Gudarz Replies to Piran
150 verbatim couplets. Gudarz Replies to Piran. From the eighth-morning summons to Piran’s opening old treasure. Next C3.22 Piran Seeks Afrasiab’s Aid begins the nighttime dispatch.
Printed verse collationThe chapter in five texts
| Text | Chapter treatment and distinctive choices |
|---|---|
| F&R English | 150 verbatim couplets. Gudarz Replies to Piran. From the eighth-morning summons to Piran’s opening old treasure. |
| Moscow | V154–162:1205–1351;147 main units. English21 main gap1225–1226 with two actual155n18 counsel units;English31 gap1233–1234;English97 gap1298–1299. English19 compresses1223–1224;English29–30 shares1233. Sword1215;westward1276;bi-honar1298;chosen1328;face1337. |
| Mohl | III257–263:1214–1363;150 main units. Fuller counsel1234–1235,divine aid1244,and comparative boast1310. English21 compresses1234–1235;English29–30 shares1243. Spear1224;every direction1287;bi-honar1309;earthly epithet1340;heart1349. |
| Ganjoor | 12rokh sh14:108–109;sh15:1–142;sh16:1–3. 147 body units. Main allocation follows Moscow. Checked local gaps sh15:19–20,27–28,92–93 correspond to English21,31,97. Shared27 at English29–30. New section sh16 begins at English148. |
| Khaleghi-Motlagh | IV77–86:1212–1359;148 main units. English21 main gap1232–1233;English97 gap1306–1307. Divine aid1241 present. English19 compresses1230–1231;English29–30 shares1240. Spear1222;onward1284 with actual81n22 westward;ba-honar1306;earthly epithet1336;face1345 with actual85n4 heart. |
Parallel text
English left · Persian right. Ganjoor supplies the Persian; Moscow and Mohl verse numbers are in the printed verse collation.
Couplet commentary
Quoted text · evidence · interpretation1–6Writing a tree of vengeance
English 1–6;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V154:1205 running text · Mohl III257:1214 running text · Khaleghi IV77:1212 running text · Ganjoor sh14:108 poem body · Moscow V154:1206 running text · Mohl III257:1215 running text · Khaleghi IV77:1213 running text · Ganjoor sh14:109 poem body · Moscow V154:1207 running text · Mohl III258:1216 running text · Khaleghi IV77:1214 running text · Ganjoor sh15:1 poem body · Moscow V154:1208 running text · Mohl III258:1217 running text · Khaleghi IV77:1215 running text · Ganjoor sh15:2 poem body · Moscow V154:1209 running text · Mohl III258:1218 running text · Khaleghi IV77:1216 running text · Ganjoor sh15:3 poem body · Moscow V154:1210 running text · Mohl III258:1219 running text · Khaleghi IV77:1217 running text · Ganjoor sh15:4 poem body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all begin with the eighth morning, the summons to a writer and the planting of renewed enmity through the reply. The English makes the writing process visibly unfold stroke by stroke. That detail is an interpretation of the act of dictation, not an additional Persian event. The tree image preserves the striking connection between composition and cultivation: this answer produces the very feud that diplomacy might have arrested. Divine praise and a pointwise response follow in every presentation. The courteous acknowledgment of Ruyin therefore does not soften the letter's purpose. It establishes that Gudarz has received both the written argument and its oral supplement before rejecting them.
7–12Sweet language and the salt-ground mirage
English 7–12;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V154:1211 running text · Mohl III258:1220 running text · Khaleghi IV77:1218 running text · Ganjoor sh15:5 poem body · Moscow V154:1212 running text · Mohl III258:1221 running text · Khaleghi IV77:1219 running text · Ganjoor sh15:6 poem body · Moscow V154:1213 running text · Mohl III258:1222 running text · Khaleghi IV77:1220 running text · Ganjoor sh15:7 poem body · Moscow V154:1214 running text · Mohl III258:1223 running text · Khaleghi IV77:1221 running text · Ganjoor sh15:8 poem body · Moscow V154:1215 running text;sword · Mohl III258:1224 running text;spear · Khaleghi IV77:1222 running text;spear · Ganjoor sh15:9 poem body · Moscow V154:1216 running text · Mohl III258:1225 running text · Khaleghi IV78:1223 running text · Ganjoor sh15:10 poem body
All four sources separate Piran's heart from his tongue and compare his persuasive appearance to salt ground that looks like water in sunlight. The English keeps the material cause of the illusion instead of replacing it with a generic deception. Its web image is an added metaphor for persuasion, while the neighboring heart and tongue retain the Persian accusation of internal division. In the weapon list Moscow and Ganjoor name a sword; Mohl and Khaleghi name a spear alongside the mace and lasso. English follows the first pair in this specific detail. Its rejection of further dealings also preserves the movement from diagnosing deceptive language to insisting upon combat as the only remaining exchange.
13–18Answering while refusing negotiation
English 13–18;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V154:1217 running text · Mohl III258:1226 running text · Khaleghi IV78:1224 running text · Ganjoor sh15:11 poem body · Moscow V154:1218 running text · Mohl III258:1227 running text · Khaleghi IV78:1225 running text · Ganjoor sh15:12 poem body · Moscow V154:1219 running text · Mohl III258:1228 running text · Khaleghi IV78:1226 running text · Ganjoor sh15:13 poem body · Moscow V155:1220 running text · Mohl III258:1229 running text · Khaleghi IV78:1227 running text · Ganjoor sh15:14 poem body · Moscow V155:1221 running text · Mohl III258:1230 running text · Khaleghi IV78:1228 running text · Ganjoor sh15:15 poem body · Moscow V155:1222 running text · Mohl III258:1231 running text · Khaleghi IV78:1229 running text · Ganjoor sh15:16 poem body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi combine a refusal of affectionate alliance with attention to heaven's distribution of strength and victory. English carries the same apparent tension: Gudarz rejects renewed negotiation but proceeds to answer the proposal methodically. That is a rhetorical refusal of its terms, not a refusal to read it. The conquering sun gives a concrete brightness to the source's victorious fortune. Piran's appeal to divine judgment is then quoted before Gudarz denies the agreement of his tongue and heart. Keeping these statements within successive speakers matters. The passage records conflicting claims to religious responsibility; it does not independently certify that one man's inward motives are transparent to the narrator.
