Rostam Exhorts the Troops
B14.7:80 couplets;160 unchanged lines.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | B14.7:80 couplets;160 unchanged lines. |
| Moscow | IV231–236:340–420;81 running units including bracketed376, plus actual apparatus. |
| Mohl | III86–89:365–445;81 running units; PDF92–95. |
| Ganjoor | Khaghan sh4:163–243;81 running units; bounded gaps. |
| Khaleghi | III217–221:1829–1910;82 running units; PDF233–237. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5The assembly and the source of legitimate rank
Moscow IV231:340 running text | IV231:341 running text; IV231 n15 alternate general-warriors wording rather than Kharad | IV231:342 running text | IV231:343 running text | IV231:344 running text; IV231 n18 actual wealth/throne alternative; Mohl III86:365 running text | III86:366 running text | III86:367 running text | III86:368 running text | III86:369 running text; Ganjoor sh4:163 running poem body | sh4:164 running poem body | sh4:165 running poem body | sh4:166 running poem body | sh4:167 running poem body; Khaleghi III217:1829 running text | III217:1830 running text; III217 n3 alternate general-warriors wording rather than Kharad | III217:1831 running text | III217:1832 running text | III217:1833 running text
Moscow printed p.231 · Mohl printed p.86 · Khaleghi printed p.217 · Ganjoor sh4:163 · Ganjoor sh4:164 · Ganjoor sh4:165 · Ganjoor sh4:166 · Ganjoor sh4:167
Rostam’s summons and the necessary words he speaks are shared by Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. English’s reference to the hour makes their necessity immediate. The list of chiefs differs at its close: Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi name Kharad, whereas Mohl ends with a general description of warriors. Moscow and Khaleghi also record that general wording. English follows the named subset without Kharad, while expanding Bijan’s battlefield epithet into brightness, bravery and strength. The address to wise and wakeful mobads remains, with an explicit instruction to listen. Divine favor then authorizes rank. English’s wealth and throne follow Mohl and a Moscow alternative; the other main texts have crown and throne, emphasizing royal insignia rather than possessions.
6–10Power restrained by mortality and upright conduct
Moscow IV231:345 running text; IV231 n20 actual not oppressing by strength alternative | IV231:346 running text | IV231:347 running text | IV232:348 running text | IV232:349 running text; Mohl III86:370 running text | III86:371 running text | III86:372 running text | III86:373 running text | III86:374 running text; Ganjoor sh4:168 running poem body | sh4:169 running poem body | sh4:170 running poem body | sh4:171 running poem body | sh4:172 running poem body; Khaleghi III217:1834 running text; III217 n7 actual unjust-claw alternatives | III217:1835 running text | III217:1836 running text | III217:1837 running text | III217:1838 running text
Moscow printed p.231 · Moscow printed p.232 · Mohl printed p.86 · Khaleghi printed p.217 · Ganjoor sh4:168 · Ganjoor sh4:169 · Ganjoor sh4:170 · Ganjoor sh4:171 · Ganjoor sh4:172
The claim of worldwide victory does not license arbitrary force. Mohl and Khaleghi forbid unjust use of the claw, while Moscow and Ganjoor frame the line around seeing one’s own strength; Moscow’s apparatus and Khaleghi’s alternatives preserve more explicit anti-oppression wording. English’s trampling what is right interprets the unjust claw in ethical terms. All four then attribute strength to God and question what humans are upon dark earth. English changes that question into why we tread there until death, adding purpose and mortality. Transience, limited delight, humaneness and uprightness remain shared. The swift harm of knavery adds speed to the source’s loss and diminution. Rostam’s authority is therefore grounded in restraint before he turns to the particular enemy.
