Rostam Is Summoned to Fight Akvan
45 couplets; 90 unchanged published lines.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 45 couplets; 90 unchanged published lines. |
| Moscow | 15 running units; 21 actual Appendix VII units; selected actual apparatus; explicit local gaps. |
| Mohl | 45 running units, III136–138:19–63. |
| Ganjoor | 15 running units, akvan sh1:20–34; expanded summons absent at30–31. |
| Khaleghi | 15 running units;24 actually printed n5 addition units; selected other apparatus and local gaps. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5The feast and the absent hero
Moscow IV302:20 running text; IV302:21 running text | IV302:22 running text; IV302 n14 actual Zangeh alternative | IV302:23 running text | IV302:23–24 checked running-text gap | IV302:24 running text; Mohl III136:19 running text; III137:20 running text | III137:21 running text | III137:22 running text | III137:23 running text | III137:24 running text; Ganjoor sh1:20, sh1:21 running poem body | sh1:22 running poem body | sh1:23 running poem body | sh1:23–24 checked gap for toast | sh1:24 running poem body; Khaleghi III289:20 running text; III289:21 running text | III289:22 running text | III289:23 running text | III289 n12 actual added toast hemistich; surrounding added heroes outside declared verse scope | III289:24 running text
Moscow printed p. 302 · Mohl printed p. 136 · Mohl printed p. 137 · Khaleghi printed p. 289 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:20 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:21 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:22 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:23 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:24
English gathers the morning and the springlike garden into a glowing court, then identifies the assembled chiefs. Its Zangeh agrees with Mohl and an actual Moscow variant. Moscow, Khaleghi and Ganjoor instead name Rostam in their running lists. This matters because their shorter narrative can commission him immediately, while the longer summons sequence requires his arrival from Zabul. English therefore follows a coherent alternative rather than casually losing a name. Mohl’s toast supports the celebration, and Khaleghi prints a related toast below the main text; Moscow and Ganjoor lack that separate action at the checked transition. Cups preserve the drinking, but strings add musical atmosphere. Calling the dehqan a minstrel likewise makes transmission explicitly performative.
6–10A monstrous animal in a golden coat
Moscow IV302 n19 actual two-couplet addition after24; ground-kiss and speech | IV302:25 running text | IV303:29 running text | IV302:26 running text | IV302:27 running text; Mohl III137:25 running text | III137:26 running text | III137:27 running text | III137:28 running text | III137:29 running text; Ganjoor sh1:24–25 checked gap for obeisance | sh1:25 running poem body | sh1:29 running poem body | sh1:26 running poem body | sh1:27 running poem body; Khaleghi III289 n14 actual added salutation; checked main24–25 gap for ground-kiss | III289:25 running text | III289:26 running text | III289:27 running text | III289:28 running text
Moscow printed p. 302 · Moscow printed p. 303 · Mohl printed p. 137 · Khaleghi printed p. 289 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:25 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:26 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:27 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:29
The herdsman’s obeisance combines evidence of different kinds. Mohl supplies approach and salutation; Moscow actually prints the ground kiss in an added couplet, while Khaleghi’s added salutation does not itself verify that action. Ganjoor moves directly to the report. The freed Div follows Mohl and Khaleghi; Moscow and Ganjoor compare the beast to an unbound lion. English thus introduces demonic suspicion before the king identifies a possible supernatural opponent. The lionlike violence survives the rearranged description, with fear added as its consequence. All four preserve the golden coat and musky stripe. English gives the sun an active role rolling over the hide, replacing the image of heaven washing the animal in gold while retaining its startling brilliance.
11–15Recognition and the longer explanation
Moscow IV303:28 running text; IV303 n3 actual conformation alternative | IV303:30 running text | IV321 Appendix VII:1 printed appendix text | IV321 Appendix VII:2 printed appendix text | IV321 Appendix VII:3 printed appendix text; Mohl III137:30 running text | III137:31 running text | III137:32 running text | III137:33 running text | III137:34 running text; Ganjoor sh1:28 running poem body | sh1:30 running poem body | sh1:30–31 checked gap for expanded summons/reception; Khaleghi III290:29 running text | III290:30 running text | III290 n5 actual printed addition units 1 | III290 n5 actual printed addition units 2 | III290 n5:2–3 checked local gap for grazing verse
Moscow printed p. 303 · Moscow printed p. 321 · Mohl printed p. 137 · Khaleghi printed p. 290 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:28 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:30
English’s anatomical catalogue has support in Mohl, Khaleghi and a printed Moscow alternative. Moscow and Ganjoor’s main description instead emphasizes a large dun animal with limbs like four maces. The noble racer therefore selects a different emphasis, although swiftness remains an inference from conformation. More significantly, the king’s stated reasoning compares an ass’s strength with a horse’s. English turns this into an unmatched breed, preserving suspicion but blurring its explicit basis. Mohl continues with the king’s prior knowledge of Akvan; Moscow prints that explanation in its appendix and Khaleghi below the line. Ganjoor lacks it at the checked transition. The grazing verse occurs in Mohl and Moscow’s appendix but not Khaleghi’s addition. English supplies the duration of nights and days.
