The Shah Replies to Rostam
B14.18:42 couplets;84 unchanged lines.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | B14.18:42 couplets;84 unchanged lines. |
| Moscow | IV265–268:874–913;40 running units plus actual apparatus. |
| Mohl | III109–110:905–946;42 running units; PDF115–116. |
| Ganjoor | Khaghan sh11:45–57 and sh12:1–27;40 running units; two checked local gaps. |
| Khaleghi | III249–251:2352–2392;41 running units plus actual apparatus; PDF265–267. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5The royal reception follows a restless heaven
Moscow IV265:874 running text; n13 no-rest alternative to rested main | IV265:875 running text | IV265:876 running text; n17 actual chiefs-and-army alternative to trumpet/drum main | IV265:877 running text | IV265 n18 actually printed praise addition after877; no corresponding running unit; Mohl III109:905 running text | III109:906 running text | III109:907 running text | III109:908 running text | III109:909 running text; Ganjoor sh11:45 running poem body | sh11:46 running poem body | sh11:47 running poem body | sh11:48 running poem body | sh11:48–49 checked local gap for praise verse; Khaleghi III249:2352 running text; n11 rested alternative to no-rest main | III249:2353 running text | III249:2354 running text; n14 actual chiefs alternative to trumpet/drum main | III249:2355 running text | III249 n15 actually printed praise additions after2355; wording differs from Mohl909; no corresponding running unit; III249 n15 actually printed praise additions after2355, wording differs from Mohl909; no running unit
Moscow printed p.265 · Mohl printed p.109 · Khaleghi printed p.249 · Ganjoor sh11:45 · Ganjoor sh11:46 · Ganjoor sh11:47 · Ganjoor sh11:48
The opening gives a consequential small variant. English follows Mohl and Khaleghi in saying that heaven never rests, while Moscow and Ganjoor’s main texts say it rested; Moscow actually prints the negative alternative. Swiftly is English’s addition to the passing days. The announcement of Fariborz and his reverence before Khosrow are shared. The reception emphasizes chiefs in Mohl but trumpet and drum in the other main texts, with chief-centered alternatives printed in Moscow and Khaleghi. English’s martial sound accommodates the ceremonial atmosphere without naming those instruments. Fariborz’s praise is running text in Mohl and a printed Moscow addition. Khaleghi prints related praise additions with different continuations, and Ganjoor has a checked local gap; that distinction prevents false unanimity.
6–10The crowned king becomes a grieving son
Moscow IV266:878 running text | IV266:879 running text; IV266:880 dismount shared with English8 | IV266:880 running text | IV266:881 running text | IV266:882 running text; Mohl III109:910 running text | III109:911 running text; III109:912 dismount shared with English8 | III109:912 running text | III109:913 running text | III109:914 running text; Ganjoor sh11:49 running poem body | sh11:50,51 running poem body | sh11:51 running poem body | sh11:52 running poem body | sh11:53 running poem body; Khaleghi III249:2356 running text | III249:2357 running text; III249:2358 dismount shared with English8 | III249:2358 running text | III249:2359 running text | III249:2360 running text
Moscow printed p.266 · Mohl printed p.109 · Khaleghi printed p.249 · Ganjoor sh11:49 · Ganjoor sh11:50 · Ganjoor sh11:51 · Ganjoor sh11:52 · Ganjoor sh11:53
All four sources turn from the captives, camels, elephants and wounded to the king’s prayer. English’s men who bore war’s pain extends attention to suffering without changing the inventory’s human element. Removing the crown and dismounting enact humility: English moves the start of the dismount into its preceding couplet, so that action shares a source unit with the rolling in dust that follows. The source’s pure world-ruler becomes holy Ruler with strength and guidance added. Fatherlessness and grief preserve the prayer’s personal center; dread intensifies it. Deliverance from distress and the nurturing of the crown are shared across Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi, while English’s realm and reign make the crown’s political implications explicit.