11–15Piran’s services and the foreseen deaths
Moscow IV232:350 running text | IV232:351 running text | IV232:352 running text | IV232:353 running text | IV232:354 running text; Mohl III86:375 running text | III86:376 running text | III86:377 running text | III86:378 running text | III86:379 running text; Ganjoor sh4:173 running poem body | sh4:174 running poem body | sh4:175 running poem body | sh4:176 running poem body | sh4:177 running poem body; Khaleghi III217:1839 running text | III217:1840 running text | III217:1841 running text; III217 n24 actual words-and-deeds alternative | III217:1842 running text | III217:1843 running text
Moscow printed p.232 · Mohl printed p.86 · Khaleghi printed p.217 · Ganjoor sh4:173 · Ganjoor sh4:174 · Ganjoor sh4:175 · Ganjoor sh4:176 · Ganjoor sh4:177
Piran’s wounded-hearted arrival and account of kindness to Siavash are shared by all four sources. English names Siavash in advance, then uses a passive construction that centers him as beneficiary. The rescue of Farangis and Kay Khosrow is attributed to Piran’s words and deeds in Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor. Khaleghi’s main text names his words, recording words and deeds as an alternative. English adds the Dragon’s breath, making the danger more vividly bodily than the source’s dragon alone. Rostam nevertheless foresees Piran’s death in vengeance and the deaths of close relatives before him. English’s among the first softens the source’s first, and wise adds approval. The passage holds gratitude and anticipated destruction together without resolving their contradiction.
16–20Foreknowledge does not remove personal restraint
Moscow IV232:355 running text | IV232:356 running text | IV232:357 running text | IV232:358 running text | IV232:359 running text; Mohl III86:380 running text | III86:381 running text | III86:382 running text | III87:383 running text | III87:384 running text; Ganjoor sh4:178 running poem body | sh4:179 running poem body | sh4:180 running poem body | sh4:181 running poem body | sh4:182 running poem body; Khaleghi III217:1844 running text | III217:1845 running text | III217:1846 running text | III218:1847 running text | III218:1848 running text
Moscow printed p.232 · Mohl printed p.86 · Mohl printed p.87 · Khaleghi printed p.217 · Khaleghi printed p.218 · Ganjoor sh4:178 · Ganjoor sh4:179 · Ganjoor sh4:180 · Ganjoor sh4:181 · Ganjoor sh4:182
Rostam’s dream of Afrasiab slain by Kay Khosrow is shared by Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. English repeats his witnessing, strengthening the speaker’s conviction. The following prediction explicitly singles out the guilty in Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor; Khaleghi’s main formulation says that no one remains without repeating that category. English retains guilt and adds war’s burning heat to the image of bodies underfoot. Yet Rostam refuses to be the killer of the old man and his assembly. English’s chief and array make that gathering more military. Piran’s truthful vocation and lack of evil thought then justify conditional amnesty. English’s stored-away wrongs interprets hiding past guilt as setting it aside, preserving the condition that Piran must fulfill his words.
21–25Tribute and the concrete conditions of peace
Moscow IV232:360 running text | IV232:361 running text | IV232:362 running text | IV232 n33 actual tribute/withdrawal addition; n37 actual tribute/power addition at later locus | IV232:363 running text; Mohl III87:385 running text | III87:386 running text | III87:387 running text | III87:388 running text | III87:389 running text; Ganjoor sh4:183 running poem body | sh4:184 running poem body | sh4:185 running poem body | sh4:185–186 checked local gap | sh4:186 running poem body; Khaleghi III218:1849 running text | III218:1850 running text | III218:1851 running text | III218:1853 running text | III218:1852 running text
Moscow printed p.232 · Mohl printed p.87 · Khaleghi printed p.218 · Ganjoor sh4:183 · Ganjoor sh4:184 · Ganjoor sh4:185 · Ganjoor sh4:186
All four sources connect surrender of the guilty and property with ending vengeance. English’s what is due adds the language of entitlement, while the preference for honesty remains shared. The allied rulers’ thrones, elephants and Nile-like army introduce a second condition. Mohl prints the tribute verse before the sending of throne and treasure; Khaleghi places tribute after the corresponding gift verse. Moscow actually prints tribute alternatives in its apparatus, and Ganjoor has a checked local gap for that separate unit. English follows Mohl’s sequence and makes submission explicit through bowing. Its throne and treasure likewise follow Mohl, where the other main gift lines have crown and treasure. Peace is imagined through transfers of authority and possessions, not through an unqualified cessation.
