The Khan Is Taken Prisoner
B14.14:69 couplets;138 unchanged lines.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | B14.14:69 couplets;138 unchanged lines. |
| Moscow | IV250–254:646–703;58 running units plus actual apparatus. |
| Mohl | III99–101:664–734;71 running units; PDF105–107. |
| Ganjoor | Khaghan sh8:51–78,sh9:1–23,sh10:1–7;58 running units. |
| Khaleghi | III235–238:2124–2185;62 running units plus actual apparatus; PDF251–254,following boundary PDF255. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5The Khan rejects the role of a subordinate
Moscow IV250:646 running text | IV250:647 running text; IV250:647 opening curse; n27–29 variants in Iran/king/mercy formulation | IV251:648 running text | IV251:649 running text | IV251:650 running text; Mohl III99:664 running text | III99:665 running text | III99:666 running text | III99:667 running text | III99:668 running text; Ganjoor sh8:51 running poem body | sh8:52 running poem body | sh8:53 running poem body | sh8:54 running poem body | sh8:55 running poem body; Khaleghi III235:2124 running text | III235:2125 running text; III235:2125 opening Iran/shah and mercy formulation; n7 actual variants; English curse follows Mohl opening | III235:2126 running text | III235:2127 running text | III235:2128 running text
Moscow printed p.250 · Moscow printed p.251 · Mohl printed p.99 · Khaleghi printed p.235 · Ganjoor sh8:51 · Ganjoor sh8:52 · Ganjoor sh8:53 · Ganjoor sh8:54 · Ganjoor sh8:55
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi begin with the Khan’s insult and his objection to becoming a soldier under Rostam. English’s stripped of worth interprets that demand as an assault on royal standing, while anger flamed dramatizes the speech. The opening curse and protection claim vary in wording: English’s my mercy follows Mohl’s from me more directly than the other main formulations. The arrow storm then replaces the verbal exchange. All four compare it to autumn wind on a tree and fill the sky with eagle feathers. English supplies the stripping of the tree as an explicit effect, while retaining the feathers as the visible presence of arrows. The battle exceeds even the warrior’s dream.
6–10Gudarz turns fear into coordinated assistance
Moscow IV251:651 running text | IV251:652 running text | IV251:653 running text; IV251:653 Chachi bows; English published Chakh retained | IV251:654 running text | IV251:655 running text; Mohl III99:669 running text | III99:670 running text | III99:671 running text | III99:672 running text | III99:673 running text; Ganjoor sh8:56 running poem body | sh8:57 running poem body | sh8:58 running poem body | sh8:59 running poem body | sh8:60 running poem body; Khaleghi III235:2129 running text | III235:2130 running text | III235:2131 running text; III235:2131 Chachi bows; no exact Chakh spelling claimed | III235:2132 running text | III235:2133 running text
Moscow printed p.251 · Mohl printed p.99 · Khaleghi printed p.235 · Ganjoor sh8:56 · Ganjoor sh8:57 · Ganjoor sh8:58 · Ganjoor sh8:59 · Ganjoor sh8:60
In all four sources, Gudarz sees the diamond rain and fears for Rostam. English preserves the precious-stone image for lethal arrows rather than replacing it with plain weaponry. His order to Rohham combines urgency with two hundred mounted men and bows; English’s laggard sharpens the rebuke, while the next couplet restores the explicit equipment. The sources give Chachi bows and khadang shafts. The published Chakh spelling remains unchanged, but this collation does not certify it as the same written form. Giv’s separate order broadens the intervention to the army. English’s dressing ranks interprets the prohibition on arrangement in a military sense, making the pressure of immediate action clearer than a general ban on adornment.
