Piran Consults Houman and the Khan
B14.4:41 couplets;82 unchanged lines.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | B14.4:41 couplets;82 unchanged lines. |
| Moscow | IV217–219:139–177;39 running units plus individually labelled actual apparatus. |
| Mohl | III77–78:146–185;40 running units; PDF83–84. |
| Ganjoor | Khaghan sh3:63–101;39 units; summons local gap. |
| Khaleghi | III203–205:1614–1653;40 running units including bracketed1640; PDF219–221. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5Recognition replaces disguise
Moscow IV217:139 running text | IV217:140 running text | IV217:141 running text | IV217:142 running text; IV217 n16 actual Iblis alternative | IV217:143 running text; Mohl III77:146 running text | III77:147 running text | III77:148 running text | III77:149 running text | III77:150 running text; Ganjoor sh3:63 running poem body | sh3:64 running poem body | sh3:65 running poem body | sh3:66 running poem body | sh3:67 running poem body; Khaleghi III203:1614 running text | III203:1615 running text | III203:1616 running text | III203:1617 running text | III203:1618 running text
Moscow printed p.217 · Mohl printed p.77 · Khaleghi printed p.203 · Ganjoor sh3:63 · Ganjoor sh3:64 · Ganjoor sh3:65 · Ganjoor sh3:66 · Ganjoor sh3:67
Houman’s loss of color and hurried return are shared by Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. English makes dread and anxiety explicit, giving the physical symptoms an immediate psychological explanation. His conclusion that the warrior is Rostam likewise remains character testimony, although its confidence prepares Piran’s alarm. No hope intensifies the source’s report that the hard business has gone badly. The comparison involving Iblis needs discrimination: Mohl and Khaleghi print him in the running verse, and Moscow records him as an actual alternative; Moscow and Ganjoor main text retain the land and sea predators without that name. English therefore follows an attested fuller reading while its report of every wrong slightly strengthens the scope of Houman’s recollection.
6–10The names and the relocated sword-fire claim
Moscow IV217:144 running text | IV217:145 running text; IV217 n22 actual ruined/thriving lands alternative | IV217:146 running text | IV218:151 running text; IV217 n23 actual earlier sword-fire addition | IV218:147 running text; Mohl III77:151 running text | III77:152 running text | III77:153 running text | III77:154 running text | III77:155 running text; Ganjoor sh3:68 running poem body | sh3:69 running poem body | sh3:70 running poem body | sh3:75 running poem body | sh3:71 running poem body; Khaleghi III203:1619 running text | III203:1620 running text | III203:1621 running text | III204:1626 running text | III203:1622 running text
Moscow printed p.217 · Moscow printed p.218 · Mohl printed p.77 · Khaleghi printed p.203 · Khaleghi printed p.204 · Ganjoor sh3:68 · Ganjoor sh3:69 · Ganjoor sh3:70 · Ganjoor sh3:75 · Ganjoor sh3:71
Houman’s report that Rostam named him first gives the disguise a disturbing retrospective uncertainty in all four sources. It does not establish that every version of the previous conversation openly exposed him. The next recollection differs: Mohl and Khaleghi mention ruined and flourishing lands, desire and justice, whereas Moscow and Ganjoor name Piran and the Viseh family; Moscow actually records the former wording as a variant. English follows that former branch but turns bloody injury into a more graphic report. Its sword-fire claim comes immediately after the injuries, as in Mohl. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi main text put it after the equipment description. The early placement makes the image corroborate the threatening report before Houman singles out Piran for affection.
11–15Mountain, armor and the elephant beneath
Moscow IV218:148 running text | IV218:149 running text | IV218:150 running text | IV218:150 running text; shared equipment unit, no separate Rakhsh naming in checked IV218:150–151 | IV218:153 running text; Mohl III77:156 running text | III77:157 running text | III77:158 running text | III77:158 running text; shared equipment unit; no separate Rakhsh naming in checked III77:158–159 | III77:159 running text; Ganjoor sh3:72 running poem body | sh3:73 running poem body | sh3:74 running poem body | sh3:77 running poem body; Khaleghi III203:1623 running text | III203:1624 running text | III204:1625 running text | III204:1625 running text; rider in saddle, no separate Rakhsh naming in checked III204:1625–1626 | III204:1628 running text
Moscow printed p.218 · Mohl printed p.77 · Khaleghi printed p.203 · Khaleghi printed p.204 · Ganjoor sh3:72 · Ganjoor sh3:73 · Ganjoor sh3:74 · Ganjoor sh3:77
The summons and mountain comparison are shared across the four sources. English expands the towering figure into one hill upon another. Its equipment list follows the helmet reading in Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor; Khaleghi instead has a mace. The next English couplet develops the same Persian unit rather than translating a separately verified Rakhsh verse. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor describe a fierce elephant underneath, allowing a comparison with the mount; English identifies that mount as Rakhsh. Khaleghi places the elephant in the saddle, pointing to the rider. This change of referent matters more than the common elephant image. The counsel to speak gently and keep the sword sheathed then makes bodily intimidation yield to diplomatic restraint.
