Akvan Flings Rostam into the Sea
56 couplets;112 unchanged published lines.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 56 couplets;112 unchanged published lines. |
| Moscow | IV304–308:59–107;49 running units, selected actually printed additions. |
| Mohl | III139–142:88–143;56 running units. |
| Ganjoor | Akvan sh1:59–107;49 indexed Persian units, retained/current extracts distinguished. |
| Khaleghi | III292–294:58–102;45 running units plus selected actual apparatus. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6Abduction and the vulnerable hero
Moscow IV304:59 running text; IV304:60 running text | IV304:61 running text | IV305:62 running text | IV305 n2 actual six-couplet lament, units1–2 | IV305 n2 actual lament unit2 | IV305 n2 actual lament unit3 first hemistich; Mohl III139:88 running text | III139:89 running text | III140:90 running text | III140:91 running text; III140:92 running text | III140:92 running text | III140:93 running text; Ganjoor sh1:59, sh1:60 indexed running poem body | sh1:61 indexed running poem body | sh1:62 indexed running poem body | sh1:62–63 checked local gap; Khaleghi III292:58 running text; III292 n6 actual sleep couplet | III292:59 running text | III292:60 running text | III292:60–61 checked local lament gap
Moscow printed p. 304 · Moscow printed p. 305 · Mohl printed p. 139 · Mohl printed p. 140 · Khaleghi printed p. 292 · Ganjoor sh1:59 · Ganjoor sh1:60 · Ganjoor sh1:61 · Ganjoor sh1:62
The windlike approach and lifting of the earth agree across the four presentations. English makes Akvan’s becoming wind a comparison and reduces the explicit ascent from plain to sky to being carried away; the later height restores the setting. On waking, the hero is distressed, but Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi also emphasize thought and struggle. English foregrounds fear and wonder. His extended lament then follows Mohl’s running text and six actual verses in Moscow’s apparatus, absent at the checked Khaleghi and Ganjoor transitions. The sword’s failure in empty air is English’s dramatization of helplessness, not a narrated unsuccessful attack. The lament makes the hero’s vulnerability unusually audible, while its threatened destruction of the world remains his own fearful anticipation.
7–12Public catastrophe and the offered choice
Moscow IV305 n2 actual lament unit3 second hemistich | IV305 n2 actual lament unit4 | IV305 n2 actual lament units5–6 | IV305:63 running text; IV305:64 running text | IV305:64 running text | IV305:65 running text; Mohl III140:93 running text | III140:94 running text | III140:95 running text; III140:96 running text | III140:97 running text; III140:98 running text | III140:98 running text | III140:99 running text; Ganjoor sh1:62–63 checked local gap | sh1:63, sh1:64 indexed running poem body | sh1:64 indexed running poem body | sh1:65 indexed running poem body; Khaleghi III292:60–61 checked local lament gap | III292:61 running text; III292:62 running text | III292:62 running text | III292:63 running text
Moscow printed p. 305 · Mohl printed p. 140 · Khaleghi printed p. 292 · Ganjoor sh1:63 · Ganjoor sh1:64 · Ganjoor sh1:65
The longer lament connects Rostam’s predicament with Afrasiab’s fulfilled desire and the loss of Iran’s leaders and royal equipment. Mohl prints this continuously; Moscow prints the corresponding verses below the line, while Khaleghi and Ganjoor proceed to Akvan’s speech. English redistributes throne and crown into the preceding couplet and adds fire, which should not be mistaken for a separately attested burning. The absence of a future avenger completes the hero’s fear of public consequences. All four then give Akvan’s choice between water and mountain, away from companions. English repeats and elaborates the invitation across its lines, retaining the cruel appearance of freedom. The additional bravery of the companions supplies characterization without altering the offered alternatives.