19–24The earlier embassy and responsibility for war
English 19–24;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V155:1223,1224 running text · Mohl III258:1232 running text · Khaleghi IV78:1230,1231 running text · Ganjoor sh15:17,sh15:18 poem body · Ganjoor sh15:17,sh15:18 poem body · Moscow V155:1225 running text · Mohl III258:1233 running text · Khaleghi IV78:1232 running text · Ganjoor sh15:19 poem body · Moscow V155:1225–1226 checked local running gap;actual V155n18 prints two complete counsel units · Mohl III258:1234,1235 running text · Khaleghi IV78:1232–1233 checked local running gap;no positive apparatus text claimed · Ganjoor sh15:19–20 checked local running gap · Moscow V155:1226 running text · Mohl III258:1236 running text · Khaleghi IV78:1233 running text · Ganjoor sh15:20 poem body · Moscow V155:1227 running text · Mohl III258:1237 running text · Khaleghi IV78:1234 running text · Ganjoor sh15:21 poem body · Moscow V155:1228 running text · Mohl III258:1238 running text · Khaleghi IV78:1235 running text · Ganjoor sh15:22 poem body
Moscow and Khaleghi give two successive running couplets to the accusation of taking the initiative in bloodshed; Ganjoor follows that arrangement. English compresses them into its justice-and-first-aggression couplet. Mohl has the justice statement without the second running unit. Conversely, Mohl prints two fuller units about Giv's prudent speech and good counsel, compressed into the next English passage; Moscow prints both in actual apparatus, while Khaleghi and Ganjoor have bounded local running gaps. This is textual support for the fuller embassy memory, not an inferred supplement. The English iron wall supplies an image for Piran's resistance. The following army movements remain accusations made by Gudarz, with clauses redistributed across adjacent couplets.
25–30From individual blame to inherited hostility
English 25–30;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V155:1229 running text · Mohl III258:1239 running text · Khaleghi IV78:1236 running text · Ganjoor sh15:23 poem body · Moscow V155:1230 running text · Mohl III258:1240 running text · Khaleghi IV78:1237 running text · Ganjoor sh15:24 poem body · Moscow V155:1231 running text · Mohl III259:1241 running text · Khaleghi IV78:1238 running text · Ganjoor sh15:25 poem body · Moscow V155:1232 running text · Mohl III259:1242 running text · Khaleghi IV79:1239 running text · Ganjoor sh15:26 poem body · Moscow V155:1233 running text · Mohl III259:1243 running text · Khaleghi IV79:1240 running text · Ganjoor sh15:27 poem body · Moscow V155:1233 shared running unit,allocated at English29;continuation,not a new verse · Mohl III259:1243 shared running unit,allocated at English29;continuation,not a new verse · Khaleghi IV79:1240 shared running unit,allocated at English29;continuation,not a new verse · Ganjoor sh15:27 shared running unit;allocated at English29
All four presentations move from Piran's disposition to the character of his lineage and then to Tur's attack upon Iraj. English retains that escalation instead of reducing the argument to a personal quarrel. The racial language belongs to Gudarz's hostile genealogy of the feud; it should not be promoted into an independent account of collective nature. The source's single Fereydoon couplet joins grief and continuous cursing. English spreads that material across two couplets, making the father's anguish a fuller emotional bridge between the murder and its consequences. The register therefore allocates that Persian unit once and explicitly marks the second English couplet as a continuation, avoiding a false extra source verse.
31–36Fereydoon's persistence and the succession of injuries
English 31–36;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V155:1233–1234 checked local running gap;no actual additional unit verified · Mohl III259:1244 running text · Khaleghi IV79:1241 running text · Ganjoor sh15:27–28 checked local running gap · Moscow V155:1234 running text · Mohl III259:1245 running text · Khaleghi IV79:1242 running text · Ganjoor sh15:28 poem body · Moscow V156:1235 running text · Mohl III259:1246 running text · Khaleghi IV79:1243 running text · Ganjoor sh15:29 poem body · Moscow V156:1236 running text · Mohl III259:1247 running text · Khaleghi IV79:1244 running text · Ganjoor sh15:30 poem body · Moscow V156:1237 running text · Mohl III259:1248 running text · Khaleghi IV79:1245 running text · Ganjoor sh15:31 poem body · Moscow V156:1238 running text · Mohl III259:1249 running text · Khaleghi IV79:1246 running text · Ganjoor sh15:32 poem body
Mohl and Khaleghi retain a separate couplet invoking the Creator's assistance and Fereydoon's continuing inward attachment; Moscow and Ganjoor pass directly from his curses to Afrasiab. English has support for the divine assistance, while making sustained vengeance the explicit object of his nurturing. That last choice is an interpretation of the surrounding argument rather than a separately named act in the Persian unit. All four then enumerate Manuchehr, Nohzar, Kay Qobad, Kavus and Siavash as stages in renewed hostility. The English flood and foundation images intensify the claim that innocent blood perpetuates the feud. Gudarz's charge against Piran concerns his failure of justice at Siavash's death, not a newly narrated execution scene.
37–42Old age as a mandate rather than a warning
English 37–42;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V156:1239 running text · Mohl III259:1250 running text · Khaleghi IV79:1247 running text · Ganjoor sh15:33 poem body · Moscow V156:1240 running text · Mohl III259:1251 running text · Khaleghi IV79:1248 running text · Ganjoor sh15:34 poem body · Moscow V156:1241 running text · Mohl III259:1252 running text · Khaleghi IV79:1249 running text · Ganjoor sh15:35 poem body · Moscow V156:1242 running text · Mohl III259:1253 running text · Khaleghi IV79:1250 running text · Ganjoor sh15:36 poem body · Moscow V156:1243 running text · Mohl III259:1254 running text · Khaleghi IV79:1251 running text · Ganjoor sh15:37 poem body · Moscow V156:1244 running text · Mohl III259:1255 running text · Khaleghi IV79:1252 running text · Ganjoor sh15:38 poem body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi agree that fallen Iranian nobles precede the renewed argument about Gudarz's old age. The English turns the Persian address to an experienced deceiver into a pointed personal rebuke. Its reference to every crime strengthens the moral accusation beyond the source's observation that Piran has seen life's rises and falls. The central reversal remains exact in argument: long life is not a reason to abandon vengeance but the opportunity granted for accomplishing it. Raising dust toward the sun preserves the martial scale of the threat. Gudarz fears dying before fulfillment, so the English separation of soul and body leads directly into unfinished purpose rather than ordinary anxiety about mortality.
43–48The feared accounting before God
English 43–48;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V156:1245 running text · Mohl III259:1256 running text · Khaleghi IV80:1253 running text · Ganjoor sh15:39 poem body · Moscow V156:1246 running text · Mohl III259:1257 running text · Khaleghi IV80:1254 running text · Ganjoor sh15:40 poem body · Moscow V156:1247 running text · Mohl III259:1258 running text · Khaleghi IV80:1255 running text · Ganjoor sh15:41 poem body · Moscow V156:1248 running text · Mohl III259:1259 running text · Khaleghi IV80:1256 running text · Ganjoor sh15:42 poem body · Moscow V156:1249 running text · Mohl III259:1260 running text · Khaleghi IV80:1257 running text · Ganjoor sh15:43 poem body · Moscow V156:1250 running text · Mohl III259:1261 running text · Khaleghi IV80:1258 running text · Ganjoor sh15:44 poem body
All four sources connect the threatened loss of life with revenge still unaccomplished and enemy territory still untrodden. The English conquered land makes the military implication explicit without adding a separate conquest to the narrative. Piran's objection about religious fear is followed by a warning concerning reckless bloodshed, then by Gudarz's imagined divine interrogation. The English attribution leaves this within his answer, although the proximity of reported objection and rebuttal can make the transition sound argumentative rather than neutral. Gifts of command, wisdom, wealth and strength become obligations requiring an account. This is the speaker's justification for action: the commentary should distinguish that constructed judgment scene from a divine speech actually heard within the story.
