Piran’s Letter to Gudarz
108 verbatim couplets.Piran’s Letter to Gudarz;from news reaching Piran to repeated midday hospitality.Next C3.21 Gudarz Replies to Piran begins on the eighth day.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | — |
| Moscow | V147–154:1095–1204;110 main units.Two source-only units1114 and1201.Pity1110 follows living/dead1109.Muliyan1130;Nimruz1134;no Sind named1137;commander/advisers1200.Actual149n30 Balkh;150n16 Sind. |
| Mohl | III253–257:1106–1213;108 main units.Individual support for every English couplet.Pity1120 before living/dead1121;negative return of time1122;Balkh1140;Sind1147;anxious youth1210.Checked gaps for S1 at1124–1125 and S2 at1210–1211. |
| Ganjoor | 12rokh sh13:113–115 plus sh14:1–107;110 body units.S1 sh14:17;S2 sh14:104.Main order and commander/advisers sh14:103 follow Moscow,not the English anxious youth.Next chapter opens sh14:108. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | IV70–77:1105–1211;107 main units.Pity1119 before living/dead1120;negative return1121;Multan1139;Hind1146;contention1163;kam1165.English105 bounded main gap1208–1209.Actual71n22 S1;72n27 Balkh;74n16 weakness;74n20 men;77n1 commander/advisers and S2 drafting. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6A peace letter begins under a narrator’s warning
English 1–6;individual running texts,selected actual apparatus and bounded checked gaps linked.
Moscow V147:1095 running text · Mohl III253:1106 running text · Khaleghi IV70:1105 running text · Ganjoor sh13:113 · Moscow V148:1096 running text · Mohl III253:1107 running text · Khaleghi IV70:1106 running text · Ganjoor sh13:114 · Moscow V148:1097 running text · Mohl III253:1108 running text · Khaleghi IV70:1107 running text · Ganjoor sh13:115 · Moscow V148:1098 running text · Mohl III253:1109 running text · Khaleghi IV70:1108 running text · Ganjoor sh14:1 · Moscow V148:1099 running text · Mohl III253:1110 running text · Khaleghi IV70:1109 running text · Ganjoor sh14:2 · Moscow V148:1100 running text · Mohl III253:1111 running text · Khaleghi IV70:1110 running text · Ganjoor sh14:3
All four first report Piran’s alarm at the Iranian preparations and his turn toward contrivance and deceit. The letter’s later humane arguments therefore arrive within a deliberately suspicious narrative frame. English cunning, fraud and wile expands the source’s cluster, while escape makes the intended relief explicit. The adviser and scribe remain separate functions: counsel finds a course through vengeance, then writing gives it diplomatic form. English calls the document a plea for peace before the Persian opening states that purpose at length. Praise of God and protection from the div begin the letter in all four, though English shelters all men generalizes the possessive protection. Public and private prayer preserves the paired open and hidden invocation.
7–12Fulfilled vengeance becomes an accusation
English 7–12;individual running texts,selected actual apparatus and bounded checked gaps linked.
Moscow V148:1101 running text · Mohl III253:1112 running text · Khaleghi IV70:1111 running text · Ganjoor sh14:4 · Moscow V148:1102 running text · Mohl III253:1113 running text · Khaleghi IV71:1112 running text · Ganjoor sh14:5 · Moscow V148:1103 running text · Mohl III253:1114 running text · Khaleghi IV71:1113 running text · Ganjoor sh14:6 · Moscow V148:1104 running text · Mohl III253:1115 running text · Khaleghi IV71:1114 running text · Ganjoor sh14:7 · Moscow V148:1105 running text · Mohl III253:1116 running text · Khaleghi IV71:1115 running text · Ganjoor sh14:8 · Moscow V148:1106 running text · Mohl III253:1117 running text · Khaleghi IV71:1116 running text · Ganjoor sh14:9
All four ask divine power to remove the field of vengeance between the armies, then turn the argument toward Gudarz’s own desire. English supplies his family line as the motive and makes fulfillment a thirst already sated. Those choices clarify the personal logic without changing Piran’s claim that enough vengeance has been taken. The close kin and lions of his army become headless bodies cast into dust in all four. English torn apart anticipates that next image and noble heart expands the victims’ praise. The accusation of failing to fear God belongs to Piran, not the narrator. English then adds a request for grace at the point where the Persian contrasts abandoned wisdom with achieved desire, drawing the following mercy appeal forward.
13–18The dead cannot be recovered by killing the living
English 13–18;individual running texts,selected actual apparatus and bounded checked gaps linked.
