The Iranians Defeat Afrasiab
C2.27 · The Iranians Defeat Afrasiab.31 couplets, Afrasiab’s reaction through victorious return.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | C2.27 · The Iranians Defeat Afrasiab.31 couplets, Afrasiab’s reaction through victorious return. |
| Moscow | V79–80:1206–1235.30 main units. Reward in main; kill-and-bind and chiefs/horses surge recorded as source-only. Left attack before Ashkash; resurrection and people-drawing dragon imagery. |
| Mohl | III201–202:1280–1307 /PDF207–208.28 main units. World drowning,sun/cloud,desire for battle,world-burning breath and Ashkash-first order. Two checked local gaps. |
| Ganjoor | bizhan sh13:49–78.30 indexed poem-body units. Moscow-like ordering and images. Earlier units1–48 excluded; automated explanations excluded. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | III390–391:1174–1200 /PDF406–407.27 main units; reward,killing/capture and surge in actual apparatus. Ashkash-first order; selected actual alternatives separately recorded. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5Fear answers the challenge with promises
Individual verse accounts for English 1–5. V79:1206 running text; V79:1207 running text; V79:1208 running text; V79:1209 running text; V79:1210 running text
Moscow printed p. 79 · Mohl printed p. 201 · Khaleghi printed p. 390 · Ganjoor sh13:49 · Ganjoor sh13:50 · Ganjoor sh13:51 · Ganjoor sh13:52 · Ganjoor sh13:53
All four begin with Afrasiab hearing Rostam, trembling and taking a sharp breath. English dread interprets that bodily response before the king tries to rally his men through the opposition of battle and feast. The promised reward has a more complicated textual position. Moscow and Ganjoor print the crown-and-treasure verse in the running text, and Khaleghi actually prints it in apparatus after the challenge. Mohl also prints the promise, but offers satisfaction and treasure rather than crowns. English therefore preserves a verified royal reward image without requiring identical wording or placement across the editions. The troops’ roar then yields to dust and apparent drowning. Mohl makes the world the drowned entity, supporting English; the other three main sequences continue from the sun, while Khaleghi’s apparatus also supplies world wording. English no earth to stand on intensifies the surrounding loss of visibility.
6–10Sound and light turn the field into confusion
Individual verse accounts for English 6–10. V79:1211 running text; V79 n12–13 inspected, no karnay wording; V79:1212 running text; V79:1213 running text; V79:1214 running text; V79:1215 running text
Moscow printed p. 79 · Mohl printed p. 201 · Khaleghi printed p. 390 · Ganjoor sh13:54 · Ganjoor sh13:55 · Ganjoor sh13:56 · Ganjoor sh13:57 · Ganjoor sh13:58
Bronze khum on elephants, armor forming an iron rampart and the disturbance of plain and mountain occur in all four. The wind instrument is specifically shaypur in each main text, alongside gavdam. English karnays preserves the martial sound but changes that name; precise historical equivalence is not established by these passages. The distinction remains explicit rather than being concealed by a general claim of agreement. The flashing weapons then expose a substantial difference in imagery. Mohl compares them with a shining sun beneath cloud, supporting English sunlight through cloud, while Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi main evoke resurrection. English concentrates on swords where Mohl names arrows as well. The subsequent hail of maces agrees across the editions; English iron gale extends that weather image. Together the sensory details make battle overwhelming while the edition-specific sunlight keeps the scene within the natural world.
11–15Rostam’s banner and bodily force
Individual verse accounts for English 11–15. V79:1216 running text; V79:1217 running text; V79 n24 actual pitch alternative; V79:1218 running text; same source unit shared across English13–14; V79:1219 running text
Moscow printed p. 79 · Mohl printed p. 202 · Khaleghi printed p. 390 · Ganjoor sh13:59 · Ganjoor sh13:60 · Ganjoor sh13:61 · Ganjoor sh13:62
The dragonlike banner coloring the sun violet, elephant dust and the indigo image agree across the four main texts. English makes the banner’s effect a spreading stain, without requiring a literal account of dye or light. Moscow also prints a pitch alternative in apparatus, which remains separate from the main indigo reading followed here. Rostam’s movement on Rakhsh and his severing of leaders’ heads occupy one Persian couplet in all four. English expands it into two, first following the horse through the ranks and then isolating the violence. Smashed adds an impact beyond the stated separation of head and body. The ox-headed mace and unbridled huyun then agree across the editions. English wild dromedary makes the animal more specific, though these loci alone do not independently settle its zoological identity. The expansion gives the central champion more visible action without adding another opponent.