11–15A curse, a cosmic blow and a tired horse
Moscow IV251:656 running text | IV251 n19 actual curse addition placed after657, not before as English/Mohl | IV251:657 running text | IV251:658 running text | IV251:659 running text; IV251:660 running text; IV251:659–660 two running verses compressed; walking conditional on Rakhsh weakening; Mohl III99:674 running text | III99:675 running text | III99:676 running text | III99:677 running text | III99:678 running text; III99:679 running text; Ganjoor sh8:61 running poem body | sh8:61–62 checked local gap for English passage | sh8:62 running poem body | sh8:63 running poem body | sh8:64 running poem body; sh8:65 running poem body; Khaleghi III235:2134 running text | III235:2136 running text; III235:2136 curse follows2135 cosmic blow; English reverses following Mohl | III235:2135 running text | III235:2137 running text | III236:2138 running text; III236:2139 running text
Moscow printed p.251 · Mohl printed p.99 · Khaleghi printed p.235 · Khaleghi printed p.236 · Ganjoor sh8:61 · Ganjoor sh8:62 · Ganjoor sh8:63 · Ganjoor sh8:64 · Ganjoor sh8:65
The rightward movement toward Piran and Houman is shared across Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. The curse that follows in English is running text in Mohl and Khaleghi and an actual Moscow addition, with a checked Ganjoor gap. English follows Mohl by placing it before the heaven-to-earth blow; Khaleghi and the Moscow addition place it after that image. Rohham then comes like a leopard to guard Rostam’s rear. English adds the passing arrows from the surrounding scene. Rostam’s concern for Rakhsh occupies two source verses: he fears exhaustion, then says he will dismount if the horse weakens. English compresses both, adding unrelenting resolve and reducing the explicit conditional link between the horse’s weakness and fighting on foot.
16–20The elephants are spared for a royal gift
Moscow IV251:661 running text | IV251:662 running text | IV251:663 running text; IV251 n27 actual Turk alternative; main Rum | IV252:664 running text | IV252:665 running text; Mohl III99:680 running text | III99:681 running text | III99:682 running text | III99:683 running text | III99:684 running text; Ganjoor sh8:66 running poem body | sh8:67 running poem body | sh8:68 running poem body | sh8:69 running poem body | sh8:70 running poem body; Khaleghi III236:2140 running text | III236:2141 running text | III236:2142 running text; III236:2142 Rum-and-Chin main; n7 actual Turk alternative | III236:2143 running text | III236:2144 running text
Moscow printed p.251 · Moscow printed p.252 · Mohl printed p.99 · Khaleghi printed p.236 · Ganjoor sh8:66 · Ganjoor sh8:67 · Ganjoor sh8:68 · Ganjoor sh8:69 · Ganjoor sh8:70
All four presentations compare the army to ants and locusts and prohibit fighting the elephants and their drivers. English’s save from the grave strengthens restraint into active protection, consistent with the next promise to deliver them to the king. Naming Kay Khosrow makes the recipient explicit. The curse joining Ahriman to enemy peoples then divides the texts: Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi print Rum and Chin, while Mohl and actual Moscow and Khaleghi alternatives give Turk and Chin. English’s Turkistan follows that branch rather than silently replacing a universally shared Rum. Dark and faithless enlarge the description of Ahriman. The subsequent questions about misfortune and ignorance of Rostam retain the intimidating address common to all four sources.
21–25The noose enters a language of lethal gifts
Moscow IV252:666 running text | IV252:667 running text | IV252:668 running text | IV252:669 running text | IV252:670 running text; IV252:670 rawhide thrown main; n8 actual charma/horse alternative; Mohl III99:685 running text | III99:686 running text | III100:687 running text | III100:688 running text | III100:689 running text; Ganjoor sh8:71 running poem body | sh8:72 running poem body | sh8:73 running poem body | sh8:74 running poem body | sh8:75 running poem body; Khaleghi III236:2145 running text | III236:2146 running text | III236:2147 running text | III236:2148 running text | III236:2149 running text; III236:2149 rawhide thrown main; no horse reading verified in local apparatus
Moscow printed p.252 · Mohl printed p.99 · Mohl printed p.100 · Khaleghi printed p.236 · Ganjoor sh8:71 · Ganjoor sh8:72 · Ganjoor sh8:73 · Ganjoor sh8:74 · Ganjoor sh8:75
Rostam’s dismissal of dragons and pursuit of elephants occur in Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. English interprets the latter as a demonstration of strength. The following promise of mace and sword as gifts is shared, and its added hoard extends the exchange metaphor before the noose becomes the practical instrument of capture. All four describe loosening the rawhide and placing its coil on the saddle, followed by a cry capable of splitting a dragon’s ear. The final movement differs: Mohl has the horse driven about, supported by an actual Moscow alternative, whereas the Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi main texts describe casting the rawhide. English follows the mounted-motion branch while preserving the clearing of warriors from the field.
