News of Houman Reaches Bijan
93 verbatim couplets;News of Houman Reaches Bijan;ends before C3.13 Giv Arms Bijan with Siavash’s Jowshan.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 93 verbatim couplets;News of Houman Reaches Bijan;ends before C3.13 Giv Arms Bijan with Siavash’s Jowshan. |
| Moscow | V119–123:593–677;85 main units. Checked local gaps for English2,3,4,33,34,35,63,76,85. Actual119n10/120n17/122n14/123n2/123n12 account for seven of these,with English3 only partial correspondence. No positive local unit for4/35. |
| Mohl | III232–235:593–686;94 main units. Fuller report;four killed596;leopard597;grief615;warmth626;negative648;birth655;dragon669;blood672;gorz/sword674;honor/shame678. |
| Ganjoor | 12rokh sh9:1–85;85 body units. Same bounded gaps as Moscow main,without importing its apparatus. God/Ahriman and hard-days/rejection order separately mapped. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | IV39–44:597–685;89 main units. Local main gaps for English3,4,5,35,76;actual39n27 positive lion reaction for5. Challenge598;dust627;negative648;birth655;Ahrimans671;steel673;trickster677. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6The fuller report and the cause of Bijan’s anger
English 1–6;individual main-text,actual apparatus and checked-gap accounts linked separately.
Moscow V119:593 running text · Moscow V119:593–595 checked local running gap;actual V119n10 first complete addition:challenge · Moscow V119:593–595 checked local running gap;actual V119n10 second complete addition:nonresponse/guile,partial correspondence · Moscow V119:593–595 checked local running and selected apparatus gap:four riders unit not printed here · Moscow V119:594 running text · Moscow V119:595 running text · Mohl III232:593 running text · Mohl III232:594 running text · Mohl III232:595 running text · Mohl III232:596 running text · Mohl III232:597 running text · Mohl III232:598 running text · Khaleghi IV39:597 running text · Khaleghi IV40:598 running text · Khaleghi IV39–40:597–599 checked local running and selected apparatus gap:angry departure unit · Khaleghi IV39–40:597–599 checked local running and selected apparatus gap:four riders unit · Khaleghi IV39–40:597–599 checked local running gap;actual IV39n27 full lion reaction · Khaleghi IV40:599 running text · Ganjoor sh9:1 poem body · Ganjoor Checked local body gap;neighboring sh9:1 · Ganjoor Checked local body gap;neighboring sh9:1 · Ganjoor Checked local body gap;neighboring sh9:1 · Ganjoor sh9:2 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:3 poem body
Mohl prints the fuller report continuously: the challenge, the absence of a respondent, the angry departure and the killing of four riders. Moscow’s actual apparatus supplies the challenge and a nonresponse unit whose second half concerns guile; its running text and Ganjoor’s body are shorter. Khaleghi retains the challenge in its main text and places a lion-like reaction in its actual apparatus. English follows Mohl’s fuller movement into anger, including the leopard and sharpened claws. Mohl’s explicit killing verb supports the report’s deadly force, although the English thrust specifies a mechanism absent from that unit. These are findings about the report to Bijan; they do not retroactively revise the preceding chapter’s account. The horse’s elephant-like bulk then converts indignation into preparation.
7–12Equipment precedes an accusation against the elder
English 7–12;individual main-text,actual apparatus and checked-gap accounts linked separately.
Moscow V119:596 running text · Moscow V119:597 running text · Moscow V119:598 running text · Moscow V119:599 running text · Moscow V119:600 running text · Moscow V119:601 running text · Mohl III232:599 running text · Mohl III232:600 running text · Mohl III232:601 running text · Mohl III232:602 running text · Mohl III232:603 running text · Mohl III232:604 running text · Khaleghi IV40:600 running text · Khaleghi IV40:601 running text · Khaleghi IV40:602 running text · Khaleghi IV40:603 running text · Khaleghi IV40:604 running text · Khaleghi IV40:605 running text · Ganjoor sh9:4 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:5 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:6 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:7 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:8 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:9 poem body
All four give Roman armor, a dark horse and the visit to Giv before Bijan recalls his earlier judgment of Gudarz. English preserves that sequence, so the argument begins after physical preparation rather than creating it. Capitalized Shabrang turns a Persian color-word into a recognizable English designation; the word alone does not independently prove a unique horse-name. Disgrace then makes explicit the subject of the conversation. The alleged decline of Gudarz’s judgment belongs to Bijan’s speech in all four, not to an objective narrative diagnosis. English intensifies the accusation with dimness and shadow, while retaining the grief for slain sons that complicates it. The severed heads and bodies are shared; red dust supplies the English battlefield’s color and texture.