16–20Choosing Rostam rather than recording refusals
Moscow IV321 Appendix VII:4 printed appendix text | IV321 Appendix VII:5 printed appendix text; IV321 Appendix VII:6 printed appendix text | IV321 Appendix VII:6 printed appendix text | IV321 Appendix VII:7 printed appendix text; IV321 Appendix VII:8 printed appendix text | IV321 Appendix VII:8 printed appendix text; IV321 Appendix VII:9 printed appendix text; Mohl III137:35 running text | III137:36 running text; III137:37 running text | III137:37 running text | III137:38 running text; III137:39 running text | III137:39 running text; III137:40 running text; Ganjoor sh1:30–31 checked gap for expanded summons/reception; Khaleghi III290 n5 actual printed addition units 3 | III290 n5 actual printed addition units 4,5 | III290 n5 actual printed addition units 5 | III290 n5 actual printed addition units 6,7 | III290 n5 actual printed addition units 7,8
Moscow printed p. 321 · Mohl printed p. 137 · Khaleghi printed p. 290 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:30 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:31
The dismissal of the herdsman and the search for a champion belong to the expanded narrative in Mohl, Moscow’s appendix and Khaleghi’s printed addition. Ganjoor proceeds directly from recognition to the commission. English’s instruction to let the matter pass can sound more permissive than the source dismissal telling the messenger not to remain; the subsequent search makes clear that the king still acts. The sources then describe his inspection of the warriors and failure to find anyone suitable except Rostam. English makes this apparent unwillingness to undertake the quest. That sharpens Rostam’s exceptional standing but changes the agency: royal judgment is explicit, individual refusals are not. The letter follows the identification of the uniquely adequate hero in the longer witnesses.
21–25A summons shaped by affection and urgency
Moscow IV321 Appendix VII:9 printed appendix text | IV322 Appendix VII:10 printed appendix text; IV322 Appendix VII:11 printed appendix text | IV322 Appendix VII:11 printed appendix text | IV322 Appendix VII:12 printed appendix text | IV322 Appendix VII:13 printed appendix text; Mohl III137:40 running text | III137:41 running text; III137:42 running text | III137:42 running text | III137:43 running text | III137:44 running text; Ganjoor sh1:30–31 checked gap for expanded summons/reception; Khaleghi III290 n5 actual printed addition units 8 | III290 n5 actual printed addition units 9,10 | III290 n5 actual printed addition units 10 | III290 n5 actual printed addition units 11 | III290 n5 actual printed addition units 12
Moscow printed p. 321 · Moscow printed p. 322 · Mohl printed p. 137 · Khaleghi printed p. 290 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:30 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:31
Mohl’s continuous text, Moscow’s actual appendix verses and Khaleghi’s printed addition agree on the affectionate, just letter entrusted to Gorgin. Ganjoor contains no messenger episode between recognition and command. English preserves the combination of authority and warmth, adding care without changing the relationship. Its smoke simile also keeps the source’s urgency, although road and valley furnish scenery absent from the local wording. The instruction to travel night and day and not sleep in Zabul becomes sleepless travel and no full day’s delay, redistributing the restriction. The wish that heaven never be without Rostam becomes a blessing for long life; freedom is additional. Calling Khosrow sovereign and friend explains the letter’s tone rather than quoting a separate source designation.
