The Second Battle of Iran and Turan
65 published English couplets preserved verbatim.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 65 published English couplets preserved verbatim. |
| Moscow IV | Printed133–137:281–343,63 running units; actual AppendixI at315:1–10 inspected separately, with local apparatus. |
| Mohl III | Printed15–18:290–354,65 running units; PDF21–24. |
| Ganjoor | Kamus sh4:98–128 plus sh5:1–32,63 running units. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh III | Printed123–127:286–350,65 numbered running units including bracketed338; PDF139–143. Actual ten-verse supplement in124 n13 and local printed apparatus. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5Night watch and the whitening world
Moscow IV133:281–285; Mohl III15:290–291, III16:292–294; Ganjoor sh4:98–102; Khaleghi III123:286–290.
The opening makes darkness and dawn a sequence of precious substances, scent and color. All four checked accounts crown heaven with jet, scatter shamameh across lapis and station the watch before the sun appears from Cancer. The English retains those compressed images instead of turning them into a literal description of stars or a dated astronomical observation. Its fair Roman face follows the source comparison, while the guarded night becomes less specifically attached to the camp curtains. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi then sound both camps and thicken the air with colored standards. The English emphasizes their varied light, preserving spectacle within the darkened air. This is organized preparation on both sides, not yet a report that one army has broken the other.
6–10The army fills the cosmos
Moscow IV133:286–290; Mohl III16:295–299; Ganjoor sh4:103–107; Khaleghi III123:291–295.
The scale grows from each warrior’s equipment to an iron-covered heaven, time and earth. All four sources support that enlargement, followed by a sun hidden in cavalry dust and a sky bent toward earth under horses and drums. The English keeps the distinct iron, dust and sound images rather than reducing them to a general statement of military strength. Its charge describes the riders’ energy more specifically than the source’s tumult and should not independently date the start of a completed assault. Houman then emerges before the ranks with a bright dart in every account. His displayed wrath interprets his fierce bearing. The sequence establishes the commander’s presence before his orders; it does not make every weapon already drawn subject to the later restriction on close combat.
11–15Who spurs, and which weapons?
Moscow IV133:291, IV134:292–294 and n5; Mohl III16:300–304; Ganjoor sh4:108–111; Khaleghi III123:296–300.
Houman’s own excitement, spurring and shout supply the signal in the Persian sequence. The English turns the spurring into an order to the troops, a small but real change of grammatical agent that the register records. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi then direct the warriors to draw swords and raise their Chinese shields in the following unit. The subsequent sword, club and mace prescription runs in Mohl and Khaleghi and is actually printed in Moscow’s apparatus, whereas Ganjoor passes directly from excluding bows and spears to loose reins and exchanged blows. The English fuller instruction is consequently verified without pretending it appears in every main text. Chinese shields raised over heads become shields held steadily in English. These are specific tactical instructions for this phase, not a ban on every spear throughout the battle.
16–20Approaching Piran and spending the treasure
Moscow IV134:295–298 and n7; Mohl III16:305–309; Ganjoor sh4:111–115; Khaleghi III123:300 and n19, III124:301–304.
The separate approach to Piran is present in Mohl’s running text and in actually printed Moscow and Khaleghi additions. Ganjoor proceeds straight into the address, so the fuller English transition has evidence beyond the displayed alignment text. The appeal is practical: release arms and do not cling to dinars when weapons are needed. English locked treasure makes that reluctance tangible, but no particular locked store is narrated. Mohl’s conditional opening to the victory couplet supports the English If; Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi use the wording of becoming victorious with favorable fortune, without that explicit conditional particle. The turn to Tus’s rooster-eye array then restores the common sequence. Brightness is the English’s chosen emphasis within a compact visual likeness, not an additional report about the formation’s geometry.
21–25Praise, warning and dependence
Moscow IV134:299–303; Mohl III16:310–314; Ganjoor sh4:116–120; Khaleghi III124:305–309.
The warriors’ acclamation places Tus’s earlier duel inside the renewed battle’s morale. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all praise the dust he raised from Houman, but that is their interpretation of the preceding encounter, not a newly narrated victory over him. Tus immediately warns of the danger in advancing to meet the enemy. The English’s collapse of strength and courage enlarges the consequence of hostile riders gaining the advantage; the checked Persian unit does not separately declare the army cowardly. The next call to Yazdan and rejection of self-pride is present in all four running texts. It therefore requires neither an inferred missing addition nor a fabricated appendix restoration. The contrast between martial praise and confessed dependence is already built into the common narrative.