26–30Captures become an organized movement uphill
Moscow IV252 n9 actual desire-for-Chin/coiled-rawhide addition | IV252:671 running text | IV252:672 running text | IV252:673 running text | IV252:674 running text; Mohl III100:690 running text | III100:691 running text | III100:692 running text | III100:693 running text | III100:694 running text; Ganjoor sh8:75–76 checked local gap for English passage | sh8:76 running poem body | sh8:77 running poem body | sh8:78 running poem body | sh9:1 running poem body; Khaleghi III236:2150 running text | III236:2151 running text | III236:2152 running text | III236:2153 running text | III236:2154 running text
Moscow printed p.252 · Mohl printed p.100 · Khaleghi printed p.236 · Ganjoor sh8:75 · Ganjoor sh8:76 · Ganjoor sh8:77 · Ganjoor sh8:78 · Ganjoor sh9:1
The desire for combat with Chin, rawhide on the arm and furrowed brow stand in Mohl and Khaleghi running text and an actual Moscow addition; Ganjoor has a checked gap. English’s drag men down anticipates the capture that follows. All four then connect the unhorsing of a chief with Tus’s instruments and an Iranian escort binding the prisoner and moving toward the mountain. English’s every captive makes the repeated pattern explicit, while thunder climbing a shaken sky enlarges the source’s rising sound. Its published karnays and koust remain untouched. Finally, the Khan watches from his elephant and sees the ground like the Nile. English supplies flood; Khaleghi’s trembling ground gives motion a different form.
31–35Spectacle gives way to a diplomatic approach
Moscow IV252:675 running text; IV252:675 main names Rostam div-binder; n20 actual captives-in-noose alternative | IV252:676 running text | IV252:677 running text | IV252:678 running text | IV252:679 running text; Mohl III100:695 running text | III100:696 running text | III100:697 running text | III100:698 running text | III100:699 running text; Ganjoor sh9:2 running poem body | sh9:3 running poem body | sh9:4 running poem body | sh9:5 running poem body | sh9:6 running poem body; Khaleghi III236:2155 running text; III236:2155 noose and lions main; n30 actual Rostam div-binder alternative. English heroes interprets lions | III237:2156 running text | III237:2157 running text | III237:2158 running text | III237:2159 running text
Moscow printed p.252 · Mohl printed p.100 · Khaleghi printed p.236 · Khaleghi printed p.237 · Ganjoor sh9:2 · Ganjoor sh9:3 · Ganjoor sh9:4 · Ganjoor sh9:5 · Ganjoor sh9:6
The elephant-on-a-height image is shared, but its second half differs. Moscow and Ganjoor name Rostam as div-binder; Mohl and an actual Moscow alternative show captives in the noose. Khaleghi has lions held by the noose and prints the div-binder alternative. English’s bound heroes follows Mohl’s captive image. Vultures drawn from dark cloud and watching celestial bodies then enlarge the spectacle in all four sources. Against that scale, the Khan selects a chief who knows Iranian speech. English’s language of his foes stresses antagonism where the source names the language. The envoy’s instruction to restrain violence begins a claim that the named foreign peoples have no share in the feud, which English expands into neither hatred nor a claim.
36–40The Khan separates the coalition from Afrasiab
Moscow IV252:680 running text | IV253:681 running text; IV253:681 fire badly distinguished from water; n1 actual cannot-distinguish alternative | IV253:682 running text | IV253:683 running text | IV253:684 running text; Mohl III100:700 running text | III100:701 running text | III100:702 running text | III100:703 running text | III100:704 running text; Ganjoor sh9:7 running poem body | sh9:8 running poem body | sh9:9 running poem body | sh9:10 running poem body | sh9:11 running poem body; Khaleghi III237:2160 running text | III237:2161 running text; III237:2161 badly distinguishes fire and water; n13 actual does-not-distinguish alternative | III237:2162 running text | III237:2163 running text | III237:2164 running text
Moscow printed p.252 · Moscow printed p.253 · Mohl printed p.100 · Khaleghi printed p.237 · Ganjoor sh9:7 · Ganjoor sh9:8 · Ganjoor sh9:9 · Ganjoor sh9:10 · Ganjoor sh9:11
Across all four sources, the Khan distinguishes the foreign rulers from Afrasiab and locates the feud with the latter. English’s stand apart makes that attempted separation explicit; it remains the Khan’s argument, not an independently established innocence of the coalition. Afrasiab’s confusion of fire and water is absolute in Mohl and actual Moscow and Khaleghi alternatives, while the other main texts describe poor discrimination. English follows the absolute form and adds judgment dire. Its evil harvest develops the source’s self-incurred harm. The appeal to honor and peace also follows Mohl’s wording more closely: Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi include greed alongside name and honor. The envoy’s guileful heart interprets the shared image of inward folds or knots.
