Bijan Is Brought before Afrasiab
C2.8 · Bijan Is Brought before Afrasiab. 85 couplets, Garsivaz approaching through the final complaint to Gorgin.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | C2.8 · Bijan Is Brought before Afrasiab. 85 couplets, Garsivaz approaching through the final complaint to Gorgin. |
| Moscow | Volume V (1967), printed24–28:272–350; PDF=printed. Actual apparatus separately recorded;319 bracketed running; Appendix II printed420:1–5 selected. |
| Mohl | Volume III consulted reprint, printed159–163:298–381; PDF165–169. Fuller insults, royal question, first-person awakening and Gorgin message in running text. |
| Ganjoor | Indexed Persian poem body bizhan sh3:20–98. Ends with lion/deer distress before sh4:1; local gaps recorded. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | Volume III printed323–328:245–318; PDF339–344. Running text and actual apparatus distinguished; n3/n5 on328 supply fuller lament/message. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5The palace is surrounded
English 1–5: see individual register accounts. V24:272 running text; V24:273 running text; V24:274 running text; V24:275 running text; V24:276 running text
Moscow printed p.24 · Mohl printed p.159 · Mohl printed p.160 · Khaleghi printed p.323 · Ganjoor sh3:20 · Ganjoor sh3:21 · Ganjoor sh3:22 · Ganjoor sh3:23 · Ganjoor sh3:24
The opening makes the revel audible before the armed intrusion becomes visible. All four sources name the chang and rabab and describe the seizure of roof and door. English retains those concrete instruments and turns the blocked approaches into individually imagined sentries. The separate gathering of riders around Garsivaz follows Moscow and Ganjoor; Khaleghi prints that unit earlier, before the roof seizure, while Mohl passes from the closed palace directly to breaking the fastening. English therefore combines a fuller encirclement with the shared sequence. High and late supplies atmosphere rather than a time independently specified in this verse. The juxtaposition of a barred entrance with the sight of wine is already compressed in the Persian accounts. It should not be explained by inventing a window, an open door, or another unprinted viewpoint.
6–10Force enters the revel
English 6–10: see individual register accounts. V24:277 running text; V24:278 running text; V24:279 running text; V24:280 running text; V24 n23 actual added verse1: MANIJEH sitting among women with red wine, not Bijan
Moscow printed p.24 · Mohl printed p.160 · Khaleghi printed p.323 · Ganjoor sh3:25 · Ganjoor sh3:26 · Ganjoor sh3:27 · Ganjoor sh3:28
Breaking the fastening, entering the hall and approaching the stranger’s chamber are shared by all four presentations. English’s led the play interprets the stranger’s prominent place as social leadership, while held his course gives the entry additional purposefulness. The bodily sign of anger is a genuine variant: Moscow and Ganjoor have blood boiling in the veins, whereas Mohl and Khaleghi place anger at the brow; Khaleghi also records the blood reading in its actual apparatus. English selects the blood image. Three hundred attendants are explicit throughout, and the surrounding women make serving-women intelligible. The separate tableau of Bijan sitting among them with red wine is Mohl running text and an actual Khaleghi addition. Moscow’s actual addition instead names Manijeh as the seated wine-holder. Ganjoor passes directly from the attendants to Bijan’s alarm. The English follows the verified Bijan reading; Moscow’s differently named subject must remain distinct.
11–15Insult meets sudden helplessness
English 11–15: see individual register accounts. V24 n23 actual added verse2: different rebuke, know your place; no kin-disowning wording at checked280–281; V24:280–V25:281 and V24 n23 checked local gap for lion-life challenge; V25:281 running text; V25:282 running text; V25:284 running text
Moscow printed p.24 · Moscow printed p.25 · Mohl printed p.160 · Khaleghi printed p.323 · Khaleghi printed p.324 · Ganjoor sh3:29 · Ganjoor sh3:30 · Ganjoor sh3:32
Mohl gives Garsivaz both the accusation of disowning kin and the warning that Bijan has fallen into the lion’s claw. English preserves their personal aggression and uses hold to carry the threat without repeating the claw image immediately. Moscow’s actual addition instead gives a different rebuke about knowing one’s place; the checked Khaleghi and Ganjoor transitions do not contain the two fuller challenges. These are bounded findings at the arrest scene, not claims about every witness. The subsequent nakedness, missing horses and reversed sun are secure in all four. English’s stripped of all my might intensifies a predicament concerned specifically with fighting unarmored. Its appeal to Giv and Gudarz precedes the solitary appeal to Izad, following Mohl and Khaleghi; Moscow and Ganjoor reverse those two cries. The clipped final Mine is an English emphasis on the threatened personal head.
