Manijeh Seeks Out Rostam
C2.22 · Manijeh Seeks Out Rostam. 54 couplets, caravan news through the gift of food and concealed ring.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | C2.22 · Manijeh Seeks Out Rostam. 54 couplets, caravan news through the gift of food and concealed ring. |
| Moscow | V63–66:943–992. 50 main units. Four fuller request verses actually printed in64n12/65n13. Main pit full of blood; ending-of-suffering prayer; blessing instead of tears. |
| Mohl | III190–192:1005–1058 / PDF196–198. 54 main units. Fuller requests, bare head, bloody garments, mercy prayer, Rostam’s tears, bread around bird and ring inside bird. Fresh start corrects inherited1006 candidate to1005. |
| Ganjoor | bizhan sh10:1–50. Moscow-like 50-unit main sequence, checked gaps for four fuller request verses. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | III372–375:909–958 / PDF388–391. 50 main units. Garments, pallor and Rostam’s tears; ending-of-suffering prayer. Selected actual alternatives and checked local gaps separately recorded. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6A blessing opens the appeal
Individual accounts for English 1–6. V63:943 running text; V63:944 running text; V63:945 running text; V64:946 running text; V64:947 running text; V64:948 running text
Moscow printed p. 63 · Moscow printed p. 64 · Mohl printed p. 190 · Khaleghi printed p. 372 · Ganjoor sh10:1 · Ganjoor sh10:2 · Ganjoor sh10:3 · Ganjoor sh10:4 · Ganjoor sh10:5 · Ganjoor sh10:6
All four presentations begin with news of the caravan and Manijeh running into town. Her approach combines royal identity with visible deprivation. Mohl explicitly describes her bare head, supporting the English choice more narrowly than the uncovered and lamenting figure in Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. The sleeve wiping bloody tears accompanies an elaborate blessing; Mohl also places that gesture before the spoken inquiry, as English does. Life, wealth, freedom from regret and protection from the evil eye remain shared. The last wish shifts slightly: Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi describe the hope for which the merchant girded himself, whereas Mohl begins with its fulfillment. English follows that affirmative movement and makes freedom from commercial loss into positive prosperity. These wishes let a desperate petitioner recognize the merchant’s interests before asking him to attend to hers.
7–13Kinship and the bodily cost of captivity
Individual accounts for English 7–13. V64:949 running text; V64:950 running text; V64:951 running text; V64:952 running text; V64:953 running text; V64:954 running text; V64 n19 actual garment alternative; V64:955 running text
Moscow printed p. 64 · Mohl printed p. 190 · Khaleghi printed p. 372 · Ganjoor sh10:7 · Ganjoor sh10:8 · Ganjoor sh10:9 · Ganjoor sh10:10 · Ganjoor sh10:11 · Ganjoor sh10:12 · Ganjoor sh10:13
Wisdom as teacher and fortunate Iran introduce the inquiry in all four. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor name Giv and Gudarz directly; Khaleghi’s main wording instead speaks of Iran and its army champion, while its printed apparatus supplies named alternatives. English then makes the grandfather’s role as remedy an explicit rescue. The description of hardship breaking the youth’s waist becomes a spine bowed by pain, with the qualification that it seems to break. The physical suffering is preserved without insisting on a literal fracture. Blood belongs to different spaces: Mohl and Khaleghi stain the garments, while Moscow and Ganjoor fill the pit; actual apparatus records the competing words. English follows the garment reading. Its sleepless concern for Bijan also fits Mohl more closely than the other main texts’ reference to Manijeh’s own distress or poverty, strengthening the passage’s relational focus.
