Puladvand Battles Giv and Tus
33 couplets;66 unchanged lines.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 33 couplets;66 unchanged lines. |
| Moscow | IV287–289:1205–1235;31 running units plus actual apparatus. |
| Mohl | III124–125:1276–1308;33 running units; PDF130–131. |
| Ganjoor | Khaghan sh15:1–31;31 running units; retained successful12 November retrieval, fresh404. |
| Khaleghi | III271–272:2677–2706;30 running units plus actual apparatus and checked gaps; PDF287–288. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–4Dawn opens another field of battle
Moscow IV287:1205 running text | IV287:1206 running text | IV287:1207 running text | IV287:1208 running text; Mohl III124:1276 running text | III124:1277 running text | III124:1278 running text | III124:1279 running text; Ganjoor sh15:1 running poem body | sh15:2 running poem body | sh15:3 running poem body | sh15:4 running poem body; Khaleghi III271:2677 running text | III271:2678 running text | III271:2679 running text | III271:2680 running text
Moscow printed p.287 · Mohl printed p.124 · Khaleghi printed p.271 · Ganjoor sh15:1 · Ganjoor sh15:2 · Ganjoor sh15:3 · Ganjoor sh15:4
The English preserves the shared transformation of violet silk into saffron as the sun displays its standard. Naming night and sky makes the metaphor’s setting explicit rather than introducing additional objects. The four editions then move from the royal gate’s drums and rising army cry to Puladvand at the head of the force. His bodily strength and arm-borne kamand have direct support; the surrounding alarm is English’s dramatic coloring. The black earth and violet air return the opening colors in a martial register. Calling them war’s dark sign interprets their ominous effect without claiming an independently specified portent. This compact opening lets visual order and mounting noise establish the scale before individual encounters begin.
5–9Two champions and the elephant image
Moscow IV287:1209 running text; IV287:1209 mount called ژنده پیل ژیان; Rakhsh not explicitly named in this unit | IV287:1210 running text | IV287:1211 running text | IV287:1212 running text | IV288:1213 running text; Mohl III124:1280 running text; mount elephant wording, no explicit Rakhsh name | III124:1281 running text | III124:1282 running text | III124:1283 running text | III125:1284 running text; Ganjoor sh15:5 running poem body | sh15:6 running poem body | sh15:7 running poem body | sh15:8 running poem body | sh15:9 running poem body; Khaleghi III271:2681 running text; III271:2681 mount called ژنده پیل ژیان; Rakhsh not explicitly named in this unit | III271:2682 running text | III271:2683 running text | III271:2684 running text; III271:2684 عمودی main; n11 actual گرزی alternative | III271:2685 running text
Moscow printed p.287 · Moscow printed p.288 · Mohl printed p.124 · Mohl printed p.125 · Khaleghi printed p.271 · Ganjoor sh15:5 · Ganjoor sh15:6 · Ganjoor sh15:7 · Ganjoor sh15:8 · Ganjoor sh15:9
English identifies Rostam’s mount as Rakhsh and treats the source’s fierce elephant as a comparison. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all print the elephant wording here without naming Rakhsh, so the identification is an interpretive resolution, not four-way lexical agreement. The subsequent right-wing assault and fallen Turkish champions are shared. Puladvand’s troubled response turns him from spectator to combatant, and his saddle’s coiled lasso gives the action a concrete starting point. English delays Tus’s name until the seizure, whereas the source engagement already names him. Its gorz agrees with Mohl, Moscow and Ganjoor and an actual Khaleghi alternative to that edition’s main club wording. The girdle throw is explicit; landing at Puladvand’s feet adds spatial precision.