41–45Peace is proposed through reciprocal withdrawal
Moscow IV253:685 running text | IV253:686 running text | IV253:687 running text | IV253:688 running text | IV253:689 running text; Mohl III100:705 running text | III100:706 running text | III100:707 running text | III100:708 running text | III100:709 running text; Ganjoor sh9:12 running poem body | sh9:13 running poem body | sh9:14 running poem body | sh9:15 running poem body | sh9:16 running poem body; Khaleghi III237:2165 running text | III237:2166 running text | III237:2167 running text | III237:2168 running text | III237:2169 running text
Moscow printed p.253 · Mohl printed p.100 · Khaleghi printed p.237 · Ganjoor sh9:12 · Ganjoor sh9:13 · Ganjoor sh9:14 · Ganjoor sh9:15 · Ganjoor sh9:16
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all give the envoy a transition from battle to feast. English adds peace explicitly and casts the opening as a request that fighting cease. His next argument denies an earlier feud with the Khan, then proposes that Rostam withdraw when the Khan does. English makes this reciprocal arrangement clear, while its war is spent sounds more settled than the immediate battlefield still warrants; that assurance belongs to the envoy. Kamus’s death and the fighters’ changed disposition supply his reason. English’s refusal to seek the plain interprets the source’s turned heads as lost appetite for combat. Rostam answers with elephants, crown and ivory throne, converting the peace proposal into a demand for possession.
46–50Possession is disputed before it is secured
Moscow IV253:690 running text | IV253:691 running text; IV253:691 battle/haste wording; n15–16 actual in-my-hand/my-restraint alternatives | IV253 n16 actual spare-head/take-regalia addition | IV253:692 running text | IV253 n17 actual men/elephants/crown/wealth addition; Mohl III100:710 running text | III100:711 running text | III101:712 running text | III101:713 running text | III101:714 running text; Ganjoor sh9:17 running poem body | sh9:18 running poem body | sh9:18–19 checked local gap for English passage | sh9:19 running poem body | sh9:19–20 checked local gap for English passage; Khaleghi III237:2170 running text | III237:2171 running text; III237:2171 army in my grasp and its haste from my delay/restraint running | III237:2172 running text; III237:2172 spare head and take wealth/regalia running; n33–35 actual torque/crown alternatives | III238:2173 running text | III238:2174 running text
Moscow printed p.253 · Mohl printed p.100 · Mohl printed p.101 · Khaleghi printed p.237 · Khaleghi printed p.238 · Ganjoor sh9:17 · Ganjoor sh9:18 · Ganjoor sh9:19
The charge that the Khan came to plunder Iran is shared by all four sources. English adds the recoil of his schemes as the reason pleading is now useless. The next line needs qualification: Mohl and Khaleghi place the enemy army in Rostam’s grasp and relate its haste to his delay or restraint, with actual Moscow alternatives. English’s restraint of my own troops changes the reference and is not explicitly established by that wording. The spare-head, take-regalia verse is running in Mohl and Khaleghi and a Moscow addition; Ganjoor has a gap. The envoy’s uncaught-gazelle proverb contests this premature division of spoils, followed by another Mohl/Khaleghi verse and Moscow addition emphasizing the Khan’s remaining resources.