26–30Colour, scent and the messenger’s chase
Moscow IV322 Appendix VII:13 printed appendix text; IV322 Appendix VII:14 printed appendix text | IV322 Appendix VII:14 printed appendix text | IV322 Appendix VII:14–15 checked local gap | IV322 Appendix VII:15 printed appendix text; IV322 Appendix VII:16 printed appendix text | IV322 Appendix VII:16 printed appendix text; Mohl III137:44 running text; III138:45 running text | III138:45 running text | III138:46 running text | III138:47 running text; III138:48 running text | III138:48 running text; Ganjoor sh1:30–31 checked gap for expanded summons/reception; Khaleghi III290 n5 actual printed addition units 12,13 | III290 n5 actual printed addition units 13 | III290 n5:13–14 checked local gap for chase simile | III290 n5 actual printed addition units 14 | III290 n5:14–15 checked local gap for journey inquiry
Moscow printed p. 322 · Mohl printed p. 137 · Mohl printed p. 138 · Khaleghi printed p. 290 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:30 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:31
The throne derives colour and scent from Rostam in Mohl and the two printed additions; English transfers those qualities to the king himself, preserving affectionate dependence through a more personal speaker. The request for immediate arrival retains urgency while expanding the timing. Gorgin’s next simile needs a firmer distinction. Mohl makes him a driving wind or a gazelle afraid of death. English supplies a pursuing Gur-e-Khar, which reconnects his speed to the threatening beast but changes both animal and pursuer. Moscow’s appendix, Khaleghi’s addition and Ganjoor lack that separate verse at the checked transitions. Mohl and Moscow then attest Rostam’s inquiry about the journey; Khaleghi omits it locally. Reading the summons at this point is English’s anticipation, not another attested action.
31–35Arrival, service and a seat beside the king
Moscow IV322 Appendix VII:17 printed appendix text | IV322 Appendix VII:18 printed appendix text | IV322 Appendix VII:19 printed appendix text; IV322 Appendix VII:20 printed appendix text | IV322 Appendix VII:20 printed appendix text | IV322 Appendix VII:21 printed appendix text; Mohl III138:49 running text | III138:50 running text | III138:51 running text; III138:52 running text | III138:52 running text | III138:53 running text; Ganjoor sh1:30–31 checked gap for expanded summons/reception; Khaleghi III290 n5 actual printed addition units 15 | III290 n5 actual printed addition units 16 | III290 n5 actual printed addition units 17,18 | III290 n5 actual printed addition units 18 | III290 n5:18–19 checked local gap for throne seating
Moscow printed p. 322 · Mohl printed p. 138 · Khaleghi printed p. 290 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:30 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:31
The expanded witnesses bring Rostam to court after he hears the command. English’s renewed reference to reading makes the written summons more prominent, while its pride and splendor interpret the energetic arrival. Mohl, Moscow’s appendix and Khaleghi’s addition preserve the ground kiss and blessing of royal fortune. The hero’s girded readiness becomes a bared arm, shifting equipment and service into a bodily image without changing his willingness to obey. English also retains the wish for goodness and dominion. Mohl and Moscow explicitly seat him beside the king on the throne; Khaleghi’s checked transition lacks that separate action, and Ganjoor lacks the whole expanded reception. The honored place conveys extraordinary intimacy and esteem, but the passage does not announce a transfer of sovereignty.
36–40Courtesy before the dangerous commission
Moscow IV322 Appendix VII:21 and IV303:30–31 checked transition gap; Mohl III138:54 running text; III138:55 running text | III138:55 running text; III138:56 running text | III138:56 running text | III138:57 running text | III138:58 running text; Ganjoor sh1:30–31 checked gap for expanded summons/reception; Khaleghi III290 n5 actual printed addition units 19,20 | III290 n5 actual printed addition units 20,21 | III290 n5 actual printed addition units 21 | III290 n5 actual printed addition units 22 | III290 n5 actual printed addition units 23
Moscow printed p. 322 · Moscow printed p. 303 · Mohl printed p. 138 · Khaleghi printed p. 290 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:30 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:31
Mohl and Khaleghi’s actual added verses preserve the greeting, delight in Rostam’s presence and introduction of the task. Moscow’s appendix ends with the seating, and its running text resumes at the battle warning; Ganjoor likewise lacks this intervening exchange. English makes the king’s delight into dependence on Rostam’s prudent mind and rare strength. These develop the awakened soul and selection of the hero, but the strongest superlative and request not to reject the task are not explicit source statements. The conditional courtesy remains: the king asks whether his command will trouble Rostam. English replaces Mohl’s appeal to crown and treasure, or Khaleghi’s fame and treasure, with the herdsman’s news from the next verse. That shifts motivation from royal reward toward the reported danger.
