The Cup Reveals Bijan
C2.13 · The Cup Reveals Bijan. 31 couplets, Nowruz consultation through promise to summon Rostam.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | C2.13 · The Cup Reveals Bijan. 31 couplets, Nowruz consultation through promise to summon Rostam. |
| Moscow | Volume V printed42–44:588–618; PDF=printed. Separate cup-setting verse in main; celestial/royal-name variants and final promise in actual apparatus. |
| Mohl | Volume III printed173–174:629–659; PDF179–180. Jupiter, Khosrow-name and closing promise in running text; no separate cup-setting verse. |
| Ganjoor | Indexed poem body bizhan sh5:150–180; section ends with secret letter instruction. No final promise before sh6:1. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | Volume III printed345–347:555–585; PDF361–363. Jupiter and Manijeh named in main; royal-name and final-promise alternatives in actual apparatus. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–4Hope resumes at the appointed season
Individual four-source accounts for English 1–4. V42:588 running text; V42:589 running text; V42:590 running text; V42:591 running text
Moscow printed p.42 · Mohl printed p.173 · Khaleghi printed p.345 · Ganjoor sh5:150 · Ganjoor sh5:151 · Ganjoor sh5:152 · Ganjoor sh5:153
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi begin with Nowruz and renewed need for the cup, followed by Giv’s hopeful approach. English explicitly gives the yearning to Giv and identifies the vessel through Khosrow and its revealing power. Those clarifications connect the scene with the preceding promise without narrating a new action. The bent posture and grief are shared, although the Persian directly relates them to the son and English describes grief that is his own. Khosrow sees a withered face and wounded heart; sunken and spare makes the bodily evidence more concrete. The Roman robe and standing before Yazdan are present in all four. Humbleness interprets the posture. The commentary therefore distinguishes the attested clothing and stance from a fuller ritual explanation, which this passage does not itself provide.
5–8Prayer precedes the act of seeing
Individual four-source accounts for English 5–8. V42:592 running text; V42 n23 actual رخشنده alternative to main خورشید; V43:593 running text; V43:594 running text; V43:595 running text
Moscow printed p.42 · Moscow printed p.43 · Mohl printed p.173 · Khaleghi printed p.345 · Ganjoor sh5:154 · Ganjoor sh5:155 · Ganjoor sh5:156 · Ganjoor sh5:157
All four make Khosrow cry before the World-Creator, seek help and ask justice against Ahriman before returning to the throne. The explicit sun in English follows Moscow and Ganjoor’s main text and a printed Khaleghi alternative; Mohl and Khaleghi’s main wording instead names the shining one. Bowing is added. The cleansing flame in the next English couplet gives judgment a vivid image, but no literal fire occurs in this checked prayer. Putting on the auspicious crown is shared; Kayanian specifies it, while reading his own fate anticipates divination beyond this verse. The cup’s seven climes then appear. Mohl places it in the king’s hand and describes looking, whereas Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi’s main text includes wine. English follows the action without naming wine and anticipates the following celestial display.
9–12A variant celestial inventory
Individual four-source accounts for English 9–12. V43:596 running text; V43:596 زمان و نشان; n6 actual کار و نشان alternative matching Mohl637; V43:597 running text; V43:598 running text; V43 nn10,13 actual هرمز and ناهید alternatives; V43:599 running text
Moscow printed p.43 · Mohl printed p.174 · Khaleghi printed p.345 · Khaleghi printed p.346 · Ganjoor sh5:158 · Ganjoor sh5:159 · Ganjoor sh5:160 · Ganjoor sh5:161
The heavenly display is comprehensive in all four, but its wording varies between time, acts, signs and designs. English makes the general disclosure into acts, decrees and mortal hope; these are interpretive categories rather than an exact Persian list. The Fish-to-Ram sequence supports its zodiacal description. More importantly, Jupiter is not an accidental substitution based on Ganjoor. Mohl and Khaleghi include Hormoz or Hormozd in the celestial list and place Venus in the following half, with corresponding actual Moscow alternatives. Moscow and Ganjoor’s main configuration instead includes Venus and the Sun. English follows the former configuration. The world-ruler’s ability to see what will happen and the enchanter epithet are shared. English read and weighed expands seeing. It follows Mohl’s shorter transition, omitting the separate cup-setting and renewed inspection preserved by the other three.
13–17The vision locates a prisoner and his attendant
Individual four-source accounts for English 13–17. V43:601 running text; V43:602 running text; V43:603 running text; V43:604 running text; V43 n21 actual Manijeh-naming first half; V43:605 running text
Moscow printed p.43 · Mohl printed p.174 · Khaleghi printed p.346 · Ganjoor sh5:163 · Ganjoor sh5:164 · Ganjoor sh5:165 · Ganjoor sh5:166 · Ganjoor sh5:167
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi first describe an unsuccessful survey of the seven climes, then the gaze reaches Gorgasaran and Bijan becomes visible by Yazdan’s command. English came should therefore be read as movement through the vision, not the king’s physical travel. Heavy bonds, the pit and the wish for death are shared; prayed turns that wish into an explicitly devotional act. The female attendant is an unnamed daughter of Kayanian lineage in Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor’s main text. Khaleghi names Manijeh, with the anonymous wording in actual apparatus, while Moscow’s apparatus also preserves her name. English follows the unnamed presentation without losing her care. The king’s turn and smile remain, but gentle, calm and sweet make his manner explicit and replace some of the source’s radiant court imagery.
