Rostam’s Quest for the Div
24 couplets;48 unchanged published lines.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 24 couplets;48 unchanged published lines. |
| Moscow | IV303–304:35–58;24 running units. |
| Mohl | III138–139:64–87;24 running units. |
| Ganjoor | Akvan sh1:35–58;24 retained indexed poem units. |
| Khaleghi | III290–292:35–57;23 running units plus actual292 n1 couplet. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5The hunter and the deceptive golden hide
Moscow IV303:35 running text | IV303:36 running text | IV303:37 running text; IV303:38 running text | IV303:38 running text; IV303:39 running text | IV303:39 running text; IV303:40 running text; Mohl III138:64 running text | III138:65 running text | III138:66 running text; III139:67 running text | III139:67 running text; III139:68 running text | III139:68 running text; III139:69 running text; Ganjoor sh1:35 retained indexed running poem body | sh1:36 retained indexed running poem body | sh1:37, sh1:38 retained indexed running poem body | sh1:38, sh1:39 retained indexed running poem body | sh1:39, sh1:40 retained indexed running poem body; Khaleghi III290:35 running text | III291:36 running text | III291:37 running text; III291:38 running text | III291:38 running text; III291:39 running text | III291:39 running text; III291:40 running text
Moscow printed p. 303 · Mohl printed p. 138 · Mohl printed p. 139 · Khaleghi printed p. 290 · Khaleghi printed p. 291 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:35 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:36 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:37 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:38 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:39 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:40
All four presentations begin with the lionlike hunter, lasso in hand, riding a mount figured as a dragon. English names Rakhsh and relocates that force into his pace, making the image kinetic rather than simply identifying the formidable animal beneath Rostam. The three days of searching and fourth day’s sighting remain intact, although English distributes their details across successive couplets. The source also describes hunting around the horses; this is compressed into the search among them. The northern wind and golden exterior survive clearly. Within the hide, however, the Persian gives an ugly adversary or monstrous presence. English’s burning mischief makes that contrast more abstract, turning concealed monstrosity into an inward quality before Rostam actively engages the creature.
6–10A living capture and an impossible escape
Moscow IV303:40 running text | IV303:41 running text | IV303:42 running text | IV303:43 running text | IV303:44 running text; Mohl III139:69 running text | III139:70 running text | III139:71 running text | III139:72 running text | III139:73 running text; Ganjoor sh1:40 retained indexed running poem body | sh1:41 retained indexed running poem body | sh1:42 retained indexed running poem body | sh1:43 retained indexed running poem body | sh1:44 retained indexed running poem body; Khaleghi III291:40 running text | III291:41 running text | III291:42 running text | III291:43 running text | III291:44 running text
Moscow printed p. 303 · Mohl printed p. 139 · Khaleghi printed p. 291 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:40 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:41 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:42 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:43 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:44
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi agree that proximity prompts a change of plan: Rostam wants the creature alive for the king. English expands the brief change of mind into other counsel, but no outside adviser enters the scene. Its sword reference anticipates the following restriction on the khanjar, while the added deadline makes the intended capture sound more immediate. The word spoil can suggest preserving valuable prey as well as avoiding its destruction. The royal lasso remains the chosen instrument. Yet the source specifies the head as its target, whereas English emphasizes surprise. That surprise is not actually achieved: in all four the creature sees the lasso and disappears. English supplies the descending coil’s trajectory to make the failed action visible.