16–20A concealed weapon and a public name
English 16–20: see individual register accounts. V25:283 running text; V25:285 running text; V25:286 running text; V25:287 running text; V25:288 running text
Moscow printed p.25 · Mohl printed p.160 · Khaleghi printed p.324 · Ganjoor sh3:31 · Ganjoor sh3:33 · Ganjoor sh3:34 · Ganjoor sh3:35 · Ganjoor sh3:36
All four sources make Izad the only remaining helper and immediately disclose the dagger kept in Bijan’s boot. English’s strange land localizes the wider Persian complaint that no helper can be seen in the world. Water-tempered is an interpretive rendering of the dagger’s abgun description; the checked wording evokes waterlike appearance and does not independently specify a forging process. From hilt to root is added completeness. The next action matters tactically: the Persian has Bijan take the doorway while declaring his name. English’s took his place generalizes that defensible position, even as it keeps the transition from private fear to public assertion. Keshvad descent and leadership among heroes and azadegan remain clear; the free gives the latter a freedom emphasis alongside noble status. The grotesque body weary of its own head is successfully retained as a warning of decapitation.
21–25Defiance turns toward negotiation
English 21–25: see individual register accounts. V25:289 running text; V25 n11 actual added bad-fortune address after289; V25:290 running text; V25:291 running text; V25:292 running text
Moscow printed p.25 · Mohl printed p.160 · Khaleghi printed p.324 · Ganjoor sh3:37 · Ganjoor sh3:38 · Ganjoor sh3:39 · Ganjoor sh3:40
The refusal to turn his back even at the resurrection is common to all four sources. English preserves its extravagant scale, with fill the track adding a spatial image. Mohl and Khaleghi then print the direct cry that bad fortune has brought him here; Moscow prints that actual added verse in its apparatus, while Ganjoor proceeds directly to the appeal to ancestors and king. English’s transition consequently has specific fuller support. Recognition of family, sovereign and rank becomes a basis for negotiation, although the blood-washing threat remains active. English addresses Garsivaz directly in the fighting condition, where the Persian presentations vary in their verb and object wording. The following threat of many severed Turanian heads is shared and does not promise a precise number. The sequence preserves a warrior attempting leverage, rather than a sudden surrender or an unconditional request for mercy.
26–30Who is to tell the story
English 26–30: see individual register accounts. V25:293 running text; V25:294 running text; V25:295 running text; V25:296 running text; V25:297 running text
Moscow printed p.25 · Mohl printed p.160 · Khaleghi printed p.324 · Ganjoor sh3:41 · Ganjoor sh3:42 · Ganjoor sh3:43 · Ganjoor sh3:44 · Ganjoor sh3:45
The English makes Bijan promise that he himself will report the whole tale at Turan’s court. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi instead address Garsivaz as the one who should convey the story favorably. Mohl’s wording about the story in its entirety lacks that same explicit second-person reporting verb, but does not independently settle the English’s first-person assignment. The shift anticipates Bijan’s later direct defense and makes his negotiation more self-directed. All four then retain the request for intercession over his blood or life and the appeal to guidance toward good. Noble heart adds an ethical characterization to that appeal. Garsivaz’s refusal to close with the sharp-clawed man and his recognition that bloodshed would follow explain why he offers oaths and kindly counsel. Those assurances are tactical within the scene; their favorable tone should not be mistaken for the narrator certifying his trustworthiness.
