Rostam Comes to Khosrow
C2.17 · Rostam Comes to Khosrow.55 couplets:fourth-day preparation through the blessing on royal remembrance.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | C2.17 · Rostam Comes to Khosrow.55 couplets:fourth-day preparation through the blessing on royal remembrance. |
| Moscow | V51–54:732–782; bracketed745 and actual apparatus separately labeled. |
| Mohl | III180–182:787–843,PDF186–188. Fuller message, distance report, procession and blessing sequence; source-only Aban833. |
| Ganjoor | Indexed poem body sh6:114–146 and sh7:1–18; section boundary falls between remounting and royal audience. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | III356–360:701–750,PDF372–376; bracketed741–742 and selected actual apparatus. Procession has checked local gap; fuller message and blessing variants actually printed. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6Departure and the stature of the hero
Individual source accounts for English 1–6. V51:732 running text; V51:733 running text; V51:734 running text; V51:735 running text; V51:736 running text; V51:737 running text
Moscow printed p. 51 · Mohl printed p. 180 · Khaleghi printed p. 356 · Ganjoor sh6:114 · Ganjoor sh6:115 · Ganjoor sh6:116 · Ganjoor sh6:117 · Ganjoor sh6:118 · Ganjoor sh6:119
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi agree on the fourth-day departure, prepared riders, Roman garment and ancestral mace. English makes the order part of the opening couplet, drawing forward the next source verse’s action. Its repeated readiness for combat gives the preparations a firmer military emphasis, although the immediate journey is to the Iranian court. The inherited gorz remains a concrete link between ancestry and present capacity. Strength and strategy interpret the less literal war and kimiya pairing. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi give war to the head and resourcefulness to the heart; Mohl reverses them. English achieves clarity while reducing the strangeness of the kimiya image. The final couplet preserves the extraordinary scale of both horse and rider. Rakhsh’s ears reach the turning sphere, while the crown-giver rises above the sun: the paired hyperbole makes their arrival a cosmic as well as a courtly event.
7–11The company and the royal destination
Individual source accounts for English 7–11. V51:739 running text; V51:738 running text; V51:740 running text; V51:741 running text; main city of warriors; V51 n20 actual royal-throne alternative; V52:742 running text
Moscow printed p. 51 · Moscow printed p. 52 · Mohl printed p. 180 · Mohl printed p. 181 · Khaleghi printed p. 356 · Khaleghi printed p. 357 · Ganjoor sh6:120 · Ganjoor sh6:121 · Ganjoor sh6:122 · Ganjoor sh6:123 · Ganjoor sh6:124
Mohl puts the baggage decision before the selection of one hundred riders, matching English order; Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi reverse those two units. All four leave the baggage not being taken with Zal and Faramarz. English omits Zal and instead makes Faramarz remain to guard Zabul’s land. That is a plausible practical interpretation, but territorial guardianship and the stars are not stated at this locus. The hundred chosen riders and their vengeance-seeking resolve are preserved. At arrival, Mohl brings the royal throne into view and Khaleghi names the palace roof. Moscow’s main text and Ganjoor name the city of warriors, while Moscow actually prints the throne alternative. English follows the court-centered presentation, then transforms visibility into shining halls. The following sweet breeze carries heaven’s greeting in all four. English turns that conveyed greeting into heaven’s welcome, allowing the atmospheric image to complete the movement from martial preparation to auspicious reception.
12–16Giv announces the arrival
Individual source accounts for English 12–16. V52:743 running text; V52 n5 actual positive going-ahead alternative; V52:744 running text; V52 n8 actual addition after744, first couplet; V52 n8 actual addition after744, second couplet; V52:746 running text
Moscow printed p. 52 · Mohl printed p. 181 · Khaleghi printed p. 357 · Ganjoor sh6:125 · Ganjoor sh6:126 · Ganjoor sh6:128
The primary texts clarify an apparent difficulty in Giv’s proposal. Moscow and Ganjoor’s running wording is negative, while Mohl and Khaleghi have him go ahead; Moscow actually prints a positive alternative. English follows that positive sense and gives it a new deadline before another dawn. Its next report names Rostam and the warriors explicitly where the shared source foregrounds Rakhsh’s completed journey. Rostam’s permission and Giv’s clean heart and road are continuous in Mohl and actually printed in Moscow’s apparatus. Khaleghi also prints them in an addition reported at a different position. Ganjoor supplies only the compact departure-and-arrival bridge. English therefore has primary support for the fuller exchange, while its hope and gladness expand the request to free the king from grief. The paired purity of messenger and road preserves a distinctive ethical image before the conventional praise and reverence at court.