26–30Good giving, abundance and the answering praise
Moscow IV233:364 running text | IV233:365 running text | IV233:366 running text | IV233:367 running text | IV233:368 running text; Mohl III87:390 running text | III87:391 running text | III87:392 running text | III87:393 running text | III87:394 running text; Ganjoor sh4:187 running poem body | sh4:188 running poem body | sh4:189 running poem body | sh4:190 running poem body | sh4:191 running poem body; Khaleghi III218:1854 running text | III218:1855 running text; III218 n24 inspected apparatus; identical affirmative Mohl wording not verified; main negation retained | III218:1856 running text | III218:1857 running text | III218:1858 running text
Moscow printed p.233 · Mohl printed p.87 · Khaleghi printed p.218 · Ganjoor sh4:187 · Ganjoor sh4:188 · Ganjoor sh4:189 · Ganjoor sh4:190 · Ganjoor sh4:191
The refusal to maintain the world by killing is shared by Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. Mohl follows it with a better policy; the other main texts describe another way associated with good giving. English’s better path follows Mohl’s practical formulation. The abundance verse then divides more sharply. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi say that everything should not belong to one fortunate person. Mohl has an affirmative formulation of the fortunate share. The inspected Khaleghi apparatus does not verify that identical affirmative wording. English’s blessing on winning all in high renown adds acquisition and glory, rather than preserving the distributive warning of the negative main texts. Gudarz’s response turns to praise, and English’s bread makes the shared nourishment of the soul by wisdom unusually concrete.
31–35An opaque proverb introduces a distrustful argument
Moscow IV233:369 running text | IV233:370 running text | IV233:371 running text; IV233 n16 actual neck/stone alternative; main cart/heavy load | IV233:372 running text | IV233:373 running text; Mohl III87:395 running text | III87:396 running text | III87:397 running text | III87:398 running text | III87:399 running text; Ganjoor sh4:192 running poem body | sh4:193 running poem body | sh4:194 running poem body | sh4:195 running poem body | sh4:196 running poem body; Khaleghi III218:1859 running text | III218:1860 running text | III218:1861 running text; III218 n30–31 cart/neck and stone/load alternatives individually inspected | III218:1862 running text | III219:1863 running text
Moscow printed p.233 · Mohl printed p.87 · Khaleghi printed p.218 · Khaleghi printed p.219 · Ganjoor sh4:192 · Ganjoor sh4:193 · Ganjoor sh4:194 · Ganjoor sh4:195 · Ganjoor sh4:196
All four sources concede that peace is better than war and retain the ox still in its hide. English preserves the proverb’s concrete strangeness. In this context it qualifies premature confidence, but the commentary should not turn that contextual reading into an asserted fixed historical gloss. The announced ancient saying then compares the wicked soul’s recoil from truth with material resistance. Mohl has neck and heavy load, Moscow and Ganjoor cart and heavy load, and Khaleghi neck and heavy stone, with alternatives recorded. English follows Mohl’s combination and interprets truth as peace. The forced covenant and attempted breach are shared. Naming Piran makes the application explicit, while double heart translates moral crookedness into divided intention rather than literal anatomy.
36–40The recalled parley and its compressed promises
Moscow IV233:374 running text | IV233:375 running text | IV233:377 running text | IV234:378 running text | IV234:379 running text | IV234:380 running text; Mohl III87:400 running text | III87:401 running text | III87:402 running text | III87:403 running text | III87:404 running text; Ganjoor sh4:197 running poem body | sh4:198 running poem body | sh4:200 running poem body | sh4:201 running poem body | sh4:202 running poem body | sh4:203 running poem body; Khaleghi III219:1864 running text | III219:1865 running text | III219:1866 running text | III219:1867 running text | III219:1868 running text | III219:1869 running text
Moscow printed p.233 · Moscow printed p.234 · Mohl printed p.87 · Khaleghi printed p.219 · Ganjoor sh4:197 · Ganjoor sh4:198 · Ganjoor sh4:200 · Ganjoor sh4:201 · Ganjoor sh4:202 · Ganjoor sh4:203
The first deployment, exchange of words and envoy’s rejection of conflict are shared by all four sources. English adds that the parley kept war at bay, stating a purpose rather than merely recording discussion. Piran’s pledge of service and refusal of land or tents remain. Moscow also brackets a separate complaint about Afrasiab that Ganjoor prints; it is retained as a source-only row because English gives no independent counterpart. The next English couplet compresses hearing counsel and announcing a report to the kin. Mohl combines those actions in one verse, whereas Moscow and Khaleghi use two, including an explicit promise of no further fighting. English leaves that additional vow implicit. Its guarantee that the kin will lack no good expands the source’s provision of a suitable place.