13–18The unopposed challenger becomes a test of prowess
English 13–18;individual main-text,actual apparatus and checked-gap accounts linked separately.
Moscow V119:602 running text · Moscow V119:603 running text · Moscow V119:604 running text · Moscow V119:605 running text · Moscow V119:606 running text · Moscow V120:607 running text · Mohl III232:605 running text · Mohl III232:606 running text · Mohl III232:607 running text · Mohl III232:608 running text · Mohl III232:609 running text · Mohl III232:610 running text · Khaleghi IV40:606 running text · Khaleghi IV40:607 running text;actual IV40n17 elephant alternative · Khaleghi IV40:608 running text · Khaleghi IV40:609 running text · Khaleghi IV40:610 running text · Khaleghi IV40:611 running text · Ganjoor sh9:10 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:11 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:12 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:13 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:14 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:15 poem body
The bold Turk is offered as proof of Iran’s inactivity in all four. English moves the spear forward from the following unit, binding the lion-like arrival directly to its weapon. Mohl then compares the challenger to a drunken elephant, while Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi’s main texts give an unqualified drunken likeness; Khaleghi’s actual apparatus includes the elephant. English thus has positive support for its animal rather than requiring an invented expansion. The imagined spearing of Houman and the bird on a roasting implement make the taunt deliberately humiliating. English spit clarifies the culinary image. The request for Siavash’s armor follows in all four, but Bijan immediately insists that only he should fight: inherited equipment and personal prowess already pull against each other.
19–24Giv defends authority through judgment and grief
English 19–24;individual main-text,actual apparatus and checked-gap accounts linked separately.
Moscow V120:608 running text · Moscow V120:609 running text · Moscow V120:610 running text · Moscow V120:611 running text · Moscow V120:612 running text · Moscow V120:613 running text · Mohl III232:611 running text · Mohl III232:612 running text · Mohl III232:613 running text · Mohl III232:614 running text · Mohl III232:615 running text · Mohl III233:616 running text · Khaleghi IV40:612 running text · Khaleghi IV40:613 running text · Khaleghi IV41:614 running text · Khaleghi IV41:615 running text · Khaleghi IV41:616 running text · Khaleghi IV41:617 running text · Ganjoor sh9:16 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:17 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:18 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:19 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:20 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:21 poem body
All four make Giv demand attention, recall his warning against hostile speech and defend Gudarz’s experience and command. The powerful warriors before the commander show that refusal to fight need not mean an absence of strength. English tearing elephants apart retains the hyperbole while making its action readily visible. The father’s next appeal differs substantially. Mohl speaks of pain to heart and soul, supporting the English grief and dread; Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi say that no one was ordered to fight. All then question whether youth has confused Bijan. English follows an emotional defense of restraint at this point, while the other main readings emphasize command discipline. The raised head and urgent approach preserve the bodily signs of the son’s resistance.
25–30The son carries his request beyond his father
English 25–30;individual main-text,actual apparatus and checked-gap accounts linked separately.
Moscow V120:614 running text · Moscow V120:615 running text · Moscow V120:616 running text · Moscow V120:617 running text · Moscow V120:618 running text · Moscow V120:619 running text · Mohl III233:617 running text · Mohl III233:618 running text · Mohl III233:619 running text · Mohl III233:620 running text · Mohl III233:621 running text · Mohl III233:622 running text · Khaleghi IV41:618 running text · Khaleghi IV41:619 running text · Khaleghi IV41:620 running text · Khaleghi IV41:621 running text · Khaleghi IV41:622 running text · Khaleghi IV41:623 running text · Ganjoor sh9:22 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:23 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:24 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:25 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:26 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:27 poem body
All four give Giv an unequivocal refusal and make Bijan answer in terms of fame. English states the implication sharply: a father who denies the request does not wish honor for his son. The decision to approach the commander follows, with girded readiness and language of entering Houman’s fight. English strike my breast makes a particular gesture definite; it should be understood as an interpretation of the compressed phrase, not certified as a distinct printed variant. All four then move Bijan rapidly to Gudarz and combine praise with pain. English supplies a throne for the audience and expands the commander’s royal titles into guarding the Shah and crowning the throne. These ceremonial additions frame a challenge to policy as respectful petition.
