The Pahlevans Feast with Khosrow
C2.18 · The Pahlevans Feast with Khosrow.42 couplets: garden opening through wine and springtime joy.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | C2.18 · The Pahlevans Feast with Khosrow.42 couplets: garden opening through wine and springtime joy. |
| Moscow | V54–57:783–825; summons earlier; Div recollection earlier in Rostam’s speech; separate cunning-versus-combat verse822. Selected actual variants distinguished. |
| Mohl | III183–184:844–885,PDF189–190. Shah under fragrant tree853; summons858; seating859 before drinkers860; Div recollection879; no separate strategy verse at882–883. |
| Ganjoor | Indexed poem body bizhan sh7:19–61. Corresponds to Moscow running sequence here, including strategic declaration58. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | III360–363:751–791,PDF376–379. Div recollection770 is king’s second-person praise; heart-and-soul and strategy verses printed in apparatus. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6A garden made fit for royal company
Individual source accounts for English 1–6. V54:784 running text; V54 n18 actual made a royal seat alternative; V54:785 running text; V54:786 running text; V54:787 running text; V55:788 running text; V55:789 running text
Moscow printed p. 54 · Moscow printed p. 55 · Mohl printed p. 183 · Khaleghi printed p. 360 · Ganjoor sh7:20 · Ganjoor sh7:21 · Ganjoor sh7:22 · Ganjoor sh7:23 · Ganjoor sh7:24 · Ganjoor sh7:25
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi share the garden opening, royal seat, crown and throne, brocade and constructed tree. English follows the active preparation found in Mohl and Khaleghi more closely than Moscow and Ganjoor’s description of an already royal sitting place; Moscow also prints the active alternative. The next command becomes the chamberlain’s direct action, and a blossom-scattering tree becomes a scented bower. The brocade then makes the garden like a lamp in all four, whereas English turns that simile into actual lamplight. The artificial tree retains its silver trunk and golden branches, but English omits ruby as a separately named branch material. Its distribution of emerald leaves and hanging jeweled fruit gives visual order to the source inventory. Overhead also accommodates the differing attachment points: Mohl and Khaleghi name a branch, while Moscow and Ganjoor name the crown or top.
7–10The tree releases its fragrance
Individual source accounts for English 7–10. V55:790 running text; V55:791 running text; V55:791 running text; V55:792 running text; V55:792 running text; V55:792–793/n10–11 checked local gap for separate Shah arrival
Moscow printed p. 55 · Mohl printed p. 183 · Khaleghi printed p. 360 · Khaleghi printed p. 361 · Ganjoor sh7:26 · Ganjoor sh7:27 · Ganjoor sh7:28
All four describe hollow golden quince and citron, musk mixed with wine, reed-like perforations and wind carrying the scent over someone seated by the Shah. English draws the perforations into the fruit couplet and distributes the fragrance mechanism across the next two. This makes the crafted tree easier to visualize, although fragrant cells and shrine are interpretive additions. The person whom the king seats becomes a kingly guest approaching the throne, changing both the gesture of royal favor and the recipient’s stated status. The separate shower of musk when the Shah himself arrives has specific support in Mohl’s additional verse. No independent counterpart appears at the inspected Moscow, Ganjoor or Khaleghi transition. English therefore has a primary basis for that second event; it should not be counted merely as a repetition invented from the preceding general description.
11–17Attendants, summons and the seating of Rostam
Individual source accounts for English 11–17. V55:793 running text; V55:794 running text; V55 n12 actual Chinese/Roman variant; V55:795 running text; V55:796 running text; V54:783 running text; earlier position before784; V55:798 running text; V55:797 running text; before798; V55 n17 reports reversed order
Moscow printed p. 54 · Moscow printed p. 55 · Mohl printed p. 183 · Khaleghi printed p. 360 · Khaleghi printed p. 361 · Ganjoor sh7:19 · Ganjoor sh7:29 · Ganjoor sh7:30 · Ganjoor sh7:31 · Ganjoor sh7:32 · Ganjoor sh7:33 · Ganjoor sh7:34
The four sources agree on wine attendants, jeweled headgear, torques, earrings, brocade-colored faces, fragrant burning wood and the sounding chang. English cupbearers selects their serving role and adds repeated light to the clothing. Chinese and Roman garments together follow Mohl, with actual Moscow and Khaleghi variant support; the latter editions’ main texts and Ganjoor name Chinese brocade only at that point. English also follows Mohl’s sequence in placing the summons after the attendants and the uninebriated company after Rostam’s seating. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi main put the summons before the garden opening and the company before Rostam sits. These are recorded relocations, not extra events. The final English negatives expand the statement that the drinkers are not drunk, while omitting their explicitly glad hearts. Sitting beside the king interprets the honor of the shared throne beneath the tree.