41–45Who proposes withdrawal, and to which country
Moscow IV234:382 running text | IV234:381 running text; IV234 n5 actual Iran-placement alternative | IV234:383 running text | IV234:384 running text | IV234:385 running text; Mohl III87:405 running text | III87:406 running text | III87:407 running text | III88:408 running text | III88:409 running text; Ganjoor sh4:205 running poem body | sh4:204 running poem body | sh4:206 running poem body | sh4:207 running poem body | sh4:208 running poem body; Khaleghi III219:1871 running text | III219:1870 running text; III219 n11 actual Iran alternative; main Turan | III219:1872 running text | III219:1873 running text | III219:1874 running text
Moscow printed p.234 · Mohl printed p.87 · Mohl printed p.88 · Khaleghi printed p.219 · Ganjoor sh4:205 · Ganjoor sh4:204 · Ganjoor sh4:206 · Ganjoor sh4:207 · Ganjoor sh4:208
The quiet corner and avoidance of exposed guilt occur in all four sources, but their place in the dialogue changes their force. Mohl puts the corner proposal before Gudarz’s reply, allowing English to assign it to Piran. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi put it after the reply, where it continues the interlocutor’s advice. The destination also differs: English and Mohl offer support in Iran, while the three other main texts name Turan. Moscow and Khaleghi record Iran alternatives. These are substantive choices of speaker and political location, not merely reordered lines. Piran’s subsequent departure and association with the Div are shared. English’s till day extends the night, and its empty air dissolving the parley supplies a new metaphor for the apparent cancellation of the promises.
46–50The renewed deployment becomes evidence of deceit
Moscow IV234 n16 actual tenth-day deployment addition | IV234:386 running text | IV234:387 running text | IV234:388 running text | IV234:389 running text; IV234:389 Sagsar and Fartus main; Manshur not verified in this local Moscow main/apparatus; Mohl III88:410 running text | III88:411 running text | III88:412 running text | III88:413 running text | III88:414 running text; Ganjoor sh4:208–209 checked local gap | sh4:209 running poem body | sh4:210 running poem body | sh4:211 running poem body | sh4:212 running poem body; Khaleghi III219:1875 running text | III219:1876 running text | III219:1877 running text | III219:1878 running text | III219:1879 running text
Moscow printed p.234 · Mohl printed p.88 · Khaleghi printed p.219 · Ganjoor sh4:208 · Ganjoor sh4:209 · Ganjoor sh4:210 · Ganjoor sh4:211 · Ganjoor sh4:212
The tenth-day return of the army is running text in Mohl and Khaleghi and an actual printed addition in Moscow. Ganjoor has a checked local gap. English therefore preserves a specific delay that the shorter running sequence does not supply. Gudarz next accuses Piran of another trick, contrasting cunning with scattered words of wisdom across all four sources. English’s trap and apparent wisdom sharpen that accusation. Fear of the kamand is tied to what Piran has seen; English adds recollection as the link between sight and present conduct. The named supports of the allied army differ. Mohl and Khaleghi give Manshur and Fartus, while Moscow and Ganjoor give Sagsar and Fartus. English follows the former list; no corresponding local Moscow Manshur reading was verified.
51–55Fear, peace and a prediction of renewed battle
Moscow IV234:390 running text | IV234:391 running text | IV234:392 running text | IV234:393 running text | IV235:394 running text; IV235 n3 actual Fariborz-and-Tus alternative; Mohl III88:415 running text | III88:416 running text | III88:417 running text | III88:418 running text | III88:419 running text; Ganjoor sh4:213 running poem body | sh4:214 running poem body | sh4:215 running poem body | sh4:216 running poem body | sh4:217 running poem body; Khaleghi III220:1880 running text | III220:1881 running text | III220:1882 running text | III220:1883 running text | III220:1884 running text
Moscow printed p.234 · Moscow printed p.235 · Mohl printed p.88 · Khaleghi printed p.220 · Ganjoor sh4:213 · Ganjoor sh4:214 · Ganjoor sh4:215 · Ganjoor sh4:216 · Ganjoor sh4:217
Kamus’s reversed fortune and death in the kamand are shared by Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. Gudarz reads Piran’s peace request through that sight and his inability to remain on the plain. English’s dares makes fear the explicit explanation of inability. The narrowing descent in the following verse becomes a perceived approaching fall, and deceit becomes a deliberate response to fear. This remains Gudarz’s diagnosis, not an independent narrative verdict. The promised guilty men and treasure are then set against the sound of the war drum. Mohl and Khaleghi name Fariborz with Tus, whereas Moscow and Ganjoor main text name Tus alone; Moscow prints the joint-name alternative. English’s prediction follows that fuller identification without treating it as unanimous main text.
