Rostam Battles Sava
B14.12:30 couplets;60 unchanged lines.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | B14.12:30 couplets;60 unchanged lines. |
| Moscow | IV245–247:566–594;29 running units plus actual apparatus;1 source-only. |
| Mohl | III95–96:591–618;28 running units; PDF101–102. |
| Ganjoor | Khaghan sh6:41–58 and sh7:1–11;29 running units;1 source-only. |
| Khaleghi | III230–232:2050–2077;28 running units plus actual apparatus; PDF246–248. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5Victory promised through different opening readings
Moscow IV245:566 running text; IV245 n18 actual no-harm-to-us alternative; main enemy loses life | IV246:567 running text; IV246:568 running text | IV246:568 running text | IV246:569 running text; Mohl III95:591 running text | III95:592 running text | III95:592–593 checked local gap; gift-to-Iran verse absent from checked running text | III95:593 running text; Ganjoor sh6:41 running poem body | sh6:42 running poem body; sh6:43 running poem body | sh6:43 running poem body | sh6:44 running poem body; Khaleghi III230:2050 running text; III230:2050 harm to them has ended; n23 actual no-harm-to-us and enemy-harm alternatives | III230:2051 running text | III230:2051–2052 checked local running gap; no complete gift-to-Iran verse verified in inspected local apparatus | III230:2052 running text
Moscow printed p.245 · Moscow printed p.246 · Mohl printed p.95 · Khaleghi printed p.230 · Ganjoor sh6:41 · Ganjoor sh6:42 · Ganjoor sh6:43 · Ganjoor sh6:44
Mohl reassures Iran that the battle has caused no harm, while Moscow and Ganjoor predict harm to the enemy. Khaleghi says that harm to them has ended and prints alternatives, as does Moscow. English follows the reassurance but qualifies it with great, allowing lesser harm. The promised transfer of spoils to Iran is explicit in Moscow and Ganjoor; Mohl and Khaleghi have checked local gaps after the list of wealth and regalia. No complete matching Khaleghi apparatus verse was verified. English’s noble line and glory enlarge the recipients and celebration. All four then combine Iran’s exclusive joy with God and Rakhsh as sufficient allies. English divides that verse into two couplets and turns assistance into guidance.
6–10Triumph, wrongdoing and the threatened salt waste
Moscow IV246:570 running text | IV246:571 running text | IV246 n7 two actually printed evil-deeds additions | IV246:572 running text | IV246:573 running text; IV246 n11 actual salt-waste alternative; main city reading; Mohl III95:594 running text | III95:595 running text | III95:596 running text | III96:597 running text | III96:598 running text; Ganjoor sh6:45 running poem body | sh6:46 running poem body | sh6:46–47 checked local gap | sh6:47 running poem body | sh6:48 running poem body; Khaleghi III230:2053 running text | III230:2054 running text | III231:2055 running text | III231:2056 running text | III231:2057 running text; III231:2057 salt-waste main; n5 city alternative
Moscow printed p.246 · Mohl printed p.95 · Mohl printed p.96 · Khaleghi printed p.230 · Khaleghi printed p.231 · Ganjoor sh6:45 · Ganjoor sh6:46 · Ganjoor sh6:47 · Ganjoor sh6:48
The three named peoples, the day of victory and heaven kindling the army occur in all four sources. English interprets that kindling as renewed spirit. The enemies’ evil deeds producing their misfortune are running text in Mohl and Khaleghi and actually printed additions in Moscow; Ganjoor has a checked gap. English’s ruin on them all makes the consequence comprehensive. The following appeal for divine strength remains conditional, even amid Rostam’s confidence. The threat against productive land then divides the texts. Mohl and Khaleghi have salt waste, with an actual Moscow alternative, whereas Moscow and Ganjoor print a city reading. English follows the salt-waste branch and supplies salting and blighted grain as its concrete mechanism.
11–15The army receives audible signals and a rhythm
Moscow IV246:574 running text | IV246:575 running text | IV246:576 running text | IV246:577 running text | IV246:578 running text; Mohl III96:599 running text | III96:600 running text | III96:601 running text | III96:602 running text | III96:603 running text; Ganjoor sh6:49 running poem body | sh6:50 running poem body | sh6:51 running poem body | sh6:52 running poem body | sh6:53 running poem body; Khaleghi III231:2058 running text | III231:2059 running text | III231:2060 running text | III231:2061 running text | III231:2062 running text
Moscow printed p.246 · Mohl printed p.96 · Khaleghi printed p.231 · Ganjoor sh6:49 · Ganjoor sh6:50 · Ganjoor sh6:51 · Ganjoor sh6:52 · Ganjoor sh6:53
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi share the messenger sent toward the army, the windlike speed, and the musical signal when Rostam moves. English’s ride back makes both mounted travel and return explicit. Cymbals and daray acquire singing voices, while dust and the sound of kus turn the earth to ebony. The published koust spelling is preserved rather than silently standardized. The mace strokes then resemble a smith hammering steel in all four sources; English’s clang emphasizes the comparison’s sound and connects it to the instruments. Finally, the troops must not fear the multitude and must raise dust from sea to cloud. The impossible scale is martial exhortation, which English retains without requiring literal battlefield geography.