18–24Praise becomes an appeal for the Gudarz family
Individual source accounts for English 18–24. V55:799 running text; V55:800 running text; V55:801 running text; V55 n20 actual city variant; V55:802 running text; V55:803 running text; V55:804 running text; V55:805 running text
Moscow printed p. 55 · Mohl printed p. 183 · Mohl printed p. 184 · Khaleghi printed p. 361 · Ganjoor sh7:35 · Ganjoor sh7:36 · Ganjoor sh7:37 · Ganjoor sh7:38 · Ganjoor sh7:39 · Ganjoor sh7:40 · Ganjoor sh7:41
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi begin with an auspicious address and the image of Rostam shielding Iran beneath Simorgh-like wings. English expands the address with throne, guardian and gates, drawing the protective function forward before preserving the winged simile itself. The following setting varies: Mohl names Iran’s battle, Moscow and Ganjoor its court, and Khaleghi its city. English field suits the martial presentation while retaining labor’s door and the girded belt. Knowledge of the Gudarz family’s conduct becomes knowledge of what they bear, making service more experiential. Giv is then singled out as a shield; English only can make that praise sound exclusive, rather than focused on one member of the gathering. Finally, lineage-wide grief narrows to the noble individual, and pain over a child becomes losing a son. Within this rescue appeal, that loss need not imply that Bijan is dead.
25–28The king relies on one rescuer
Individual source accounts for English 25–28. V56:806 running text; V56 n3 actual no-other-remedy alternative and added negative-condition verse; V56:807 running text; V56:808 running text; V56 n6 actual weapons/equipment alternative; V56:808 running text; V56:809 running text; V56 n10 actual rising/moving alternative
Moscow printed p. 56 · Mohl printed p. 184 · Khaleghi printed p. 362 · Ganjoor sh7:42 · Ganjoor sh7:43 · Ganjoor sh7:44 · Ganjoor sh7:45
The condition has two distinct forms. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi main say that a fierce lion will not confront Rostam if he undertakes the work. Mohl instead declares that no other remedy exists unless he takes it on; Moscow and Khaleghi actually print corresponding alternatives. English follows this latter logic, emphasizing indispensable personal agency rather than heroic invulnerability. The next verse specifies Bijan’s iron chain and dark Turan where all four state his misfortune more generally. The offered horses, men, equipment and treasure remain intact; armor is closer to Mohl and Khaleghi’s weapons term, also recorded by Moscow, than to Moscow and Ganjoor’s running sword. English then joins the warning not to count the task as toil with Rostam’s earth-kiss, splitting two source units across its boundary. His subsequent rising follows Mohl and Khaleghi rather than the drawn breath of Moscow and Ganjoor main.
29–33Rostam’s praise of sovereign judgment
Individual source accounts for English 29–33. V56:810 running text; V56:811 running text; V56:812 running text; V56:813 running text; V56:814 running text
Moscow printed p. 56 · Mohl printed p. 184 · Khaleghi printed p. 362 · Ganjoor sh7:46 · Ganjoor sh7:47 · Ganjoor sh7:48 · Ganjoor sh7:49 · Ganjoor sh7:50
All four compare the king’s reach with the sun, wish harm upon his ill-wisher and place other rulers at his feet. English turns the sun’s broadly extended desire or sway into power crowning the royal name. Greed is supported by Mohl and Khaleghi, whereas Moscow and Ganjoor invoke the two eyes of need. Mohl additionally names anxiety and Khaleghi anger; English does not separately retain either. The following dust-at-the-feet metaphor becomes homage by crowned heads, making the political relation explicit. Throne, sun and moon then attest the king’s uniqueness, with night and noon added to complete the English cosmic range. The final source praise concerns separating the bad from the good and controlling the dragon through enchantment and bonds. English shifts enacted discrimination into knowing the difference, omits enchantment and adds a world gone mad. The resulting praise remains forceful but simplifies the source’s account of sovereign action.