49–54Public vengeance and the seventy sons
English 49–54;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V156:1251 running text · Mohl III259:1262 running text · Khaleghi IV80:1259 running text · Ganjoor sh15:45 poem body · Moscow V156:1252 running text · Mohl III259:1263 running text · Khaleghi IV80:1260 running text · Ganjoor sh15:46 poem body · Moscow V156:1253 running text · Mohl III259:1264 running text · Khaleghi IV80:1261 running text · Ganjoor sh15:47 poem body · Moscow V157:1254 running text · Mohl III259:1265 running text · Khaleghi IV80:1262 running text · Ganjoor sh15:48 poem body · Moscow V157:1255 running text · Mohl III260:1266 running text · Khaleghi IV80:1263 running text · Ganjoor sh15:49 poem body · Moscow V157:1256 running text · Mohl III260:1267 running text · Khaleghi IV80:1264 running text · Ganjoor sh15:50 poem body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all set the duty toward Siavash beside the blood of seventy beloved sons. English keeps the numeral and the shift from national obligation to paternal loss, while adding the sunset comparison to give the numerical reckoning emotional weight. Fear or charm as possible reasons for abandoning revenge elaborates the source's question about turning back; it does not introduce a different answer from God. Piran's fourth point then challenges killing the living for a body already reduced to earth. That contrast is preserved rather than dismissed in the translation. Gudarz responds by renewing the history of injuries, so the dispute turns on whether past violence continues to impose present duties.
55–60Broken treaties and the proposed hostages
English 55–60;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V157:1257 running text · Mohl III260:1268 running text · Khaleghi IV80:1265 running text · Ganjoor sh15:51 poem body · Moscow V157:1258 running text · Mohl III260:1269 running text · Khaleghi IV80:1266 running text · Ganjoor sh15:52 poem body · Moscow V157:1259 running text · Mohl III260:1270 running text · Khaleghi IV80:1267 running text · Ganjoor sh15:53 poem body · Moscow V157:1260 running text · Mohl III260:1271 running text · Khaleghi IV80:1268 running text · Ganjoor sh15:54 poem body · Moscow V157:1261 running text · Mohl III260:1272 running text · Khaleghi IV80:1269 running text · Ganjoor sh15:55 poem body · Moscow V157:1262 running text · Mohl III260:1273 running text · Khaleghi IV80:1270 running text · Ganjoor sh15:56 poem body
All four sources place injuries to Iran's rulers beside broken agreements and renewed hostility. English's murdered peace personifies the accumulated damage and makes Gudarz's refusal arise from remembered conduct rather than momentary anger. The next proposal supplies a concrete alternative: Turanian leaders as hostages and treasure sent to Khosrow. The translation keeps that distinction between a pledge and its material guarantees. It also retains the change in authority when Gudarz invokes the Shah's command. This is why the offer cannot be accepted simply as a private bargain between two commanders. The Persian presentations agree on that structure, even where their wording varies between the king's command being different and being the one already given.
61–66A royal command and a conditional opening
English 61–66;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V157:1263 running text · Mohl III260:1274 running text · Khaleghi IV80:1271 running text · Ganjoor sh15:57 poem body · Moscow V157:1264 running text · Mohl III260:1275 running text · Khaleghi IV81:1272 running text · Ganjoor sh15:58 poem body · Moscow V157:1265 running text · Mohl III260:1276 running text · Khaleghi IV81:1273 running text · Ganjoor sh15:59 poem body · Moscow V157:1266 running text · Mohl III260:1277 running text · Khaleghi IV81:1274 running text · Ganjoor sh15:60 poem body · Moscow V157:1267 running text · Mohl III260:1278 running text · Khaleghi IV81:1275 running text · Ganjoor sh15:61 poem body · Moscow V157:1268 running text · Mohl III260:1279 running text · Khaleghi IV81:1276 running text · Ganjoor sh15:62 poem body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi require battle and bloodshed for Siavash before considering the possibility that Khosrow might receive an approach more favorably. English makes the threatened struggle a fight to the death, intensifying the force of the Persian command to engage and shed blood. It nevertheless preserves the conditional opening: Piran may send the named wealth and hostages directly to the Shah. Lahhak and Ruyin are explicit in all four running texts. The road to Iran is open for that embassy, not for an agreed withdrawal from the campaign. Gudarz thus refuses authority to settle the feud himself while allowing the superior royal authority to hear the proposal.
67–72Territory that can no longer be offered
English 67–72;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V157:1269 running text · Mohl III260:1280 running text · Khaleghi IV81:1277 running text · Ganjoor sh15:63 poem body · Moscow V157:1270 running text · Mohl III260:1281 running text · Khaleghi IV81:1278 running text · Ganjoor sh15:64 poem body · Moscow V157:1271 running text · Mohl III260:1282 running text · Khaleghi IV81:1279 running text · Ganjoor sh15:65 poem body · Moscow V157:1272 running text · Mohl III260:1283 running text · Khaleghi IV81:1280 running text · Ganjoor sh15:66 poem body · Moscow V158:1273 running text · Mohl III260:1284 running text · Khaleghi IV81:1281 running text · Ganjoor sh15:67 poem body · Moscow V158:1274 running text · Mohl III260:1285 running text · Khaleghi IV81:1282 running text · Ganjoor sh15:68 poem body
All four sources reject the territorial concession by claiming that divine action has already made it unnecessary. English's assertion that God has seized the lands turns that implication into direct possession, preparing the subsequent reports of Iranian commanders. Lohrasp's advance toward Khazar and the southern extent to Sind appear in each presentation. The comparison with a blade creates a landscape of martial brightness; the English gleaming iron emphasizes its armed character. Rostam's raised day of doom is likewise preserved as battlefield hyperbole. The Indian chief and black standard are dispatched to the Shah, not identified as a new commander of the campaign. These are claims within Gudarz's letter, not an independently reconstructed geographical map.