51–55The envoy’s warning meets the binding noose
Moscow IV253:693 running text | IV253:694 running text | IV253:695 running text; IV253:695 band main; n25 actual pand/counsel alternative | IV253:696 running text | IV254:697 running text; IV254:697 mounted chiefs collectively bound; n1 actual singular rider waist alternative; envoy identity contextual, not explicit noun; Mohl III101:715 running text | III101:716 running text | III101:717 running text | III101:718 running text | III101:719 running text; Ganjoor sh9:20 running poem body | sh9:21 running poem body | sh9:22 running poem body | sh9:23 running poem body | sh10:1 running poem body; Khaleghi III238:2175 running text | III238:2176 running text | III238:2177 running text; III238:2177 pand/counsel main; n6–7 actual deception/bond alternatives | III238:2178 running text | III238:2179 running text; III238:2179 riders waist collectively bound main; n9–10 actual head/chiefs variants; no explicit envoy noun
Moscow printed p.253 · Moscow printed p.254 · Mohl printed p.101 · Khaleghi printed p.238 · Ganjoor sh9:20 · Ganjoor sh9:21 · Ganjoor sh9:22 · Ganjoor sh9:23 · Ganjoor sh10:1
All four sources ask who can know the battle’s outcome, then give Rostam the boast of lion-feller and crown-giver. English converts those titles into present actions, conquering and dividing crowns. His strong body and noose on the arm are shared. Counsel has support in Mohl, Khaleghi and an actual Moscow alternative, while deception and bonds vary across the other wording. The parallel between Khan and lion sustains confidence in binding either opponent. The next capture is less explicit than English suggests: Mohl has a single rider caught at the waist, with a Moscow alternative, while Moscow and Ganjoor mainly bind mounted chiefs and Khaleghi binds riders. Identifying this captive as the envoy is contextual interpretation, not an explicit noun in the checked verse.
56–60The Khan loses height, freedom and regalia
Moscow IV254:698 running text | IV254 n6 actual Rostam son-of-Zal casting addition | IV254:699 running text | IV254:700 running text | IV254:701 running text; IV254:701 River Shahd main; n7 mountain variant; Mohl III101:720 running text | III101:721 running text | III101:722 running text | III101:723 running text | III101:724 running text; Ganjoor sh10:2 running poem body | sh10:2–3 checked local gap for English passage | sh10:3 running poem body | sh10:4 running poem body | sh10:5 running poem body; Khaleghi III238:2180 running text | III238:2180–2181 checked local gap for separate son-of-Zal casting verse; no corresponding complete local apparatus verse verified | III238:2181 running text | III238:2182 running text | III238:2183 running text; III238:2183 Mount Shahd main; n14 actual River variant; locality not independently identified
Moscow printed p.254 · Mohl printed p.101 · Khaleghi printed p.238 · Ganjoor sh10:2 · Ganjoor sh10:3 · Ganjoor sh10:4 · Ganjoor sh10:5
All four sources place the Khan on a white elephant and make him despair as Rostam approaches. The separate verse naming Rostam son of Zal and describing the cast is running in Mohl and actually printed in Moscow’s apparatus; Ganjoor and Khaleghi have checked local gaps. No complete matching Khaleghi addition was verified. The released noose catches the head, and the Khan is pulled down and bound. English’s passive construction leaves the binders unspecified, consistent with the source’s plural agents. His destination also varies: Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor print River Shahd, whereas Khaleghi prints Mount Shahd with an actual River alternative. English follows the river branch; the geographical identification itself remains unverified. Walking without regalia completes the reversal.
