Afrasiab Comes against Rostam
C2.26 · Afrasiab Comes against Rostam.49 couplets, sunrise through Rostam’s death threat.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | C2.26 · Afrasiab Comes against Rostam.49 couplets, sunrise through Rostam’s death threat. |
| Moscow | V76–78:1158–1205.48 main units; separate readiness, vengeance and hawk units retained as source-only. Selected actual apparatus inspected. |
| Mohl | III199–201:1235–1279 / PDF205–207.45 main units. Arrival before uproar, karnay and iron-piercing wording; three bounded local gaps. |
| Ganjoor | bizhan sh13:1–48.48 indexed poem-body units. Later battle units49–78 excluded. Automated explanations excluded. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | III386–390:1126–1173 / PDF402–406.48 main units. Hawk after fox, different hawk ending and courage wording; actual alternatives separately recorded. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5The muster and its displaced uproar
Individual verse accounts for English 1–5. V76:1158 running text; V76:1160 running text; same source unit shared across English2–3; V76:1159 running text; V76:1162 running text; V76:1161 running text; V76:1163 running text
Moscow printed p. 76 · Mohl printed p. 199 · Khaleghi printed p. 386 · Khaleghi printed p. 387 · Ganjoor sh13:1 · Ganjoor sh13:2 · Ganjoor sh13:3 · Ganjoor sh13:4 · Ganjoor sh13:5 · Ganjoor sh13:6
All four begin with sunrise and riders preparing, but the assembly does not have one uniform order. Mohl places the arrival at the gate before the city’s uproar, as English does; Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi place the noise first. English divides the arrival and its ranks across two couplets, making the crowd’s spatial arrangement visible. That expansion should not conceal another difference. Moscow separately describes readiness and release from fear and rest; Ganjoor and Khaleghi refer to home and rest. All three then place revenge-filled, girded warriors after nobles with loosened belts. Mohl lacks both units at the checked transitions, and neither has a distinct English counterpart. The register therefore retains two source-only entries. English shame interprets the nobles’ heads in dust, while the opening crowned sunlight brings a royal image into the dawn. Its concentrated scene follows Mohl’s shorter assembly without claiming that the fuller sequence is empty repetition.
6–10Disgrace becomes a command to fight
Individual verse accounts for English 6–10. V76:1164 running text; V76:1165 running text; V76:1166 running text; V76:1167 running text; V76:1168 running text
Moscow printed p. 76 · Mohl printed p. 199 · Mohl printed p. 200 · Khaleghi printed p. 387 · Ganjoor sh13:7 · Ganjoor sh13:8 · Ganjoor sh13:9 · Ganjoor sh13:10 · Ganjoor sh13:11
The deliberation, Bijan’s enduring stain, the fear of being called belted women and the king’s leopardlike anger occur in all four. English focuses the disgrace on the Shah, matching Mohl’s narrower royal wording where the other three also include the great men. The gendered taunt is the assembled speakers’ measure of martial reputation, not the analyst’s description of women. English preserves its contradiction by keeping the battle-belts: the speakers possess a warrior’s equipment but fear losing the name of warriors. The command to Piran then gives shame an organized military outlet. Mohl describes the enterprise turning to failure and scorn, supporting English defeat; Moscow and Ganjoor emphasize mockery from Iran, while Khaleghi warns against further mockery. English compresses these stakes into an accomplished humiliation before the renewed mobilization.
11–16The approaching army becomes a sea
Individual verse accounts for English 11–16. V77:1169 running text; V77:1170 running text; V77:1171 running text; V77:1172 running text; V77:1173 running text; V77:1174 running text
Moscow printed p. 77 · Mohl printed p. 200 · Khaleghi printed p. 387 · Khaleghi printed p. 388 · Ganjoor sh13:12 · Ganjoor sh13:13 · Ganjoor sh13:14 · Ganjoor sh13:15 · Ganjoor sh13:16 · Ganjoor sh13:17
The bronze nay, assembling ranks, sea-like army and watchman’s alarm agree across the four presentations. The next instrument does not. Mohl actually names the karnay in the ranks verse, supporting English; Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi main instead name buq and Hindi daray. The English instrument is thus an edition-supported choice, not a casual replacement of a uniform list. Repeated water imagery then carries the passage from the marching force to the lookout’s perception. English ocean’s roar adds sound to the first visual transformation, and solid ground no more intensifies its scale. The warning turns that spectacle into a practical demand to arm. Rostam’s refusal to fear agrees across the four, but English raising battle’s dust follows Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi more closely than Mohl’s image of reducing battle to dust. His confidence answers the alarm without denying the army’s size.
