Rostam Goes to Khutan to Piran
C2.21 · Rostam Goes to Khutan to Piran.53 couplets,pre-dawn mustering through the dawn marketplace.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | C2.21 · Rostam Goes to Khutan to Piran.53 couplets,pre-dawn mustering through the dawn marketplace. |
| Moscow | V60–63:892–942;formation later;seven horses,100 jewel camels,ten gift horses in main;Turanian chiefs before Piran;shorter lodging reply;actual apparatus alternatives recorded. |
| Mohl | III187–189:953–1005,PDF193–195;formation early;seven horses,ten jewel camels,two gift horses;Piran absent;fuller praise978;wealth/outside lodging997–998;guards1000. |
| Ganjoor | bizhan sh9:1–51 indexed poem body;Moscow-like running sequence and shorter praise/lodging passages. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | III368–371:858–908,PDF384–387;formation early;seven horses,100 jewel camels,two gift horses;Khutan spectators in actual369n9;empty forecourt;wealth offer in main;guards in actual371n17. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5A martial departure before the disguise
Individual accounts for English 1–5. V60:892 running text; V61:897 running text; later placement; V61n1/n6 placement notices distinguished from printed verse897; V61:893 running text; V61:894 running text; V61:895 running text; V61:896 running text
Moscow printed p. 60 · Moscow printed p. 61 · Mohl printed p. 187 · Khaleghi printed p. 368 · Ganjoor sh9:1 · Ganjoor sh9:2 · Ganjoor sh9:3 · Ganjoor sh9:4 · Ganjoor sh9:5 · Ganjoor sh9:6
All four begin with warriors girding themselves before daylight, but their arrangement differs. Mohl and Khaleghi put the chiefs ahead of the following troops immediately after the gate scene, as English does. Moscow and Ganjoor delay this formation until Rostam appears, and separately enumerate spear-bearing border lords. English compresses that martial enumeration into armed troops. It also interprets hands washed in blood as familiarity with battle, reducing the literal force of the image. At dawn Mohl makes drums sound from the court, supporting the English setting; Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi instead strap the kus onto an elephant. Tabiras therefore changes the instrument name while keeping the ceremonial sound. Rostam’s cypress stature, hand-held mace and saddle-mounted lasso remain shared. The passage establishes the visible warrior identity that the subsequent merchant clothes must conceal.
6–10The army waits while the chiefs advance
Individual accounts for English 6–10. V61:898 running text; V61:899 running text; V61:900 running text; V61:901 running text; V61:902 running text
Moscow printed p. 61 · Mohl printed p. 188 · Khaleghi printed p. 368 · Ganjoor sh9:7 · Ganjoor sh9:8 · Ganjoor sh9:9 · Ganjoor sh9:10 · Ganjoor sh9:11
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi agree on departure with blessings for the country, selection of chiefs near Turan, and instructions to the waiting force. English supplies seven at the selection point from the expedition’s established design; the individual source verse merely speaks of choosing the leaders. Its cheerful hearts interpret bright spirits without weakening the command to stay. The condition allowing departure is severe and explicit: the holy divine power must first separate Rostam’s soul from his body. English preserves this condition and its theological agency. Battle readiness then returns through claws sharpened for blood. To rend your prey extends the animal metaphor, but the underlying aggression belongs to all four presentations. These instructions make the disguise a limited tactical operation supported by an armed reserve, rather than a renunciation of the force with which Rostam set out.
11–16Merchant clothing and disputed animal counts
Individual accounts for English 11–16. V61:903 running text; V61:904 running text; V61:905 running text; V61:906 running text; V61:907 running text; V61 n17 actual eight alternative; V61:908 running text
Moscow printed p. 61 · Mohl printed p. 188 · Khaleghi printed p. 368 · Khaleghi printed p. 369 · Ganjoor sh9:12 · Ganjoor sh9:13 · Ganjoor sh9:14 · Ganjoor sh9:15 · Ganjoor sh9:16 · Ganjoor sh9:17
All four leave the army at the frontier and change the travelers into merchants. Silver belts give way to plain gelim garments; English woolen robes makes the change legible while its hostile eyes explains the disguise’s purpose. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi explicitly locate the waiting force at Iran’s border, whereas Mohl says that frontier. The colored, fragrant caravan remains common. Its numbers require separate treatment. All four running texts say seven horses and then include Rakhsh in the description. English eight has actual support in Moscow’s printed apparatus, not in Mohl’s running text; it should not be presented as unanimous agreement. For jewel-bearing camels, however, Mohl gives ten, agreeing with English, while Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi give a hundred. All four retain the hundred camel-loads of army garments. The register preserves these different counts rather than harmonizing the caravan silently.
