Gorgin Brings False Tidings of Bijan
C2.11 · Gorgin Brings False Tidings of Bijan.86 couplets, elapsed week through Giv’s final threat.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | C2.11 · Gorgin Brings False Tidings of Bijan.86 couplets, elapsed week through Giv’s final threat. |
| Moscow | Volume V printed34–39:439–524; PDF=printed. Selected actual apparatus variants/additions and order notes distinguished. |
| Mohl | Volume III printed167–170:480–566; PDF173–176. Two fuller homeward-anxiety verses; withheld-news, counselor, dragon and Simorgh-wing readings in running text. |
| Ganjoor | Indexed poem body bizhan sh5:1–86. Next unit87 begins Giv’s arrival before Shah and is excluded. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | Volume III printed335–341:409–494; PDF351–357. Speech introduction and burning-concern verse differently positioned; selected actual apparatus checked. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5Repentance in an emptied landscape
Individual four-source verse accounts for English 1–5. V34:439 running text; V34:440 running text; V34:441 running text; V34:442 running text; V34 n16 actual search-for-companion alternative; V34:443 running text
Moscow printed p.34 · Mohl printed p.167 · Khaleghi printed p.335 · Khaleghi printed p.336 · Ganjoor sh5:1 · Ganjoor sh5:2 · Ganjoor sh5:3 · Ganjoor sh5:4 · Ganjoor sh5:5
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi open with the elapsed week, fruitless searching and remorse for the evil done to a companion. English makes fear the immediate emotional cause and turns Bijan’s failure to return into the wider statement that none returned. The blood-tear image remains, while heat and ceaseless activity intensify it. The return to the scene differs slightly: Moscow and Ganjoor name the festive place of disappearance, Khaleghi the place, and Mohl describes seeking the companion in the meadow. English follows the disappearance connection but adds fading daylight. The empty forest and absence of bird calls are shared. These details make the guilty search desolate without establishing a new supernatural event outside Gorgin’s later fabricated account.
6–10The riderless horse and an inference of death
Individual four-source verse accounts for English 6–10. V34:444 running text; V34:445 running text; V34 n22 actual جویباری / جویباران variants; V34:446 running text; V34 n25 actual foam/lip wording beside main forlorn horse; V34:445 running text; V34:447 running text; V34:447 running text; V34:448 running text
Moscow printed p.34 · Mohl printed p.167 · Khaleghi printed p.336 · Ganjoor sh5:6 · Ganjoor sh5:7 · Ganjoor sh5:8 · Ganjoor sh5:9 · Ganjoor sh5:10
The search and sudden sighting are compressed into one English couplet. Moscow and Ganjoor’s main text places the horse in a meadow, while Mohl, Khaleghi and actual Moscow variants support the waterside detail. Likewise, the foaming mouth follows Mohl and Khaleghi and a printed Moscow alternative rather than the forlorn immobility of Moscow and Ganjoor’s main verse. English can therefore combine visible distress with a variant physical description. The broken bridle and overturned saddle are stable signs of disaster. Gorgin then infers that Bijan will not return and that Afrasiab has harmed him, whether by gallows or imprisonment. English makes that inference spoken and more conclusively fatal through the farther strand of death. The checked Persian does not yet supply certain knowledge of death.
11–15Returning with the horse and withholding news
Individual four-source verse accounts for English 11–15. V35:449 running text; V35:450 running text; V35:451 running text; V35 n3 actual homeward self-talk addition; n7 actual worry about facing Shah; n6 actual خفتن variant; V35:452 running text; V35:453 running text
Moscow printed p.35 · Mohl printed p.167 · Mohl printed p.168 · Khaleghi printed p.336 · Ganjoor sh5:11 · Ganjoor sh5:12 · Ganjoor sh5:13 · Ganjoor sh5:14 · Ganjoor sh5:15
All four preserve catching the horse, a day in the tent and a troubled return toward Iran. Khaleghi’s sleepless wording supports English unrest, while Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor’s main text stresses inability to rest or eat. Fuller Mohl verses and actual Moscow apparatus give self-talk and fear of facing the Shah; Khaleghi prints the latter in apparatus. English redirects that anxiety toward Giv’s blame. More consequentially, Mohl says the Shah did not tell Giv, whereas Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi say he did. English follows Mohl in withholding news, so it is not simply an invented secret. Questioning alone adds a degree of privacy beyond the checked wording. Royal anger is also English characterization at this point, rather than an independently stated reaction.