17–22Protection, confidence and the weapons list
Individual verse accounts for English 17–22. V77:1175 running text; V77:1176 running text; V77:1177 running text; V77:1178 running text; V77:1179 running text; same source unit shared across English21–22; V77 n18 actual iron-piercing alternative; V77:1179 running text; same source unit shared across English21–22
Moscow printed p. 77 · Mohl printed p. 200 · Khaleghi printed p. 388 · Ganjoor sh13:18 · Ganjoor sh13:19 · Ganjoor sh13:20 · Ganjoor sh13:21 · Ganjoor sh13:22
All four send Manijeh with the baggage before Rostam puts on battle clothing. English onward supplies direction without locating a new destination, preserving the practical protection before the heroic display. The ascent, lionlike roar and fox proverb then make his confidence public. English my men supplies an audience that the following address establishes in the sequence. The weapons list expands one Persian couplet into two English couplets, allowing sword and darts, spear and ox-headed mace to receive separate emphasis. Iron-piercing follows Mohl and Khaleghi main and an actual Moscow apparatus alternative; Moscow and Ganjoor main instead have the poison-water expression. The distinction is recorded without asserting a technical metallurgy or poison practice. English adds commands to bring the weapons forward, transforming an inventory framed as questions into an immediately usable exhortation.
23–28From exhortation to an ordered position
Individual verse accounts for English 23–28. V77:1180 running text; V77:1181 running text; V77:1182 running text; V77:1183 running text; V77:1184 running text; V77:1185 running text
Moscow printed p. 77 · Mohl printed p. 200 · Khaleghi printed p. 388 · Ganjoor sh13:23 · Ganjoor sh13:24 · Ganjoor sh13:25 · Ganjoor sh13:26 · Ganjoor sh13:27 · Ganjoor sh13:28
The demand to show prowess agrees across all four. Its next clause differs: Mohl urges rushing to battle, supporting English, while Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi call for vengeance on the plain. English side by side makes coordination explicit. The karnay, mounting Rakhsh, descent toward open ground and spreading force then agree. The iron enclosure describes the military array; the text does not require a separately built fortification. English armies broadens the collective force into a plural, while the following couplet restores Rostam’s specific act of arranging the battlefield. Its darkened world follows Mohl and Khaleghi where Moscow and Ganjoor name the air. All four place Ashkash and Gostaham on the right with numerous riders. The passage turns proclaimed courage into positions, equipment and controlled movement, giving the coming challenge a concrete tactical setting.
29–34The rescued Bijan holds the center
Individual verse accounts for English 29–34. V77:1186 running text; V78:1187 running text; same source unit shared across English30–31; V78:1188 running text; V78:1189 running text; V78:1190 running text
Moscow printed p. 77 · Moscow printed p. 78 · Mohl printed p. 200 · Khaleghi printed p. 388 · Khaleghi printed p. 389 · Ganjoor sh13:29 · Ganjoor sh13:30 · Ganjoor sh13:31 · Ganjoor sh13:32 · Ganjoor sh13:33
All four put Rohham and Zangeh on the left, though their accompanying description differs. Mohl’s arranged force supports the English drawn-up troops, while Moscow and Ganjoor connect the position more explicitly with blood and war. Khaleghi describes assigning the men. The center is jointly occupied by Rostam and Bijan in a single Persian couplet in all four. English gives each a separate couplet, first concentrating the protective metaphor on Rostam, then restoring joint agency through together. This expansion makes the recently rescued prisoner visibly active in defending the army. Bistoon behind and the sword-wall before agree, but the printed name alone does not establish a modern geographical identification for this battlefield. Afrasiab’s distress, battle coat and halt also agree: the king recognizes the opposing commander and pauses to deploy rather than immediately charging.
35–40Two commands and one personal challenge
Individual verse accounts for English 35–40. V78:1191 running text; V78:1192 running text; V78:1193 running text; V78:1194 running text; V78 n11 inspected, shield not verified; V78:1195 running text; V78:1196 running text
Moscow printed p. 78 · Mohl printed p. 200 · Mohl printed p. 201 · Khaleghi printed p. 389 · Ganjoor sh13:34 · Ganjoor sh13:35 · Ganjoor sh13:36 · Ganjoor sh13:37 · Ganjoor sh13:38 · Ganjoor sh13:39
All four give the opposing formation, indigo air, Piran and Houman on the wings, and Garsivaz with Shideh at the center. English reverses the central pair’s name order without changing their assignment. Rostam’s movement as a black mountain of iron likewise agrees. English jowshan-clad makes the armor specific, but the additional shield is not named in these main units or verified by the selected local apparatus; that detail remains qualified. The taunt substitutes country for the source army, broadening the disgrace beyond the fighting force. A second distinction affects courage and shame. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor reproach Afrasiab’s lack of shame before his warriors, supporting English. Khaleghi main instead denies his champions an inclination to fight, while its actual apparatus prints the shame alternative. English therefore keeps the accusation personally directed at the king.