Moscow V148:1107 running text · Mohl III254:1118 running text · Khaleghi IV71:1117 running text · Ganjoor sh14:10 · Moscow V148:1108 running text · Mohl III254:1119 running text · Khaleghi IV71:1118 running text · Ganjoor sh14:11 · Moscow V148:1110 running text · Mohl III254:1120 running text · Khaleghi IV71:1119 running text · Ganjoor sh14:13 · Moscow V148:1109 running text · Mohl III254:1121 running text · Khaleghi IV71:1120 running text · Ganjoor sh14:12 · Moscow V148:1111 running text · Mohl III254:1122 running text · Khaleghi IV71:1121 running text · Ganjoor sh14:14 · Moscow V148:1112 running text · Mohl III254:1123 running text · Khaleghi IV71:1122 running text · Ganjoor sh14:15
All four couple the losses of both peoples with a demand to stop bloodshed. Mohl and Khaleghi put pity before the question about killing living men for a vanished dead person; Moscow and Ganjoor put that question first. English follows Mohl and Khaleghi’s order. Its vanished breath softens the dead person into an image, while doom to death generalizes the source’s severed living heads. The next condition differs materially: Moscow and Ganjoor print recovery of departed time, whereas Mohl and Khaleghi print its failure to return. English states the negative sense directly and preserves the prohibition on sowing vengeance. Soul and body then give the argument an inward cost as well as a public death toll.
19–24An evil name and the uncertainty of survival
English 19–24;individual running texts,selected actual apparatus and bounded checked gaps linked.
Moscow V149:1113 running text · Mohl III254:1124 running text · Khaleghi IV71:1123 running text · Ganjoor sh14:16 · Moscow V149:1115 running text · Mohl III254:1125 running text · Khaleghi IV71:1124 running text · Ganjoor sh14:18 · Moscow V149:1116 running text · Mohl III254:1126 running text · Khaleghi IV71:1125 running text · Ganjoor sh14:19 · Moscow V149:1117 running text · Mohl III254:1127 running text · Khaleghi IV71:1126 running text · Ganjoor sh14:20 · Moscow V149:1118 running text · Mohl III254:1128 running text · Khaleghi IV72:1127 running text · Ganjoor sh14:21 · Moscow V149:1119 running text · Mohl III254:1129 running text · Khaleghi IV72:1128 running text · Ganjoor sh14:22 · Moscow V149:1114 running text · Mohl III254:1124–1125 checked local running gap · Khaleghi IV71:1123–1124 checked local running gap;actual IV71n22 prints complete additional warning · Ganjoor sh14:17
All four connect an evil posthumous name with a curse, then invoke whitening hair and dwindling life. Moscow and Ganjoor add another warning about the name left behind; Mohl has a checked local running gap, while Khaleghi prints the additional couplet in actual apparatus. English follows the shorter running sequence. Its blood and destruction specifies what makes the name evil in this war. The feared renewed battle would leave neither force standing. Moscow and Ganjoor leave bodies after souls depart; Mohl and Khaleghi leave vengeance. English carries that lingering vengeance into the next couplet, then renders the uncertain alternatives through shining and sinking. Piran’s warning challenges the usefulness of victory without establishing which side would actually win.
25–30Territorial division is offered under royal authority
English 25–30;individual running texts,selected actual apparatus and bounded checked gaps linked.
Moscow V149:1120 running text · Mohl III254:1130 running text · Khaleghi IV72:1129 running text · Ganjoor sh14:23 · Moscow V149:1121 running text · Mohl III254:1131 running text · Khaleghi IV72:1130 running text · Ganjoor sh14:24 · Moscow V149:1122 running text · Mohl III254:1132 running text · Khaleghi IV72:1131 running text · Ganjoor sh14:25 · Moscow V149:1123 running text · Mohl III254:1133 running text · Khaleghi IV72:1132 running text · Ganjoor sh14:26 · Moscow V149:1124 running text · Mohl III254:1134 running text · Khaleghi IV72:1133 running text · Ganjoor sh14:27 · Moscow V149:1125 running text · Mohl III254:1135 running text · Khaleghi IV72:1134 running text · Ganjoor sh14:28
All four ask whether Iran itself is the object of the fighting and offer a messenger to Afrasiab for authority to divide the land. English makes the request for a clear purpose explicit, then renders division as drawing borders. The Manuchehr precedent follows in all four. English made peace interprets the older division through the current diplomatic offer; these lines alone do not establish details of a historical treaty. Gudarz is invited to identify Iranian towns, and Piran promises their clearance of Turks. Prosperous and ruined land alike falls within the proposed settlement. English throne and sets the bound emphasize sovereignty, while preserving the important limit that Piran still seeks his own king’s command for the arrangement.
31–36The territorial list preserves a consequential place-name variant
English 31–36;individual running texts,selected actual apparatus and bounded checked gaps linked.