10–14Giv enters and is caught
Moscow IV288:1214 running text | IV288:1215 running text | IV288:1216 running text; IV288:1216 cow-headed mace main; n2 actual brave-man mace alternative | IV288:1217 running text | IV288:1218 running text; Mohl III125:1285 running text | III125:1286 running text | III125:1287 running text; brave-man mace without cow-head specification | III125:1288 running text | III125:1289 running text; Ganjoor sh15:10 running poem body | sh15:11 running poem body | sh15:12 running poem body | sh15:13 running poem body | sh15:14 running poem body; Khaleghi III271:2686 running text | III271:2687 running text | III271:2688 running text; III271:2688 cow-headed mace main; n14 notes witness omission, not missing running text | III271:2689 running text | III271:2690 running text; III271:2690 گرز main; n18 actual برز/بالا alternatives support height wording
Moscow printed p.288 · Mohl printed p.125 · Khaleghi printed p.271 · Ganjoor sh15:10 · Ganjoor sh15:11 · Ganjoor sh15:12 · Ganjoor sh15:13 · Ganjoor sh15:14
The four sources make Giv’s intervention a response to seeing Tus overturned, retaining Tus’s paternal identification and the name Shabdiz for Giv’s horse. English’s commitment of body and soul follows the source’s preparation for combat and gives his action deliberate resolve. The lion comparison belongs to Giv as he engages the opponent called a Div. English retains armor and a gorz without specifying the cow head found in Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi’s main texts; Mohl and an actual Moscow alternative give a less specific mace description. The lasso catching Giv’s head is shared. Rohham and Bijan then assess the adversary: English’s towering form has primary support and actual Khaleghi height alternatives, while Khaleghi’s main wording mentions his mace.
15–19The attempted rescue and the broken standard
Moscow IV288:1219 running text; IV288:1219 attempt to bind; wary awareness is first hemistich1220, redistributed into English15 | IV288:1220 running text; IV288:1220 hand action,horse and cry; awareness shared with English15 | IV288:1221 running text | IV288:1222 running text; IV288:1222 trampling main; n10 actual killing alternative, not adopted as death verification | IV288:1223 running text; Mohl III125:1290 running text; awareness in next verse1291 redistributed into English15 | III125:1291 running text; awareness,hand,horse and cry redistributed across English15–16 | III125:1292 running text | III125:1293 running text | III125:1294 running text; Ganjoor sh15:15 running poem body | sh15:16 running poem body | sh15:17 running poem body | sh15:18 running poem body | sh15:19 running poem body; Khaleghi III271:2691 running text; III271:2691 attempt to bind; awareness in III272:2692 redistributed into English15 | III272:2692 running text; III272:2692 hand,horse and cry; awareness shared with English15 | III272:2693 running text | III272:2694 running text; III272:2694 گشتند خوار main; n4 actual بسپرد alternative supports trampling, no death inferred | III272:2695 running text
Moscow printed p.288 · Mohl printed p.125 · Khaleghi printed p.271 · Khaleghi printed p.272 · Ganjoor sh15:15 · Ganjoor sh15:16 · Ganjoor sh15:17 · Ganjoor sh15:18 · Ganjoor sh15:19
English redistributes Puladvand’s awareness across the transition between the rescue attempt and his response. The four sources first describe the two warriors approaching to bind his hands, then give his alert hand action, horse and cry. English’s quick eye develops that awareness rather than adding another encounter. The victims remain the same two noble champions throughout. Throwing them down and trampling them follows Mohl, Moscow and Ganjoor, with an actual Khaleghi alternative to its humbled wording. This violence should not automatically become a verified death report. The attack on the Kavian standard then enlarges the humiliation from individual bodies to the army’s emblem. English’s standard of Kaveh interprets the source epithet; the dagger and division into two are explicit.