14–19An early request and an alarming refusal
Individual accounts for English 14–19. V64 n12 actual added verse 1 of 3 at951–952; early placement differs from Mohl; V64 n12 actual added verse 2 of 3 at951–952; early placement differs from Mohl; V64 n12 actual added verse 3 of 3 at951–952; early placement differs from Mohl; V64:956 running text; V64:957 running text; V64:958 running text
Moscow printed p. 64 · Mohl printed p. 190 · Khaleghi printed p. 372 · Khaleghi printed p. 373 · Ganjoor sh10:14 · Ganjoor sh10:15 · Ganjoor sh10:16
Mohl prints the first three-couplet request to carry news to Iran continuously before Rostam’s outburst. Moscow actually prints a corresponding three-verse addition in its apparatus, placed earlier in the lament; this is textual evidence, not an unprinted addition notice. Ganjoor and Khaleghi’s checked main transitions lack this first request, and the inspected local Khaleghi apparatus does not supply it. Their later appeal remains separately accounted for. English therefore follows a verified fuller sequence, although its multiplication of pains specifies the source warning that the situation will worsen. All four then narrate Rostam’s fear, shout and denial of knowing the Iranian leaders. English preserves the alarm without explaining it as fear of discovery, which is a plausible narrative inference rather than an explicit statement. The deliberately empty-headed merchant reply makes the rebuff sound harsh to Manijeh while sustaining his disguise.
20–24Manijeh challenges the merchant’s conduct
Individual accounts for English 20–24. V64:959 running text; V64:960 running text; V64:961 running text; V64:962 running text; V65:963 running text
Moscow printed p. 64 · Moscow printed p. 65 · Mohl printed p. 190 · Mohl printed p. 191 · Khaleghi printed p. 373 · Ganjoor sh10:17 · Ganjoor sh10:18 · Ganjoor sh10:19 · Ganjoor sh10:20 · Ganjoor sh10:21
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all give Manijeh a tearful response followed by a pointed ethical challenge. English moves the bloody tears across her breast, choosing a more elevated bodily location for the source lap or bosom. Cold speech becomes heartless speech, making the judgment explicit. Her request is modest and precise: even if the merchant will not answer, he should not drive her away. English adds helplessness and weariness to the wounded heart but preserves that distinction between silence and expulsion. The appeal to Iranian custom then tests the national identity she hopes will help Bijan. Rostam answers with the startling Ahriman image shared by all four. English capitalizes Judgment, emphasizing judicial catastrophe where resurrection or overwhelming upheaval is also available. The exchange allows Manijeh to rebuke a powerful stranger without yet knowing whom she addresses.
25–30The trading excuse gives way to food
Individual accounts for English 25–30. V65:964 running text; V65:965 running text; V65:966 running text; V65:967 running text; V65:968 running text; V65:969 running text
Moscow printed p. 65 · Mohl printed p. 191 · Khaleghi printed p. 373 · Ganjoor sh10:22 · Ganjoor sh10:23 · Ganjoor sh10:24 · Ganjoor sh10:25 · Ganjoor sh10:26 · Ganjoor sh10:27
All four preserve Rostam’s explanation that Manijeh interrupted his commerce, followed by an effort to soften his harshness. English makes the marketplace and the pursuit of gain explicit, developing a merchant identity already established in the episode. His denial of residence in Khosrow’s city and acquaintance with Giv and Gudarz remains part of that spoken cover story; it should not be reported as the narrator’s factual account. The sequence then changes from refusal to practical assistance. Rostam orders all available food placed before her before questioning her circumstances further. English’s food they had to share suggests generosity without changing that order. Its questioning at length interprets the source’s stepwise inquiry. The common sequence matters: compassion appears through an action while his public identity remains concealed, so food can begin to repair the cruelty of his words without an immediate revelation.
