Irman’s People Appeal to Khosrow
C2.2 · Irman’s People Appeal to Khosrow.69 couplets; invocation through Gorgin’s commission, before C2.3 preparations.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | C2.2 · Irman’s People Appeal to Khosrow.69 couplets; invocation through Gorgin’s commission, before C2.3 preparations. |
| Moscow | Volume V1967, printed9–12, running38–105, including bracketed88; PDF pages equal printed. Selected actual apparatus independently read. |
| Mohl | Volume III consulted reprint, printed148–151, running40–108; PDF154–157. No separate critical apparatus on these pages. |
| Ganjoor | bizhan/sh2:1–68, indexed Persian poem body only; section continues into later English subchapters, excluded here. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | Volume III, printed306–310, running24–89 including bracketed85; PDF322–326. Selected actual apparatus read separately. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5Invocation and the restored world
Moscow: V9:37–38 boundary and n1 checked local gap; no invocation printed here | V9:38 running text | V9:39 running text | V9:39 running text; V9:40 running text | V9:40 running text; V9:41 running text; Mohl: III148:40 running text | III148:41 running text | III148:42 running text | III148:42 running text; III148:43 running text | III148:43 running text; III149:44 running text; Ganjoor: Checked local boundary gap at start of sh2; no invocation in indexed poem opening. | sh2:1 indexed poem body | sh2:2 indexed poem body | sh2:2, sh2:3 indexed poem body | sh2:3, sh2:4 indexed poem body; Khaleghi: III306:23–24 boundary and n6 checked local gap; heading variant only, no invocation | III306:24 running text | III306:25 running text | III306:25 running text; III306:26 running text | III306:26 running text; III306:27 running text
Moscow printed p.9 · Mohl printed p.148 · Mohl printed p.149 · Khaleghi printed p.306 · Ganjoor sh2:1 · Ganjoor sh2:2 · Ganjoor sh2:3 · Ganjoor sh2:4
The invocation belongs to this published subchapter, although Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi begin the corresponding narrative directly with Khosrow’s vengeance. Mohl actually prints the invocation, naming the wheeling sky, Tir and Mehr; this is running support, not an inferred addition. English retains those names without requiring their identification here. The next movement redistributes the collapse of Turanian authority and the Iranian king’s elevation. Mohl and Khaleghi have the throne rising toward the sun, while Moscow and Ganjoor have the crown; English follows the former image. Brightening Iran supplies a further consequence. The world-maker wording interprets the syntax of the renewal verse rather than establishing a separate divine intervention. In the favor bestowed on nobles, English may transfer agency from heaven to Khosrow. Faith also gives a religious coloring to the source’s fidelity or loyalty.
6–10The watercourse, two portions and the ruby cup
Moscow: V9:42 running text | V9:43 running text; V9 n9 actual دو بهره variant | V9:44 running text | V9:45 running text | V9:46 running text; V9 n12 actual ruby-cup half-line; Mohl: III149:45 running text | III149:46 running text | III149:47 running text | III149:48 running text | III149:49 running text; Ganjoor: sh2:5 indexed poem body | sh2:6 indexed poem body | sh2:7 indexed poem body | sh2:8 indexed poem body | sh2:9 indexed poem body; Khaleghi: III306:28 running text | III306:29 running text; III306 n14 actual دو بهره variant | III307:30 running text | III307:31 running text; III307 n6 actual کیانی variant | III307:32 running text
Moscow printed p.9 · Mohl printed p.149 · Khaleghi printed p.306 · Khaleghi printed p.307 · Ganjoor sh2:5 · Ganjoor sh2:6 · Ganjoor sh2:7 · Ganjoor sh2:8 · Ganjoor sh2:9
The warning against sleeping in a former watercourse remains vivid in English, though torrent increases the force of the stream named by all four sources. The restored dominion is more textually specific: two parts follows Mohl, with actual corresponding variants in Moscow and Khaleghi, against the single portion in their running texts and Ganjoor. The toast to every warrior interprets remembrance at the feast rather than adding a separately attested action. The royal furnishings then combine readings: the Kayanian cap follows Moscow and Ganjoor, whereas Mohl and Khaleghi print a jeweled cap. Conversely, the ruby wine cup follows Mohl and Khaleghi and an actual Moscow apparatus half-line; Ganjoor merely places wine in the king’s hand. This mixed selection has precise textual support. It should not be described as an accidental luxury invented by the English.