11–15Thanks to God coexist with praise for Rostam
Moscow IV266:883 running text | IV266:884 running text | IV266:885 running text | IV266:886 running text | IV266:887 running text; Mohl III109:915 running text | III109:916 running text | III109:917 running text | III109:918 running text | III109:919 running text; Ganjoor sh11:54 running poem body | sh11:55 running poem body | sh11:56 running poem body | sh11:57 running poem body | sh12:1 running poem body; Khaleghi III249:2361 running text | III249:2362 running text | III250:2363 running text | III250:2364 running text | III250:2365 running text
Moscow printed p.266 · Mohl printed p.109 · Khaleghi printed p.249 · Khaleghi printed p.250 · Ganjoor sh11:54 · Ganjoor sh11:55 · Ganjoor sh11:56 · Ganjoor sh11:57 · Ganjoor sh12:1
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all make earth and time subject to the king and fill the world with his treasure. English’s throne and emphatic ownership expand that sovereignty. The next contrast gives thanks to God rather than the assembly; English identifies that assembly as the men who won the fighting. This is a narrower referent, not a reason to erase the subsequent human gratitude. The plea that Rostam’s life be preserved and the blessing of his bright spirit immediately maintain the hero’s importance in all four accounts. English’s enduring wish makes that blessing especially warm. The return to the palace and the tree planted in greatness’s garden remain metaphorical; one more presents the reply as a further act of cultivation.
16–20The reply locates contrary fortunes in one creator
Moscow IV266:888 running text; IV266 n18 actual good/ill alternative to bright-heart/fortune main | IV266:889 running text; IV266 n19 actual Saturn alternative to Venus main; n20 alliance alternative to repose main | IV266:890 running text | IV266:891 running text | IV266:892 running text; Mohl III109:920 running text | III109:921 running text | III109:922 running text | III110:923 running text | III110:924 running text; Ganjoor sh12:2 running poem body | sh12:3 running poem body | sh12:4 running poem body | sh12:5 running poem body | sh12:6 running poem body; Khaleghi III250:2366 running text; III250 n7 bright-heart/fortune alternative to good/ill main | III250:2367 running text; III250 n8 Venus alternative to Saturn main; n9 repose variant to alliance main | III250:2368 running text | III250:2369 running text | III250:2370 running text; III250 n14 actual thanks alternative to manliness/fear/reverence main
Moscow printed p.266 · Mohl printed p.109 · Mohl printed p.110 · Khaleghi printed p.250 · Ganjoor sh12:2 · Ganjoor sh12:3 · Ganjoor sh12:4 · Ganjoor sh12:5 · Ganjoor sh12:6
English’s good and ill follows Mohl and Khaleghi and an actual Moscow alternative; Moscow and Ganjoor’s main opening instead names a bright heart and good fortune. Saturn likewise follows Mohl and Khaleghi, with Moscow’s main Venus supported by Ganjoor and its Saturn alternative printed below. Treaties interprets the bond or alliance reading, against repose in Moscow and Ganjoor’s main texts. The adornment of the world by night and day is shared, as is the contrast between dark fortune and fitness for a throne. English’s by right gives that fitness a juridical emphasis. At the close, gratitude follows Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and a Khaleghi alternative; Khaleghi’s main wording instead includes manliness, fear and reverence.
21–25Received treasure becomes a measure of martial power
Moscow IV267:893 running text | IV267 n3 actually printed goods addition after893; no corresponding running unit | IV267:894 running text | IV267:895 running text | IV267:896 running text; Mohl III110:925 running text | III110:926 running text | III110:927 running text | III110:928 running text | III110:929 running text; Ganjoor sh12:7 running poem body | sh12:7–8 checked local gap for goods verse | sh12:8 running poem body | sh12:9 running poem body | sh12:10 running poem body; Khaleghi III250:2371 running text | III250:2372 running text | III250:2373 running text | III250:2374 running text | III250:2375 running text
Moscow printed p.267 · Mohl printed p.110 · Khaleghi printed p.250 · Ganjoor sh12:7 · Ganjoor sh12:8 · Ganjoor sh12:9 · Ganjoor sh12:10
Mohl and Khaleghi acknowledge what Rostam said, whereas Moscow and Ganjoor’s main texts acknowledge what he gave; Moscow prints the speech alternative. English’s wrote specifies the medium already established by the narrative. The detailed Chinese fabric, ivory throne and Arabian-horse verse is running text in Mohl and Khaleghi and actually printed in Moscow’s apparatus, with a checked Ganjoor gap. English expands the torque into a golden chain and does not separately repeat its crown. The following clothing and spreads become more specific textile types, while rare supplies an evaluation. All four then turn these feast goods into a rhetorical question about fighting Rostam. English’s courting death makes explicit the suicidal logic of challenging him when one has wearied of life.