41–45The king’s caution and the hero’s assurance
Moscow IV322 Appendix VII:21 and IV303:30–31 checked transition gap | IV303:31 running text | IV303:32 running text | IV303:33 running text | IV303:34 running text; Mohl III138:59 running text | III138:60 running text | III138:61 running text | III138:62 running text | III138:63 running text; Ganjoor sh1:30–31 checked gap for expanded summons/reception | sh1:31 running poem body | sh1:32 running poem body | sh1:33 running poem body | sh1:34 running poem body; Khaleghi III290 n5 actual printed addition units 24 | III290:31 running text | III290:32 running text | III290:33 running text | III290:34 running text
Moscow printed p. 322 · Moscow printed p. 303 · Mohl printed p. 138 · Khaleghi printed p. 290 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:31 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:32 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:33 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:34
Mohl and Khaleghi’s added passage explicitly say that the king repeats the herdsman’s story from beginning to end. Moscow and Ganjoor omit that separate repetition, then converge with the others on the warning to measure oneself against the struggle. English makes this a comparison of strength, preserving the king’s caution rather than treating the task as an ordinary hunt. The suggestion that the opponent may be Ahriman remains conjectural in all four and in English; it should not be promoted into a definitive identity. Rostam answers through the king’s fortune and his own service to the throne. English preserves those relational grounds for confidence. Its final catalogue and sharp sword retain the boast, with the added condition of active assault sharpening its martial delivery.
Source record and limits
C1.2 only: 45 English couplets, 90 unchanged published lines, 9 notes. Moscow IV302–303 main20–34 (15 units), IV321–322 Appendix VII1–21 (21 units), actual IV302 nn14/19 and IV303 n3. Mohl III136–138:19–63 (45 running units; PDF142–144). Ganjoor akvan sh1:20–34 (15 running units). Khaleghi III289–290 main20–34 (15 units; PDF305–306), III290 n5 printed addition1–24 (24 units, local ordinal numbering), selected actual III289 nn12/14. Every declared main/appendix/addition unit accounted; shared mappings and partial half-lines explicit. Moscow and Mohl checked individually first, then Ganjoor and Khaleghi.
Edition scope and inspected pages
- Published English C1.2, captured12November2026
- Moscow: printed 302 / PDF 302, printed 303 / PDF 303, printed 321 / PDF 321, printed 322 / PDF 322
- Mohl: printed 136 / PDF 142, printed 137 / PDF 143, printed 138 / PDF 144
- Khaleghi: printed 289 / PDF 305, printed 290 / PDF 306
- Ganjoor akvan sh1:20–34, indexed Persian poem body
Evidence classes and local gaps
Moscow303 n7 merely directs to an addition: verification instead uses the actual Appendix VII text on321–322, individually mapped. Khaleghi290 n5 is actual printed Persian, not an unprinted notice: all24 units mapped. Moscow302 n14 Zangeh,302 n19 ground-kiss/salutation and303 n3 conformation were inspected; Khaleghi289 n12 toast hemistich and n14 salutation inspected. Other apparatus additions, including extra banquet heroes, are outside the declared unit scope and not exhaustively collated. Checked local gaps are limited to the named transitions, not claims about all manuscripts. No source availability is counted as verification.
Inherited flags retained verbatim, including C1.1 unclear Mohl verb. C1.2: English minstrel/music elaboration; Zangeh versus Rostam; selected Div/lion and conformation readings; force comparison recast as breed; added duration; dismissal softened; royal selection recast as refusal; travel restriction redistributed; freedom supplied; throne qualities transferred to king; Gur-e-Khar pursuit differs from Mohl gazelle/death simile; letter-reading anticipated/repeated; bared arm replaces girding; added strongest/rejection wording; crown-or-fame/treasure motive omitted. Ganjoor current indexed Persian body inspected at trailing-slash URL after no-slash/direct requests failed; no AI gloss or reader comment used. Mohl supplies clearly labelled Persian display for passages absent from Ganjoor; these are not a reconstructed Ganjoor text.
Selected inspected readings
- Moscow IV302 n14, actual variant: زنگه
- Mohl III137:26 / Khaleghi III289:25 running text: چو دیوی که از بند گردد یله
- Moscow IV302:25 / Ganjoor sh1:25 running text: چو شیری که از بند گردد یله
- Moscow IV302 n19, actual added ground kiss: بشد پیش خسرو زمین بوسه داد
- Mohl III138:46, running simile: ویا چو گوزنی که ترسد زمان
- Moscow IV322 Appendix VII:13, actual appendix: که تخت من از تست با رنگ و بوی
- Khaleghi III290 n5:22, actual addition: ببندی میان از پی نام و گنج
- Mohl III138:57, running text: ببندی میان از پی تاج و گنج
Ganjoor indexed body retrieved12November2026 as turn50view0, lines117–174; next scene starts176. No-slash retrievals returned404; trailing-slash indexed retrieval succeeded. Mohl running Persian, when displayed instead, is explicitly labelled with its own verse locators. Existing PDFs inspected as PNG facsimiles.