11–15Recognition, reported knowledge and the sword
Moscow IV304:45 running text | IV304:46 running text | IV304:48 running text; IV304 n8 actual order notice, read alongside running47–48 | IV304:47 running text; IV304 n8 actual order notice, read alongside running47–48 | IV304:49 running text; Mohl III139:74 running text | III139:75 running text | III139:76 running text | III139:77 running text | III139:78 running text; Ganjoor sh1:45 retained indexed running poem body | sh1:46 retained indexed running poem body | sh1:48 retained indexed running poem body | sh1:47 retained indexed running poem body | sh1:49 retained indexed running poem body; Khaleghi III291:45 running text | III291:46 running text | III291:47 running text; III291 n19 actual order notice, read alongside running47–48 | III291:48 running text; III291 n19 actual order notice, read alongside running47–48 | III291:49 running text
Moscow printed p. 304 · Mohl printed p. 139 · Khaleghi printed p. 291 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:45 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:46 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:47 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:48 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:49
The disappearance establishes the need for craft rather than force in all four witnesses. English explains the inference through the impossibility of an ordinary onager fading, then embellishes the proposed sword stroke with concealment and a hidden heart. Those are interpretive details, not verified anatomy. Its ordering follows Mohl and Khaleghi: remembered knowledge precedes the renewed sword plan. Moscow and Ganjoor put the bloodshed plan first. The actual verses, not merely the printed order notices, establish the distinction. The skin image also requires care: taking an onager’s skin becomes hiding within it. English makes the remembered report a direct explanation of disguise. Its added intention to strike before another disappearance anticipates the tactical problem, while the reappearance itself remains shared narrative evidence.
16–20The second pursuit and the exhausted body
Moscow IV304:50 running text | IV304:51 running text | IV304:52 running text | IV304:53 running text | IV304:54 running text; Mohl III139:79 running text | III139:80 running text | III139:81 running text | III139:82 running text | III139:83 running text; Ganjoor sh1:50 retained indexed running poem body | sh1:51 retained indexed running poem body | sh1:52 retained indexed running poem body | sh1:53 retained indexed running poem body | sh1:54 retained indexed running poem body; Khaleghi III291:50 running text | III291:51 running text | III291:52 running text | III291:53 running text | III291:54 running text
Moscow printed p. 304 · Mohl printed p. 139 · Khaleghi printed p. 291 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:50 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:51 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:52 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:53 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:54
The bow, windlike mount and Azargashasp comparison occur in all four presentations. English preserves the proper name but renders its effect as force, then supplies a flame simile for the creature’s disappearance. This extends the preceding fiery imagery rather than reproducing a second explicit comparison. The apparent movement from releasing an arrow to drawing the bow is already present in the sources; English does not originate that compression. A second period of three days and nights follows the earlier search and should remain distinct. Thirst, hunger and the head nodding against the saddle make the hero’s bodily limits conspicuous. English intensifies the hunger and can suggest fuller sleep while mounted. Its rose-bright spring visualizes a comparison that the Persian expresses through rosewater.
21–24Rest without laying aside the equipment
Moscow IV304:55 running text | IV304:56 running text; IV304 n17 omission notice; running56 itself inspected | IV304:57 running text | IV304:58 running text; Mohl III139:84 running text | III139:85 running text | III139:86 running text | III139:87 running text; Ganjoor sh1:55 retained indexed running poem body | sh1:56 retained indexed running poem body | sh1:57 retained indexed running poem body | sh1:58 retained indexed running poem body; Khaleghi III292:55 running text | III292 n1 actual printed armor/lasso couplet after55; main55–56 checked local gap | III292:56 running text | III292:57 running text
Moscow printed p. 304 · Mohl printed p. 139 · Khaleghi printed p. 292 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:55 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:56 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:57 · Ganjoor akvan sh1:58
Dismounting and watering Rakhsh precede the yielding of tired eyes in all four presentations. The equipment couplet requires a different kind of agreement: Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor print it continuously, while Khaleghi’s running text omits it and the apparatus actually supplies both hemistichs. English retains the garment, arm lasso and bound waist without establishing what material the Babr-e Bayan is made from. The loosened girth and khadang headrest follow, with a lexical difference between the printed forms in Moscow and Ganjoor versus Mohl and Khaleghi. English specifies a bow rather than preserving that lexical uncertainty. Finally, the source pairs Rakhsh’s grazing with a place for sleep. English expressly gives the sleeping place to Rakhsh, narrowing an unexpressed possessor that can leave Rostam’s rest in view.
Source record and limits
C1.3 only:24 English couplets,48 unchanged published lines,5 notes. Moscow IV303–304:35–58 (24 running units); Mohl III138–139:64–87 (24 running units; PDF144–145); Ganjoor akvan sh1:35–58 (24 retained indexed running units); Khaleghi III290–292:35–57 (23 running units; PDF306–308) plus actual III292 n1 armor/lasso couplet. All declared units accounted; early shared mappings explicit. Moscow and Mohl individually checked first, then retained Ganjoor and Khaleghi.