17–21A noisy caravan and an empty forecourt
Individual accounts for English 17–21. V61:909 running text; V61:910 running text; V61 n22–23 actual resounding-plain alternatives; V62:911 running text; V62:912 running text; V62:913 running text
Moscow printed p. 61 · Moscow printed p. 62 · Mohl printed p. 188 · Khaleghi printed p. 369 · Ganjoor sh9:18 · Ganjoor sh9:19 · Ganjoor sh9:20 · Ganjoor sh9:21 · Ganjoor sh9:22
The bell-and-cry comparison with a Tahmuras-associated horn is shared by Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. English gives the caravan’s noise a bodily effect when the countryside shakes. Mohl and Khaleghi describe the resounding plain, while Moscow and Ganjoor’s main text instead mentions carrying a litter from town to town; Moscow’s apparatus actually records the sound alternatives. Khutan’s male and female spectators stand in Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor main, and in a fully printed Khaleghi apparatus addition. English then follows Mohl’s absence of Piran and absence of anyone at his gate. Moscow and Ganjoor instead place Turanian heroes before him. Khaleghi main gives an empty forecourt, and its apparatus records wording like Mohl’s fuller absence statement. These are materially different staging choices. All four nevertheless proceed to Piran returning from the hunt and Rostam seeing him on the road.
22–26Gifts and praise open the approach
Individual accounts for English 22–26. V62:914 running text; V62:915 running text; V62 n5 actual two alternative; V62:916 running text; V62:917 running text; V62:917–918 checked local gap; inspected n8–9 no matching full praise
Moscow printed p. 62 · Mohl printed p. 188 · Khaleghi printed p. 369 · Ganjoor sh9:23 · Ganjoor sh9:24 · Ganjoor sh9:25 · Ganjoor sh9:26
The jeweled golden cup and brocade covering are shared, but the gift horses differ. Mohl and Khaleghi give two; Moscow and Ganjoor give ten, with two actually recorded in Moscow’s apparatus. English’s jeweled, golden saddles also fit Mohl’s description more closely than the other running texts’ emphasis on adornment and brocade. Entrusting gifts to attendants and moving toward Piran then preserves the etiquette of approach. The blessing of Piran’s fame in Iran and Turan occurs in all four, though English adds a bow. Its next couplet has independent Mohl support: incomparable glory and crown accompany the description of Piran as the king’s counsellor and ornament of the seat. The checked Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi transitions lack that particular praise; locally inspected apparatus does not supply it. This bounded result supports Mohl’s fuller address without pretending to establish absence throughout each edition’s manuscript tradition.
27–31Divine concealment and a plausible trading identity
Individual accounts for English 27–31. V62:918 running text; V62:919 running text; V62:920 running text; V62:921 running text; V62:922 running text
Moscow printed p. 62 · Mohl printed p. 188 · Mohl printed p. 189 · Khaleghi printed p. 370 · Ganjoor sh9:27 · Ganjoor sh9:28 · Ganjoor sh9:29 · Ganjoor sh9:30 · Ganjoor sh9:31
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi attribute the successful concealment to the World-Lord’s arrangement of Rostam’s face. English Maker and God preserve that agency, while grace adds an explicitly benevolent interpretation. The failure of recognition is therefore more than a claim that merchant garments alone deceive Piran. Piran’s questions of origin, identity and hurried arrival receive the same basic answer in all four: the speaker is his lesser servant, God has placed his livelihood in this city, and trade has brought him by a long difficult road from Iran. English subject gives the deferential address a more political shade, while for gain states the motive of commerce. Buying and selling diverse things completes the cover story. Valuable and rare heightens the merchandise beyond the general source wording, fitting the impressive gifts already placed before the reader.