11–15A catalogue made into an assembly
Moscow: V9:47 running text | V9:48 running text | V10:49 running text | V10:50 running text; Mohl: III149:50 running text | III149:51 running text | III149:52 running text | III149:53 running text; Ganjoor: sh2:10 indexed poem body | sh2:11 indexed poem body | sh2:12 indexed poem body | sh2:13 indexed poem body; Khaleghi: III307:33 running text | III307:34 running text | III307:35 running text | III307:36 running text
Moscow printed p.9 · Moscow printed p.10 · Mohl printed p.149 · Khaleghi printed p.307 · Ganjoor sh2:10 · Ganjoor sh2:11 · Ganjoor sh2:12 · Ganjoor sh2:13
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi name the same principal company in this passage, but English changes the distribution of names across its couplets. Gudarz, Farhad, Giv, Gorgin and Shapur occupy one Persian couplet and two English couplets, allowing Keshvad and Milad to remain visible as patronymics. The rearrangement does not add a warrior. Fariborz’s association with Kavus drops out, while first gives him an order of arrival or prominence that the catalogue does not require. Wise, grave and alert supply differentiated qualities rather than translate separate local epithets. Tus’s Nozar affiliation and the martial descriptions of Rohham and Bijan remain recognizable; the published spelling Nohzar is preserved. Raising cups supplies movement to the shared description of wine in hand and devotion to Khosrow. The result stages an assembly from a compact list without changing its membership.
16–18Color, fragrance and the court attendants
Moscow: V10:51 running text | V10:52 running text | V10:53 running text; Mohl: III149:54 running text | III149:55 running text | III149:56 running text; Ganjoor: sh2:14 indexed poem body | sh2:15 indexed poem body | sh2:16 indexed poem body; Khaleghi: III307:37 running text; III307 n14 actual لاله variant | III307:38 running text | III307:39 running text; III307 n16 actual بهار variant
Moscow printed p.10 · Mohl printed p.149 · Khaleghi printed p.307 · Ganjoor sh2:14 · Ganjoor sh2:15 · Ganjoor sh2:16
The English preserves the distinctive comparison of wine to Yemeni carnelian and the floral setting. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor name tulip and nastaran; Khaleghi’s running text has a bouquet of nastaran, with tulip actually recorded in the apparatus. Eglantine is an English floral rendering, not a botanical determination made by this collation. The fairy-faced figures and musk against jasmine are secure across the four presentations, but slaves explicitly assigns a status that the local Persian noun does not state. Spring itself follows Moscow and Ganjoor; Mohl and Khaleghi instead give color and ornament, with the spring reading present in Khaleghi’s apparatus. The final line also expands the staging. The source has the girded court marshal before the king; English places plural girded servants before the marshal. That redistribution of the personnel deserves notice even while the luxurious atmosphere remains faithful.
19–24The petition passes through the court
Moscow: V10:54 running text | V10:55 running text | V10:56 running text | V10:57 running text; V10:58 running text | V10:58 running text | V10:59 running text; Mohl: III149:57 running text | III149:58 running text | III149:59 running text | III149:60 running text; III149:61 running text | III149:61 running text | III149:62 running text; III149:63 running text; Ganjoor: sh2:17 indexed poem body | sh2:18 indexed poem body | sh2:19 indexed poem body | sh2:20, sh2:21 indexed poem body | sh2:21 indexed poem body | sh2:22 indexed poem body; Khaleghi: III307:40 running text | III307:41 running text | III307:42 running text | III307:43 running text; III307:44 running text | III307:44 running text | III307:45 running text; III307:44–45 checked local gap for separate Mohl62 arrival verse; not a gap for weeping itself
Moscow printed p.10 · Mohl printed p.149 · Khaleghi printed p.307 · Ganjoor sh2:17 · Ganjoor sh2:18 · Ganjoor sh2:19 · Ganjoor sh2:20 · Ganjoor sh2:21 · Ganjoor sh2:22
All four accounts preserve the chain of access: a curtain-keeper informs the court officer, the officer approaches Khosrow, obtains permission and brings the petitioners inside. English varies marshal and chamberlain for the officer without requiring two different men. Chiefs is a social specification beyond the Irmanians named in the checked verse, and contested shore should not establish a coastal location: the sources describe a frontier between Iran and Turan. The long journey and request for justice are explicit; fear and grief develop the urgency. Mohl prints an additional arrival couplet describing the petitioners crying before the king. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi do not print that separate unit at this junction, although their next verse already includes weeping during the prostration. Thus English’s cries are supported, while the fuller entrance has particularly close Mohl support. Arms held low simplifies the folded-arm gesture.