61–65The prisoner prompts a reflection on reversal
Moscow IV254 n11 actual transfer-to-Tus/kus verse at end of additions after703; English relocates before world reflection | IV254:702 running text | IV254:703 running text; IV254:703 war/poison and sweetness/love main; n9–11 actual word-order and hate/sweetness alternatives | IV254 n11 actual additions beginning yeki-ra be-arad and yeki-ra ze-takht; English blends details and omits army promotion | IV254 n11 actual na-inat-mehr Creator-address addition; Mohl III101:725 running text | III101:726 running text | III101:727 running text | III101:728 running text; III101:729 running text; two source units combined; partial unmatched half-verse retained as S1 | III101:730 running text; Ganjoor sh10:5–6 checked local gap for English passage | sh10:6 running poem body | sh10:7 running poem body | sh10:7–8 checked local gap for English passage; Khaleghi III238 n19 actual guards-of-the-shah transfer addition; no Tus/kus wording in inspected addition. Partial support only; running gap2183–2184 | III238:2184 running text | III238:2185 running text; III238:2185 war/hate and sweetness/love main; n17–19 actual poison alternatives | III238 n19 actual raised-to-sky and made-mournful addition; no separate king/dust/army-promotion verse verified locally | III238–239:2185–2186 checked running gap; Creator-address verse not verified in inspected local apparatus
Moscow printed p.254 · Mohl printed p.101 · Khaleghi printed p.238 · Ganjoor sh10:5 · Ganjoor sh10:6 · Ganjoor sh10:7
Mohl puts the transfer to Tus’s guards and the rising kus before the reflection on worldly instability. Moscow prints it later within an actual addition; Ganjoor has a gap, while Khaleghi’s inspected addition gives only transfer to the shah’s guards without Tus or the drum. English follows Mohl’s sequence. The deceptive world and alternating fortunes are shared, although war, hatred, poison and sweetness vary. English then blends two Mohl verses, also printed as Moscow additions, into one contrast between elevation from dust and a king’s humiliation, dropping promotion into the army. Khaleghi prints only the sky-and-suffering comparison locally. The Creator address that follows is verified in Mohl and Moscow’s addition; Ganjoor and Khaleghi have checked local gaps.
66–69The closing address moves from mystery to a plea
Moscow IV254 n11 actual jahandara-bolandi height/depth addition, after joy/lack verse | IV254 n11 actual ze-to-shadmani joy/grief/excess/lack addition, before height/depth verse | IV254 n11 actual yeki-ra be-ari kingship/fishes addition | IV254 n11 actual yeki-ra be-dadi give/no-hatred addition; Mohl III101:731 running text | III101:732 running text | III101:733 running text | III101:734 running text; Ganjoor sh10:7–8 checked local gap for English passage; Khaleghi III238–239:2185–2186 checked running gap; height/depth/all-is-You verse not verified in inspected local apparatus | III238 n19 actual joy/distress addition gives partial support; excess/lack wording not verified in inspected local apparatus | III238–239:2185–2186 checked running gap; kingship/fishes verse not verified in inspected local apparatus | III238–239:2185–2186 checked running gap; give-to-another/no-hatred verse not verified in inspected local apparatus
Moscow printed p.254 · Mohl printed p.101 · Khaleghi printed p.238 · Ganjoor sh10:7
Mohl prints the height-and-depth address, joy and grief, unequal portions, kingship and fishes, and the plea for another gift. Moscow prints these individually in its actual local addition, with the height-and-depth verse placed after joy and grief. English follows Mohl’s order. Ganjoor has a checked local gap for this sequence. Khaleghi’s inspected apparatus gives a partial joy-and-distress parallel, but not the excess-and-lack wording or the other complete verses; their presence elsewhere remains unverified. English’s capitalized You makes the divine address unmistakable without establishing a particular philosophical doctrine. Its throne and ocean depths expand the kingship-and-sea contrast. The final appeal to avoid hatred between two noble men turns reflection on unequal fortune into a request for generosity.
Source record and limits
Inspected 12 November 2026. B14.14 only:69 English couplets;138 exact published lines;14 notes. Moscow IV250–254:646–703 (58 running units); Mohl III99–101:664–734 (71); Ganjoor khaghan sh8:51–78,sh9:1–23,sh10:1–7 (58); Khaleghi III235–238:2124–2185 (62), with III239 checked as the following boundary. Every declared running unit accounted. S1 retains one unmatched half-verse from a source unit partly used in English64; no double counting. Moscow and Mohl inspected individually first, then Ganjoor and Khaleghi. Earlier chapters unchanged.