56–60Bahram’s fate turns counsel into personal testimony
Moscow IV235:395 running text | IV235:396 running text | IV235:397 running text | IV235:398 running text; IV235 n5 actual singular him alternative; n8 additional cemetery verse | IV235:398 running text | IV235:399 running text; Mohl III88:420 running text | III88:421 running text | III88:422 running text | III88:423 running text | III88:423 running text | III88:424 running text; Ganjoor sh4:218 running poem body | sh4:219 running poem body | sh4:220 running poem body | sh4:221 running poem body | sh4:221 running poem body | sh4:222 running poem body; Khaleghi III220:1885 running text | III220:1886 running text | III220:1887 running text; III220:1887 affirmative if you hear; negative English branch not verified in inspected local apparatus | III220:1888 running text | III220:1888 running text | III220:1889 running text
Moscow printed p.235 · Mohl printed p.88 · Khaleghi printed p.220 · Ganjoor sh4:218 · Ganjoor sh4:219 · Ganjoor sh4:220 · Ganjoor sh4:221 · Ganjoor sh4:222
The prediction that Piran will lead fresh fighting and the association of his speech with Ahriman are shared by all four sources. English adds a plan and gives Ahriman marching motion, making the accusation militarily active. The appeal to Bahram then differs in polarity. Mohl says if you do not hear, supporting English’s deafness condition; Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi say if you hear. The next object also differs: Mohl’s him refers back to Bahram, while the other main texts name the army; Moscow records the singular alternative. English’s flattery interprets that treatment and carries the Gudarzian cemetery into the next couplet. Personal witness, bloodlike tears and enduring grief transform strategic distrust into the testimony of a bereaved father.
61–65Agreement qualified by a debt of gratitude
Moscow IV235:399 running text | IV235:400 running text | IV235:401 running text | IV235:402 running text | IV235:403 running text | IV235:404 running text; Mohl III88:424 running text | III88:425 running text | III88:426 running text | III88:427 running text | III88:428 running text | III88:429 running text; Ganjoor sh4:222 running poem body | sh4:223 running poem body | sh4:224 running poem body | sh4:225 running poem body | sh4:226 running poem body | sh4:227 running poem body; Khaleghi III220:1889 running text | III220:1890 running text | III220:1891 running text | III220:1892 running text | III220:1893 running text | III220:1894 running text
Moscow printed p.235 · Mohl printed p.88 · Khaleghi printed p.220 · Ganjoor sh4:222 · Ganjoor sh4:223 · Ganjoor sh4:224 · Ganjoor sh4:225 · Ganjoor sh4:226 · Ganjoor sh4:227
English crosses a Persian boundary when the Indian blade as physician shares a couplet with Rostam’s reply. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all preserve both the cure image and the responding appeal to wisdom. English’s words are wisely weighed states approval where the Persian formulation is a wish that speech be joined with wisdom. Rostam accepts that Piran is not of their voice; English adds the brightness of day to make the difference unmistakable. Yet prior good conduct remains a reason to avoid pressing the feud. The assistance to Iran’s king and concern for Siavash are shared, with English identifying the killing as unjust. The conditional possibility of renewed war preserves readiness without allowing Gudarz’s account to erase the earlier obligation.
66–70Good expectation backed by the kamand
Moscow IV235:405 running text | IV235:406 running text | IV235:407 running text; IV235 n19 actual negative see-pain alternative | IV235:408 running text | IV235:409 running text; Mohl III88:430 running text | III88:431 running text | III88:432 running text | III89:433 running text | III89:434 running text; Ganjoor sh4:228 running poem body | sh4:229 running poem body | sh4:230 running poem body | sh4:231 running poem body | sh4:232 running poem body; Khaleghi III220:1895 running text | III220:1896 running text | III220:1897 running text; III220:1897 negative see-pain main; n32 positive alternative | III220:1898 running text | III221:1899 running text
Moscow printed p.235 · Mohl printed p.88 · Mohl printed p.89 · Khaleghi printed p.220 · Khaleghi printed p.221 · Ganjoor sh4:228 · Ganjoor sh4:229 · Ganjoor sh4:230 · Ganjoor sh4:231 · Ganjoor sh4:232
The kamand tied to the saddle straps and capable of binding an elephant is shared by all four sources. English adds bringing the animal to ground, converting restraint into downward motion. Rostam then begins from favorable expectation; English frames the hoped-for result as escaping the conflict’s worst. The consequence of betrayal divides the texts. Moscow and Ganjoor say Piran will see pain and care from Rostam’s side. Mohl and Khaleghi instead say he will not see their grief or care, and Moscow records the negative alternative. English’s absence of pity interprets that negative branch. The ensuing praise by Gudarz and Tus is shared. English replaces the failure of Piran’s words to shine with their inability to hide behind a veil, preserving exposure through a different image.