16–20The signal precedes the attack on the right
Moscow IV246:580 running text; IV246:580 follows579 helmet signal; English reverses sequence following Mohl/Khaleghi | IV246:579 running text | IV246:581 running text | IV247:582 running text; IV247:583 running text | IV247:583 running text; Mohl III96:604 running text | III96:605 running text | III96:606 running text | III96:607 running text; III96:608 running text | III96:608 running text; Ganjoor sh6:55 running poem body | sh6:54 running poem body | sh6:56 running poem body | sh6:57 running poem body; sh6:58 running poem body | sh6:58 running poem body; Khaleghi III231:2063 running text | III231:2064 running text | III231:2065 running text | III231:2066 running text; III231:2067 running text | III231:2067 running text
Moscow printed p.246 · Moscow printed p.247 · Mohl printed p.96 · Khaleghi printed p.231 · Ganjoor sh6:55 · Ganjoor sh6:54 · Ganjoor sh6:56 · Ganjoor sh6:57 · Ganjoor sh6:58
English places the command to split Chin and Saklab’s ranks before the instruction to watch Rostam’s helmet, following Mohl and Khaleghi. Moscow and Ganjoor reverse those verses. The dust command also changes its visible object: the sources prevent earth from seeing air or sky, while English conceals the sun. The helmet and war cry then coordinate the troops, with the English charge interpreting the accompanying imperatives. All four compare Rostam’s movement to an elephant and give him an ox-faced mace; English raises it overhead. His advance toward Kundur and the destruction of the right wing occupy two Persian verses. English rearranges their material, reserving the detached heads and helmets for its next couplet while preserving the sequence of victory.
21–25Sava answers an elephant with the Nile
Moscow IV247:584 running text | IV247:585 running text | IV247:586 running text | IV247:587 running text | IV247:588 running text; Mohl III96:609 running text | III96:610 running text | III96:611 running text | III96:612 running text | III96:613 running text; Ganjoor sh7:1 running poem body | sh7:2 running poem body | sh7:3 running poem body | sh7:4 running poem body | sh7:5 running poem body; Khaleghi III231:2068 running text | III231:2069 running text | III231:2070 running text | III231:2071 running text | III231:2072 running text; III231:2072 you will see no further battle main; n29 actual if-I-have-further-battle alternative
Moscow printed p.247 · Mohl printed p.96 · Khaleghi printed p.231 · Ganjoor sh7:1 · Ganjoor sh7:2 · Ganjoor sh7:3 · Ganjoor sh7:4 · Ganjoor sh7:5
All four sources introduce Sava as Kamus’s kinsman, armed with an Indian sword and seeking revenge. English’s ambition that none can curb strengthens the broadly extended desire of the source description. His movement to left and right becomes an explicit left-then-right sequence. The elephant address and Nile wave are shared: Sava answers Rostam’s imposing animal identity with a force capable of confronting it. English’s dark and terrible rising wave enlarges that threat. The final boast differs more substantially. Mohl and Khaleghi tell Rostam that he will see no further battle, while Moscow and Ganjoor condition Sava’s vengeance on further combat. Khaleghi prints that conditional alternative. English follows the direct final-battle threat of Mohl and Khaleghi.
26–30The killing blow and the strange final harvest
Moscow IV247:589 running text | IV247:590 running text | IV247:592 running text | IV247:593 running text | IV247:594 running text; IV247 n16 actual thorn/brain and earth/thorn variants; main earth yields brains; Mohl III96:614 running text | III96:615 running text | III96:616 running text | III96:617 running text | III96:618 running text; Ganjoor sh7:6 running poem body | sh7:7 running poem body | sh7:9 running poem body | sh7:10 running poem body | sh7:11 running poem body; Khaleghi III232:2073 running text | III232 n1 actually printed head-blow and departing-spirit addition | III232:2075 running text | III232:2076 running text | III232:2077 running text; III232:2077 thorns yield brains; n7 earth/thorn/fruit variants
Moscow printed p.247 · Mohl printed p.96 · Khaleghi printed p.232 · Ganjoor sh7:6 · Ganjoor sh7:7 · Ganjoor sh7:9 · Ganjoor sh7:10 · Ganjoor sh7:11
Rostam’s drawn mace, Sava’s overthrow and the fall of the Kashani standard are accounted for across all four sources. The head-blow and departing spirit are running text in Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor but an actual Khaleghi addition. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi also print another head-and-helmet blow, retained separately here; Mohl has a checked gap. English follows Mohl’s shorter killing sequence. Its fear specifies the army’s distress. The final productive image is more disturbing in Moscow and Ganjoor, where earth yields brains, and Khaleghi, where thorns do so. Mohl’s earth-and-khavar wording supplies a different bearing image. English’s fruit from thorns preserves unexpected productivity but removes the explicit brains and adds barren clay.