32–37Patronage expressed in the language of commerce
Individual accounts for English 32–37. V62:923 running text; V62:924 running text; V62:925 running text; V62:926 running text; V62:927 running text; V62:928 running text
Moscow printed p. 62 · Mohl printed p. 189 · Khaleghi printed p. 370 · Ganjoor sh9:32 · Ganjoor sh9:33 · Ganjoor sh9:34 · Ganjoor sh9:35 · Ganjoor sh9:36 · Ganjoor sh9:37
All four connect confidence in Piran’s affection with the hope of trading under his protection. English shade makes the Persian sheltering arm or embrace into a familiar image of patronage. The projected exchange of jewels for quadrupeds remains specific; livestock is a broad, defensible rendering of that animal category. Justice prevents interference, and affection becomes a cloud raining jewels. English makes the latter a blessing or request, retaining its productive ambiguity between commercial success and a patron’s generosity. The cup is then presented. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor emphasize a royal jewel cup among the nobles; Khaleghi’s main description stresses a large golden cup and fitting jewels, with related alternatives actually recorded below. The Arab horses whose hair the wind cannot dust maintain their extraordinary polish in every version. English finally makes Rostam’s agency in arranging the transaction explicit, strengthening his control of the encounter.
38–43Piran offers safety and kinship
Individual accounts for English 38–43. V62:929 running text; V62:930 running text; V63:931 running text; V63:932 running text; V63:933 running text; V63:934 running text
Moscow printed p. 62 · Moscow printed p. 63 · Mohl printed p. 189 · Khaleghi printed p. 370 · Khaleghi printed p. 371 · Ganjoor sh9:38 · Ganjoor sh9:39 · Ganjoor sh9:40 · Ganjoor sh9:41 · Ganjoor sh9:42 · Ganjoor sh9:43
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all make Piran inspect the gems, honor Rostam and seat him on a turquoise throne. English reverses the verbal order of praise and seating without changing the welcome. The invitation combines entry into the city with freedom from fear. Moscow and Mohl support Piran arranging nearby lodging; Khaleghi’s main wording instead instructs the guest to make his lodging, with related alternatives recorded in apparatus. The protection of goods is shared. English fight gives the possible dispute over wealth a strong physical sense, though the commercial situation also permits a less violent reading of the Persian term. Bringing sale goods and finding purchasers follows naturally from that guarantee. The offer of the son’s house then extends hospitality into kinlike affiliation. English hand in hand embodies this relationship, but no separate handclasp is narrated in the four running texts.
44–48A courteous refusal of closer lodging
Individual accounts for English 44–48. V63:935 running text; V63 n9 actual added wealth-and-lodging verses at935–936; V63:935 running text; no explicit outside atV63:935–936; V63:936 running text; V63:937 running text
Moscow printed p. 63 · Mohl printed p. 189 · Khaleghi printed p. 371 · Ganjoor sh9:44 · Ganjoor sh9:45 · Ganjoor sh9:46
Mohl gives the fullest direct support for English’s courteous progression: cheerful willingness to stay, an offer of all wealth to Piran, and an explicit request to remain outside with the caravan. Moscow’s running reply is shorter, while its apparatus actually prints wealth-and-lodging additions. Ganjoor preserves the shorter sequence. Khaleghi includes the wealth offer in main and explicitly recalls bringing the caravan from Iran, but does not specify outside in the checked reply. English thus follows a verified primary spatial detail rather than inventing distance from Piran. All four give the mixed company and safeguarding jewels as Rostam’s stated reason; that explanation also serves his concealed purpose. Piran’s final assistance differs: Mohl promises guards, while Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi main offer guidance. Khaleghi’s actual apparatus records guards. English’s protection from harm expands their expected function without changing the courteous resolution.