Edition scope and inspected pages
- Published English C1.3, captured12November2026
- Moscow: printed 303 / PDF 303, printed 304 / PDF 304
- Mohl: printed 138 / PDF 144, printed 139 / PDF 145
- Khaleghi: printed 290 / PDF 306, printed 291 / PDF 307, printed 292 / PDF 308
- Ganjoor sh1:35–58, retained indexed Persian body
Evidence classes and retained limits
Khaleghi III292 n1 actually prints the armor/lasso couplet after55; both hemistichs were inspected, not inferred from its addition notice. Khaleghi main55–56 transition checked. Moscow IV304:56 itself inspected, with n17 recording omission in witnesses. Actual Moscow IV304 n8 and Khaleghi III291 n19 order notices checked alongside both complete running47–48 verses; notices alone are not their verification. No appendix needed for this passage. Other local apparatus additions outside the declared running scope were not exhaustively collated and are not used to verify English.
Every inherited flag retained verbatim. C1.3: dragon mount changed to pace; hunting compressed; monstrosity abstracted; anticipatory sword/deadline; unaware and lasso trajectory supplied; hidden heart and disguise interpretation; reversed advice/sword order follows Mohl/Khaleghi; added pre-emptive timing; Azargashasp comparison and supplied flame; mounted sleep strengthened; rosewater visualized; Khaleghi armor couplet verified in printed apparatus only; khadang object specified as bow despite lexical variation; sleeping-place assigned explicitly to Rakhsh. Ganjoor uses the successful prior indexed body turn50view0 lines176–267 in this conversation; refresh turn51view0 returned404. No fresh Ganjoor retrieval, AI gloss or reader-comment evidence claimed.
Selected inspected readings
- Moscow IV303:35 / Mohl III138:64 / Khaleghi III290:35 running image: اژدهایی بزیر
- Moscow IV304:45 / Khaleghi III291:45, running counsel: چاره باید نه زور
- Moscow IV304:48 and Khaleghi III291:47, shared skin phrase: بستاند از گور پوست
- Khaleghi III292 n1, actual printed garment reading: ببر بیان
- Moscow IV304:57 / Ganjoor sh1:57, headrest form: جناغ خدنگ
- Mohl III139:86 / Khaleghi III292:56, headrest form: جناح خدنگ
Persian display follows Ganjoor separately, including its sword/advice ordering and continuous armor couplet; it does not silently adopt Khaleghi’s running sequence. Source body retained from turn50view0 lines176–267; current refresh failed404.
C1.3 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV303:35 running text | III138:64 running text |
| 2 | IV303:36 running text | III138:65 running text |
| 3 | IV303:37 running text; IV303:38 running text | III138:66 running text; III139:67 running text |
| 4 | IV303:38 running text; IV303:39 running text | III139:67 running text; III139:68 running text |
| 5 | IV303:39 running text; IV303:40 running text | III139:68 running text; III139:69 running text |
| 6 | IV303:40 running text | III139:69 running text |
| 7 | IV303:41 running text | III139:70 running text |
| 8 | IV303:42 running text | III139:71 running text |
| 9 | IV303:43 running text | III139:72 running text |
| 10 | IV303:44 running text | III139:73 running text |
| 11 | IV304:45 running text | III139:74 running text |
| 12 | IV304:46 running text | III139:75 running text |
| 13 | IV304:48 running text; IV304 n8 actual order notice, read alongside running47–48 | III139:76 running text |
| 14 | IV304:47 running text; IV304 n8 actual order notice, read alongside running47–48 | III139:77 running text |
| 15 | IV304:49 running text | III139:78 running text |
| 16 | IV304:50 running text | III139:79 running text |
| 17 | IV304:51 running text | III139:80 running text |
| 18 | IV304:52 running text | III139:81 running text |
| 19 | IV304:53 running text | III139:82 running text |
| 20 | IV304:54 running text | III139:83 running text |
| 21 | IV304:55 running text | III139:84 running text |
| 22 | IV304:56 running text; IV304 n17 omission notice; running56 itself inspected | III139:85 running text |
| 23 | IV304:57 running text | III139:86 running text |
| 24 | IV304:58 running text | III139:87 running text |
New Naqqali