71–75The night divides speech, wine and military care
Moscow IV235:410 running text | IV235:411 running text | IV235:412 running text | IV235:413 running text | IV236:414 running text; Mohl III89:435 running text | III89:436 running text | III89:437 running text | III89:438 running text | III89:439 running text; Ganjoor sh4:233 running poem body | sh4:234 running poem body | sh4:235 running poem body | sh4:236 running poem body | sh4:237 running poem body; Khaleghi III221:1900 running text | III221:1901 running text | III221:1902 running text | III221:1903 running text | III221:1904 running text
Moscow printed p.235 · Moscow printed p.236 · Mohl printed p.89 · Khaleghi printed p.221 · Ganjoor sh4:233 · Ganjoor sh4:234 · Ganjoor sh4:235 · Ganjoor sh4:236 · Ganjoor sh4:237
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi share the blessing that the world not lack the king’s crowned head and that Rostam remain his support. English adds the years ahead, extending that wish explicitly through time. Darkness and minds dazed by talk then close the debate. The division of the night is practical: wine until midnight, care of the army afterward. English preserves both activities rather than letting the festive moment displace command responsibility. The question about what the Creator hides within the manifest becomes what lies concealed in things we know, an epistemic interpretation of appearance. Rostam’s wine-associated auspicious omen remains shared, while English supplies red as the wine’s color and pairs omen with sign.
76–80Sahm’s weapon and the promised spoils
Moscow IV236:415 running text; IV236 n3 actual Mazandaran alternative | IV236:416 running text | IV236:417 running text; IV236 n6 actual gorz alternative | IV236:418 running text | IV236:419 running text | IV236:420 running text; Mohl III89:440 running text | III89:441 running text | III89:442 running text | III89:443 running text | III89:444 running text | III89:445 running text; Ganjoor sh4:238 running poem body | sh4:239 running poem body | sh4:240 running poem body | sh4:241 running poem body | sh4:242 running poem body | sh4:243 running poem body; Khaleghi III221:1905 running text; III221 n9 actual first-person Mazandaran alternative | III221:1906 running text | III221:1907 running text; III221 n15 actual gorz alternative | III221:1908 running text | III221:1909 running text | III221:1910 running text
Moscow printed p.236 · Mohl printed p.89 · Khaleghi printed p.221 · Ganjoor sh4:238 · Ganjoor sh4:239 · Ganjoor sh4:240 · Ganjoor sh4:241 · Ganjoor sh4:242 · Ganjoor sh4:243
English’s recollection of Mazandaran follows material printed in Mohl and Khaleghi, while Moscow’s main verse and Ganjoor instead speak of shouldering the mace and fighting. Moscow actually records the Mazandaran alternative. Mohl’s wording makes the earlier deed first-person; English assigns the blow to the weapon, avoiding a newly explicit personal claimant. The shouldering is then preserved in the next English couplet, where Mohl and Khaleghi place it. The promised inventory differs as well: English and Mohl include gorz, while Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi main text have treasure, with gorz alternatives in the printed apparatus. English merges the final acclamation and return to tents into one couplet. The conditional promise of spoils therefore gives way promptly to the army’s need for sleep.
Source record and limits
Inspected 12 November 2026. B14.7 only:80 English couplets;160 exact published lines;16 notes. Moscow IV231–236:340–420 (81 running units including bracketed376); Mohl III86–89:365–445 (81); Ganjoor khaghan sh4:163–243 (81); Khaleghi III217–221:1829–1910 (82). Every declared running unit accounted. Source-only Moscow376/Ganjoor199 retained with Khaleghi actual apparatus. English39 compresses source units,60–61 overlap units,80 merges two final units. Moscow and Mohl inspected individually first, then Ganjoor and Khaleghi.