49–53The lodging becomes a public marketplace
Individual accounts for English 49–53. V63:938 running text; V63:939 running text; V63:940 running text; V63:941 running text; V63:942 running text
Moscow printed p. 63 · Mohl printed p. 189 · Khaleghi printed p. 371 · Ganjoor sh9:47 · Ganjoor sh9:48 · Ganjoor sh9:49 · Ganjoor sh9:50 · Ganjoor sh9:51
The final movement is common to Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi: Rostam takes a house, puts his baggage inside, and becomes known as an Iranian merchant arriving before Piran. English filled its space adds fullness to the act of installing the goods, without a source inventory establishing how completely the rooms were occupied. Buyers attend to the news, and the English pricked ears gives their interest an animated bodily form. The list of brocade, furnishings and gems is preserved, with carpets choosing a concrete sense for farsh. The last couplet turns the sun’s adornment of the world into the opening of commerce. Warehouse specifies the lodging’s practical use. The Persian habitual verb forms can suggest a repeated morning market, whereas English presents a single dawn transition. This public commercial success completes the disguise before Manijeh hears of the caravan in the next subchapter.
Source record and limits
C2.21 only:53 English couplets/106 unchanged lines;10 substantive notes. Moscow V60–63:892–942 (51 running units); Mohl III187–189:953–1005 (PDF193–195,53 running units); Ganjoor bizhan sh9:1–51; Khaleghi III368–371:858–908 (PDF384–387,51 running units). All declared running units accounted,including adjacent reuse,relocation and bounded gaps. Moscow and Mohl individually checked first,then Ganjoor/Khaleghi comparison. No separate source-only row required;Moscow893 enumeration is accounted under English3 and Khaleghi899 caravan-route statement under44/46.
Coverage means individual verified accounts,not universal agreement. All four main texts say seven horses;actual Moscow61n17 supports eight. Mohl supports ten jewel camels,absent Piran,fuller praise,outside lodging and guards. Actual Khaleghi369n9 prints the Khutan spectators absent from main. Checked local gaps remain bounded. No appendix evidence used;apparatus selectively read,not exhaustively transcribed. Inherited provisional flags retained.
All106 indexed English lines compared with retained12 November HTML.
- Moscow: printed 60 / PDF 60 · printed 61 / PDF 61 · printed 62 / PDF 62 · printed 63 / PDF 63. Existing PDF reused;PNG facsimiles inspected;scans excluded.
- Mohl: printed 187 / PDF 193 · printed 188 / PDF 194 · printed 189 / PDF 195. Existing PDF reused;PNG facsimiles inspected;scans excluded.
- Khaleghi: printed 368 / PDF 384 · printed 369 / PDF 385 · printed 370 / PDF 386 · printed 371 / PDF 387. Existing PDF reused;PNG facsimiles inspected;scans excluded.
- Ganjoor sh9:1–51 (turn102view0,lines43–240). Poem body only;automated explanations excluded.
No appendix evidence used. Actual Moscow V61n17 eight horses,n22–23 resounding plain; V62n5 two gift horses; V63n9 full wealth/lodging additions read. Moscow61n1/n6 placement notices are not treated as unprinted text:main897 supplies the relocated formation. Actual Khaleghi III369n9 full Khutan spectator verse,n11 Piran absence and empty gate,n18 court; III370n21–22 royal-cup/among-nobles alternatives,n34 lodging wording; III371n17 guards read. Mohl978 fuller praise has checked main gaps at Moscow917–918/Ganjoor26–27/Khaleghi881–882;inspected Moscow62n8–9 and Khaleghi369n21/370n1 do not print that specific praise. English45 has Mohl997/Khaleghi900 main and Moscow63n9 actual apparatus,with Ganjoor44–45 local gap. Explicit outside lodging in Mohl998 is not present at checked Moscow935–936/Khaleghi899–902. No global absence claim.
