Rostam Pleads for Gorgin
C2.19 · Rostam Pleads for Gorgin.42 couplets,news of Rostam through Gorgin’s release.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | C2.19 · Rostam Pleads for Gorgin.42 couplets,news of Rostam through Gorgin’s release. |
| Moscow | V57–59:826–867. One day/night; second day; Lord of Bahram; first avenger. Selected actual variants separately recorded. |
| Mohl | III184–186:886–927,PDF190–192. Two days/night; third day; Bahram/Nahid with sun/moon; first avenger. |
| Ganjoor | bizhan sh8:1–42, indexed poem body. Main order and readings closely follow Moscow here. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | III363–366:792–833,PDF379–382. Two days/two nights; third day; Lord of Khordad; vengeance setting. Selected actual apparatus separated. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5A plea framed as fallen fortune
Individual accounts for English 1–5. V57:826 running text; V57:827 running text; V57:828 running text; V57:828 running text; V57:829 running text; V57:829 running text; V57:830 running text; V57 n10 actual crooked-sky alternatives; V57:830 running text; V57:831 running text
Moscow printed p. 57 · Mohl printed p. 184 · Mohl printed p. 185 · Khaleghi printed p. 363 · Ganjoor sh8:1 · Ganjoor sh8:2 · Ganjoor sh8:3 · Ganjoor sh8:4 · Ganjoor sh8:5 · Ganjoor sh8:6
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all begin with Gorgin discovering a possible remedy in Rostam’s arrival. The English path to freedom gives narrative form to the Persian key to grief. His complimentary address then redistributes several images across adjacent couplets: sword and scabbard become general heroic praise, while tree, loyalty and refuge remain prominent. Mohl instead calls Rostam auspicious and renowned, supporting the general sense of English fame. Farr is interpretive here, not a directly transcribed noun from Mohl. The confession is less exact. The Persian asks Rostam to speak about Gorgin’s conduct, whereas English makes Gorgin announce that he will tell his own wrong. Moscow and Ganjoor supply the crooked heavenly dome; Mohl reads this crooked work and Khaleghi this crooked Time, with sky alternatives in the printed apparatus. The turning sun is an English addition. The extinguished heart-lamp preserves Gorgin’s effort to cast wrongdoing as misfortune.
6–10Fire, age and the promise of restitution
Individual accounts for English 6–10. V57:831 running text; V57:832 running text; V57:832 running text; V57:833 running text; V57:833 running text; V57:834 running text; V57:835 running text
Moscow printed p. 57 · Mohl printed p. 185 · Khaleghi printed p. 363 · Khaleghi printed p. 364 · Ganjoor sh8:6 · Ganjoor sh8:7 · Ganjoor sh8:8 · Ganjoor sh8:9 · Ganjoor sh8:10
All four running presentations connect written destiny, a proposed fire ordeal, a damaged name and dishonorable old age. The English preserves that sequence while spreading clauses across its couplet boundaries. Its statement that Gorgin must face fire makes the ordeal sound imposed; the Persian instead volunteers self-exposure to fire if forgiveness follows. This matters because Gorgin is bargaining for rehabilitation, rather than reporting a sentence already passed. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi also retain the ghorm comparison. Mountain sheep therefore has direct textual grounds, and its speed carries the eagerness to accompany Rostam. At Bijan’s feet, however, the source promises rolling in dust, stronger bodily abasement than an English bow. Honor, name and trust offer a socially legible interpretation of pure kish, while reducing its possible religious resonance. The gray head bowed beneath dishonor is likewise an effective English elaboration of the source’s old age and bad outcome.
11–18Animal fable and the mastery of appetite
Individual accounts for English 11–18. V57:836 running text; V57:837 running text; V57:838 running text; V57:839 running text; V57:840 running text; V58:841 running text; V58:842 running text; V58:843 running text
Moscow printed p. 57 · Moscow printed p. 58 · Mohl printed p. 185 · Khaleghi printed p. 364 · Ganjoor sh8:11 · Ganjoor sh8:12 · Ganjoor sh8:13 · Ganjoor sh8:14 · Ganjoor sh8:15 · Ganjoor sh8:16 · Ganjoor sh8:17 · Ganjoor sh8:18
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi preserve the same progression: Rostam’s visceral grief, condemnation of Gorgin, the leopard’s encounter with the nahang, the rule of reason over appetite, and the fox that fails to see a trap. English retains the cold breath from the liver rather than replacing this bodily idiom with a neutral sigh. Its sea-floor is more specific than the deep sea named in the source; retaining nahang avoids silently fixing the creature’s English zoological identity. The fatal bite and lion’s crown develop the Persian grip of passion and lionlike reputation. The hunting maxim remains intelligible across Moscow and Ganjoor’s face wording and Mohl and Khaleghi’s scent wording. The final English fox has already been trapped, while the Persian directly reproaches failure to notice the hunter’s snare. Both connect misused cunning with vulnerability, but the English makes the consequence more explicit.
