Houman Challenges Fariborz
28 verbatim couplets;Houman Challenges Fariborz;ends before C3.11 Houman Challenges Gudarz.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 28 verbatim couplets;Houman Challenges Fariborz;ends before C3.11 Houman Challenges Gudarz. |
| Moscow | V113–114:491–516;26 main units plus actual113n23 ancestry claim. Wind492;vengeance498 before duel499;household unit locally absent;Siavash507;command511. |
| Mohl | III227–228:489–516;28 main units. Elephant490;ancestry496;duel497 before vengeance498;direct lion address502;household505;Kayanian507;command511;horsemen515;unlovely gorz516. |
| Ganjoor | 12rokh sh8:49–74;26 main units. Local gaps for ancestry and household units. Wind50;vengeance56 before duel57;Siavash65;Viseh wording69. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | IV33–35:494–520;27 main units. Elephant495;vengeance501,ancestry502,duel503;household local gap;Kayanian511;outcome515;wooden gorz520. Selected actual alternatives separately recorded. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–5The challenge turns lost command into humiliation
English 1–5;individual source locators and linked evidence below. Main text,actual apparatus and checked local gaps distinguished.
Moscow V113:491 running text · Moscow V113:492 running text;actual113n17 elephant alternative · Moscow V113:493 running text · Moscow V113:494 running text · Moscow V113:495 running text · Mohl III227:489 running text · Mohl III227:490 running text · Mohl III227:491 running text · Mohl III227:492 running text · Mohl III227:493 running text · Khaleghi IV33:494 running text · Khaleghi IV33:495 running text · Khaleghi IV33:496 running text · Khaleghi IV33:497 running text · Khaleghi IV33:498 running text · Ganjoor sh8:49 poem body · Ganjoor sh8:50 poem body · Ganjoor sh8:51 poem body · Ganjoor sh8:52 poem body · Ganjoor sh8:53 poem body
All four move Houman through the army’s center to the other side, with an interpreter accompanying him. Mohl and Khaleghi compare him to a raging elephant; Moscow and Ganjoor have a rushing wind, with elephant preserved in Moscow’s actual apparatus. English follows the animal reading and amplifies its bodily strength. The address to Fariborz then contrasts his lowered neck with the other chiefs. Horsemen, elephants, golden footwear and the banner establish the standing he has lost. English makes the banner’s association with Kaveh explicit and adds a duty to uphold it. The accusation of surrender to the Turks is shared, but English supplies witnesses through Houman’s own men. Its final temporal qualification makes the denial of manhood sound like a damaged reputation that might yet be recovered.
6–10Royal birth becomes a demand for personal combat
English 6–10;individual source locators and linked evidence below. Main text,actual apparatus and checked local gaps distinguished.
Moscow V113:496 running text · Moscow V113:497 running text · Moscow V113:497–499 checked local running-text gap;actual113n23 prints full descent claim after498 · Moscow V113:499 running text · Moscow V113:498 running text · Mohl III227:494 running text · Mohl III227:495 running text · Mohl III228:496 running text · Mohl III228:497 running text · Mohl III228:498 running text · Khaleghi IV33:499 running text · Khaleghi IV33:500 running text · Khaleghi IV33:502 running text · Khaleghi IV33:503 running text · Khaleghi IV33:501 running text · Ganjoor sh8:54 poem body · Ganjoor sh8:55 poem body · Ganjoor Checked local body gap between sh8:55–56 · Ganjoor sh8:57 poem body · Ganjoor sh8:56 poem body
All four make subordinate command sound like servitude and contrast Fariborz’s royal birth with his commander’s rank. The appeal to his brother Siavash then turns ancestry into an obligation to avenge. Mohl and Khaleghi print Houman’s descent from Tur; Moscow preserves the complete couplet in its actual apparatus, while Ganjoor has a checked local gap. The verified Persian claims possible equality with Fariborz, not superiority. English preserves the tentative claim but intensifies its substance by giving Houman the higher place. This is a substantive departure, not an additional verified variant. English follows Mohl in placing the duel before the vengeance demand; the other three put vengeance first. The watching shields make the army’s public scrutiny concrete, sustaining the pressure on Fariborz’s reputation.