13–18Thinking against a contrary will
Moscow IV305:66 running text; IV305:67 running text | IV305:68 running text | IV306:71 running text; IV305:70–71 and IV306 n13 checked for separate oath clause, not present there | IV305:70 running text | IV305:70 running text; IV305 n13 continued IV306, actual two-couplet ruse/shattering addition | IV306:71 running text; IV305 n13 continued IV306, actual two-couplet ruse/shattering addition; Mohl III140:100 running text | III140:101 running text | III140:102 running text | III140:103 running text | III140:104 running text | III140:105 running text; Ganjoor sh1:66, sh1:67 indexed running poem body | sh1:68 indexed running poem body | sh1:71 indexed running poem body | sh1:70 indexed running poem body; Khaleghi III292:64 running text; III292 n15 actual self-address addition | III292:65 running text | ; III292 n17 actual contrary-action/divine-aid addition; no separate oath/ruse/shattering wording at checked65–67
Moscow printed p. 305 · Moscow printed p. 306 · Mohl printed p. 140 · Khaleghi printed p. 292 · Ganjoor sh1:66 · Ganjoor sh1:67 · Ganjoor sh1:68 · Ganjoor sh1:70 · Ganjoor sh1:71
English’s dark spell makes the uncanny situation explicit, but the source’s reversal in the demon’s grasp leads toward contrary conduct rather than merely enchanted air. Mohl’s world wording differs from the air or desire wording of the other running texts. His explicit disregard for oath and covenant supports English’s oath sentence; the other checked presentations supply contrary action without that clause. Mohl and actual Moscow additions also develop the shattering mountain fall and deliberate ruse. Khaleghi records contrary action below the line, while Ganjoor retains it continuously. English’s matched guile sharpens the intellectual contest. A separate source-only row preserves the positive internal preference for the sea in Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi; it must not be confused with the later negative spoken request.
19–23The drowning tale and the mountain’s claws
Moscow IV306:72 running text | IV306:73 running text | IV306:74 running text | IV306 n6 actual negative-sea/coffin couplet after74; distinguish positive internal sea preference IV305:69 | IV306:75 running text; Mohl III140:106 running text | III140:107 running text | III140:108 running text | III140:108–109 checked local gap for separate negative-sea request | III140:109 running text; Ganjoor sh1:72 indexed running poem body | sh1:73 indexed running poem body | sh1:74 indexed running poem body | sh1:74–75 checked local gap (negative request absent between74–75) | sh1:75 indexed running poem body; Khaleghi III292:67 running text | III292:68 running text | III293:69 running text | III293:69–70 checked gap for negative sea request | III293:70 running text
Moscow printed p. 306 · Moscow printed p. 305 · Mohl printed p. 140 · Khaleghi printed p. 292 · Khaleghi printed p. 293 · Ganjoor sh1:72 · Ganjoor sh1:73 · Ganjoor sh1:74 · Ganjoor sh1:75
All four presentations introduce the wise man of Chin and a story Rostam uses in his deception. Their next verse explicitly concerns a person who dies in water. English begins with an unexplained possessive and omits that condition, making the passage less immediately clear; the paradise gates and welcome further expand the image. The separate negative sea request has actual Moscow apparatus support, but is absent at the checked Mohl, Khaleghi and Ganjoor transitions. It remains distinct from the positive internal preference. The mountain line changes more sharply: the Persian asks that tiger and lion see the brave man’s claws. English instead lets lions tear dead flesh, reversing the agency and replacing a defiant self-image with anticipated bodily destruction.
24–28Akvan repeats the feared punishment
Moscow IV306:76 running text | IV306:77 running text | IV306:77–78 checked local gap for repeated doom in Akvan speech; actual n11 additions do not supply that couplet | IV306:78 running text | IV306:79 running text; IV307:80 running text; Mohl III140:110 running text | III140:111 running text | III140:112 running text | III140:113 running text | III140:114 running text; III141:115 running text; Ganjoor sh1:76 indexed running poem body | sh1:77 indexed running poem body | sh1:77–78 checked local gap | sh1:78 indexed running poem body | sh1:79, sh1:80 indexed running poem body; Khaleghi III293:71 running text | III293:72 running text | III293:72–73 checked gap for Akvan repeated doom | III293:73 running text | III293:74 running text; III293:75 running text
Moscow printed p. 306 · Moscow printed p. 307 · Mohl printed p. 140 · Mohl printed p. 141 · Khaleghi printed p. 293 · Ganjoor sh1:76 · Ganjoor sh1:77 · Ganjoor sh1:78 · Ganjoor sh1:79 · Ganjoor sh1:80
Akvan’s roar toward the sea and threat of concealment in both worlds are shared by all four presentations. English makes the destination more geographically absolute by saying that no living person can be there, although the source threat concerns disappearance from the two worlds. Mohl alone among the checked local sequences then repeats the miserable dwelling and barred passage in Akvan’s speech. English follows that repetition; the earlier similar words spoken by Rostam cannot independently verify the change of speaker elsewhere. The casting into deep water remains common. English supplies a cloud and states the contrary intention explicitly. Its arrival couplet compresses the drawn sword and routed nahang, preserving the unfamiliar creature name without requiring a modern zoological identification.