31–35Smooth words and binding
English 31–35: see individual register accounts. V25:298 running text; V25 n28 actual به چربی variant; V26:299 running text; V26 n1 actual سرپای variant; V26:300 running text; V26 nn2 and4 actual added tearful-delivery verse; V26:301 running text
Moscow printed p.25 · Moscow printed p.26 · Mohl printed p.161 · Khaleghi printed p.325 · Ganjoor sh3:46 · Ganjoor sh3:47 · Ganjoor sh3:48 · Ganjoor sh3:49
The pact removes the dagger before it removes Bijan’s freedom. All four retain that sequence, but English’s oil and smoothness draws on Mohl and Khaleghi’s charbi wording, also actually recorded as a Moscow variant, rather than Moscow’s and Ganjoor’s main wording about goodness or kindliness. The oily idiom makes the verbal maneuver tangible without adding a second agreement. Head-to-foot likewise follows Mohl’s wording and an actual Moscow variant. The cheetah comparison then makes the humiliation depend on disabling a dangerous creature, not proving it harmless. The crooked celestial agent and the contrast of softness with harshness remain recognizable across the sources. Bijan’s yellow face and tears during the transfer are Mohl running text and actual Moscow and Khaleghi apparatus, with a checked Ganjoor gap. The next shared bareheaded appearance concerns the uncovered head; English adds the detail of standing on royal ground.
36–40A defense begins with a lost hawk
English 36–40: see individual register accounts. V26:301–302 and n7 checked local gap; n7 is heading only, not question; V26:302 running text; V26:304 running text; V26:305 running text; V26:306 running text; V26 n11 actual میهن variant
Moscow printed p.26 · Mohl printed p.161 · Khaleghi printed p.325 · Ganjoor sh3:50 · Ganjoor sh3:52 · Ganjoor sh3:53 · Ganjoor sh3:54
Mohl prints the king’s reckless-head address and question about coming to this land. Moscow and Ganjoor move directly from the bound appearance to Bijan’s blessing. Khaleghi’s actual apparatus gives different insults concerning appearance and origin, not this same geographical question. English’s fuller exchange therefore follows a specific verified presentation. Bijan offers truth, denies voluntary attendance and disclaims anyone’s guilt. Moscow and Ganjoor add a separate promise to recount everything if the king will listen, also in Khaleghi’s actual apparatus; English absorbs the listening invitation without a separate promise verse. Feast follows the fuller banquet wording where Khaleghi’s main text instead has presence or the land of Turan. The lost hawk is common to all four. House and home follows Mohl and Khaleghi’s homeland wording, while Moscow and Ganjoor describe the dear household. These are assertions in a defense, not newly supplied narrator facts.
41–45The pari as an alibi
English 41–45: see individual register accounts. V26:307 running text; V26:308 running text; V26:309 running text; V26:310 running text; V26:311 running text
Moscow printed p.26 · Mohl printed p.161 · Khaleghi printed p.325 · Khaleghi printed p.326 · Ganjoor sh3:55 · Ganjoor sh3:56 · Ganjoor sh3:57 · Ganjoor sh3:58 · Ganjoor sh3:59
Cypress sleep, a wing-spreading pari, removal from the horse and the princess’s procession appear in all four sources. English keeps that sequence, including its awkward move from sleeping beneath a tree to being separated from a horse. Because Bijan is speaking defensively, the commentary need not repair his account into a consistent eyewitness itinerary or treat the abduction as the narrator’s factual explanation. The feminine pronoun specifies a gender that Persian grammar itself leaves unmarked. It is understandable within the episode but remains a translation choice. Horsemen, multiple litters and the Indian parasol give the alibi recognizable royal surroundings. English’s train on train intensifies their multiplicity, while appeared in view generalizes the parasol’s explicit emergence at a distance. The specificity of the procession makes the story persuasive without establishing that its supernatural explanation is true.