41–45Numbers cannot equal a different kind of power
Individual verse accounts for English 41–45. V78:1197 running text; V78:1198 running text; V78:1199 running text; V78:1200 running text; same source unit shared across English44–45
Moscow printed p. 78 · Mohl printed p. 201 · Khaleghi printed p. 389 · Ganjoor sh13:40 · Ganjoor sh13:41 · Ganjoor sh13:42 · Ganjoor sh13:43
All four challenge the many men and horses covering the earth, predict seeing Afrasiab’s back and invoke Dastan’s remembered saying. English renders Dastan as Zal and adds that he told the saying to all, making inherited wisdom public rather than merely remembered. The prediction remains a boast before combat; it should not be read as a report of an already completed rout. A single Persian couplet then pairs lion against a plain of wild asses with star against sun. English expands that unit into two complete couplets, giving the animal and celestial comparisons equal room. Weak or strong and countless throng emphasize that multiplying inferior opponents cannot alter the hierarchy. The star’s admitted light similarly grants a lesser capacity while denying equality with the sun. The four editions agree on this paired contrast despite differences elsewhere in the proverb sequence.
46–49The shortened sequence of animal comparisons
Individual verse accounts for English 46–49. V78:1201 running text; V78:1203 running text; V78:1204 running text; V78:1205 running text; V78:1202 running text
Moscow printed p. 78 · Mohl printed p. 201 · Khaleghi printed p. 389 · Khaleghi printed p. 390 · Ganjoor sh13:44 · Ganjoor sh13:45 · Ganjoor sh13:46 · Ganjoor sh13:47 · Ganjoor sh13:48
The ram terrified by wolf-claws, the fox unchanged by trial and the wild asses avoiding lion-claws agree across the four. Moscow and Ganjoor also print a hawk frightening a partridge between ram and fox. Khaleghi places its hawk unit after the fox and gives it a different main ending in which a male lion does not fear the hawk’s claws; its actual apparatus prints the partridge alternative. Mohl lacks a hawk unit at the checked transition, and English follows that shorter sequence. The source-only entry preserves both the omitted image and the editorial difference rather than quietly normalizing them. All four then condemn the foolish king and deny escape in life and body. English you shall be slain converts that formula into an explicit death threat. The chapter ends with Rostam’s prediction, leaving Afrasiab’s reaction and the battle itself to the next published section.
Source record and limits
C2.26 only: 49 English couplets / 98 unchanged lines; 9 substantive notes. Moscow V76–78:1158–1205 (48 main units); Mohl III199–201:1235–1279 (PDF205–207,45 main units); Ganjoor bizhan sh13:1–48; Khaleghi III386–390:1126–1173 (PDF402–406,48 main units). Every English couplet and declared main unit accounted individually. Moscow and Mohl checked first, then Ganjoor and Khaleghi.
Coverage means checked individual accounts, not universal agreement. English38 shield is unverified in the inspected main units and selected apparatus. Bistoon geographical identification and precise historical instrument identities are not independently established. Three source-only rows retained. All inherited provisional flags preserved verbatim. Apparatus selectively inspected, not exhaustive; no appendix evidence used.
C2.27 starts with Afrasiab’s reaction and is excluded.
- Moscow: printed 76 / PDF 76 · printed 77 / PDF 77 · printed 78 / PDF 78. Existing source PDF reused; PNG facsimiles read. Scans excluded.
- Mohl: printed 199 / PDF 205 · printed 200 / PDF 206 · printed 201 / PDF 207. Existing source PDF reused; PNG facsimiles read. Scans excluded.
- Khaleghi: printed 386 / PDF 402 · printed 387 / PDF 403 · printed 388 / PDF 404 · printed 389 / PDF 405 · printed 390 / PDF 406. Existing source PDF reused; PNG facsimiles read. Scans excluded.
- Ganjoor sh13:1–48. Indexed poem body only.
Actual Moscow77n18 gives iron-piercing alternative to main poison-water weapon wording. Actual Khaleghi389n14 gives shame-before-warriors alternative;389n25 gives hawk/partridge alternative to its main lion-claw ending. Selected Moscow78n11 and Khaleghi389n8–10 do not verify English38 shield. Mohl1236–1237,1238–1239 and1276–1277 are checked local gaps for S1,S2,S3 respectively; no global manuscript-absence claim. No appendix evidence or unprinted addition notice used.