29–34Swimming, mortality and gratitude
Moscow IV307:81 running text | IV307:82 running text | IV307:83 running text | IV307:84 running text | IV307:85 running text; IV307:86 running text | IV307:86 running text; Mohl III141:116 running text | III141:117 running text | III141:118 running text | III141:119 running text | III141:120 running text; III141:121 running text | III141:121 running text; Ganjoor sh1:81 indexed running poem body | sh1:82 indexed running poem body | sh1:83 indexed running poem body | sh1:84 indexed running poem body | sh1:85, sh1:86 indexed running poem body | sh1:86 indexed running poem body; Khaleghi III293:76 running text | III293:77 running text | III293:78 running text | III293:79 running text | III293:80 running text; III293:81 running text | III293:81 running text
Moscow printed p. 307 · Mohl printed p. 141 · Khaleghi printed p. 293 · Ganjoor sh1:81 · Ganjoor sh1:82 · Ganjoor sh1:83 · Ganjoor sh1:84 · Ganjoor sh1:85 · Ganjoor sh1:86
The simultaneous swimming and defense are precise in all four sources: left hand and feet propel the hero while the other hand seeks a way through enemies. English reasonably identifies that other hand as the right. It then adds waves like walls, converting a general statement about the warrior’s refusal to delay into a visible obstacle. The mortality reflection is broader in Persian: if anyone could endure through valor, time would not remove his trace. English names Rostam and speaks of his name, bringing the meditation close to the hero but potentially shifting survival toward remembrance. The alternation of sweetness and poison survives as nourishment and poison. Landing and praise remain linked, with sovereign will making the Creator’s rescuing agency more explicit.
35–40Equipment, anger and the saddle’s reversal
Moscow IV307:87 running text | IV307:88 running text | IV307:89 running text | IV307:90 running text | IV307:91 running text | IV307 n15 actual world-reversal couplet after91; Mohl III141:122 running text | III141:123 running text | III141:124 running text | III141:125 running text | III141:126 running text | III141:127 running text; Ganjoor sh1:87 indexed running poem body | sh1:88 indexed running poem body | sh1:89 indexed running poem body | sh1:90 indexed running poem body | sh1:91 indexed running poem body | sh1:91–92 checked local gap; Khaleghi III293:82 running text | III293:83 running text | III293:84 running text | III293:85 running text | III294:86 running text | III294:86–87 checked gap for world-reversal maxim
Moscow printed p. 307 · Mohl printed p. 141 · Khaleghi printed p. 293 · Khaleghi printed p. 294 · Ganjoor sh1:87 · Ganjoor sh1:88 · Ganjoor sh1:89 · Ganjoor sh1:90 · Ganjoor sh1:91
The sources agree on resting, loosening the waist and placing the Babr-e Bayan beside the spring. English anticipates drying, which the following verse supplies for lasso and equipment. It then names the garment where the source speaks more generally of equipment and replaces putting on mail with arming. A more substantial change occurs at the return to the spring: the Persian describes Rostam’s anger at the demon, whereas English describes destruction sweeping the banks. The absent Rakhsh and recovered tack remain shared. Mohl and an actual Moscow addition then offer the rough-world maxim of alternately riding a saddle and carrying it. Khaleghi and Ganjoor lack that separate local verse. English’s unexplained turning year by year generalizes away its pointed physical reversal.