16–20Grief takes the warrior to his horse
Individual four-source verse accounts for English 16–20. V35:454 running text; V35:455 running text; V35:455 running text; V35:456 running text; V35:456 running text; V35:457 running text; V35:458 running text; V35 n16 actual پلنگ saddle variant; n17 actual نهنگ vengeance variant
Moscow printed p.35 · Mohl printed p.168 · Khaleghi printed p.336 · Khaleghi printed p.337 · Ganjoor sh5:16 · Ganjoor sh5:17 · Ganjoor sh5:18 · Ganjoor sh5:19 · Ganjoor sh5:20
News reaches Giv and drives him from his house into the street in all four presentations. English spreads the wounded heart, tears and question about Irman across successive couplets, preserving the abrupt movement from uncertainty to action. The name Keshvad’s bay and its readiness for an emergency remain concrete markers of the warrior household. Two neighboring animal images require separate treatment. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi give leopard-like vengeance and a khadang saddle; Mohl gives a leopard saddle and nahang vengeance. Actual Moscow and Khaleghi apparatus preserves relevant alternatives. English follows the former configuration, rather than mistranslating Mohl’s saddle. Its rearrangement puts vengeance beside the summons for the horse and leaves the day-of-need explanation with the saddling. The overlapping register references record this redistribution explicitly.
21–25Suspicion before the meeting
Individual four-source verse accounts for English 21–25. V35:459 running text; V35:460 running text; V35:461 running text; V35:461 main همی گفت; Mohl III168:503 / Khaleghi III337:431 main به دل گفت; V35:462 running text; V35:463 running text
Moscow printed p.35 · Moscow printed p.168 · Moscow printed p.337 · Mohl printed p.168 · Khaleghi printed p.337 · Ganjoor sh5:21 · Ganjoor sh5:22 · Ganjoor sh5:23 · Ganjoor sh5:24 · Ganjoor sh5:25
Immediate mounting and windlike movement are shared by Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi, as is Giv’s purpose of questioning Gorgin. English turns the suspicion into private thought, following the explicit inward speech of Mohl and Khaleghi rather than the less specifically marked speech in Moscow and Ganjoor. Its declaration that one thing is plain strengthens a suspicion expressed with a qualifying word in the Persian. The next threat is conditional: if Gorgin is encountered without Bijan, Giv will take off his head. English reshapes this as an either-or resolution to see his son or kill Gorgin. That preserves the violent pressure while making it sound more like a chosen course. Gorgin’s dismounting and running forward are verified; fear is the English explanation of the gesture.
26–30Submission and the rhetoric of shame
Individual four-source verse accounts for English 26–30. V35:464 running text; V35:465 running text; V35 n22 actual Iranian/chief/guardian alternatives; V36:466 running text; V36:467 running text; V36:468 running text; V36 n5 actual face-washing/bloody-tear variant
Moscow printed p.35 · Moscow printed p.36 · Mohl printed p.168 · Khaleghi printed p.337 · Ganjoor sh5:26 · Ganjoor sh5:27 · Ganjoor sh5:28 · Ganjoor sh5:29 · Ganjoor sh5:30
The four sources share Gorgin’s dust-covered abasement, torn cheeks and bare head. English adds pallor, then moves into honorific speech. The Iranian designation has Mohl support and printed alternatives in Moscow and Khaleghi; it is not dependent on Ganjoor’s solar court image alone. The question about Giv’s blood-filled eyes keeps the outward signs of distress. Gorgin’s rejection of sweet life concerns further degradation, which English turns into successive blows of woe. That makes pain more prominent than dishonor. The tears that follow are warm water in Moscow and Ganjoor’s main wording, with face-washing and bloody-tear alternatives actually printed; Mohl and Khaleghi also use the bloody-tear expression. English heightens this to pouring blood, sustaining the emotional register while preserving the speaker’s shame.