20–25The army calls for its deliverer
Moscow IV288:1224 running text | IV288:1225 running text; IV288:1225 نشان گرفتن main; n13 actual seeing alternative matches English | IV288:1226 running text | IV288:1227 running text | IV288:1228 running text | IV288:1229 running text; Mohl III125:1295 running text | III125:1296 running text | III125:1297 running text | III125:1298 running text | III125:1299 running text | III125:1300 running text; Ganjoor sh15:20 running poem body | sh15:21 running poem body | sh15:22 running poem body | sh15:23 running poem body | sh15:24 running poem body | sh15:25 running poem body; Khaleghi III272:2696 running text | III272:2697 running text; III272:2697 چودیدند main supports seeing | III272:2698 running text | III272:2699 running text | III272:2700 running text | III272:2701 running text
Moscow printed p.288 · Mohl printed p.125 · Khaleghi printed p.272 · Ganjoor sh15:20 · Ganjoor sh15:21 · Ganjoor sh15:22 · Ganjoor sh15:23 · Ganjoor sh15:24 · Ganjoor sh15:25
The empty field and Iranian outcry make the defeat collective. English names spear, sword and shield to amplify the statement that no champion remains in the combat ground; the source does not list those weapons in that particular verse. Mohl and Khaleghi describe the chiefs seeing the opponent, while Moscow’s actual alternative supports that wording beside its main formulation of taking a sign, also retained by Ganjoor. English adds fear and strength as the significance of their observation. Their report to Rostam keeps the sweeping claim that no mounted chief has escaped unseating and preserves the subsequent weapon list. Those universals belong to urgent battlefield speech. Rendering Rostam as the needed responder makes the source’s designation of him as deliverer an explicit summons.
26–28Gudarz fears the loss of his family
Moscow IV289:1230 running text | IV289 n4 actually printed addition:Gudarz believes loss,Rohham and Bijan named; Giv not separately named in this addition; IV289 n4 actual belief addition, not narrator confirmation of deaths | IV289:1231 running text; IV289:1231 two sons main; grandson not named in this unit; Mohl III125:1301 running text | III125:1302 running text; Gudarz belief; Rohham,Bijan,Giv individually named | III125:1303 running text; هر سه پسر all three sons; English resolves two sons and grandson; Ganjoor sh15:26 running poem body | sh15:26–27 checked local gap for separate unit | sh15:27 running poem body; Khaleghi III272:2702 running text | III272:2702–2703 checked local gap for separate Gudarz-belief verse; inspected n18–20 does not print it | III272:2703 running text; III272:2703 two sons main; no separately named grandson in this unit
Moscow printed p.289 · Mohl printed p.125 · Khaleghi printed p.272 · Ganjoor sh15:26 · Ganjoor sh15:27
English explicitly frames the loss as Gudarz’s fearful belief. Mohl supplies a separate verse naming Rohham, Bijan and Giv; Moscow actually prints a related belief verse naming Rohham and Bijan, while Ganjoor and the checked Khaleghi locus lack that separate unit. The following count differs: Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi name two sons, whereas Mohl speaks of all three as sons. English resolves the relationship as two sons and a grandson, rather than reproducing Mohl’s kinship label literally. Its lost retains the father’s experience of disaster without independently declaring these three men dead. That distinction matters because the earlier action establishes defeat and unseating. The prayer to the just Judge therefore arises from perception under pressure, not a new omniscient casualty report.
29–33Pride turns into the gestures of mourning
Moscow IV289:1232 running text | IV289:1233 running text | IV289:1234 running text; IV289:1234 living old man main; youth death implication supplied by lament context | IV289 n10 actually printed addition:young men and darkened happy fortune | IV289:1235 running text; Mohl III125:1304 running text | III125:1305 running text | III125:1306 running text; جوانان و من مانده با پیر سر, living old survivor | III125:1307 running text | III125:1308 running text; Ganjoor sh15:28 running poem body | sh15:29 running poem body | sh15:30 running poem body | sh15:30–31 checked local gap for separate unit | sh15:31 running poem body; Khaleghi III272:2704 running text | III272:2705 running text; III272:2705 برگشته main versus English grief/pain and Moscow/Mohl/Ganjoor گشته wording | III272:2706 running text; III272:2706 جوانان من کشته main explicit young-men deaths in Gudarz speech; n25 actual مانده/زنده alternatives | III272:2706–2707 checked local gap for separate young-men/happy-fortune lament; n25 prints cap/belt verse only | III272 n25 actually printed addition:cap/belt removal and lament
Moscow printed p.289 · Mohl printed p.125 · Khaleghi printed p.272 · Ganjoor sh15:28 · Ganjoor sh15:29 · Ganjoor sh15:30 · Ganjoor sh15:31
Gudarz’s former abundance of sons and grandsons becomes the measure of his present shame. The four sources preserve his sun-surpassing pride, remembered killings before his eyes and contrast between youth and the surviving old man. Khaleghi explicitly calls the young men slain in its main text; the others let the preceding lament supply that connection. English makes it explicit while keeping the words within Gudarz’s speech. The additional lament over young men and darkened smiling fortune runs in Mohl and is actually printed in Moscow’s apparatus, with checked local gaps in Ganjoor and Khaleghi. Removing cap and belt then gives grief visible form. That closing action is running text in the first three sources and an actual Khaleghi addition, not an unprinted notice.