Edition scope and inspected pages
- Published English B14.14
- Moscow: printed 250 / PDF 250, printed 251 / PDF 251, printed 252 / PDF 252, printed 253 / PDF 253, printed 254 / PDF 254
- Mohl: printed 99 / PDF 105, printed 100 / PDF 106, printed 101 / PDF 107
- Khaleghi: printed 235 / PDF 251, printed 236 / PDF 252, printed 237 / PDF 253, printed 238 / PDF 254, printed 239 / PDF 255
- Ganjoor sh8:51–78
- Ganjoor sh9:1–23
- Ganjoor sh10:1–7
Evidence distinctions and retained limits
Actual Moscow apparatus used:250 n27–29;251 n19,n27;252 n8,n9,n20;253 n1,n15–17,n25;254 n1,n6,n7,n9–11. The extended254 n11 addition is actually printed and individual clauses are identified, not inferred from an addition notice. Actual Khaleghi apparatus used:235 n7;236 n7,n30;237 n13,n33–35;238 n6–7,n9–10,n14,n17–19. Khaleghi238 n19 gives only selected closing parallels; no complete local Creator-address,height/depth,kingship/fishes or final giving/no-hatred verses verified. Its joy/distress parallel is partial. No appendix evidence used or exhaustive appendix claim. Unprinted notices never establish verification.
All inherited provisional flags retained. Current qualifications:8 published Chakh versus source Chachi;12 curse position follows Mohl;15 conditional dismount compressed and resolve supplied;18 Turk/Rum branch;25 horse/rawhide variant;31 captives versus div-binder/lions;39 greed absent following Mohl;47 my-own-army restraint changes source reference;55 envoy identification contextual rather than explicit;57 Khaleghi local gap;60 River/Mount Shahd and unverified geography;61 guards transfer partial in Khaleghi;64 two verses blended with unmatched army-promotion half-line;65–69 checked Khaleghi/Ganjoor local gaps or partial parallels, not exhaustive absence. English unchanged.
Selected inspected readings
- Mohl III99:678–679 condition on dismounting: چنو سست گردد پیاده شوم
- Mohl III100:711 army in my grasp: چو داند که لشکر بچنگ منست
- Mohl III101:719 single rider waist: میان سوار اندر آمد ببند
- Moscow IV254:697 collective chiefs: سران سواران همی کرد بند
- Khaleghi III238:2183 Mount Shahd running: پیاده همی راند تا کوه شهد
- Mohl III101:730 Creator address: نه با آنت مهر و نه با اینت کین
- Mohl III101:734 gift and hatred: یکی را بدادی دگرا بده / میان دو آزاده کینه منه
Persian display uses labelled Ganjoor units or Mohl transcription for checked Ganjoor gaps. Full Mohl728–729 accompanies English64, with the unmatched army-promotion half-line separately recorded in S1. Source units shared between rows are counted once. The philosophical ending is verified in the specific running text and printed additions stated; local gaps do not establish absence from an entire edition. No composite reconstruction from English or scans distributed.
B14.14 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV250:646 running text | III99:664 running text |
| 2 | IV250:647 running text; IV250:647 opening curse; n27–29 variants in Iran/king/mercy formulation | III99:665 running text |
| 3 | IV251:648 running text | III99:666 running text |
| 4 | IV251:649 running text | III99:667 running text |
| 5 | IV251:650 running text | III99:668 running text |
| 6 | IV251:651 running text | III99:669 running text |
| 7 | IV251:652 running text | III99:670 running text |
| 8 | IV251:653 running text; IV251:653 Chachi bows; English published Chakh retained | III99:671 running text |
| 9 | IV251:654 running text | III99:672 running text |
| 10 | IV251:655 running text | III99:673 running text |
| 11 | IV251:656 running text | III99:674 running text |
| 12 | IV251 n19 actual curse addition placed after657, not before as English/Mohl | III99:675 running text |
| 13 | IV251:657 running text | III99:676 running text |
| 14 | IV251:658 running text | III99:677 running text |
| 15 | IV251:659 running text; IV251:660 running text; IV251:659–660 two running verses compressed; walking conditional on Rakhsh weakening | III99:678 running text; III99:679 running text |
| 16 | IV251:661 running text | III99:680 running text |
| 17 | IV251:662 running text | III99:681 running text |
| 18 | IV251:663 running text; IV251 n27 actual Turk alternative; main Rum | III99:682 running text |
| 19 | IV252:664 running text | III99:683 running text |
