |
| 11 | IV128:195 running text | III12:207 running text |
| 12 | IV128:196 running text | III12:208 running text |
| 13 | IV128:197 running text | III12:209 running text |
| 14 | IV128:197; IV128:198 running text | III12:209; III12:210 running text |
| 15 | IV128:198; IV128:199 running text | III12:210; III12:211 running text |
| 16 | IV128:199 running text | III12:211 running text |
| 17 | IV128:200 running text | III12:212 running text |
| 18 | IV128:201 running text | III12:213 running text |
| 19 | IV128:202 running text | III12:214 running text |
| 20 | IV128:203 running text | III12:215 running text |
| 21 | IV128:203; IV128:204 running text | III12:215; III12:216 running text |
| 22 | IV128:204 running text | III12:216 running text |
| 23 | IV128:205 running text | III12:217 running text |
| 24 | IV128:206 running text | III12:218 running text |
| 25 | IV128:206 running text | III12:218 running text |
| 26 | IV128:209 running text | III13:221 running text |
| 27 | IV128:210 running text | III13:222 running text |
| 28 | IV128:210; IV128:211 running text | III13:222; III13:223 running text |
| 29 | IV128:207 running text | III13:219 running text |
| 30 | IV128:208 running text | III13:220 running text |
| 31 | IV128:212 running text | III13:224 running text |
| 32 | IV129:213 running text | III13:225 running text |
| 33 | IV129:214 running text | III13:226 running text |
| 34 | IV129:214–216 checked local running gap; IV129 n2 actually printed royal-arrival replacement | III13:227 running text |
| 35 | IV129:215 running text | III13:228 running text |
| 36 | IV129:217 running text | III13:229 running text |
| 37 | IV129:218; IV129:219 running text | III13:230; III13:231 running text |
| 38 | IV129:219; IV129:220 running text | III13:231; III13:232 running text |
| 39 | IV129:220; IV129:221 running text | III13:232; III13:233 running text |
| 40 | IV129:221; IV129:222 running text | III13:233; III13:234 running text |
| 41 | IV129:222 running text | III13:234 running text |
| 42 | IV129:223 running text | III13:235 running text |
| 43 | IV129:224 running text | III13:236 running text |
| 44 | IV129:225 running text | III13:237 running text |
| 45 | IV129:226 running text | III13:238 running text |
| 46 | IV129:227 running text | III13:239 running text |
| 47 | IV129:228; IV129:229 running text | III13:240; III13:241 running text |
| 48 | IV129:228; IV129:229; IV130:230 running text | III13:240; III13:241; III13:242 running text |
| 49 | IV130:230 running text | III13:242 running text |
| 50 | IV130:231 running text | III13:243 running text |
| 51 | IV130:232; IV130:233 running text; IV130 n4 actually printed named-field variants (not verification of Ladan) | III14:244; III14:245 running text |
| 52 | IV130:233; IV130:234 running text | III14:245; III14:246 running text |
| 53 | IV130:234 running text | III14:246 running text |
| 54 | IV130:235 running text | III14:247 running text |
| 55 | IV130:235 running text | III14:247 running text |
| 56 | IV130:236 running text | III14:248 running text |
| 57 | IV130:237 running text | III14:249 running text |
| 58 | IV130:239 running text | III14:250 running text |
| 59 | IV130:240 running text | III14:251 running text |
| 60 | IV130:241 running text | III14:252 running text |
| 61 | IV130:242 running text | III14:253 running text |
| 62 | IV130:243 running text | III14:254 running text |
| 63 | IV130:244; IV130:245 running text | III14:255; III14:256 running text |
| 64 | IV130:246; IV131:247 running text | III14:257; III14:258 running text |
| 65 | IV131:247 running text | III14:258 running text |
| 66 | IV131:248 running text | III14:259 running text |
| 67 | IV131:250; IV131:252 running text | III14:261; III14:262 running text |
| 68 | IV131:250 running text | III14:261 running text |
| 69 | IV131:253 running text | III14:263 running text |
| 70 | IV131:254 running text | III14:264 running text |
| 71 | IV131:255 running text | III14:265 running text |
| 72 | IV131:256 running text; IV131 n15 actually printed no-water variant | III14:266 running text |
| 73 | IV131:257 running text | III14:267 running text |
| 74 | IV131:258 running text | III14:268 running text |
| 75 | IV131:259 running text | III15:269 running text |
| 76 | IV131:260 running text | III15:270 running text |
| 77 | IV131:261 running text | III15:271 running text |
| 78 | IV131:262 running text | III15:272 running text |
| 79 | IV132:263 running text | III15:273 running text |
| 80 | IV132:264; IV132:265 running text | III15:274; III15:275 running text |
| 81 | IV132:265; IV132:266 running text | III15:275; III15:276 running text |
| 82 | IV132:267 running text | III15:277 running text |
| 83 | IV132:268 running text | III15:277–278 checked local running gap for renewed attack/night unit |
| 84 | IV132:269 running text | III15:278 running text |
| 85 | IV132:270 running text | III15:279 running text |
| 86 | IV132:273 running text | III15:280 running text |
| 87 | IV132:271 running text | III15:281 running text |
| 88 | IV132:272 running text | III15:282 running text |
| 89 | IV132:274 running text | III15:283 running text |
| 90 | IV132:275 running text | III15:284 running text |
| 91 | IV132:276 running text | III15:285 running text |
| 92 | IV133:277 running text | III15:286 running text |
| 93 | IV133:278 running text | III15:287 running text |
| 94 | IV133:279; IV133:280 running text | III15:288; III15:289 running text |
| 95 | IV133:280 running text; IV133 n6 actually printed lion variant | III15:289 running text |
New Naqqali