31–36A garden in place of battle exposes unequal sequences
English 31–36;individual main-text,actual apparatus and checked-gap accounts linked separately.
Moscow V120:620 running text · Moscow V120:621 running text · Moscow V120:621–622 checked local running gap;actual V120n17 second complete addition:rest · Moscow V120:621–622 checked local running gap;actual V120n17 first complete addition:sword/dust · Moscow V120:621–622 checked local running and selected apparatus gap:offer to bind not printed here · Moscow V120:622 running text · Mohl III233:623 running text · Mohl III233:624 running text · Mohl III233:625 running text · Mohl III233:626 running text · Mohl III233:627 running text · Mohl III233:628 running text · Khaleghi IV41:624 running text · Khaleghi IV41:625 running text · Khaleghi IV41:626 running text · Khaleghi IV41:627 running text · Khaleghi IV41:627–628 checked local running and selected apparatus gap:offer to bind · Khaleghi IV41:628 running text · Ganjoor sh9:28 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:29 poem body · Ganjoor Checked local body gap;neighboring sh9:29 · Ganjoor Checked local body gap;neighboring sh9:29 · Ganjoor Checked local body gap;neighboring sh9:29 · Ganjoor sh9:30 poem body
Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi give Bijan’s wondering at Gudarz; Mohl uses disconcerted wording. English marvel follows the former while preserving the concession of limited wisdom. All four accuse the commander of making a garden from the battlefield. Mohl and Khaleghi then print the rest and sword units in the English order; Moscow supplies them in reversed order in its actual apparatus, while Ganjoor has a local gap. Mohl gives warmth over the air, against dust in Khaleghi and Moscow’s apparatus. English warmth follows Mohl, but exact support for gorz remains unverified. Mohl alone among the inspected local texts prints the ensuing offer to bind an opponent. Those positive and negative findings remain separate rather than being smoothed into one sequence.
37–42Providence and tactics are made to contradict restraint
English 37–42;individual main-text,actual apparatus and checked-gap accounts linked separately.
Moscow V121:623 running text · Moscow V121:624 running text · Moscow V121:625 running text;actual V121n4 wild-ass alternative · Moscow V121:626 running text · Moscow V121:627 running text · Moscow V121:628 running text · Mohl III233:629 running text · Mohl III233:630 running text · Mohl III233:631 running text · Mohl III233:632 running text · Mohl III233:633 running text · Mohl III233:634 running text · Khaleghi IV41:629 running text · Khaleghi IV41:630 running text · Khaleghi IV41:631 running text;actual IV41n15 wild-ass alternative · Khaleghi IV42:632 running text · Khaleghi IV42:633 running text · Khaleghi IV42:634 running text · Ganjoor sh9:31 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:32 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:33 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:34 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:35 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:36 poem body
All four give divine agency in bringing the enemy toward destruction at Gudarz’s hand. English keeps the result prospective, so Bijan is arguing that an opportunity has been wasted rather than reporting Houman already dead. The main texts all use the wolf released from a trap; wild-ass wording occurs in the selected actual apparatus of Moscow and Khaleghi. English therefore follows the shared main animal. The next premise is differently framed: Mohl and Khaleghi use supposition, while Moscow and Ganjoor use knowing. English think follows the former. The argument turns on whether Piran will advance, not merely whether Houman can be beaten. Bijan’s blood-washed hands then declare readiness and turn a tactical dispute into a personal demand for action.
43–48Royal armor joins personal permission and ancestral memory
English 43–48;individual main-text,actual apparatus and checked-gap accounts linked separately.
Moscow V121:629 running text · Moscow V121:630 running text · Moscow V121:631 running text · Moscow V121:632 running text · Moscow V121:633 running text · Moscow V121:634 running text · Mohl III233:635 running text · Mohl III233:636 running text · Mohl III233:637 running text · Mohl III233:638 running text · Mohl III233:639 running text · Mohl III233:640 running text · Khaleghi IV42:635 running text · Khaleghi IV42:636 running text · Khaleghi IV42:637 running text · Khaleghi IV42:638 running text · Khaleghi IV42:639 running text · Khaleghi IV42:640 running text · Ganjoor sh9:37 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:38 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:39 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:40 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:41 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:42 poem body
All four have Bijan seek permission to advance like a roaring lion and ask Gudarz to order Giv to supply Siavash’s arms. English no thought to yield states the resolve implied by the lion image, while in your sight gives the request immediate force. Head protection and Roman armor are shared, as is opening the fastening; English lets the plea become an explicit demand for compliance. Gudarz recognizes both courage and judgment, so the narrative does not simply dismiss the petition as youthful noise. His joyful blessing remains a wish that fortune endure. All four then connect the leopard saddle with the silencing of nahang and lions. English generalizes their stillness while retaining the exceptional scale of the praise.