19–26Mercy remains conditional on Bijan’s survival
Individual accounts for English 19–26. V58:844 running text; V58:845 running text; V58:846 running text; V58:847 running text; V58:848 running text; V58 n15 actual champion variant; V58:849 running text; V58:850 running text; V58:851 running text
Moscow printed p. 58 · Mohl printed p. 185 · Khaleghi printed p. 364 · Khaleghi printed p. 365 · Ganjoor sh8:19 · Ganjoor sh8:20 · Ganjoor sh8:21 · Ganjoor sh8:22 · Ganjoor sh8:23 · Ganjoor sh8:24 · Ganjoor sh8:25 · Ganjoor sh8:26
All four distinguish compassion for helpless Gorgin from cancellation of his responsibility. Rostam will petition Khosrow and brighten the dark moon, but Bijan’s release remains the condition of safety. English preserves that structure. Its ill-willer follows Moscow and Ganjoor, while Mohl and Khaleghi name the champion; actual apparatus records the competing wording. Blood-claim interprets the vengeance in context. A substantial divergence occurs in couplet25. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor make Rostam come first as an avenger; Khaleghi likewise places him at the scene of vengeance. None of these running readings says rescue quest. The following Gudarz-and-Giv threat therefore continues an alternative chain of avengers against Gorgin. English can instead suggest Rostam’s failure to return from a rescue. Yazdan’s strength and the king’s command are retained accurately, but they do not remove this change of purpose. The published English is preserved; the register marks the divergence without manufacturing edition support.
27–30The waiting interval and the royal audience
Individual accounts for English 27–30. V58:852 running text; V58:853 running text; V58 n20 actual third-day variant; V58:854 running text; V58:855 running text
Moscow printed p. 58 · Mohl printed p. 185 · Mohl printed p. 186 · Khaleghi printed p. 365 · Ganjoor sh8:27 · Ganjoor sh8:28 · Ganjoor sh8:29 · Ganjoor sh8:30
Mohl provides the closest running support for the English interval: two days and a night, followed by the third day. Moscow and Ganjoor have one day and a night, then the second day. Khaleghi gives two days and two nights, then the third day. Moscow’s actual apparatus also records third-day wording, while Khaleghi records competing day counts. These must remain distinct accounts rather than a synthetic unanimous chronology. A second difference concerns the actor on the ivory throne. In all four running texts it is the Shah who displays his crown and sits; English transfers both acts to the sun. Khaleghi’s apparatus records moon as an alternative, but that is not evidence for sun. The next English couplet restores the human king explicitly through his solar farr. Rostam’s petition and Gorgin’s ruined fortune agree across the sources, though English omits Rostam’s breast-spreading gesture and adds his stirred thoughts during the wait.
31–34An oath with different celestial witnesses
Individual accounts for English 31–34. V58:856 running text; V58:857 running text; V58 n26 actual Nahid/Bahram and creator alternatives; V58:858 running text; V59:859 running text
Moscow printed p. 58 · Moscow printed p. 59 · Mohl printed p. 186 · Khaleghi printed p. 365 · Ganjoor sh8:31 · Ganjoor sh8:32 · Ganjoor sh8:33 · Ganjoor sh8:34
The king’s resistance rests on a binding royal commitment, not simple unwillingness to hear Rostam. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all retain that obstacle and the requirement that Bijan be released. The English celestial list has particularly clear primary support in Mohl: Bahram and Nahid accompany sun and moon, corresponding to Mars and Venus. Moscow and Ganjoor instead invoke the Lord of Bahram, sun and moon; Khaleghi’s running text has the Lord of Khordad, sun and moon. Actual Moscow and Khaleghi apparatus preserve relevant alternative names, but their main texts should not be reported as the English list. The refusal’s force is maintained when English turns nothing but affliction into no good or grace. Finally, swords, signets, crowns and thrones concretize the extraordinary range of permissible requests. Their abundance makes the single excluded request more emphatic, and prepares the reader for the personal appeal that overturns it.