73–78The cleared frontier and the remaining contest
English 73–78;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V158:1275 running text · Mohl III260:1286 running text · Khaleghi IV81:1283 running text · Ganjoor sh15:69 poem body · Moscow V158:1276 running text;westward · Mohl III260:1287 running text;every direction · Khaleghi IV81:1284 running text;onward from that side;actual IV81n22 westward · Ganjoor sh15:70 poem body · Moscow V158:1277 running text · Mohl III260:1288 running text · Khaleghi IV81:1285 running text · Ganjoor sh15:71 poem body · Moscow V158:1278 running text · Mohl III260:1289 running text · Khaleghi IV81:1286 running text · Ganjoor sh15:72 poem body · Moscow V158:1279 running text · Mohl III260:1290 running text · Khaleghi IV81:1287 running text · Ganjoor sh15:73 poem body · Moscow V158:1280 running text · Mohl III261:1291 running text · Khaleghi IV82:1288 running text · Ganjoor sh15:74 poem body
Moscow and Ganjoor send the forces toward Bakhtar after clearing Dehestan and Khwarazm. Mohl instead describes movement in every direction; Khaleghi's running text points onward from that quarter, while its actual apparatus records the westward wording. English therefore has specific support for Bakhtar, without requiring all four main texts to agree. Ashkash's hail upon Shideh and the sending of captives and goods are shared. The English purging of war and toil interprets the result rather than naming an additional source action. The remaining arena then narrows to the two commanders. Honor and disgrace depend on their encounter, giving the preceding territorial report a rhetorical function: Piran's proposed concessions have already lost their bargaining value.
79–84Threats under the sun and moon
English 79–84;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V158:1281 running text · Mohl III261:1292 running text · Khaleghi IV82:1289 running text · Ganjoor sh15:75 poem body · Moscow V158:1282 running text · Mohl III261:1293 running text · Khaleghi IV82:1290 running text · Ganjoor sh15:76 poem body · Moscow V158:1283 running text · Mohl III261:1294 running text · Khaleghi IV82:1291 running text · Ganjoor sh15:77 poem body · Moscow V158:1284 running text · Mohl III261:1295 running text · Khaleghi IV82:1292 running text · Ganjoor sh15:78 poem body · Moscow V158:1285 running text · Mohl III261:1296 running text · Khaleghi IV82:1293 running text · Ganjoor sh15:79 poem body · Moscow V158:1286 running text · Mohl III261:1297 running text · Khaleghi IV82:1294 running text · Ganjoor sh15:80 poem body
All four sources preserve the invitation to face Gudarz, the promise to end argument and the threat to flood the field with blood through divine and royal authority. English's added sand gives the inundation a battlefield surface but does not alter its agent. The following celestial image makes Turanian fortune already trapped. The Persian expression pictures the head of fortune caught in a constricting implement; the English snare favors entrapment over the more physical pressure of the wording. The argument then binds impending disaster to previous wrongdoing. Its logic is retaliatory and providential in Gudarz's voice. Preserving that voice prevents the commentary from treating the letter's certainty about punishment as neutral foreknowledge supplied by the narrator.
85–90The army as an audience beyond persuasion
English 85–90;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V158:1287 running text · Mohl III261:1298 running text · Khaleghi IV82:1295 running text · Ganjoor sh15:81 poem body · Moscow V158:1288 running text · Mohl III261:1299 running text · Khaleghi IV82:1296 running text · Ganjoor sh15:82 poem body · Moscow V158:1289 running text · Mohl III261:1300 running text · Khaleghi IV82:1297 running text · Ganjoor sh15:83 poem body · Moscow V158:1290 running text · Mohl III261:1301 running text · Khaleghi IV82:1298 running text · Ganjoor sh15:84 poem body · Moscow V159:1291 running text · Mohl III261:1302 running text · Khaleghi IV82:1299 running text · Ganjoor sh15:85 poem body · Moscow V159:1292 running text · Mohl III261:1303 running text · Khaleghi IV82:1300 running text · Ganjoor sh15:86 poem body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all give the army a strength of one hundred thousand sword-bearing riders. The English retains the number but distributes the refusal of persuasion across two couplets: the men cannot be charmed, and their pursuit of honor and revenge will not yield to sweet language. This keeps the essential connection between collective purpose and resistance to Piran's verbal skill. The seventh point turns from army morale to the credibility of oaths. Gudarz does not deny that Piran can utter a promise; he denies that promising can establish trust after repeated breach. The English language of buying wisdom preserves the Persian commercial metaphor, making that rejection sharper than a general charge of foolishness.
91–96Siavash's oath and the test of prowess
English 91–96;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V159:1293 running text · Mohl III261:1304 running text · Khaleghi IV82:1301 running text · Ganjoor sh15:87 poem body · Moscow V159:1294 running text · Mohl III261:1305 running text · Khaleghi IV82:1302 running text · Ganjoor sh15:88 poem body · Moscow V159:1295 running text · Mohl III261:1306 running text · Khaleghi IV82:1303 running text · Ganjoor sh15:89 poem body · Moscow V159:1296 running text · Mohl III261:1307 running text · Khaleghi IV82:1304 running text · Ganjoor sh15:90 poem body · Moscow V159:1297 running text · Mohl III261:1308 running text · Khaleghi IV82:1305 running text · Ganjoor sh15:91 poem body · Moscow V159:1298 running text;bi-honar · Mohl III261:1309 running text;bi-honar · Khaleghi IV82:1306 running text;ba-honar · Ganjoor sh15:92 poem body
All four presentations make Siavash's destruction the decisive example against trusting Piran's oath, followed by his failure to provide help in distress. The English preserves accusation and appeal without adding a new account of the murder. Piran's eighth claim then compares rank, wealth, troops and courage, while professing painful affection. Gudarz answers by appealing to experience in battle. Moscow, Mohl and Ganjoor phrase the ensuing challenge through possible lack of skill; Khaleghi's running text instead uses possession of skill. The English request to judge every art avoids committing to that polarity. It keeps the challenge intelligible while the register preserves the difference, so rhetorical smoothness does not erase the actual variant.
97–102The fuller comparison and compassion for soldiers
English 97–102;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V159:1298–1299 checked local running gap;no actual additional unit verified · Mohl III261:1310 running text · Khaleghi IV82–83:1306–1307 checked local running gap;no actual additional unit verified · Khaleghi IV82–83:1306–1307 checked local running gap;no actual additional unit verified · Ganjoor sh15:92–93 checked local running gap · Moscow V159:1299 running text · Mohl III261:1311 running text · Khaleghi IV83:1307 running text · Ganjoor sh15:93 poem body · Moscow V159:1300 running text · Mohl III261:1312 running text · Khaleghi IV83:1308 running text · Ganjoor sh15:94 poem body · Moscow V159:1301 running text · Mohl III261:1313 running text · Khaleghi IV83:1309 running text · Ganjoor sh15:95 poem body · Moscow V159:1302 running text · Mohl III261:1314 running text · Khaleghi IV83:1310 running text · Ganjoor sh15:96 poem body · Moscow V159:1303 running text · Mohl III261:1315 running text · Khaleghi IV83:1311 running text · Ganjoor sh15:97 poem body
Mohl prints the additional comparison of treasure, fortune, crown, throne and skill that supports the opening English couplet here. Moscow, Ganjoor and Khaleghi have checked local running gaps between the preceding test and the proposal to select champions; no unprinted addition notice is counted as verification. All four then present the selection of a few fighters as Piran's way to limit suffering in the army. English's worn and weak sharpens the compassionate motive without naming a separate class of troops in the sources. Gudarz questions that professed motive and returns to royal responsibility. The issue is therefore both personal trust and permission: even a humane proposal cannot simply override the commission under which he commands.