31–36A renewed demand for news and recognition
Individual accounts for English 31–36. V65:970 running text; V65 n9 actual royal-throne alternative; V65:971 running text; V65:972 running text; V65 n13 actual full added news-request verse at972–973; V65:973 running text; V65:974 running text
Moscow printed p. 65 · Mohl printed p. 191 · Khaleghi printed p. 373 · Ganjoor sh10:28 · Ganjoor sh10:29 · Ganjoor sh10:30 · Ganjoor sh10:31 · Ganjoor sh10:32
Mohl and Khaleghi explicitly mention the royal throne in Rostam’s question; Moscow’s main text names the army leader and its apparatus records the throne alternative, while Ganjoor names king and army. All ask why she watches the road to Iran. Her answer returns to the painful journey from the pit. Mohl then gives a separate request for news of Giv and Gudarz, also actually printed as an addition in Moscow. The checked Ganjoor and Khaleghi transitions lack that separate verse. English preserves this renewed insistence before the warriorlike-shout accusation. The appeal to the Judge is shared, though English turns a past-tense rebuke into a present moral question. Her declaration of royal identity follows in every version. The sun never seeing her uncovered face becomes the English unveiled image, conveying former seclusion without establishing a separate narrated act of removing a veil.
37–42Two forms of despair
Individual accounts for English 37–42. V65:975 running text; V65 n17 actual yellow-cheek alternative; V65:976 running text; V65:977 running text; V65:978 running text; V65:979 running text; V65:980 running text
Moscow printed p. 65 · Mohl printed p. 191 · Khaleghi printed p. 374 · Ganjoor sh10:33 · Ganjoor sh10:34 · Ganjoor sh10:35 · Ganjoor sh10:36 · Ganjoor sh10:37 · Ganjoor sh10:38
Mohl and Khaleghi’s yellow cheeks support English pallor; Moscow and Ganjoor instead describe wandering round and round, with yellow cheeks actually recorded in Moscow’s apparatus. All four give collected kashkin bread and a divinely decreed fate. The English barley bread fixes the grain more narrowly than this collation verifies, so that identification remains qualified. The next prayer is more consequential. Mohl asks for divine mercy, supporting English, whereas Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi ask the Creator to bring the suffering or life to an end. Bijan’s own request for death then follows in all four. English thus keeps the two sufferers’ petitions distinct in the manner supported by Mohl. Darkness and heavy bonds retain their bodily force. The final multiplication of tears interprets the source image of tears flowing or being drained, while the added restless heart continues the emotional emphasis.
43–48Urgency answered by tenderness
Individual accounts for English 43–48. V66:981 running text; V66:982 running text; V66:983 running text; V66:984 running text; V66:985 running text; V66 n7 actual tears-of-affection alternative; V66:986 running text
Moscow printed p. 66 · Mohl printed p. 191 · Khaleghi printed p. 374 · Ganjoor sh10:39 · Ganjoor sh10:40 · Ganjoor sh10:41 · Ganjoor sh10:42 · Ganjoor sh10:43 · Ganjoor sh10:44
The renewed appeal to Gudarz, Giv and Rostam at Khosrow’s court appears in all four main texts. English makes the warning especially urgent: worsening circumstances become an explicit threat that Bijan will die in the pit. Stone above and iron below preserve the source’s compressed image of vertical confinement, with brow personalizing the stone’s position. Rostam’s response differs. Mohl and Khaleghi explicitly give tears of affection, supporting English’s tender transition. Moscow and Ganjoor instead bless the endurance of Manijeh’s love; Moscow’s actual apparatus records the tears, and Khaleghi’s records the blessing. English moves the address to the beautiful woman into the next couplet, so the emotional turn remains continuous. All four then suggest nobles petitioning her father. This advice is what Rostam says while disguised; the text does not establish that he sincerely expects it to replace his own rescue mission.