Moscow V149:1126 running text · Mohl III254:1136 running text · Khaleghi IV72:1135 running text · Ganjoor sh14:29 · Moscow V149:1127 running text · Mohl III254:1137 running text · Khaleghi IV72:1136 running text · Ganjoor sh14:30 · Moscow V149:1128 running text · Mohl III254:1138 running text · Khaleghi IV72:1137 running text · Ganjoor sh14:31 · Moscow V149:1129 running text · Mohl III254:1139 running text · Khaleghi IV72:1138 running text · Ganjoor sh14:32 · Moscow V149:1130 running text;Muliyan main;actual V149n30 Balkh · Mohl III254:1140 running text · Khaleghi IV72:1139 running text;Multan main;actual IV72n27 Balkh · Ganjoor sh14:33 · Moscow V150:1131 running text · Mohl III254:1141 running text · Khaleghi IV72:1140 running text · Ganjoor sh14:34
All four name the mountain approach, Gharchagan, Bost, Talikan, Fariyab, Balkh, Andarab, Panjhir and Bamiyan before continuing the list. English turns the compressed sequence into an itinerary through height, sight and possession. The Kayanian place becomes a home, preserving the dynastic association without adding a modern location. The Guzganan naming formula retains an unspecific world-ruler as its agent. A more consequential difference follows: Mohl prints Balkh before Badakhshan, Moscow and Ganjoor print Muliyan, and Khaleghi prints Multan. Actual Moscow and Khaleghi apparatus records Balkh. English thus has direct Mohl support for its starting point. The lower Amuy, Zam and Khatlan tract then restores shared named ground, though English reverses Amuy and Zam’s order.
37–42Rostam’s sphere and the distinction between Hind and Sind
English 37–42;individual running texts,selected actual apparatus and bounded checked gaps linked.
Moscow V150:1132 running text · Mohl III254:1142 running text · Khaleghi IV73:1141 running text · Ganjoor sh14:35 · Moscow V150:1133 running text · Mohl III255:1143 running text · Khaleghi IV73:1142 running text · Ganjoor sh14:36 · Moscow V150:1134 running text · Mohl III255:1144 running text · Khaleghi IV73:1143 running text · Ganjoor sh14:37 · Moscow V150:1135 running text · Mohl III255:1145 running text · Khaleghi IV73:1144 running text · Ganjoor sh14:38 · Moscow V150:1136 running text · Mohl III255:1146 running text · Khaleghi IV73:1145 running text · Ganjoor sh14:39 · Moscow V150:1137 running text;no Sind named in main unit;actual V150n16 Sind wording · Mohl III255:1147 running text · Khaleghi IV73:1146 running text · Ganjoor sh14:40
The four presentations give variant spellings around Shingan, then agree on Tirmid, Visagard, Bukhara and the extension to Sughd. English makes the offer explicit through I yield and identifies the rival claimant as a Turkish lord. Rostam’s sphere is Nimruz in Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi; Mohl describes a fortunate realm instead. English follows the named territory. All four then clear troops and open the Bakhtar route before extending the clearance toward Hind. The next unit must be distinguished from that broader destination: Mohl explicitly names the Sind with Kashmir, Kabul and Kandahar, Moscow and Ganjoor do not name it there, and Khaleghi has Hind. English follows Mohl; Moscow’s actual apparatus also records the Sind wording.
43–48Withdrawal becomes a covenant against renewed hostility
English 43–48;individual running texts,selected actual apparatus and bounded checked gaps linked.
Moscow V150:1138 running text · Mohl III255:1148 running text · Khaleghi IV73:1147 running text · Ganjoor sh14:41 · Moscow V150:1139 running text · Mohl III255:1149 running text · Khaleghi IV73:1148 running text · Ganjoor sh14:42 · Moscow V150:1140 running text · Mohl III255:1150 running text · Khaleghi IV73:1149 running text · Ganjoor sh14:43 · Moscow V150:1141 running text · Mohl III255:1151 running text · Khaleghi IV73:1150 running text · Ganjoor sh14:44 · Moscow V150:1142 running text · Mohl III255:1152 running text · Khaleghi IV73:1151 running text · Ganjoor sh14:45 · Moscow V150:1143 running text · Mohl III255:1153 running text · Khaleghi IV73:1152 running text · Ganjoor sh14:46
All four assign Lohrasp the Alan territory. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi also name Ghuzz, whereas Mohl describes the accompanying territory generally. English all that region follows that less specific wording and adds the helm as an image of military control. The offer extends to Kaf without fighting, then clears the land reached by Ashkash. English makes the withdrawal of Piran’s own troops the means of clearance. The scattered host is recalled before an oath is promised in Gudarz’s presence. All four renounce ill intent and claim truth, love and fidelity. English no longer your foe makes that disposition a public relationship. These remain proposed commitments within Piran’s letter, not actions already completed or independently guaranteed by the narrator.
49–54Messages, treasure and hostages depend on agreement
English 49–54;individual running texts,selected actual apparatus and bounded checked gaps linked.
Moscow V150:1144 running text · Mohl III255:1154 running text · Khaleghi IV73:1153 running text · Ganjoor sh14:47 · Moscow V150:1145 running text · Mohl III255:1155 running text · Khaleghi IV73:1154 running text · Ganjoor sh14:48 · Moscow V150:1146 running text · Mohl III255:1156 running text · Khaleghi IV73:1155 running text · Ganjoor sh14:49 · Moscow V150:1147 running text · Mohl III255:1157 running text · Khaleghi IV73:1156 running text · Ganjoor sh14:50 · Moscow V151:1148 running text · Mohl III255:1158 running text · Khaleghi IV73:1157 running text · Ganjoor sh14:51 · Moscow V151:1149 running text · Mohl III255:1159 running text · Khaleghi IV74:1158 running text · Ganjoor sh14:52
All four require communication with the two kings: Piran will inform his ruler, while Gudarz should write Khosrow with goodwill. English names Afrasiab directly and emphasizes Khosrow’s judgment, making the political hierarchy legible. The offer of wealth is conditional on a properly established covenant. English sealed suggests a documentary act beyond the general agreement language, while the sending extends across the source’s next couplet. The hope that Khosrow will restrain the army remains uncertain. English perhaps preserves that limit, although drawing away his force makes the hoped restraint a withdrawal. Hostages and goods follow the preceding settlement steps in all four. English spare no goods and rare treasures enlarges the compact offer without making the transfer immediate.