11–14Substitutes and the disputed lion address
English 11–14;individual source locators and linked evidence below. Main text,actual apparatus and checked local gaps distinguished.
Moscow V113:500 running text · Moscow V114:501 running text · Moscow V114:502 running text · Moscow V114:503 running text;actual114n4 direct-address alternative · Mohl III228:499 running text · Mohl III228:500 running text · Mohl III228:501 running text · Mohl III228:502 running text · Khaleghi IV34:504 running text · Khaleghi IV34:505 running text · Khaleghi IV34:506 running text · Khaleghi IV34:507 running text;actual34n6 direct-address alternatives · Ganjoor sh8:58 poem body · Ganjoor sh8:59 poem body · Ganjoor sh8:60 poem body · Ganjoor sh8:61 poem body
All four promise sun-like fame, name Zavareh and Guraza as alternatives, and ask for a renowned Iranian champion. English turns the request to locate the alternatives into explicit substitution, then supplies a sword that can answer Houman’s claim. This frames combat as the answer to an accusation rather than simply the appearance of another warrior. Fariborz’s reply has a consequential grammatical difference. Mohl directly addresses the rending lion, supporting the English vocative. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi instead warn against making an enemy of a rending lion, allowing Fariborz to describe the danger of challenging himself. Actual Moscow and Khaleghi apparatus readings also preserve direct address. English thus has printed support for addressing Houman, while its request to avoid this fight narrows the broader warning against enmity.
15–18Prudence answers the accusation of cowardice
English 15–18;individual source locators and linked evidence below. Main text,actual apparatus and checked local gaps distinguished.
Moscow V114:504 running text · Moscow V114:505 running text · Moscow V114:505–506 checked local running-text gap;no unit in inspected local apparatus · Moscow V114:506 running text · Mohl III228:503 running text · Mohl III228:504 running text · Mohl III228:505 running text · Mohl III228:506 running text · Khaleghi IV34:508 running text · Khaleghi IV34:509 running text · Khaleghi IV34:509–510 checked local running-text gap;no unit in inspected local apparatus · Khaleghi IV34:510 running text · Ganjoor sh8:62 poem body · Ganjoor sh8:63 poem body · Ganjoor Checked local body gap between sh8:63–64 · Ganjoor sh8:64 poem body
All four contrast the happy victor with the suffering opponent, then warn that even victory gives no security under changing heavens. English enlarges the contrast into fame against destruction, grief and shame, making reputation part of the danger as well as Houman’s promised reward. Mohl next warns that stubbornness brings speech to a point that ruins ancient households. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi pass directly from unstable fortune to the Shah’s authority in the checked local text. Their local gaps are recorded separately from Mohl’s positive running-text evidence; no uninspected appendix is claimed as confirmation. English preserves the warning but replaces the escalation of speech with growing anger and makes people the agents of their households’ ruin. The shared defense of the Shah’s right to redistribute command then gives Fariborz a political answer to Houman’s personal insult.
19–23Dynastic service legitimizes Gudarz’s authority
English 19–23;individual source locators and linked evidence below. Main text,actual apparatus and checked local gaps distinguished.