49–54Praise stops short of an unconditional license
English 49–54;individual main-text,actual apparatus and checked-gap accounts linked separately.
Moscow V121:635 running text · Moscow V121:636 running text · Moscow V121:637 running text · Moscow V121:638 running text · Moscow V121:639 running text · Moscow V121:640 running text · Mohl III234:641 running text · Mohl III234:642 running text · Mohl III234:643 running text · Mohl III234:644 running text · Mohl III234:645 running text · Mohl III234:646 running text · Khaleghi IV42:641 running text · Khaleghi IV42:642 running text · Khaleghi IV42:643 running text · Khaleghi IV42:644 running text · Khaleghi IV42:645 running text · Khaleghi IV42:646 running text · Ganjoor sh9:43 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:44 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:45 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:46 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:47 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:48 poem body
All four praise Bijan’s courage and victory in combat, but English extends the praise into never resting, leading and seeking adventure. Those habitual qualities fit the speech’s admiration without being separate claims printed in this unit. The qualification that follows matters: Gudarz asks whether Bijan can actually face Houman before he challenges him. All four describe Houman as malicious and guileful through the Ahriman comparison, then contrast Bijan’s youth with his disregard for his own safety. English makes the danger explicit through risking life among the dead. The proposed substitute is an experienced lion-like warrior sent like a cloud. English thunder develops that image before the shared hail of arrows, and skin specifies the helmet’s bodily point of attachment.
55–60Bijan answers caution with remembered performance
English 55–60;individual main-text,actual apparatus and checked-gap accounts linked separately.
Moscow V121:641 running text · Moscow V122:642 running text;actual V122n1 negative alternatives · Moscow V122:643 running text · Moscow V122:644 running text · Moscow V122:645 running text · Moscow V122:646 running text · Mohl III234:647 running text · Mohl III234:648 running text · Mohl III234:649 running text · Mohl III234:650 running text · Mohl III234:651 running text · Mohl III234:652 running text · Khaleghi IV42:647 running text · Khaleghi IV42:648 running text · Khaleghi IV42:649 running text · Khaleghi IV43:650 running text · Khaleghi IV43:651 running text · Khaleghi IV43:652 running text · Ganjoor sh9:49 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:50 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:51 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:52 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:53 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:54 poem body
All four make youth compatible with courage and skill, allowing Bijan to answer caution without accepting that experience belongs only to older men. The Forood clause differs: Moscow and Ganjoor say if Gudarz saw the fight; Mohl and Khaleghi say if he did not. Moscow’s actual apparatus also contains negative alternatives. English follows the affirmative main witnesses and names Forood’s fall to identify the episode. The Pashn battle and denial of showing one’s back then support a claim about demonstrated performance. English retains its published Pashan form. The final threat moves from martial reputation to royal appeal: all four give complaint to the Shah and rejection of belt and crown. English cast aside makes that renunciation a concrete act.
61–66The blessing joins paternal pride to permission
English 61–66;individual main-text,actual apparatus and checked-gap accounts linked separately.
Moscow V122:647 running text · Moscow V122:648 running text · Moscow V122:648–650 checked local running gap;actual V122n14 full birth unit after649 · Moscow V122:649 running text · Moscow V122:650 running text · Moscow V122:652 running text · Mohl III234:653 running text · Mohl III234:654 running text · Mohl III234:655 running text · Mohl III234:656 running text · Mohl III234:657 running text · Mohl III234:658 running text · Khaleghi IV43:653 running text · Khaleghi IV43:654 running text · Khaleghi IV43:655 running text · Khaleghi IV43:656 running text · Khaleghi IV43:657 running text · Khaleghi IV43:658 running text · Ganjoor sh9:55 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:56 poem body · Ganjoor Checked local body gap;neighboring sh9:56 · Ganjoor sh9:57 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:58 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:60 poem body
All four respond with Gudarz’s delighted laughter and the cypress image, then congratulate Giv on his son. English rising high develops the image’s stateliness and heroic seed emphasizes inheritance. The blessing of the birth and pure mother appears in Mohl and Khaleghi’s main texts; Moscow supplies it in its actual apparatus after the following claw unit, and Ganjoor has a local gap. English follows the fuller main sequence. The leopard’s defeated claws are shared, while English adds lion-like strength and flight. Permission for the duel follows in all four. The invocation of God precedes the Ahriman exhortation in Mohl and Khaleghi, but follows it in Moscow and Ganjoor. English’s order therefore has direct support and is not an omission in the other sequence.