55–60Fidelity is asked to close an inherited feud
English 55–60;individual running texts,selected actual apparatus and bounded checked gaps linked.
Moscow V151:1150 running text · Mohl III255:1160 running text · Khaleghi IV74:1159 running text · Ganjoor sh14:53 · Moscow V151:1151 running text · Mohl III255:1161 running text · Khaleghi IV74:1160 running text · Ganjoor sh14:54 · Moscow V151:1152 running text · Mohl III255:1162 running text · Khaleghi IV74:1161 running text · Ganjoor sh14:55 · Moscow V151:1153 running text · Mohl III255:1163 running text · Khaleghi IV74:1162 running text · Ganjoor sh14:56 · Moscow V151:1154 running text · Mohl III255:1164 running text · Khaleghi IV74:1163 running text;contention main;actual IV74n16 weakness · Ganjoor sh14:57 · Moscow V151:1155 running text · Mohl III255:1165 running text · Khaleghi IV74:1164 running text · Ganjoor sh14:58
All four use the striking image of fidelity sewing shut the eye of vengeance. English preserves it while replacing the accompanying love, custom and religion with the language of a solemn signed treaty. The historical injury then reaches back through Tur and Salm to Fereydoon’s grief for Iraj. English wound and mourning nations expands that inherited damage, keeping it within Piran’s argument for reconciliation. Further requests and a letter to the Shah remain possible. The warning against misreading the soft language differs: Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor name weakness; Khaleghi’s main text reads contention, with weakness in actual apparatus. English fear or shame interprets weakness and adds shame. Its following peaceful end makes the professed goodwill explicit without certifying sincerity.
61–66A boast is placed beside compassion and divine judgment
English 61–66;individual running texts,selected actual apparatus and bounded checked gaps linked.
Moscow V151:1156 running text · Mohl III255:1166 running text · Khaleghi IV74:1165 running text;kam main;actual IV74n20 men · Ganjoor sh14:59 · Moscow V151:1157 running text · Mohl III255:1167 running text · Khaleghi IV74:1166 running text · Ganjoor sh14:60 · Moscow V151:1158 running text · Mohl III256:1168 running text · Khaleghi IV74:1167 running text · Ganjoor sh14:61 · Moscow V151:1159 running text · Mohl III256:1169 running text · Khaleghi IV74:1168 running text · Ganjoor sh14:62 · Moscow V151:1160 running text · Mohl III256:1170 running text · Khaleghi IV74:1169 running text · Ganjoor sh14:63 · Moscow V151:1161 running text · Mohl III256:1171 running text · Khaleghi IV74:1170 running text · Ganjoor sh14:64
Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor give Piran more treasure and men and a superior martial name. Khaleghi’s main text has treasure and desire or fortune, with men recorded in actual apparatus. English follows the former account, so the appeal to peace does not abandon a claim of strength. All four then condemn unjust bloodshed and grieve for the army. English godless makes the injustice explicitly religious, while a crimson flood internalizes the violence in the speaker’s heart. Fear of the Creator is numbered third in Moscow and Ganjoor but simply another reason in Mohl and Khaleghi; English Besides avoids the discrepancy. Its squandered time interprets the temporal wording of the latter pair before the conditional challenge resumes.
67–72Accusation narrows into a proposal for chosen combatants
English 67–72;individual running texts,selected actual apparatus and bounded checked gaps linked.
Moscow V151:1162 running text · Mohl III256:1172 running text · Khaleghi IV74:1171 running text · Ganjoor sh14:65 · Moscow V151:1163 running text · Mohl III256:1173 running text · Khaleghi IV74:1172 running text · Ganjoor sh14:66 · Moscow V151:1164 running text · Mohl III256:1174 running text · Khaleghi IV74:1173 running text · Ganjoor sh14:67 · Moscow V152:1165 running text · Mohl III256:1175 running text · Khaleghi IV75:1174 running text · Ganjoor sh14:68 · Moscow V152:1166 running text · Mohl III256:1176 running text · Khaleghi IV75:1175 running text · Ganjoor sh14:69 · Moscow V152:1167 running text · Mohl III256:1177 running text · Khaleghi IV75:1176 running text · Ganjoor sh14:70
All four let Piran assert innocence and accuse Gudarz of treating justice and injustice alike. English in effect sharpens the appeal through heart and hand, but these are partisan assertions rather than an adjudication by the poem’s narrator. The proposed remedy changes the scale of violence. Iranian leaders fit for the heavy gorz are selected, and Piran chooses corresponding men from his own force. English most worthy broadens martial suitability into merit, while best equipped specifies readiness. Pair the champions makes the one-against-another arrangement explicit. All four then require the commanders themselves to fight. English wheeling movement and resounding arms dramatizes the encounter while preserving that Piran does not ask only subordinates to assume the danger.