103–108Full battle before chosen champions
English 103–108;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V159:1304 running text · Mohl III262:1316 running text · Khaleghi IV83:1312 running text · Ganjoor sh15:98 poem body · Moscow V159:1305 running text · Mohl III262:1317 running text · Khaleghi IV83:1313 running text · Ganjoor sh15:99 poem body · Moscow V159:1306 running text · Mohl III262:1318 running text · Khaleghi IV83:1314 running text · Ganjoor sh15:100 poem body · Moscow V159:1307 running text · Mohl III262:1319 running text · Khaleghi IV83:1315 running text · Ganjoor sh15:101 poem body · Moscow V159:1308 running text · Mohl III262:1320 running text · Khaleghi IV83:1316 running text · Ganjoor sh15:102 poem body · Moscow V159:1309 running text · Mohl III262:1321 running text · Khaleghi IV83:1317 running text · Ganjoor sh15:103 poem body
Moscow and Ganjoor explicitly label this challenge as another numbered point, while Mohl and Khaleghi use a connective equivalent to another matter. English's also follows the less rigid transition and avoids making the preceding last point a numerical contradiction. All four reject withdrawal from a force charged with offenses against Iran. They require the armies to clash first, with the mountain image conveying mass and impact; selected champions become the subsequent alternative if that does not settle the contest. The English preserves this sequence. It should not be read as immediate acceptance of single combat. The response changes Piran's proposed procedure while retaining a route by which the named fighters may eventually meet.
109–114A promise that includes time to prepare
English 109–114;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V160:1310 running text · Mohl III262:1322 running text · Khaleghi IV83:1318 running text · Ganjoor sh15:104 poem body · Moscow V160:1311 running text · Mohl III262:1323 running text · Khaleghi IV83:1319 running text · Ganjoor sh15:105 poem body · Moscow V160:1312 running text · Mohl III262:1324 running text · Khaleghi IV83:1320 running text · Ganjoor sh15:106 poem body · Moscow V160:1313 running text · Mohl III262:1325 running text · Khaleghi IV83:1321 running text · Ganjoor sh15:107 poem body · Moscow V160:1314 running text · Mohl III262:1326 running text · Khaleghi IV83:1322 running text · Ganjoor sh15:108 poem body · Moscow V160:1315 running text · Mohl III262:1327 running text · Khaleghi IV83:1323 running text · Ganjoor sh15:109 poem body
All four sources distinguish Gudarz's claimed fidelity to his own word from Piran's anticipated breach. The English develops that opposition by recalling the history of unreliable oaths. An insufficient force may seek help from its own ruler, and wounded relatives or allies may be given time for treatment. English carries the request for royal reinforcements slightly earlier, across the boundary between adjacent source units; both units are still accounted once. The offer of delay is not a retreat from vengeance. It is a condition intended to prevent a later charge of unfair advantage. The final command to fight if no delay is wanted preserves the direct alternation between recuperation and immediate military action.
115–120No future excuse and no change of resolve
English 115–120;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V160:1316 running text · Mohl III262:1328 running text · Khaleghi IV84:1324 running text · Ganjoor sh15:110 poem body · Moscow V160:1317 running text · Mohl III262:1329 running text · Khaleghi IV84:1325 running text · Ganjoor sh15:111 poem body · Moscow V160:1318 running text · Mohl III262:1330 running text · Khaleghi IV84:1326 running text · Ganjoor sh15:112 poem body · Moscow V160:1319 running text · Mohl III262:1331 running text · Khaleghi IV84:1327 running text · Ganjoor sh15:113 poem body · Moscow V160:1320 running text · Mohl III262:1332 running text · Khaleghi IV84:1328 running text · Ganjoor sh15:114 poem body · Moscow V160:1321 running text · Mohl III262:1333 running text · Khaleghi IV84:1329 running text · Ganjoor sh15:115 poem body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all explain the offered interval by imagining an accusation of surprise attack or ambush. The English makes that anticipated complaint audible in direct quotation, then returns to Gudarz's declared persistence. One hundred years and the present moment are equivalent with respect to his resolve. The concluding comparison treats night and day as alike to someone without sight; it does not describe the army's tactics or the conditions of the coming battle. Its force is the removal of a meaningful temporal distinction. The transition to the beautiful envoy then releases the reader from the letter's sustained hostility, preserving the contrast between a severe message and courteous handling of its bearer.
121–126Dismounting and public ratification
English 121–126;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V160:1322 running text · Mohl III262:1334 running text · Khaleghi IV84:1330 running text · Ganjoor sh15:116 poem body · Moscow V160:1323 running text · Mohl III262:1335 running text · Khaleghi IV84:1331 running text · Ganjoor sh15:117 poem body · Moscow V160:1324 running text · Mohl III262:1336 running text · Khaleghi IV84:1332 running text · Ganjoor sh15:118 poem body · Moscow V160:1325 running text · Mohl III262:1337 running text · Khaleghi IV84:1333 running text · Ganjoor sh15:119 poem body · Moscow V160:1326 running text · Mohl III262:1338 running text · Khaleghi IV84:1334 running text · Ganjoor sh15:120 poem body · Moscow V160:1327 running text · Mohl III262:1339 running text · Khaleghi IV84:1335 running text · Ganjoor sh15:121 poem body
All four sources bring Ruyin down from his horse and place him with his companions before Gudarz. The English reference to leaving the saddle should be understood as dismounting, not as depositing horse equipment on the ground. The summons gathers learned advisers and respected men from the army; it is not a new religious ceremony. Gudarz orders the answer read before them, and the scribe's recitation turns a drafted letter into a publicly endorsed statement. English's cogent characterizes the answer in accordance with their favorable reception, while the diminished judgment of Piran belongs to that assembled audience. Keeping this procedural scene makes the refusal more than a private outburst: the commander secures institutional assent before dispatch.
127–132Praise, sealing and gifts to the envoy
English 127–132;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V160:1328 running text;chosen · Mohl III262:1340 running text;earthly epithet · Khaleghi IV84:1336 running text;earthly epithet · Ganjoor sh15:122 poem body · Moscow V160:1329 running text · Mohl III263:1341 running text · Khaleghi IV84:1337 running text · Ganjoor sh15:123 poem body · Moscow V161:1330 running text · Mohl III263:1342 running text · Khaleghi IV84:1338 running text · Ganjoor sh15:124 poem body · Moscow V161:1331 running text · Mohl III263:1343 running text · Khaleghi IV84:1339 running text · Ganjoor sh15:125 poem body · Moscow V161:1332 running text · Mohl III263:1344 running text · Khaleghi IV84:1340 running text · Ganjoor sh15:126 poem body · Moscow V161:1333 running text · Mohl III263:1345 running text · Khaleghi IV84:1341 running text · Ganjoor sh15:127 poem body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi agree on praise of Gudarz, sealing the letter and handing it to Ruyin before the gifts are prepared. Moscow and Ganjoor call the commander chosen, whereas Mohl and Khaleghi use an epithet connected with the earth; the English selected epithet follows the former pair and adds lasting fame. Horses with golden trappings, headgear and swords in golden sheaths give the departure ceremonial dignity. Silver, gold, caps and belts also reach the companions according to their standing. The translation keeps that distribution rather than treating everything as Ruyin's personal reward. Courtesy to the embassy survives rejection of its policy, which is crucial to the scene's contrast with the violent letter.