46–50An enchanted sleeper changes identity
English 46–50: see individual register accounts. V26:312 running text; V26 n19 actual عماری variant; V26:313 running text; V26:314 running text; V27:315 running text; V27:316 running text; V27 nn2–3 actual first-person variants
Moscow printed p.26 · Moscow printed p.27 · Mohl printed p.161 · Khaleghi printed p.326 · Ganjoor sh3:60 · Ganjoor sh3:61 · Ganjoor sh3:62 · Ganjoor sh3:63 · Ganjoor sh3:64
Aloeswood, a parniyan covering, the sleeping idol-like figure and the pillow-side crown are verified across the four presentations. Ammari follows Mohl and Khaleghi where Moscow uses a cradle-like litter term and also records the alternative; sweet and catching light add sensory emphasis. The pari’s invocation of Ahriman and spell over the beautiful face make the princess the immediate object of enchantment. At the next verse English follows Mohl’s explicit first-person sleep and awakening: Bijan sleeps in the hall, moves and weeps. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi keep the enchanted figure motionless or asleep until the palace while Bijan is already tearful. Actual Moscow and Khaleghi variants record first-person forms, but should not be conflated with their main text. English thus selects a printed alternative that changes the continuity of consciousness and the relation between the spell and the following awakening.
51–55Innocence claimed and mocked
English 51–55: see individual register accounts. V27:317 running text; V27:318 running text; V27:320 running text; V27 n6 actual روز variant; V27:321 running text; V27 n7 actual گرز variant, main تیغ; neither shaft; V27:322 running text
Moscow printed p.27 · Mohl printed p.161 · Khaleghi printed p.326 · Ganjoor sh3:65 · Ganjoor sh3:66 · Ganjoor sh3:68 · Ganjoor sh3:69 · Ganjoor sh3:70
Bijan’s joint exoneration of himself and Manijeh, followed by identifying the pari with reversed fortune, is present in all four sources. English keeps it inside his speech, preserving the distinction between self-defense and narrative judgment. Moscow’s additional insistence on the account’s exactness and his lack of kin is bracketed running text, also found in Ganjoor and in Khaleghi’s actual apparatus; Mohl and English pass directly to the royal reply. Evil day follows Mohl and Khaleghi’s wording beside Moscow and Ganjoor’s bad fortune. The next weapon requires qualification: Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi print sword and kamand, whereas Mohl prints a heavy mace and kamand. The checked variants do not verify English’s shaft here. Afrasiab’s comparison to bound women and a drunken dreamer is then shared. Its contempt belongs to the hostile king, not an explanatory judgment supplied by the commentator.
56–60Equipment and the fairness of combat
English 56–60: see individual register accounts. V27:323 running text; V27:324 running text; V27:325 running text; V27:326 running text; V27:327 running text
Moscow printed p.27 · Mohl printed p.162 · Khaleghi printed p.326 · Ganjoor sh3:71 · Ganjoor sh3:72 · Ganjoor sh3:73 · Ganjoor sh3:74 · Ganjoor sh3:75
Afrasiab’s accusation that lies are being tried to save a head is common to all four sources. English’s doom ahead makes the implied death sentence explicit. Bijan answers by insisting that the king listen; judge what truth may be adds an evaluative instruction to that request. The animal comparison then depends on equipment: boars have tusks and lions have claws, just as warriors need weapons. English’s nature’s laws turns that concrete analogy into a general principle. The sword, shaft and bow follow Moscow, Ganjoor and Mohl; Khaleghi has a mace in its main list but actually records arrow as a variant. This verified arrow belongs here and does not certify shaft in the earlier royal accusation. The contrast between a bound naked man and a steel-clad opponent is preserved, while sword in hands adds a weapon to this particular pair of half-lines.
61–65The thousand-warrior challenge
English 61–65: see individual register accounts. V27:328 running text; V27:329 running text; V27:330 running text; V27:331 running text; V27 n17 actual ماند variant against مانم main; V27:332 running text
Moscow printed p.27 · Mohl printed p.162 · Khaleghi printed p.326 · Khaleghi printed p.327 · Ganjoor sh3:76 · Ganjoor sh3:77 · Ganjoor sh3:78 · Ganjoor sh3:79 · Ganjoor sh3:80
The lion deprived of sharp claws returns Bijan’s argument to the disabling effect of captivity. English’s blunt claws is more specific than the source’s lack of sharp claws, but preserves the mismatch between courage and equipment. All four presentations then request a horse, a heavy mace and a thousand Turanian opponents. English’s chiefs follows the main Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi wording; Mohl calls them riders. The survival condition must be read with its variant record: the checked running texts use a first-person form, if I remain alive, whereas actual Moscow and Khaleghi variants give a third-person form. English’s if one of that thousand remains alive selects the latter construction and makes exterminating every opponent the test of manhood. This has printed support but is not unanimous running-text agreement. The king’s angry glance ends the challenge without accepting its proposed terms.