73–78The first safe-passage condition protects Turan’s survivors
English 73–78;individual running texts,selected actual apparatus and bounded checked gaps linked.
Moscow V152:1168 running text · Mohl III256:1178 running text · Khaleghi IV75:1177 running text · Ganjoor sh14:71 · Moscow V152:1169 running text · Mohl III256:1179 running text · Khaleghi IV75:1178 running text · Ganjoor sh14:72 · Moscow V152:1170 running text · Mohl III256:1180 running text · Khaleghi IV75:1179 running text · Ganjoor sh14:73 · Moscow V152:1171 running text · Mohl III256:1181 running text · Khaleghi IV75:1180 running text · Ganjoor sh14:74 · Moscow V152:1172 running text · Mohl III256:1182 running text · Khaleghi IV75:1181 running text · Ganjoor sh14:75 · Moscow V152:1173 running text · Mohl III256:1183 running text · Khaleghi IV75:1182 running text · Ganjoor sh14:76
All four present relief for the guiltless as a hoped consequence of the restricted combat. English dread gives those men an emotion and perhaps preserves the proposal’s uncertainty. The fighters brought forward are those whom Gudarz considers guilty or responsible for his pain. English in your thought carefully retains that attribution rather than endorsing the accusation. Piran then requires a further covenant for the possibility of Iranian victory. Troops, land and royal seat must be spared, and the surviving army must be allowed back to Turan. English throne makes the seat concrete and homeward makes the destination relational. The source’s image of ambush as a lasso becomes a direct prohibition, preserving the practical protection for the withdrawing soldiers.
79–84Reciprocity distinguishes chosen combat from mass battle
English 79–84;individual running texts,selected actual apparatus and bounded checked gaps linked.
Moscow V152:1174 running text · Mohl III256:1184 running text · Khaleghi IV75:1183 running text · Ganjoor sh14:77 · Moscow V152:1175 running text · Mohl III256:1185 running text · Khaleghi IV75:1184 running text · Ganjoor sh14:78 · Moscow V152:1176 running text · Mohl III256:1186 running text · Khaleghi IV75:1185 running text · Ganjoor sh14:79 · Moscow V152:1177 running text · Mohl III256:1187 running text · Khaleghi IV75:1186 running text · Ganjoor sh14:80 · Moscow V152:1178 running text · Mohl III256:1188 running text · Khaleghi IV75:1187 running text · Ganjoor sh14:81 · Moscow V152:1179 running text · Mohl III256:1189 running text · Khaleghi IV75:1188 running text · Ganjoor sh14:82
All four mirror the terms if Piran wins: favorable fortune must not license an ambush or renewed vengeance against Iran. English no pursuit anticipates that protection, and reaching home moves the destination forward from the following source unit. The sequence still protects both life and property and requires that no soldier be lost. English safely to his own makes the royal destination an individual homecoming, while no further cost turns security into an economic metaphor. Piran then permits another choice. If Gudarz rejects this mode, the whole army may enter battle. English prove your might and make us yield intensify the challenge without erasing the distinction between paired champions and mass warfare on which the preceding protections depend.
85–90The warning is entrusted to Piran’s son
English 85–90;individual running texts,selected actual apparatus and bounded checked gaps linked.
Moscow V152:1180 running text · Mohl III256:1190 running text · Khaleghi IV75:1189 running text · Ganjoor sh14:83 · Moscow V152:1181 running text · Mohl III256:1191 running text · Khaleghi IV75:1190 running text · Ganjoor sh14:84 · Moscow V152:1182 running text · Mohl III256:1192 running text · Khaleghi IV75:1191 running text · Ganjoor sh14:85 · Moscow V152:1183 running text · Mohl III257:1193 running text · Khaleghi IV76:1192 running text · Ganjoor sh14:86 · Moscow V152:1184 running text · Mohl III257:1194 running text · Khaleghi IV76:1193 running text · Ganjoor sh14:87 · Moscow V153:1185 running text · Mohl III257:1195 running text · Khaleghi IV76:1194 running text · Ganjoor sh14:88
All four close the letter by holding Gudarz accountable in the other world for blood shed after rejecting the offer. English answer renders that accountability without retaining the source’s more forceful image of being suspended or implicated there. The letter is then bound and the valued son called. Ruyin’s name, leadership and metallic body epithet appear in all four. English iron strength renowned interprets the epithet as capability and reputation; it does not require an unsupported assertion of literal invulnerability. His instructions combine wise speech with listening for the answer. The escort of ten riders is preserved exactly. English in pride adds an attitude, while Iran’s high command broadens the Pahlevan’s pavilion into its institutional role.
91–96Courtesy to the envoy precedes any decision on the offer
English 91–96;individual running texts,selected actual apparatus and bounded checked gaps linked.