- Moscow V61n17 actual alternative to seven horses;word only: هشت
- Mohl III188:968 running;number phrase only: ده اشتر
- Mohl III188:972 second hemistich;empty gate: نه کس پیش درگاه او در بپای
- Khaleghi III369n9 actual full addition,spacing normalized: چو آمد به نزدیک شهر ختن / نظاره بیامد برش مرد و زن
- Mohl III188:978 running,fuller praise;spacing normalized: چو تو کس نباشد به فر و کلاه / که دستور شاهی و زیبای گاه
- Mohl III189:997 running,wealth and lodging;spacing normalized: همه خواسته سر بسر مر تراست / هر آنجا که باشم ازین پس رواست
- Mohl III189:998 first hemistich;outside lodging: به بیرون فرود آمدم ای پهلوان
- Mohl III189:1000 second hemistich;guards: کنم پاسبانان به پیشت بپای
- Moscow V63:937/Ganjoor46 main;guidance: کنم رهنمایی به پیشت بپای
Quoted phrases,hemistichs and complete verses are labeled separately. English26/45 display Mohl Persian because Ganjoor has checked gaps. Other register excerpts display their cited Ganjoor unit;the four accounts distinguish competing readings. Khaleghi’s caravan-route statement is retained in the44/46 accounts. No English repairs made and no new unreadable primary passage used as proof.
C2.21 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V60:892 running text | III187:953 running text |
| 2 | V61:897 running text; later placement; V61n1/n6 placement notices distinguished from printed verse897 | III187:954 running text |
| 3 | V61:893 running text; V61:894 running text | III187:955 running text |
| 4 | V61:895 running text | III187:956 running text |
| 5 | V61:896 running text | III187:957 running text |
| 6 | V61:898 running text | III188:958 running text |
| 7 | V61:899 running text | III188:959 running text |
| 8 | V61:900 running text | III188:960 running text |
| 9 | V61:901 running text | III188:961 running text |
| 10 | V61:902 running text | III188:962 running text |
| 11 | V61:903 running text | III188:963 running text |
| 12 | V61:904 running text | III188:964 running text |
| 13 | V61:905 running text | III188:965 running text |
| 14 | V61:906 running text | III188:966 running text |
| 15 | V61:907 running text; V61 n17 actual eight alternative | III188:967 running text |
| 16 | V61:908 running text | III188:968 running text |
| 17 | V61:909 running text | III188:969 running text |
| 18 | V61:910 running text; V61 n22–23 actual resounding-plain alternatives | III188:970 running text |
| 19 | V62:911 running text | III188:971 running text |
| 20 | V62:912 running text | III188:972 running text |
| 21 | V62:913 running text | III188:973 running text |
| 22 | V62:914 running text | III188:974 running text |
| 23 | V62:915 running text; V62 n5 actual two alternative | III188:975 running text |
| 24 | V62:916 running text | III188:976 running text |
| 25 | V62:917 running text | III188:977 running text |
| 26 | V62:917–918 checked local gap; inspected n8–9 no matching full praise | III188:978 running text |
| 27 | V62:918 running text | III188:979 running text |
| 28 | V62:919 running text | III188:980 running text |
| 29 | V62:920 running text | III188:981 running text |
| 30 | V62:921 running text | III188:982 running text |
| 31 | V62:922 running text | III189:983 running text |
| 32 | V62:923 running text | III189:984 running text |
| 33 | V62:924 running text | III189:985 running text |
| 34 | V62:925 running text | III189:986 running text |
| 35 | V62:926 running text | III189:987 running text |
| 36 | V62:927 running text | III189:988 running text |
| 37 | V62:928 running text | III189:989 running text |
| 38 | V62:929 running text | III189:990 running text |
| 39 | V62:930 running text | III189:991 running text |
| 40 | V63:931 running text | III189:992 running text |
| 41 | V63:932 running text | III189:993 running text |
| 42 | V63:933 running text | III189:994 running text |
| 43 | V63:934 running text | III189:995 running text |
| 44 | V63:935 running text | III189:996 running text |
| 45 | V63 n9 actual added wealth-and-lodging verses at935–936 | III189:997 running text |
| 46 | V63:935 running text; no explicit outside atV63:935–936 | III189:998 running text |
| 47 | V63:936 running text | III189:999 running text |
| 48 | V63:937 running text | III189:1000 running text |
| 49 | V63:938 running text | III189:1001 running text |
| 50 | V63:939 running text | III189:1002 running text |
| 51 | V63:940 running text | III189:1003 running text |
| 52 | V63:941 running text | III189:1004 running text |
| 53 | V63:942 running text | III189:1005 running text |
New Naqqali