66–70A private offense becomes a national warning
English 66–70: see individual register accounts. V27:333 running text; V27:334 running text; V27:335 running text; V28:336 running text; V28:337 running text
Moscow printed p.27 · Moscow printed p.28 · Mohl printed p.159 · Mohl printed p.162 · Khaleghi printed p.327 · Ganjoor sh3:81 · Ganjoor sh3:82 · Ganjoor sh3:83 · Ganjoor sh3:84 · Ganjoor sh3:85
Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi print the grievance about what Iran has done and will yet do at this point. Mohl gives the glance toward Garsivaz with a different second half, while printing the Iran grievance earlier in the discovery scene. The English retains it in both C2.7 and C2.8. That duplication combines placements and should not be treated as two independently attested statements in every edition; the earlier chapter remains unchanged. All four make the king resent Bijan’s continuing ambition and demand immediate removal in bonds. Heavy specifies their weight beyond this command’s wording. The public gallows then changes a private palace offense into a visible assertion of power. Every road passing the site is grounded in the shared text, while men waiting adds a staged audience. The threat’s political scale emerges from the following deterrent order, rather than from an invented legal procedure.
71–75Execution ordered, reputation endangered
English 71–75: see individual register accounts. V28:338 running text; V28:339 running text; V28:340 running text; V28:341 running text; V28:342 running text
Moscow printed p.28 · Mohl printed p.162 · Khaleghi printed p.327 · Ganjoor sh3:86 · Ganjoor sh3:87 · Ganjoor sh3:88 · Ganjoor sh3:89 · Ganjoor sh3:90
The order to hang Bijan alive and never speak of him again agrees across Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi. English preserves the king’s wish to end both the life and the conversation. His ensuing warning is directed toward Iranian men who might look toward Turan; lift his eyes gives that look an additional implication of daring. The removal from the royal presence and Bijan’s wounded heart are shared. At the gate the Persian makes blood from his eyelashes form the mire holding his feet. English retains the extraordinary mud of weeping but drops its explicit blood, making the image less violent. Bijan’s next conditional accepts what the Maker may have written for his death. The movement from royal orders to this inner reckoning prepares his concern about public dishonor; it does not imply that he has abandoned his claim to courage.
76–80Fear of shame and grief for home
English 76–80: see individual register accounts. V28:343 running text; V28 n9 actual grief variants and added distinction between champions and Iranians; V28:344 running text; V28:345 running text; V28:347 running text; V28 n15 actual wish-fulfilled-on-body variant; V28:348 running text
Moscow printed p.28 · Mohl printed p.162 · Khaleghi printed p.327 · Khaleghi printed p.328 · Ganjoor sh3:91 · Ganjoor sh3:92 · Ganjoor sh3:93 · Ganjoor sh3:95 · Ganjoor sh3:96
Bijan distinguishes the gallows from the judgment of Iran’s heroes. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi’s main wording names fear, while Mohl and actual variants support grief or distress; further printed additions distinguish champions from Iranians more generally. English’s fill my heart leaves the emotion open, preserving its object while reducing the sharp declaration of fearing reputation more than death. The unwounded body on the gallows matters because it could invite the enemy’s accusation of unmanliness; base is a broader English insult. Noble ancestors and posthumous reproach agree across the presentations. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi also give a separate verse about the soul remaining here from shame before the father, omitted by Mohl and English. The enemy’s fulfilled wish on Bijan’s flesh follows Mohl and actual variants, beside the main luminous-body image elsewhere. The lament for king, comrades and Giv then retains their personal loss.