18–22Survival does not cancel suffering
Individual four-source accounts for English 18–22. V43:606 running text; V43:607 running text; V43:608 running text; V43:609 running text; V43:610 running text
Moscow printed p.43 · Mohl printed p.174 · Khaleghi printed p.346 · Ganjoor sh5:168 · Ganjoor sh5:169 · Ganjoor sh5:170 · Ganjoor sh5:171 · Ganjoor sh5:172
All four reassure Giv that Bijan lives and urge him not to injure himself through grief. The assurance concerns the son’s life even while captivity remains plainly visible. English all is well is broader than that limited reassurance, and the next lines are essential to its interpretation: the king immediately describes bondage, an attendant and suffering. Dark Turan, being beyond sight and attendance day and night extend atmosphere and duration beyond the compact source. The king’s pain at Bijan’s hardship is shared, while hunger and the renewed specification of chains expand the list at this particular locus. The attendant then weeps over him as time passes. English correctly preserves her agency in that action. The passage offers Giv knowledge and grounds for rescue, rather than declaring the captive free from misery.
23–27Whose name is on Bijan’s tongue?
Individual four-source accounts for English 23–27. V43:611 running text; V43 n25 actual لرزان variant; n26 actual چو یک alternative; V44:612 running text; V44 n1 actual شاه alternative to main خویشان; V44:613 running text; V44:614 running text; V44:615 running text
Moscow printed p.43 · Moscow printed p.44 · Mohl printed p.174 · Khaleghi printed p.347 · Ganjoor sh5:173 · Ganjoor sh5:174 · Ganjoor sh5:175 · Ganjoor sh5:176 · Ganjoor sh5:177
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi describe despair of kin and compare Bijan’s movement to a willow branch. Mohl explicitly gives trembling, also preserved in actual Moscow and Khaleghi alternatives; English adds rain and fear. The following name is consequential. Mohl says Bijan remembers Khosrow; Moscow and Ganjoor’s main text and Khaleghi’s main text say his kin. Actual Moscow and Khaleghi variants also supply a royal referent. English my name follows Mohl and turns the vision into a direct appeal to the king’s responsibility. The spring-cloud image and death wish then continue Bijan’s suffering. English both extends the cloud comparison to the attendant as well, drawing her earlier tears into the image rather than reproducing the singular sequence exactly. The call for a girded, faithful rescuer converts this distress into an immediate obligation.
28–31From revealed knowledge to a rescue commission
Individual four-source accounts for English 28–31. V44:616 running text; V44:617 running text; V44:618 running text; V44 n8 actual added promise after618
Moscow printed p.44 · Mohl printed p.174 · Khaleghi printed p.347 · Ganjoor sh5:178 · Ganjoor sh5:179 · Ganjoor sh5:180
All four identify Rostam as the indispensable rescuer through the feat of drawing a nahang from the deep sea. English preserves the creature’s name and sharp-clawed force, adding sand to the sea setting without establishing a species. The order to gird up, go to Nimruz and rest neither night nor day is shared. So is carrying the letter without speaking of the matter on the road. English give it him alone adds private delivery to that explicit secrecy. The final promise is Mohl running text and an actual Moscow apparatus couplet, not an invention caused by Ganjoor’s shorter ending. Khaleghi records a related promise within a longer addition at alternative positions, with imperative and first-person variants. English keeps the king as the promising agent and closes on easing Giv’s burden before the next chapter’s letter-writing.
Source record and limits
C2.13 only:31 English couplets/62 unchanged lines;7 substantive notes. Moscow V42–44:588–618; Mohl III173–174:629–659 (PDF179–180); Ganjoor bizhan sh5:150–180; Khaleghi III345–347:555–585 (PDF361–363). One source-only row. All declared running units accounted. Moscow and Mohl checked individually first, then Ganjoor and Khaleghi.
Coverage means individual source accounting, not universal agreement. Jupiter and royal-name readings have Mohl support and actual Moscow variants; Khaleghi also supports Jupiter in main and royal name in apparatus. English31 follows Mohl running and actual Moscow addition; Khaleghi related promise is within a longer, differently placed addition. Sun praise and anonymous daughter follow specific presentations. Cleansing flame, reading own fate, mortal hope, hunger, rain, both weeping, sea sand and private delivery are interpreted/added details. All-is-well exceeds survival alone. No appendix evidence used; apparatus checked selectively. All inherited flags unchanged.
All62 retained English lines compared with indexed publication turn67view1/turn68view1. Index turn67view0. Retained12 November raw HTML is not a fresh HTTP download.
- Moscow: printed 42 / PDF 42 · printed 43 / PDF 43 · printed 44 / PDF 44. Existing PDFs reused and PNG facsimiles visually read; no scans attached.
- Mohl: printed 173 / PDF 179 · printed 174 / PDF 180. Existing PDFs reused and PNG facsimiles visually read; no scans attached.