C1.2 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV302:20 running text; IV302:21 running text | III136:19 running text; III137:20 running text |
| 2 | IV302:22 running text; IV302 n14 actual Zangeh alternative | III137:21 running text |
| 3 | IV302:23 running text | III137:22 running text |
| 4 | IV302:23–24 checked running-text gap | III137:23 running text |
| 5 | IV302:24 running text | III137:24 running text |
| 6 | IV302 n19 actual two-couplet addition after24; ground-kiss and speech | III137:25 running text |
| 7 | IV302:25 running text | III137:26 running text |
| 8 | IV303:29 running text | III137:27 running text |
| 9 | IV302:26 running text | III137:28 running text |
| 10 | IV302:27 running text | III137:29 running text |
| 11 | IV303:28 running text; IV303 n3 actual conformation alternative | III137:30 running text |
| 12 | IV303:30 running text | III137:31 running text |
| 13 | IV321 Appendix VII:1 printed appendix text | III137:32 running text |
| 14 | IV321 Appendix VII:2 printed appendix text | III137:33 running text |
| 15 | IV321 Appendix VII:3 printed appendix text | III137:34 running text |
| 16 | IV321 Appendix VII:4 printed appendix text | III137:35 running text |
| 17 | IV321 Appendix VII:5 printed appendix text; IV321 Appendix VII:6 printed appendix text | III137:36 running text; III137:37 running text |
| 18 | IV321 Appendix VII:6 printed appendix text | III137:37 running text |
| 19 | IV321 Appendix VII:7 printed appendix text; IV321 Appendix VII:8 printed appendix text | III137:38 running text; III137:39 running text |
| 20 | IV321 Appendix VII:8 printed appendix text; IV321 Appendix VII:9 printed appendix text | III137:39 running text; III137:40 running text |
| 21 | IV321 Appendix VII:9 printed appendix text | III137:40 running text |
| 22 | IV322 Appendix VII:10 printed appendix text; IV322 Appendix VII:11 printed appendix text | III137:41 running text; III137:42 running text |
| 23 | IV322 Appendix VII:11 printed appendix text | III137:42 running text |
| 24 | IV322 Appendix VII:12 printed appendix text | III137:43 running text |
| 25 | IV322 Appendix VII:13 printed appendix text | III137:44 running text |
| 26 | IV322 Appendix VII:13 printed appendix text; IV322 Appendix VII:14 printed appendix text | III137:44 running text; III138:45 running text |
| 27 | IV322 Appendix VII:14 printed appendix text | III138:45 running text |
| 28 | IV322 Appendix VII:14–15 checked local gap | III138:46 running text |
| 29 | IV322 Appendix VII:15 printed appendix text; IV322 Appendix VII:16 printed appendix text | III138:47 running text; III138:48 running text |
| 30 | IV322 Appendix VII:16 printed appendix text | III138:48 running text |
| 31 | IV322 Appendix VII:17 printed appendix text | III138:49 running text |
| 32 | IV322 Appendix VII:18 printed appendix text | III138:50 running text |
| 33 | IV322 Appendix VII:19 printed appendix text; IV322 Appendix VII:20 printed appendix text | III138:51 running text; III138:52 running text |
| 34 | IV322 Appendix VII:20 printed appendix text | III138:52 running text |
| 35 | IV322 Appendix VII:21 printed appendix text | III138:53 running text |
| 36 | IV322 Appendix VII:21 and IV303:30–31 checked transition gap | III138:54 running text; III138:55 running text |
| 37 | IV322 Appendix VII:21 and IV303:30–31 checked transition gap | III138:55 running text; III138:56 running text |
| 38 | IV322 Appendix VII:21 and IV303:30–31 checked transition gap | III138:56 running text |
| 39 | IV322 Appendix VII:21 and IV303:30–31 checked transition gap | III138:57 running text |
| 40 | IV322 Appendix VII:21 and IV303:30–31 checked transition gap | III138:58 running text |
| 41 | IV322 Appendix VII:21 and IV303:30–31 checked transition gap | III138:59 running text |
| 42 | IV303:31 running text | III138:60 running text |
| 43 | IV303:32 running text | III138:61 running text |
| 44 | IV303:33 running text | III138:62 running text |
| 45 | IV303:34 running text | III138:63 running text |
New Naqqali