25–29Justice across the seven realms
Moscow: V10:59 running text; V10:60 running text | V10:60 running text; V10:61 running text | V10:61 running text; V10:62 running text | V10:63 running text; V10:64 running text; Mohl: III149:63 running text; III149:64 running text | III149:64 running text; III149:65 running text | III149:65 running text; III149:66 running text | III149:67 running text; III149:68 running text; Ganjoor: sh2:22, sh2:23 indexed poem body | sh2:23, sh2:24 indexed poem body | sh2:24, sh2:25 indexed poem body | sh2:26, sh2:27 indexed poem body; Khaleghi: III307:45 running text; III307:46 running text | III307:46 running text; III307:47 running text | III307:47 running text; III308:48 running text | III308:49 running text; III308:50 running text
Moscow printed p.10 · Mohl printed p.149 · Khaleghi printed p.307 · Khaleghi printed p.308 · Ganjoor sh2:22 · Ganjoor sh2:23 · Ganjoor sh2:24 · Ganjoor sh2:25 · Ganjoor sh2:26 · Ganjoor sh2:27
English distributes the prostration, longevity blessing and explanation of origin across new couplet boundaries. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all supply the essential sequence: faces to the ground, a wish for the king’s long life, a distant frontier city and the name Khan-e-Irman. The English removes the more absolute assertion that Khosrow deserves everlasting life, making the greeting easier to hear as ceremonial praise. Its borderland language preserves the relative position between Iran and Turan without warranting a modern geographical identification. The second blessing combines sweetness of life, power over wrongdoers and protection throughout the seven realms. Let evil be laid low turns the king’s capacity to reach evildoers into a wished result; rescue men makes the protective function explicit. These are interpretive adjustments within the shared petition, rather than evidence of an additional source passage.
30–33The woodland as the community’s livelihood
Moscow: V10:65 running text; V10:66 running text | V10:67 running text | V10:68 running text; V10 n17 actual بنیاد variant | V10:69 running text; V10 n18 actual جویبار variant; Mohl: III150:69 running text; III150:70 running text | III150:71 running text | III150:72 running text | III150:73 running text; Ganjoor: sh2:28, sh2:29 indexed poem body | sh2:30 indexed poem body | sh2:31 indexed poem body | sh2:32 indexed poem body; Khaleghi: III308:51 running text; III308:52 running text | III308:53 running text | III308:54 running text | III308:55 running text
Moscow printed p.10 · Mohl printed p.150 · Khaleghi printed p.308 · Ganjoor sh2:28 · Ganjoor sh2:29 · Ganjoor sh2:30 · Ganjoor sh2:31 · Ganjoor sh2:32
The speakers first distinguish the dangerous Turanian border from the woodland toward Iran. All four accounts retain this economic landscape of cultivated ground, fruit trees and grazing, so the English is justified in making the loss more than a hunting inconvenience. Rows and repeated harvests elaborate the abundance. Root and stay is especially important: it follows Mohl’s foundation reading and an actual Moscow apparatus variant. Moscow’s running text, Ganjoor and Khaleghi instead have faryad, the language of a cry or succor; those forms should not silently be transcribed as foundation. The next English couplet follows Moscow and Ganjoor in naming meadow or pasture, whereas Mohl and Khaleghi name the watercourse. Lands adds a general term to the specific losses. The translation therefore combines independently supported features of the fuller landscape, while the register keeps their edition-specific origins visible.
34–38The boars and the limits of recollection
Moscow: V11:70 running text | V11:71 running text | V11:72 running text | V11:73 running text; Mohl: III150:74 running text | III150:75 running text | III150:76 running text | III150:77 running text; Ganjoor: sh2:33 indexed poem body | sh2:34 indexed poem body | sh2:35 indexed poem body | sh2:36 indexed poem body; Khaleghi: III308:56 running text | III308:57 running text | III308:58 running text | III308:59 running text
Moscow printed p.11 · Mohl printed p.150 · Khaleghi printed p.308 · Ganjoor sh2:33 · Ganjoor sh2:34 · Ganjoor sh2:35 · Ganjoor sh2:36
The elephant-like tusks and mountain bodies are common to Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. English expands the single source couplet into size and communal distress, allowing the Irmanians’ suffering to receive its own beat. Hills slightly reduces the scale of mountains, while blocking the sight is supplied. Livestock and cultivated land remain the primary losses; orchard shade develops the neighboring fruit-tree description. The trees beyond recollection present a harder phrase: Moscow and Khaleghi print wording about planted trees, Mohl a closely related construction, while Ganjoor’s local text has the awkward kashtan form. English’s past our reckoning can convey immeasurable number or age without resolving that wording silently. The delighted splitting and the claim that even stone cannot withstand the tusks are retained. Dawn-to-dusk substitutes a sustained image of failing fortune for the source’s abrupt reversal.