Moscow V153:1186 running text · Mohl III257:1196 running text · Khaleghi IV76:1195 running text · Ganjoor sh14:89 · Moscow V153:1187 running text · Mohl III257:1197 running text · Khaleghi IV76:1196 running text · Ganjoor sh14:90 · Moscow V153:1188 running text · Mohl III257:1198 running text · Khaleghi IV76:1197 running text · Ganjoor sh14:91 · Moscow V153:1189 running text · Mohl III257:1199 running text · Khaleghi IV76:1198 running text · Ganjoor sh14:92 · Moscow V153:1190 running text · Mohl III257:1200 running text · Khaleghi IV76:1199 running text · Ganjoor sh14:93 · Moscow V153:1191 running text · Mohl III257:1201 running text · Khaleghi IV76:1200 running text · Ganjoor sh14:94
All four report Ruyin’s arrival through a runner, summon him behind the curtain and give the folded-hand, lowered-head greeting. English eager-eyed supplies an expression beyond the recorded movement, while hands across the breast makes the gesture physically specific. Gudarz’s response is immediate and affectionate: he rises and embraces the young man tightly. English honored guest explains that welcome but drops the source’s speed comparison with smoke. Questions then widen from Piran to his army, champions, king and land in all four. This courtesy does not itself accept the peace terms. Ruyin finally presents letter and message; English just as he was taught emphasizes faithful delivery rather than a new contribution by the messenger.
97–102Smooth language produces astonishment and a deferred answer
English 97–102;individual running texts,selected actual apparatus and bounded checked gaps linked.
Moscow V153:1192 running text · Mohl III257:1202 running text · Khaleghi IV76:1201 running text · Ganjoor sh14:95 · Moscow V153:1193 running text · Mohl III257:1203 running text · Khaleghi IV76:1202 running text · Ganjoor sh14:96 · Moscow V153:1194 running text · Mohl III257:1204 running text · Khaleghi IV76:1203 running text · Ganjoor sh14:97 · Moscow V153:1195 running text · Mohl III257:1205 running text · Khaleghi IV76:1204 running text · Ganjoor sh14:98 · Moscow V153:1196 running text · Mohl III257:1206 running text · Khaleghi IV76:1205 running text · Ganjoor sh14:99 · Moscow V153:1197 running text · Mohl III257:1207 running text · Khaleghi IV76:1206 running text · Ganjoor sh14:100
All four have a scribe read the letter and convey its contents to Gudarz. English exact and true describes the report’s fidelity, not the truth of Piran’s claims. The distinguished listeners are astonished by the smooth speech, counsel and invitation to alliance. English disbelief can sound more skeptical than simple amazement, but the source unit does not yet announce rejection. Calling the counsel kindly preserves its conciliatory appearance alongside the narrator’s earlier account of fear and deceit. Gudarz addresses Ruyin respectfully as the commander’s fortunate son. All four then place hospitality before the reply. English when the time agrees leaves that timing deliberately open, so the later delay follows from an already deferred rather than promised immediate answer.
103–108The anxious youth and the commander’s drafting are distinct readings
English 103–108;individual running texts,selected actual apparatus and bounded checked gaps linked.
Moscow V153:1198 running text · Mohl III257:1208 running text · Khaleghi IV76:1207 running text · Ganjoor sh14:101 · Moscow V153:1199 running text · Mohl III257:1209 running text · Khaleghi IV77:1208 running text · Ganjoor sh14:102 · Moscow V153:1200 running text;commander/advisers,not youth · Mohl III257:1210 running text;anxious youth · Khaleghi IV77:1208–1209 checked local running gap;actual IV77n1 commander/advisers unit,not anxious-youth reading · Ganjoor sh14:103 · Moscow V153:1202 running text · Mohl III257:1211 running text · Khaleghi IV77:1209 running text · Ganjoor sh14:105 · Moscow V154:1203 running text · Mohl III257:1212 running text · Khaleghi IV77:1210 running text · Ganjoor sh14:106 · Moscow V154:1204 running text · Mohl III257:1213 running text · Khaleghi IV77:1211 running text · Ganjoor sh14:107 · Moscow V153:1201 running text · Mohl III257:1210–1211 checked local running gap · Khaleghi IV77:1208–1209 checked local running gap;actual IV77n1 prints full drafting unit · Ganjoor sh14:104
All four prepare a royal pavilion with Roman brocade, food and entertainers. The next account differs substantially. Mohl makes the young envoy anxious about the Pahlevan’s reply, as English does. Moscow and Ganjoor instead place thought in the commander’s heart among learned advisers, then add a separate drafting couplet. Khaleghi’s running text has a checked local gap for both units, while its actual apparatus prints the commander and drafting account. That apparatus does not verify the anxious youth. English therefore follows independently checked Mohl main text. All four retain the week of postponed reply, wine and music, with the envoy summoned at midday. The published chapter ends before the eighth-day answer, leaving preparation and delivery distinct.