26–30Numbers, the mountain and an actual appendix
Moscow IV134:304–306, IV135:307–309; AppendixI, IV315:1–10; Mohl III16:315–316, III17:317–320; Ganjoor sh4:121–126; Khaleghi III124:310–314 and n13, III125:315.
Tus’s appeal for help leads into stationing the golden-shod chiefs beside the standard and forbidding movement from the mountain foot. All four main accounts then estimate at least two hundred enemies for each Iranian. The English makes the ratio firmer by omitting the possibility of still more and the tentative formulation. Moscow’s note after the appeal points to ten supplemental verses, which have been inspected in the actual appendix; Khaleghi prints the corresponding exchange in its apparatus. Mohl and Ganjoor have checked gaps at that position. The supplement expands Gudarz’s protest and Tus’s report of Houman’s threat. Its themes overlap the running counsel, but the ten units are not silently inserted into English rows or counted as Moscow running text. The separate record preserves both placement and content.
31–35Morale, fate and the first deployment
Moscow IV135:309–313; Mohl III17:320–324; Ganjoor sh4:126–128 and sh5:1–2; Khaleghi III125:315–319.
Gudarz’s answer refuses to make numbers the sole measure of the battle. All four sources join that refusal to a warning against disheartening Iran, then contrast adverse fortune with the limits of caution or superior numbers. The English develops divine control into an explicit statement about the few and many, while narrowing the next ineffective remedy to a cautious pause. Its closing acceptance of what must arrive is consistent with the source’s injunction against tormenting the spirit. Tus then arrays the troops, and the footmen move toward the mountain with baggage while Gudarz takes the right. This movement is explicitly shared by Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. The later infantry screen must be read as another deployment, not used retrospectively to suppress this first one.
36–40Gorgin and a changed weapon
Moscow IV135:314–318 and n16; Mohl III17:325–329; Ganjoor sh5:3–7; Khaleghi III125:320–324.
Mohl names Rohham and Gorgin on the left, and Moscow’s apparatus actually prints the Gorgin alternative beside its main reference to Rohham of Gudarz. Ganjoor and Khaleghi retain the latter main wording. The English two-name formation therefore has specific support, though not agreement across all four main texts. The following cosmic dislocation is much more widely shared: drums move heaven, its heart splits, the sun’s mouth fills with dust, and the plain disappears. English makes the hidden warriors explicit within the hidden landscape. The sparks passage introduces a different issue. All four checked main accounts kindle fire from mace and sword, while English uses helm and sword. The inspected relevant local variants do not verify that substitution. Vivid imagery alone does not establish textual equivalence.
41–45Above, below and the recalled warning
Moscow IV135:319–322, IV136:323–324; Mohl III17:330–335; Ganjoor sh5:8–13; Khaleghi III125:325–330.
The source arranges standards above and heavy maces below amid shining spears and swords. The English gives the maces whirling or thrown motion, replacing a spatial relation with an action not expressly narrated in the checked unit. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi then share the iron-filled air, hoof-and-mail earth, sea of blood and sword-lamps. Those images make the battle simultaneously material and disorienting; they need not be literalized into solid iron terrain or already separated heads and feet. Tus’s address to Gudarz follows as the sky darkens and recalls an astrologer’s forecast. The English preserves that return from panoramic narration to speech. Its old Gudarz and the warning made clear add characterization and emphasis, rather than new source events.
46–50Forecast, voice and a fuller roster
Moscow IV136:324–328 and n9; Mohl III17:335–339; Ganjoor sh5:13–17; Khaleghi III125:330–332, III126:333–334 and n3.
The forecast runs through three watches of night, with swords shedding blood like dark clouds. The English spreads the timing and blood-rain across two couplets, first making swords themselves seem to rain and then restoring the clouds’ bloody effect. Its quotation also places the final fear of enemy victory within the astrologer’s warning. The Persian sequence allows caution about that boundary: Tus’s present fear and the reported prediction should not be treated as independently verified voices merely from modern punctuation. The approaching roster has another kind of variation. Farhad appears in Mohl and in actually printed Moscow and Khaleghi roster variants, while Ganjoor and their main texts have shorter or different lists. This supports the name without certifying the exact combined English list as unanimous. Their wounded livers express grief and vengeance, not necessarily fresh bodily injuries.
51–55Div-like sound and fuller battle lines
Moscow IV136:329–332 and n12–13; Mohl III17:340–341, III18:342–344; Ganjoor sh5:18–21; Khaleghi III126:335–340.