39–44Compassion becomes a public challenge
Moscow: V11:74 running text | V11:75 running text | V11:76 running text | V11:77 running text | V11:78 running text; Mohl: III150:78 running text | III150:79 running text | III150:80 running text | III150:81 running text | III150:82 running text; Ganjoor: sh2:37 indexed poem body | sh2:38 indexed poem body | sh2:39 indexed poem body | sh2:40 indexed poem body | sh2:41 indexed poem body; Khaleghi: III308:60 running text | III308:61 running text | III308:62 running text | III308:63 running text | III308:64 running text
Moscow printed p.11 · Mohl printed p.150 · Khaleghi printed p.308 · Ganjoor sh2:37 · Ganjoor sh2:38 · Ganjoor sh2:39 · Ganjoor sh2:40 · Ganjoor sh2:41
Khosrow’s inward pain and compassion anchor the challenge in all four sources. English maintains that sequence: he hears the appeal, suffers with the petitioners and then calls on his champions. Its sorrow aligns directly with Ganjoor and Khaleghi’s phrasing at the transition, whereas Moscow and Mohl use the connective that carries the action into raising his voice. Far and wide extends an address delivered to the gathered court. The offer of fame and combat occupies one Persian couplet but two English couplets, giving the summons a more expansive rhythm. Riding and driving the animals back are elaborations; the following explicit demand for decapitation prevents the task from becoming merely their dispersal. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all support the promise of gems and treasure. English’s shining sword intensifies the visual register without changing the proposed deed or its reward.
45–50Treasure makes the challenge tangible
Moscow: V11:79 running text | V11:80 running text | V11:81 running text | V11:82 running text | V11:83 running text | V11:84 running text; Mohl: III150:83 running text | III150:84 running text | III150:85 running text | III150:86 running text | III150:87 running text | III150:88 running text; Ganjoor: sh2:42 indexed poem body | sh2:43 indexed poem body | sh2:44 indexed poem body | sh2:45 indexed poem body | sh2:46 indexed poem body | sh2:47 indexed poem body; Khaleghi: III309:65 running text | III309:66 running text | III309:67 running text | III309:68 running text | III309:69 running text | III309:70 running text
Moscow printed p.11 · Mohl printed p.150 · Khaleghi printed p.309 · Ganjoor sh2:42 · Ganjoor sh2:43 · Ganjoor sh2:44 · Ganjoor sh2:45 · Ganjoor sh2:46 · Ganjoor sh2:47
The reward is displayed rather than merely promised. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all provide a golden salver, varied jewels, ten gold-bridled horses and Kavus’s brand. English preserves those concrete particulars, including the dynastic mark on the animals; flank specifies its placement beyond the checked wording. The Roman brocade remains a material designation, without requiring a modern provenance claim. The repeated summons to the famous warriors also survives, though the passive addressed makes the summoning less direct. The final question is a significant lexical choice: honor follows Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi’s azarm, whereas Mohl prints desire. English therefore grounds the volunteer’s toil in service to royal honor rather than simply satisfying a wish. Making the king’s treasure his own is securely shared; wholly strengthens the extent without identifying a separate, unlimited grant.
51–55Bijan’s pledge and the apparatus blessing
Moscow: V11:85 running text | V11:86 running text | V11:89 running text; V11 n19 actual جز تو مبیناد ایوان تو variant | V11:89 running text; V11 n19 actual منم گوش داده بفرمان تو; n20 actual پیمان تو | V12:90 running text; Mohl: III150:89 running text | III150:90 running text | III150:91 running text | III150:92 running text | III150:93 running text; Ganjoor: sh2:48 indexed poem body | sh2:49 indexed poem body | sh2:52 indexed poem body | sh2:53 indexed poem body; Khaleghi: III309:71 running text | III309:72 running text | III309:73 running text; III309 n12 actual که جز تو مبیناد ایوان تو variant | III309:73 running text; III309 n12 actual و من گوش داده بفرمان تو; following main command is not silently changed to covenant | III309:74 running text
Moscow printed p.11 · Moscow printed p.12 · Mohl printed p.150 · Khaleghi printed p.309 · Ganjoor sh2:48 · Ganjoor sh2:49 · Ganjoor sh2:52 · Ganjoor sh2:53
The silence of the assembly and Bijan’s solitary advance are shared by all four presentations. The ensuing blessing is not identical. English’s wish that no other master possess the hall has actual printed support in Moscow’s and Khaleghi’s apparatus; it is not their running text, and Mohl instead blesses the hall’s happiness. Ganjoor’s running blessing concerns the soul and the king’s command. The next English couplet closely follows Mohl’s separate pledge of obedience and world-spanning covenant. Moscow actually records the listening phrase and covenant variant, while Khaleghi records the listening phrase without making its running command a covenant. Moscow’s extra longevity blessing and bracketed cup verse, also in Ganjoor and actually printed in Khaleghi’s apparatus, are retained as source-only material. Finally, life and wealth changes the shared pledge of body and soul: the wealth component remains an English substitution, not a verified variant.