67–72The grant of combat carries a conditional reward
English 67–72;individual main-text,actual apparatus and checked-gap accounts linked separately.
Moscow V122:651 running text · Moscow V122:653 running text · Moscow V122:654 running text · Moscow V122:655 running text · Moscow V122:656 running text · Moscow V122:657 running text · Mohl III234:659 running text · Mohl III234:660 running text · Mohl III234:661 running text · Mohl III234:662 running text · Mohl III234:663 running text · Mohl III234:664 running text · Khaleghi IV43:659 running text · Khaleghi IV43:660 running text · Khaleghi IV43:661 running text · Khaleghi IV43:662 running text · Khaleghi IV43:663 running text · Khaleghi IV43:664 running text · Ganjoor sh9:59 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:61 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:62 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:63 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:64 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:65 poem body
All four urge Houman’s death at Bijan’s hand under divine command and promise to tell Giv to provide the requested armor. English destined makes the anticipated fate explicit, but the speech remains an exhortation rather than a narrator’s guarantee. Its helm and all recalls the earlier equipment request beyond the immediate reference to armor. The promised increase in standing is conditional on success in all four. English crush emphasizes the force of victory while retaining that condition. Elevation above Farhad and Giv comes with treasure, army, throne and crown, turning recognition into concrete reward. The grandfather then faces a grandson full of devices; English judgment clear evaluates those resources favorably. Dismounting, kissing the ground and blessing the elder close the successful petition.
73–78Giv’s attachment interrupts the apparent settlement
English 73–78;individual main-text,actual apparatus and checked-gap accounts linked separately.
Moscow V122:658 running text · Moscow V122:659 running text · Moscow V122:660 running text;V123:661 running text · Moscow V122:660 running text;V123:661 running text · Moscow V123:661–662 checked local running gap;actual V123n2 full dragon unit · Moscow V123:662 running text · Moscow V123:663 running text · Mohl III234:665 running text · Mohl III235:666 running text · Mohl III235:667 running text;III235:668 running text · Mohl III235:669 running text · Mohl III235:670 running text · Mohl III235:671 running text · Khaleghi IV43:665 running text · Khaleghi IV43:666 running text · Khaleghi IV43:667 running text;IV43:668 running text · Khaleghi IV43:668–669 checked local running and selected apparatus gap:dragon unit · Khaleghi IV43:669 running text · Khaleghi IV44:670 running text · Ganjoor sh9:66 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:67 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:68 poem body;sh9:69 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:68 poem body;sh9:69 poem body · Ganjoor Checked local body gap;neighboring sh9:69 · Ganjoor sh9:70 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:71 poem body
All four summon Giv and recall the royal armor requested for combat. His reply occupies two source units: an introduction identifying the son’s answer to his father, followed by the declaration that Bijan is his mind, life and world. English combines them into one couplet, so source coverage must count both without inventing an extra English unit. Mohl then prints refusal to part with Bijan or send him into a dragon’s breath; Moscow preserves that unit in actual apparatus, while Ganjoor and Khaleghi have checked local gaps. English scorching air develops its danger. Mohl’s following appeal concerns torment of the soul, supporting English; Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi instead ask for a different judgment of Bijan. All defend his wisdom despite youth.
79–84Public vengeance is placed above private kinship
English 79–84;individual main-text,actual apparatus and checked-gap accounts linked separately.