16–20The attack spreads from the center to the wings
Individual verse accounts for English 16–20. V79:1221 running text; V80:1224 running text; V79:1223 running text; V80:1225 running text; V80:1226 running text; V79:1220 running text; V79:1222 running text
Moscow printed p. 79 · Moscow printed p. 80 · Mohl printed p. 202 · Khaleghi printed p. 390 · Khaleghi printed p. 391 · Ganjoor sh13:63 · Ganjoor sh13:64 · Ganjoor sh13:65 · Ganjoor sh13:66 · Ganjoor sh13:67 · Ganjoor sh13:68 · Ganjoor sh13:69
Rostam’s wolf-like entry into the center and the army’s scattering agree across all four, but the surrounding sequence is fuller in Moscow and Ganjoor. A kill-and-bind statement precedes that entry, and a separate windlike surge of chiefs and horses follows it. Khaleghi actually prints both in apparatus; Mohl lacks them at the checked transitions. They remain two source-only entries rather than being credited to English by loose narrative resemblance. English then follows Mohl and Khaleghi in placing Ashkash’s attack before the left-wing action, reversing Moscow and Ganjoor’s order. The named participants and Garsivaz as the object of vengeance agree. Bijan’s role also agrees, but his emotional presentation differs: Mohl explicitly gives desire for battle, supporting English, while the other three main texts turn battle into a banquet for him. English keeps the eagerness while surrendering that festive metaphor.
21–25Defeat becomes visible to the king
Individual verse accounts for English 21–25. V80:1227 running text; V80:1228 running text; V80:1229 running text; V80:1230 running text; V80:1231 running text; same source unit shared across English25–26
Moscow printed p. 80 · Mohl printed p. 202 · Khaleghi printed p. 391 · Ganjoor sh13:70 · Ganjoor sh13:71 · Ganjoor sh13:72 · Ganjoor sh13:73 · Ganjoor sh13:74
Blood across the battlefield and the fallen Turanian standard agree in all four. English generalizes the standard’s possessor, accommodating the commander in Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor and the riders in Khaleghi. The king’s recognition of reversed fortune then gives the rout a perceiving center. Discarding the Indian sword and mounting a fresher horse agree: the details make survival replace royal aggression. The company in flight differs. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor send the king with chosen followers; Khaleghi main describes him separated from the Turks, while its actual apparatus prints the chosen-companions wording. English follows the former account and interprets the failure to obtain vengeance as a dead hope. Rostam’s pursuit begins a Persian couplet whose second half rains weapons on the army. English separates pursuit from blows, extending the chase across two couplets while keeping its target explicit.
26–31The dragon pursues, then the victor distributes
Individual verse accounts for English 26–31. V80:1231 running text; same source unit shared across English25–26; V80:1232 running text; V80 n16–17 inspected, no world-burning wording; V80:1233 running text; V80:1234 running text; V80:1235 running text; same source unit shared across English30–31
Moscow printed p. 80 · Mohl printed p. 202 · Khaleghi printed p. 391 · Ganjoor sh13:74 · Ganjoor sh13:75 · Ganjoor sh13:76 · Ganjoor sh13:77 · Ganjoor sh13:78
Mace and arrow blows, the two-farsang pursuit and the dragon comparison occur in all four. The breath image differs sharply. Mohl burns a world with that breath, supporting English worlds, while Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi main draw people from the fleeing enemy by breath. English it seemed marks the extravagant comparison rather than presenting an ordinary physical action. The following thousand captives prevents the rout from becoming a claim of universal death: three main texts explicitly say alive, while Mohl calls them captives. English bound supplies the restraint. Return to camp and distribution then agree across all four. The last Persian couplet combines loading elephants with victorious movement to the sovereign; English expands it into two and names Kay Khosrow from the narrative context. The chapter closes on transport and return, leaving the reception itself to the next published section.
Source record and limits
C2.27 only:31 English couplets /62 unchanged lines;6 substantive notes. Moscow V79–80:1206–1235 (30 main units); Mohl III201–202:1280–1307 (PDF207–208,28 main units); Ganjoor bizhan sh13:49–78; Khaleghi III390–391:1174–1200 (PDF406–407,27 main units) and selected actual apparatus. Every English couplet and declared main unit accounted individually. Moscow and Mohl checked first, then Ganjoor and Khaleghi.
Coverage means individual checked accounts, not uniform agreement. English6 karnays changes the main shaypur term; exact historical instrument equivalence remains unverified here. English15 dromedary is a specific interpretation of huyun, not an independently established zoological identification. Two source-only rows and three shared source units explicit. All inherited flags preserved verbatim. Apparatus selectively inspected, not exhaustive; no appendix evidence used.
C2.28 starts with news reaching Khosrow and is excluded.