35–38Repentance as the ground for pardon
Individual accounts for English 35–38. V59:860 running text; V59:861 running text; V59:861 running text; V59:862 running text; V59:862 running text; V59 n8 actual life/name variants; V59:863 running text
Moscow printed p. 59 · Mohl printed p. 186 · Khaleghi printed p. 365 · Khaleghi printed p. 366 · Ganjoor sh8:35 · Ganjoor sh8:36 · Ganjoor sh8:37 · Ganjoor sh8:38
Rostam answers the oath by distinguishing bad intention from a person permanently beyond recovery. All four running accounts acknowledge Gorgin’s harmful purpose and present his present distress and readiness to sacrifice life. English compresses the royal address and admission of wrongdoing, then expands the relation between pardon and inner peace. That pardon would end inward strife is interpretive, rather than a separate action in the source. The next condition has firmer differentiated support: Mohl and Khaleghi explicitly place life alongside name and kish, whereas Moscow and Ganjoor’s main formulations emphasize name and departure from kish. Moscow’s apparatus records related life wording. English faith selects the religious sense and therefore should not be treated as merely another word for reputation. The concluding maxim is shared: whoever turns from reason eventually suffers for the deed. English dust adds an image of abasement without establishing an additional prostration in any of the four running witnesses.
39–42Past service outweighs the present offense
Individual accounts for English 39–42. V59:864 running text; V59:865 running text; V59:866 running text; V59:867 running text
Moscow printed p. 59 · Mohl printed p. 186 · Khaleghi printed p. 366 · Ganjoor sh8:39 · Ganjoor sh8:40 · Ganjoor sh8:41 · Ganjoor sh8:42
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi close the appeal through remembered service, the king’s ancestors, and Rostam’s request that Gorgin be given to him. English battles he has won strengthens the source’s repeated fighting into explicit victories. Service from sire to son interprets the dynastic dimension of the next verse, whose girded belt remains a concrete sign of readiness. The appeal to a good star follows Moscow and Ganjoor’s running wording. Mohl and Khaleghi instead name fortune, with Khaleghi actually recording the star alternative in its apparatus. The final concession is therefore personal and political: Khosrow grants Gorgin to Rostam and releases him. English preserves chains and fetters but replaces the source’s dark pit with grief and pain. That preserves emotional relief while reducing the physical specificity of imprisonment. The chapter ends here; the king’s question about Rostam’s expedition belongs to the next published subchapter.
Source record and limits
C2.19 only:42 English couplets/84 unchanged lines;8 substantive notes. Moscow V57–59:826–867 (42 running units); Mohl III184–186:886–927 (PDF190–192,42 running units); Ganjoor bizhan sh8:1–42; Khaleghi III363–366:792–833 (PDF379–382,42 running units). Every unit accounted individually, with adjacent reuse explicitly registered. Moscow and Mohl checked first, then Ganjoor/Khaleghi comparison. No source-only unit in these boundaries.
Coverage means checked individual accounts, not universal agreement. English25 rescue quest differs from all four vengeance readings. Sun as seated actor in28 is not verified in the checked main texts or selected apparatus; Khaleghi has an actual moon alternative. Different day counts and celestial oath names remain separate. No appendix evidence used; apparatus selectively inspected, not exhaustively transcribed. Inherited provisional flags retained.
All84 indexed English lines compared with retained12 November HTML.
- Moscow: printed 57 / PDF 57 · printed 58 / PDF 58 · printed 59 / PDF 59. Existing PDF reused; PNG facsimiles inspected; no scans included.
- Mohl: printed 184 / PDF 190 · printed 185 / PDF 191 · printed 186 / PDF 192. Existing PDF reused; PNG facsimiles inspected; no scans included.
- Khaleghi: printed 363 / PDF 379 · printed 364 / PDF 380 · printed 365 / PDF 381 · printed 366 / PDF 382. Existing PDF reused; PNG facsimiles inspected; no scans included.
- Ganjoor sh8:1–42 (turn96view0,lines43–205). Poem body only; automated explanations excluded.
No appendix evidence invoked and no checked local gap claimed. Actual Moscow V57n10 sky/work alternatives; V58n15 champion, n20 third day, n26 Nahid/Bahram celestial variants; V59n8 life/name variants inspected. Actual Khaleghi III363n19 crooked-sky wording; III365n6 suspicious-ill-wisher, n13 duration, n17 second/third day, n18 moon, n26 celestial names; III366n13 star variant inspected. The moon alternative is not sun. Selected apparatus is distinguished from the running readings and from unverified interpretation. No addition notice used as proof of unprinted text.