17–22A report of obedience and companionship
Individual source accounts for English 17–22. V52:747 running text; V52:748 running text; V52:749 running text; V52:750 running text; V52:751 running text; V52:752 running text
Moscow printed p. 52 · Mohl printed p. 181 · Khaleghi printed p. 357 · Ganjoor sh6:129 · Ganjoor sh6:130 · Ganjoor sh6:131 · Ganjoor sh6:132 · Ganjoor sh6:133 · Ganjoor sh6:134
All four present the king’s inquiry, Giv’s assurance of royal fortune, Rostam’s obedience and the letter touched to eyes and face. English keeps this sequence, adding a broader request for news and turning successful accomplishment into difficult labor becoming light. That metaphor gives the king’s fortune an immediate emotional effect without introducing a different outcome. The English touch retains the eyes but omits the face, while faithful soul supplies the reverence implied by the gesture. Joined reins then become both companionship and a binding of will. This makes explicit the source’s combination of riding together and serving the king, so loyalty does not displace the personal bond between the heroes. Finally, English describes Rostam as still traveling, where Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi formulate the message as his arrival from the road. The approach remains narratively intelligible, but its completion is softened.
23–28Honor and the distance still to travel
Individual source accounts for English 23–28. V52:753 running text; V52:754 running text; V52 n17 actual addition after754, first couplet; V52 n17 actual addition after754, second couplet; V52:755 running text; V52:756 running text
Moscow printed p. 52 · Mohl printed p. 181 · Khaleghi printed p. 357 · Ganjoor sh6:135 · Ganjoor sh6:136 · Ganjoor sh6:137 · Ganjoor sh6:138
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi agree that Rostam is the support of greatness and seed of fidelity, and that his service deserves honor. English adds the ending of grief and describes an enduring friendship, concentrating the public tribute into a personal relationship. Giv’s answer that Rostam is two stages behind is running text in Mohl and actual apparatus in Moscow and Khaleghi; Ganjoor moves directly from praise to the reception order. The respectful words are verified, but their low and private delivery is an English interpretation, as is the aim of easing an anxious wait. The ensuing social titles also vary. English’s Khosrow-born men and freemen are particularly close to Mohl; Khaleghi has the former in main text and the latter in an actual variant. English retains the collective summons while its court wording makes the source’s accompanying army less explicit.
29–34A ceremonial army goes out to meet him
Individual source accounts for English 29–34. V52:757 running text; V53:758 running text; V53:759 running text; V53:760 running text; V53 n4 actual chargers alternative; V53:761 running text; V53:762 running text
Moscow printed p. 52 · Moscow printed p. 53 · Mohl printed p. 181 · Khaleghi printed p. 358 · Ganjoor sh6:139 · Ganjoor sh6:140 · Ganjoor sh6:141 · Ganjoor sh6:142 · Ganjoor sh6:143 · Ganjoor sh6:144
The four sources name Gudarz, Tus and Farhad and send two-thirds of the warrior body to the reception. English preserves the unusually precise proportion and Keshvad’s relationship to Gudarz, but omits Tus’s Nowzarian royal designation and adds honor to Farhad. Kavus’s custom gives the ceremony inherited authority; English ancient best develops that authority into visible splendor. The dust image has a distinct color change: all four make the world purple, while English uses azure. The chargers, however, have specific support in Mohl’s running text and actual Moscow and Khaleghi variants; Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi main instead display shining spears beside the standards. At the meeting, English adds audible acclaim to the prescribed reverence. Rostam’s own dismounting then preserves the reciprocal nature of the encounter: the assembled chiefs honor him, and he responds bodily rather than remaining elevated above them.
35–39From mutual greeting to royal praise
Individual source accounts for English 35–39. V53:763 running text; V53:764 running text; V53 n13 actual procession addition after764; V53:765 running text; V53:766 running text; V53:767 running text
Moscow printed p. 53 · Mohl printed p. 182 · Khaleghi printed p. 358 · Ganjoor sh6:145 · Ganjoor sh6:146 · Ganjoor sh7:1 · Ganjoor sh7:2 · Ganjoor sh7:3
All four give Rostam’s inquiry after the king a solar and lunar comparison. English retains that exaltation but changes the shining moon into a moon without waning, emphasizing constancy. The next source verse remounts both heroes and Rostam and compares the spectacle to Azargashasp. English concentrates the radiance on Rostam, while chiefs taking seat can leave their return to horseback less clear. The subsequent procession with Rostam at its head is continuous in Mohl and actually printed in Moscow’s apparatus. It has no separate verse at the inspected Khaleghi and Ganjoor transition. At court, the shared king who favors his dependents becomes one who loves his men, a warmer formulation. English also transfers the claim that love and praise befit the king into Rostam’s devoted manner, and draws the lifting of his head and speaking forward from the next source unit.