31–35Reassurance collapses before the evidence
Individual four-source verse accounts for English 31–35. V36:469 running text; V36:470 running text; V36:471 running text; V36:472 running text; V36:473 running text
Moscow printed p.36 · Mohl printed p.168 · Khaleghi printed p.337 · Ganjoor sh5:31 · Ganjoor sh5:32 · Ganjoor sh5:33 · Ganjoor sh5:34 · Ganjoor sh5:35
All four make Gorgin assert that Bijan’s life is unharmed and promise an explanatory sign or account. English adds a pledge that truth will guide him, sharpening the irony of the coming lie. The horse and dust-covered agitation then precede Giv’s collapse. English assigns that agitation expressly to Gorgin; the compressed Persian permits the description to be heard with Giv’s reaction as well. Falling from the horse and losing consciousness support the collapse, but silence is added. The Pahlavi garment, hair tearing and dust are concrete mourning actions in all four. One directional change matters: the Persian pours dust upon the head, whereas English says from his wounded head. The wound is inferred, the beard disappears, and the dust action is altered rather than merely compressed.
36–40A father’s prayer and the dragon image
Individual four-source verse accounts for English 36–40. V36:474 running text; V36:475 running text; V36:476 running text; V36:477 running text; V36 n18 actual son/companion/pure-counselor whole-couplet alternative; V36:478 running text; V36 n20 actual dragon-jaws half-line
Moscow printed p.36 · Mohl printed p.168 · Mohl printed p.169 · Khaleghi printed p.337 · Khaleghi printed p.338 · Ganjoor sh5:36 · Ganjoor sh5:37 · Ganjoor sh5:38 · Ganjoor sh5:39 · Ganjoor sh5:40
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi address the heavenly maker and connect grief with the love implanted in Giv’s heart. English omits the paired understanding or wisdom and makes acceptance of a broken life-bond a direct plea. Spirit too and bear both away extend a source sequence in which the bond breaks and the spirit reaches the good people’s abode. The pure counselor description follows Mohl and an actual Moscow whole-couplet alternative; Ganjoor and Khaleghi’s main text instead emphasizes consolation and help. From birth is added. The dragon is likewise supported by Mohl and Moscow’s actual variant against worldly affliction in the other main texts. English moves the father from the dragon’s jaws to a dragon gnawing his heart, internalizing an attested image rather than inventing its creature.
41–45Questions become a search for an agent
Individual four-source verse accounts for English 41–45. V36:479 running text; V36:480 running text; V36:480 running text; V36:481 running text; V36:481 running text; V36:482 running text; V36:482 running text; V36:483 running text; V36:483 running text; V36:484 running text
Moscow printed p.36 · Mohl printed p.169 · Khaleghi printed p.338 · Ganjoor sh5:41 · Ganjoor sh5:42 · Ganjoor sh5:43 · Ganjoor sh5:44 · Ganjoor sh5:45 · Ganjoor sh5:46
All four ask for the original sequence, what fate has done, whether Bijan disappeared from sight, what evils befell him and what Div encountered him in the meadow. English reorganizes those questions across couplet boundaries and repeatedly asks who caused the damage. By his own choice gives disappearance a voluntary motive absent from the checked wording, while raising a Div from the ground replaces the named meadow setting. Murder and ruined joy make Giv’s assumption of catastrophe more personal and final. The riderless horse remains a demand for explanation, not corroboration of Gorgin’s later story. Gorgin’s appeal for recovered senses begins in the last English line and is repeated in the following couplet. That is reuse of one response, not two independently attested interventions.
46–50Preparing a persuasive account
Individual four-source verse accounts for English 46–50. V36:484 running text; V37:485 running text; V37:486 running text; V37:487 running text; V37:488 running text
Moscow printed p.36 · Moscow printed p.37 · Mohl printed p.169 · Khaleghi printed p.338 · Ganjoor sh5:46 · Ganjoor sh5:47 · Ganjoor sh5:48 · Ganjoor sh5:49 · Ganjoor sh5:50
Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor place the promise to describe the boar-fight before the formal address to the Pahlevan; Khaleghi places the address first and records the alternative order. English follows the first sequence. Recovering the senses and opening the ears are shared, while casting off doubt adds a request especially convenient to the deceptive speaker. The journey toward Irman and the damaged woodland give the account recognizable substance. English supplies a wooded crest and renders the flattened or opened wood, cut trees and low pasture as ruin, trampling and defacement. These choices stress devastation but do not reproduce every physical detail. The note treats the episode as Gorgin’s reported version: the collective first-person claims here belong to his rhetoric, not a fresh narrator’s certification of his conduct.