Source record and limits
Inspected 12 November 2026. B14.23 only:33 English couplets;66 exact published lines;7 substantive notes. Moscow IV287–289:1205–1235 (31 running units); Mohl III124–125:1276–1308 (33 running units; PDF130–131); Ganjoor khaghan sh15:1–31 (31 running units); Khaleghi III271–272:2677–2706 (30 running units; PDF287–288), plus actual272 n25 closing addition. Every English couplet individually checked in Moscow and Mohl first, then Ganjoor and Khaleghi. Awareness from Moscow1220/Mohl1291/Khaleghi2692/Ganjoor16 is redistributed across English15–16. No source-only running unit in declared scope. Earlier chapters unchanged.
Edition scope and inspected pages
- Published English B14.23
- Moscow: printed 287 / PDF 287, printed 288 / PDF 288, printed 289 / PDF 289
- Mohl: printed 124 / PDF 130, printed 125 / PDF 131
- Khaleghi: printed 271 / PDF 287, printed 272 / PDF 288
- Ganjoor sh15:1–31; retained text
Evidence distinctions and retained limits
Actually printed Moscow additions:289 n4 belief verse,289 n10 youth/fortune lament. Actually printed Khaleghi addition:272 n25 cap/belt removal and crying. Actual alternatives used: Moscow288 n2,n13; Khaleghi271 n11,n18 and272 n4,n25. Khaleghi272:2702–2703 checked gap for separate belief verse;2706–2707 checked gap for extra youth/fortune lament; n25 prints only closing cap/belt verse. No appendix evidence invoked or exhaustive appendix search claimed. Unprinted notices and source availability are not verification. Ganjoor body1–31 retained from successful 12 November retrieval of sh15 in the preceding turn; fresh retrieval attempts returned404. Retained inspected text, not the error response, supplies the comparison.
B14.23:5 elephant-named mount interpreted as Rakhsh, name not explicit in checked unit;8 club/gorz and delayed Tus naming;12 cow-headed versus less specific mace;14 height versus Khaleghi main mace;15–16 redistributed awareness;18 trampling versus humbled wording and no inferred death certification;19 Kaveh interpretation of Kavian;20 supplied weapons;21 seeing versus taking sign and supplied fear;22 contextual Zal parentage;23–25 universal report kept as speech;27 Mohl names three, Moscow actual addition names two, Khaleghi/Ganjoor local gaps;28 two sons versus Mohl all three sons, English two sons/grandson resolution;30–31 old losses remain Gudarz speech;32 actual addition versus checked gaps;33 Khaleghi actual apparatus status. Ganjoor fresh404 and retained prior successful text recorded.