- Moscow V57:834; Mohl III185:894; Khaleghi III364:800; mountain sheep image: چو غرم ژیان
- Moscow V58:850; Ganjoor sh8:25; first avenger, not rescue quest: نخستین من آیم بدین کینهخواه
- Khaleghi III365:816 running; vengeance setting: نخستین من آیم بدین کینهگاه
- Mohl III185:912 running; two days and a night: برآمد برین کار دو روز و شب
- Khaleghi III365:818 running; two days and two nights: برآمد برین بر دو روز و دو شب
- Moscow V58:853 running; second day and king: دوم روز چون شاه بنمود تاج
- Mohl III185:913 running; third day and king: سیم روز چون شه بنمود تاج
- Mohl III186:917 running; celestial names: ببهرام و ناهید و خورشید و ماه
- Khaleghi III365:823 running; Lord of Khordad: به دارای خرداد و خورشید و ماه
- Khaleghi III365n18 actual alternative for شاه; not sun: ماه
- Moscow V59:866 running and actual Khaleghi III366n13 star alternative: اختر
Selected quotations are expressly phrases, hemistichs or single words, not reconstructed complete couplets. Verse register Persian displays the cited Ganjoor unit; source differences remain in the four separate accounts. English25 is a material divergence, not an unreadable source. No new unverified facsimile reading is used as proof.
C2.19 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V57:826 running text | III184:886 running text |
| 2 | V57:827 running text; V57:828 running text | III184:887 running text; III184:888 running text; auspicious and renowned address, not literal farr noun |
| 3 | V57:828 running text; V57:829 running text | III184:888 running text; III185:889 running text |
| 4 | V57:829 running text; V57:830 running text; V57 n10 actual crooked-sky alternatives | III185:889 running text; III185:890 running text |
| 5 | V57:830 running text; V57:831 running text | III185:890 running text; III185:891 running text |
| 6 | V57:831 running text; V57:832 running text | III185:891 running text; III185:892 running text |
| 7 | V57:832 running text; V57:833 running text | III185:892 running text; III185:893 running text |
| 8 | V57:833 running text | III185:893 running text |
| 9 | V57:834 running text | III185:894 running text |
| 10 | V57:835 running text | III185:895 running text |
| 11 | V57:836 running text | III185:896 running text |
| 12 | V57:837 running text | III185:897 running text |
| 13 | V57:838 running text | III185:898 running text |
| 14 | V57:839 running text | III185:899 running text |
| 15 | V57:840 running text | III185:900 running text |
| 16 | V58:841 running text | III185:901 running text |
| 17 | V58:842 running text | III185:902 running text |
| 18 | V58:843 running text | III185:903 running text |
| 19 | V58:844 running text | III185:904 running text |
| 20 | V58:845 running text | III185:905 running text |
| 21 | V58:846 running text | III185:906 running text |
| 22 | V58:847 running text | III185:907 running text |
| 23 | V58:848 running text; V58 n15 actual champion variant | III185:908 running text |
| 24 | V58:849 running text | III185:909 running text |
| 25 | V58:850 running text | III185:910 running text |
| 26 | V58:851 running text | III185:911 running text |
| 27 | V58:852 running text | III185:912 running text |
| 28 | V58:853 running text; V58 n20 actual third-day variant | III185:913 running text |
| 29 | V58:854 running text | III186:914 running text |
| 30 | V58:855 running text | III186:915 running text |
| 31 | V58:856 running text | III186:916 running text |
| 32 | V58:857 running text; V58 n26 actual Nahid/Bahram and creator alternatives | III186:917 running text |
| 33 | V58:858 running text | III186:918 running text |
| 34 | V59:859 running text | III186:919 running text |
| 35 | V59:860 running text; V59:861 running text | III186:920 running text; III186:921 running text |
| 36 | V59:861 running text; V59:862 running text | III186:921 running text; III186:922 running text |
| 37 | V59:862 running text; V59 n8 actual life/name variants | III186:922 running text |
| 38 | V59:863 running text | III186:923 running text |
| 39 | V59:864 running text | III186:924 running text |
| 40 | V59:865 running text | III186:925 running text |
| 41 | V59:866 running text | III186:926 running text |
| 42 | V59:867 running text | III186:927 running text |
New Naqqali