- Moscow: printed 79 /PDF 79 · printed 80 /PDF 80. Existing source PDF reused; PNG facsimiles read. Scans excluded.
- Mohl: printed 201 /PDF 207 · printed 202 /PDF 208. Existing source PDF reused; PNG facsimiles read. Scans excluded.
- Khaleghi: printed 390 /PDF 406 · printed 391 /PDF 407. Existing source PDF reused; PNG facsimiles read. Scans excluded.
- Ganjoor sh13:49–78. Indexed poem body only.
Actual Khaleghi390n9 full reward verse;390n13 world-drowning alternative;390n30 full killing/capture verse;391n4 full chiefs/horses surge;391n19 chosen-companions alternative inspected. Actual Moscow79n24 pitch alternative inspected. Moscow79n12–13 and Khaleghi390n14–15 do not verify karnay wording; Moscow80n16–17 and Khaleghi391n23–24 do not supply Mohl’s burning-world image. Mohl1293–1294 and1294–1295 are checked local gaps for S1/S2; Khaleghi main1175–1176 reward gap,1186–1187 killing gap,1187–1189 surge gap are individually distinguished from actual printed additions. No appendix evidence or unprinted addition notice counted.
- Mohl III201:1282 main, reward phrase: بسی کام و گنج
- Moscow V79:1208 main, reward phrase: بسی تاج و گنج
- Mohl III201:1284 main, world-drowning phrase: جهان ماند غرقه در آب
- Mohl III201:1288 main, second hemistich; sunlight: چو خورشید رخشنده در زیر میغ
- Moscow V79:1214 main, second hemistich; resurrection: تو گفتی برآمد همی رستخیز
- Mohl III202:1297 main, desire phrase: همی آرزو آمدش جای جنگ
- Mohl III202:1304 main, second hemistich; burning: جهانی همی سوخت گفتی بدم
- Moscow V80:1232 main, second hemistich; drawing people: همی مردم آهخت ازیشان بدم
Persian register displays cited Ganjoor units without blended reconstruction. English13–14,25–26,30–31 each share a source unit. Source-only S1 killing/capture and S2 chiefs/horses surge retain Moscow/Ganjoor main,actual Khaleghi apparatus and checked Mohl local gaps. Selected Mohl readings are displayed separately from the Ganjoor reference text.
C2.27 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V79:1206 running text | III201:1280 running text |
| 2 | V79:1207 running text | III201:1281 running text |
| 3 | V79:1208 running text | III201:1282 running text |
| 4 | V79:1209 running text | III201:1283 running text |
| 5 | V79:1210 running text | III201:1284 running text |
| 6 | V79:1211 running text; V79 n12–13 inspected, no karnay wording | III201:1285 running text |
| 7 | V79:1212 running text | III201:1286 running text |
| 8 | V79:1213 running text | III201:1287 running text |
| 9 | V79:1214 running text | III201:1288 running text |
| 10 | V79:1215 running text | III201:1289 running text |
| 11 | V79:1216 running text | III202:1290 running text |
| 12 | V79:1217 running text; V79 n24 actual pitch alternative | III202:1291 running text |
| 13 | V79:1218 running text; same source unit shared across English13–14 | III202:1292 running text; same source unit shared across English13–14 |
| 14 | V79:1218 running text; same source unit shared across English13–14 | III202:1292 running text; same source unit shared across English13–14 |
| 15 | V79:1219 running text | III202:1293 running text |
| 16 | V79:1221 running text | III202:1294 running text |
| 17 | V80:1224 running text | III202:1295 running text |
| 18 | V79:1223 running text | III202:1296 running text |
| 19 | V80:1225 running text | III202:1297 running text |
| 20 | V80:1226 running text | III202:1298 running text |
| 21 | V80:1227 running text | III202:1299 running text |
| 22 | V80:1228 running text | III202:1300 running text |
| 23 | V80:1229 running text | III202:1301 running text |
| 24 | V80:1230 running text | III202:1302 running text |
| 25 | V80:1231 running text; same source unit shared across English25–26 | III202:1303 running text; same source unit shared across English25–26 |
| 26 | V80:1231 running text; same source unit shared across English25–26 | III202:1303 running text; same source unit shared across English25–26 |
| 27 | V80:1232 running text; V80 n16–17 inspected, no world-burning wording | III202:1304 running text |
| 28 | V80:1233 running text | III202:1305 running text |
| 29 | V80:1234 running text | III202:1306 running text |
| 30 | V80:1235 running text; same source unit shared across English30–31 | III202:1307 running text; same source unit shared across English30–31 |
| 31 | V80:1235 running text; same source unit shared across English30–31 | III202:1307 running text; same source unit shared across English30–31 |
New Naqqali