26–30The king discloses private anxiety and public dependence
Moscow IV267:897 running text; IV267 n11 actual many troops alternative to Turan army main | IV267:898 running text; IV267 n12 actual anxious-day/night alternative to news main | IV267:899 running text; IV267 n15 actual wise-chief alternative to torn-heart main | IV267:900 running text | IV267:901 running text; Mohl III110:930 running text | III110:931 running text | III110:932 running text | III110:933 running text | III110:934 running text; Ganjoor sh12:11 running poem body | sh12:12 running poem body | sh12:13 running poem body | sh12:14 running poem body | sh12:15 running poem body; Khaleghi III250:2376 running text; III250 n28 actual many troops alternative to Turan army main | III251:2377 running text; III251 n1 news and anxious-day/night alternatives to endured wording main | III251:2378 running text; III251 n3 wise-chief alternative to torn-heart main | III251:2379 running text | III251:2380 running text
Moscow printed p.267 · Mohl printed p.110 · Khaleghi printed p.250 · Khaleghi printed p.251 · Ganjoor sh12:11 · Ganjoor sh12:12 · Ganjoor sh12:13 · Ganjoor sh12:14 · Ganjoor sh12:15
Mohl gives the numerous enemy troops where Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi’s main texts specify Turan; Moscow and Khaleghi print the numerical alternative. English supplies battlefield dust for the source’s day-and-night exposure, carrying the temporal phrase into its next couplet. That couplet follows Mohl’s anxiety rather than Moscow and Ganjoor’s receipt of news; Khaleghi’s main endurance wording and its printed anxiety alternative are distinguished. Silence to outsiders remains shared. The wise chief in the prayer follows Mohl and actual Moscow and Khaleghi alternatives to the torn heart of their main texts and Ganjoor. All four link Rostam’s protection with enduring youth. English’s sliding kingdoms supplies political instability around that hyperbole, before preserving fortune’s affection for an unequalled servant.
31–34The royal reward has variant quantities
Moscow IV267:902 running text | IV267:903 running text | IV267:904 running text; IV267 n21 actual girdled alternative; main gold-girdled; n22 ten horses alternative to hundred main | IV267:905 running text; IV267 n23 ten first camels alternative to hundred main; Mohl III110:935 running text | III110:936 running text | III110:937 running text | III110:938 running text; Ganjoor sh12:16 running poem body | sh12:17 running poem body | sh12:18 running poem body | sh12:19 running poem body; Khaleghi III251:2381 running text | III251:2382 running text | III251:2383 running text; III251 n9 hundred horses alternative to ten main | III251:2384 running text; III251 n11 hundred first camels alternative to ten main
Moscow printed p.267 · Mohl printed p.110 · Khaleghi printed p.251 · Ganjoor sh12:16 · Ganjoor sh12:17 · Ganjoor sh12:18 · Ganjoor sh12:19
The completed writing, royal seal, honor garment and prepared horse fittings are shared by Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. English’s seal upon the praise describes the letter through its content; well wrought adds workmanship. The attendants’ curls and girdles are retained, with slaves making their courtly status more explicit. Mohl gives girdled attendants, while the other main texts specify golden girdles. The horses and first camel-loads expose a numerical difference: English’s hundred follows Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor, whereas Khaleghi gives ten in each main reading and prints hundred alternatives. The second hundred camel-loads is shared. English’s tapestries specifies the broader category of spreads rather than documenting a distinct textile construction in every edition.
35–38Jewels and weapons distinguish the recipients
Moscow IV267:906 running text; IV267 n26 actual golden-crown alternative to pearl wording main | IV267:907 running text | IV267:908 running text | IV267:909 running text; IV267 n30 sword/mace variants; n31 actual crown alternative to golden throne main; Mohl III110:939 running text | III110:940 running text | III110:941 running text | III110:942 running text; Ganjoor sh12:20 running poem body | sh12:21 running poem body | sh12:22 running poem body | sh12:23 running poem body; Khaleghi III251:2385 running text; III251 n13 two rings alternative to ten main; n15 pearl/crown variants | III251:2386 running text | III251:2387 running text | III251:2388 running text; III251 n18 mace alternative; n19 sword alternative; n20 mace alternative to torque main; these are separate apparatus readings, not one silently constructed combined text
Moscow printed p.267 · Mohl printed p.110 · Khaleghi printed p.251 · Ganjoor sh12:20 · Ganjoor sh12:21 · Ganjoor sh12:22 · Ganjoor sh12:23
The two ruby rings follow Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor; Khaleghi prints ten in its main text and two as an actual alternative. English’s golden crown has support in Mohl and Khaleghi and a Moscow alternative, while Moscow and Ganjoor’s main wording emphasizes pearls. Royal garments, armlet, torque and belt are shared, with beaten gold and many folds supplying material detail. Gifts for every chief and the emptied treasury retain their collective scale. Fariborz’s specific reward follows Mohl’s crown, mace, flag, golden sword and boots. Moscow and Khaleghi arrange throne, crown, torque and weapon readings differently across main text and apparatus. Their separate variants must not be assembled into a fictitious single reading merely to reproduce the English list.