41–46Finding Rakhsh among the mares
Moscow IV307:92 running text | IV307:93 running text | IV307:94 running text; IV307:95 running text | IV307:95 running text | IV307:96 running text | IV307:97 running text; Mohl III141:128 running text | III141:129 running text | III141:130 running text; III141:131 running text | III141:131 running text | III141:132 running text | III141:133 running text; Ganjoor sh1:92 indexed running poem body | sh1:93 indexed running poem body | sh1:94, sh1:95 indexed running poem body | sh1:95 indexed running poem body | sh1:96 indexed running poem body | sh1:97 indexed running poem body; Khaleghi III294:87 running text | III294:88 running text | III294:89 running text; III294:90 running text | III294:90 running text | III294:91 running text | III294:92 running text
Moscow printed p. 307 · Mohl printed p. 141 · Khaleghi printed p. 294 · Ganjoor sh1:92 · Ganjoor sh1:93 · Ganjoor sh1:94 · Ganjoor sh1:95 · Ganjoor sh1:96 · Ganjoor sh1:97
The meadow, running waters and birds establish a different setting after the dangerous sea. All four sources include woodland and singing birds; English moves the birds into the air, exchanging sound for spatial description, while its later glade restores the wooded setting. The sleeping keeper belongs to Afrasiab’s horses, so the English royal designation has contextual support. Rakhsh’s demonlike energy amid the mares preserves a vivid comparison, although wrath supplies an explicit emotion. The royal lasso then catches his head. English’s drawing him close elaborates the successful capture rather than reporting a distinct source action. Brushing away dust and setting the saddle remain precise; blessing Yazdan’s name turns the source remembrance of divine beneficence into a more explicitly voiced thanksgiving.
47–52Driving the herd and waking its guardians
Moscow IV307:98 running text | IV308:99 running text | IV308:100 running text | IV308:101 running text | IV308:102 running text | IV308:103 running text; Mohl III141:134 running text | III141:135 running text | III141:136 running text | III141:137 running text | III141:138 running text | III141:139 running text; Ganjoor sh1:98 indexed running poem body | sh1:99 indexed running poem body | sh1:100 indexed running poem body | sh1:101 indexed running poem body | sh1:102 indexed running poem body | sh1:103 indexed running poem body; Khaleghi III294:93 running text | III294:94 running text | III294:95 running text | III294:96 running text | III294:97 running text | III294:98 running text
Moscow printed p. 307 · Moscow printed p. 308 · Mohl printed p. 141 · Khaleghi printed p. 294 · Ganjoor sh1:98 · Ganjoor sh1:99 · Ganjoor sh1:100 · Ganjoor sh1:101 · Ganjoor sh1:102 · Ganjoor sh1:103
Bridling, mounting and laying a hand on the sharp sword agree in all four presentations. English specifies the hilt and readiness to ride, then drives the royal herd onward under Yazdan’s name. The source also mentions the sword in that act, so English reduces its immediate prominence while retaining it in the preceding couplet. The keeper wakes startled at the horses’ noise and calls the accompanying riders. English’s head groom assigns a more precise hierarchy, and trembling adds bodily fear. Taking bows and lassos and questioning the intruder’s daring remain shared. Calling the act an invasion of the land broadens a local challenge over the meadow. Camped and armed similarly elaborate the riders’ presence without establishing a separate military encampment.
53–56The threat to flay and the answering name
Moscow IV308:104 running text | IV308:105 running text | IV308:106 running text | IV308:107 running text; Mohl III142:140 running text | III142:141 running text | III142:142 running text | III142:143 running text; Ganjoor sh1:104 indexed running poem body | sh1:105 indexed running poem body | sh1:106 indexed running poem body | sh1:107 indexed running poem body; Khaleghi III294:99 running text | III294:100 running text | III294:101 running text | III294:102 running text
Moscow printed p. 308 · Mohl printed p. 142 · Khaleghi printed p. 294 · Ganjoor sh1:104 · Ganjoor sh1:105 · Ganjoor sh1:106 · Ganjoor sh1:107
The pursuers’ desire to tear the hero’s skin is explicit across the checked texts, though the referent varies: Moscow and Ganjoor name Rostam, Mohl calls him that lion, and Khaleghi uses lions in the plural. English follows the explicit personal reference and intensifies the stripping. Its dust and riders’ thrust supply battle texture beyond the simple approach and drawn blade. The lionlike declaration of lineage remains intact; identifying Dastan as Zal clarifies the descent from Sahm, while the invitation to face him is additional. The killing formula gives two portions without a numerical denominator in this verse; English renders it as two-thirds. Its in-flight wording moves flight onto those killed, whereas the source follows the killing with the keeper turning away.