40–42Guardians named in the blessing
Individual source accounts for English 40–42. V53:767 running text; V53:768 running text; V53:768 running text; V53:769 running text; V53:769 running text; V53 n26 actual Bahram/Tir variant
Moscow printed p. 53 · Mohl printed p. 182 · Khaleghi printed p. 358 · Khaleghi printed p. 359 · Ganjoor sh7:3 · Ganjoor sh7:4 · Ganjoor sh7:5
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all join the favorable-fortune wish to Ormozd, Bahman and Ordibehesht. Their wording differs around the royal station, and English redistributes protection across court, throne and crown. Its explicit harms and fears elaborate the sequence’s guarding language. Throne and crown together are especially close to Mohl’s Bahman verse. Bahram and Tir require a separate evidential judgment: Mohl names them in running text, and both Moscow and Khaleghi actually print that variant. Their main versions, like Ganjoor, instead give wise guardianship without the two names. English thus follows a supported fuller naming rather than inventing additional protectors. It divides Mohl’s Ordibehesht and Bahram/Tir unit across two English couplets and carries the annual duration into the latter. The register consequently reuses the same source unit instead of pretending that the English division represents another independent Persian verse.
43–47Prosperity and the changing sequence of names
Individual source accounts for English 43–47. V53:770 running text; V54:771 running text; V54:772 running text; V54 n3 actual Khordad/land variant and n4 actual Mordad/livestock addition; V54:773 running text; main Dey/Ormozd; checked V54:773/n4 no Farvardin wording; V54:774 running text; V54 n5 actual night/day alternatives
Moscow printed p. 53 · Moscow printed p. 54 · Mohl printed p. 182 · Khaleghi printed p. 359 · Ganjoor sh7:6 · Ganjoor sh7:7 · Ganjoor sh7:8 · Ganjoor sh7:9 · Ganjoor sh7:10
Shahrivar’s victory and Sapandarmad’s protection agree across all four, with English preserving the union of farr, ability and wisdom. The prosperity verse then follows Moscow and Ganjoor: Khordad brings fruit through helpers, and Mordad brings joy in land. Khaleghi prints that alternative but chooses land for Khordad and livestock for Mordad in main text. Mohl likewise assigns livestock to Mordad and land and throne to Khordad, reversing their order. English helping hands therefore should not be credited to Mohl’s running text. Farvardin follows Mohl and an actual Khaleghi addition; Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi’s bracketed main blessing name Ormozd there instead. Azar and night/day brightness are clearest in Mohl, with relevant actual variants in Moscow and Khaleghi; the main formulations differ. English equal brightness changes Mohl’s comparative but preserves the world-lighting crown. Mohl’s separate Aban blessing, also printed in Khaleghi’s apparatus, is not rendered and remains source-only evidence.
48–51The king answers the public blessing
Individual source accounts for English 48–51. V54:775 running text; V54:776 running text; V54:777 running text; V54:778 running text
Moscow printed p. 54 · Mohl printed p. 182 · Khaleghi printed p. 360 · Ganjoor sh7:11 · Ganjoor sh7:12 · Ganjoor sh7:13 · Ganjoor sh7:14
Moscow and Ganjoor explicitly name Rostam standing at the close of the blessing. Mohl and Khaleghi main use the description of one praising Khosrow, while Khaleghi prints the Rostam-standing alternative. All four then give him a place beside the king. English received him preserves the welcome but makes that spatial honor less explicit, adding joy in the royal gaze. Safe arrival and the wish to keep evil far from his life are retained through a more luminous English image of blessing and light. The next hidden-and-manifest paradox is shared across the four presentations. English wisely keeps its balanced opposition rather than imposing an explanation that the verse itself does not supply. The praise then returns to a clearer political role: chosen Kayanian, support of the army and protector of Iran. English fort and wall give concrete defensive form to those functions without introducing a new military event.