81–85The wind carries an accusation
English 81–85: see individual register accounts. V28:349 running text; V28:350 running text; V420 Appendix II after349, actual verse3; V28 n20 is only its pointer; V420 Appendix II after349, actual verse4; V28 n20 is only its pointer; V420 Appendix II after349, actual verse5; V28 n20 is only its pointer
Moscow printed p.28 · Moscow printed p.420 · Mohl printed p.163 · Khaleghi printed p.328 · Ganjoor sh3:97 · Ganjoor sh3:98
The wind message to Iran and its king is Moscow and Mohl running text, Ganjoor’s closing passage and actual Khaleghi apparatus. English retains the address but removes the comparison of Bijan to a deer in a lion’s grasp, adding a chain to make captivity explicit. The final Gudarz and Gorgin messages require a different evidence class: Mohl prints them continuously, Moscow prints them in Appendix II after the wind address, and Khaleghi prints them in its long actual addition. Ganjoor ends locally without those units. Khaleghi reverses the last two complaints. The fuller appendix and addition also route the message toward Sistan and Rostam, omitted by English. English preserves blame for lost honor, the dog insult and reckoning in the other abode; where souls are brought interprets that last phrase. Reading the actual appendix supplies verification that its earlier pointer alone could not provide.
Source record and limits
C2.8 only: 85 English couplets / 170 unchanged lines; 17 substantive notes. Moscow V24–28:272–350, plus selected actual apparatus and Appendix II, V420:1–5 after349. Mohl III159–163:298–381 (PDF165–169). Ganjoor bizhan sh3:20–98. Khaleghi III323–328:245–318 (PDF339–344), plus actual apparatus including selected portions of III328 n5. Every declared running unit accounted; four source-only rows. Moscow and Mohl checked individually first.
Primary coverage means individual source accounting, including checked local gaps, not universal agreement. Moscow319 is bracketed running text. Appendix II1–5 actually read; its6–9 concern the following episode and are not collated here. Khaleghi long n5 is selectively collated, not exhaustively certified. Actual apparatus means inspected printed words, never an addition notice. Selected Persian readings normalize spacing and are not complete diplomatic transcriptions. Shaft in English54 is not verified at the checked locus; abgun does not independently certify a forging process. Mohl III162:362 second hemistich is not transcribed or used as lexical evidence; the glance and its difference from the Iran grievance are recorded. All inherited flags remain unchanged.
All170 lines of retained12 November raw HTML compared with current indexed text (turn49view0,turn49view1). C2.9 Piran Pleads for Bijan’s Life starts divine mercy and is excluded. Raw capture is retained, not described as a fresh HTTP capture.
- Moscow: printed 24 /PDF 24 · printed 25 /PDF 25 · printed 26 /PDF 26 · printed 27 /PDF 27 · printed 28 /PDF 28 · printed 420 /PDF 420. Existing PDF reused; PNG facsimiles visually inspected. No scans delivered.
- Mohl: printed 159 /PDF 165 · printed 160 /PDF 166 · printed 161 /PDF 167 · printed 162 /PDF 168 · printed 163 /PDF 169. Existing PDF reused; PNG facsimiles visually inspected. No scans delivered.
- Khaleghi: printed 323 /PDF 339 · printed 324 /PDF 340 · printed 325 /PDF 341 · printed 326 /PDF 342 · printed 327 /PDF 343 · printed 328 /PDF 344. Existing PDF reused; PNG facsimiles visually inspected. No scans delivered.
- Ganjoor sh3 indexed Persian poem body (turn50search0,turn51search0; re-retrieved for source capture); only verse body used, excluding comments, AI glosses and transliteration. End of sh3 checked against sh4 opening.
Evidence classes: Moscow/Mohl running text was checked first for every English account. Moscow319 is bracketed running text, not apparatus. Moscow V24n23, V25n11/n28, V26nn1–4, V27nn2–3/n17 and V28n15 contain actual words used here. V28n20 only points to Appendix II; actual Appendix II1–5 at420 was separately read. Khaleghi III323n22,325nn4/10/11,326nn9–11,327n4/n20 and328n3/n5 contain selected actual readings. Whole-edition absence and exhaustive apparatus claims are not made.
Source-only S1: promise to tell everything (Moscow303,Ganjoor51,Khaleghi325n11; Mohl333–334 local gap). S2: exactness/no kin (bracketed Moscow319,Ganjoor67,Khaleghi326n11; Mohl348–349 local gap). S3: soul held by shame (Moscow346,Khaleghi318,Ganjoor94; Mohl374–375 gap). S4: wind route to heroes/Sistan/Rostam, Moscow Appendix II1–2 and selected Khaleghi328n5:11–13; Mohl378–379 and Ganjoor ending locally lack this separate route.