56–60Giv asks for experience, not confidence alone
Moscow: V12:91 running text | V12:92 running text; V12:93 running text | V12:94 running text | V12:95 running text | V12:96 running text; Mohl: III151:94 running text | III151:95 running text; III151:96 running text | III151:97 running text | III151:98 running text | III151:99 running text; Ganjoor: sh2:54 indexed poem body | sh2:55, sh2:56 indexed poem body | sh2:57 indexed poem body | sh2:58 indexed poem body | sh2:59 indexed poem body; Khaleghi: III309:75 running text | III309:76 running text; III309:77 running text | III309:78 running text | III309:79 running text | III309:80 running text
Moscow printed p.12 · Mohl printed p.151 · Khaleghi printed p.309 · Ganjoor sh2:54 · Ganjoor sh2:55 · Ganjoor sh2:56 · Ganjoor sh2:57 · Ganjoor sh2:58 · Ganjoor sh2:59
Giv’s concern and his respectful blessing of the king precede the rebuke in Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. English makes the father’s heavy reaction sharper as dissent, but keeps the order that distinguishes loyalty to Khosrow from doubt about the young volunteer. The central word for what youth lacks is experience or testing. Discipline can express the formation that such testing brings, though it narrows a broader encounter with life into training. English further replaces the source’s paired good and bad, bitter and salty experiences with hardship, wounds and weary roads. These are intelligible martial developments, not separately verified details of Bijan’s past. The warning about an untried road remains particularly close. Its final clause, however, omits the explicit danger of losing face before the Shah. English thus preserves prudence while making the threatened dishonor less specifically public and courtly.
61–63Young in years, old in judgment
Moscow: V12:97 running text; V12:98 running text; V12:99 running text | V12:98 running text; V12:99 running text | V12:100 running text; Mohl: III151:100 running text; III151:101 running text; III151:102 running text | III151:101 running text; III151:102 running text | III151:103 running text; Ganjoor: sh2:60, sh2:61, sh2:62 indexed poem body | sh2:61, sh2:62 indexed poem body | sh2:63 indexed poem body; Khaleghi: III310:81 running text; III310:82 running text; III310:83 running text; III310:83 main هشیار پیر; n6 actual جوانم ولیکن بیندیشه پیر form | III310:82 running text; III310:83 running text | III310:84 running text; III310 n7 records reversed hemistich order; not an added couplet
Moscow printed p.12 · Mohl printed p.151 · Khaleghi printed p.310 · Ganjoor sh2:60 · Ganjoor sh2:61 · Ganjoor sh2:62 · Ganjoor sh2:63
All four sources portray Bijan as angered by his father’s speech and then address his answer to the victorious Shah. English drops both the explicit anger and that vocative. The conversational placement can consequently make the reply sound directed chiefly to Giv, even though the source seeks the king’s confidence. Young but old in thought is secure in Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor and actually recorded in Khaleghi’s variants beside its wise-old formulation. Comparing that judgment with the years that make Giv wise is an English personalization without local textual support. The rejection of weakness and the promise to sever the boar’s head remain faithful. Mohl and Khaleghi reverse the order of the two hemistichs identifying Bijan and promising the deed; they do not add another verse. English’s sword and whole armies amplify the army-breaking epithet without requiring its grammatical attachment to be settled here.