52–55Recognition extends to Rostam’s household
Individual source accounts for English 52–55. V54:779 running text; V54:780 running text; V54:781 running text; V54:782 running text; V54 n17 actual farr alternative
Moscow printed p. 54 · Mohl printed p. 182 · Khaleghi printed p. 360 · Ganjoor sh7:15 · Ganjoor sh7:16 · Ganjoor sh7:17 · Ganjoor sh7:18
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all join the king’s joy at seeing Rostam to his skilled and wakeful spirit. English’s keen and wise reinforces that alertness rather than reducing the compliment to strength alone. The inquiry after Zavareh, Faramarz and Dastan son of Sahm then broadens royal attention from the visiting hero to his household. English identifies Dastan as Zal and keeps the three people distinct. Rostam’s bow and kiss of the throne answer that recognition before his report of their health. The final causal word differs: Mohl invokes the king’s farr, supported by an actual Moscow variant, while Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi main use fortune. English chooses farr and omits the family’s explicit gladness, but preserves the closing blessing on whoever the king remembers. That reciprocal courtesy closes the audience before the next chapter begins preparations for the feast.
Source record and limits
C2.17 only:55 English couplets/110 unchanged lines;11 substantive notes. Moscow V51–54:732–782 (51 main units including bracketed745) and selected actual apparatus; Mohl III180–182:787–843 (PDF186–188,57 main units); Ganjoor bizhan sh6:114–146 plus sh7:1–18 (51 units); Khaleghi III356–360:701–750 (PDF372–376,50 main units including bracketed741–742), selected actual apparatus. Every declared main unit accounted. Moscow and Mohl individually checked first, then Ganjoor and Khaleghi. Two source-only entries.
Coverage means individual source accounting, including partial support and checked local gaps, not universal agreement. Faramarz guarding the land, a dawn deadline, private speech and brightly shining halls are English elaborations at these loci. Purple becomes azure. Mohl and actual Moscow apparatus support the fuller message and procession. Blessing names have individually differentiated evidence. No appendix evidence used; selected apparatus is not exhaustive. All inherited provisional flags retained.
- Moscow: printed 51 / PDF 51 · printed 52 / PDF 52 · printed 53 / PDF 53 · printed 54 / PDF 54. Existing PDFs reused; PNG facsimiles read. Scans excluded.
- Mohl: printed 180 / PDF 186 · printed 181 / PDF 187 · printed 182 / PDF 188. Existing PDFs reused; PNG facsimiles read. Scans excluded.
- Khaleghi: printed 356 / PDF 372 · printed 357 / PDF 373 · printed 358 / PDF 374 · printed 359 / PDF 375 · printed 360 / PDF 376. Existing PDFs reused; PNG facsimiles read. Scans excluded.
- Ganjoor sh6:114–146 (turn88view0,lines483–610) and sh7:1–18 (turn90view0,lines43–111). Poem body only; comments and automated explanations excluded. Direct sh7 open returned404; following the observed next-section link retrieved its indexed text successfully.
No appendix evidence used for C2.17. Actual Moscow V52n5 positive advance reading, n8 permission/purity couplets, n17 distance report; V53n4 chargers, n13 procession, n26 Bahram/Tir; V54nn3–4 Khordad/Mordad alternatives, n5 night/day variants, n17 farr read. Actual Khaleghi III357n6 departure and permission/purity additions with their reported positions, n22 distance report, n24 freemen; III358n9 chargers; III359n3 Farvardin addition, n7 Bahram/Tir, n13 helpers alternative, n14 expanded blessings including Aban, n16 Azar/night/day; III360n1 Rostam-standing variant read. Moscow745 and Khaleghi741–742 are bracketed running text, not apparatus. Checked local gaps are bounded to named loci; no whole-manuscript absence or exhaustive apparatus survey claimed.
- Mohl III181:800; actual Moscow V52n8 and Khaleghi III357n6: بدو گفت رستم برو شاد باش / بگو شاه را وز غم آزاد باش
- Mohl III181:812; actual Moscow V52n17 and Khaleghi III357n22: که من آمدم از دو منزل به پیش / به آگاه کردن سوی شاه خویش
- Mohl III182:823; actual Moscow V53n13: وز آنجا برفتند زی شهریار / به پیش اندرون رستم نامدار
- Mohl III182:828; actual Moscow V53n26 and Khaleghi III359n7: نگهدار تو باد بهرام و تیر
- Moscow V54:772; Ganjoor sh7:8; actual Khaleghi III359n13 alternative: چو خردادت از یاوران بر دهاد / ز مرداد باش از بر و بوم شاد
- Mohl III182:831; related actual Khaleghi III359n3 addition: دی و فرودینت خجسته بواد / در هر بدی بر تو بسته بواد
- Mohl III182:833; related actual Khaleghi III359n14 Aban addition: از آبانت هر کار فرخنده باد / سپهر روان پیش تو بنده باد
- Moscow V54:782 main versus actual n17 and Mohl III182:843: ببخت تو / بفر تو
S1: Giv leaves Rostam and reaches the young Shah’s court. English14–15 follows the fuller permission and purity sequence instead; its arrival overlaps this compact bridge. Kept separately to account for bracketed Moscow745, not counted as another English unit.