51–55The collective boast of the boar-fight
Individual four-source verse accounts for English 51–55. V37:489 running text; V37:490 running text; V37:491 running text; V37:491 running text; V37:492 running text; V37:493 running text
Moscow printed p.37 · Mohl printed p.169 · Khaleghi printed p.339 · Ganjoor sh5:51 · Ganjoor sh5:52 · Ganjoor sh5:53 · Ganjoor sh5:54 · Ganjoor sh5:55
All four continue the account with a boar-infested wood, distress in Irman, raised spears, shouting and mountainlike animals appearing in groups. English expands the city’s suffering into all Irman and lets the forest shake under the noise. The movement from singular mountain comparison to herd-by-herd attack spreads one source unit across two English couplets. A more substantive change comes at the battle’s end. The Persian says the day passed without the heart becoming satiated with combat; English says victory and work were completed and no rest taken before completion. It replaces continued appetite for fighting with finished purpose. Elephantlike overthrow and tusk removal are supported, although piling the bodies and dropping the nail or peg image reshape the action. The shared boast remains Gorgin’s claim.
56–60An impossible animal assembled from familiar likenesses
Individual four-source verse accounts for English 56–60. V37:494 running text; V37:495 running text; V37:496 running text; V37:497 running text; V37 n18 actual Simorgh wing/stature variants; V37:498 running text
Moscow printed p.37 · Mohl printed p.169 · Khaleghi printed p.339 · Ganjoor sh5:56 · Ganjoor sh5:57 · Ganjoor sh5:58 · Ganjoor sh5:59 · Ganjoor sh5:60
The cheerful homeward hunt and onager of exceptional beauty occur in all four. Its likenesses to Gudarz’s Golgun and Farhad’s Shabahang make Gorgin’s invention recognizable to a warrior audience. The Simorgh wing is not supported by Ganjoor’s silver feet, but is printed in Mohl and actual Moscow variants. Khaleghi’s main text also has silver-foot wording; its local apparatus records alternative wing diction without independently establishing the whole Mohl phrase. English selects the more fantastic primary reading, retains the steel hoof and Shabrang comparison, and omits ears from the inventory. The following lion neck and Rakhsh ancestry agree, but speed is wind in all four, not fire. Calling Rakhsh the sire narrows a general lineage comparison to direct fatherhood. These details characterize a fabricated marvel, not an observed zoological form.
61–65The chase disappears into dust
Individual four-source verse accounts for English 61–65. V37:499 running text; V37 n19 actual بلند variant; V37:500 running text; V37:501 running text; V37:502 running text; V37:502 running text; V38:503 running text
Moscow printed p.37 · Moscow printed p.38 · Mohl printed p.169 · Mohl printed p.170 · Khaleghi printed p.339 · Ganjoor sh5:61 · Ganjoor sh5:62 · Ganjoor sh5:63 · Ganjoor sh5:64 · Ganjoor sh5:65
Mohl and Khaleghi describe the onager through a tall elephant comparison, also printed as an actual Moscow variant; Moscow and Ganjoor’s main epithet is different. English follows the height reading and strengthens the kamand with tight. The simultaneity of casting and going is shared across all four, but break-away interprets departure without establishing that the rope broke. Dust rises from pursuit and the earth swells like a sea before rider and quarry vanish. English redistributes those images, makes the dust swallow them and lets the cloud continue onward. That supplies a visible mechanism beyond the compact disappearance. The exhausted mount and search through plain and hill retain Gorgin’s effort to present himself as a devoted companion, while the valley and roar are additional scene detail.
66–70The alleged White Div and the listening father
Individual four-source verse accounts for English 66–70. V38:504 running text; V38:505 running text; V38:506 running text; V38:507 running text; V38:508 running text
Moscow printed p.38 · Mohl printed p.170 · Khaleghi printed p.339 · Khaleghi printed p.340 · Ganjoor sh5:66 · Ganjoor sh5:67 · Ganjoor sh5:68 · Ganjoor sh5:69 · Ganjoor sh5:70
The horse and saddle are the remaining trace in all four, and Gorgin claims an exhaustive search. His burning concern is placed before lingering and return in Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor but after the White Div claim in Khaleghi; the actual apparatus records alternative positions. English follows the first order. The question about Bijan’s combat becomes fear that he could not withstand the beast’s blow, an interpretation of the source’s compressed concern. The White Div identification is shared, but the English disguise seen before his eyes implies a visual experience more explicit than the Persian assertion. It should not be treated as a witnessed transformation. Giv’s recognition of ruined prospects then interrupts the account. English adds the cost of falsehood, anticipating the judgment developed in the following verses.