- Khaleghi: printed 345 / PDF 361 · printed 346 / PDF 362 · printed 347 / PDF 363. Existing PDFs reused and PNG facsimiles visually read; no scans attached.
- Ganjoor sh5 body150–180, indexed lines623–742 (turn69view0), excluding comments and automated explanations.
No appendix evidence invoked for C2.13. Selected actual Moscow V42n23;V43nn6,10,13,16,17,21,25,26;V44nn1,8 and actual Khaleghi III345nn19,25,28;III346nn1,3,6–8,15,17;III347nn1–3,12 inspected. Khaleghi347n12 is a long addition: only its relevant final promise and recorded placement/voice alternatives are collated here; intervening material is not exhaustively certified. Khaleghi346n17 extra sage address is noted as apparatus, not counted as main text. No addition notice alone is treated as verification.
Running text, actual apparatus, appendix evidence, checked local gaps and unverified details remain separate categories. No appendix evidence is asserted. Source-only S1: Additional looking, setting cup before him and seeing what is to come; English12–13 follows the shorter Mohl sequence without a separate handling/reinspection action. Moscow: V43:600 running text; nn16–17 actual variants; Mohl: III174:640–641 checked local gap; seeing future moves directly to seven-clime search; Khaleghi: III346:567 running text; nn6–8 actual variants; Ganjoor: sh5:162 indexed poem body
- Moscow V42:592/n23;Mohl III173:633;Ganjoor154;Khaleghi III345:559/n19: خورشید / رخشنده
- Moscow V43:595;Mohl III173:636;Ganjoor157;Khaleghi III345:562/n25: نبید / پس آن جام بر کف نهاد و بدید
- Mohl III174:639;Khaleghi III346:565;actual Moscow V43nn10,13 versus Moscow598/Ganjoor160 main: هرمز / هرمزد؛ ناهید؛ خورشید
- Moscow V43:600;Khaleghi III346:567;Ganjoor162;Mohl640–641 local gap: نگه کرد و پس جام بنهاد پیش
- Moscow V43:604/n21;Mohl III174:644;Ganjoor166;Khaleghi III346:571/n15: یکی دختری از نژاد کیان / منیژه کجا بود دخت کیان
- Mohl III174:651;actual Moscow V43n25/Khaleghi III347nn1–2: لرزان / گرازنده
- Mohl III174:652;actual Moscow V44n1/Khaleghi III347n3 versus other main texts: ز خسرو / ز شاه / ز خویشان
- Mohl III174:659;actual Moscow V44n8;Khaleghi III347n12 related promise;Ganjoor section transition gap: بخوانم وزین کارش آگه کنم / غمان بر تو ای گیو کوته کنم
The cup is a narrative instrument of revelation. No historical reconstruction of ritual, horoscope, geography or creature species is claimed. Seeing the region is not bodily travel. English interpretation and specified main/apparatus support are distinguished in every account.
C2.13 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V42:588 running text | III173:629 running text |
| 2 | V42:589 running text | III173:630 running text |
| 3 | V42:590 running text | III173:631 running text |
| 4 | V42:591 running text | III173:632 running text |
| 5 | V42:592 running text; V42 n23 actual رخشنده alternative to main خورشید | III173:633 running text |
| 6 | V43:593 running text | III173:634 running text |
| 7 | V43:594 running text | III173:635 running text |
| 8 | V43:595 running text | III173:636 running text; III173:636 puts cup in hand and looks; no wine word |
| 9 | V43:596 running text; V43:596 زمان و نشان; n6 actual کار و نشان alternative matching Mohl637 | III174:637 running text |
| 10 | V43:597 running text | III174:638 running text |
| 11 | V43:598 running text; V43 nn10,13 actual هرمز and ناهید alternatives | III174:639 running text |
| 12 | V43:599 running text | III174:640 running text |
| 13 | V43:601 running text | III174:641 running text |
| 14 | V43:602 running text | III174:642 running text |
| 15 | V43:603 running text | III174:643 running text |
| 16 | V43:604 running text; V43 n21 actual Manijeh-naming first half | III174:644 running text |
| 17 | V43:605 running text | III174:645 running text |
| 18 | V43:606 running text | III174:646 running text |
| 19 | V43:607 running text | III174:647 running text |
| 20 | V43:608 running text | III174:648 running text |
| 21 | V43:609 running text | III174:649 running text |
| 22 | V43:610 running text | III174:650 running text |
| 23 | V43:611 running text; V43 n25 actual لرزان variant; n26 actual چو یک alternative | III174:651 running text |
| 24 | V44:612 running text; V44 n1 actual شاه alternative to main خویشان | III174:652 running text |
| 25 | V44:613 running text | III174:653 running text |
| 26 | V44:614 running text | III174:654 running text |
| 27 | V44:615 running text | III174:655 running text |
| 28 | V44:616 running text | III174:656 running text |
| 29 | V44:617 running text | III174:657 running text |
| 30 | V44:618 running text | III174:658 running text |
| 31 | V44 n8 actual added promise after618 | III174:659 running text |
New Naqqali