Moscow V114:507 running text;actual114n7 Kayanian alternatives · Moscow V114:508 running text · Moscow V114:509 running text · Moscow V114:510 running text · Moscow V114:511 running text · Mohl III228:507 running text · Mohl III228:508 running text · Mohl III228:509 running text · Mohl III228:510 running text · Mohl III228:511 running text · Khaleghi IV34:511 running text;actual34n9 Siavash and temporal alternatives · Khaleghi IV34:512 running text · Khaleghi IV34:513 running text · Khaleghi IV34:514 running text · Khaleghi IV34:515 running text;actual34n15 command alternatives · Ganjoor sh8:65 poem body · Ganjoor sh8:66 poem body · Ganjoor sh8:67 poem body · Ganjoor sh8:68 poem body · Ganjoor sh8:69 poem body
Mohl and Khaleghi name Kayanian vengeance after Kay Qobad, whereas Moscow and Ganjoor’s main texts name Siavash; actual apparatus alternatives document the difference. English follows the Kayanian reading, making the broader dynastic claim intelligible without silently correcting the other presentations. Its disjunction between arming and prospering the world makes two alternatives where the source sequence does not explicitly supply that choice. All four connect Gudarz and his forebears with royal service and predict that his gorz will end the opposing leader’s life. Moscow and Mohl then assign command of war to him, supporting English. Khaleghi speaks of war’s outcome, with command alternatives in its apparatus; Ganjoor instead prints Viseh in this clause. That discrepant wording remains visible rather than being normalized into agreement.
24–28Permission remains the answer to the final taunt
English 24–28;individual source locators and linked evidence below. Main text,actual apparatus and checked local gaps distinguished.
Moscow V114:512 running text · Moscow V114:513 running text · Moscow V114:514 running text · Moscow V114:515 running text · Moscow V114:516 running text;actual114n25 unlovely/crude alternative · Mohl III228:512 running text · Mohl III228:513 running text · Mohl III228:514 running text · Mohl III228:515 running text · Mohl III228:516 running text · Khaleghi IV34:516 running text · Khaleghi IV34:517 running text · Khaleghi IV34:518 running text · Khaleghi IV34:519 running text · Khaleghi IV35:520 running text;actual35n1 unlovely alternative · Ganjoor sh8:70 poem body · Ganjoor sh8:71 poem body · Ganjoor sh8:72 poem body · Ganjoor sh8:73 poem body · Ganjoor sh8:74 poem body
All four make Fariborz’s participation conditional on his commander’s permission and describe combat as healing his heart. English follows Mohl and Khaleghi’s wound image, while Moscow and Ganjoor use pain, and makes vengeance the explicit cure. Its raised head and cleared name render the shared emergence from shame as bodily and reputational recovery. Houman dismisses this answer as verbal skill. Mohl then asks why the sword-belted warrior stays clear of the horsemen’s fighting, supporting English’s question; the other main texts instead speak of supposing he has escaped battle. The final disparagement likewise follows Mohl’s unlovely gorz, with actual apparatus support. Khaleghi calls it wood; Moscow and Ganjoor do not qualify its manufacture. All four deny its effectiveness against helm and jowshan, which English interprets as failure to break armor.
Source record and limits
C3.10 only:28 English couplets. Moscow V113–114:491–516 (26 main units),plus actual113n23 descent claim;Mohl III227–228:489–516 (PDF233–234,28 main units);Ganjoor12rokh sh8:49–74 (26 units);Khaleghi IV33–35:494–520 (PDF49–51,27 main units). Every declared main unit accounted;no source-only rows.
Existing Moscow V and Mohl III PDFs inspected individually as PNG facsimiles first;then the existing Ganjoor sh8 body capture and Khaleghi IV PNG. Every English couplet has an individual account for both primary editions. Persian reference text is Ganjoor except English8 and17,which use explicitly labeled,scan-checked Mohl units. Orthographic joining in those short transcriptions is normalized;readings are not combined from witnesses.
- F&R English: 28 verbatim couplets;Houman Challenges Fariborz;ends before C3.11 Houman Challenges Gudarz.
- Moscow: V113–114:491–516;26 main units plus actual113n23 ancestry claim. Wind492;vengeance498 before duel499;household unit locally absent;Siavash507;command511.
- Mohl: III227–228:489–516;28 main units. Elephant490;ancestry496;duel497 before vengeance498;direct lion address502;household505;Kayanian507;command511;horsemen515;unlovely gorz516.
- Ganjoor: 12rokh sh8:49–74;26 main units. Local gaps for ancestry and household units. Wind50;vengeance56 before duel57;Siavash65;Viseh wording69.