Source record and limits
C1.4 only:56 English couplets,112 unchanged published lines,10 notes. Moscow IV304–308:59–107 (49 running units), plus selected actual apparatus; Mohl III139–142:88–143 (56 running units; PDF145–148); Ganjoor akvan sh1:59–107 (49 indexed running units); Khaleghi III292–294:58–102 (45 running units; PDF308–310), plus selected actual apparatus. S1 preserves the unrendered positive internal sea-preference unit (Moscow/Ganjoor69,Khaleghi66). Every declared running unit individually accounted. Moscow and Mohl checked first, then Ganjoor and Khaleghi.
Edition scope and inspected pages
- Published English C1.4, captured12November2026
- Moscow: printed 304 / PDF 304, printed 305 / PDF 305, printed 306 / PDF 306, printed 307 / PDF 307, printed 308 / PDF 308
- Mohl: printed 139 / PDF 145, printed 140 / PDF 146, printed 141 / PDF 147, printed 142 / PDF 148
- Khaleghi: printed 292 / PDF 308, printed 293 / PDF 309, printed 294 / PDF 310
- Ganjoor sh1:59–107, indexed Persian body
Evidence classes and scope limits
Actual Moscow305 n2 six-verse lament collated individually against English4–9 and Mohl91–96. Actual Moscow305 n13 continuation on306 ruse/shattering couplets,306 n6 negative sea/coffin request,307 n15 saddle-reversal maxim inspected. Actual Khaleghi292 n6 sleep unit,n15 self-address,n17 contrary-action/divine-aid units inspected. Named local gaps checked independently; earlier similar speech does not verify later speaker-specific repetition. No appendix required. Other apparatus additions, including alternate lament forms and boundary pursuit verses after the slaughter, remain outside the declared selected scope and are not exhaustively collated. No unprinted notice or mere availability treated as verification.
All inherited flags retained verbatim. C1.4: wind transformation softened; fear foregrounded; longer lament verified in Moscow apparatus/Mohl running text but locally absent in Khaleghi/Ganjoor; fire supplied; oath follows Mohl; positive internal sea preference retained as S1; drowning antecedent omitted in English20; mountain claws reversed into lions eating flesh; Akvan repeated doom follows Mohl; cloud supplied; universal mortality narrowed to Rostam/name; drying equipment specified and mail generalized; anger at demon changed into destruction of banks; saddle-reversal maxim generalized; bird song visualized; groom hierarchy and invasion amplified; explicit Rostam follows Moscow/Ganjoor against lion wording; two-thirds interprets two portions; flight sequence and plural keepers expanded. Ganjoor59–99 retained from successful turn50view0 indexed body;100–107 checked against current indexed poem-body extract turn53search0/1, excluding AI gloss and reader comments. Full-page refresh turn52view0 failed404.
Selected inspected readings
- Moscow IV305 n2 actual lament, unit1: که دیو پلید
- Mohl III140:102, oath clause: نه سوگند داند نه پیمان کند
- Moscow IV305:69 / Khaleghi III292:66, positive inner preference: بدریا به آید که اندازدم
- Moscow IV306 n6, actual negative request: بدریا نباید که اندازیم
- Moscow IV306:75 / Khaleghi III293:70, heroic claws: ببینند چنگال مرد دلیر
- Mohl III141:127 / Moscow IV307 n15, reversal: گهی پشت زین و گهی زین پشت
- Moscow IV308:107 / Khaleghi III294:102, portion formula: دو بهره بکشت
Ganjoor display preserves its own text; where it lacks the expanded English passage, the Persian display is expressly labelled Mohl or actual Moscow apparatus. S1 is a positive inner preference, not the negative spoken request. Ganjoor59–99 derives from retained turn50view0 lines269–427;100–107 from current turn53search0/1 poem body before AI/comment sections.