34–38Service sworn through remembered and future danger
Individual source accounts for English 34–38. V56:816 running text; V56:817 running text; V56:818 running text; V56:815 running text; main first-person feat before816; V56 n17 reports later placement; V56:819 running text; V56:820 running text
Moscow printed p. 56 · Mohl printed p. 184 · Khaleghi printed p. 361 · Khaleghi printed p. 362 · Ganjoor sh7:51 · Ganjoor sh7:52 · Ganjoor sh7:53 · Ganjoor sh7:54 · Ganjoor sh7:55 · Ganjoor sh7:56
Mohl places the maternal declaration, compact obedience verse and Div recollection in the same order as English. Moscow and Ganjoor put the Div feat first and give obedience two verses, including heart and soul directed toward the crown. Khaleghi places the feat earlier still, in the king’s second-person praise; its apparatus actually records first-person wording and the additional heart-and-soul verse elsewhere. These are different placements and speaker relations, not interchangeable running witnesses. English preserves Rostam’s memorable division of labor: his birth is for the king’s toil, while the king’s portion is repose. The Div’s torn heart, Kayanian farr and mace then authenticate that service. In the future ordeal, all four make him disregard heavenly fire for Giv and refuse to turn from the royal command even at spearpoint. English moves explicit loyalty to Khosrow into the fire couplet, maintaining the two motives across the pair.
39–42A promise without an army
Individual source accounts for English 39–42. V56:821 running text; V56 n23 actual farr alternative; V57:823 running text; V57:824 running text; V57:825 running text; V57 n5 actual heart alternative
Moscow printed p. 56 · Moscow printed p. 57 · Mohl printed p. 184 · Khaleghi printed p. 363 · Ganjoor sh7:57 · Ganjoor sh7:59 · Ganjoor sh7:60 · Ganjoor sh7:61
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi agree that Rostam will accomplish the task without a commander or picked warriors. English farr follows Mohl and actual Moscow and Khaleghi alternatives; the main readings otherwise name fortune or the king’s wish. The next strategic declaration requires separate accounting. Moscow and Ganjoor say that deception is the key and this is no time for mace or terror; Khaleghi actually prints that verse in apparatus. Mohl passes directly to the chiefs’ response, as English does. The missing explanation therefore follows a verified primary sequence. The named respondents and invocation of the World-Creator remain shared, with English reordering the names and adding the crown as an honorific object. The closing open hearts follow Mohl and an actual Moscow variant rather than the door image in the other running versions. Wine and springtime joy conclude the promise without requiring a claim that the company became drunk.
Source record and limits
C2.18 only:42 English couplets/84 unchanged lines;8 substantive notes. Moscow V54–57:783–825 (43 running units); Mohl III183–184:844–885 (PDF189–190,42 running units); Ganjoor bizhan sh7:19–61 (43 units); Khaleghi III360–363:751–791 (PDF376–379,41 running units). Selected actual apparatus read. Every declared running unit accounted, with reuse, relocation and changed speaker labeled. Moscow and Mohl individually checked first, then Ganjoor and Khaleghi. One source-only entry.
Coverage is individual source accounting, not universal agreement. Mohl supports the separate Shah/fragrance event, order of summons and seating, negative no-other-remedy condition and later Div recollection. Moscow/Ganjoor and actual Khaleghi apparatus have a strategy verse absent from the checked Mohl transition and English. Lamplight, shrine, guest approach, iron chains and a mad world are English elaborations or shifts at these loci. No appendix evidence used; apparatus not exhaustively transcribed. All inherited provisional flags retained.
Retained12 November raw HTML compared with all84 currently indexed lines.
- Moscow: printed 54 / PDF 54 · printed 55 / PDF 55 · printed 56 / PDF 56 · printed 57 / PDF 57. Existing source PDF reused; PNG facsimiles read. Scans excluded.
- Mohl: printed 183 / PDF 189 · printed 184 / PDF 190. Existing source PDF reused; PNG facsimiles read. Scans excluded.
- Khaleghi: printed 360 / PDF 376 · printed 361 / PDF 377 · printed 362 / PDF 378 · printed 363 / PDF 379. Existing source PDF reused; PNG facsimiles read. Scans excluded.
- Ganjoor sh7:19–61 (turn94view0,lines113–279). Poem body only; comments and automated explanations excluded.
No appendix evidence used. Actual Moscow V54n18 made-a-seat alternative; V55n12 Chinese/Roman garments; V56n3 no-other-remedy alternative and added negative-condition verse, n6 weapons, n10 rising, n23 farr; V57n5 heart alternative inspected. Actual Khaleghi III361n6 Roman garment, n15 battle setting, n18 first-person Div wording; III362n3 no-other-remedy variant and n24 full heart-and-soul addition; III363n1 farr and n3 full cunning-versus-combat addition inspected. Order notices in Moscow55n17/56n17 and Khaleghi361n9/n19 are labeled as placement notices, not proof of unprinted verse text. Running verses supply the actual words for those comparisons. No bracketed running passage or appendix invoked for this chapter. Bounded gaps do not imply global manuscript absence.