- Mohl III200:1245 main, second hemistich; instrument: خروش آمد و نالهٔ کرنای
- Moscow V77:1179 main, first hemistich; weapon: کجا تیغ و ژوپین زهرآبدار
- Mohl III200:1254 main, first hemistich; weapon: کجا تیغ و ژوپین آهنگذار
- Moscow V77 n18 actual alternative: آهنگذار
- Khaleghi III389:1164 main, second hemistich; champions: به جنگ دلیرانت آهنگ نیست
- Khaleghi III389 n14 actual alternative: ز گردان لشکر ترا ننگ نیست
- Khaleghi III389:1171 main, second hemistich; hawk unit: نترسد ز چنگال او شیر نر
- Moscow V78:1202 main, second hemistich; hawk unit: بترسد ز چنگال او کبک نر
Persian register displays cited Ganjoor units without blended reconstruction. English2–3,21–22,30–31,44–45 each share a Persian unit. Source-only S1 readiness, S2 vengeance and S3 hawk are separately accounted. Selected Khaleghi hawk reading differs from the displayed Ganjoor text and is explicitly identified.
C2.26 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V76:1158 running text | III199:1235 running text |
| 2 | V76:1160 running text; same source unit shared across English2–3 | III199:1236 running text; same source unit shared across English2–3 |
| 3 | V76:1160 running text; same source unit shared across English2–3 | III199:1236 running text; same source unit shared across English2–3 |
| 4 | V76:1159 running text | III199:1237 running text |
| 5 | V76:1162 running text | III199:1238 running text |
| 6 | V76:1164 running text | III199:1239 running text |
| 7 | V76:1165 running text | III199:1240 running text |
| 8 | V76:1166 running text | III199:1241 running text |
| 9 | V76:1167 running text | III199:1242 running text |
| 10 | V76:1168 running text | III200:1243 running text |
| 11 | V77:1169 running text | III200:1244 running text |
| 12 | V77:1170 running text | III200:1245 running text |
| 13 | V77:1171 running text | III200:1246 running text |
| 14 | V77:1172 running text | III200:1247 running text |
| 15 | V77:1173 running text | III200:1248 running text |
| 16 | V77:1174 running text | III200:1249 running text |
| 17 | V77:1175 running text | III200:1250 running text |
| 18 | V77:1176 running text | III200:1251 running text |
| 19 | V77:1177 running text | III200:1252 running text |
| 20 | V77:1178 running text | III200:1253 running text |
| 21 | V77:1179 running text; same source unit shared across English21–22; V77 n18 actual iron-piercing alternative | III200:1254 running text; same source unit shared across English21–22 |
| 22 | V77:1179 running text; same source unit shared across English21–22 | III200:1254 running text; same source unit shared across English21–22 |
| 23 | V77:1180 running text | III200:1255 running text |
| 24 | V77:1181 running text | III200:1256 running text |
| 25 | V77:1182 running text | III200:1257 running text |
| 26 | V77:1183 running text | III200:1258 running text |
| 27 | V77:1184 running text | III200:1259 running text |
| 28 | V77:1185 running text | III200:1260 running text |
| 29 | V77:1186 running text | III200:1261 running text |
| 30 | V78:1187 running text; same source unit shared across English30–31 | III200:1262 running text; same source unit shared across English30–31 |
| 31 | V78:1187 running text; same source unit shared across English30–31 | III200:1262 running text; same source unit shared across English30–31 |
| 32 | V78:1188 running text | III200:1263 running text |
| 33 | V78:1189 running text | III200:1264 running text |
| 34 | V78:1190 running text | III200:1265 running text |
| 35 | V78:1191 running text | III200:1266 running text |
| 36 | V78:1192 running text | III200:1267 running text |
| 37 | V78:1193 running text | III201:1268 running text |
| 38 | V78:1194 running text; V78 n11 inspected, shield not verified | III201:1269 running text |
| 39 | V78:1195 running text | III201:1270 running text |
| 40 | V78:1196 running text | III201:1271 running text |
| 41 | V78:1197 running text | III201:1272 running text |
| 42 | V78:1198 running text | III201:1273 running text |
| 43 | V78:1199 running text | III201:1274 running text |
| 44 | V78:1200 running text; same source unit shared across English44–45 | III201:1275 running text; same source unit shared across English44–45 |
| 45 | V78:1200 running text; same source unit shared across English44–45 | III201:1275 running text; same source unit shared across English44–45 |
| 46 | V78:1201 running text | III201:1276 running text |
| 47 | V78:1203 running text | III201:1277 running text |
| 48 | V78:1204 running text | III201:1278 running text |
| 49 | V78:1205 running text | III201:1279 running text |
New Naqqali