S2: Mohl invokes Aban to make every undertaking fortunate and the moving sphere obedient. Khaleghi actually prints an Aban addition in apparatus, with a slightly different second hemistich. English omits this separate blessing. No corresponding verse in the checked Moscow or Ganjoor transition; no global manuscript absence claimed.
Persian quotations normalize spacing only. Rows with reused main verses identify redistribution, not additional independent Persian units. All English preserved; no repairs proposed. Inherited uncertainties remain verbatim in the checkpoint.
C2.17 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V51:732 running text | III180:787 running text |
| 2 | V51:733 running text | III180:788 running text |
| 3 | V51:734 running text | III180:789 running text |
| 4 | V51:735 running text | III180:790 running text |
| 5 | V51:736 running text | III180:791 running text |
| 6 | V51:737 running text | III180:792 running text |
| 7 | V51:739 running text | III180:793 running text |
| 8 | V51:738 running text | III180:794 running text |
| 9 | V51:740 running text | III180:795 running text |
| 10 | V51:741 running text; main city of warriors; V51 n20 actual royal-throne alternative | III181:796 running text |
| 11 | V52:742 running text | III181:797 running text |
| 12 | V52:743 running text; V52 n5 actual positive going-ahead alternative | III181:798 running text |
| 13 | V52:744 running text | III181:799 running text |
| 14 | V52 n8 actual addition after744, first couplet | III181:800 running text |
| 15 | V52 n8 actual addition after744, second couplet | III181:801 running text |
| 16 | V52:746 running text | III181:802 running text |
| 17 | V52:747 running text | III181:803 running text |
| 18 | V52:748 running text | III181:804 running text |
| 19 | V52:749 running text | III181:805 running text |
| 20 | V52:750 running text | III181:806 running text |
| 21 | V52:751 running text | III181:807 running text |
| 22 | V52:752 running text | III181:808 running text |
| 23 | V52:753 running text | III181:809 running text |
| 24 | V52:754 running text | III181:810 running text |
| 25 | V52 n17 actual addition after754, first couplet | III181:811 running text |
| 26 | V52 n17 actual addition after754, second couplet | III181:812 running text |
| 27 | V52:755 running text | III181:813 running text |
| 28 | V52:756 running text | III181:814 running text |
| 29 | V52:757 running text | III181:815 running text |
| 30 | V53:758 running text | III181:816 running text |
| 31 | V53:759 running text | III181:817 running text |
| 32 | V53:760 running text; V53 n4 actual chargers alternative | III181:818 running text |
| 33 | V53:761 running text | III181:819 running text |
| 34 | V53:762 running text | III181:820 running text |
| 35 | V53:763 running text | III182:821 running text |
| 36 | V53:764 running text | III182:822 running text |
| 37 | V53 n13 actual procession addition after764 | III182:823 running text |
| 38 | V53:765 running text | III182:824 running text |
| 39 | V53:766 running text; V53:767 running text | III182:825 running text |
| 40 | V53:767 running text; V53:768 running text | III182:826 running text; III182:827 running text |
| 41 | V53:768 running text; V53:769 running text | III182:827 running text; III182:828 running text |
| 42 | V53:769 running text; V53 n26 actual Bahram/Tir variant | III182:828 running text |
| 43 | V53:770 running text | III182:829 running text |
| 44 | V54:771 running text | III182:830 running text |
| 45 | V54:772 running text; V54 n3 actual Khordad/land variant and n4 actual Mordad/livestock addition | III182:834 running text; III182:835 running text |
| 46 | V54:773 running text; main Dey/Ormozd; checked V54:773/n4 no Farvardin wording | III182:831 running text |
| 47 | V54:774 running text; V54 n5 actual night/day alternatives | III182:832 running text |
| 48 | V54:775 running text | III182:836 running text |
| 49 | V54:776 running text | III182:837 running text |
| 50 | V54:777 running text | III182:838 running text |
| 51 | V54:778 running text | III182:839 running text |
| 52 | V54:779 running text | III182:840 running text |
| 53 | V54:780 running text | III182:841 running text |
| 54 | V54:781 running text | III182:842 running text |
| 55 | V54:782 running text; V54 n17 actual farr alternative | III182:843 running text |
New Naqqali