71–75Reading guilt and feeling murderous anger
Individual four-source verse accounts for English 71–75. V38:509 running text; V38 n8 actual جهان پیش چشم اندر variant beside main darkened gaze wording; V38:510 running text; V38:511 running text; V38:512 running text; V38:513 running text
Moscow printed p.38 · Mohl printed p.170 · Khaleghi printed p.340 · Ganjoor sh5:71 · Ganjoor sh5:72 · Ganjoor sh5:73 · Ganjoor sh5:74 · Ganjoor sh5:75
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi expose the account as confused or false and connect Gorgin with pallor, trembling and guilt. English turns the darkened-eye wording into avoided eye contact. That is a plausible psychological staging, but the main syntax can also describe Giv’s sight darkening at the encounter; actual variants mentioning the world before the eye reinforce the need for caution. Mohl has bodily trembling where the others emphasize speech. Giv’s lost son and tainted story then invite Ahriman’s impulse toward violence. The vengeance verse has another meaningful contrast: Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor’s main text speaks of good or favorable consequence, while Khaleghi prints shame and records alternatives. English specifies possible good from Gorgin, making utility more explicit before Giv’s reflection interrupts the impulse.
76–80Deliberation postpones vengeance
Individual four-source verse accounts for English 76–80. V38:514 running text; V38:515 running text; V38:516 running text; V38:518 running text; V38 n20 explicitly records517/518 reversed order; actual Mohl III170:559–560 checked; V38:517 running text; V38 n20 explicitly records517/518 reversed order; actual Mohl III170:559–560 checked
Moscow printed p.38 · Moscow printed p.170 · Mohl printed p.170 · Khaleghi printed p.340 · Ganjoor sh5:76 · Ganjoor sh5:77 · Ganjoor sh5:78 · Ganjoor sh5:79 · Ganjoor sh5:80
All four preserve the pause, lack of illumination and recognition that killing would fulfill Ahriman’s desire. The question about benefit to Bijan from Gorgin’s life belongs within that deliberation over taking a life; it should not be isolated as an argument that keeping him alive is useless. English’s other cure than strife makes the practical turn plain. The order then differs. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi’s main texts put waiting for the Shah before the claim that vengeance is easy. Mohl reverses those verses, and actual Moscow and Khaleghi apparatus records alternate arrangements. English follows Mohl, allowing the easy-vengeance statement to lead into a closing decision to wait. The spear and wall image survives as an assertion that postponement comes from choice, not inability.
81–86A threat redirected toward the speaker’s unrest
Individual four-source verse accounts for English 81–86. V38:519 running text; V38:520 running text; V39:521 running text; V39:522 running text; V39 n3 actual بیابم variant beside main یابی; V39:523 running text; V39:524 running text
Moscow printed p.38 · Moscow printed p.39 · Mohl printed p.170 · Khaleghi printed p.340 · Khaleghi printed p.341 · Ganjoor sh5:81 · Ganjoor sh5:82 · Ganjoor sh5:83 · Ganjoor sh5:84 · Ganjoor sh5:85 · Ganjoor sh5:86
The closing accusations are shared across all four: Gorgin has taken the father’s sun and moon, forced restless wandering and must answer before the Shah. English adds hope and spring to the lost son’s value. A significant pronoun choice follows. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi’s main text asks where you will find rest, threatening Gorgin. Mohl and actual Moscow and Khaleghi variants use the first person, which English follows in lamenting Giv’s own unrest. The loss of Gorgin’s latitude is tied to Giv seeing the king; the English combination of no power now and till makes that temporal threat less straightforward. Final vengeance is retained. Khaleghi’s main text specifies a dagger, with a printed alternative matching the other texts; English preserves the broader threat without naming the weapon.
Source record and limits
C2.11 only:86 English couplets/172 unchanged lines;17 substantive notes. Moscow V34–39:439–524; Mohl III167–170:480–566 (PDF173–176); Ganjoor bizhan sh5:1–86; Khaleghi III335–341:409–494 (PDF351–357). Three selected source-only rows. Every declared running unit accounted, with overlap and reorderings labeled. Moscow and Mohl checked individually first, then Ganjoor and Khaleghi.