C1.4 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | IV304:59 running text; IV304:60 running text | III139:88 running text |
| 2 | IV304:61 running text | III139:89 running text |
| 3 | IV305:62 running text | III140:90 running text |
| 4 | IV305 n2 actual six-couplet lament, units1–2 | III140:91 running text; III140:92 running text |
| 5 | IV305 n2 actual lament unit2 | III140:92 running text |
| 6 | IV305 n2 actual lament unit3 first hemistich | III140:93 running text |
| 7 | IV305 n2 actual lament unit3 second hemistich | III140:93 running text |
| 8 | IV305 n2 actual lament unit4 | III140:94 running text |
| 9 | IV305 n2 actual lament units5–6 | III140:95 running text; III140:96 running text |
| 10 | IV305:63 running text; IV305:64 running text | III140:97 running text; III140:98 running text |
| 11 | IV305:64 running text | III140:98 running text |
| 12 | IV305:65 running text | III140:99 running text |
| 13 | IV305:66 running text; IV305:67 running text | III140:100 running text |
| 14 | IV305:68 running text | III140:101 running text |
| 15 | IV306:71 running text; IV305:70–71 and IV306 n13 checked for separate oath clause, not present there | III140:102 running text |
| 16 | IV305:70 running text | III140:103 running text |
| 17 | IV305:70 running text; IV305 n13 continued IV306, actual two-couplet ruse/shattering addition | III140:104 running text |
| 18 | IV306:71 running text; IV305 n13 continued IV306, actual two-couplet ruse/shattering addition | III140:105 running text |
| 19 | IV306:72 running text | III140:106 running text |
| 20 | IV306:73 running text | III140:107 running text |
| 21 | IV306:74 running text | III140:108 running text |
| 22 | IV306 n6 actual negative-sea/coffin couplet after74; distinguish positive internal sea preference IV305:69 | III140:108–109 checked local gap for separate negative-sea request |
| 23 | IV306:75 running text | III140:109 running text |
| 24 | IV306:76 running text | III140:110 running text |
| 25 | IV306:77 running text | III140:111 running text |
| 26 | IV306:77–78 checked local gap for repeated doom in Akvan speech; actual n11 additions do not supply that couplet | III140:112 running text |
| 27 | IV306:78 running text | III140:113 running text |
| 28 | IV306:79 running text; IV307:80 running text | III140:114 running text; III141:115 running text |
| 29 | IV307:81 running text | III141:116 running text |
| 30 | IV307:82 running text | III141:117 running text |
| 31 | IV307:83 running text | III141:118 running text |
| 32 | IV307:84 running text | III141:119 running text |
| 33 | IV307:85 running text; IV307:86 running text | III141:120 running text; III141:121 running text |
| 34 | IV307:86 running text | III141:121 running text |
| 35 | IV307:87 running text | III141:122 running text |
| 36 | IV307:88 running text | III141:123 running text |
| 37 | IV307:89 running text | III141:124 running text |
| 38 | IV307:90 running text | III141:125 running text |
| 39 | IV307:91 running text | III141:126 running text |
| 40 | IV307 n15 actual world-reversal couplet after91 | III141:127 running text |
| 41 | IV307:92 running text | III141:128 running text |
| 42 | IV307:93 running text | III141:129 running text |
| 43 | IV307:94 running text; IV307:95 running text | III141:130 running text; III141:131 running text |
| 44 | IV307:95 running text | III141:131 running text |
| 45 | IV307:96 running text | III141:132 running text |
| 46 | IV307:97 running text | III141:133 running text |
| 47 | IV307:98 running text | III141:134 running text |
| 48 | IV308:99 running text | III141:135 running text |
| 49 | IV308:100 running text | III141:136 running text |
| 50 | IV308:101 running text | III141:137 running text |
| 51 | IV308:102 running text | III141:138 running text |
| 52 | IV308:103 running text | III141:139 running text |
| 53 | IV308:104 running text | III142:140 running text |
| 54 | IV308:105 running text | III142:141 running text |
| 55 | IV308:106 running text | III142:142 running text |
| 56 | IV308:107 running text | III142:143 running text |
New Naqqali