64–66The shield and the king’s authorization
Moscow: V12:101 running text; V12:102 running text | V12:102 running text; V12:103 running text | V12:101 running text; Mohl: III151:104 running text; III151:105 running text | III151:105 running text; III151:106 running text | III151:104 running text; Ganjoor: sh2:64, sh2:65 indexed poem body | sh2:65, sh2:66 indexed poem body | sh2:64 indexed poem body; Khaleghi: III310:85 running text; III310:86 running text; III310:85 is bracketed running text, not apparatus-only | III310:86 running text; III310:87 running text; III310 n13 actual نترسد variant | III310:85 running text; III310:85 bracketed running text
Moscow printed p.12 · Mohl printed p.151 · Khaleghi printed p.310 · Ganjoor sh2:64 · Ganjoor sh2:65 · Ganjoor sh2:66
The English moves the blessing and authorization after the royal praise, drawing on the same source unit rather than narrating a second appointment. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor print that unit ordinarily; Khaleghi includes it in brackets in the running text, which must not be mislabeled as apparatus-only evidence. The praise of abundant skill becomes superiority to all other men in English. More substantially, the shield metaphor is transferred from Bijan himself to the man who possesses such a servant. The following Persian judgment also varies: Moscow and Mohl say that such a master does not fear the enemy, while Ganjoor and Khaleghi say that fearing the enemy would make him foolish; Khaleghi actually records the negative reading as a variant. English keeps the general reassurance but removes this verbal contrast. Its combined image is coherent without reproducing every step of the source argument.
67–69Gorgin’s commission and the stopping point
Moscow: V12:104 running text; V12:105 running text | V12:104 running text | V12:105 running text; Mohl: III151:107 running text; III151:108 running text | III151:107 running text | III151:108 running text; Ganjoor: sh2:67, sh2:68 indexed poem body | sh2:67 indexed poem body | sh2:68 indexed poem body; Khaleghi: III310:88 running text; III310:89 running text | III310:88 running text; III310 n14 actual بتوران reading | III310:89 running text
Moscow printed p.12 · Mohl printed p.151 · Khaleghi printed p.310 · Ganjoor sh2:67 · Ganjoor sh2:68
The published subchapter ends with the commission to Gorgin, before Bijan prepares to depart. Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all appoint him as guide and helper as far as the water-barrier. That expression is retained without identifying a modern site or deciding what physical structure the verse describes. English moves the destination before the explanation of Bijan’s ignorance, then closes on the two roles. The Turan route follows Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor; Khaleghi’s running text instead calls Bijan young and unable to find the way, with Turan actually recorded in its apparatus. English’s additional line about approaching the marches expands that ignorance. Counsel and where he shall lead give the relationship a further advisory shape, but neither is a separate verified instruction here. The next preparations belong to C2.3 and are excluded from this package.
Source record and limits
C2.2 only:69 English couplets,138 unchanged published lines,15 substantive notes. Moscow V9–12:38–105; Mohl III148–151:40–108 (PDF154–157); Ganjoor bizhan sh2:1–68 indexed poem body; Khaleghi III306–310:24–89 (PDF322–326). Moscow and Mohl visually inspected individually first; Ganjoor and Khaleghi then compared. Every English couplet has a separate four-edition account; every declared main unit is mapped, including source-only S1.
Ganjoor direct retrieval failed404; indexed Persian poem-body segments were retrieved and collated, excluding AI glosses and comments. Selected Persian readings are not a full diplomatic transcription of each print edition. Apparatus claims refer only to actually read printed wording, not addition notices; no exhaustive apparatus collation or volume-wide appendix search claimed. Checked local gaps do not establish absence throughout an edition or manuscript tradition. No unverified C2.2 reading is used to support the English. Retained C2.1 uncertainty: Mohl III148:28 terminal word after نیرنگ و remains uncertified and unused. All older provisional flags retained verbatim.
Starts “In the name of Yazdan of the wheeling sky,” and ends “And let your counsel go where he shall lead.” The next heading is C2.3, Bijan Goes to Fight the Wild Boars, beginning preparations for departure. All138 English line spans retained exactly, including punctuation and spelling. C2.3 is not collated here.
- Moscow: printed 9 / PDF 9 · printed 10 / PDF 10 · printed 11 / PDF 11 · printed 12 / PDF 12. Retrieved existing volume and inspected local PNG facsimiles. Scans excluded.
- Mohl: printed 148 / PDF 154 · printed 149 / PDF 155 · printed 150 / PDF 156 · printed 151 / PDF 157. Retrieved existing volume and inspected local PNG facsimiles. Scans excluded.
- Khaleghi: printed 306 / PDF 322 · printed 307 / PDF 323 · printed 308 / PDF 324 · printed 309 / PDF 325 · printed 310 / PDF 326. Retrieved existing volume and inspected local PNG facsimiles. Scans excluded.
- Ganjoor bizhan sh2: first68 poem-body units, reconstructed from overlapping indexed retrievals (turn10search0, turn13search0, turn14search0, turn15search0). Direct page fetch failed404. A mirror surfaced during search but was not treated as independent Ganjoor authority. AI text, comments and Tajik transliteration excluded.