The cloud-reaching cry is compared to dark night and a Div host in the common source sequence. English shifts the emphasis toward the advancing men as Div-like troops. The change strengthens their monstrous appearance while making the sound-based relation less exact. Houman’s mountain-like force then advances in all four accounts. Mohl and Khaleghi additionally print weapons so dense that stirrup and rein cannot be distinguished; Moscow prints corresponding additions in its apparatus, while Ganjoor has a checked local gap. Khaleghi also numbers a repeated massing of the warriors in brackets, separately recorded rather than merged with the earlier mountain image. The resulting English fullness has real printed support. Selection of opponents and the Guraza–Nahl pairing then return to the shared running sequence.
56–60Paired opponents, then the wrong speaker
Moscow IV136:333–336, IV137:337; Mohl III18:345–349; Ganjoor sh5:22–26; Khaleghi III126:341–345.
The pairing sequence keeps Rohham against Farshidvard, Shidush against Lahhak, Bijan against Kulbad, Giv against Shatrakh, and the elder commanders against one another. The English makes the terse list active without confusing those opponents. Mohl ends it with the battlefield disappearing, whereas Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi emphasize the absence of delay or hesitation; the English follows the latter branch. A much larger discrepancy begins with the ensuing vow. Every checked running text explicitly names Houman as speaker, while English names Tus. The inspected local apparatus offers no verification for Tus here. This cannot be resolved as an ambiguous pronoun or defended merely by the existence of other variants nearby. The speaker change transfers the stated aim of the next couplet from the Turanian commander to his Iranian opponent.
61–65The vow and the infantry screen
Moscow IV137:338–343; Mohl III18:349–354; Ganjoor sh5:26–32; Khaleghi III126:345–347 and n24, III127:348–350.
The demand to empty the land of enemies and prevent renewed vengeance continues Houman’s speech in all four running accounts. English retains the demand but carries forward its assignment to Tus. Moscow and Ganjoor insert an additional exhortation about sweet life in the hand and a shouted charge; Mohl has a checked gap and Khaleghi actually prints the unit in its apparatus. The narrative then turns to Tus and his infantry, elephants and drums. In the English, the reassigned vow makes this look like one commander’s continuous order and execution; the sources mark a switch from Houman to Tus. The shielded infantry screen before the horsemen and the hold-position order are otherwise supported in all four. Their spears do not contradict Houman’s earlier close-combat restriction, which belongs to the opposing command.
Source record
Checked Moscow IV133–137 and Mohl III15–18 first, then Ganjoor sh4:98–128/sh5:1–32 and Khaleghi III123–127. Moscow134 n19 prompted actual inspection of AppendixI, printed315:1–10; the corresponding ten verses are actually printed Khaleghi124 n13. Other actual printed evidence includes Moscow134 n5/n7,135 n16,136 n9/n12/n13; Khaleghi123 n19,126 n3/n24. The local following Bazur opening was checked as boundary, not analyzed. No exhaustive whole-volume appendix search claimed. No unprinted notice counts as verification. Selected excerpts are normalized readings, not complete diplomatic transcriptions.
Main flag: English60–61 assigns Houman’s explicitly named speech to Tus in conflict with all four checked running texts. The actual appendix’s quoted Houman threat does not verify that reassignment. English11 shifts spurring from Houman to the troops;40 changes mace to helm;41 makes below-positioned maces whirl or fly;51 shifts the Div simile from battle-cry/scene toward the fighters. Conditional victory19 follows Mohl versus the other main wording; firmer enemy ratio29 and voice boundary48 remain interpretive qualifications. Names36 Gorgin and49 Farhad have specific printed support, not unanimous main-text agreement. Published English unchanged; inherited flags preserved.
Selected printed excerpts normalize spacing only. Persian display follows Ganjoor sh4:98–128 and sh5:1–32 except English14,16,53, explicitly labelled Mohl. Supplemental and bracketed readings are separately labelled; AppendixI unit2 is a selected excerpt. Edition-specific variants and rearrangements retain their individual locators in the comparison register. No composite Persian is reconstructed; every edition-specific reading and checked gap retains its own locator.