49–54Food carries a concealed promise
Individual accounts for English 49–54. V66:987 running text; V66:988 running text; V66:989 running text; V66:990 running text; V66:991 running text; V66:992 running text
Moscow printed p. 66 · Mohl printed p. 192 · Khaleghi printed p. 374 · Khaleghi printed p. 375 · Ganjoor sh10:45 · Ganjoor sh10:46 · Ganjoor sh10:47 · Ganjoor sh10:48 · Ganjoor sh10:49 · Ganjoor sh10:50
All four connect the father’s possible pity with the burning liver image. Mohl makes love boil where the other main texts make blood boil; English’s stirring love follows Mohl while retaining the unfamiliar bodily seat of feeling. Rostam’s conditional generosity and order for dishes then agree across the sources. English narrates the food being brought, adding fulfillment to the instruction. The preparation is more specific in Mohl: soft bread wraps around the roasted bird, and the ring is hidden inside the bird. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi use less explicit pronominal constructions, with explicit bird wording also printed in Khaleghi’s apparatus. English follows the primary detail while keeping the pari comparison for Rostam’s deft hand. His final address recognizes Manijeh as guide of the helpless. The food becomes a covert means of communication, though recognition of the ring belongs to the following subchapter.
Source record and limits
C2.22 only: 54 English couplets / 108 unchanged lines; 9 substantive notes. Moscow V63–66:943–992 (50 running units); Mohl III190–192:1005–1058 (PDF196–198, 54 running units); Ganjoor bizhan sh10:1–50; Khaleghi III372–375:909–958 (PDF388–391, 50 running units). Every running unit and every English couplet accounted. Moscow and Mohl individually checked first, then Ganjoor and Khaleghi. No source-only row required.
Coverage means individual verified accounts, not universal agreement. Four English couplets have Mohl running and actual Moscow apparatus support, with checked Ganjoor/Khaleghi local gaps. Barley as the exact grain of kashkin bread remains unverified here. Apparatus selectively inspected, not exhaustively transcribed; no appendix evidence used. All inherited provisional flags preserved.
All108 English lines compared with the retained HTML capture.
- Moscow: printed 63 / PDF 63 · printed 64 / PDF 64 · printed 65 / PDF 65 · printed 66 / PDF 66. Existing PDF reused; PNG facsimiles inspected; scans excluded.
- Mohl: printed 190 / PDF 196 · printed 191 / PDF 197 · printed 192 / PDF 198. Existing PDF reused; PNG facsimiles inspected; scans excluded.
- Khaleghi: printed 372 / PDF 388 · printed 373 / PDF 389 · printed 374 / PDF 390 · printed 375 / PDF 391. Existing PDF reused; PNG facsimiles inspected; scans excluded.
- Ganjoor sh10:1–50. Poem body only; later verses and automated explanations excluded.
Actual Moscow V64n12 prints the three-verse early request at951–952, rather than Mohl’s later position after the sleeplessness verse; V65n13 prints the separate Giv/Gudarz inquiry. Selected actual alternatives: Moscow64n19 garments,65n9 throne,65n17 yellow cheeks,66n7 tears; Khaleghi372n11 names,372n18 pit,374n19 love blessing,375n1 explicit bird. Checked main gaps: Ganjoor13–14 and Khaleghi921–922 for English14–16; Ganjoor30–31 and Khaleghi938–939 for English34. Inspected Khaleghi372n21–22 and373n20–21 do not print those missing requests. No global absence claim or appendix evidence. Fresh Mohl printed numbering corrects inherited C2.22 candidate start1006 to1005; previous package remains closed and unchanged.
- Mohl III190:1006 running, first-hemistich phrase; bare head: برهنه سر
- Moscow V64n12 actual addition, first-verse destination phrase; spacing normalized: به ایران شوی
- Mohl III191:1038 running, full news-request verse; spacing normalized: که از تو یکی باز پرسم خبر / ز گیو و ز گودرز فرخ اثر
- Mohl III191:1043 running, mercy verb phrase only: بخشایدم کردگار
- Moscow V65:977 / Ganjoor35 second hemistich: سر آرد مگر بر من این کردگار
- Mohl III191:1051 running, first hemistich; tears: فرو ریخت از دیدگان آب مهر
- Khaleghi III374:951 running, second hemistich; tears: فرو ریخت از دیدگان آب مهر
- Mohl III192:1056 running, bread-wrapping phrase: به گرد اندران نان نرم
- Mohl III192:1057 running, second hemistich; bird: نهفت اندر آن مرغ انگشتری
Selected phrases, hemistichs and full verses are labeled separately. English14–16/34 display independently verified Mohl Persian at Ganjoor gaps. Other Persian excerpts display the cited Ganjoor unit, not a synthetic conflation. Mohl’s numbered page190 begins1005; this fresh boundary supersedes the inherited candidate1006 without revising C2.21. No unreadable primary phrase is used as proof.