Actual apparatus evidence: Moscow V9 n9 prints two portions, n12 the ruby cup; V10 n17 foundation and n18 watercourse; V11 n19 prints the no-other-hall blessing and listening phrase, n20 covenant. Khaleghi III306 n14 prints two portions; III307 n6 Kayanian, n14 tulip and n16 spring; III309 n11 actually prints the additional blessing and cup pair, n12 the no-other-hall and listening variants; III310 n6 records young/old wording, n7 reversed hemistichs, n13 the negative fear reading and n14 Turan. These are actual printed readings, not a generic notice that additions exist. Moscow88 and Khaleghi85 are bracketed running text, not apparatus-only.
Checked local gaps: Moscow V9:37–38 and Khaleghi III306:23–24 with their adjacent apparatus do not supply the Mohl40 invocation; Ganjoor begins sh2 with vengeance. The separate Mohl62 crying arrival has no separate unit between Moscow58–59, Ganjoor21–22 and Khaleghi44–45, although weeping is already present in their prostration verse. Mohl90–91 lacks the separate longevity/cup pair retained as S1. No appendix evidence is used, and no volume-wide absence is certified. Unverified English details include wealth in the body/life pledge, an explicit comparison with Giv’s wisdom, and the closing counsel instruction. They are analyzed as English developments, not repaired or supported by conjectural variants.
- Mohl III148:40 running invocation: بنام خداوند گردان سپهر / خداوند تیر و خداوند مهر
- Moscow V9:37–38 and n1 / Khaleghi III306:23–24 and n6: Checked local invocation gap; no invocation inferred from heading variant.
- Mohl III149:46 running / Moscow V9 n9 / Khaleghi III306 n14 actual variants: دو بهره
- Moscow V9:45 and Ganjoor sh2:8 running: کیانی کلاه
- Mohl III149:48 / Khaleghi III307:31 running: ز گوهر کلاه
- Mohl III149:49 / Khaleghi III307:32 running; Moscow V9 n12 actual half-line: یکی جام یاقوت پر می بچنگ
- Mohl III149:62 extra running arrival: برفتند یکسر بر شاه / غریوان و گریان و فریادخواه
- Moscow V10:53 / Ganjoor sh2:16 running vs Mohl III149:56 / Khaleghi III307:39 running: بهار / نگار
- Mohl III150:72 running; Moscow V10 n17 actual variant: بنیاد
- Moscow V10:68 / Ganjoor sh2:31 / Khaleghi III308:54 running: فریاد
- Moscow V10:69 / Ganjoor sh2:32 vs Mohl III150:73 / Khaleghi III308:55 running: مرغزار / جویبار
- Moscow V11:84 / Ganjoor sh2:47 / Khaleghi III309:70 running vs Mohl III150:88: آزرم / آرزو
- Moscow V11 n19 actual variant; Khaleghi III309 n12 actual variant: جز تو مبیناد ایوان تو
- Mohl III150:92 running; Moscow V11 n19 actual variant: منم گوش داده بفرمان تو
- Mohl III150:92 running and Moscow V11 n20 actual variant: پیمان تو
- Khaleghi III309 n12 actual listening variant: و من گوش داده بفرمان تو
- Moscow V11:87–88 running (88 bracketed); Ganjoor sh2:50–51; Khaleghi III309 n11 actual addition: که جاوید بادی و پیروز و شاد / سرت سبز باد و دلت پر ز داد / گرفته بدست اندرون جام می / شب و روز بر یاد کاووس کی
- All four pledge: Moscow V12:90; Mohl III150:93; Ganjoor sh2:53; Khaleghi III309:74: تن و جان — body and soul/life; no wealth reading verified
- Moscow V12:99 / Mohl III151:102 / Ganjoor sh2:62; Khaleghi III310 n6 actual variant: جوانم ولیکن بیندیشه پیر
- Khaleghi III310:83 running: جوانم به کردار و هشیار پیر
- Moscow V12:103 / Mohl III151:106 running; Khaleghi III310 n13 actual variant: نترسد
- Ganjoor sh2:66 / Khaleghi III310:87 running: بترسد
- Khaleghi III310:85: Bracketed running blessing/authorization, not apparatus-only.
- Khaleghi III310:88 main vs n14 actual variant: جوان / بتوران
- Moscow V12:105 / Mohl III151:108 / Ganjoor sh2:68 / Khaleghi III310:89: همش راهبر باش و هم یارمند
Inherited qualifications remain verbatim in .