- Khaleghi-Motlagh: IV33–35:494–520;27 main units. Elephant495;vengeance501,ancestry502,duel503;household local gap;Kayanian511;outcome515;wooden gorz520. Selected actual alternatives separately recorded.
Positive apparatus evidence:actual Moscow V113n23 prints the complete Tur-descent couplet after498. It is not counted as Moscow running text. Mohl496 and Khaleghi502 print it in the main text. All three use peer/equal wording,so English8 higher place is a substantive intensification,not a verified higher-rank variant. Ganjoor has a checked local gap. English9–10 follows Mohl’s duel-before-vengeance order;the other three put vengeance first.
Mohl505 positively supports the household warning. Moscow505–506,Ganjoor63–64 and Khaleghi509–510 were checked locally and pass directly to the banner defense;the inspected local apparatus does not print the warning. No appendix was used or certified absent. These bounded negative findings are not converted into claims about every witness.
Selected actual apparatus:Moscow113n17 elephant;114n4 direct lion address;114n7 Kayanian wording;114n25 unlovely gorz. Khaleghi34n6 direct-address alternatives;34n9 Siavash/temporal alternatives;34n15 command against main outcome;35n1 unlovely against main wood. Only the specified readings are certified;this is not a complete apparatus transcription. Ganjoor69’s به ویسه است remains a separately recorded body reading rather than being silently changed to the primary editions’ بدویست. Mohl515 supports the horsemen question.
Selected actual apparatus only:Moscow113n17,113n23,114n4,114n7,114n25;Khaleghi34n6,34n9,34n15,35n1. No appendix evidence,no unprinted addition notice counted as verification. English8 higher place is not the verified peer/equal reading. English17 has Mohl support and checked local gaps in the other three;no global absence claimed. Ganjoor69 Viseh wording retained as printed. All inherited flags retained,including C3.7.19 Ladan,C3.4.55 Chakh and prior Mohl boundary correction;no retrospective audit or cumulative unique Mohl-source count certified.
Capture:56 lines;first From Rohham, Houman crossed the central ground,;last Too weak for helm or jowshan here to break?”.
Confirmed file offsets:Moscow0,Mohl6,Khaleghi16.
C3.10 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V113:491 running text | III227:489 running text |
| 2 | V113:492 running text;actual113n17 elephant alternative | III227:490 running text |
| 3 | V113:493 running text | III227:491 running text |
| 4 | V113:494 running text | III227:492 running text |
| 5 | V113:495 running text | III227:493 running text |
| 6 | V113:496 running text | III227:494 running text |
| 7 | V113:497 running text | III227:495 running text |
| 8 | V113:497–499 checked local running-text gap;actual113n23 prints full descent claim after498 | III228:496 running text |
| 9 | V113:499 running text | III228:497 running text |
| 10 | V113:498 running text | III228:498 running text |
| 11 | V113:500 running text | III228:499 running text |
| 12 | V114:501 running text | III228:500 running text |
| 13 | V114:502 running text | III228:501 running text |
| 14 | V114:503 running text;actual114n4 direct-address alternative | III228:502 running text |
| 15 | V114:504 running text | III228:503 running text |
| 16 | V114:505 running text | III228:504 running text |
| 17 | V114:505–506 checked local running-text gap;no unit in inspected local apparatus | III228:505 running text |
| 18 | V114:506 running text | III228:506 running text |
| 19 | V114:507 running text;actual114n7 Kayanian alternatives | III228:507 running text |
| 20 | V114:508 running text | III228:508 running text |
| 21 | V114:509 running text | III228:509 running text |
| 22 | V114:510 running text | III228:510 running text |
| 23 | V114:511 running text | III228:511 running text |
| 24 | V114:512 running text | III228:512 running text |
| 25 | V114:513 running text | III228:513 running text |
| 26 | V114:514 running text | III228:514 running text |
| 27 | V114:515 running text | III228:515 running text |
| 28 | V114:516 running text;actual114n25 unlovely/crude alternative | III228:516 running text |
New Naqqali