Moscow V123:664 running text · Moscow V123:665 running text · Moscow V123:666 running text · Moscow V123:667 running text · Moscow V123:668 running text · Moscow V123:669 running text · Mohl III235:672 running text · Mohl III235:673 running text · Mohl III235:674 running text · Mohl III235:675 running text · Mohl III235:676 running text · Mohl III235:677 running text · Khaleghi IV44:671 running text · Khaleghi IV44:672 running text · Khaleghi IV44:673 running text · Khaleghi IV44:674 running text · Khaleghi IV44:675 running text · Khaleghi IV44:676 running text · Ganjoor sh9:72 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:73 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:74 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:75 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:76 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:77 poem body
The editions differ at the forceful image introducing the argument. Mohl prints washing the world in blood, supporting English, while Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi print cleansing it of Ahrimans. All subordinate kinship to vengeance for Siavash under royal command. English cannot spare our own makes that sacrifice explicit. The rain of weapons also follows Mohl: it gives gorz and sword, whereas the other main readings give steel blade wording. This verified gorz should not be confused with the unverified one earlier in the chapter. All four then forbid breaking Bijan’s heart and warn that idleness diminishes spirit. English concentrates name and shame into honor and adds coldness to darkness. Giv’s subsequent device shows that the argument has not ended his resistance.
85–89A second attempt changes the basis of refusal
English 85–89;individual main-text,actual apparatus and checked-gap accounts linked separately.
Moscow V123:669–670 checked local running gap;actual V123n12 full honor/shame unit · Moscow V123:670 running text · Moscow V123:672 running text · Moscow V123:671 running text · Moscow V123:673 running text · Mohl III235:678 running text · Mohl III235:679 running text · Mohl III235:680 running text · Mohl III235:681 running text · Mohl III235:682 running text · Khaleghi IV44:677 running text · Khaleghi IV44:678 running text · Khaleghi IV44:679 running text · Khaleghi IV44:680 running text · Khaleghi IV44:681 running text · Ganjoor Checked local body gap;neighboring sh9:77 · Ganjoor sh9:78 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:80 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:79 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:81 poem body
Mohl explicitly turns martial name into shame; Moscow preserves this unit in actual apparatus and Ganjoor has a checked local gap. Khaleghi’s main text instead describes a trickster’s display of color. English follows Mohl’s direct rebuke, making the device an attack on the very honor Bijan invokes. The ensuing speech rejects family, wealth and authority where life is at stake. Mohl and Khaleghi place that rejection before the complaint about hard days; Moscow and Ganjoor reverse those units. English follows the former sequence. The speech should remain Giv’s attempt to stop his son, rather than an unqualified declaration of the poem’s values. Its last question narrows the dispute to equipment: Bijan already has armor, so why demand Giv’s?
90–93The demand for inherited armor becomes a claim of independence
English 90–93;individual main-text,actual apparatus and checked-gap accounts linked separately.
Moscow V123:674 running text · Moscow V123:675 running text · Moscow V123:676 running text · Moscow V123:677 running text · Mohl III235:683 running text · Mohl III235:684 running text · Mohl III235:685 running text · Mohl III235:686 running text · Khaleghi IV44:682 running text · Khaleghi IV44:683 running text · Khaleghi IV44:684 running text · Khaleghi IV44:685 running text · Ganjoor sh9:82 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:83 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:84 poem body · Ganjoor sh9:85 poem body
All four have Bijan deny needing his father’s armor and question whether warriors throughout the world obtain prowess through that single garment. English makes the implied absurdity explicit by asking whether all must be dressed in it. The next question names Siavash’s armor again and asks whether great warriors can pursue reputation without it. English fame concentrates the paired formula of name and shame into its positive ambition. This does not establish that the armor is worthless; it shows Bijan resisting the dependence created by his own earlier request. All four end with his departure from the army toward the combat ground. The English boundary is therefore coherent: the dispute ends in movement, while the actual arming belongs to the next published chapter.
Source record and limits
C3.12 only:93 English couplets/186 lines;Moscow V119–123:593–677(85 running units);Mohl III232–235:593–686(PDF238–241;94 running units);Ganjoor12rokh sh9:1–85(85 body units);Khaleghi IV39–44:597–685(PDF55–60;89 running units).English75 combines two main units in every presentation. Main order changes explicitly mapped;no source-only rows.
Existing Moscow V and Mohl III PDFs inspected individually as PNG facsimiles first,then fresh Ganjoor sh9 body capture and Khaleghi IV PNG. Enlargements of Mohl232/233 resolve the killing verb and warmth/air wording. The Persian register uses Ganjoor where present and explicitly labeled Mohl readings for its nine local gaps;Mohl595 is only a selected first-hemistich excerpt. This presentation does not claim identical wording across editions.
- F&R English: 93 verbatim couplets;News of Houman Reaches Bijan;ends before C3.13 Giv Arms Bijan with Siavash’s Jowshan.