39–42The return carries an unfinished demand for revenge
Moscow IV268:910 running text | IV268:911 running text | IV268:912 running text; IV268 n3 lofty alternative to harmful main; n4 one alternative to bound main | IV268:913 running text; Mohl III110:943 running text | III110:944 running text | III110:945 running text | III110:946 running text; Ganjoor sh12:24 running poem body | sh12:25 running poem body | sh12:26 running poem body | sh12:27 running poem body; Khaleghi III251:2389 running text | III251:2390 running text | III251:2391 running text; III251 n24 harmful alternative to lofty main; n25 bound alternative to one main | III251:2392 running text
Moscow printed p.268 · Mohl printed p.110 · Khaleghi printed p.251 · Ganjoor sh12:24 · Ganjoor sh12:25 · Ganjoor sh12:26 · Ganjoor sh12:27
All four sources send Fariborz back from Iran toward the commander and attach an instruction about the struggle with Afrasiab. English’s charged him thus to say turns the narrative sequence into an explicit messenger’s commission. Its we must makes the prohibition of rest, food and sleep collective, without establishing that Khosrow himself joins the march. The wished-for capture remains conditional. Mohl and Khaleghi describe the king’s lofty head; Moscow and Ganjoor’s main wording stresses harmfulness, with a lofty alternative actually printed in Moscow. English adds pride and renders capture as bowing within the lasso. The final departure follows the Shah’s desire in all four accounts. English’s wished and said combines that satisfaction with the preceding command rather than adding a new instruction.
Source record and limits
Inspected 12 November 2026. B14.18 only:42 English couplets;84 exact published lines;9 notes. Moscow IV265–268:874–913 (40 running units) plus actual apparatus; Mohl III109–110:905–946 (42 running units; PDF115–116); Ganjoor khaghan sh11:45–57 and sh12:1–27 (40 running units); Khaleghi III249–251:2352–2392 (41 running units; PDF265–267) plus actual apparatus. English5 uses Mohl running praise verse, actual Moscow addition, related Khaleghi additions and checked Ganjoor gap; English22 uses Mohl/Khaleghi running goods verse, actual Moscow addition and checked Ganjoor gap. English7–8 share the dismount unit, counted once. No source-only running unit in declared scope. Moscow and Mohl inspected individually first, then Ganjoor and Khaleghi. Earlier chapters unchanged.
Edition scope and inspected pages
- Published English B14.18
- Moscow: printed 265 / PDF 265, printed 266 / PDF 266, printed 267 / PDF 267, printed 268 / PDF 268
- Mohl: printed 109 / PDF 115, printed 110 / PDF 116
- Khaleghi: printed 249 / PDF 265, printed 250 / PDF 266, printed 251 / PDF 267
- Ganjoor sh11:45–57; Ganjoor sh12:1–27
Evidence distinctions and retained limits
Actual Moscow apparatus used:265 n13,n17–18;266 n18–20;267 n1,n3,n11–12,n15,n21–23,n26,n30–31;268 n3–4. Actual Khaleghi apparatus used:249 n11,n14–15;250 n7–9,n14,n28;251 n1,n3,n9,n11,n13,n15,n18–20,n24–25. Praise and goods additions individually read, not inferred from availability or unprinted notices. Khaleghi249 n15 praise additions have different continuations from Mohl909. Separate weapon/ornament apparatus readings are not a composite edition text. No appendix evidence used or exhaustive appendix claim. Other additions on inspected pages not exhaustively collated.
Every inherited provisional flag retained. B14.18 qualifications:1 rested/no-rest;3 reception variant;5 praise addition status and different Khaleghi wording;7–8 shared dismount;12 assembly interpreted as victorious men;16 good/ill versus bright fortune;17 Saturn/Venus and alliance/repose;20 thanks versus Khaleghi main manliness/fear/reverence;21 said/gave;22 actual goods addition and Ganjoor gap;26 dust supplied and day/night carried forward;27 anxiety/news/endurance;28 wise chief/torn heart;33–35 hundred/ten horses and first camels, two/ten rings;35 golden/pearl crown;38 separate Fariborz gift readings;41 lofty/harmful and capture image. English unchanged.