16–20Waiting, mourning and the evil star
Moscow IV218:152 running text | IV218:154 running text | IV218:155 running text | IV218:156 running text | IV218:157 running text; Mohl III77:160 running text | III77:161 running text | III77:162 running text | III77:163 running text | III77:164 running text; Ganjoor sh3:76 running poem body | sh3:78 running poem body | sh3:79 running poem body | sh3:80 running poem body | sh3:81 running poem body; Khaleghi III204:1627 running text | III204:1629 running text | III204:1630 running text | III204:1631 running text | III204:1632 running text
Moscow printed p.218 · Mohl printed p.77 · Khaleghi printed p.204 · Ganjoor sh3:76 · Ganjoor sh3:78 · Ganjoor sh3:79 · Ganjoor sh3:80 · Ganjoor sh3:81
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi say the warrior will not move until he sees Piran. English interprets seeing as speaking together, making the expected meeting explicitly conversational. Its order follows Mohl, placing the waiting claim after the advice to speak gently; the other three put waiting first. Piran’s conditional identification preserves the remaining uncertainty even after Houman’s confident report. Mourning follows from that identification, while the fire and ill-star image extends danger to the homeland. English turns a question about what the ominous star has done into an assertion that it already rules their fate. Tears and the wounded liver retain the bodily register, but pierced and burning sharpen the expression of distress and wrath.
21–25A suspicion confirmed and a back never seen
Moscow IV218:158 running text | IV218:159 running text | IV218:160 running text | IV218:161 running text; IV218 n32 actual no-back-in-dream alternative | IV219:162 running text; Mohl III77:165 running text | III78:166 running text | III78:167 running text | III78:168 running text | III78:169 running text; Ganjoor sh3:82 running poem body | sh3:83 running poem body | sh3:84 running poem body | sh3:85 running poem body | sh3:86 running poem body; Khaleghi III204:1633 running text | III204:1634 running text | III204:1635 running text | III204:1636 running text | III204:1637 running text
Moscow printed p.218 · Moscow printed p.219 · Mohl printed p.77 · Mohl printed p.78 · Khaleghi printed p.204 · Ganjoor sh3:82 · Ganjoor sh3:83 · Ganjoor sh3:84 · Ganjoor sh3:85 · Ganjoor sh3:86
Piran’s appeal for restraint precedes his recollection of Kamus’s death in all four sources. English adds shame to that death and visible care to the changed situation, stressing humiliation and apprehension. The iron rampart and twisting rawhide lasso then join apparent immovability to a weapon that coils and captures. The claim about Afrasiab is less uniform. Mohl and Khaleghi say that no one would see Rostam’s back even in a dream; Moscow records that wording as an actual alternative, while its main text and Ganjoor speak of fear in dreams. English’s refusal to turn away follows the non-retreat branch. The exhausted Divs and the equal futility of one opponent or a field of men extend the argument beyond ordinary numerical advantage.
26–30The bereaved father and the reluctant embassy
Moscow IV219:163 running text | IV219:164 running text | IV219 n8 actual summons addition | IV219:165 running text | IV219:166 running text; Mohl III78:170 running text | III78:171 running text | III78:172 running text | III78:173 running text | III78:174 running text; Ganjoor sh3:87 running poem body | sh3:88 running poem body | sh3:88–89 checked local gap | sh3:89 running poem body | sh3:90 running poem body; Khaleghi III204:1638 running text | III204:1639 running text | III204:1640 bracketed running text | III204:1641 running text | III205:1642 running text
Moscow printed p.219 · Mohl printed p.78 · Khaleghi printed p.204 · Khaleghi printed p.205 · Ganjoor sh3:87 · Ganjoor sh3:88 · Ganjoor sh3:89 · Ganjoor sh3:90
All four sources connect Rostam’s former standing in Zabul with his nurturing of Siavash and describe his war as fatherlike grief. English strengthens that standing into long rule and reverence, while moving the father comparison into the account of upbringing as well. The result makes the emotional cause of battle especially continuous. Piran’s explicit statement that the elephant-bodied warrior summoned him is running text in Mohl, an actual printed addition in Moscow, and a bracketed running verse in Khaleghi. Ganjoor has a checked local gap between the fatherlike-war passage and the proposed visit. English retains the fuller connective explanation. The wasting of Piran’s spirit motivates the visit, and the Khan answers with permission and a demand for appropriate speech.