Edition scope and inspected pages
- Published English B14.7
- Moscow: printed 231 / PDF 231, printed 232 / PDF 232, printed 233 / PDF 233, printed 234 / PDF 234, printed 235 / PDF 235, printed 236 / PDF 236
- Mohl: printed 86 / PDF 92, printed 87 / PDF 93, printed 88 / PDF 94, printed 89 / PDF 95
- Khaleghi: printed 217 / PDF 233, printed 218 / PDF 234, printed 219 / PDF 235, printed 220 / PDF 236, printed 221 / PDF 237
- Ganjoor sh4:163–243
Evidence distinctions and retained limits
Actual Moscow apparatus:231 n15 general warriors, n18 wealth/throne, n20 restraint;232 n33/n37 tribute;233 n16 neck/stone;234 n5 Iran and n16 tenth-day deployment;235 n3 Fariborz/Tus, n5 singular Bahram, n8 extra cemetery wording, n19 negative consequence;236 n3 Mazandaran, n6 gorz. Actual Khaleghi apparatus:217 n3 general warriors,n7 restraint,n24 words/deeds;218 n24 inspected fortune variants without verified affirmative support,n30–31 proverb components;219 n3 tears verse,n11 Iran;221 n9 first-person Mazandaran,n15 gorz. Moscow376 bracketed running versus Ganjoor199 unbracketed poem body. Ganjoor tribute185–186 and tenth-day208–209 checked gaps. No appendix evidence used or exhaustive apparatus/appendix claim. Unprinted notices and source availability never verify a reading.
All inherited flags retained. Current qualifications: Kharad/general-warriors2; wealth/crown5; restraint6; mortality7; words/deeds13; first/among-first14; guilt scope17; tribute addition/order24; crown/throne25; distributive negation versus affirmative acquisition27; proverb components33; compressed39; dialogue agency and Iran/Turan41–42; tenth-day addition46; Manshur/Sagsar50; named chiefs55; hearing polarity58; Bahram/army59; overlap60–61; betrayal-consequence polarity68; Mazandaran agent76; gorz/treasure78; final merge80; source-only Afrasiab-tears verse. English unchanged.
Selected inspected readings
- Mohl III87:388 tribute running verse; Moscow IV232 n33 actual addition: فرستند نزدیک ما ساو و باز / ز پیکار ایشان شوم بی نیاز
- Mohl III87:391 affirmative second half: که باشد همه بهرهٔ نیکبخت
- Khaleghi III218:1855 negative second half: نباید همه بهر یک نیکبخت
- Mohl III88:422 negative hearing condition: اگر نشنوی سر بسر پند من
- Moscow IV235:397 affirmative hearing condition: اگر بشنوی سر بسر پند من
- Mohl III88:432 negative response after betrayal: نبیند ز ما درد و تیمار خویش
Persian display uses labelled Ganjoor units or Mohl transcriptions for the two local gaps. Spacing is normalized in display transcriptions. S1 records the extra Afrasiab-tears verse, distinguishing bracketed Moscow running text, Ganjoor body, Khaleghi printed apparatus and the checked Mohl gap. No unprinted notice establishes support.