C2.22 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V63:943 running text | III190:1005 running text |
| 2 | V63:944 running text | III190:1006 running text |
| 3 | V63:945 running text | III190:1007 running text |
| 4 | V64:946 running text | III190:1008 running text |
| 5 | V64:947 running text | III190:1009 running text |
| 6 | V64:948 running text | III190:1010 running text |
| 7 | V64:949 running text | III190:1011 running text |
| 8 | V64:950 running text | III190:1012 running text |
| 9 | V64:951 running text | III190:1013 running text |
| 10 | V64:952 running text | III190:1014 running text |
| 11 | V64:953 running text | III190:1015 running text |
| 12 | V64:954 running text; V64 n19 actual garment alternative | III190:1016 running text |
| 13 | V64:955 running text | III190:1017 running text |
| 14 | V64 n12 actual added verse 1 of 3 at951–952; early placement differs from Mohl | III190:1018 running text |
| 15 | V64 n12 actual added verse 2 of 3 at951–952; early placement differs from Mohl | III190:1019 running text |
| 16 | V64 n12 actual added verse 3 of 3 at951–952; early placement differs from Mohl | III190:1020 running text |
| 17 | V64:956 running text | III190:1021 running text |
| 18 | V64:957 running text | III190:1022 running text |
| 19 | V64:958 running text | III190:1023 running text |
| 20 | V64:959 running text | III190:1024 running text |
| 21 | V64:960 running text | III190:1025 running text |
| 22 | V64:961 running text | III190:1026 running text |
| 23 | V64:962 running text | III190:1027 running text |
| 24 | V65:963 running text | III191:1028 running text |
| 25 | V65:964 running text | III191:1029 running text |
| 26 | V65:965 running text | III191:1030 running text |
| 27 | V65:966 running text | III191:1031 running text |
| 28 | V65:967 running text | III191:1032 running text |
| 29 | V65:968 running text | III191:1033 running text |
| 30 | V65:969 running text | III191:1034 running text |
| 31 | V65:970 running text; V65 n9 actual royal-throne alternative | III191:1035 running text |
| 32 | V65:971 running text | III191:1036 running text |
| 33 | V65:972 running text | III191:1037 running text |
| 34 | V65 n13 actual full added news-request verse at972–973 | III191:1038 running text |
| 35 | V65:973 running text | III191:1039 running text |
| 36 | V65:974 running text | III191:1040 running text |
| 37 | V65:975 running text; V65 n17 actual yellow-cheek alternative | III191:1041 running text |
| 38 | V65:976 running text | III191:1042 running text |
| 39 | V65:977 running text | III191:1043 running text |
| 40 | V65:978 running text | III191:1044 running text |
| 41 | V65:979 running text | III191:1045 running text |
| 42 | V65:980 running text | III191:1046 running text |
| 43 | V66:981 running text | III191:1047 running text |
| 44 | V66:982 running text | III191:1048 running text |
| 45 | V66:983 running text | III191:1049 running text |
| 46 | V66:984 running text | III191:1050 running text |
| 47 | V66:985 running text; V66 n7 actual tears-of-affection alternative | III191:1051 running text |
| 48 | V66:986 running text | III191:1052 running text |
| 49 | V66:987 running text | III192:1053 running text |
| 50 | V66:988 running text | III192:1054 running text |
| 51 | V66:989 running text | III192:1055 running text |
| 52 | V66:990 running text | III192:1056 running text |
| 53 | V66:991 running text | III192:1057 running text |
| 54 | V66:992 running text | III192:1058 running text |
New Naqqali