31–35Gifts, leopard skin and the order of battle
Moscow IV219:167 running text | IV219:168 running text | IV219:169 running text | IV219:171 running text | IV219:170 running text; Mohl III78:175 running text | III78:176 running text | III78:177 running text | III78:178 running text | III78:179 running text; Ganjoor sh3:91 running poem body | sh3:92 running poem body | sh3:93 running poem body | sh3:95 running poem body | sh3:94 running poem body; Khaleghi III205:1643 running text | III205:1644 running text | III205:1645 running text | III205:1647 running text; III205 n9 actual smiling-battle alternative | III205:1646 running text
Moscow printed p.219 · Mohl printed p.78 · Khaleghi printed p.205 · Ganjoor sh3:91 · Ganjoor sh3:92 · Ganjoor sh3:93 · Ganjoor sh3:95 · Ganjoor sh3:94
The four sources oppose possible peace and resources to continued suffering by the army. English specifies wealth, narrowing the range of the source term. Its promise him fixes the direction of the gifts in a verse whose wording also permits the literal sense accept gifts; that direction should not be advertised as identical across the witnesses. The leopard skin marks a continued readiness for combat. English’s since follows the assertive wording of Mohl and Khaleghi, whereas Moscow and Ganjoor make it conditional. Prayer precedes the attack in English and Mohl; the other main texts reverse those units. Gladly also follows Mohl’s smiling battle, with a corresponding printed Khaleghi alternative. These choices make divine reliance prepare the Khan’s renewed confidence.
36–38Making the formidable body vulnerable
Moscow IV219:172 running text | IV219:173 running text | IV219:174 running text; Mohl III78:180 running text | III78:181 running text | III78:182 running text; Ganjoor sh3:96 running poem body | sh3:97 running poem body | sh3:98 running poem body; Khaleghi III205:1648 running text | III205:1649 running text | III205:1650 running text
Moscow printed p.219 · Mohl printed p.78 · Khaleghi printed p.205 · Ganjoor sh3:96 · Ganjoor sh3:97 · Ganjoor sh3:98
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all answer the image of overwhelming power by insisting on ordinary flesh, blood and hair. Mohl’s negative list also includes fire alongside iron and bronze; English retains the two metals. Its phrase before a blade adds a weapon to the anatomical claim, translating bodily composition directly into vulnerability. The contrast between combat on earth and combat in the air similarly reduces awe to a practical encounter. Reason dying is an additional consequence of fear in English, beyond the Persian concern with painful anxiety. Finally, even a diet of iron and stone cannot defeat arrows and zhupin. Piercing bone supplies a precise bodily endpoint for the shared assertion that weapons will pass through him.
39–41Numerical confidence and elephant-play
Moscow IV219:175 running text | IV219:176 running text | IV219:177 running text; Mohl III78:183 running text | III78:184 running text | III78:185 running text; Ganjoor sh3:99 running poem body | sh3:100 running poem body | sh3:101 running poem body; Khaleghi III205:1651 running text | III205:1652 running text | III205:1653 running text
Moscow printed p.219 · Mohl printed p.78 · Khaleghi printed p.205 · Ganjoor sh3:99 · Ganjoor sh3:100 · Ganjoor sh3:101
All four sources give the Khan a three-hundred-to-one advantage for each opposing man. English preserves that extraordinary ratio as his own boast, not an independent census of the armies. The warning against harmful worry becomes an appeal not to lose strength through brooding. Rostam is then reduced to no more than an elephant in battle, continuing the attempt to turn terrifying imagery into something manageable. English’s but conveys the dismissal even while elephant retains formidable scale. The final elephant-play boast is shared, promising a demonstration after which he will not face battle. English’s never strengthens the duration of that threat. The passage closes on the Khan’s confidence without converting that confidence into the narrator’s guarantee of success.
Source record and limits
Inspected 12 November 2026. B14.4 only:41 English couplets;82 exact published lines;9 notes. Moscow IV217–219:139–177 (39 running units); Mohl III77–78:146–185 (40); Ganjoor khaghan sh3:63–101 (39); Khaleghi III203–205:1614–1653 (40, including bracketed1640). Every declared unit accounted. English13–14 share one source unit; English28 has distinct edition placements. Moscow and Mohl individually inspected first, then Ganjoor and Khaleghi.
Edition scope and inspected pages
- Published English B14.4
- Moscow: printed 217 / PDF 217, printed 218 / PDF 218, printed 219 / PDF 219
- Mohl: printed 77 / PDF 83, printed 78 / PDF 84
- Khaleghi: printed 203 / PDF 219, printed 204 / PDF 220, printed 205 / PDF 221
- Ganjoor sh3:63–101
Evidence distinctions and retained limits
Actual Moscow apparatus:217 n16 Iblis;217 n22 ruined/flourishing lands;217 n23 earlier sword-fire placement;218 n32 no-back-in-dream;219 n8 explicit summons. Khaleghi1640 is bracketed running text, not apparatus;205 n9 actually records smiling battle. Ganjoor sh3:88–89 checked local gap for summons. No separate Rakhsh-naming verse verified in the checked equipment loci: Moscow218:150–151, Mohl77:158–159, Ganjoor74–75, Khaleghi204:1625–1626. No appendix evidence used or exhaustive appendix search claimed. Unprinted addition notices do not establish verification.