133–138Receiving the message and concealing its force
English 133–138;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V161:1334 running text · Mohl III263:1346 running text · Khaleghi IV85:1342 running text · Ganjoor sh15:128 poem body · Moscow V161:1335 running text · Mohl III263:1347 running text · Khaleghi IV85:1343 running text · Ganjoor sh15:129 poem body · Moscow V161:1336 running text · Mohl III263:1348 running text · Khaleghi IV85:1344 running text · Ganjoor sh15:130 poem body · Moscow V161:1337 running text;face · Mohl III263:1349 running text;heart · Khaleghi IV85:1345 running text;face;actual IV85n4 heart · Ganjoor sh15:131 poem body · Moscow V161:1338 running text · Mohl III263:1350 running text · Khaleghi IV85:1346 running text · Ganjoor sh15:132 poem body · Moscow V161:1339 running text · Mohl III263:1351 running text · Khaleghi IV85:1347 running text · Ganjoor sh15:133 poem body
All four sources move from Ruyin's arrival and embrace to his oral report, the scribe's reading and Piran's darkened response. Moscow and Ganjoor place the blackness upon the commander's face; Mohl places it upon his heart. Khaleghi's running text has the face, with the heart reading in actual apparatus. English follows Mohl's inward location and then preserves the shared pain and dread of approaching decline. Its mention of the returning band extends the escort context rather than supplying an independent new arrival. Piran's silence conceals the message from the troops. That act is distinct from failing to understand it: his subsequent address shows that he has grasped the uncompromising demand for vengeance.
139–144Answering paternal loss with fraternal loss
English 139–144;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V161:1340 running text · Mohl III263:1352 running text · Khaleghi IV85:1348 running text · Ganjoor sh15:134 poem body · Moscow V161:1341 running text · Mohl III263:1353 running text · Khaleghi IV85:1349 running text · Ganjoor sh15:135 poem body · Moscow V161:1342 running text · Mohl III263:1354 running text · Khaleghi IV85:1350 running text · Ganjoor sh15:136 poem body · Moscow V161:1343 running text · Mohl III263:1355 running text · Khaleghi IV85:1351 running text · Ganjoor sh15:137 poem body · Moscow V161:1344 running text · Mohl III263:1356 running text · Khaleghi IV85:1352 running text · Ganjoor sh15:138 poem body · Moscow V161:1345 running text · Mohl III263:1357 running text · Khaleghi IV85:1353 running text · Ganjoor sh15:139 poem body
Moscow, Mohl, Ganjoor and Khaleghi all report seventy sons as the source of Gudarz's unrest and nine hundred fallen chiefs as a counterweight in Piran's speech. English retains both figures and the shift from describing the opponent's grief to justifying his own renewed violence. The call to avenge brothers gathers Houman and Nastihan into that response, although the Persian reference to brother can be grammatically singular at its first appearance. Houman's unmatched riding and Nastihan's shade-giving cypress distinguish martial prowess from protective stature. These are Piran's memorial valuations, not a neutral ranking of every Turanian fighter. The translation preserves the emotional mechanism by which sympathy for another father's loss becomes an argument for continuing the same feud.
145–150From mourning to material preparation
English 145–150;individual source locators and evidence classes linked below.
Moscow V161:1346 running text · Mohl III263:1358 running text · Khaleghi IV85:1354 running text · Ganjoor sh15:140 poem body · Moscow V162:1347 running text · Mohl III263:1359 running text · Khaleghi IV85:1355 running text · Ganjoor sh15:141 poem body · Moscow V162:1348 running text · Mohl III263:1360 running text · Khaleghi IV85:1356 running text · Ganjoor sh15:142 poem body · Moscow V162:1349 running text · Mohl III263:1361 running text · Khaleghi IV86:1357 running text · Ganjoor sh16:1 poem body · Moscow V162:1350 running text · Mohl III263:1362 running text · Khaleghi IV86:1358 running text · Ganjoor sh16:2 poem body · Moscow V162:1351 running text · Mohl III263:1363 running text · Khaleghi IV86:1359 running text · Ganjoor sh16:3 poem body
All four presentations retain Nastihan's vanished cypress, the resolution to take arms, a threat of devastation and the distribution of horses and treasure. English's day of doom continues the poem's martial hyperbole rather than introducing an actual cosmic event. The last three couplets cross into a new Ganjoor section, but remain inside the published English chapter; the register respects that boundary. Making footmen mounted and providing riders with two horses converts the speech into logistical preparation. The source wording around the battle connection varies, so the English same-day phrasing is treated as narrative smoothing, not precise independent chronology. Opening old stores finally gives Piran's followers tangible support after he has withheld the letter's full discouraging force.
Source record and limits
C3.21 only:150 English couplets/300 lines. Moscow V154–162:1205–1351 (147 running units);Mohl III257–263:1214–1363 (PDF263–269;150 running units);Ganjoor12rokh sh14:108–109,sh15:1–142,sh16:1–3 (147 body units);Khaleghi IV77–86:1212–1359 (PDF93–102;148 running units). No source-only rows. English29–30 shares one unit in each source,allocated once at29. English19 compresses two Moscow/Ganjoor/Khaleghi units;English21 compresses two Mohl units. Each declared main unit allocated exactly once.
Inspection sequence:individual MoscowV154–162 and MohlIII257–263 PNG facsimiles first;then fresh Ganjoor sh14/sh15/sh16 bodies and KhaleghiIV77–86 PNG facsimiles. Source files were retrieved from existing project files;availability alone was not counted as verification.
- F&R English: 150 verbatim couplets. Gudarz Replies to Piran. From the eighth-morning summons to Piran’s opening old treasure. Next C3.22 Piran Seeks Afrasiab’s Aid begins the nighttime dispatch.
- Moscow: V154–162:1205–1351;147 main units. English21 main gap1225–1226 with two actual155n18 counsel units;English31 gap1233–1234;English97 gap1298–1299. English19 compresses1223–1224;English29–30 shares1233. Sword1215;westward1276;bi-honar1298;chosen1328;face1337.
- Mohl: III257–263:1214–1363;150 main units. Fuller counsel1234–1235,divine aid1244,and comparative boast1310. English21 compresses1234–1235;English29–30 shares1243. Spear1224;every direction1287;bi-honar1309;earthly epithet1340;heart1349.
- Ganjoor: 12rokh sh14:108–109;sh15:1–142;sh16:1–3. 147 body units. Main allocation follows Moscow. Checked local gaps sh15:19–20,27–28,92–93 correspond to English21,31,97. Shared27 at English29–30. New section sh16 begins at English148.