| 20 | IV252:665 running text | III99:684 running text |
| 21 | IV252:666 running text | III99:685 running text |
| 22 | IV252:667 running text | III99:686 running text |
| 23 | IV252:668 running text | III100:687 running text |
| 24 | IV252:669 running text | III100:688 running text |
| 25 | IV252:670 running text; IV252:670 rawhide thrown main; n8 actual charma/horse alternative | III100:689 running text |
| 26 | IV252 n9 actual desire-for-Chin/coiled-rawhide addition | III100:690 running text |
| 27 | IV252:671 running text | III100:691 running text |
| 28 | IV252:672 running text | III100:692 running text |
| 29 | IV252:673 running text | III100:693 running text |
| 30 | IV252:674 running text | III100:694 running text |
| 31 | IV252:675 running text; IV252:675 main names Rostam div-binder; n20 actual captives-in-noose alternative | III100:695 running text |
| 32 | IV252:676 running text | III100:696 running text |
| 33 | IV252:677 running text | III100:697 running text |
| 34 | IV252:678 running text | III100:698 running text |
| 35 | IV252:679 running text | III100:699 running text |
| 36 | IV252:680 running text | III100:700 running text |
| 37 | IV253:681 running text; IV253:681 fire badly distinguished from water; n1 actual cannot-distinguish alternative | III100:701 running text |
| 38 | IV253:682 running text | III100:702 running text |
| 39 | IV253:683 running text | III100:703 running text |
| 40 | IV253:684 running text | III100:704 running text |
| 41 | IV253:685 running text | III100:705 running text |
| 42 | IV253:686 running text | III100:706 running text |
| 43 | IV253:687 running text | III100:707 running text |
| 44 | IV253:688 running text | III100:708 running text |
| 45 | IV253:689 running text | III100:709 running text |
| 46 | IV253:690 running text | III100:710 running text |
| 47 | IV253:691 running text; IV253:691 battle/haste wording; n15–16 actual in-my-hand/my-restraint alternatives | III100:711 running text |
| 48 | IV253 n16 actual spare-head/take-regalia addition | III101:712 running text |
| 49 | IV253:692 running text | III101:713 running text |
| 50 | IV253 n17 actual men/elephants/crown/wealth addition | III101:714 running text |
| 51 | IV253:693 running text | III101:715 running text |
| 52 | IV253:694 running text | III101:716 running text |
| 53 | IV253:695 running text; IV253:695 band main; n25 actual pand/counsel alternative | III101:717 running text |
| 54 | IV253:696 running text | III101:718 running text |
| 55 | IV254:697 running text; IV254:697 mounted chiefs collectively bound; n1 actual singular rider waist alternative; envoy identity contextual, not explicit noun | III101:719 running text |
| 56 | IV254:698 running text | III101:720 running text |
| 57 | IV254 n6 actual Rostam son-of-Zal casting addition | III101:721 running text |
| 58 | IV254:699 running text | III101:722 running text |
| 59 | IV254:700 running text | III101:723 running text |
| 60 | IV254:701 running text; IV254:701 River Shahd main; n7 mountain variant | III101:724 running text |
| 61 | IV254 n11 actual transfer-to-Tus/kus verse at end of additions after703; English relocates before world reflection | III101:725 running text |
| 62 | IV254:702 running text | III101:726 running text |
| 63 | IV254:703 running text; IV254:703 war/poison and sweetness/love main; n9–11 actual word-order and hate/sweetness alternatives | III101:727 running text |
| 64 | IV254 n11 actual additions beginning yeki-ra be-arad and yeki-ra ze-takht; English blends details and omits army promotion | III101:728 running text; III101:729 running text; two source units combined; partial unmatched half-verse retained as S1 |
| 65 | IV254 n11 actual na-inat-mehr Creator-address addition | III101:730 running text |
| 66 | IV254 n11 actual jahandara-bolandi height/depth addition, after joy/lack verse | III101:731 running text |
| 67 | IV254 n11 actual ze-to-shadmani joy/grief/excess/lack addition, before height/depth verse | III101:732 running text |
| 68 | IV254 n11 actual yeki-ra be-ari kingship/fishes addition | III101:733 running text |
| 69 | IV254 n11 actual yeki-ra be-dadi give/no-hatred addition | III101:734 running text |
New Naqqali