Selected printed readings
Mohl III16:303 running weapons prescription
چنان چون بود رزم کندآوران
Moscow IV134 n5 actually printed weapons addition excerpt
Mohl III16:305 running approach
بیامد به پیش برادر چو شیر
Mohl III16:308 running explicit condition excerpt
Moscow IV134:297 running opening excerpt
Moscow IV315 AppendixI:5 actually printed supplemental verse
دل و تیغ و اخترش سالار ماست
Moscow IV135 n16 actually printed left-wing variant excerpt
Mohl III17:325 running left-wing excerpt
Khaleghi III125:324 running weapons that kindle fire excerpt
Khaleghi III126 n3 actually printed Farhad roster variant excerpt
Mohl III18:342 running weapons/rein/stirrup unit
نبد هیچ پیدا رکاب از عنان
Khaleghi III126:338 bracketed running unit
بکردند گردان همه همگروه]
Moscow IV137:337 running explicit speaker
نباید که چون دی بود کارزار
Mohl III18:349 running explicit speaker excerpt
Khaleghi III126:345 running explicit speaker
نباید که چون دی بود کارزار
Khaleghi III126 n24 actually printed sweet-life exhortation
چو من برخروشم دمید و دهید
B13.9 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow IV | Mohl III |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV133:281 running text | III15:290 running text |
| 2 | IV133:282 running text | III15:291 running text |
| 3 | IV133:283 running text | III16:292 running text |
| 4 | IV133:284 running text | III16:293 running text |
| 5 | IV133:285 running text | III16:294 running text |
| 6 | IV133:286 running text | III16:295 running text |
| 7 | IV133:287 running text | III16:296 running text |
| 8 | IV133:288 running text | III16:297 running text |
| 9 | IV133:289 running text | III16:298 running text |
| 10 | IV133:290 running text | III16:299 running text |
| 11 | IV133:291 running text | III16:300 running text |
| 12 | IV134:292 running text | III16:301 running text |
| 13 | IV134:293 running text | III16:302 running text |
| 14 | IV134:293–294 checked running gap; IV134 n5 actually printed sword/club/mace addition | III16:303 running text |
| 15 | IV134:294 running text | III16:304 running text |
| 16 | IV134:294–295 checked running gap; IV134 n7 actually printed approach addition | III16:305 running text |
| 17 | IV134:295 running text | III16:306 running text |
| 18 | IV134:296 running text | III16:307 running text |
| 19 | IV134:297 running text | III16:308 running text |
| 20 | IV134:298 running text | III16:309 running text |
| 21 | IV134:299 running text | III16:310 running text |
| 22 | IV134:300 running text | III16:311 running text |
| 23 | IV134:301 running text | III16:312 running text |
| 24 | IV134:302 running text | III16:313 running text |
| 25 | IV134:303 running text | III16:314 running text |
| 26 | IV134:304 running text; IV315 AppendixI:1–10 supplementary passage actually inspected | III16:315 running text |
| 27 | IV134:305 running text | III16:316 running text |
| 28 | IV134:306 running text | III17:317 running text |
| 29 | IV135:307 running text | III17:318 running text |
| 30 | IV135:308; IV135:309 running text | III17:319; III17:320 running text |
| 31 | IV135:309 running text | III17:320 running text |
| 32 | IV135:310 running text | III17:321 running text |
| 33 | IV135:311 running text | III17:322 running text |
| 34 | IV135:312 running text | III17:323 running text |
| 35 | IV135:313 running text | III17:324 running text |
| 36 | IV135:314 running text; IV135 n16 actually printed Gorgin variant | III17:325 running text |
| 37 | IV135:315 running text | III17:326 running text |
| 38 | IV135:316 running text | III17:327 running text |
| 39 | IV135:317 running text | III17:328 running text |
| 40 | IV135:318 running text | III17:329 running text |
| 41 | IV135:319 running text | III17:330 running text |
| 42 | IV135:320 running text | III17:331 running text |
| 43 | IV135:321 running text | III17:332 running text |
| 44 | IV135:322 running text | III17:333 running text |
| 45 | IV136:323; IV136:324 running text | III17:334; III17:335 running text |
| 46 | IV136:324; IV136:325 running text | III17:335; III17:336 running text |
| 47 | IV136:325 running text | III17:336 running text |
| 48 | IV136:326 running text | III17:337 running text |
| 49 | IV136:327 running text; IV136 n9 actually printed Farhad roster variant | III17:338 running text |
| 50 | IV136:328 running text | III17:339 running text |
| 51 | IV136:329 running text | III17:340 running text |
| 52 | IV136:330 running text | III17:341 running text |
| 53 | IV136:330–331 checked running gap; IV136 n12 and n13 actually printed weapons addition | III18:342 running text |
| 54 | IV136:331 running text | III18:343 running text |
| 55 | IV136:332 running text | III18:344 running text |
| 56 | IV136:333 running text | III18:345 running text |
| 57 | IV136:334 running text | III18:346 running text |
| 58 | IV136:335 running text | III18:347 running text |
| 59 | IV136:336 running text | III18:348 running text |
| 60 | IV137:337 running text; IV137:338 intervening source-only unit | III18:349 running text |
| 61 | IV137:339 running text | III18:350 running text |
| 62 | IV137:340 running text | III18:351 running text |
| 63 | IV137:341 running text | III18:352 running text |
| 64 | IV137:342 running text | III18:353 running text |
| 65 | IV137:343 running text | III18:354 running text |
New Naqqali