Coverage is individual source accounting, not universal literal agreement. Mohl483 compresses search and differs from the disappearance wording; separate Moscow444 has a checked Mohl local gap. English15 follows Mohl withholding news;39–40 follow counselor/dragon variants;59 follows Mohl/Moscow Simorgh wing. English79–80 follows Mohl order;84 follows first-person variants. English35 reverses dust direction;54 changes unsated fighting to completed work;60 substitutes fire for wind. Other added or interpretive details are marked individually. No appendix evidence invoked; selected apparatus is not an exhaustive survey. Persian selections normalize spacing, not diplomatic transcription. All inherited flags unchanged.
All172 lines in retained12 November raw HTML compared with current indexed publication (turn60view2,turn61view0,turn62view1). Index turn61view1. C2.12 Giv Brings Gorgin before Khosrow begins immediately after the final threat and is excluded. Retained raw capture is not described as a fresh HTTP download.
- Moscow: printed 34 / PDF 34 · printed 35 / PDF 35 · printed 36 / PDF 36 · printed 37 / PDF 37 · printed 38 / PDF 38 · printed 39 / PDF 39. Existing PDFs reused; PNG facsimiles visually read. No scans included.
- Mohl: printed 167 / PDF 173 · printed 168 / PDF 174 · printed 169 / PDF 175 · printed 170 / PDF 176. Existing PDFs reused; PNG facsimiles visually read. No scans included.
- Khaleghi: printed 335 / PDF 351 · printed 336 / PDF 352 · printed 337 / PDF 353 · printed 338 / PDF 354 · printed 339 / PDF 355 · printed 340 / PDF 356 · printed 341 / PDF 357. Existing PDFs reused; PNG facsimiles visually read. No scans included.
- Ganjoor sh5 indexed poem body1–86 read (turn62view0); next unit87 confirms boundary. Search excerpt was discontinuous and was not used as the verse sequence. Comments, transliteration and automated explanations excluded.
No appendix evidence invoked for C2.11. Actual Moscow V34nn16,22,25;35nn3,6,7,16,17,22;36nn5,18,20;37nn18,19;38nn8,20;39nn2,3 and actual Khaleghi III336nn9,18,20;337nn4,17,21;338nn4–6,17;339nn16,27;340nn4,10,18,23;341nn7,11 checked. Printed additions/variants and order notices distinguished; notices are supported by inspected running texts where order is discussed.
Running text is distinguished from actual printed apparatus and from checked local gaps. Mohl’s negated news report is actual running text, not a conjecture. Moscow’s dragon and Simorgh evidence is printed apparatus, while Mohl prints those readings continuously. Khaleghi339n16 records local alternative wing diction but is not claimed to print the complete Mohl Simorgh phrase. No technical/historical reconstruction is inferred from the fabulous animal. Gorgin’s claims of shared fighting and a White Div remain character speech.
- S1: Gorgin turns homeward speaking to himself; English13 compresses return and anxiety, without a separate self-talk action. Moscow: V35 n3 actual added self-talk verse after450. Mohl: III167:491 running text. Ganjoor: Checked local gap sh5:12–13; neighbor is not support. Khaleghi: III336:420–421 and adjacent apparatus checked local gap for this distinct homeward self-talk
- S2: Explicit anxiety about facing Shah; English13 substitutes dread of Giv’s blame. Moscow: V35 n7 actual added worry verse after451. Mohl: III167:493 running text. Ganjoor: Checked local gap sh5:13–14; neighbor is not support. Khaleghi: III336 n18 actual first added verse after421
- S3: Extra charge of practiced lying and seeking to rob Giv of his head; English condemns deceit without this separate accusation. Moscow: V39 n2 actual added accusation after521. Mohl: III170:563–564 checked local gap. Ganjoor: Checked local gap sh5:83–84; neighbor is not support. Khaleghi: III341:491–492 and n4 checked local gap
Source overlaps include English6/8,8/9,16–18,19–20,41–46,52–53 and63–64. Khaleghi reverses the introductory address/question and relocates burning concern after the return claim. English79/80 follows Mohl’s reversal of Moscow517/518. No source units are invented to equal the English count. Local apparatus gaps are bounded claims, not whole-edition absence. Published English remains verbatim.