- Khaleghi-Motlagh: IV77–86:1212–1359;148 main units. English21 main gap1232–1233;English97 gap1306–1307. Divine aid1241 present. English19 compresses1230–1231;English29–30 shares1240. Spear1222;onward1284 with actual81n22 westward;ba-honar1306;earthly epithet1336;face1345 with actual85n4 heart.
English21:actual MoscowV155n18 prints two full counsel units in opposite order to MohlIII258:1234–1235;both are represented by the English passage. Moscow main gap1225–1226,Khaleghi main gap1232–1233 and Ganjoorsh15:19–20 are locally checked. English31:Mohl1244 and Khaleghi1241 main;Moscow1233–1234 and Ganjoorsh15:27–28 locally checked gaps. English97:Mohl1310 main;Moscow1298–1299,Khaleghi1306–1307 and Ganjoorsh15:92–93 locally checked gaps. No actual additional apparatus unit is certified for the latter gaps.
English19 combines Moscow1223–1224,Khaleghi1230–1231 and Ganjoorsh15:17–18;Mohl1232 contains the justice unit. English29–30 expands one source unit:Moscow1233,Mohl1243,Ganjoorsh15:27,Khaleghi1240. The register assigns references at29 and marks30 as shared continuation. English110–111 redistributes the request for royal aid across a source boundary without double-counting.
Selected actual apparatus:KhaleghiIV81n22 prints westward against the onward running wording at1284;IV85n4 prints heart against face at1345. Moscow155n18 full counsel units are the only additional full apparatus units used. Other notices are not counted as verified additions. No appendix evidence used.
All inherited provisional flags retained verbatim,including C3.19.44 Pashan identification. No new unresolved reading counted positively. Running text,actual apparatus,checked local gaps,appendix evidence and unverified inherited interpretations remain distinct. No appendix evidence used. Only specifically transcribed apparatus alternatives count as support. No global absence claim. Modern geographic identifications not certified.
First English line:Upon the eighth day, at the dawn’s first light, Last English line:And gave dinars and wealth in lavish scores. C3.22 Piran Seeks Afrasiab’s Aid:opening candidates MoscowV162:1352;MohlIII264:1364(PDF270);KhaleghiIV86:1360(PDF102);Ganjoorsh16:4.
Additional Ganjoor boundaries:sh14:108–109 and sh16:1–3. PDF offsets:Moscow0,Mohl6,Khaleghi16.
- Moscow V154:1215 main;sword — که هنگام گرزست و تیغ و کمند
- Mohl III258:1224 main;spear — به هنگام گرز و سنان و کمند
- Khaleghi IV77:1222 main;spear — که هنگام گرز و سنان و کمند
- Moscow V155n18 actual apparatus;two counsel units — ابا پند و اندرز و گفتار نغز / بزرگان ایران پاکیزه مغز / سخن گفت با تو ز هر دری / ز هر نامداری و هر کشوری
- Mohl III258:1234–1235 main;fuller counsel — سخن گفت خود با تو از هر دری / ز هر نامداری و هر کشوری / ابا پند و اندرز و گفتار نغز / ابا آن بزرگان پاکیزه مغز
- Mohl III259:1244 main;divine aid and persistence — بیاری دادار نیکی دهش / همش مهر دل بود هم پرورش
- Khaleghi IV79:1241 main;divine aid and persistence — به یاری دادار نیکی دهش / همش مهر دل بود و هم پرورش
- Moscow V158:1276 main;westward — سوی باختر تاختن ساختند
- Mohl III260:1287 main;every direction — که از هر سوی تاختن ساختند
- Khaleghi IV81:1284 main;onward — کزان سو همی تاختن ساختند
- Khaleghi IV81n22 actual apparatus;westward — سوی باختر
- Moscow V159:1298 main;negative skill — گرم بیهنر یافتی روز کین
- Khaleghi IV82:1306 main;positive skill — گرم باهنر یافتی روز کین
- Mohl III261:1310 main;additional comparison — به گنج و به بخت و به تاج و هنر / برآیم به تو مگر سر بسر
- Moscow V160:1328 main;chosen — ورا پهلوان گزین خواندند
- Mohl III262:1340 main;earthly epithet — ورا پهلوان زمین خواندند
- Mohl III263:1349 main;heart — یکایک دل پهلوان شد چو قیر
- Khaleghi IV85:1345 main;face — یکایک رخ پهلوان شد چو قیر
- Khaleghi IV85n4 actual apparatus;heart — دل
C3.21 · Printed verse collation
| English couplet | Moscow | Mohl |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | V154:1205 running text | III257:1214 running text |
| 2 | V154:1206 running text | III257:1215 running text |
| 3 | V154:1207 running text | III258:1216 running text |
| 4 | V154:1208 running text | III258:1217 running text |
| 5 | V154:1209 running text | III258:1218 running text |
| 6 | V154:1210 running text | III258:1219 running text |
| 7 | V154:1211 running text | III258:1220 running text |
| 8 | V154:1212 running text | III258:1221 running text |
| 9 | V154:1213 running text | III258:1222 running text |
| 10 | V154:1214 running text | III258:1223 running text |
| 11 | V154:1215 running text;sword | III258:1224 running text;spear |
| 12 | V154:1216 running text | III258:1225 running text |
| 13 | V154:1217 running text | III258:1226 running text |
| 14 | V154:1218 running text | III258:1227 running text |
| 15 | V154:1219 running text | III258:1228 running text |
| 16 | V155:1220 running text | III258:1229 running text |
| 17 | V155:1221 running text | III258:1230 running text |
| 18 | V155:1222 running text | III258:1231 running text |
| 19 | V155:1223,1224 running text | III258:1232 running text |
| 20 | V155:1225 running text | III258:1233 running text |
| 21 | V155:1225–1226 checked local running gap;actual V155n18 prints two complete counsel units | III258:1234,1235 running text |
| 22 | V155:1226 running text | III258:1236 running text |
| 23 | V155:1227 running text | III258:1237 running text |
| 24 | V155:1228 running text | III258:1238 running text |
| 25 | V155:1229 running text | III258:1239 running text |
| 26 | V155:1230 running text | III258:1240 running text |
| 27 | V155:1231 running text | III259:1241 running text |
| 28 | V155:1232 running text | III259:1242 running text |
| 29 | V155:1233 running text | III259:1243 running text |
| 30 | V155:1233 shared running unit,allocated at English29;continuation,not a new verse | III259:1243 shared running unit,allocated at English29;continuation,not a new verse |
| 31 | V155:1233–1234 checked local running gap;no actual additional unit verified | III259:1244 running text |
| 32 | V155:1234 running text | III259:1245 running text |
| 33 | V156:1235 running text | III259:1246 running text |
| 34 | V156:1236 running text | III259:1247 running text |
| 35 | V156:1237 running text | III259:1248 running text |
| 36 | V156:1238 running text | III259:1249 running text |
| 37 | V156:1239 running text | III259:1250 running text |
| 38 | V156:1240 running text | III259:1251 running text |
| 39 | V156:1241 running text | III259:1252 running text |
| 40 | V156:1242 running text | III259:1253 running text |
| 41 | V156:1243 running text | III259:1254 running text |
| 42 | V156:1244 running text | III259:1255 running text |