Source record and limits
Inspected 12 November 2026. B14.12 only:30 English couplets;60 exact published lines;6 notes. Moscow IV245–247:566–594 (29 running units); Mohl III95–96:591–618 (28); Ganjoor khaghan sh6:41–58 and sh7:1–11 (29); Khaleghi III230–232:2050–2077 (28). Every declared running unit accounted. Shared/partial-verse alignments explicit; one source-only entry retained. Moscow and Mohl inspected individually first, then Ganjoor and Khaleghi. Earlier chapters unchanged.
Edition scope and inspected pages
- Published English B14.12
- Moscow: printed 245 / PDF 245, printed 246 / PDF 246, printed 247 / PDF 247
- Mohl: printed 95 / PDF 101, printed 96 / PDF 102
- Khaleghi: printed 230 / PDF 246, printed 231 / PDF 247, printed 232 / PDF 248
- Ganjoor sh6:41–58
- Ganjoor sh7:1–11
Evidence distinctions and retained limits
Actual Moscow apparatus:245 n18 no-harm-to-us;246 n7 evil-deeds additions,n11 salt-waste alternative;247 n16 thorn/brain and earth/thorn variants. Actual Khaleghi apparatus:230 n23 opening alternatives;231 n5 city alternative,n29 conditional further-battle reading;232 n1 departing-spirit blow addition,n7 final bearing variants. Gift-to-Iran verse has checked Mohl592–593 and Khaleghi2051–2052 gaps; no complete corresponding Khaleghi apparatus verse verified. Extra head/helmet blow is running in Moscow/Ganjoor/Khaleghi and a checked Mohl615–616 gap. No appendix evidence used or exhaustive appendix claim. Unprinted notices never establish verification.
All inherited flags retained. Current qualifications: opening reassurance versus enemy harm1; gift-to-Iran gaps3; one Persian verse expanded across4–5; salt-waste reading and supplied salting mechanism10; published koust spelling13; reordered signal and sun substitution16–17; shared-source compression19–20; final-battle versus conditional threat25; different placement of killing blows27–28; final harvest removes explicit brains30. English unchanged.
Selected inspected readings
- Mohl III95:591 no harm to us: کز این جنگ ما را نیامد زیان
- Moscow IV245:566 enemy harmed: کزین جنگ دشمن کند جان زیان
- Mohl III96:598 salt waste: برومند را شورستانی کنم
- Moscow IV246:573 city reading: برومند را شارستانی کنم
- Khaleghi III231:2072 final battle threat: نبینی مگر زین سپس کارزار
- Mohl III96:618 final bearing image: ز خاک و ز خاور برآورد بار
Persian display uses labelled Ganjoor units or Mohl transcription for the checked evil-deeds gap. Full source verses are repeated where two English couplets share them; this is alignment, not a claim of additional Persian verses. S1 retains the extra blow. No composite reconstruction from English or scans distributed.
B14.12 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV245:566 running text; IV245 n18 actual no-harm-to-us alternative; main enemy loses life | III95:591 running text |
| 2 | IV246:567 running text; IV246:568 running text | III95:592 running text |
| 3 | IV246:568 running text | III95:592–593 checked local gap; gift-to-Iran verse absent from checked running text |
| 4 | IV246:569 running text | III95:593 running text |
| 5 | IV246:569 running text | III95:593 running text |
| 6 | IV246:570 running text | III95:594 running text |
| 7 | IV246:571 running text | III95:595 running text |
| 8 | IV246 n7 two actually printed evil-deeds additions | III95:596 running text |
| 9 | IV246:572 running text | III96:597 running text |
| 10 | IV246:573 running text; IV246 n11 actual salt-waste alternative; main city reading | III96:598 running text |
| 11 | IV246:574 running text | III96:599 running text |
| 12 | IV246:575 running text | III96:600 running text |
| 13 | IV246:576 running text | III96:601 running text |
| 14 | IV246:577 running text | III96:602 running text |
| 15 | IV246:578 running text | III96:603 running text |
| 16 | IV246:580 running text; IV246:580 follows579 helmet signal; English reverses sequence following Mohl/Khaleghi | III96:604 running text |
| 17 | IV246:579 running text | III96:605 running text |
| 18 | IV246:581 running text | III96:606 running text |
| 19 | IV247:582 running text; IV247:583 running text | III96:607 running text; III96:608 running text |
| 20 | IV247:583 running text | III96:608 running text |
| 21 | IV247:584 running text | III96:609 running text |
| 22 | IV247:585 running text | III96:610 running text |
| 23 | IV247:586 running text | III96:611 running text |
| 24 | IV247:587 running text | III96:612 running text |
| 25 | IV247:588 running text | III96:613 running text |
| 26 | IV247:589 running text | III96:614 running text |
| 27 | IV247:590 running text | III96:615 running text |
| 28 | IV247:592 running text | III96:616 running text |
| 29 | IV247:593 running text | III96:617 running text |
| 30 | IV247:594 running text; IV247 n16 actual thorn/brain and earth/thorn variants; main earth yields brains | III96:618 running text |
New Naqqali