- Moscow: V119–123:593–677;85 main units. Checked local gaps for English2,3,4,33,34,35,63,76,85. Actual119n10/120n17/122n14/123n2/123n12 account for seven of these,with English3 only partial correspondence. No positive local unit for4/35.
- Mohl: III232–235:593–686;94 main units. Fuller report;four killed596;leopard597;grief615;warmth626;negative648;birth655;dragon669;blood672;gorz/sword674;honor/shame678.
- Ganjoor: 12rokh sh9:1–85;85 body units. Same bounded gaps as Moscow main,without importing its apparatus. God/Ahriman and hard-days/rejection order separately mapped.
- Khaleghi-Motlagh: IV39–44:597–685;89 main units. Local main gaps for English3,4,5,35,76;actual39n27 positive lion reaction for5. Challenge598;dust627;negative648;birth655;Ahrimans671;steel673;trickster677.
Actual Moscow apparatus inspected:119n10 challenge and nonresponse/guile;120n17 sword/dust then rest;121n4 wild-ass alternative;122n1 negative Forood alternatives;122n14 birth;123n2 dragon;123n12 honor/shame. Actual Khaleghi39n27 lion reaction;40n17 elephant alternative;41n15 wild-ass alternative. Full added units distinguished from partial lexical variants and omission notices. Neither an unprinted addition notice nor appendix availability counts as positive evidence.
Checked Moscow main and Ganjoor gaps:English2,3,4,33,34,35,63,76,85. Seven have actual Moscow apparatus correspondence,with3 only partial;4 and35 lack a positive unit in the checked local main/apparatus. Khaleghi main gaps:3,4,5,35,76;actual39n27 verifies the reaction at5 but uses lion rather than Mohl’s leopard. Other checked local gaps remain gaps,not edition-wide absence claims. Mohl supplies continuous positive main evidence for the chapter. English75 joins two units in each presentation. Moscow/Ganjoor reverse the God/Ahriman order and the rejection/hard-days order relative to English,Mohl and Khaleghi.
NEW QUALIFICATION:C3.12.34 exact gorz reading unverified in the inspected loci. Mohl’s warmth is over air;Khaleghi and actual Moscow apparatus have dust over air. The gorz at English81 is separately verified in Mohl674 and does not resolve English34. Mohl596 explicitly reports four killed;this current reported unit does not reopen the prior chapter. English remains unchanged.
C3.12.34 exact gorz support UNVERIFIED:inspected Mohl626 gives warmth over air,Khaleghi627 and actual Moscow120n17 give dust over air;Moscow main/Ganjoor have checked local gaps. English remains verbatim. Mohl595 Persian register is explicitly a selected first-hemistich excerpt,not a full diplomatic transcription. Only selected actual apparatus inspected;no appendix evidence or unprinted addition notice used;no exhaustive edition-absence claim. All inherited flags retained verbatim,including C3.11.25/C3.7.19 Ladan,C3.4.55 Chakh and prior Mohl boundary correction.
PDF offsets:Moscow0,Mohl6,Khaleghi16.
C3.12 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V119:593 running text | III232:593 running text |
| 2 | V119:593–595 checked local running gap;actual V119n10 first complete addition:challenge | III232:594 running text |
| 3 | V119:593–595 checked local running gap;actual V119n10 second complete addition:nonresponse/guile,partial correspondence | III232:595 running text |
| 4 | V119:593–595 checked local running and selected apparatus gap:four riders unit not printed here | III232:596 running text |
| 5 | V119:594 running text | III232:597 running text |
| 6 | V119:595 running text | III232:598 running text |
| 7 | V119:596 running text | III232:599 running text |
| 8 | V119:597 running text | III232:600 running text |
| 9 | V119:598 running text | III232:601 running text |
| 10 | V119:599 running text | III232:602 running text |
| 11 | V119:600 running text | III232:603 running text |
| 12 | V119:601 running text | III232:604 running text |
| 13 | V119:602 running text | III232:605 running text |
| 14 | V119:603 running text | III232:606 running text |
| 15 | V119:604 running text | III232:607 running text |
| 16 | V119:605 running text | III232:608 running text |
| 17 | V119:606 running text | III232:609 running text |
| 18 | V120:607 running text | III232:610 running text |
| 19 | V120:608 running text | III232:611 running text |
| 20 | V120:609 running text | III232:612 running text |
| 21 | V120:610 running text | III232:613 running text |
| 22 | V120:611 running text | III232:614 running text |
| 23 | V120:612 running text | III232:615 running text |