B14.7 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV231:340 running text | III86:365 running text |
| 2 | IV231:341 running text; IV231 n15 alternate general-warriors wording rather than Kharad | III86:366 running text |
| 3 | IV231:342 running text | III86:367 running text |
| 4 | IV231:343 running text | III86:368 running text |
| 5 | IV231:344 running text; IV231 n18 actual wealth/throne alternative | III86:369 running text |
| 6 | IV231:345 running text; IV231 n20 actual not oppressing by strength alternative | III86:370 running text |
| 7 | IV231:346 running text | III86:371 running text |
| 8 | IV231:347 running text | III86:372 running text |
| 9 | IV232:348 running text | III86:373 running text |
| 10 | IV232:349 running text | III86:374 running text |
| 11 | IV232:350 running text | III86:375 running text |
| 12 | IV232:351 running text | III86:376 running text |
| 13 | IV232:352 running text | III86:377 running text |
| 14 | IV232:353 running text | III86:378 running text |
| 15 | IV232:354 running text | III86:379 running text |
| 16 | IV232:355 running text | III86:380 running text |
| 17 | IV232:356 running text | III86:381 running text |
| 18 | IV232:357 running text | III86:382 running text |
| 19 | IV232:358 running text | III87:383 running text |
| 20 | IV232:359 running text | III87:384 running text |
| 21 | IV232:360 running text | III87:385 running text |
| 22 | IV232:361 running text | III87:386 running text |
| 23 | IV232:362 running text | III87:387 running text |
| 24 | IV232 n33 actual tribute/withdrawal addition; n37 actual tribute/power addition at later locus | III87:388 running text |
| 25 | IV232:363 running text | III87:389 running text |
| 26 | IV233:364 running text | III87:390 running text |
| 27 | IV233:365 running text | III87:391 running text |
| 28 | IV233:366 running text | III87:392 running text |
| 29 | IV233:367 running text | III87:393 running text |
| 30 | IV233:368 running text | III87:394 running text |
| 31 | IV233:369 running text | III87:395 running text |
| 32 | IV233:370 running text | III87:396 running text |
| 33 | IV233:371 running text; IV233 n16 actual neck/stone alternative; main cart/heavy load | III87:397 running text |
| 34 | IV233:372 running text | III87:398 running text |
| 35 | IV233:373 running text | III87:399 running text |
| 36 | IV233:374 running text | III87:400 running text |
| 37 | IV233:375 running text | III87:401 running text |
| 38 | IV233:377 running text | III87:402 running text |
| 39 | IV234:378 running text | IV234:379 running text | III87:403 running text |
| 40 | IV234:380 running text | III87:404 running text |
| 41 | IV234:382 running text | III87:405 running text |
| 42 | IV234:381 running text; IV234 n5 actual Iran-placement alternative | III87:406 running text |
| 43 | IV234:383 running text | III87:407 running text |
| 44 | IV234:384 running text | III88:408 running text |
| 45 | IV234:385 running text | III88:409 running text |
| 46 | IV234 n16 actual tenth-day deployment addition | III88:410 running text |
| 47 | IV234:386 running text | III88:411 running text |
| 48 | IV234:387 running text | III88:412 running text |
| 49 | IV234:388 running text | III88:413 running text |
| 50 | IV234:389 running text; IV234:389 Sagsar and Fartus main; Manshur not verified in this local Moscow main/apparatus | III88:414 running text |
| 51 | IV234:390 running text | III88:415 running text |
| 52 | IV234:391 running text | III88:416 running text |
| 53 | IV234:392 running text | III88:417 running text |
| 54 | IV234:393 running text | III88:418 running text |
| 55 | IV235:394 running text; IV235 n3 actual Fariborz-and-Tus alternative | III88:419 running text |
| 56 | IV235:395 running text | III88:420 running text |
| 57 | IV235:396 running text | III88:421 running text |
| 58 | IV235:397 running text | III88:422 running text |
| 59 | IV235:398 running text; IV235 n5 actual singular him alternative; n8 additional cemetery verse | III88:423 running text |
| 60 | IV235:398 running text | IV235:399 running text | III88:423 running text | III88:424 running text |
| 61 | IV235:399 running text | IV235:400 running text | III88:424 running text | III88:425 running text |
| 62 | IV235:401 running text | III88:426 running text |
| 63 | IV235:402 running text | III88:427 running text |
| 64 | IV235:403 running text | III88:428 running text |
| 65 | IV235:404 running text | III88:429 running text |
| 66 | IV235:405 running text | III88:430 running text |
| 67 | IV235:406 running text | III88:431 running text |
| 68 | IV235:407 running text; IV235 n19 actual negative see-pain alternative | III88:432 running text |
| 69 | IV235:408 running text | III89:433 running text |
| 70 | IV235:409 running text | III89:434 running text |
| 71 | IV235:410 running text | III89:435 running text |
| 72 | IV235:411 running text | III89:436 running text |
| 73 | IV235:412 running text | III89:437 running text |
| 74 | IV235:413 running text | III89:438 running text |
| 75 | IV236:414 running text | III89:439 running text |
| 76 | IV236:415 running text; IV236 n3 actual Mazandaran alternative | III89:440 running text |
| 77 | IV236:416 running text | III89:441 running text |
| 78 | IV236:417 running text; IV236 n6 actual gorz alternative | III89:442 running text |
| 79 | IV236:418 running text | III89:443 running text |
| 80 | IV236:419 running text | IV236:420 running text | III89:444 running text | III89:445 running text |
New Naqqali