Selected inspected readings
- Mohl III109:905 no rest running: ز گردش نیاسود چرخ بلند
- Moscow IV265:874 rest running: ز گردش بیاسود چرخ بلند
- Mohl III109:921 Saturn running: خداوند کیوان و گردان سپهر
- Moscow IV266:889 Venus running: خداوند ناهید و گردان سپهر
- Mohl III110:931 anxiety running: ز کارت غمی بوده ام روز و شب
- Moscow IV267:898 news running: ز کارت خبر بد مرا روز و شب
- Khaleghi III251:2383 ten horses running: ده اسپ گرانمایه با زین زر
- Mohl III110:937 hundred horses running: صد اسپ گرانمایه با زین زر
- Khaleghi III251:2385 ten rings running: ز یاقوت رخشان ده انگشتری
Persian display uses labelled Ganjoor units and individually labelled Mohl units for English5 and22. English7 begins the dismount belonging to the next displayed Persian unit; both rows account for that shared source unit without counting it twice. Variants remain separate; no composite Persian text is reconstructed to match English. Every declared running unit is accounted.
B14.18 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV265:874 running text; n13 no-rest alternative to rested main | III109:905 running text |
| 2 | IV265:875 running text | III109:906 running text |
| 3 | IV265:876 running text; n17 actual chiefs-and-army alternative to trumpet/drum main | III109:907 running text |
| 4 | IV265:877 running text | III109:908 running text |
| 5 | IV265 n18 actually printed praise addition after877; no corresponding running unit | III109:909 running text |
| 6 | IV266:878 running text | III109:910 running text |
| 7 | IV266:879 running text; IV266:880 dismount shared with English8 | III109:911 running text; III109:912 dismount shared with English8 |
| 8 | IV266:880 running text | III109:912 running text |
| 9 | IV266:881 running text | III109:913 running text |
| 10 | IV266:882 running text | III109:914 running text |
| 11 | IV266:883 running text | III109:915 running text |
| 12 | IV266:884 running text | III109:916 running text |
| 13 | IV266:885 running text | III109:917 running text |
| 14 | IV266:886 running text | III109:918 running text |
| 15 | IV266:887 running text | III109:919 running text |
| 16 | IV266:888 running text; IV266 n18 actual good/ill alternative to bright-heart/fortune main | III109:920 running text |
| 17 | IV266:889 running text; IV266 n19 actual Saturn alternative to Venus main; n20 alliance alternative to repose main | III109:921 running text |
| 18 | IV266:890 running text | III109:922 running text |
| 19 | IV266:891 running text | III110:923 running text |
| 20 | IV266:892 running text | III110:924 running text |
| 21 | IV267:893 running text | III110:925 running text |
| 22 | IV267 n3 actually printed goods addition after893; no corresponding running unit | III110:926 running text |
| 23 | IV267:894 running text | III110:927 running text |
| 24 | IV267:895 running text | III110:928 running text |
| 25 | IV267:896 running text | III110:929 running text |
| 26 | IV267:897 running text; IV267 n11 actual many troops alternative to Turan army main | III110:930 running text |
| 27 | IV267:898 running text; IV267 n12 actual anxious-day/night alternative to news main | III110:931 running text |
| 28 | IV267:899 running text; IV267 n15 actual wise-chief alternative to torn-heart main | III110:932 running text |
| 29 | IV267:900 running text | III110:933 running text |
| 30 | IV267:901 running text | III110:934 running text |
| 31 | IV267:902 running text | III110:935 running text |
| 32 | IV267:903 running text | III110:936 running text |
| 33 | IV267:904 running text; IV267 n21 actual girdled alternative; main gold-girdled; n22 ten horses alternative to hundred main | III110:937 running text |
| 34 | IV267:905 running text; IV267 n23 ten first camels alternative to hundred main | III110:938 running text |
| 35 | IV267:906 running text; IV267 n26 actual golden-crown alternative to pearl wording main | III110:939 running text |
| 36 | IV267:907 running text | III110:940 running text |
| 37 | IV267:908 running text | III110:941 running text |
| 38 | IV267:909 running text; IV267 n30 sword/mace variants; n31 actual crown alternative to golden throne main | III110:942 running text |
| 39 | IV268:910 running text | III110:943 running text |
| 40 | IV268:911 running text | III110:944 running text |
| 41 | IV268:912 running text; IV268 n3 lofty alternative to harmful main; n4 one alternative to bound main | III110:945 running text |
| 42 | IV268:913 running text | III110:946 running text |
New Naqqali