Unverified or interpretive distinctions: shaft in English54; forging process inferred from abgun; first-person reporter in English26; explicit female pronoun for pari; sensory/staging additions. English50 and64 have individually documented printed alternatives; they are not promoted into agreement of all main texts. The duplicated Iran grievance combines variant placements; prior C2.7 remains untouched. Mohl362 second half is not certified as a lexical quotation. All inherited flags retained verbatim.
- Mohl III160:307–308 running; Moscow V24 n23 has different rebuke; Khaleghi323:253–254/Ganjoor28–29 gaps: خویش نشناس نازاده مرد / فتادی به چنگال شیر ژیان
- All four dagger descriptions: Moscow V25:285;Mohl III160:313;Khaleghi III324:258;Ganjoor sh3:33: خنجری ... آبگون
- Moscow V25:293 and Ganjoor sh3:41; Khaleghi III324:267 differs in introduction but retains second-person report: به خوبی برو داستان آوری / بخواه برو داستان آوری
- Mohl III161:327;Khaleghi III325:272;actual Moscow V25 n28: به چربی کشیدش به بند اندرا
- Mohl III161:332 running question; Khaleghi III325 n10 actual different insults: چرا آمدستی بدین بوم و بر
- Mohl III161:346 running first-person awakening: زمانی به ایوان بماندم بخواب / بجنبیدم و چشم کردم پر آب
- Moscow V27:316;Ganjoor sh3:64;Khaleghi III326:289 main third-person continuity: که تا اندر ایوان نیامد ز خواب / نجنبید و من چشم کرده پر آب
- Moscow V27:319 BRACKETED running, Ganjoor sh3:67;actual Khaleghi III326 n11: چنین بد که گفتم کم و بیش نه / مرا ایدر اکنون کس و خویش نه
- English54: Moscow V27:321/Ganjoor sh3:69/Khaleghi III326:293 main versus Mohl III161:350: تیغ و کمند / گرز گران و کمند
- English64: Moscow V27:331 and Khaleghi III327:303 running versus actual V27 n17/III327 n4: مانم / ماند
- English79: Mohl III162:375 and actual Moscow V28 n15/Khaleghi III328 n3 variant: برآید همه کام دل بر تنم
- Moscow V420 Appendix II3–5; Mohl III163:379–381; actual Khaleghi III328 n5:16–18, reordered: به گودرز کشواد از من بگوی / که از کار گرگین شدم آبروی
C2.8 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V24:272 running text | III159:298 running text |
| 2 | V24:273 running text | III159:299 running text |
| 3 | V24:274 running text | III159:300 running text |
| 4 | V24:275 running text | III159:301 running text |
| 5 | V24:276 running text | III159:301–III160:302 checked local gap for separate encircling-riders verse |
| 6 | V24:277 running text | III160:302 running text |
| 7 | V24:278 running text | III160:303 running text |
| 8 | V24:279 running text | III160:304 running text; III160:304 anger at brow, not blood in veins |
| 9 | V24:280 running text | III160:305 running text |
| 10 | V24 n23 actual added verse1: MANIJEH sitting among women with red wine, not Bijan | III160:306 running text |
| 11 | V24 n23 actual added verse2: different rebuke, know your place; no kin-disowning wording at checked280–281 | III160:307 running text |
| 12 | V24:280–V25:281 and V24 n23 checked local gap for lion-life challenge | III160:308 running text |
| 13 | V25:281 running text | III160:309 running text |
| 14 | V25:282 running text | III160:310 running text |
| 15 | V25:284 running text | III160:311 running text |
| 16 | V25:283 running text | III160:312 running text |
| 17 | V25:285 running text | III160:313 running text |
| 18 | V25:286 running text | III160:314 running text |
| 19 | V25:287 running text | III160:315 running text |
| 20 | V25:288 running text | III160:316 running text |
| 21 | V25:289 running text | III160:317 running text |
| 22 | V25 n11 actual added bad-fortune address after289 | III160:318 running text |
| 23 | V25:290 running text | III160:319 running text |
| 24 | V25:291 running text | III160:320 running text |
| 25 | V25:292 running text | III160:321 running text |
| 26 | V25:293 running text | III160:322 running text |
| 27 | V25:294 running text | III160:323 running text |
| 28 | V25:295 running text | III160:324 running text |