Selected inspected readings
- Moscow IV287:1209 mount wording: نشست از بر ژنده پیل ژیان
- Mohl III124:1280 mount wording: نشست از بر ژنده پیل ژیان
- Mohl III125:1287 less specific mace: زره دار با گرز مرد دلیر
- Khaleghi III271:2688 cow-headed mace: زره دار با گرزه گاوسر
- Mohl III125:1303 kinship count: که کم شد ز پولاد هر سه پسر
- Moscow IV289:1231 kinship count: چو کم شد ز گودرز هر دو پسر
- Khaleghi III272:2703 kinship count: چو کم شد ز گودرز هر دو پسر
- Khaleghi III272 n25 actual mourning addition: کمر برگشاد و کله برگرفت
Persian display uses labelled Ganjoor units or bounded Mohl transcriptions at Ganjoor gaps, with spacing normalized. No composite edition is constructed. All declared running units accounted; no source-only row required. Apparatus outside cited readings is not exhaustively collated.
B14.23 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV287:1205 running text | III124:1276 running text |
| 2 | IV287:1206 running text | III124:1277 running text |
| 3 | IV287:1207 running text | III124:1278 running text |
| 4 | IV287:1208 running text | III124:1279 running text |
| 5 | IV287:1209 running text; IV287:1209 mount called ژنده پیل ژیان; Rakhsh not explicitly named in this unit | III124:1280 running text; mount elephant wording, no explicit Rakhsh name |
| 6 | IV287:1210 running text | III124:1281 running text |
| 7 | IV287:1211 running text | III124:1282 running text |
| 8 | IV287:1212 running text | III124:1283 running text |
| 9 | IV288:1213 running text | III125:1284 running text |
| 10 | IV288:1214 running text | III125:1285 running text |
| 11 | IV288:1215 running text | III125:1286 running text |
| 12 | IV288:1216 running text; IV288:1216 cow-headed mace main; n2 actual brave-man mace alternative | III125:1287 running text; brave-man mace without cow-head specification |
| 13 | IV288:1217 running text | III125:1288 running text |
| 14 | IV288:1218 running text | III125:1289 running text |
| 15 | IV288:1219 running text; IV288:1219 attempt to bind; wary awareness is first hemistich1220, redistributed into English15 | III125:1290 running text; awareness in next verse1291 redistributed into English15 |
| 16 | IV288:1220 running text; IV288:1220 hand action,horse and cry; awareness shared with English15 | III125:1291 running text; awareness,hand,horse and cry redistributed across English15–16 |
| 17 | IV288:1221 running text | III125:1292 running text |
| 18 | IV288:1222 running text; IV288:1222 trampling main; n10 actual killing alternative, not adopted as death verification | III125:1293 running text |
| 19 | IV288:1223 running text | III125:1294 running text |
| 20 | IV288:1224 running text | III125:1295 running text |
| 21 | IV288:1225 running text; IV288:1225 نشان گرفتن main; n13 actual seeing alternative matches English | III125:1296 running text |
| 22 | IV288:1226 running text | III125:1297 running text |
| 23 | IV288:1227 running text | III125:1298 running text |
| 24 | IV288:1228 running text | III125:1299 running text |
| 25 | IV288:1229 running text | III125:1300 running text |
| 26 | IV289:1230 running text | III125:1301 running text |
| 27 | IV289 n4 actually printed addition:Gudarz believes loss,Rohham and Bijan named; Giv not separately named in this addition; IV289 n4 actual belief addition, not narrator confirmation of deaths | III125:1302 running text; Gudarz belief; Rohham,Bijan,Giv individually named |
| 28 | IV289:1231 running text; IV289:1231 two sons main; grandson not named in this unit | III125:1303 running text; هر سه پسر all three sons; English resolves two sons and grandson |
| 29 | IV289:1232 running text | III125:1304 running text |
| 30 | IV289:1233 running text | III125:1305 running text |
| 31 | IV289:1234 running text; IV289:1234 living old man main; youth death implication supplied by lament context | III125:1306 running text; جوانان و من مانده با پیر سر, living old survivor |
| 32 | IV289 n10 actually printed addition:young men and darkened happy fortune | III125:1307 running text |
| 33 | IV289:1235 running text | III125:1308 running text |
New Naqqali