All inherited provisional flags retained. Current qualifications: English4 Iblis variant;7 lands versus family list;9 sword-fire relocation;13 helmet/mace;14 mount versus rider and explicit Rakhsh identification;15–16 reversed order;19 star question becomes assertion;24 fear versus non-retreat dream;26 long rule/reverence amplified;28 actual addition/bracketed verse/local gap;32 gift direction interpretive;33 conditional versus assertive skin;34–35 prayer/attack order and smiling/lion/many battle;36 Mohl fire omitted;38 bone added;41 never intensified. English unchanged.
Selected inspected readings
- Moscow IV217 n16 actual alternative; Mohl III77:149 / Khaleghi III203:1617 main: که ابلیس با او نتابد به جنگ
- Moscow IV218:150 / Ganjoor sh3:74 main, mount underneath: به زیر اندرون ژنده پیلی ژیان
- Khaleghi III204:1625 main, rider in saddle: به زین اندرون ژنده پیلی ژیان
- Mohl III78:172 main; Moscow IV219 n8 actual addition; Khaleghi III204:1640 bracketed: مرا جست ازین بیکران انجمن / ندانم چه خواهد ز من پیلتن
- Mohl III78:178 main, prayer and glad battle: همه پشت را سوی یزدان کنیم / به نیروی او رزم خندان کنیم
English13–14 share the equipment unit. Persian display repeats that identified unit for transparency; it does not invent an independent Rakhsh verse. English28 uses an explicitly labelled Mohl reading because Ganjoor has a local gap. No source-only running units remain within the declared ranges. Source availability does not verify a reading.
B14.4 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV217:139 running text | III77:146 running text |
| 2 | IV217:140 running text | III77:147 running text |
| 3 | IV217:141 running text | III77:148 running text |
| 4 | IV217:142 running text; IV217 n16 actual Iblis alternative | III77:149 running text |
| 5 | IV217:143 running text | III77:150 running text |
| 6 | IV217:144 running text | III77:151 running text |
| 7 | IV217:145 running text; IV217 n22 actual ruined/thriving lands alternative | III77:152 running text |
| 8 | IV217:146 running text | III77:153 running text |
| 9 | IV218:151 running text; IV217 n23 actual earlier sword-fire addition | III77:154 running text |
| 10 | IV218:147 running text | III77:155 running text |
| 11 | IV218:148 running text | III77:156 running text |
| 12 | IV218:149 running text | III77:157 running text |
| 13 | IV218:150 running text | III77:158 running text |
| 14 | IV218:150 running text; shared equipment unit, no separate Rakhsh naming in checked IV218:150–151 | III77:158 running text; shared equipment unit; no separate Rakhsh naming in checked III77:158–159 |
| 15 | IV218:153 running text | III77:159 running text |
| 16 | IV218:152 running text | III77:160 running text |
| 17 | IV218:154 running text | III77:161 running text |
| 18 | IV218:155 running text | III77:162 running text |
| 19 | IV218:156 running text | III77:163 running text |
| 20 | IV218:157 running text | III77:164 running text |
| 21 | IV218:158 running text | III77:165 running text |
| 22 | IV218:159 running text | III78:166 running text |
| 23 | IV218:160 running text | III78:167 running text |
| 24 | IV218:161 running text; IV218 n32 actual no-back-in-dream alternative | III78:168 running text |
| 25 | IV219:162 running text | III78:169 running text |
| 26 | IV219:163 running text | III78:170 running text |
| 27 | IV219:164 running text | III78:171 running text |
| 28 | IV219 n8 actual summons addition | III78:172 running text |
| 29 | IV219:165 running text | III78:173 running text |
| 30 | IV219:166 running text | III78:174 running text |
| 31 | IV219:167 running text | III78:175 running text |
| 32 | IV219:168 running text | III78:176 running text |
| 33 | IV219:169 running text | III78:177 running text |
| 34 | IV219:171 running text | III78:178 running text |
| 35 | IV219:170 running text | III78:179 running text |
| 36 | IV219:172 running text | III78:180 running text |
| 37 | IV219:173 running text | III78:181 running text |
| 38 | IV219:174 running text | III78:182 running text |
| 39 | IV219:175 running text | III78:183 running text |
| 40 | IV219:176 running text | III78:184 running text |
| 41 | IV219:177 running text | III78:185 running text |
New Naqqali