| 43 | V156:1245 running text | III259:1256 running text |
| 44 | V156:1246 running text | III259:1257 running text |
| 45 | V156:1247 running text | III259:1258 running text |
| 46 | V156:1248 running text | III259:1259 running text |
| 47 | V156:1249 running text | III259:1260 running text |
| 48 | V156:1250 running text | III259:1261 running text |
| 49 | V156:1251 running text | III259:1262 running text |
| 50 | V156:1252 running text | III259:1263 running text |
| 51 | V156:1253 running text | III259:1264 running text |
| 52 | V157:1254 running text | III259:1265 running text |
| 53 | V157:1255 running text | III260:1266 running text |
| 54 | V157:1256 running text | III260:1267 running text |
| 55 | V157:1257 running text | III260:1268 running text |
| 56 | V157:1258 running text | III260:1269 running text |
| 57 | V157:1259 running text | III260:1270 running text |
| 58 | V157:1260 running text | III260:1271 running text |
| 59 | V157:1261 running text | III260:1272 running text |
| 60 | V157:1262 running text | III260:1273 running text |
| 61 | V157:1263 running text | III260:1274 running text |
| 62 | V157:1264 running text | III260:1275 running text |
| 63 | V157:1265 running text | III260:1276 running text |
| 64 | V157:1266 running text | III260:1277 running text |
| 65 | V157:1267 running text | III260:1278 running text |
| 66 | V157:1268 running text | III260:1279 running text |
| 67 | V157:1269 running text | III260:1280 running text |
| 68 | V157:1270 running text | III260:1281 running text |
| 69 | V157:1271 running text | III260:1282 running text |
| 70 | V157:1272 running text | III260:1283 running text |
| 71 | V158:1273 running text | III260:1284 running text |
| 72 | V158:1274 running text | III260:1285 running text |
| 73 | V158:1275 running text | III260:1286 running text |
| 74 | V158:1276 running text;westward | III260:1287 running text;every direction |
| 75 | V158:1277 running text | III260:1288 running text |
| 76 | V158:1278 running text | III260:1289 running text |
| 77 | V158:1279 running text | III260:1290 running text |
| 78 | V158:1280 running text | III261:1291 running text |
| 79 | V158:1281 running text | III261:1292 running text |
| 80 | V158:1282 running text | III261:1293 running text |
| 81 | V158:1283 running text | III261:1294 running text |
| 82 | V158:1284 running text | III261:1295 running text |
| 83 | V158:1285 running text | III261:1296 running text |
| 84 | V158:1286 running text | III261:1297 running text |
| 85 | V158:1287 running text | III261:1298 running text |
| 86 | V158:1288 running text | III261:1299 running text |
| 87 | V158:1289 running text | III261:1300 running text |
| 88 | V158:1290 running text | III261:1301 running text |
| 89 | V159:1291 running text | III261:1302 running text |
| 90 | V159:1292 running text | III261:1303 running text |
| 91 | V159:1293 running text | III261:1304 running text |
| 92 | V159:1294 running text | III261:1305 running text |
| 93 | V159:1295 running text | III261:1306 running text |
| 94 | V159:1296 running text | III261:1307 running text |
| 95 | V159:1297 running text | III261:1308 running text |
| 96 | V159:1298 running text;bi-honar | III261:1309 running text;bi-honar |
| 97 | V159:1298–1299 checked local running gap;no actual additional unit verified | III261:1310 running text |
| 98 | V159:1299 running text | III261:1311 running text |
| 99 | V159:1300 running text | III261:1312 running text |
| 100 | V159:1301 running text | III261:1313 running text |
| 101 | V159:1302 running text | III261:1314 running text |
| 102 | V159:1303 running text | III261:1315 running text |
| 103 | V159:1304 running text | III262:1316 running text |
| 104 | V159:1305 running text | III262:1317 running text |
| 105 | V159:1306 running text | III262:1318 running text |
| 106 | V159:1307 running text | III262:1319 running text |
| 107 | V159:1308 running text | III262:1320 running text |
| 108 | V159:1309 running text | III262:1321 running text |
| 109 | V160:1310 running text | III262:1322 running text |
| 110 | V160:1311 running text | III262:1323 running text |
| 111 | V160:1312 running text | III262:1324 running text |
| 112 | V160:1313 running text | III262:1325 running text |
| 113 | V160:1314 running text | III262:1326 running text |
| 114 | V160:1315 running text | III262:1327 running text |
| 115 | V160:1316 running text | III262:1328 running text |
| 116 | V160:1317 running text | III262:1329 running text |
| 117 | V160:1318 running text | III262:1330 running text |
| 118 | V160:1319 running text | III262:1331 running text |
| 119 | V160:1320 running text | III262:1332 running text |
| 120 | V160:1321 running text | III262:1333 running text |
| 121 | V160:1322 running text | III262:1334 running text |
| 122 | V160:1323 running text | III262:1335 running text |
| 123 | V160:1324 running text | III262:1336 running text |
| 124 | V160:1325 running text | III262:1337 running text |
| 125 | V160:1326 running text | III262:1338 running text |
| 126 | V160:1327 running text | III262:1339 running text |
| 127 | V160:1328 running text;chosen | III262:1340 running text;earthly epithet |
| 128 | V160:1329 running text | III263:1341 running text |
| 129 | V161:1330 running text | III263:1342 running text |
| 130 | V161:1331 running text | III263:1343 running text |
| 131 | V161:1332 running text | III263:1344 running text |
| 132 | V161:1333 running text | III263:1345 running text |
| 133 | V161:1334 running text | III263:1346 running text |
| 134 | V161:1335 running text | III263:1347 running text |
| 135 | V161:1336 running text | III263:1348 running text |
| 136 | V161:1337 running text;face | III263:1349 running text;heart |
| 137 | V161:1338 running text | III263:1350 running text |
| 138 | V161:1339 running text | III263:1351 running text |
| 139 | V161:1340 running text | III263:1352 running text |
| 140 | V161:1341 running text | III263:1353 running text |
| 141 | V161:1342 running text | III263:1354 running text |
| 142 | V161:1343 running text | III263:1355 running text |
| 143 | V161:1344 running text | III263:1356 running text |
| 144 | V161:1345 running text | III263:1357 running text |
| 145 | V161:1346 running text | III263:1358 running text |
| 146 | V162:1347 running text | III263:1359 running text |
| 147 | V162:1348 running text | III263:1360 running text |
| 148 | V162:1349 running text | III263:1361 running text |
| 149 | V162:1350 running text | III263:1362 running text |
| 150 | V162:1351 running text | III263:1363 running text |
New Naqqali