| 29 | V25:296 running text | III160:325 running text |
| 30 | V25:297 running text | III160:326 running text |
| 31 | V25:298 running text; V25 n28 actual به چربی variant | III161:327 running text |
| 32 | V26:299 running text; V26 n1 actual سرپای variant | III161:328 running text |
| 33 | V26:300 running text | III161:329 running text |
| 34 | V26 nn2 and4 actual added tearful-delivery verse | III161:330 running text |
| 35 | V26:301 running text | III161:331 running text |
| 36 | V26:301–302 and n7 checked local gap; n7 is heading only, not question | III161:332 running text |
| 37 | V26:302 running text | III161:333 running text |
| 38 | V26:304 running text | III161:334 running text |
| 39 | V26:305 running text | III161:335 running text |
| 40 | V26:306 running text; V26 n11 actual میهن variant | III161:336 running text |
| 41 | V26:307 running text | III161:337 running text |
| 42 | V26:308 running text | III161:338 running text |
| 43 | V26:309 running text | III161:339 running text |
| 44 | V26:310 running text | III161:340 running text |
| 45 | V26:311 running text | III161:341 running text |
| 46 | V26:312 running text; V26 n19 actual عماری variant | III161:342 running text |
| 47 | V26:313 running text | III161:343 running text |
| 48 | V26:314 running text | III161:344 running text |
| 49 | V27:315 running text | III161:345 running text |
| 50 | V27:316 running text; V27 nn2–3 actual first-person variants | III161:346 running text |
| 51 | V27:317 running text | III161:347 running text |
| 52 | V27:318 running text | III161:348 running text |
| 53 | V27:320 running text; V27 n6 actual روز variant | III161:349 running text |
| 54 | V27:321 running text; V27 n7 actual گرز variant, main تیغ; neither shaft | III161:350 running text |
| 55 | V27:322 running text | III161:351 running text |
| 56 | V27:323 running text | III162:352 running text |
| 57 | V27:324 running text | III162:353 running text |
| 58 | V27:325 running text | III162:354 running text |
| 59 | V27:326 running text | III162:355 running text |
| 60 | V27:327 running text | III162:356 running text |
| 61 | V27:328 running text | III162:357 running text |
| 62 | V27:329 running text | III162:358 running text |
| 63 | V27:330 running text | III162:359 running text |
| 64 | V27:331 running text; V27 n17 actual ماند variant against مانم main | III162:360 running text |
| 65 | V27:332 running text | III162:361 running text |
| 66 | V27:333 running text | III162:362 running text; III159:294 earlier running Iran grievance; current III162:362 has different second hemistich, not used as lexical evidence |
| 67 | V27:334 running text | III162:363 running text |
| 68 | V27:335 running text | III162:364 running text |
| 69 | V28:336 running text | III162:365 running text |
| 70 | V28:337 running text | III162:366 running text |
| 71 | V28:338 running text | III162:367 running text |
| 72 | V28:339 running text | III162:368 running text |
| 73 | V28:340 running text | III162:369 running text |
| 74 | V28:341 running text | III162:370 running text |
| 75 | V28:342 running text | III162:371 running text |
| 76 | V28:343 running text; V28 n9 actual grief variants and added distinction between champions and Iranians | III162:372 running text |
| 77 | V28:344 running text | III162:373 running text |
| 78 | V28:345 running text | III162:374 running text |
| 79 | V28:347 running text; V28 n15 actual wish-fulfilled-on-body variant | III162:375 running text |
| 80 | V28:348 running text | III162:376 running text |
| 81 | V28:349 running text | III163:377 running text |
| 82 | V28:350 running text | III163:378 running text |
| 83 | V420 Appendix II after349, actual verse3; V28 n20 is only its pointer | III163:379 running text |
| 84 | V420 Appendix II after349, actual verse4; V28 n20 is only its pointer | III163:380 running text |
| 85 | V420 Appendix II after349, actual verse5; V28 n20 is only its pointer | III163:381 running text |
New Naqqali