- Moscow V34:445–446 / nn22,25; Mohl III167:485–486; Khaleghi III336:415–416; Ganjoor7–8: جویباران / مرغزاران؛ فروبرده لفج و برآورده کف
- Moscow V35:453 / Ganjoor15 / Khaleghi III336:423 versus Mohl III168:495: بگفت / نگفت
- Moscow V35:458 and nn16–17; Mohl III168:500; Khaleghi III337:428 and n4; Ganjoor20: زین خدنگ / زین پلنگ؛ کین پلنگ / کین نهنگ
- Moscow V36:473 / Mohl III168:515 / Ganjoor35 / Khaleghi III337:443: خروشان بسر بر همی ریخت خاک
- Mohl III169:519 / actual Moscow V36n18; Khaleghi447/Ganjoor39 main differ: همم پور و هم پاک دستور بود
- Mohl III169:520 / actual Moscow V36n20; Khaleghi448/Ganjoor40 main differ: چنین ماندم اندر دم اژدها
- Moscow V37:485–486 / Mohl III169:527–528 / Ganjoor47–48; Khaleghi III338:455–456 reversed: بدان پهلوانا و آگاه باش / همیشه فروزنده گاه باش
- Moscow V37:492 / Mohl III169:534 / Ganjoor54 / Khaleghi III339:462: بشد روز و نامد دل از جنگ سیر
- Mohl III169:539 / actual Moscow V37n18 versus Moscow497/Ganjoor59/Khaleghi467 main: چو سیمرغ بال و چو پولاد سم / چو سیمش دو پا و چو پولاد سم
- All four: Moscow V37:498 / Mohl III169:540 / Ganjoor60 / Khaleghi III339:468: بگردن چو شیر و برفتن چو باد
- Moscow V38:505 / Mohl III170:547 / Ganjoor67; relocated Khaleghi III340:477: دلم شد پر آتش ز تیمار اوی
- Khaleghi III340:483 and n18 versus Moscow V38:513 / Mohl III170:555 / Ganjoor75: ننگ / نیک
- Mohl III170:559–560 versus Moscow V38:517–518 / Ganjoor79–80 / Khaleghi III340:487–488: Easy vengeance before waiting for Shah in Mohl; reverse in other main texts
- Mohl III170:564 / actual Moscow V39n3 and Khaleghi III341n7 versus other main texts: بیابم / یابی
C2.11 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V34:439 running text | III167:480 running text |
| 2 | V34:440 running text | III167:481 running text |
| 3 | V34:441 running text | III167:482 running text |
| 4 | V34:442 running text; V34 n16 actual search-for-companion alternative | III167:483 running text |
| 5 | V34:443 running text | III167:484 running text |
| 6 | V34:444 running text; V34:445 running text; V34 n22 actual جویباری / جویباران variants | III167:485 running text; III167:483 partial search counterpart; no separate unit between484–485 for Moscow444 |
| 7 | V34:446 running text; V34 n25 actual foam/lip wording beside main forlorn horse | III167:486 running text |
| 8 | V34:445 running text; V34:447 running text | III167:485 running text; III167:487 running text |
| 9 | V34:447 running text | III167:487 running text |
| 10 | V34:448 running text | III167:488 running text |
| 11 | V35:449 running text | III167:489 running text |
| 12 | V35:450 running text | III167:490 running text |
| 13 | V35:451 running text; V35 n3 actual homeward self-talk addition; n7 actual worry about facing Shah; n6 actual خفتن variant | III167:492 running text; III167:491 and493 fuller self-talk/worry, separately accounted S1/S2 |
| 14 | V35:452 running text | III168:494 running text |
| 15 | V35:453 running text | III168:495 running text; III168:495 prints نگفت, withholding news from Giv |
| 16 | V35:454 running text; V35:455 running text | III168:496 running text; III168:497 running text |
| 17 | V35:455 running text; V35:456 running text | III168:497 running text; III168:498 running text |
| 18 | V35:456 running text | III168:498 running text |
| 19 | V35:457 running text; V35:458 running text; V35 n16 actual پلنگ saddle variant; n17 actual نهنگ vengeance variant | III168:499 running text; III168:500 running text |
| 20 | V35:457 running text; V35:458 running text; V35 n16 actual پلنگ saddle variant; n17 actual نهنگ vengeance variant | III168:499 running text; III168:500 running text |
| 21 | V35:459 running text | III168:501 running text |
| 22 | V35:460 running text | III168:502 running text |
| 23 | V35:461 running text; V35:461 main همی گفت; Mohl III168:503 / Khaleghi III337:431 main به دل گفت | III168:503 running text |
| 24 | V35:462 running text | III168:504 running text |
| 25 | V35:463 running text | III168:505 running text |
| 26 | V35:464 running text | III168:506 running text |
| 27 | V35:465 running text; V35 n22 actual Iranian/chief/guardian alternatives | III168:507 running text |