Source record and limits
C3.20 only:108 English couplets/216 lines.Moscow V147–154:1095–1204,110 running units;Mohl III253–257:1106–1213(PDF259–263),108 running units;Ganjoor12rokh sh13:113–115 plus sh14:1–107,110 body units;Khaleghi IV70–77:1105–1211(PDF86–93),107 running units.Two source-only rows S1/S2.Moscow/Ganjoor reverse English15–16.English105 follows Mohl’s anxious youth against Moscow/Ganjoor’s commander/advisers;Khaleghi main has a bounded gap with commander/advisers and drafting in actual77n1.Each declared main unit allocated once.
Inspection sequence:MoscowV147–154 and MohlIII253–257 independently first for each English unit;fresh Ganjoor sh13/sh14 bodies;then KhaleghiIV70–77.Existing PDFs inspected as PNG facsimiles.No scan availability counted as textual verification.
- F&R English: 108 verbatim couplets.Piran’s Letter to Gudarz;from news reaching Piran to repeated midday hospitality.Next C3.21 Gudarz Replies to Piran begins on the eighth day.
- Moscow: V147–154:1095–1204;110 main units.Two source-only units1114 and1201.Pity1110 follows living/dead1109.Muliyan1130;Nimruz1134;no Sind named1137;commander/advisers1200.Actual149n30 Balkh;150n16 Sind.
- Mohl: III253–257:1106–1213;108 main units.Individual support for every English couplet.Pity1120 before living/dead1121;negative return of time1122;Balkh1140;Sind1147;anxious youth1210.Checked gaps for S1 at1124–1125 and S2 at1210–1211.
- Ganjoor: 12rokh sh13:113–115 plus sh14:1–107;110 body units.S1 sh14:17;S2 sh14:104.Main order and commander/advisers sh14:103 follow Moscow,not the English anxious youth.Next chapter opens sh14:108.
- Khaleghi-Motlagh: IV70–77:1105–1211;107 main units.Pity1119 before living/dead1120;negative return1121;Multan1139;Hind1146;contention1163;kam1165.English105 bounded main gap1208–1209.Actual71n22 S1;72n27 Balkh;74n16 weakness;74n20 men;77n1 commander/advisers and S2 drafting.
Actual apparatus specifically used:Moscow149n30 Balkh and150n16 Sind.Khaleghi71n22 full extra warning S1;72n27 Balkh;74n16 weakness;74n20 men;77n1 full commander/advisers unit and drafting S2.Other apparatus notices do not create positive readings.No appendix evidence claimed.
S1:Moscow1114/Ganjoorsh14:17 main;Mohl1124–1125 and Khaleghi1123–1124 bounded main gaps,Khaleghi71n22 actual text.S2:Moscow1201/Ganjoorsh14:104 main;Mohl1210–1211 and Khaleghi1208–1209 bounded main gaps,Khaleghi77n1 actual text.English105:Mohl1210 directly prints the anxious youth;Moscow1200/Ganjoorsh14:103 print a different subject,while Khaleghi77n1 supports that commander reading only.The gap is not turned into support for the young envoy.
English15–16 follows Mohl/Khaleghi order against Moscow1109–1110 and Ganjoorsh14:12–13.The vengeance clause in English23 is carried from Mohl1127/Khaleghi1126,whose primary alignment is English22.English27–28,52–53 and79–81 likewise redistribute clauses across adjacent units without double-counting.
Additional Ganjoor opening:sh13:113–115.PDF offsets:Moscow0,Mohl6,Khaleghi16.All inherited flags retained in checkpoint.
C3.20 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V147:1095 running text | III253:1106 running text |
| 2 | V148:1096 running text | III253:1107 running text |
| 3 | V148:1097 running text | III253:1108 running text |
| 4 | V148:1098 running text | III253:1109 running text |
| 5 | V148:1099 running text | III253:1110 running text |
| 6 | V148:1100 running text | III253:1111 running text |
| 7 | V148:1101 running text | III253:1112 running text |
| 8 | V148:1102 running text | III253:1113 running text |
| 9 | V148:1103 running text | III253:1114 running text |
| 10 | V148:1104 running text | III253:1115 running text |
| 11 | V148:1105 running text | III253:1116 running text |
| 12 | V148:1106 running text | III253:1117 running text |
| 13 | V148:1107 running text | III254:1118 running text |
| 14 | V148:1108 running text | III254:1119 running text |
| 15 | V148:1110 running text | III254:1120 running text |
| 16 | V148:1109 running text | III254:1121 running text |
| 17 | V148:1111 running text | III254:1122 running text |
| 18 | V148:1112 running text | III254:1123 running text |
| 19 | V149:1113 running text | III254:1124 running text |
| 20 | V149:1115 running text | III254:1125 running text |
| 21 | V149:1116 running text | III254:1126 running text |
| 22 | V149:1117 running text | III254:1127 running text |
| 23 | V149:1118 running text | III254:1128 running text |
| 24 | V149:1119 running text | III254:1129 running text |
| 25 | V149:1120 running text | III254:1130 running text |
| 26 | V149:1121 running text | III254:1131 running text |
| 27 | V149:1122 running text | III254:1132 running text |
| 28 | V149:1123 running text | III254:1133 running text |
| 29 | V149:1124 running text | III254:1134 running text |