| 24 | V120:613 running text | III233:616 running text |
| 25 | V120:614 running text | III233:617 running text |
| 26 | V120:615 running text | III233:618 running text |
| 27 | V120:616 running text | III233:619 running text |
| 28 | V120:617 running text | III233:620 running text |
| 29 | V120:618 running text | III233:621 running text |
| 30 | V120:619 running text | III233:622 running text |
| 31 | V120:620 running text | III233:623 running text |
| 32 | V120:621 running text | III233:624 running text |
| 33 | V120:621–622 checked local running gap;actual V120n17 second complete addition:rest | III233:625 running text |
| 34 | V120:621–622 checked local running gap;actual V120n17 first complete addition:sword/dust | III233:626 running text |
| 35 | V120:621–622 checked local running and selected apparatus gap:offer to bind not printed here | III233:627 running text |
| 36 | V120:622 running text | III233:628 running text |
| 37 | V121:623 running text | III233:629 running text |
| 38 | V121:624 running text | III233:630 running text |
| 39 | V121:625 running text;actual V121n4 wild-ass alternative | III233:631 running text |
| 40 | V121:626 running text | III233:632 running text |
| 41 | V121:627 running text | III233:633 running text |
| 42 | V121:628 running text | III233:634 running text |
| 43 | V121:629 running text | III233:635 running text |
| 44 | V121:630 running text | III233:636 running text |
| 45 | V121:631 running text | III233:637 running text |
| 46 | V121:632 running text | III233:638 running text |
| 47 | V121:633 running text | III233:639 running text |
| 48 | V121:634 running text | III233:640 running text |
| 49 | V121:635 running text | III234:641 running text |
| 50 | V121:636 running text | III234:642 running text |
| 51 | V121:637 running text | III234:643 running text |
| 52 | V121:638 running text | III234:644 running text |
| 53 | V121:639 running text | III234:645 running text |
| 54 | V121:640 running text | III234:646 running text |
| 55 | V121:641 running text | III234:647 running text |
| 56 | V122:642 running text;actual V122n1 negative alternatives | III234:648 running text |
| 57 | V122:643 running text | III234:649 running text |
| 58 | V122:644 running text | III234:650 running text |
| 59 | V122:645 running text | III234:651 running text |
| 60 | V122:646 running text | III234:652 running text |
| 61 | V122:647 running text | III234:653 running text |
| 62 | V122:648 running text | III234:654 running text |
| 63 | V122:648–650 checked local running gap;actual V122n14 full birth unit after649 | III234:655 running text |
| 64 | V122:649 running text | III234:656 running text |
| 65 | V122:650 running text | III234:657 running text |
| 66 | V122:652 running text | III234:658 running text |
| 67 | V122:651 running text | III234:659 running text |
| 68 | V122:653 running text | III234:660 running text |
| 69 | V122:654 running text | III234:661 running text |
| 70 | V122:655 running text | III234:662 running text |
| 71 | V122:656 running text | III234:663 running text |
| 72 | V122:657 running text | III234:664 running text |
| 73 | V122:658 running text | III234:665 running text |
| 74 | V122:659 running text | III235:666 running text |
| 75 | V122:660 running text;V123:661 running text | III235:667 running text;III235:668 running text |
| 76 | V123:661–662 checked local running gap;actual V123n2 full dragon unit | III235:669 running text |
| 77 | V123:662 running text | III235:670 running text |
| 78 | V123:663 running text | III235:671 running text |
| 79 | V123:664 running text | III235:672 running text |
| 80 | V123:665 running text | III235:673 running text |
| 81 | V123:666 running text | III235:674 running text |
| 82 | V123:667 running text | III235:675 running text |
| 83 | V123:668 running text | III235:676 running text |
| 84 | V123:669 running text | III235:677 running text |
| 85 | V123:669–670 checked local running gap;actual V123n12 full honor/shame unit | III235:678 running text |
| 86 | V123:670 running text | III235:679 running text |
| 87 | V123:672 running text | III235:680 running text |
| 88 | V123:671 running text | III235:681 running text |
| 89 | V123:673 running text | III235:682 running text |
| 90 | V123:674 running text | III235:683 running text |
| 91 | V123:675 running text | III235:684 running text |
| 92 | V123:676 running text | III235:685 running text |
| 93 | V123:677 running text | III235:686 running text |
New Naqqali