| 28 | V36:466 running text | III168:508 running text |
| 29 | V36:467 running text | III168:509 running text |
| 30 | V36:468 running text; V36 n5 actual face-washing/bloody-tear variant | III168:510 running text |
| 31 | V36:469 running text | III168:511 running text |
| 32 | V36:470 running text | III168:512 running text |
| 33 | V36:471 running text | III168:513 running text |
| 34 | V36:472 running text | III168:514 running text |
| 35 | V36:473 running text | III168:515 running text |
| 36 | V36:474 running text | III168:516 running text |
| 37 | V36:475 running text | III168:517 running text |
| 38 | V36:476 running text | III168:518 running text |
| 39 | V36:477 running text; V36 n18 actual son/companion/pure-counselor whole-couplet alternative | III169:519 running text |
| 40 | V36:478 running text; V36 n20 actual dragon-jaws half-line | III169:520 running text |
| 41 | V36:479 running text; V36:480 running text | III169:521 running text; III169:522 running text |
| 42 | V36:480 running text; V36:481 running text | III169:522 running text; III169:523 running text |
| 43 | V36:481 running text; V36:482 running text | III169:523 running text; III169:524 running text |
| 44 | V36:482 running text; V36:483 running text | III169:524 running text; III169:525 running text |
| 45 | V36:483 running text; V36:484 running text | III169:525 running text; III169:526 running text |
| 46 | V36:484 running text | III169:526 running text |
| 47 | V37:485 running text | III169:527 running text |
| 48 | V37:486 running text | III169:528 running text |
| 49 | V37:487 running text | III169:529 running text |
| 50 | V37:488 running text | III169:530 running text |
| 51 | V37:489 running text | III169:531 running text |
| 52 | V37:490 running text; V37:491 running text | III169:532 running text; III169:533 running text |
| 53 | V37:491 running text | III169:533 running text |
| 54 | V37:492 running text | III169:534 running text |
| 55 | V37:493 running text | III169:535 running text |
| 56 | V37:494 running text | III169:536 running text |
| 57 | V37:495 running text | III169:537 running text |
| 58 | V37:496 running text | III169:538 running text |
| 59 | V37:497 running text; V37 n18 actual Simorgh wing/stature variants | III169:539 running text |
| 60 | V37:498 running text | III169:540 running text |
| 61 | V37:499 running text; V37 n19 actual بلند variant | III169:541 running text |
| 62 | V37:500 running text | III169:542 running text |
| 63 | V37:501 running text; V37:502 running text | III169:543 running text; III170:544 running text |
| 64 | V37:502 running text | III170:544 running text |
| 65 | V38:503 running text | III170:545 running text |
| 66 | V38:504 running text | III170:546 running text |
| 67 | V38:505 running text | III170:547 running text |
| 68 | V38:506 running text | III170:548 running text |
| 69 | V38:507 running text | III170:549 running text |
| 70 | V38:508 running text | III170:550 running text |
| 71 | V38:509 running text; V38 n8 actual جهان پیش چشم اندر variant beside main darkened gaze wording | III170:551 running text |
| 72 | V38:510 running text | III170:552 running text |
| 73 | V38:511 running text | III170:553 running text |
| 74 | V38:512 running text | III170:554 running text |
| 75 | V38:513 running text | III170:555 running text |
| 76 | V38:514 running text | III170:556 running text |
| 77 | V38:515 running text | III170:557 running text |
| 78 | V38:516 running text | III170:558 running text |
| 79 | V38:518 running text; V38 n20 explicitly records517/518 reversed order; actual Mohl III170:559–560 checked | III170:560 running text |
| 80 | V38:517 running text; V38 n20 explicitly records517/518 reversed order; actual Mohl III170:559–560 checked | III170:559 running text |
| 81 | V38:519 running text | III170:561 running text |
| 82 | V38:520 running text | III170:562 running text |
| 83 | V39:521 running text | III170:563 running text |
| 84 | V39:522 running text; V39 n3 actual بیابم variant beside main یابی | III170:564 running text |
| 85 | V39:523 running text | III170:565 running text |
| 86 | V39:524 running text | III170:566 running text |
New Naqqali