| 30 | V149:1125 running text | III254:1135 running text |
| 31 | V149:1126 running text | III254:1136 running text |
| 32 | V149:1127 running text | III254:1137 running text |
| 33 | V149:1128 running text | III254:1138 running text |
| 34 | V149:1129 running text | III254:1139 running text |
| 35 | V149:1130 running text;Muliyan main;actual V149n30 Balkh | III254:1140 running text |
| 36 | V150:1131 running text | III254:1141 running text |
| 37 | V150:1132 running text | III254:1142 running text |
| 38 | V150:1133 running text | III255:1143 running text |
| 39 | V150:1134 running text | III255:1144 running text |
| 40 | V150:1135 running text | III255:1145 running text |
| 41 | V150:1136 running text | III255:1146 running text |
| 42 | V150:1137 running text;no Sind named in main unit;actual V150n16 Sind wording | III255:1147 running text |
| 43 | V150:1138 running text | III255:1148 running text |
| 44 | V150:1139 running text | III255:1149 running text |
| 45 | V150:1140 running text | III255:1150 running text |
| 46 | V150:1141 running text | III255:1151 running text |
| 47 | V150:1142 running text | III255:1152 running text |
| 48 | V150:1143 running text | III255:1153 running text |
| 49 | V150:1144 running text | III255:1154 running text |
| 50 | V150:1145 running text | III255:1155 running text |
| 51 | V150:1146 running text | III255:1156 running text |
| 52 | V150:1147 running text | III255:1157 running text |
| 53 | V151:1148 running text | III255:1158 running text |
| 54 | V151:1149 running text | III255:1159 running text |
| 55 | V151:1150 running text | III255:1160 running text |
| 56 | V151:1151 running text | III255:1161 running text |
| 57 | V151:1152 running text | III255:1162 running text |
| 58 | V151:1153 running text | III255:1163 running text |
| 59 | V151:1154 running text | III255:1164 running text |
| 60 | V151:1155 running text | III255:1165 running text |
| 61 | V151:1156 running text | III255:1166 running text |
| 62 | V151:1157 running text | III255:1167 running text |
| 63 | V151:1158 running text | III256:1168 running text |
| 64 | V151:1159 running text | III256:1169 running text |
| 65 | V151:1160 running text | III256:1170 running text |
| 66 | V151:1161 running text | III256:1171 running text |
| 67 | V151:1162 running text | III256:1172 running text |
| 68 | V151:1163 running text | III256:1173 running text |
| 69 | V151:1164 running text | III256:1174 running text |
| 70 | V152:1165 running text | III256:1175 running text |
| 71 | V152:1166 running text | III256:1176 running text |
| 72 | V152:1167 running text | III256:1177 running text |
| 73 | V152:1168 running text | III256:1178 running text |
| 74 | V152:1169 running text | III256:1179 running text |
| 75 | V152:1170 running text | III256:1180 running text |
| 76 | V152:1171 running text | III256:1181 running text |
| 77 | V152:1172 running text | III256:1182 running text |
| 78 | V152:1173 running text | III256:1183 running text |
| 79 | V152:1174 running text | III256:1184 running text |
| 80 | V152:1175 running text | III256:1185 running text |
| 81 | V152:1176 running text | III256:1186 running text |
| 82 | V152:1177 running text | III256:1187 running text |
| 83 | V152:1178 running text | III256:1188 running text |
| 84 | V152:1179 running text | III256:1189 running text |
| 85 | V152:1180 running text | III256:1190 running text |
| 86 | V152:1181 running text | III256:1191 running text |
| 87 | V152:1182 running text | III256:1192 running text |
| 88 | V152:1183 running text | III257:1193 running text |
| 89 | V152:1184 running text | III257:1194 running text |
| 90 | V153:1185 running text | III257:1195 running text |
| 91 | V153:1186 running text | III257:1196 running text |
| 92 | V153:1187 running text | III257:1197 running text |
| 93 | V153:1188 running text | III257:1198 running text |
| 94 | V153:1189 running text | III257:1199 running text |
| 95 | V153:1190 running text | III257:1200 running text |
| 96 | V153:1191 running text | III257:1201 running text |
| 97 | V153:1192 running text | III257:1202 running text |
| 98 | V153:1193 running text | III257:1203 running text |
| 99 | V153:1194 running text | III257:1204 running text |
| 100 | V153:1195 running text | III257:1205 running text |
| 101 | V153:1196 running text | III257:1206 running text |
| 102 | V153:1197 running text | III257:1207 running text |
| 103 | V153:1198 running text | III257:1208 running text |
| 104 | V153:1199 running text | III257:1209 running text |
| 105 | V153:1200 running text;commander/advisers,not youth | III257:1210 running text;anxious youth |
| 106 | V153:1202 running text | III257:1211 running text |
| 107 | V154:1203 running text | III257:1212 running text |
| 108 | V154:1204 running text | III257:1213 running text |
New Naqqali