- Mohl III183:853 second hemistich only; separate Shah/fragrance event: به سر برش ریزنده مشک از درخت
- Mohl III183:855; actual Moscow V55n12; Khaleghi III361n6 Roman alternative: ز دیبای چینی و رومی قبای
- Mohl III184:868; actual Moscow V56n3 and Khaleghi III362n3 related alternatives: برین کار گر تو نبندی کمر / نبینم بگیتی دگر چاره گر
- Moscow V56:815/Mohl III184:879 first-person; Khaleghi III361:770 second-person and n18 first-person alternative: بکندم / بکندی
- Moscow V56:818/Ganjoor54 main; related actual Khaleghi III362n24 differs in wording: دل و جان نهاده بسوی کلاه / بران ره روم کم بفرمود شاه
- Moscow V56:822/Ganjoor58 main; actual Khaleghi III363n3; checked Mohl III184:882–883 gap: کلید چنین بند باشد فریب / نه هنگام گرزست و روز نهیب
- Mohl III184:885; actual Moscow V57n5: گشاده بشادی دل و نوبهار
S1: The key to this bond is deception; this is no time for the mace or terror. Moscow/Ganjoor print the strategic declaration, and Khaleghi actually prints it in apparatus. Mohl and English pass directly to the chiefs’ response. English’s omission therefore follows Mohl’s local sequence; it should not be described as an unsupported translator deletion.
English remains verbatim. Persian excerpts normalize spacing only; the Shah/fragrance quotation is expressly a hemistich, not a fabricated complete couplet. Reused main units are not counted as independent additional verses. Different speaker and sequence relations remain explicit. No English repairs proposed.
C2.18 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V54:784 running text; V54 n18 actual made a royal seat alternative | III183:844 running text |
| 2 | V54:785 running text | III183:845 running text |
| 3 | V54:786 running text | III183:846 running text |
| 4 | V54:787 running text | III183:847 running text |
| 5 | V55:788 running text | III183:848 running text |
| 6 | V55:789 running text | III183:849 running text |
| 7 | V55:790 running text; V55:791 running text | III183:850 running text |
| 8 | V55:791 running text; V55:792 running text | III183:851 running text |
| 9 | V55:792 running text | III183:852 running text |
| 10 | V55:792–793/n10–11 checked local gap for separate Shah arrival | III183:853 running text |
| 11 | V55:793 running text | III183:854 running text |
| 12 | V55:794 running text; V55 n12 actual Chinese/Roman variant | III183:855 running text |
| 13 | V55:795 running text | III183:856 running text |
| 14 | V55:796 running text | III183:857 running text |
| 15 | V54:783 running text; earlier position before784 | III183:858 running text |
| 16 | V55:798 running text | III183:859 running text |
| 17 | V55:797 running text; before798; V55 n17 reports reversed order | III183:860 running text |
| 18 | V55:799 running text | III183:861 running text |
| 19 | V55:800 running text | III183:862 running text |
| 20 | V55:801 running text; V55 n20 actual city variant | III183:863 running text |
| 21 | V55:802 running text | III183:864 running text |
| 22 | V55:803 running text | III183:865 running text |
| 23 | V55:804 running text | III183:866 running text |
| 24 | V55:805 running text | III184:867 running text |
| 25 | V56:806 running text; V56 n3 actual no-other-remedy alternative and added negative-condition verse | III184:868 running text |
| 26 | V56:807 running text | III184:869 running text |
| 27 | V56:808 running text; V56 n6 actual weapons/equipment alternative | III184:870 running text |
| 28 | V56:808 running text; V56:809 running text; V56 n10 actual rising/moving alternative | III184:871 running text |
| 29 | V56:810 running text | III184:872 running text |
| 30 | V56:811 running text | III184:873 running text |
| 31 | V56:812 running text | III184:874 running text |
| 32 | V56:813 running text | III184:875 running text |
| 33 | V56:814 running text | III184:876 running text |
| 34 | V56:816 running text | III184:877 running text |
| 35 | V56:817 running text; V56:818 running text | III184:878 running text |
| 36 | V56:815 running text; main first-person feat before816; V56 n17 reports later placement | III184:879 running text |
| 37 | V56:819 running text | III184:880 running text |
| 38 | V56:820 running text | III184:881 running text |
| 39 | V56:821 running text; V56 n23 actual farr alternative | III184:882 running text |
| 40 | V57:823 running text | III184:883 running text |
| 41 | V57:824 running text | III184:884 running text |
| 42 | V57:825 running text; V57 n5 actual heart alternative | III184:885 running text |
New Naqqali