C2.2 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V9:37–38 boundary and n1 checked local gap; no invocation printed here | III148:40 running text |
| 2 | V9:38 running text | III148:41 running text |
| 3 | V9:39 running text | III148:42 running text |
| 4 | V9:39 running text; V9:40 running text | III148:42 running text; III148:43 running text |
| 5 | V9:40 running text; V9:41 running text | III148:43 running text; III149:44 running text |
| 6 | V9:42 running text | III149:45 running text |
| 7 | V9:43 running text; V9 n9 actual دو بهره variant | III149:46 running text |
| 8 | V9:44 running text | III149:47 running text |
| 9 | V9:45 running text | III149:48 running text |
| 10 | V9:46 running text; V9 n12 actual ruby-cup half-line | III149:49 running text |
| 11 | V9:47 running text | III149:50 running text |
| 12 | V9:48 running text | III149:51 running text |
| 13 | V9:48 running text | III149:51 running text |
| 14 | V10:49 running text | III149:52 running text |
| 15 | V10:50 running text | III149:53 running text |
| 16 | V10:51 running text | III149:54 running text |
| 17 | V10:52 running text | III149:55 running text |
| 18 | V10:53 running text | III149:56 running text |
| 19 | V10:54 running text | III149:57 running text |
| 20 | V10:55 running text | III149:58 running text |
| 21 | V10:56 running text | III149:59 running text |
| 22 | V10:57 running text; V10:58 running text | III149:60 running text; III149:61 running text |
| 23 | V10:58 running text | III149:61 running text |
| 24 | V10:59 running text | III149:62 running text; III149:63 running text |
| 25 | V10:59 running text; V10:60 running text | III149:63 running text; III149:64 running text |
| 26 | V10:60 running text; V10:61 running text | III149:64 running text; III149:65 running text |
| 27 | V10:61 running text; V10:62 running text | III149:65 running text; III149:66 running text |
| 28 | V10:63 running text; V10:64 running text | III149:67 running text; III149:68 running text |
| 29 | V10:63 running text; V10:64 running text | III149:67 running text; III149:68 running text |
| 30 | V10:65 running text; V10:66 running text | III150:69 running text; III150:70 running text |
| 31 | V10:67 running text | III150:71 running text |
| 32 | V10:68 running text; V10 n17 actual بنیاد variant | III150:72 running text |
| 33 | V10:69 running text; V10 n18 actual جویبار variant | III150:73 running text |
| 34 | V11:70 running text | III150:74 running text |
| 35 | V11:70 running text | III150:74 running text |
| 36 | V11:71 running text | III150:75 running text |
| 37 | V11:72 running text | III150:76 running text |
| 38 | V11:73 running text | III150:77 running text |
| 39 | V11:74 running text | III150:78 running text |
| 40 | V11:75 running text | III150:79 running text |
| 41 | V11:76 running text | III150:80 running text |
| 42 | V11:77 running text | III150:81 running text |
| 43 | V11:77 running text | III150:81 running text |
| 44 | V11:78 running text | III150:82 running text |
| 45 | V11:79 running text | III150:83 running text |
| 46 | V11:80 running text | III150:84 running text |
| 47 | V11:81 running text | III150:85 running text |
| 48 | V11:82 running text | III150:86 running text |
| 49 | V11:83 running text | III150:87 running text |
| 50 | V11:84 running text | III150:88 running text |
| 51 | V11:85 running text | III150:89 running text |
| 52 | V11:86 running text | III150:90 running text |
| 53 | V11:89 running text; V11 n19 actual جز تو مبیناد ایوان تو variant | III150:91 running text |
| 54 | V11:89 running text; V11 n19 actual منم گوش داده بفرمان تو; n20 actual پیمان تو | III150:92 running text |
| 55 | V12:90 running text | III150:93 running text |
| 56 | V12:91 running text | III151:94 running text |
| 57 | V12:92 running text; V12:93 running text | III151:95 running text; III151:96 running text |
| 58 | V12:94 running text | III151:97 running text |
| 59 | V12:95 running text | III151:98 running text |
| 60 | V12:96 running text | III151:99 running text |
| 61 | V12:97 running text; V12:98 running text; V12:99 running text | III151:100 running text; III151:101 running text; III151:102 running text |
| 62 | V12:98 running text; V12:99 running text | III151:101 running text; III151:102 running text |
| 63 | V12:100 running text | III151:103 running text |
| 64 | V12:101 running text; V12:102 running text | III151:104 running text; III151:105 running text |
| 65 | V12:102 running text; V12:103 running text | III151:105 running text; III151:106 running text |
| 66 | V12:101 running text | III151:104 running text |
| 67 | V12:104 running text; V12:105 running text | III151:107 running text; III151:108 running text |
| 68 | V12:104 running text | III151:107 running text |
| 69 | V12:105 running text | III151:108 running text |
New Naqqali